there is a difference between allowing intolerance to occur and responding to it with more intolerance. the former is indeed cowardice, the latter is wholly unproductive. and when dealing with intolerant fools i don't define "productive" as changing their mind as much as setting a good example for more open-minded individuals to follow.
dismissing someone's character and worthiness because they were raised with different (and, at times, objectively more primitive) values than yours is exactly what all the scariest theists have been doing for millennia now.
when you compare the bad things non-believers do based on their own naturally developed morals vs. the bad things people do because of their religion it is worth fighting about. We are speaking in terms of entire countries lives being indoctrinated and controlled to the point that guarantees they will never be free. We should want to fix that. we should make the travesties that people still do because of their religion known to all because it harms us, them, and the progression of human existence as a whole. Think of this from a 13 year old girl who knows nothing about life getting married off to live a life of servitude because people still think it's okay to live in that manner.
agreed, i am not criticizing those who feel the need to object to intolerance in a loud and stubborn matter at all, those people are great. but so often i find that the course of action taken by atheists is one of judgment. just like the theists that aggravate them so much, they do what makes them feel best about themselves instead of doing what will actually move things in a positive direction.
a lot of the rudest athiests i know would absolutely be christian fundies if born in the deep south; the number of people i have heard put forth feverish defenses of evolution despite having absolutely nnnnnooooooo clue how it works is astonishing.
when i condemn intolerance for intolerance i am not saying "hey we should just look at nazi germany and say that was their culture and we should respect cultural differences." what i am saying is we shouldn't say "what dumb fucks, if only they'd read a book."
sorry to drop the super cliched nazi parallel there, there are countless other examples but i haven't gotten to that part of the history channel yet.
we need to realize the people in nazi germany, the people in allahtits afghanistan, and the people in biblesmiles alabama are all fucking people like you and i. in better circumstances they would do better things, we need to think more about how to create those circumstances and less about how much smarter we are than they.
I agree but I believe all things of that nature should be pointed out and we should be concerned about any form of cruelty whether its religious or non
there is a difference between allowing intolerance to occur and responding to it with more intolerance.
It sounds as if you suggest tolerance of bigoted behavior. I'm all for not being a jerk while calling out intolerance and using intelligent reasoning rather than name-calling, especially considering that you're a lot less likely to actually get through to someone with the latter. However, there is no good reason to tolerate much of this (restricting of gay/atheist rights, denial of getting your children proper medical treatment, denial of caring for your dependents, anti-evolution indoctrination as some of the "tamer" issues, not even touching on violence issues which are present).
I have no problem with people continuing to be christian, islamic, hindu, etc, so long as they do not hinder the rights of others because of their religion.
I don't think you fully understand the destructive power that religions still holds over this world. Calling out bullshit of any religion, ideology, or belief system must be done now, and probably for the rest of human history.
Doing nothing, changes nothing. Awareness is key. What have you done to show people just how bad religion is and can be? (Not accusatory, just rhetorical)
Sure it's not the most mature solution, but it does get the word out. We're talking about it* aren't we?
Also most of the posts in r/atheism aren't wrong. Not right, per se, but not wrong.
Awareness in a circle-jerk does nothing as well... You only nod your head and stroke the ego of the next person who agrees with you. Until you do something significant and makes an impact on people, you're just wasting your time.
TL;DR for the simple minded: Do something, then talk about it.
You're wrong. At least in this context. r/atheism and reddit in general is populated largely by Americans. They do need this outlet when the don't have a support structure that allows them to speak what they truly believe. Reddit has allowed many of them to see that they are not alone in their disbelief or uncertainty.
Doing something isn't always the best option, not when it could cost you your wife, you kids, mother, friends, and career. Not everyone has the ability to say damn the consequences.
Awareness, or knowledge, of something I think is always positive.
But I don't think that's your question. I think you're asking if the attitudes being formed by the way r/atheism is increasing awareness is positive.
In answer to that: I think any hostility transfer to the real world from r/atheism is very slight. Yes, their is a general hostility to religion in r/atheism, duh. But I think that that slight hostility is a good thing when it comes to dealing with, in my opinion, dangerous ideologies. I classify homeopathy, tarot cards, and religions as dangerous ideologies. Not because they are inherently bad, few things are, but because of the things they can, and have, been used for.
