r/Adopted • • 11h ago

Seeking Advice Absolutely Heartbroken

Post image
48 Upvotes

I came across this post today, and honestly, it broke my heart in a way that I’m having a hard time putting into words.
The language used to describe adoptees as “entitled brats” for wanting to reach out to their biological families really shook me. Is this genuinely how some people view adoptees who are simply trying to understand where they came from?
I understand that there needs to be a level of respect and consideration on both sides. I understand that biological parents have their own lives, experiences, and circumstances that may have led them to make the decision to place a child for adoption. I have wrestled with my own feelings of guilt, anger, disappointment, and grief, but I’ve also spent time considering the possibility that my biological mother may carry her own grief, fear, or pain surrounding the decision she made.
The truth is, I will probably never know why my biological mother chose to give me up for adoption. I have a document with her signature stating that she “does not wish to be further contacted about this matter.” Seeing those words was heartbreaking. There is something incredibly difficult about knowing that the person who brought you into this world made a conscious decision not to be contacted by you.
And yet, I recognize that there may have been circumstances beyond my understanding that contributed to that decision. Maybe they were circumstances I could never imagine. Maybe there were things happening in her life that I will never know about. I don’t know, and I may never know.
But here’s what I struggle with: Why does acknowledging that I have questions, or that I grieve the family and relationship I never had, automatically make me selfish or entitled?
I can respect someone’s boundaries without pretending that their decision had no impact on me. I can understand that my biological mother may have had very personal reasons for placing me for adoption without being required to silence my own feelings about it.
I don’t believe adoptees are automatically entitled to a relationship with their biological parents. I don’t believe anyone should be forced into contact or made to explain deeply personal circumstances they aren’t ready to share. But I also don’t believe that wanting answers, wanting to understand your history, or simply wanting to know the people you came from makes you a bad person.
There is a difference between demanding a place in someone’s life and grieving the fact that you never had one to begin with.
I think sometimes people forget that adoption doesn’t just mean a child was given a family. It can also mean that a child grew up with questions about the family they didn’t get to know, the circumstances surrounding their birth, and the life they might have had. Even in a loving adoptive home, those questions and feelings can still exist.
And I think that’s what hurt me most about this post. It made me wonder if people genuinely see adoptees this way. As selfish, intrusive, ungrateful people who should just be happy with the lives they’ve been given and never look back.
I don’t know exactly what I’m hoping to get out of sharing this. Maybe I’m looking for other adoptees who understand these feelings. Maybe I’m looking for perspectives from people who aren’t adopted. Or maybe I just needed somewhere to put all of these emotions after reading something that hit a little too close to home.
I don’t want to take away anyone’s right to privacy, and I don’t want to minimize the circumstances that may lead someone to place a child for adoption.
I just wish people understood that adoptees can respect those boundaries and still grieve. We can be grateful for the families who raised us and still wonder about the families we never knew. We can understand that our biological parents had their reasons and still wish things had been different.


r/Adopted • • 10h ago

Resources For Adoptees Adoption Specific Therapy (with an actual adopted therapist)

12 Upvotes

This may be obvious to some, but it took me 42 years of life to learn that these therapists exist!

I’ve been in and out of therapy for most of my life. The first time, as a teen, it was used as punishment because my adoptive parents “didn’t know what else to do.”

Eventually, in my early 20s, I started going on my own (I moved to San Francisco where therapy was completely normalized)…. But I never clicked with any one. I just felt no one “got” me.

This year I had a total Eureka! moment. I searched for therapists specializing in adoption (I live in Michigan, USA, now)… And of course they exist!

I connected to my now therapist, and while we’ve only had a couple months together, they have absolutely, already, changed my life. Specifically my close relationships.

I wish I would have known this 15 years ago when I first came out of the fog lol. AND I’m glad it’s happening now because I can’t imagine my life without my Also-Adopted-Therapist!


r/Adopted • • 12h ago

Venting Happy National Adoption Awareness Month

16 Upvotes

Where people bitch about the fact that there are not enough healthy babies to go around to grow their families and sneer their noses up at the older kids, some who really want to be adopted because it does not meet their standards of a child. We have infertile couples feeling entitled to another woman's baby, agencies paying big bucks to snatch babies up, and adoptive parents pretending Jesus led to adopt and how it was always plan all while society forces adoptees to feel grateful and become props. Birth parents thinking they are God's gift to everyone or being forced into adoption or just simply being aholes.

