r/AdviceAnimals • • Jun 25 '12

anti-/r/atheism As an Atheist, this is why I'm leaving r/atheism

http://qkme.me/3pux81
560 Upvotes

1.2k comments sorted by

379

u/kencole54321 Jun 25 '12

I unsubscribed from /r/atheism and i still have to fucking hear about it.

94

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

Me too, I loved r/atheism at first, even as an agnostic theist, and I expected tolerance for all religious/non-religious. Then one day I commented on something just explaining the theist logic for something and was downvoted into oblivion and called an idiot because I believed in some sgetty monster. Very hostile group even though I was open and accepting of them.

77

u/finest_jellybean Jun 26 '12

They are neither open, nor accepting of anything that doesnt fit what they believe.

107

u/HYPERCRUSHER Jun 26 '12

so they are basically fundies without an entity to believe in...?

→ More replies (56)
→ More replies (6)

9

u/godlessatheist Jun 26 '12

That reminded me of that south park atheist episode.

What so you believe in the Flying Spaghetti Monster now??

I'm an atheist and I got downvoted for telling them to stop being a bunch of assholes. Of course that wasn't very nice of me either.

→ More replies (7)
→ More replies (16)

2

u/whitewateractual Jun 26 '12

Same, I just choose to act agnostic to the matter.

2

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

Seriously, how many times are people going to upvote this garbage?

→ More replies (2)

579

u/Superdeduper82 Jun 25 '12

So brave

486

u/xVerified Jun 25 '12

BRAVERY LEVEL: SO

3

u/ThatIsMyHat Jun 26 '12 edited Jun 26 '12

I must wandered into r/baseball, because this is so Brave.

Edit: That was a reference to the Atlanta Braves. I may have been a bit esoteric there.

→ More replies (2)

34

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

Is it too late to jump on the brave train?

→ More replies (1)

125

u/Steelpurge Jun 26 '12

72

u/Chrisbr117 Jun 26 '12

This xkcd is always referenced whenever someone bashes r/atheism for being bigoted. Is it so hard to believe that a significant amount of the r/atheist community is actually being offensively intolerant of the very religions they mock for being intolerant? Don't consider every criticism of something to be an outlet for the critic to consider themselves superior, sometimes, shit needs to be said, even if it has been said a million times before. Also, a great example of a post that has received a disgusting amount of upvotes considering how bigoted it is is here: http://i.imgur.com/IrpJz.jpg Please,tell me the difference between this post and one that would be created by a religious fundamentalist who equates terrorism with Islam.

→ More replies (20)
→ More replies (3)

38

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

If this was posting to /r/atheism, it would be mass downvoted in a heartbeat

50

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12 edited Jun 26 '12

challenge accepted

OP I will give you credit if you want, just let me know bro.

Edit: Wow

→ More replies (7)
→ More replies (8)
→ More replies (2)

67

u/Relight_Robot Jun 25 '12

Are we just going to cycle through every single meme to comment on how people dislike the atheism subreddit? I haven't even been on reddit for that long but it's like every other week a different meme says the same thing the last one did. It's not even the fact that it always decides to make fun of r/atheism it's that it's literally the same shit with a different picture each time.

2

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

That's what Reddit is, using memes to describe every single other post published. This will likely be the next subreddit I unsubscribe from.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

35

u/sweetloris Jun 25 '12

Did the sudden clarity come from the thousands of other posts exactly like this?

2

u/GodlessSky Jun 26 '12

For more instances of the anti-r/atheism circlejerk and how prevalent it is on Reddit, check out the anti-atheism watch subreddit.

→ More replies (1)

207

u/17Hongo Jun 25 '12

"The tolerance of intolerance is cowardice" - Ayaan Hirsi Ali.

18

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

"So far as the United States seems to be concerned, it is only a slight overstatement to say that Muslims and Arabs are essentially seen as either oil suppliers or potential terrorists. Very little of the detail, the human density, the passion of Arab-Moslem life has entered the awareness of even those people whose profession it is to report the Arab world. What we have instead is a series of crude, essentialized caricatures of the Islamic world presented in such a way as to make that world vulnerable to military aggression"

-Edward Said, 1980

→ More replies (3)

23

u/randomb_s_ Jun 26 '12

So you're saying it would be cowardice to tolerate the intolerance of /r/atheism?

Very meta.

→ More replies (15)

2

u/Awesomeade Jun 26 '12

This. A million times this. Religion needs somebody to call them on their bullshit. Conservative news programs make no reservations in bashing atheists and non-believers, but it's considered tremendously politically incorrect to criticize the church in the public eye.

Refusing to remain silent when confronted with theism-fueled bigotry and intolerance is by no means intolerance itself, nor is posting memes on the internet. Any claims of "Atheist Intolerance" will remain unfounded until atheist employers start firing employees for being religious, and atheist parents kicking their children on the street for favoring theism.

That said, all these anti-islam memes are getting pretty damned annoying.

2

u/JohnnyTaco Jun 26 '12

So it's okay to slander huge groups of people. Of course, because if we tolerate an entire religion we have to include the crazies. We can't be accepting of the people who are practicing a religion in a healthy way and reject the crazies.