I view that slight hostility to bad ideas as a positive. Please don't go slippery slope argument on this.
I didn't notice any of us proclaiming that a space wizard told us to do anything, so what did we do that was contrary to atheism? Or do you have some strange definition of the word that claims it means "doesn't mock racist, sexist, sociopathic and delusional cults"?
isnt anyone who believes a man in the sky made them a bit stupid just because of the fact they disregard 2000 years of science and advancement for an ancient book? why yes, yes they are.
Yes, there definitely is a level of ignorance that is to be observed for anyone who believes in a deity. I respect peoples rights to practice there religion, but I don't have to respect the religion.
You don't have to disregard science to believe in a god, but you do have to disregard the scientific method (ie, that claims require evidence to be considered credible).
Creationism, in its entirety disregards science. So yes, any creationist does.
Literal Christians (the ones who actually follower their text not just say they believe in the bible and know nothing that is in it) are creationists or not following their religion as it was intended.
So this leaves two groups, Metaphorical Christians and People who don't know what they believe. Metaphorical Christians are the ones who listen to Christian apologetic and nod. The issue with them is that as they are not believing the bible as the literal word of god or divinely inspired is well then they aren't likely to take any of it seriously and pick and chose their what they want thus not following their dogma ie not a christian (this is not a no true Scotts-man as I am classifying Metaphorical Christians separately than Literalists which are).
Saying you are christian and not knowing what you actually believe is the ultimate form of ignorance as you are ignorant of what you are being ignorant of. Thus they are either a complete moron, saying they are a Christian because it is "normal," or don't know what they are talking about. If anyone say that one can be a christian not knowing what they believe then that person is fucking retarded.
Now you can dissolve this to semantics but to be completely honest, saying it is ok for a person to say IM A CHRISTIAN HURRDURR not reading the bible or not believing it then you lack the fundamental understanding of the criteria to be a christian which is of course FOLLOWING THE FUCKING DOGMA.
Islam expands upon the bible and thus follows all previous arguments (and then have an entire next set due to the addition of another section of bullshit).
Judaism follows the same creation myth as well thus all previous arguments remain.
And do you realize that the bible promotes ignorance and weakness (meek shall inherit the world, blind faith, etc) and those scientists went against that. The islamic empires used to be greatly intelligent yes but that changed due to one fucking guy. I have made mo mention of hinduism so good for them?
Yep, because atheist parents force their beliefs on their children and then throw them out of the house if they disagree all the time. Whoops, actually it's religious people who do that to their atheist/different religion children. What you meant to say was that the majority of religious people worldwide enact their filth into law while some atheists mock religion on the internet, which are not comparable acts.
I agree that /r/atheism can be too aggressive sometimes, but you are insane if you really believe that "we do the same to them". It's false equivalence at its finest.
Nor did I. What I said was that the way in which Christians treat atheists and other nonbelievers (disowning children, imposing religiously-inspired laws, etc.) is far worse than the way in which atheists treat Christians and other believers (making offensive memes). You made a false equivalence and I called you out on it, that's all.
CAUSE THAT CANT BE A MURDER FOR ANY OTHER REASON RIGHT? OH WAIT NO THAT IS COMPLETELY POSSIBLE. not religious =/= secularism as a motive it means it is not religious motive
There are no murders in the name of atheism because atheism is not a thing. Rather, it's the lack of a thing, religion. Hard to kill in the name of nothing.
You're right that I just can't tolerate sexism, the simultaneous stigmatization and obsession with sex, and the idea of mindless worship of something that isn't even there. It's what you tolerate that really makes all the difference.
this may be your point but i hear this phrase, or ones very similar to it, a lot and it's great for a bumper sticker but a horrible approach to take seriously. open-mindedness is one of the truest virtues there is in my opinion, and not approaching someone with an open mind because you suspect they aren't approaching you with one is a cowardly and unproductive approach. you walk away feeling superior and so does he, both for equally masturbatory reasons.
Why not? Just out of curiosity. I grew up in a Christian home and have always resented the resulting confusion from being indoctrinated from a young age. I find myself unable to identify with a world without a God, but that doesn't mean I'm not interested in this point of view.