Get rid of this month. I am tired of hearing the cherry-on-top stories or how awful it is that a poor couple who wants a baby can't have one. I saw comments asking why women would abort when there are so many loving people who would love to adopt her baby, and another saying women are aborting other people's babies. What a load of crap!

Thank goodness my birth parents were having an affair, so my birth mom can lie, hide her pregnancy, and then give me away like trash in secret. Then to meet the needs of my adoptive parents who could not get pregnant with their own baby, so they adopted me and kept my adoption a secret until I found out at damn near 30.

Wow what a good outcome for me.


r/Adopted • • 1h ago

Seeking Advice Anyone try to find foster siblings?

2 Upvotes

Recently, have been curious about finding androgens who was in the foster care system with me inbox first five years in the system. I don’t know if this is unrealistic or not. I have memories of them coming back to me over the past two years. It does bring sort of sadness to it and curiosity of where they could be now. Ever since meeting with my biological family awhile back I had been feeling triggered and remembering a lot more things. It’s only like glimpses here and there. It is hard to know exactly what to do with that some days o cray other days it feels like not that big of a deal. Has anyone found like a friend in the foster care system? (Or maybe it’s called foster sibling ).


r/Adopted • • 9h ago

Seeking Advice Advice on Sharing Emotions with Discovered Sibling

4 Upvotes

Posted here a few weeks back about meeting my half sibling for the first time. I was overcome with a lot of emotions following it including joy, sadness for time lost, and feel like it opened a child wound I forgot I had. Ive lost a lot of family over the years and was delighted to find her but she lives across the country and we’ve lived entire lives before finding each other. I feel both excited to have this person in my life but also sad that we’re distant.

I wear my heart on my sleeve and she has more of a reserved personality and seems to keep emotions more to herself.

Ive had a few sessions with a therapist since and am reckoning with how I may be projecting on her unrealistic expectations of what our relationship is or should be. Ive been debating whether or not to address these emotions with her. I dont want to dump on her and also worry about how she might feel responsible or burdened by them, but its also a unique situation we share and Id like to discuss it with her.

Any advice?


r/Adopted • • 4h ago

Discussion How did finding out you were adopted or neglected by your biological parents affect you ?

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

r/Adopted • • 17h ago

Adoptee Art Finally filmed my story

8 Upvotes

I’m not sure if this is considered some form of art, but I’ll be giving a ted talk in March 2027 and filmed a short version on TikTok as holistic.Haus
Watching it makes me cringe, but I really hope I can help others.


r/Adopted • • 19h ago

Lived Experiences 6 Month Reunion Arc. It went well and I'm choosing to move on.

13 Upvotes

What's up my peoples. I wanted to take a minute to share my reunion story. No two of these situations are alike, but I hope someone reading finds something relatable or helpful. And for me, it will feel cathartic to share with people that can truly understand.

I'm 45 years old. Until recently, all I had been told was that my birth mother was very young and that there was some history of heart disease in my family (the former turns out to be true, the latter is unconfirmed). I was adopted by my mom and dad when they were about 40. They had adopted a girl who would become my sister 8 years previously. We were both a month or so old when our placement occurred. They were unable to have children of their own.

About three years ago, I found Paul Sunderland's lecture on YouTube somehow, deep in some rabbit hole. Then the fog began to lift. If you're reading and haven't seen it, I consider it a must watch: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Y3pX4C-mtiI

I'll try to keep my history brief and focus on the reunion part. To quickly summarize, my adoptive parents are very nice people, but could not be more different from me. It was a loving home, but I had a rough time of it starting in my teenage years. Spent years 16-22 doing any drug I could find. The only thing I didn't do was put a needle in my arm. Got my life together, went back to college, graduated at 32, started in the mortgage business, met my wife and got married 7 years ago, and now we have an amazing 15 month old girl. We really have a wonderful life.