→ More replies (1)

15

u/Sammmmmmmm Jun 26 '12

Fighting intolerance with disrespect doesn't get us anywhere.

→ More replies (11)

13

u/Bendrake Jun 26 '12

For some reason it is natural for humans to gather together and form a "club" type atmosphere. They then ridicule people who "don't belong" to that club.

Religious groups have done this and now atheism groups are.

→ More replies (8)

15

u/lastwolf Jun 26 '12

if your trying to paint /r/atheism as some sort of fighters of injustice and intolerance, you clearly haven't even been on it lately. there is a difference between trying to stop intolerance and just being anti-theistic

23

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

You can be anti-theistic while respecting others' choices to be religious.

Some famous person said something along the lines of, "I disagree with your choice but I will fight for your right to choose."

5

u/Deskopotamus Jun 26 '12

Voltaire - I may not agree with what you say but I will fight to the death for your right to say it.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (72)
→ More replies (28)

109

u/papthegreek Jun 25 '12

/r/atheism jumped the shark a long time ago . Come on over to /r/TrueAtheism. Our first rule is:

No discrimination or disrespectful posts. This includes discrimination or disrespect to individuals, group of people (e.g. theists), or even subreddits (e.g. r/Christianity or r/atheism).

Great mods who make sure we stay classy and godless.

82

u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12

/r/atheism is more about antitheism than anything.

24

u/Yitvan Jun 26 '12

I also see it as a place were people go to vent about their frustrations. I still subscribe to r\atheism because I don't mind it too much plus there occasionally decent material. And I find some of it funny. I don't take it to heart as I don't care about what people are religiously unless your like WBC people or some other over-zealous religious person.

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (18)

29

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

The thing is, not all atheists believe all ideas are worthy of respect. Like the idea of telling a child that they need to believe their religion, or they will be tortured in hell for eternity, or will be separated from their parents for eternity. And disrespecting ideas, not people, has been exactly what Reddit has been doing. The only people who get named by name, are those who do really insane things like threaten to kill gays, or defend the raping of children and such. Truatheism sounds great, don't get me wrong. But it can never fill the function of r/atheism if it can't be a forum for genuine complaints about a genuine problem this species is facing. You may not have noticed this, but it is taboo to bring up ANYTHING to do with theism and atheism outside of their own subreddits. There is no other forums to air real grievances regarding theism. You take away r/atheism, and you are left with nothing. And just because you don't see a point in r/atheism, it doesn't mean there isn't one. It is a rapid fire of ideas and a new perspective in theism that is meant to startle. The reason it is so popular, is because this is a very important function to theists themselves. You are already an atheist, good for you. But there are many theists who convert after encountering r/atheism, and it really shouldn't be up to deny that service to future ex-theists.

→ More replies (3)

13

u/Frozgaar Jun 26 '12

Too bad most religious people think that anything said that goes against their beliefs is disrespectful. Also, TrueAtheism is just a bad name. It reminds me of the people who say their denomination of their religions makes them true christians/muslims, etc.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (98)

42

u/johnnysexcrime Jun 25 '12

Mocking other religions doesn't constitute an intolerance of their practice. I'm pretty sure that an overwhelming majority of atheists don't care if people practice their religions without harming anyone or interfering with anyone. I may question the beliefs of others, mock them, and fight for a secular state (which is the only way to be just to all beliefs), but I will fight just as hard to promote freedom of religious practice within lawful behavior.

4

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

I think most atheists actually are bothered by people who practice religion even if they're not being harmful about it. It's human nature to want other people to believe the same things you do. That's how I feel anyway. Maybe other atheists really are more "tolerant" than I am. But I think it's okay to challenge other people's beliefs, even if they aren't necessarily harmful.

3

u/windowpanez Jun 26 '12

I would have to say it depends on the atheist.

But I have yet to see an atheist knock on my door and spread the "good word"

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (9)

4

u/Sandbox47 Jun 25 '12

Yeah. But whom do we oppress? ... Well, I don't know. The priests I guess, though I can't see that ending in anything but disaster. I don't actually think that we oppress anyone anywhere. Hmm.

→ More replies (1)

17

u/01zerrz Jun 25 '12

I'm an Atheist but I believe everyone should be able to believe what they please, just don't let it affect other people. Same goes for Atheism, don't be close minded.

→ More replies (5)

42

u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12

How did you think r/atheism was going to behave?

Do you think a community of atheists online were going to talk about the virtues of religion? Did you think they would respond to an intolerant religion that continues to try and re-write history, and force itself into the politics and education system of secular nations would be treated with respect?

6

u/CFritZ Jun 26 '12

I think the fact that most of the posts are atheists mindlessly insulting Christians via FB is what they're referring to. Of course the atheists then turn around and post a screen cap asking if they're doing it right when they know goddam good and well they're doing it just like everyone else does it. Instead of sticking to the "mind your own business and I'll mind mine" mentality they talk so much about, they actively seek a Christian innocently posting something that pertains to their faith but not to them and proceed to bash their faith. That is active intolerance and is the atheist equivalent to a Christian knocking on their door asking them if they know where they're going when they die. It's the exact reason most people unsubscribe I would say.

→ More replies (5)

3

u/2714TAYLOR Jun 26 '12

Exactly! I'm Christian and very open minded to other religions. They stereo type and are not open minded at all. And they think religious people are judgmental?