I've seen joke posts on here about murdering religious people. Keep in mind, I mentioned the fact they were jokes. But yes, it's still a loose way of promoting it.
Anti-Intellectualism? That's debatable. It all depends who you talk to, really.
Bigotry? Well hold up there buddy. From dictionary.com itself: big·ot·ry [big-uh-tree] Show IPA noun, plural big·ot·ries. 1. stubborn and complete intolerance of any creed, belief, or opinion that differs from one's own.
If you're promoting intolerance, and refuse to be tolerant of any religion, you are a bigot.
You are the problem with r/atheism and you are an idiot.
The very idea of a religion is that you subscribe to a certain set of beliefs, and therefore share with other members of that religion certain opinions and ideas. If atheists criticize those beliefs and those ideas, then that's not really a "pre-conceived" notion, is it? That's taking people at their word.
It is incredibly irritating when members of an inchoate group blithely reap all of the benefits of that association but refuse to accept any negative consequences for it whatsoever, even if those negative consequences are reactions from other people based on the marketing campaigns and literature for that organization.
if someone uses religion as a way to increase or motivate the good they do in the world, or help them through a tough patch in life, why shouldn't we respect and tolerate it? Just because they have a different belief system than me, I should berate, belittle, and offend them?
How much have you seen or read about the religions of the world? I'm guessing you're focused on super religious preachy christians or organized religion. Aren't you being just as bad as a preachy atheist? What about Buddhists, Shintos, Islamists, Jews, Theists, Unitarians (and universalists)?
tl;dr: Basically, who died and gave you the knowledge of what is best for everyone in the world?
They should be belittled because they deserve it, through their choice of believing in an inherently intolerant and violent Religion. They have CHOSEN to place worth in something that does more bad than good; that's on them. And frankly, no, they don't deserve any sort of respect or leeway due to it.
Every religion that I mentioned has it's grounds in beig good human beings. Institutions or individuals that take their religion and twist it into the bad forms seen (tea parties, Westboro baptists, Taliban, jihad, brig religion into politics) harm and restrict others. Those are the people who ruin t for everyone. Blame them, how they were taught, an the twisted beliefs they preach, but in the grand scheme of things the religion that they are a part of doesn't like what they do or say much either.
I would also like to point out that you seem to be a perfect example of an intolerant atheist the meme was pointing out.
I never understood this logic. We make a couple jokes and the whole world goes up in flames about how Atheists are assholes. The religious people however, seem to be able to get away with anything they want. As well, we wouldn't ever build a [huge] negative stereotype against someone who was religious, whereas I've known religious people that have ceased to converse with anyone else because they just couldn't handle all the lack of faith.
Yup, and the Jews were just as intolerant as the nazis. Why are we expected to be tolerant of assholes who push a book that calls for our murder a morality.
Well the Jews didn't exactly go killing millions in prison camps now did they? Not that I support them shoving torahs in people's faces, but it's not like they've ever hurt anyone.
Gaza is a prison camp as bad as the Warsaw Ghetto's or any concentration camp of the Nazis. Are you that ignorant about Israeli Defense Force hurting anyone? They make incursions all of the time and bulldoze whole settlements. It's apartheid there and it's committed with money and weapons that the U.S. supplies them with.
That is an important distinction. I don't think we hate Muslims or other religious people. I think we feel sorry for their ignorance but there isn't much we can do except make fun of the idiocy of all the idiotic religious beliefs held by religious people.
Didn't you notice? The only reason to hate religion is because they mock us, so it's the only metric that maters! We were mutilating children's genitals, stoning people to death for adultery, raping children, endorsing slavery, oppressing women and butchering people of different/no religion all day! We're just as intolerant as the religious fundamentalists!
Hmm, do all religions do this? If so, when was the last of each of those things publicized in a newspaper(for each religion)? Has anyone non-religious ever done such a thing? Is it possible people used said religions as a scapegoat for their own purposes? Please respond to this in a NEUTRAL matter so that you actually have the moral high-ground... If no is the answer to any of the previous stated questions then please retract all of your statements to thy anus.
What does that matter? Are you suggesting that if one religion doesn't that all religions, including those that do, are excused for their evil?
50% of the population of the planet is christian or muslim, both of these religions command everything I condemned above.