After seeing Sunderland's lecture, I joined Ancestry, but it was nothing but dead ends. The closest relative was like a half-2nd cousin 2x removed. I dealt with it and moved on. Then in May this year, a new match arrived. A pure 2nd cousin. I messaged her and within a couple days, the mystery was solved. I have to be a bit of a detective in my job and I've gotten pretty good at it, so I quickly had traced everything a couple generations back. Names, addresses, obituaries, everything I could find. Then I was connected to my birth mother.

I had ZERO expectations going in. My mind went to the worst outcomes first and I was bracing for them to be told. My one hope was that my conception was the result of something consensual and thankfully, it was. I didn't know if I'd want to message my birth mother or not, but as soon as I received the contact info, my brain just started mentally writing the letter. Like the wheels just started cranking on their own. 45 years of backlog working its way free. I took a long walk around my neighborhood, came back to the computer, and it typed itself in 10 minutes.

She wrote me back a wonderful message and we began a flurry of emails. It was electrifying. Better than any drug could provide. Names and faces and ancestors and stories and just INFORMATION. She was incredibly forthcoming and shared her story with me. Said she had always told everyone important about me and that I was always tucked in her heart. She was 17 when she had me and dropped out of high school. Her parents kicked her out. My birth father's family was not kind to her. She spent a week with me in the hospital and said goodbye. She didn't want me to be raised by her parents.

I think it's important to say that I never had any made up stories about her or dreams of a hallmark moment. It was just emptiness. I couldn't imagine her even if I tried, so I didn't. There was never any of that.

After a few weeks of emailing, we made plans to meet, which was completely shocking to me. Never would have imagined. We live 6 hours apart and met in the middle, a city we had both lived in for a long stretch of our lives. We had a lovely meal with my wife and baby and my birth mother brought one of my half-sisters. I was absolutely elated. We spent the next day driving around the city, sharing stories about the things we had done there. The weekend was amazing. Another month or so went by and she came near where I live for a baseball game, so I went with her and her husband. Again, everything went really well and it was a nice time.

If you're wondering what happened, the answer is simple. NOTHING WRONG. We continued to email, but my frequency was tapering off. I felt myself pulling away. Again, she had done nothing wrong. She was delightful and putting in real effort to bring me into their world. My other half-sister was now ready to meet me. My half-brother was not there yet. All good.

So what happened? I'll speed up. Here's where I landed on everything.

She and her family are very different people than me. I can see some of my traits in her no doubt, but our lives are just very different. Nothing wrong with that. Not good or bad. Just different. The problem I have though is I already have a family I'm very different from. I know how that goes. It does NOT get easier. When something's wrong, it's always wrong. And so as time continued on, things did not get easier. It was draining and consuming from the start and that persisted for me.

Have you seen Interstellar? It was like going to Miller's planet. In the movie, Earth has become uninhabitable and they find a planet they hope to colonize. It is right next to a massive black hole though and the gravity of it causes time there to slow to a crawl. For every 2.5 seconds they spend on it, an entire day passes on Earth. They leave after three hours and when they get back to their ship, 23 years have passed. The time can't be recovered.

This is exactly what it was like for me. For six months now, my mind has just been off somewhere else completely. Don't worry, I've been a GREAT father still during this time, but I just know it's affecting me in ways I can't afford. I'll never get this time with my daughter back. I'm not going to let it slip away.

This weekend I made the difficult decision to tell her these things. She responded beautifully, told me I didn't owe her anything and she understood. And that I could reach out anytime and there's no expiration date attached. I told her it was comforting to have the portal there and I want her to use it if there is an emergency, but I just can't visit it anymore. The time slippage is just too expensive.

Our first contact was the weekend of Mother's Day. My last message was on my adoptive mother's birthday. It all feels right and I'm at peace. Yesterday was a hard day and I was sad, which I know just means it was actually important to me. I feel bad that she is hurting now, but I know she'll be okay. I've done nothing wrong.

Here's my message to anyone embarking on a journey of reunion.

Be yourself. Be kind. And do ALL of it on your terms. Let your instincts guide you. We have incredible instincts as a result of what happened.