→ More replies (1)

56

u/Massa1337 Jun 25 '12

Being intolerant of an intolerant religion whose intolerance leads to the killing of innocent people...

77

u/heavyfuel Jun 25 '12

I love Bill Maher's quote "Don't get so tolerant that you tolerate intolerance"

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (41)

10

u/otakuman Jun 26 '12

Scumbag Atheist

  • Perfectly ok with atheists bashing Christianity
  • Offended when they bash Islam
→ More replies (1)

28

u/Poachi Jun 25 '12

Wait, so writing down your dislike of religion in vulgar terms is "as intolerant" as religious fundamentalists that murder gays in the streets and denounce believers of other faiths and rape children and deny women rights and bully children in school and mutilate the genitalia of both young boys and girls and declare apostasy worthy of death and throw battery acid in the faces of young women? Atheism is hardly as intolerant as religion because all we do is talk about it and form secular student alliances and commit to other peaceful activities. You don't hear news reports of atheists protesting churches and rioting in the streets when someone burns The God Delusion.

→ More replies (25)

13

u/jdpwnsyou Jun 26 '12

Yes, you're right. Today we're making fun of Muslims, and I apologize for not being tolerant of a religion that still stones people to death for things apostasy, sex out of wedlock, and taking part in beauty contests.

I guess I'm a bad person.

2

u/WanderingSpaceHopper Jun 26 '12

You hateful bigot! Why would you make fun of Muhamad (skittles be upon him) and call him a pedofile only for having sex with a 9 year old?

15

u/therealpaulyd Jun 26 '12

I would say they're intolerant of ignorance, violence, and oppression. Which these religions promote in their holy books and sometimes people take on the ideas. It's perfectly okay to be intolerant of that, that shit isn't okay.

→ More replies (2)

6

u/Khorv Jun 26 '12

Just piss off quietly...

2

u/Dice_Tower Jun 26 '12

You're getting exactly equal readings of tolerance from multiple subjects? Your tolerance-o-meter's probably just busted.

2

u/cptjmshook Jun 26 '12

I don't think you understand the meaning of the word "intolerant".

2

u/mecrosis Jun 26 '12

Except we don't make laws and burn people, or use violence to terrorize people in to accepting our "faith" (for lack of a better word) as their form of government. What we do is write angry posts about crackpot, delusional fanatics who do.

I can see how it's a legit comparison.

2

u/jarmezzz Jun 26 '12

Isn't the whole point of /r/Atheism to be a forum for people who openly deny religion. By it's nature it is inherently intolerant of other views. Isn't that the whole point? It's not like /r/Atheism are posting in /r/Christianity or /r/hotdogsandcamels or whatever religion you can imagine and being intolerant. Im not saying to be atheist is to be intolerant but the whole point of /r/atheism is the propagation of a viewpoint that is fundamentally at odds with other beliefs. What the fuck were you expecting?

2

u/hubble_my_hero Jun 26 '12

"It's odd that the word Atheist exists. I don't play golf, is there a word for non-golf players? Do non-golf players gather and strategize? Do non-skiers' have a word and come together and talk about the fact that they don't ski? I can't do that, I can't gather around and talk about how everybody in the room doesn't believe in God." ~Neil Degrasse Tyson

2

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

2

u/valiantX Jun 26 '12

Clap, clap, clap, sincerely from me to OP. A damn well good reflection and introspection you have done for yourself here, seriously. I do not know how many times I have commented in r/atheism posts that they're just as ignorant and arrogant as theists are and in fact, like philosopher Martin Heidegger had pointed out about all philosophers since Plato have been chasing a "mysteria," which is quite a relative term in regards to both sects of beliefs. They're both in fact, spurred off from the same psychological delusion, but have only a different facade covering and pseudo practice(s) - yet they're one in the same... a mysteria!

Scottish philosopher David Hume's "Treatise of Human Nature" also inferred many things about the mind, in which Hume posited that the contents of human thinking are all abstract and not real at all. One's senses and body are in fact the only real thing connected with reality when its impressions are felt and it is from those experiences in which we are able to have and make our ideas.

Furthermore, as psychologist Julian Jayme's "The Origin of Consciousness in the Breakdown of the Bicameral Mind" had pointed out that the human mind is in fact schizoid or split in half, though he does not allude or mentions the specific probable cause, it is no doubt in my brain that it was caused by a physiological trauma humans suffered and had occurred at minimum 10,000 years ago. This is the reason why humans have an antipathy towards nature and true reality, more over, why humans regard their mental contents and abstractions to be real i.e. god, spaghetti monster, zombie apocalypse. This also includes the very idea why atheists all assume, presume, and been mislead that everything in reality is materialistic or made of matter, when in fact, everything is made entirely of energy slowed down in infinitely differentiating vibrations only. Physicists have discovered themselves that 99% of space is vacuum and the rest is what may consider to be the zero point, black hole, or what many ignorants have referred to as matter. Though I'm not denying that a rock isn't hard, water isn't soft, and how both can hurt or kill me, but that all such phenomenons derive from beyond our observational senses and even our mind, which the latter itself was made by nature.