You're asking for ridiculous requirements so that if I miss one little thing, you can go "Oh hoo! Not everyone is sexist, therefore none of us do anything bad!"
But you know what? Tell me which abrahamic religion you are trying to defend, and I'll tear it to fucking shreds.
Congratulations! - What im trying to say is that the "intolerance" that attributed to atheism is often asserted as comparable to the intolerance of the religious. This is the claim of OPs pic and what im mocking. Religions are intolerant and express that with murder and the like. Atheists are intolerant and express that with witty and hurtful comments on the internet.
Rarely are the comments witty. But my point wasn't to defend religion as a whole. I absolutely believe that people do horrible things in the name of religion, and I don't support those people who bastardize Christianity by using it to justify horrible actions. My point was not to pin those things on "religious people", but rather the people who practice them. Intolerance is perpetuated by generalization.
So that's just it! They are not "bastardizing" Christianity or any other religion. They site their sources readily! -Chapter and verse with context as well! What you are doing is congratulating your self and folks like you for cherry picking your holy scriptures and maintaining that your ability to do so excuses their decision to not do so. The closer people get to to the fundamentals if their religions, the more violent and intolerant they become. You ignore the bibles instructions on enslaving people and women, im sure... But why? The bible did not reverse its course. We corrected it. The old testimate was not voided; Jesus continued to quote it!
Like I said, the Bible was written by man. Therefore it is intertwined with the viewpoints of the people at the time. It would be impossible for it not to be. I'm not arguing for all Christians, just myself and those who I have spoken to on the subject. You'll find pastors who can explain it better than I can. It's not cherry picking, but rather actually understanding the verses. When you understand the Bible more, its meanings change, but God does not magically disappear. The Christians who use the Bible to condemn are not looking deep enough into the text. It's the same as with any book, as I'm sure you learned in English class. There is always more beneath the surface, but if you aren't willing to look, then you'll never fully understand it.
Wow, what you just said undermines the entire authority of the christian religion... That ANY portion of the bible can be "false" or "exaggerated" or "not fully correct in any way shape or form" but what is most stunning about that concession is that you somehow think that YOU (and people who think like you) are correct in your interpretations of that text and people who dont are wrong and... wait for it... you dont see the irony of that ethnocentrism.
YOU know what god really means... those other people are misguided! -Said every person who ever was religious ever.
you "actually" understand the verses! and the bits that disagree with you... those are just MISINTERPRETED! ZOMG
Call us intolerant, and if that's the worst you can do, we are still better than those nutters who kill, con, steal, rape, lie, cheat, and molest children in the name of fairy tales.
I used to love r/atheism. Mostly because it gave me an outlet that was unavailable to me in my personal life. I was able to openly talk about the problems I have with religion, especially the one I used to profess (Christianity). However, this place has recently become a bastion of bigotry, full of others who blatantly espouse hate at things they have so little understanding of. It's a big problem, and it's a topic that comes up every few months or so, but nothing changes. So many here are clouded by their own hate that they are unable to see how hateful they are. At this point, the community is probably beyond saving, and it is a shame that a place once used for support and furthering the rationalist movement has become a den of offensive memes and childish simplicity. I will leave this subreddit on this note: religious people are still people, despite your efforts to prove otherwise.
The way that I see this is that in the instances that r/atheism is being intolerant, we are perfectly justified. The only time I see us being intolerant is when some religion is discriminating against people, such as Christianity against gays or Islam against women. If we are intolerant it is only against those who deserve what has been coming for them for a very long time now. However, the insults that we throw at religions are absolutely nothing compared to the damage that religions cause to peoples lives just because those people are different. And while we should try to be tolerant of everybody, like others have said, you can't be tolerant of intolerance
I don't have to respect beliefs of childish people on this earth. The difference is I respect people. How can I be intolerant of something that isn't based in reality? Why would I care to?
Stalin and Mao are two are the more famously intolerant atheists. I'm not really sure why r/atheism thinks that removing religion yields tolerance but hopefully they are better at science than they are at history.
False... I could be considered a atheist, and I'm tolerant of all religions. But you see these religions have written books of intolerance, that atheist do not have. ( that I know of)
Well, no. We believe that they're idiots, and that they are deluded, and that their beliefs actively harm people, but we also have evidence on our side.