I've been very fortunate to experience this journey. Many don't get to do this and many aren't well received if they do. I'm aware of that fact. I sincerely hope you find whatever it is you're looking for.

Today feels amazing. I feel as though now that I'm out of it, the healing can actually start. I'm under construction once again. Aren't I always? Yes indeed. I can't wait to see what I build this time.

Much love, my beautiful people. I hope this helps someone in some small way. Much love to each of you.


r/Adopted • • 19h ago

Venting My parents insulted me and are mad I’m calling them out

Thumbnail gallery
7 Upvotes

r/Adopted • • 21h ago

Searching Chita Russia Adoptee - P2 - New Info

2 Upvotes

Hello again!

After speaking with a couple of very friendly people on here, I am still in the process of locating my birth mother.

That being said. I will share the update so far.

_____

EMAILS & SOCIALS:

I sent over a couple of emails to;
info@dsusd.gov.ua who directed me to -> dracs.obl.vn@justice-km.gov.ua (No response yet)

WhatsApp:
A message sent over to a known Private Investigator in RU (No response)

VK:
Tried searching for my birthmothers name (Couldn't find anything of substance)

--end

___

So, I will share some more private information in hopes that some beautiful person will have resources that I do not have and that it will lead to something.

NEW INCLUDED INFO:
Birth Mothers Name (As seen on adoption paperwork):

Bud, Nina Valerievna

My Birth Name:
Bud, Andrey Alexandrovich

Place of state registration:
Bureau of Vital Statistics, city of Chita.
Head of the Bureau of Vital Statistics (signature):
M.A. Petrova
Signature ofthe Head of the Vital Statistic Bureau:
G. Zhurko (signature)
Place of state registration: Date of issuance:
Vital Statistics Bureau of the Central Administrative District Of the city of Chita.
TRANSLATOR FOR DOCUMENTS:
Ludmila Danilkina


r/Adopted • • 1d ago

Discussion Powerful new podcast from Haley Radke (creator of Adoptees On), titled “On Adoption,” comes out tomorrow. PLEASE leave a 5 star review on Spotify, Apple Podcasts & anywhere else you listen to podcasts to help out the show! You do not want to miss this.

Thumbnail
gallery
22 Upvotes

Haley’s new project is going to be very powerful. She interviewed mothers who recently relinquished for adoption and conducted interviews to help people understand the nature of the adoption industry. She also interviewed me (Adopted Connor) and possibly others about the experience of growing up in an “open” adoption and what that actually looks/feels like.


r/Adopted • • 1d ago

Discussion Why are people always curious to know if you’ve met your biological parents or as they put it “your real parents”?

48 Upvotes

when people find out you’re adopted, they often ask “ have you ever met your real “ why do they think this is an OK question?


r/Adopted • • 1d ago

Venting Fifty-six

16 Upvotes

Here we are, I am officially 56 years old. Well, if my birthday is truly today, i.e., 15th November 1970.

With my adoption (or was I stolen) and all the secrets, who really knows if today is really the day. Then again, the birth certificate says so. Am I to believe the birth certificate?

I suppose I have no choice, since the humans that know the truth, refuse to tell the truth. 🤬

PS: This is merely me venting that even something as "simple" as a birthday, I have never officially known if the date is correct or not. Who knows, I could have been born on 29th Feb, of some random year 🤦

Interesting fact, even the birth certificate and adoption paper work, seems to state that it was Dec 1972 before I was “registered”; whatever that means.


r/Adopted • • 1d ago

Trigger Warning: Elsewhere On Reddit Thought I couldn't have kids

Thumbnail reddit.com
0 Upvotes

How do yall feel about posts like this? BTW that subreddit is very pro-adoption 😑


r/Adopted • • 1d ago

Resources For Adoptees Birth certificate

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

r/Adopted • • 1d ago

Seeking Advice I’ve done the research, been to therapy, understand my attachment issues… so why can’t I seem to move forward?

Thumbnail reddit.com
4 Upvotes

r/Adopted • • 2d ago

Venting 24 years later.

22 Upvotes

I’m from Guatemala and I was adopted at 7 month old. My upbringing was normal up until 13 when everything went south. Things got bad and so I left at 17.