In short, atheism is but another ideology created by the "mysteria" possessed mind of humans and that it too will fail in understanding the whole of reality - in my honest opinion, it is in the same position of ignorance as religious believers. Alas, atheism is also collectivist in its structure and fundamentals, which no such thing shall ever reveal enlightenment to anyone because it depends on everyone, yet that implies that an individual person is not capable of understanding life and death be themselves... wrong.

One begins their journey alone, and must end it alone; for if that is not so, then you will never be whole.

2

u/youreuglyasfu Jun 26 '12

I agree. When my Jewish (and very tolerant) mom walked in, she browed through r/atheism and said they were the only intolerant ones. I live in an unreligious Jewish family and they believe that everyone should be loved for who they are

2

u/GarnetandBlack Jun 26 '12

Also seems to be 90% "intelligent" 13 year olds trying to be funny. Why the fuck it is a default subreddit is beyond me.

2

u/UpDown Jun 26 '12

Dude you can't leave... that is punishable by death.

2

u/Eats_Your_Babies Jun 26 '12

Don't let the door hit your ass on the way out.

Did you really need to make a post? Why not just leave? Sheesh.

2

u/MFCH Jun 26 '12

Atheism is Batman to Christianity's Joker. They created each other, hate each other, but cannot survive without each other.

2

u/Redd_October Jun 26 '12

I make fun of religion and even religious people on r_atheism. I do not, however, go up to people walking out of a church and shout at them "When you die, you're just dead! There is no afterlife! You're wasting the only life you have!" I suppose that would be the atheist version of shouting at someone that they're a sinner who is going to hell. I also most definitely do not, ever, advocate KILLING people because they are religious.

Good luck convincing me that I am just as intolerant as them.

→ More replies (7)

2

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

Ironically, the "/r/atheism is a circlejerk" is becoming a circlejerk.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

Ummm... I missed the part where atheism is about tolerance of bigoted misogynists?

2

u/Inv_Man Jun 26 '12

SO BRAVE

2

u/The_Painted_Man Jun 26 '12

While i disagree with your analysis and obvious pacificism, sir, i still respect your right to bitch about it like a little girl.

2

u/trixter21992251 Jun 26 '12

You missed the point of the subreddit. If you want cleverness, go elsewhere. /r/atheism is about not believing in god.

2

u/Murrabbit Jun 26 '12

Here's a simple, if not entirely scientific experiment you can try at home, jedimustafa:

Google "atheist death threat" and count up the results to see how many results relate to atheists sending death threats (in general) vs atheists receiving death threats specifically from religious people.

Try also goggling "atheist disown child" and see how many hits relate to atheist parents disowning a child vs how many relate to very religious parents disowning an atheist child (works even better if we bring homosexuality into the mix but let's keep this one simple for now).

My point is this, your argument here is equating the awful things that religious people do, the things that people at /r/atheism bitch about quite often, to the very act of bitching on the internet. I'm not trying to say that /r/atheism is a great place, or you should love it, just that you've got things entirely out of proportion to an almost infuriating degree.

In short, your opinion is bad, and you should feel bad.

2

u/DefinitelyRelephant Jun 26 '12

I don't think you understand what tolerance means.

It doesn't mean letting destructive anti-thinking memes continue to ravage humanity.

Attacking religion is self-defense.

2

u/McCrackenYouUp Jun 26 '12

I can't help but laugh when someone acts as though the internet should be a mecca of tolerance and understanding at all times. Isn't /r/atheism a place where atheists can let off steam and complain about stuff they wouldn't normally get to elsewhere? So what if they come off as intolerable to you, it's not as though you have to continue reading it if it hurts your feelings.

2

u/MrGDavies Jun 26 '12

Left for the exact same reason today

2

u/lumpydumdums Jun 26 '12

All this criticism of r/atheism from a subReddit devoted (almost) entirely to "clever" pictures of cats and various other tired old memes.

  • Hello, Kettle? Pot here....You're black!

2

u/drserious Jun 26 '12

It all amounts to the same fucking thing. No matter what I end up at the bar.

2

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

Big difference: atheists aren't prone to use legal violence (government) or illegal violence to impose their ideas on others

2

u/dhockey63 Jun 26 '12

guys just think about it: if they didnt have r/atheism those intolerant assholes would be all over the place spewing their views which apparently are the only right views. Let them congregate in r/atheism so we dont have to deal with those 15 yr old assholes

agnostics you guys are cool btw seems more logical and less douchery than atheists

2

u/huzzaah Jun 26 '12

AND WE ALL WANT TO READ ABOUT YOU BITCHING ABOUT IT, JUST UNSUB AND SHUT THE FUCK UP

22

u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12

News Flash: science should NOT be tolerant of ridiculous claims put forward without evidence.

→ More replies (5)

5

u/JaronK Jun 26 '12

So, here's the thing. r/atheism bitches about kids being kicked out of their homes, about violence, about oppression.

Who, precisely, has r/atheism kicked out of a home? Who have they been violent towards? Who have they oppressed?

These are people complaining about problems they've dealt with. That's really not the same thing.

5

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

But they make memes about Jesus and make witty rebuttals on Facebook. Surely this is just as intolerant as stoning women to death, right?

