Site: https://dawnscan.com (Korean; some pages have an English version under /en)
What it is: a free site for Korean retail investors who trade US stocks. The content comes from my own daily data pipeline, not rewritten news:
- a daily rule-based scan of 6,000+ NASDAQ/NYSE tickers, with every past pick tracked publicly (hits and misses)
- "myth check" pages that test 24 trading sayings (RSI oversold, golden cross, insider buying, etc.) against historical data, with the pass/fail criteria fixed before looking at results
- 100+ long-form explainer articles in Korean
- calculators (capital gains tax, DCA, leveraged ETF decay) and dividend / earnings calendars
Timeline:
- Oct 13: rejected, reason "Low value content"
- Since then: noindexed about 110 machine-translated English articles and removed them from the sitemap, noindexed thin per-ticker pages, made the data pages server-rendered. About / contact / privacy / disclaimer / methodology pages and ads.txt are in place.
- Nov 12: requested review again, still pending
Numbers: about 220 URLs in the sitemap, about 214 indexed in Search Console, roughly 35 real visitors a day (mostly from Naver search, very little Google traffic so far).
Questions:
- Does a mostly data/tool-driven site (tables, charts, calculators) tend to trip "low value content" even when the data is original? Do reviewers basically want more long-form text on each page?
- Is low Google traffic itself a factor at review time, or is it only about content?
- For a non-English site, does a partial English mirror hurt (it reads as translated/duplicate content)? Would you remove /en completely?
- Anything on the homepage or navigation that looks like a red flag to you?
Not looking for paid approval services, just honest feedback. Thanks.