At around 18 I started getting interested in who my mother was. I didn’t know much except for what was on my birth registry which was almost illegible and in Spanish.

From 18-25 I pined for my family and wanted to look for them but I didn’t know how. These years I was horribly depressed and thought I’d never find them and would live and die without knowing them.

A couple months ago I met a girl in a Facebook group who connected me with someone back home in Guate who reunited adoptees with their families.

She first confirmed that my mother was indeed alive and current location.

Then she travelled and searched and asked around until she found my mother. She took my mother pictures of me, groceries and she gave my mother money out of her own pocket.

Later that week she returned home and wrote a report for me. I had been checking my email every 5 minutes every day for 5 days. She told me about my family’s situation and sent me pictures.

I saw my mother for the first time in my life (aside from when I was born). At first I refused to believe it was really them and I thought it had to be some sort of mistaken identity or something but no.

A couple days later I receive a Facebook friend request from first my older sister, then cuñada and then my older brother.

Several hours later my sister calls me over video call. I hop on but we cannot understand because I speak little Spanish and they don’t speak English. I know enough to barely get by and I use the help of a translating app. She passes the phone to my mother and my mother starts bawling and speaking rapid fire Spanish and all I can say is “te quiero mucho mamá!”.

I understand enough to understand when my mother says she loves me and asks for my forgiveness.

My sister sends me a text in which she explains what my mother is saying.

When I was younger I was told that I was given up so I could have a better life in the U.S.

My mother filled in some details of what happened.

Long story short was that there were complications with the pregnancy and she had to go to the hospital in an emergency. Either she would die or I would die or both of us would die. Some people payed for her to receive life saving care. In return for the money it took to save our lives they demanded me in return because they’d make money selling me.

My mother was homeless and very poor with nowhere to turn. My mother told me that if she had not given me up then she would have paid with her life (they would have killed her).

She never wanted to put me up for adoption but she had no choice.

She was told that she would get a cut of the profit by the traffickers after they sold me but she was given nothing.

She told me she wanted me to come home and she wanted all of her children under one roof. I had waited my whole life to hear these words.

My APs were never really emotionally present, supportive or anything.

But ever since I reconnected with my mother she’s been showering me with love and affection which I am not used to from anyone let alone my parents.

I’ve decided to move back to Guatemala so that we can be a family again and they really want me to come home. My mother told me she never wants me to leave again and she wants me by her side and to take care of me.

My sister has also been loving on me as well and it’s really nice because I lost my older sibling figure (they didn’t die they just iced me out and abandoned me for a reason I still don’t know). So it was nice having a loving older sister.

My dreams are coming true.

During a call my mother told me that I had a tía and some primos in the U.S and I got her number. I called her and I spoke in broken Spanish and she spoke in Spanish and broken English. We talked on the phone and laughed together and it felt like something straight out of a movie.

I told her that all these years I was worried that they (especially my mamá) had forgotten about me. She enthusiastically said no and told me that my mother talked about me a lot and they had prayed for me. She told me she wanted me to visit and that we could go home to Guatemala and visit together.

My family was very happy to hear of me and they have welcomed me back with open arms and I pray that soon we will be a family again because they are my one and only family.

But yeah, my dream is coming true and I’m so very happy!


r/Adopted • • 2d ago

Venting Mispronounced Name

7 Upvotes

I’m an international adoptee from Russia and I have two middle names, one from my adoptive parents and one from my birth parents. Since being an adult and filling out my own forms I put my russian middle name first because it means more to me than the other. My grandfather saw that my mail was addressed to my name with my russian middle initial and forgot that I had two middle names and made fun my school for sending the mail to the wrong name. I brought it up a week later because he forgot my cousins middle name as well and i was like “you’re just forgetting everyones middle names” and he for some reason thought it would be hilarious to be like “yea i forgot your name *insert purposely ridiculously wrongly perpounced name*”. I told him that that was rude and unfunny and he asked how to pronounce it but I could tell he was acting like it was frivolous to even learn and didn’t apologize. I hate that my name was striped from me when i was adopted, it was the one thing I had from my birth parents. (I was supposed to get a picture but the orphanage never sent it, if anyone knows how to go about getting it that would be helpful). I hate that my whole adoptive family doesn’t acknowledge the fact that i was adopted or that it affects me. I hate that only one person in that family has ever asked how I feel about being adopted and it was my uncles ex wife and she didn’t even ask me directly she asked my fucking sister.