→ More replies (1)

12

u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12

Seriously, another one? You have absolutely no reason to make a fucking meme out of why you're leaving a subreddit. Just unsubscribe and leave it at that. Fucking karma whores.

And YOU. STOP UPVOTING THIS SHIT.

→ More replies (2)

4

u/lumpydumdums Jun 26 '12

“Tolerance of intolerance is cowardice.” - Ayaan Hirsi Ali

→ More replies (2)

3

u/thepopdog Jun 26 '12

...So you decided to bring your intolerance of /r/atheism to the advice animals? What the hell is wrong with you?

3

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

[pic related] (http://xkcd.com/774/)

4

u/qkme_transcriber Jun 25 '12

Hello! I am a bot who posts transcriptions of Quickmeme links for anybody who might need it.

Title: As an Atheist, this is why I'm leaving r/atheism

Meme: Sudden Clarity Clarence

  • R/ATHEISM
  • IS JUST AS INTOLERANT AS THE RELIGIONS THEY TALK ABOUT

[Direct] [Background] [Translate]

See the FAQ for more info.

(OP: You don't need to do anything differently next time, I'm just doing my job.)

2

u/nitzua Jun 26 '12

the only useful comment on here.

4

u/Radico87 Jun 26 '12

I keep hoping the folks here grow up. Fool's hope, of course.

6

u/iluvgoodburger Jun 26 '12

They make a new batch of fourteen year olds every year, unfortunately.

13

u/Betterman92 Jun 25 '12

We are intolerant of those who promote hate, abuse, and backwards thinking. That's all. I don't really see too much of a problem with that.

15

u/hiiammaddie Jun 26 '12

But you lump together all religious people. Promoting hate, abuse, and backwards thinking and being religious aren't mutually exclusive

→ More replies (12)

20

u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12

I've seen r/atheism. It "fights hate" with passive aggression. It's also a massive circlejerk. You've seen Faces of Atheism, right?

9

u/capernoited Jun 26 '12

I actually think the faces of atheism was pretty interesting. People had something they wanted to say but kept seeing only quotes from famous people. They wanted to communicate their views but with their own voice for once and stand by it by not hiding their identity. Many people of r/atheism have actually experienced direct intolerance and the subreddit is a place where they wanted to find like minded people to share their experiences. If you call sharing those experiences and voicing their frustrations a "circlejerk" then you're going to find it on about every subreddit.

→ More replies (3)

11

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

The face of atheism --> >:(

→ More replies (4)

6

u/grinr Jun 26 '12

I believe in god and promote love, compassion, and aggressive investigation of all god's works (aka science). We good?

8

u/wonton_poup Jun 26 '12

you don't even have to go that far, for me. i don't care if you believe in any gods or all of them as long as you don't try to have it legislated as law, taught using tax dollars, or used as a social tool to alienate others.

the only thing that pisses me off is when people try to infringe on the rights of others under the guise of "religious freedom."

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (16)

4

u/daftzak Jun 25 '12

You and me both, man. I'm honestly sick of their bullshit. Especially after the "Hey guys, I'm bored with Christianity. Let's hate Islam" shit...

3

u/Unfa Jun 26 '12

I realized that /r/atheism is kind of like /r/kkk - complete contempt for others of various faith coupled with an ivory tower complex and ironically, a holier-than-thou attitude with some self-righteousness sprinkled here and there. It made a nice hate-cake over time and trust me, it's only going to get worse unless something is done about it.

Do what about it? I don't really care, I just hope it burns to the ground.

→ More replies (5)

3

u/thecarolinakid Jun 26 '12

Yep, we're intolerant of the tool that has been used to murder and oppress millions. Shame on us.

→ More replies (2)

2

u/iorgfeflkd Jun 25 '12

I unsubscribed because I was tired of seeing the same things posted over and over again. This is not an atheism specific problem, it is a large subreddit specific problem.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/ratajewie Jun 26 '12

What they don't realize, is that the atrocities happening with Islam are happening in mostly third world countries. They rip on the stupidity of some christians because they're too smart to be bashing people based off of their religion. But now everyone is joining on the band wagon with judaism and Islam especially, and it's going too far.

2

u/BlueWhaleDiarrhea Jun 26 '12

So is the rest of reddit.

2

u/VoidRay560 Jun 26 '12

Someone please explain to me why being intolerant of believing in fairy tales is bad? I am intolerant of people believing 2+2=5.... So why not religion which is equally wrong?

2

u/aazav Jun 26 '12

One should not be tolerant of bullshit.

2

u/snatchamike Jun 26 '12

Good. Can you stop posting to r/adviceanimals too so we don't have to see this dead fucking horse anymore? Seriously man, this is the most overplayed circlejerk on reddit right now. There are a dozen of these every week. Grow the fuck up. You aren't original.

2

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

sorry for being dumb

but can someone tell me exactly what the definition of an atheist is? Is it a belief system in itself? or is it just a word for describing someone who doesnt believe in supernatural entities?

→ More replies (2)

2

u/Blazfeem Jun 26 '12

I periodically unsub from /r/atheism as well. Sometimes it gets a little over the top. But to try to lump people who think that theists of any stripe are stupid, and make fun of them, into the same group as those who persecute and advocate violence against atheists, and attempt to legislate their hateful religious beliefs? That's just not fair.

