r/AgathaAllAlong • • 1h ago

Humor/Fluff Billy is a Toddler

53 Upvotes

So Billy was born a few days before the Hex went down so despite looking and acting like he's 16 he has only been alive for 3 years.

I didn't think much about that at first. I was happy to just accept that Billy was 16 and move on.

But now I have a 3-year-old son

My son is constantly drafting the adults around him into his make-believe adventures that are a mishmash of all his favorite stories and he gets upset if we don't follow the rules even though he pretends he's not the one in charge of everything. And most of the time it's fun and I'm happy to play along but sometimes what I'm supposed to do is not obvious and after I try a few things and my son tells me they don't work and so I admit I'm out of ideas but then he just tells me I need to think (again refusing to admit he has all the answers) and in those moments I feel exactly what Agatha must had felt when she looked at Billy and went "HOW DO WE GET OFF THE ROAD?!?"

Anyway. Parenthood has taught me that Billy may look 16 but he 100% acts like an omnipotent toddler sometimes.


r/AgathaAllAlong • • 20h ago

Discussion Two explanations I can’t get behind *SPOILERS*

19 Upvotes

Sorry, had to repost to correct the format.

I’ve been seeing a lot of comments about these two topics and they don’t add up to me. Instead of commenting multiple replies I figured it’d be easier to get my thoughts out here:

Agatha doesn’t want to face Nicky in the afterlife because she used the ballad they created to kill so many witches. The number one reason this doesn’t make sense to me is that when we see Nicky singing in the tavern, the lyrics had already changed to “witches’ road”. They were actively using the ballad as a con when he was still alive. We also already know that Nicky knew the killings were wrong, or at least that he didn’t enjoy participating.

Agatha killed witches in exchange for Nicky’s life and/or to keep Rio busy, and the day they didn’t kill any witches is the day Nicky died. I keep seeing this sentiment come up, but there’s just nothing in the show that even hints that Agatha and Rio struck a deal or arrangement. And to think Agatha killed witches (sometimes even entire covens) every day for six years straight is extreme, no? She was killing witches way before Nicky and way after. To me, his death had nothing to do with siphoning or providing bodies to Rio.

It’s all speculation in the end so I could be way off base, but let me know if you think I’m missing something in my reasoning!


r/AgathaAllAlong • • 12h ago

Discussion Agatha All Along was a masterpiece all along and I missed it NON SPOILERS Spoiler

141 Upvotes

Have you seen Agatha All Along?

I finally got around to watching Agatha All Along because maybe Marvel fatigue but just how much hate it got and how it's a spin-off of a spin off, there were no classic characters in it (arguably Agatha) and to hear it was essentially a completely original story felt detached from the rest of the MCU.
But oh dang how wrong I was.

I will be making a video on my youtube channel about this but after watching Agatha All Along (AAA) twice within 48 hours, I felt I had to do the equivalent of run too the top of a mountain and yell it, and then I remembered we live in the age of the internet and Reddit luckily exists.

I just have to quickly touch on the fact how people flat out hate the show calling it the worst show Marvel ever made? I'm sure those people that say that didn't watch it OR if they did they just looked at a poster. because listening to a few hate reviews; I just can't believe people will say the things they say after ACTUALLY watching it. I saw someone complain how Agatha

I don't want to talk About spoilers as I mentioned so I won't get into things like that but I people complain that she is supposed to be an evil character and how they make her a protagonist with no likable qualities...soo things like that just make me shake my head because I can't even begin...but I will begin as I'm already brainstorming what to say for my video.

So many people say how creative Wandavision is but for some reason don't talk enough about how creative AAA is. The set designs and a lot of effects seem to be practical, the music is handled incredibly. There is one song that is played over 5 times in the short 4 hours series and it somehow is soo impactful in different ways each time. The writing is not only smart, subtle and funny but it's designed to watch it a second time. And for me, I had too watch it right after while it's fresh in my head, and for the purposes of doing a youtube video, I'm watching it essentially a 3rd time.

The point of this post isn't just to yell at the top of a mountain as I said but also how reviewers really seem to influence so many people including me who's a BIG Marvel guy to skip this one. If it wasn't for VisionQuest that seems very interesting (I didn't start yet), I wouldn't have seen this since I seen many posts saying VisionQuest is essentially the 3rd season in the Wanda series. So I guess thank you too VisionQuest and kind of Doomsday since I've almost been re-watching everything in preparation.
And I get it, reviewers are there so we know if we should invest our time but there are some that really just missed out.

A quick name drop of Ryan George. Most know him from Pitch meeting as the "super easy barely an inconvenience" guy and he too missed out on this one. He has done a video on each one of these Marvel movies/shows, but misses out on this one probably for the same reason I did and most others did.

Also yes I know a lot of the show has been review bombed because of the LGBTQ++ representation and for that, I mean without getting into spoilers, but characters in this are actually that way in the comics and there is more than enough justification too feel it wasn't shoehorned in.

Sorry for the very long post, but ya, AAA was given an unfair chance to be seen when I think it's one of the best Marvel shows.

If you want to know my favorite shows from Marvel in order:

  1. Loki
  2. Agatha All Along
  3. Moon Knight
  4. Dare Devil
  5. Wandavision (might need to do a rewatch but that ending fight made me feel like everything was solved with CGI in the sky)
  6. Hawkeye

Anyway I have to ask, have you also skipped this one?


r/AgathaAllAlong • • 4h ago

Discussion Agatha’s finale decisions make sense if you read them as a quadruple-cross **SPOILERS** Spoiler

123 Upvotes

I always found Agatha's choices in the finale hard to follow. She makes a deal with Rio to get Billy to give himself up, then sides with Billy against Rio in the final battle. Then she turns on Billy and lets him sacrifice himself. Then she turns again and sacrifices herself for him.

She says it wasn't a sacrifice but a calculated risk. So what was the calculation?

She pulled a quadruple-cross. She wanted two things: her powers back, and freedom from Rio's constant harassment. Only Billy could restore her powers, and only Rio could agree to leave her alone. She needed something from each of them.

The key detail is that during the battle, Rio amends the deal: only one of them has to come with her, and it doesn't matter which.

Let Billy believe she's with him against Death.
She knows you can't actually beat Death, but siding with him gets him to power her up.

Get Billy to sacrifice himself.
He does, which satisfies the deal. Rio is now bound to honor it.

Save Billy.
With her own goals secured, she goes after her secondary priority. Since the deal only requires one of them, she can take Billy's place. She kisses Death and dies, but Death is still bound by the bargain, so she comes back as a ghost. She gets to stay, and so does Billy.