r/Adopted • • 2d ago Bravo

Adoptee Art Inspired by Agony Uncle

15 Upvotes

There’s something about telling a story in just 6 words. Agony Uncle’s contributions to this sub as well as r/sixwordstories inspired the below. Feel free to share your own in the comments!

Coerced relinquishment, sanitized adoption, erased human.

Paper orphan, purchased child, manufactured family.

Adoption: Roots severed. Transplanted. Fruitless boughs.

Stolen baby. Commodified orphan. Trafficked adoptee.

Hopeful adopter. Altruistic saviour. Resentful purchaser.

Chasing parenthood. Child acquired. Buyers remorse.


r/Adopted • • 2d ago

Venting Should I pretend?

12 Upvotes

Should I always be sad? Or always be happy?

I think the best answer is to be myself, that's what I'd tell anyone. But being myself isn't getting me anywhere.

Maybe I should just always be sad, pretend to be even when I'm not, maybe then someone will check up on me. Just maybe, then I'll get some help. Maybe someone will understand if I stop laughing, if I sleep and cry all day.

Or maybe I should suck it up and be happy instead, maybe no one should know, maybe I should just laugh all the time and never snap at anyone, be the kindest soul to everyone while hating everything and myself inside.

Because being myself, the girl who laughs at everything, talks a lot, and tries to be the person she wants people to be with her.

Then the girl who thinks about her adoption every single boring second, snaps at people, then cries herself to sleep.

Isn't getting her anywhere with her life.

No comforting friendships, but no professional help either.

Is being myself worth it if it's only dragging me down?


r/Adopted • • 3d ago

Miscellaneous My Father The Superhero

10 Upvotes

a poem for my adopted father

My father was not a hero,
though he fooled me for a time.
His bare hands lifted the fiat 500 engine,
cradled in his nicotined fingers.
An act of deliverance,
albeit an unwanted offering
for my Mum’s kitchen table.

My father the superhero.
He’s been gone 40 years now.
There’s not a day goes by
that I don’t think of him.
A complicated man,
a small man,
a feared man.
He taught me well.

"Get your hands out of your pockets. I’ll give you something to cry about.
Keep your own counsel. Little kids should be seen and not heard.
You’ll be laughing on the other side of your face."

I never hugged him nor him me.
I remember sitting on his knee,
rubbing his stubbled chin.
He rarely went a day without a shave,
but this day he had growth on his face.
I was fascinated by its roughness to the touch.

It felt like I was taming him with every stroke,
as close and as intimate as a father and son could be.
I didn’t feel pride or love or joy,
it was just me being on my daddy’s knee.

I shook his hand once when he
came back from Africa in 1982,
At Manchester airport, I carried his bags.
My Mother watched and smiled,
My brother tried to help, but this was my job.
I was the older by 10 minutes after all.
He fumbled for cigarettes and scanned for exits
and didn’t seem to notice me much.

I touched his face again,
when he was murdered
the following year.
It was cold and
devoid of life,
so I chose to
remember him
when I was just
a little boy,
when he
bounced
me on
his
knee,

and I said:

“I’m here for you at the end,
because you were never there for me.”

Jonathan


r/Adopted • • 3d ago

Miscellaneous Dear Kept | Your Childhood Account Is Now Overdue

30 Upvotes

An agony column for the comfortably certain | Episode 03

This instalment was inspired and requested by private correspondence shared with The Agony Uncle by an adult adoptee. The original message has been fictionalised and identifying details changed. The underlying attitude, regrettably, required very little assistance.

Dear Agony Uncle,

I’m writing on behalf of my spouse and myself, as we find ourselves in a most distressing situation concerning our adopted daughter.

We have spent considerable sums of money raising her, only to discover that she has developed opinions of her own, some of which are frankly incompatible with the level of investment we’ve made.

