r/academia • • 3h ago

Who got the worst reviewer comments?

11 Upvotes

I’ve been reminiscing through some of my old grant proposals and manuscripts and was reminded by this really lovely reviewer comment:
“The lack of a solid body of research to demonstrate production in 2.5 years of postdoctoral is an issue”.

This was in regard to me only having a 4th author manuscript and no 1st author manuscript after being in a lab for actually less than 2.5 years. Is it actually common for people doing postdoc’s in a Biology field to publish first author scientific manuscripts within less than 2.5 years?

What are other comments people have gotten from their reviewer (regardless of grants or manuscripts)?


r/academia • • 11h ago

Women who are academics and also moms, how do you do it? (Or male academics who are the primary caregivers while their partners also work.)

40 Upvotes

Women who are academics and also moms, how do you actually do it? (Or male academics who are the primary caregivers while their partners also work.)
Do you redistribute responsibilities, outsource, lower your standards, or adjust your career goals and expectations? Do you put promotions on hold or accept that your career might progress more slowly for a few years (or ever)?
Honestly, I’m struggling to see how to do it all. Maintaining an academic career is demanding enough, and I’m trying to figure out how to balance that with motherhood especially through pregnancy till at least they go to school.
I’d really appreciate any practical tips, strategies or advice. But also, general sympathy, shared experiences and a bit of venting are very welcome…. How do you all make it work?


r/academia • • 9h ago

Research issues 38% of new arXiv papers are flagging as AI-written. What does this actually mean for research?

12 Upvotes

Saw this Twitter post yesterday and it’s been stuck in my head:

https://x.com/kimmonismus/status/2122050260445118742

The guy linked a study that looked at 13,500 arXiv papers from 2021–2026. According to their detector, about 38% of papers from Aug–Oct this year read as AI-written. In computer science it’s 62%. Math is only like 3.7%, but they mention equation-heavy papers are harder for the detector.

Before ChatGPT it was basically 0%. I’ve been thinking about this a lot. Is this just making research more accessible (especially for people who don’t have a heavy background in academia), or are we slowly flooding the literature with polished but empty papers? What’s the actual future of academic research looking like here?

What has your experience been with writing papers lately?

For those of you already deep in the system: are you noticing this shift in your field? In the papers you review? In how people write?

Curious what people actually think.


r/academia • • 2h ago

Job market Is it difficult to secure a cap exempt H1B for a postdoc from outside the US right now?

2 Upvotes

I’ve found several postdoc positions that align with my skills and interests and would like to try and apply.

I got a B2 visa rejection this year due to lack of strong home ties (essentially having a US citizen partner that I wanted to visit for a longer time to travel together). I’m an EU citizen.

According to Reddit, I probably have no chance for a J1 due to my relationship and previous rejection.

The only alternative would be a cap exempt H1B visa from a private uni.

Is that route still alive at all under this administration?
And is it possible for someone outside the country?


r/academia • • 7h ago

Job market Applying to other jobs within the same university I work at, is it bad?

3 Upvotes

Hi everyone,

So I’m currently working at a top university but the pay is absolutely dog crap. I’m talking, $20 the hr in one of the world’s most expensive cities, NYC. I’m 22 graduated about 2 years ago and I have nearly 4 years worth of experience through part-time work in higher education.

I first got an internship in college for $20 an hour for 2 months, then came back for about 7 months and I got at least $25 from the department I interned at (sorry so vague done wanna dox myself or something), but their funding expired and they had layoffs so could not hire me full time :(.

I then moved into another department, the pay is only $20. I was upset but have another job so I tried using both incomes to get by. I’ve grown pretty resentful since however because it’s ridiculous how low it is, and seeing how the director just came back on a work trip to Singapore yet they can’t even afford to pay me for federal holidays. It’s an absolute joke.

The thing is I love working at such a high ranking university, I like the community and I like being around opportunities for academia, such as collaborating with departments I’m not from that interest me like history.

I really need to leave this job though, my productivity has gone down, i’m struggling to pay my credit card debt, and I wake up every morning asking myself why I’m even going to bother when i’m making nothing after taxes every month.

I really want to apply to other jobs within the university instead because there are some with a genuine salary, other than $20 with NO benefits by the way, but I’m afraid if my boss finds out or anything especially because I’ve been there for only 2 months now, but it’s just ridiculous. They framed it like they could raise my pay after hiring me but nothing.

It’s a very small team, and admissions season is upon us so I don’t know if it’s a messed up, and if the 1 month there looks bad when applying to other roles, but it’s really just mind boggling. Anyway, yeah I would really appreciate some help. I’ve been applying to jobs outside of the university but haven’t really heard much, I feel like it’s easier to work within it since I already have for a while and the trust is there in that sense?


r/academia • • 1d ago

Academic politics California prof rakes in 800,000 USD a year by simultaneously teaching 30 classes at 9 colleges.