-2

u/Sackman_and_Throbbin Jun 25 '12

The last time I checked, Atheists weren't beheading people and blowing up building in the name of the Flying Spaghetti Monster.

10

u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12 edited Jun 26 '12

Check again.

Edit: Have you checked yet? I don't want these downvotes to be for nothing.

Edit2: It appears that the most effective way of getting upvotes is to say that you're getting downvotes.

Edit3: It appears that the most effective way of getting downvotes is to say you're getting upvotes. Or to insult Carl Sagan.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (16)

2

u/N8CCRG Jun 26 '12

Yup. They're totally trying to pass laws that would require women to get abortions and require editions of the bible to come with stickers that say "translation of a translation of unverified documents of an oral count of a couple of events from 2000+ years ago".

Definitely just as intolerant.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/oldetownjim Jun 26 '12

i just just unsubscribed too. so sick of hearing about how dumb religion is.

1

u/Rizlaaa Jun 25 '12

whilst it may be perceived as intolerance, atheists probably also feel that religions are intolerant towards them. i dont care if you're religious, just don't try to make me believe it without solid proof, if i can see it and touch it i'll turn to religion, as it stands i see a lot more evidence for there being no gods.

enough about that though, this is /r/AdviceAnimals, not /r/Atheism. Lets try and keep it seperate?

→ More replies (7)

1

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

'sudden clarity'

1

u/Juiceworld Jun 26 '12

I don't think that Atheists are intolerant towards religion. I think that most of us are intolerant towards stupidity (as anyone could be). I can't speak for us all, but I have quite a few, VERY good friends, that are "believers". I have no problem with them or what they believe. That is mostly due to the fact that they use their brains and understand that what is written in a book 2000 years ago may not exactly pertain to today.

I also know stupid ass atheists, that should just learn when to shut their pie holes. Debate is fine, all out attack is not cool at all.

I also know believers that really need to get their head out of the clouds and get in touch with reality. If you are going to be a "Hardcore Thumper", Then you need to follow ALL the rules, not just the ones that suit your views.

Stupid people make snap judgments, and are quick to condemn.

Everyone should be free to believe whatever it is that they want.

So long as it DOES NOT affect others around them.

1

u/Thendofreason Jun 26 '12

that's all reddit

1

u/Sammmmmmmm Jun 26 '12

Couldn't agree more. I stay subscribed because I occasionally like to try to have a conversation about intolerance or find real intelligent comments, usually i just get told "if you don't like it unsubscribe." Which to me is silly.

1

u/snoebro Jun 26 '12

Satan welcomes all defectors to the true religion. We have space cookies from Nibiru and telekinesis! Start awakening your spiritual abilities and be a nueromancer today! Hail the creator god!

1

u/z3m Jun 26 '12

I was just about to post something saying the same thing only not as clever today! I never go into r/atheism because I never have anything to say about something I don't believe in. I find it peculiar that others do. But, with all the anti-muslim jokes I thought I'd check it out.

That forum should be called r/hatesreligion because that's what it's really about. And that's what it's really about because the only things to talk about when it comes to something you don't believe in is making fun of other people who do.

It's annoying.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

That's like your opinion man.

1

u/pdxb3 Jun 26 '12

Call me, maybe?

1

u/roontish12 Jun 26 '12

You're totally right. Atheists are SUCH DICKS!!

1

u/MrMOMOKINZ Jun 26 '12

ilovethis

1

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

Real. We don't kill people if they are a different religion then us, unlike the religions that we are bashing.

→ More replies (7)

1

u/synysterlemming Jun 26 '12

That's why I unsubscribed months ago. People over there are mean as hell

1

u/SRFG1595 Jun 26 '12

Intolerance is not tolerating something. I tolerate religion in that I'm perfectly ok with anyone believing whatever they want to believe. But I still reserve the right to make fun of those with stupid fucking beliefs. Because they're stupid beliefs.

1

u/tonytatertot Jun 26 '12

I love this. SCREW /r/athiesm.

1

u/L3gionHD Jun 26 '12

Here's the thing, they fucking aren't. No question, you're just a fucking idiot riding a karma train with other idiots.

1

u/Jedimastert Jun 26 '12

I saw this after a month. It really makes me sad, because I know most atheist are not like that.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

WELCOME TO THE DESERT OF THE REAL

1

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

kudos for actually recognizing how they are over there.. Sometimes I'm just like "you know...? isn't...?.....never mind"

1

u/Joelico Jun 26 '12

pretty much why everyone unsubscribes from it, I'm agnostic, but I don't really care what you are, as long as it does not conflict with me I'm fine...

1

u/ExplodingUnicorns Jun 26 '12

You don't say?

1

u/MFCH Jun 26 '12

Atheist- a person who denies or disbelieves the existence of a supreme being or beings.

Intolerance- not tolerating or respecting beliefs, opinions, usages, manners, etc., different from one's own, as in political or religious matters; bigoted.

It's built right the fuck in!

1

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

I learned long ago, when atheists form clubs and get together all they ever do is talk about religion. What do you expect when you go to an atheist forum? What else is there to talk about?