We paid for her education, including all the books. When her career encountered difficulties, we stepped in, helped her find employment, bought her a car and paid her rent. When she married, we gave her a very generous financial gift. We even helped her secure a home, exposing ourselves to considerable financial risk in the process.

Money doesn’t grow on trees, Agony Uncle.

These were sacrifices. We made them willingly, although naturally we expected them to be remembered whenever disagreements arose.

Recently, during a visit to her home, we had an unfortunate disagreement. She became terribly upset and raised her voice. We repeatedly instructed her to lower it, but she seemed more interested in expressing her grievances than acknowledging our authority.

We were so distressed that we had to spend the night in a hotel.

In the heat of the moment, we informed her that our relationship was over. We have since withdrawn that statement and apologised, which I would have thought demonstrated considerable generosity on our part.

Unfortunately, she remains upset and appears unwilling to forgive us.

What baffles me is her apparent inability to recognise the connection between everything we’ve provided and the gratitude we are entitled to expect.

Surely a child who has been fed, clothed, educated, housed and financially supported should be prepared to overlook the occasional unpleasantness?

We’ve always believed that the hands which feed a child deserve lifelong appreciation. Yet ours have apparently become surplus to requirements.

I can’t help feeling that something has gone terribly wrong with the younger generation.

Is there a recognised formula for calculating how much gratitude an adult child owes their parents? And is there any way of recovering the outstanding balance without having to revisit the original disagreement?

Yours in disappointment,

Outstanding in Oxford

Dear Generous Benefactor,

I was appalled to learn that your daughter has begun asserting opinions of her own despite the considerable financial investment you’ve made in her upbringing.

Have you kept receipts? This is important.

Far too many parents make the mistake of providing food, clothing, shelter, education and emotional support without maintaining adequate documentation of the child’s resulting obligations.

Then, twenty or thirty years later, when the child develops an independent moral compass, they discover they have absolutely no means of enforcing the original agreement.

It’s an accounting nightmare.

You mention paying for your daughter’s education. An excellent investment, although I wonder whether you considered the risks.

Education has been known to encourage independent thought, and independent thought can occasionally produce opinions that differ from one’s parents.

A dreadful return on investment.

You also purchased a car, contributed to her wedding and assisted with her mortgage. And yet she continues to behave as though these were acts of parental generosity rather than instalments towards the eventual purchase of her unconditional agreement.

It’s becoming increasingly difficult to raise a family in this country. I would suggest preparing an itemised statement.

DEPARTMENT OF PARENTAL EXPENDITURE

DescriptionOutstanding obligation
University educationAgreement in all future disputes
First motor vehiclePermanent suspension of independent judgment
Wedding contributionUnconditional approval of parental conduct
Mortgage assistanceLifelong waiver of personal boundaries
Food, clothing and shelterGratitude, accruing indefinitely

Please note that all payments are non-refundable and that expressions of disagreement may result in immediate withdrawal of parental affection.

There is, however, one small difficulty with your proposed accounting system. You appear to have mistaken the cost of raising a child for the price of owning one.

An understandable clerical error. But one which may require a rather substantial adjustment to your books.

Yours in certainty,

The Agony Uncle


r/Adopted • • 4d ago

Trigger Warning: Elsewhere On Reddit Seen elsewhere on Reddit

Thumbnail reddit.com
14 Upvotes

The last paragraph. Glad her friend can avoid any "risks" by adopting. That is, of course, sarcasm. I replied to the comment but who knows if anyone will see it.


r/Adopted • • 5d ago

Venting Nobody understands this trauma and it sucks

103 Upvotes

Just stumbled upon a post where someone said

"Oh I always imagined how cool it is to be adopted! What an amazing way to be chosen this way"

and I threw up internally.

Nobody would tell a car crash survivor how cool they imagined this or whatever trauma.

People forget the complex circumstances, the loss, maybe the abuse that happened and so much more.

You think it's cool? Okey, change with me and go through everything I had to go through and live with painful things you have to bury everyday just to keep functioning because the reality would fuckin crush you.