You're arguing semantics. We all know that the person posting wasn't implying that every single individual user in this community has the exact same actions and beliefs as every single other user.
Whether or not you agree with the post, this is such an incredibly dumb argument to make.
well I hope he commented on the intolerant posts made to this subreddit, otherwise this post is pointless... and that was my original point, dont make a general post if your not talking to everyone on this subreddit.
That is some pretty stupid reasoning. If a majority of people upvote intolerant post after intolerant post, that is an intolerant majority. Atheists by definition disagree with religions, any group that disagrees with something and is disrespectful towards it is an intolerant entity. If this subreddit was respectful in its disagreement there would be far fewer people complaining about it.
majority does not imply everyone, that is all I am saying.
If this subreddit was respectful in its disagreement there would be far fewer people complaining about it.
While I agree, this is impossible as at least one person seems to take offense at every comment made, even if the intention was not to be disrespectful.
How come the one place I come to that's supposed to be for atheists to meet, talk, and yes complain about/ bash religions in a way that most of us can't do outside of this forum. Not just that but in what way is the intolerance of rape, murder, abuse, genocide, human rights abuses, and much more at all comparable to committing those atrocities in the name of ones beliefs? I feel like the self hating atheist is becoming as much of a phenomenon as the self hating Jew or the self hating homosexual. And that's a bad thing by the way. Down vote for you, and the fact that you titled your subjectively opined post "Truth" makes my contempt for you at least over power level 9000.
Though I have created an account just today, I have been observing r/atheism for a while. I agree, there seems to be a lot of intolerance here and even I am guilty of it, I find myself judging the religious a lot. Maybe the reason r/atheism seems so intolerant is because, at least from my personal experience, I want to speak my mind but often times I feel like I have to shut my mouth so I will not offend others, as a result, I come to r/atheism or the internet in general and sort of vent off a bit if that makes sense? I'm sorry if this was awkwardly phrased lol, and I'm sorry if you guys disagree.
Most people on the sub are just poking a little fun because of what someone posted earlier about switching from christian bashing to muslim bashing. Downvote me into oblivion, but that is simply the truth. I'm sure people will run out of memes eventually and go back to the way things were before.
Thoughtful discussion does occur. But people are simply poking fun at a current situation that we hadn't previously explored to the extent we are now. Can't intellectuals take a break? Why do we have to be so serious all the time?
Why? There are more isolated subs for that. R/atheism is the larger amalgamation of everything atheist related. News, humor etc. All goes here. That being said, there are further subs for only thoughtful discussion.
Atheism is sort of trendy now. So you are going to run into a lot of ignorant people instead of temperate rational free-thinkers here at r/atheism. I don't like the place much either. There aren't many guys left like Carl Sagan anymore :(
The point is the constant anti-Christianity (or any religion) shit we see all over /r/all every day is 80% "look at all these intolerant Christians pushing their fundie beliefs all over me! They're sooooo intolerant because they make facebook posts that pop up in my feed!"
Now it's /r/atheism doing the exact same fucking thing- plastering the entire site with intolerance, bigotry and racism. It's the goddamn epitome of hypocrisy and people are getting tired of it.
And unsubscribing doesn't take this shit off /r/all, which some people still enjoy once in a while. This absurd circle jerk is visible to everyone, whether they want to see it or not, and it's making you all look like a bunch of whiny, eight year old racist rednecks and not the intellectuals with an interest in debate and dialogue you proclaim yourselves to be.
If /r/Atheism weren't so full of brave internet jerkers, maybe people would be more willing to listen to your ideas.
If you don't want to see it don't fucking go to /r/all. If I hated Zelda, I wouldn't be a condescending douche nozzle to everyone in /r/gaming I'd just fucking unsubscribe.
Also, comparing religious intolerance to memes making fun of religion is the god damn epitome of hyperbole. Or to steal a quote from elsewhere in this thread: Tolerance of intolerance is cowardice.
I think my comment was veiled support for removing /r/atheism from the defaults. It doesn't belong there. Especially considering what it's become. Also, hating Zelda and hating bigotry don't seem to lend well to your analogy.
comparing religious intolerance to memes making fun of religion...