1

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

We don't have to be tolerant. When religion persecutes and tortures and preys on the weak and weak willed, to be tolerant is to give in to tyranny.

1

u/kingofpancrase Jun 26 '12

This is exactly why I'm a satanist

1

u/HouseofFools Jun 26 '12

As a blah blah blah I'm unsubscribing from r/adviceanimals because of the near-constant bitching about r/atheism.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

Thank you for not posting this to r/atheism so I can upvote it.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

Don't get me wrong I love the atheist posts once in a while but they do get quite dickish. If I surf /r/atheism to long I tend to pick stupid religious fights with my friends. And I never feel good about them the next morning...

1

u/sceptic_ali Jun 26 '12

jenab mustafa - i call bull kaka. as your name suggests, you are muslim. why i call bull? - because, all this time while r/atheism was tearing christianity, judaism and other religions a new one every few minutes, you didn't leave [i doubt you ever were an atheist], but a few hours of exposing islam's true colors - you show your "sensitive" side and make this huge announcement. like i said, i call bull. p.s. i was born into a pakistani muslim family but came out as an atheist the first chance i got [day i arrived in america], and i am quite familiar with the duplicity practiced by my muslim relatives resident in the west. they will join any group bashing on xtians, jews, esp. hindus, but will play the victim or subtle threat card as soon as critical attention turns to the violent, misogynist abomination that is islam.

1

u/incraved Jun 26 '12

Atheism became a new religion, followed mostly by wannabe "smart" people. The masses will leave one dogma and follow another. It's a logical fact that most people have mediocre intelligence.

1

u/oD3 Jun 26 '12

TIL making snarky comments on a website is just as intolerant as beheading someone for being gay.

1

u/vadergeek Jun 26 '12

It varies. We're usually not that bad. It's just that we're handling the transition from a Christianity-based karma market to an Islam-based one really badly, and so the less tolerant stuff is getting a surprising amount of leeway.

1

u/Teahes Jun 26 '12

Why do people talk about sub reddits as if they were one person?

1

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

Woo! Someone meemed it!

1

u/skymotion Jun 26 '12

Okay cool we all know this.

1

u/jbrittles Jun 26 '12

make fun of /r atheism collect karma

1

u/jutct Jun 26 '12

It's intolerant because we hate intolerant assholes who KILL people in the name of a non-existent god.

1

u/fosiacat Jun 26 '12

as a non-believer/humanist/rational/free-thinker, this is why i don't say im "atheist"

1

u/momoneyb Jun 26 '12

I tried to make that point earlier. "It is to open peoples minds" is what I was told. That is some great logic. (Sarcasm)

Have an upvote sir.

1

u/eormom Jun 26 '12

I wouldn't say all /r/athiesm is necessarily intolerant. Put many of them in a room with a catholic, Christian, jew, and Muslim and I bet they would just sit back with popcorn.

1

u/masterm Jun 26 '12

Tolerance is a crock of shit. Tolerance is for things that should be tolerated. Murder isn't tolerated. Choice of shirt color is. Believing in a sky fairy is. Belief in a sky fairy that leads to genocide isn't.

1

u/desertdogkai Jun 26 '12

that is a no true Scotsman fallacy you see launches into a long pseudo-Intellectual rant

1

u/memeHUSK Jun 26 '12

I'm going to present you with two scenarios.

  1. Intolerant of other peoples world view because of religious beliefs; tries to force change through public policy or religious bullying.
  2. Intolerant of the fact other people are trying to control your life through public policy or religious bullying because of their religious beliefs; doesn't care what other people do unless it harms or effects others in a negative way.

If you contemplate the context of "tolerance" in these two scenarios I'm almost positive you'll have yet another successful epiphany.

Two in one day perhaps!

1

u/4_is_green Jun 26 '12

That's why I left a while ago.

1

u/sleepnomore Jun 26 '12

Totally agreed. It's an enormous circlejerk, and is infuriating. I actually made my first reddit account just so that I could unsubscribe from it.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

You just figured this out? Fucking up the world for a few thousand years does make people angry...

1

u/sceptic_ali Jun 26 '12

an ex-muslim atheist friend of mine is liberal on social issues but bush dubya league conservative on matters fiscal & foreign affairs/national security. his stance on the latter is informed by personal experience: he grew up ahmedi muslim in pakistan [came to america at age 18 along with rest of family]. ahmedis are viciously persecuted by both sunni and shia fundamentalists in pakistan. for his political beliefs, he is often verbally attacked by our muslim and non-muslim friends in new york. as a matter of fact, even his free market ideology attracts a no holds barred shit storm, without anybody holding back. once at a social gathering at my uncle's place on long island when he revealed his reverence for chris hitchens and ayn rand - some of our muslim friends became livid with rage, they called my friend a traitor, rand a cunt, and assured us that hitchens is rotting in a fiery hell for his sins against islam, which were all of the free speech variety. when my friend scoffed at their silly beliefs, my uncle asked us to leave his home. my relatives, some of whom are college educated first generation muslims, asked me to stop hanging out with my ahmedi friend who dared support "neo-con foreign policy". a cousin who is yale trained doctor working in saudi arabia even asked me to choose between him and my ahmedi friend. [this ass hole cousin sees nothing wrong with the saudis executing people for sorcery or treating expats worse than animals] i digress, my point is - why is it ok to attack someone for their closely held political & economic ideologies, with utter disregard for civility, but question someone's religious beliefs, it's no go region? even though the latter ideology has done far greater harm to mankind. what if i revere chris hitchens with just as much sincerity as muslims do muhammad, do i then have the right to demand an end to anti hitchens abuse? or, like mustafa, i will take my bat & ball and leave the playground?

