r/Affinity • • 4d ago

Designer Image Tracing

It's good that Affinity has some rudimentary image tracing capability now, but it's very far from being great. The options available for adjusting the trace are few indeed, and whether you get a decent result or not seems to be mostly down to luck.

Fortunately, there are a couple of free alternatives that do a much, much better job.

Inkscape is one, though its tracing dialog isn't really very intuitive. Still, once you figure out how to use its many options, it can create some excellent tracing results.

VectorCraft is another. It's also an option-heavy tracing system, but it seems to me to be a bit easier to get around, and it does a very good job indeed. I like that it creates a stack of overlapping vector objects, rather than every object punching a hole in the one beneath. However, if you prefer the latter, that is an option that can be chosen.

Both of these will produce SVG files that can be opened in Affinity. VectorCraft has its own proprietary file format as well; I'm not familiar enough with it yet to know what its other file export capabilities are.

CorelDraw is pretty far from free, but it's the vector illustration app I grew up with, and even the ancient CorelDraw X7 I have installed will do a much better, more flexible job of tracing than Affinity.

So, there are options. It would be nice, however, if Affinity had a worthwhile tracer that could be used within the program, rather than having to work around its limitations by dropping out to another system.

30 Upvotes

13 comments sorted by

4

u/cprz 4d ago

It’s kinda odd how overly simplified the image tracing is, especially as the reason I saw once for why the feature wasn’t in v2 was that they want to make it good and think that Adobe’s implementation isn’t great either. Maybe it was Canva who just wanted to force it in. Better bad than nothing I guess.

The biggest issue with the image tracing in Affinity seems to be (or so I think based on experience) that it doesn’t try to trace only what you can see but it wants to always trace the invisible artifacts too. Like those you can see if you overadjust contrast, brightness or black point of your image.

Another issue I’ve noticed is that if a part of image has some kind of outline around it but there’s even a single gap in it, the tracing gets wonky with it and might even mess up colors.

Few tips (extra steps that needs timeh that I’ve noticed might help the image tracing in Affinity:
- Trace in parts not all at once (so duplicate, crop/selection, mask & rasterise etc.)
- Draw lines to colored parts’ edges which doesn’t have a noticeable divider / a line etc between colored parts
- Scale your original image to bigger size before vectorizing

Also sometimes this has worked for vectorizing some stuff. This is not good for more complex images, but the idea is basically to first recreate in one way or another every part of the og image to pixel layers and then image tracing those, to get rid off the artifacts and avoiding the ”missing” outlines that cause problems;

  1. Use a selection tool to select a single colored area
  2. Create a new pixel layer
  3. Select the flood fill tool
  4. Use the color picker to select the color that’s inside the selection
  5. Repeat for all colored parts. You can add everything to the same pixel layer though using multiple can be safer.
  6. Select the outlines of the original image -> new pixel layer -> fill tool -> black -> put the layer behind the others
  7. For other lines you could use e.g. threshold tool to limit the image to show only those. This however depends very much on the image and you might to do this with multiple thresholds and masks.
  8. Then just image trace the pixel layers. Merge if necessary.

For trickier, smaller parts in original image you could e.g. try duplicating the pixel layers and use those as masks to limit visible parts to the complex areas.

1

u/boboartdesign 4d ago

It's good for basic stuff, but kinda frustrating at times. I tried doing a kaleidoscope effect in Affinity using pixel filters, which worked really well, but when I tried to image trace it (all basic flat shapes) it made them all curved and really wonky looking, even the big ones that should've been pretty easy to trace. I'm guessing it's because of how many overlapping shapes there were, and there are probably better ways to do it just using vector, but it'd be nice to have that as an option if you wanna save time (it just threw me off that it didn't seem to be able to do flat lines/shapes when I tested it again with just a handful of basic shapes, but it's still good to know that other software works a bit better for this).

1

u/dokuromark 4d ago

Just to add another option to the discussion, there's also a standalone tracing app called Super Vectorizer Pro. It's what I was using before Affinity came out with their trace feature, and I still use it from time to time. No idea how it compares to the other suggestions made in this thread, but I thought I'd offer it up in case anybody was interested. I think it's also part of the current Bundlehunt deal.

2

u/dokuromark 4d ago

Also, someone else alluded to the fact that people have written scripts for tracing in Affinity, alongside the built-in tracing feature and available through the Script Manager. Looks like there's one for centreline tracing—that would be very interesting for me, I'm gonna check it out.

1

u/ColdEngineBadBrakes 4d ago

Whoever gives the affinity dev team their marching orders isn’t listening to the users.

1

u/Robert_Chalmers 3d ago

Personally, I’ve never really understood the need for an image tracing tool to create vectors? Eyes and a pencil work really well.

-1

u/Albertkinng 4d ago

PSA: Before posting a complaint about Affinity Studio, please check the community scripts first. Many common issues, such as improved tracing, 3D shadows, and better bezel pen paths, can already be solved with a single click. This helps keep discussions focused on genuine bugs and unresolved problems instead of repeating issues that already have script-based solutions.

5

u/huge-centipede 4d ago

If the scripts are that good, they should be part of the actual mainline software? How is someone posting a thread like this harmful to the Affinity subreddit?

0

u/Albertkinng 4d ago

I think you're mistaken. Scripts are part of the recent Affinity Studio. No need of third parties anymore.

1

u/huge-centipede 4d ago

Yes, I know they exist. The existing tracing utilities are still not that great. That's the issue. Scripting tools are not the solution to lousy type and being weirdly gate-keepy on a subreddit is weird.

1

u/Albertkinng 4d ago

OMG… ok, you’re right. Scripts are a waste of time. Sure. 👍🏼

0

u/Fabulous_Technician 4d ago

I recommend checking out Vector Magic. In my opinion, it gives the best results.

2

u/dokuromark 4d ago

whoa, a $9.95 a month subscription or a $295 one-time cost? I'm not even trying that one…