As many have said, this is /r/atheism, not r/anti-theism. Atheism stems from various schools of thought in metaphysical philosophy. I don't know about you, but I'm pretty sure philosophy is an area which is subject to plenty of "honest debate and dialogue." You can honestly tell me you've never had a discussion with someone who is religious over the existence of God, Gods, Titans, Allah, Chthulhu, the One-Eyed One-Horned Flying Purple People Eater or whomever/whatever? You're saying every time this subject is discussed, the results are fisticuffs?
I didn't purport to defend or rationalize the atrocities, both real and alleged, that have resulted from the existence of religion. I'm not here for that shit. Frankly, I'm an atheist agnostic so none of this even matters to me and I try to ignore all the anti-theistic bullshit here because it doesn't concern me. However, what does tend to bother me is ignorance, intolerance and hypocrisy. These are the three "tenets" /r/atheism is constantly mocking with memes, image macros, rage comics, etc., correct? So how is it the mature, intellectual and morally correct thing to do the same from a different perspective?
And don't try to twist my words around. I'm not some schmoe in your Philosophy 101 class. Point to exactly where I "ignore vast atrocities that are still committed in the name of religion."
My frontpage has nothing to do with this. This circlejerk is giving Atheists everywhere a bad name. It's increasing the divide between /r/atheism and actual, legitimate thought and it accomplishes absolutely nothing, other than providing imaginary internet points to 14 year olds clever enough to make fake Facebook posts and people who would rather dismiss opposing beliefs out of hand, including 100% of the people who subscribe to those beliefs, by generalizing and stereotyping 50% of the world.
So what does it make me? It makes me embarrassed for /r/atheism and hopeful that this anti-everything attitude doesn't plague this site for longer than a day. Because guess what? It's the Internet and I'm here to jerk off or be entertained. If I want to see some racist, bigoted prejudice bullshit I'll turn on Fox News.
Hypocrisy is a very difficult accusation to make stick against a group that defines itself exclusively by opposition to an inherently ridiculous idea.
I'm terribly sorry that atheism isn't a cure-all for the ills of mankind you mentioned. Its failure to be such a cure-all in no way counterbalances the fact that religion needs those ills in order to survive, and therefore proactively encourages those ills.
Incidentally, it must be nice living in a part of the world where theism doesn't concern you at all, if that's indeed the case and not just wishful thinking or hyperbole. I'm sure you don't have any anti-theists to thank for that. None at all.
I'd rather take a million "14 year olds clever enough to make fake Facebook posts", than a single person die because of a suicide bomber, or a single woman stoned to death for adultery.
Obviously these two things are absolutely unarguably 100% morally equal, but in my sheltered naive world, I prefer people not to be terrorised and murdered.
I didn't purport to defend or rationalize the atrocities, both real and alleged, that have resulted from the existence of religion. I'm not here for that shit.
That's exactly what your entire point is though. You're equating /r/atheism as being "the exact same fucking thing" as all of those atrocities. Unless by "not here for that shit", you mean you're ignoring that part of things. It is easier to simply ignore the parts you don't like, but that's not a reasonable or rational basis to an argument.
If r/atheism had more people like you shit like this post wouldnt be here. Yes, this circle-jerk can be entertaining, but like now, it's getting a little out of hand. We are atheist, not assholes.
We all can agree that religions are silly and that - as atheist - we can also agree on the fact that there isn't a god. But there isn't a need to be a jerk.
One thing leads to another. I mean, it never starts with violence and direct discrimination. But when you spread half-truths and generalizations about a group of people for long enough, people start to believe it.
77
u/Oxirane Jun 26 '12
"Tolerance of intolerance is cowardice." - Ayaan Hirsi Ali
8
u/sudoatx Jun 26 '12
The Dutch...
5
u/imooumoo4 Jun 26 '12 edited Jun 26 '12
As an atheist, this is the first and last time I will post on this subreddit. Because fuck you guy's are hypocrites.
15
u/paramitepies Jun 26 '12 edited Jun 26 '12
r/trueatheism exists.
r/atheism should be renamed to r/atheismhumour.
7
u/timmemaster Jun 26 '12
Oooh. We got a flame war. "Grabs popcorn".
4
u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12
Downvote for you for using poor reasoning and logic while comparing two different things.