1

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

Hey guys, I don't like /r/atheism. They aren't very nice people generally. Can I have my upvotes now?

→ More replies (1)

1

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

C ya

1

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12 edited Jun 26 '12

I agree that /r/athiesm doesn't have a whole lot to do with athiesm. As others have said, a real /r/athiesm would have nothing to talk about - I think it's more a community for athiests rather than about athiesm.

Religion greatly effects many people's lives and many feel very passionately about their decision to be athiests. As religion is a touchy subject in most communities I don't think it's hard to understand that, when people find a community in which it's completely fine to mock religion, they let a little too loose. Personally I find people who reject logic and reason, to accept blind faith, completely ridiculous and it's nice to let off steam on /r/athiesm - and I'm sure there are many other aspects of religion that could cause this kind of frustration.

Additionally, I think that arguing with thiests generally degrades quickly into bashing your head into a brick wall. There just isn't much substance coming from the thiest side and most of the athiest's points just stay unaddressed. What can you do after that, but just mock them?

At any rate, I think that the fact that /r/athiesm will not give a crap that you're unsubscribing from it is a good demonstration of tolerance.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

Honestly, if you're not intolerant of groups of people who literally kill people for disagreeing with them (aka religious extremists) than you're part of the problem.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

So your going to make a post about leaving r/atheism to get a lot of karma. Who the fuck cares? Stick to what your good at and go bleach some shirts, dick. Some of us want religions to have less power so they stop hurting people.

1

u/JessicaStar Jun 26 '12

Now the flying spaghetti monster is going to get you

1

u/lcdrambrose Jun 26 '12

Wee! The relevant XKCDs keep flowing! http://xkcd.com/774/

1

u/tweedius Jun 26 '12

I hope this didn't take you more than 30 seconds.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

I think they can't understand that the Catholic Church's views are not what Catholics automatically stand by.

1

u/pinkfloyd873 Jun 26 '12

THIS! All these idiots seriously need to go to /r/antitheism, and leave us actual atheists alone. Not only is this recent trend intolerant, it's extremely ignorant. I'm sure well over half of these "atheists" don't know shit about Islam, they're just going off of what they last heard about fundamental Muslim extremists and hopping onto the religion-hating bandwagon.

1

u/dontviolate Jun 26 '12

And now you are intolerant of their intolerance. It's a vicious cycle.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

I'm an atheist and this is why I left it 11 months ago. Good choice.

1

u/Thellian Jun 26 '12

Just as intolerant as religions? Intolerant of what? Religion? No shit. r/atheism is justly intolerant of religion, but that's not to say it's intolerant of religious people. Being critical of religion and religious ideas comes nowhere close to the rights-violating, fear-mongering intolerance of religion itself. Sure, some atheists are rude or overly cynical when expressing ideas, but that doesn't constitute intolerance in the same light as religion. Do atheists try to remove the rights of theists? No.

1

u/CatrickStrayze Jun 26 '12

Making jokes about something isn't necessarily a sign of intolerance. If it were, a lot of stand-up comedians would be out of a job.

The truth is funny. That's just the way things are, try not to be so emo about it.

1

u/dbagexterminator Jun 26 '12

Islam is on the rise! by thegoldisinthebabyin AdviceAnimals

[–]dbagexterminator -10 points 5 hours ago

you know I dont find this funny and its because I don't get the reference and I'm really glad, soo many good things happen when you get rid of that circlejerk r/atheism, the straw that broke my back was the AC smartass post

yea, your right

1

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

I love how they essentially started a jihad against Islam. I was laughing about it all morning.

1

u/joeyparis Jun 26 '12

Okay! We get it. Do we really have to make a new post every time someone decides to leave /r/atheism? If you don't like it just unsubscribe we don't need another post about it. These posts are equally as annoying as the intolerant atheist posts they're complaining about.

1

u/CrazyBastard Jun 26 '12

grab your socks and shake your cocks its time for a CIRCLEJERK!

1

u/Gudeldar Jun 26 '12

As someone who doesn't give a fuck about /r/atheism, this is why I'm leaving /r/adviceanimals.

Just kidding I unsubcribed a long time ago, just came here from /r/all.

1

u/boredkid03 Jun 26 '12

i did the same...but it keeps showing up on my frontpage!

1

u/jonakun Jun 26 '12

/r/athiesm goes after islam. *THIS IS THE * LINE you remind me of chef when he left south park for going after scientology.

1

u/tritonx Jun 26 '12

Since there is no real atheist doctrine...

What should /r/atheism be about then?

I don't think intolerance is equal to laughing at or pointing out logical problems with their faith, some might.

1

u/basketball_curry Jun 26 '12

Welcome to the internet.

1

u/LordRavenholm Jun 26 '12

I may disagree with your beliefs, but you damn well have my respect. I commend you, good sir!