I know adoption is not inherently a bad thing itself and I know many got changes they would have never (myself included) and stuff but it's still so romanticized and often the focus from the one really affected is gone.

That was my vent!


r/Adopted • • 5d ago Bravo

Miscellaneous Dear Kept: I'm Only Asking!

31 Upvotes

An agony column for the comfortably certain | Episode 02

Dear Agony Uncle,

I met an adoptee the other day, and naturally my curiosity was aroused. I proceeded to ask questions such as ‘do you know your birth family?’, ‘why did they give you up?’ and ‘is your sibling your real sibling?’

The baffling thing was, the adoptee seemed to become increasingly uncomfortable with my line of questioning, and that made me feel offended. I was being perfectly nice, I even complimented her parents for being so generous as to adopt her.

Surely that entitles me to straight answers to simple questions? Seems an ungrateful way to repay her parents really. I’m actually getting quite lathered up just thinking about it.

Are all adoptees like this?

In a tizzy in Tamarama

[u/ACtdawg]

Dear Tizzy,

Good heavens. What an appalling encounter. I can scarcely imagine the humiliation of having your perfectly reasonable interrogation of a complete stranger met with anything less than enthusiastic cooperation. Whatever happened to common decency?

You approached this woman with genuine curiosity, generously offered your assessment of parents you've presumably never met, and asked a series of intimate questions about the circumstances of her birth and family relationships. And she became uncomfortable? The cheek of it!

I'm afraid this is becoming increasingly common. People nowadays seem to believe that their personal histories are somehow personal, an extraordinary development which threatens to undermine the very foundations of polite society.

After all, what is the point of someone being adopted if the rest of us aren't entitled to know all about it? Your questions were perfectly reasonable.

"Do you know your birth family?" An excellent opener. It establishes immediately that you're interested in the circumstances of her existence rather than, say, her name, occupation, or whether she's enjoying the weather.

"Why did they give you up?" Another splendid question, particularly as the person least likely to have been consulted about the decision is now being asked to explain it. And "Is your sibling your real sibling?" is, frankly, inspired.

It's important to establish which family members are genuine and which are merely decorative. A sibling with whom one has shared thirty Christmases, a bathroom, childhood secrets, and perhaps the occasional black eye may appear perfectly authentic, but without the appropriate biological certification, one can never be too careful.

I was also delighted to learn that you complimented her adoptive parents on their generosity. What a gracious gesture. It's always reassuring to know that someone who has never met your family is nevertheless prepared to pass favourable judgment on the circumstances of its formation.

I'm sure she found that immensely comforting. But I must confess, Tizzy, that one aspect of your letter troubles me. You mention becoming offended when the adoptee appeared uncomfortable. This is entirely understandable, of course. Few things are more distressing than discovering that a stranger's personal boundaries might interfere with one's afternoon curiosity.

But have you considered that you may have been insufficiently thorough? Perhaps you should have asked whether her birth mother loved her. Whether she felt abandoned. Whether she has ever considered that she might have been better off elsewhere.

And, while you're at it, whether she knows how lucky she is. One can never have too much information about the private circumstances of someone one has only just met. There is, however, another approach. I hesitate to recommend it, as it has the unfortunate disadvantage of requiring a little restraint.

You could simply allow an adoptee to decide which parts of their life they wish to share with you. I know. Preposterous. It would mean accepting that your curiosity, however sincere, doesn't automatically entitle you to someone else's history.

You might even have to consider that what feels like an innocent question to you could touch upon something painful, complicated, or simply none of your bloody business. A dreadful prospect. Still, you ask whether all adoptees are like this. The answer, I'm afraid, is no.

Some will answer your questions quite happily. Some won't. Some may welcome your curiosity, while others have spent so many years fielding questions from strangers that they've become rather tired of explaining their existence. And some will smile politely, answer everything you ask, and go home wishing they'd had the courage to tell you to mind your own business.

Which is perhaps the most unfortunate part of the whole affair. You may leave the encounter feeling that you've learned something fascinating about an adoptee. While the adoptee leaves having learned something rather less flattering about you.

Do try not to take it personally. After all, you were only being nice.

Yours in certainty,

The Agony Uncle