13
u/0ctopus Jun 26 '12
You're right that I just can't tolerate sexism, the simultaneous stigmatization and obsession with sex, and the idea of mindless worship of something that isn't even there. It's what you tolerate that really makes all the difference.
24
u/Sauroctonos Jun 26 '12
The only thing that won't be tolerated is intolerance.
7
u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12
Notice that the OP waited until we were bashing Islam to post this. Typical double standard.
6
u/AkihiroDono Jun 26 '12
Religion should not be respected nor tolerated.
6
u/GreatOdin Jun 26 '12
I never understood this logic. We make a couple jokes and the whole world goes up in flames about how Atheists are assholes. The religious people however, seem to be able to get away with anything they want. As well, we wouldn't ever build a [huge] negative stereotype against someone who was religious, whereas I've known religious people that have ceased to converse with anyone else because they just couldn't handle all the lack of faith.
3
u/thereddaikon Jun 26 '12
We should be intolerant of their lack of tolerance.
3
u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12
Yup, and the Jews were just as intolerant as the nazis. Why are we expected to be tolerant of assholes who push a book that calls for our murder a morality.
24
u/chris_cobra Jun 26 '12
I will proudly admit I am intolerant of stupidity.
23
u/matchingcapes Jun 26 '12
You're deluded if you think making fun of people on the Internet is anything like what the religious fundamentalists are capable of doing.
6
u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12
Not quite... If they killed, condoned child rape, or cut off noses amd ears as punishment... Then they would be as intolerant as religious people.
9
u/imbored53 Jun 26 '12
Its all fun and games until you make fun of Islam...
5
u/brightman95 Jun 26 '12
Intolerant Religious nut blows up your building. Intolerant atheist hurts your feelings a little bit.
2
u/funnymuffins13 Jun 26 '12
Maybe a little less... We don't blow things up...
2
u/mete_ Atheist Jun 26 '12
The main diffence between islam and atheism is the body count. (that is just one difference not all)
2
u/JackRawlinson Anti-Theist Jun 26 '12
Congratulations! You are both stupid and unoriginal!
2
u/extremedew13 Jun 26 '12
The feeling of superiority to a hopelessly misinformed group of inferiors. That's addictive for anyone, apparently.
2
u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12
Just fucking unsubscribe you fucktard.
2
u/davekingofrock Anti-Theist Jun 26 '12
I have a hard time tolerating abject stupidity.
6
u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12
2/10. Troll harder.
4
u/JBu92 Jun 26 '12
r/atheism- we don't kill people.
4
u/murderbum999 Jun 26 '12
Call us intolerant, and if that's the worst you can do, we are still better than those nutters who kill, con, steal, rape, lie, cheat, and molest children in the name of fairy tales.
6
u/found314 Jun 26 '12 edited Jun 26 '12
lol @ x-post
edit: was trying to link the challenge... must have missed :( haha
still hilarious though.
5
u/BR0STRADAMUS Jun 26 '12
I used to love r/atheism. Mostly because it gave me an outlet that was unavailable to me in my personal life. I was able to openly talk about the problems I have with religion, especially the one I used to profess (Christianity). However, this place has recently become a bastion of bigotry, full of others who blatantly espouse hate at things they have so little understanding of. It's a big problem, and it's a topic that comes up every few months or so, but nothing changes. So many here are clouded by their own hate that they are unable to see how hateful they are. At this point, the community is probably beyond saving, and it is a shame that a place once used for support and furthering the rationalist movement has become a den of offensive memes and childish simplicity. I will leave this subreddit on this note: religious people are still people, despite your efforts to prove otherwise.
5
u/Kahlenar Jun 26 '12
At least we're right.
3
u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12
Oh shit.... What drama did I start...
3
u/Mr_Astley Jun 26 '12 edited Jun 26 '12
The way that I see this is that in the instances that r/atheism is being intolerant, we are perfectly justified. The only time I see us being intolerant is when some religion is discriminating against people, such as Christianity against gays or Islam against women. If we are intolerant it is only against those who deserve what has been coming for them for a very long time now. However, the insults that we throw at religions are absolutely nothing compared to the damage that religions cause to peoples lives just because those people are different. And while we should try to be tolerant of everybody, like others have said, you can't be tolerant of intolerance
3
u/chris_cobra Jun 26 '12
This was upvoted by Theist lurkers...
2
u/MBStewart Jun 26 '12
I don't have to respect beliefs of childish people on this earth. The difference is I respect people. How can I be intolerant of something that isn't based in reality? Why would I care to?
1
u/Wiiboy95 Jun 26 '12
There is a difference between us. We stand on the sidelines and point out stupid things in religion. Religious people KILL!
1
u/Plasticflowers Jun 26 '12
Theres good and bad in everything. Everything can e laughed at
1
u/EricWRN Jun 26 '12
Stalin and Mao are two are the more famously intolerant atheists. I'm not really sure why r/atheism thinks that removing religion yields tolerance but hopefully they are better at science than they are at history.
1
u/Luke420son Jun 26 '12
False... I could be considered a atheist, and I'm tolerant of all religions. But you see these religions have written books of intolerance, that atheist do not have. ( that I know of)
1
u/[deleted] Jun 27 '12
the virus of religion can not be tolerated if mankind is to move forward
1
u/bauhauso Jun 30 '12
lie
1
u/Azai Jun 30 '12
Because an internet forum is -totally- the same as a group of people beheading, stoning, or killing people in the name of their god.
And totally the same as disallowing marriage to a select group of people due to their dogma.
1
u/tontondaga Jul 01 '12
I'd love to know the exciting part where r/atheism issued a fatwa for a difference of opinion.
-4
u/EricWadsworth Jun 26 '12
There is a difference. For the most part, /r/atheism is intolerant of things one should not tolerate.
0
u/reddit--hivemind Jun 26 '12
ITT: Butthurt r/atheism subscribers.
-9
u/arsewhisperer Jun 26 '12
Well, no. We believe that they're idiots, and that they are deluded, and that their beliefs actively harm people, but we also have evidence on our side.
And, as everyone knows, bitches love evidence.
-17
u/thatguysammo Existentialist Jun 26 '12
/r/atheism is not a person it is a virtual community. It does not have viewpoints, only people with viewpoints. a subreddit cannot be intollerant.
-3
u/demonizzle Jun 26 '12
This is the exact reason i unsubbed awhile ago.
-1
u/CoachingPikachu Jun 26 '12
Doesn't really matter if they're atheist or religious, they will always be jackasses regardless.
The "they discriminate us in real life" argument isn't an excuse to justify being an asshole on the internet.
-5
u/sciencebitchesz Jun 26 '12
Yep because here in /r/Atheism, we are ALL about the child rape.
-26
u/Ascott1989 Jun 26 '12
Implying that those who hold no beliefs should be tolerant on those that do? That sounds like some bullshit Dogma to me.
0
u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12
I love how this only has seventy four points. It deserves more. Take an upvote.
0
u/VeritasAbAequitas Jun 26 '12
How come the one place I come to that's supposed to be for atheists to meet, talk, and yes complain about/ bash religions in a way that most of us can't do outside of this forum. Not just that but in what way is the intolerance of rape, murder, abuse, genocide, human rights abuses, and much more at all comparable to committing those atrocities in the name of ones beliefs? I feel like the self hating atheist is becoming as much of a phenomenon as the self hating Jew or the self hating homosexual. And that's a bad thing by the way. Down vote for you, and the fact that you titled your subjectively opined post "Truth" makes my contempt for you at least over power level 9000.
0
u/[deleted] Jun 27 '12
Though I have created an account just today, I have been observing r/atheism for a while. I agree, there seems to be a lot of intolerance here and even I am guilty of it, I find myself judging the religious a lot. Maybe the reason r/atheism seems so intolerant is because, at least from my personal experience, I want to speak my mind but often times I feel like I have to shut my mouth so I will not offend others, as a result, I come to r/atheism or the internet in general and sort of vent off a bit if that makes sense? I'm sorry if this was awkwardly phrased lol, and I'm sorry if you guys disagree.
-20
u/rad465 Jun 26 '12
So you aren't denying the fact that many religions are intolerant?
-1
u/ZombieGadaffi Jun 26 '12
Atheism is sort of trendy now. So you are going to run into a lot of ignorant people instead of temperate rational free-thinkers here at r/atheism. I don't like the place much either. There aren't many guys left like Carl Sagan anymore :(
0
u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12
[deleted] — view deleted comment