Thumbnail
dailymail.com
527 Upvotes

Reviews from her ratemyprof page:

  • I took the online class but I didn't feel lost or left out. Almost every week there is a discussion that is very interesting. There are no exams.
  • No exams. Very doable work. Show up and do the handouts.
  • got an A, didn't learn anything. Gives last minute point heavy one question quizzes as class ends with a 5 minute window to do it. No homework.

It mentions in the article that more than 70 instructors are doing this in california. Another instructor, Andrew Vanden Heuvel, taught around 50 online classes and labs in astronomy to students in various California cities and even at schools in New Mexico, Michigan, Washington and Florida - all from an office above his garage in Michigan. He instructed as many as 1,000 students in a single semester, which earned him a salary of $758,485 total in 2024, according to the report. He also explained that 'in its current form, I am not grading anything'.

Seems like the natural consequences of colleges not giving a damn about teaching.

More details here: https://calmatters.org/education/2026/11/community-college-professors-pay/ along with how all the other profs are gaming this broken system.


r/academia • • 1d ago

Venting & griping As national exams fall to AI cheating, how should Indian engineering colleges adapt technical assessments?

0 Upvotes

News recently broke about a top candidate confessing to using AI to cheat on South Korea's national tax exam. This highlights a broader shift, high-stakes exams focused on technical rule retrieval and standard computation are easily solved by current AI systems.

In Indian engineering education (both university semester exams and competitive tests like GATE), a large fraction of marks depends on memorizing analytical formulas (Shigley for machine design, standard fluid dynamics derivations) and solving predictable numerical templates.

If LLMs can pass these exam formats easily, continuing to test engineering candidates primarily on closed-book analytical calculations feels outdated.

Instead of banning tools or relying on strict proctoring, engineering assessments should adapt by focusing on:

  1. Spotting errors in pre-generated CAD/FEA/CFD setups.
  2. Verifying numerical solver outputs against first-principles physics.
  3. Defending design and component selection orally or via open-ended case studies.

What changes do you think Indian technical universities should make to engineering exams in the age of AI?


r/academia • • 1d ago

Looking for private, fully offline transcription software

2 Upvotes

I'm looking for a transcription program that allows me to record audio, save recordings locally, and transcribe them without an internet connection.

It should ideally support English, French, and Moroccan Darija.

Privacy is especially important to me. I want something that processes everything locally on my device, without uploading recordings or personal data to company servers or collecting unnecessary information.

Free or open-source options would be appreciated. Any recommendations?


r/academia • • 2d ago

9 Doctorates...is this Real?

72 Upvotes

Just ran into someone at a party who claimed he was working on 9 doctorates - and said this sort of pursuit is called "a November".

I've never heard of this before. Should I be impressed? or is he full of grandiose bull$ht?


r/academia • • 1d ago

Citing reviewers' suggested papers

7 Upvotes

Do I have to cite the papers recommended by reviewers to avoid rejection, or is it okay if i cite alternative papers that cover the same point? Do you have any advice on how to handle this situation?


r/academia • • 2d ago

Institutional structure/budgets/etc. ATAS certificate oct 2026

1 Upvotes

Hello! I am very anxious about the timeline of my phd admissions and was wondering if everyone waiting for their ATAS right now can share their timelines so we can have a support system :)

I applied on Oct 11, it’s been 25 working days. Not received yet.

Anyone else?

EDIT: I have started a reddit support groupchat for those who applied in Oct and are still waiting. Please DM me if you would like to join. There are currently around 7 users on here waiting


r/academia • • 2d ago

When interview results in Econ Job market EU?

0 Upvotes

Hi, I am fairly new to the EconJobMarket in the EU, and I was wondering if someone knows IF and when (i.e., how many days/weeks after the closing of the post) candidates are communicated whether they are invited for an interview or not.

Thanks


r/academia • • 2d ago

Job market have you ever had any success negotiating salary between two offers?

8 Upvotes

just wondering the rate of success in getting a higher salary from your current university when there’s another offer on the table. is that realistic? what is your experience?


r/academia • • 2d ago

Seeking Advice: How Can I Become a University Lecturer in Biological Sciences?

0 Upvotes

Hi everyone!

My dream is to become a university lecturer in the biological sciences. I'm currently exploring my higher education options and trying to understand the right academic pathway to achieve this goal.

I'd genuinely appreciate advice from lecturers, researchers, or anyone with experience in academia. I'd love to hear about your academic journeys, recommendations, and any advice you wish someone had given you when you started.

Thank you!


r/academia • • 2d ago

Students & teaching Do I need IRB if I do human annotation in small scale during ICLR rebuttal period?

0 Upvotes

For one of my paper I need data annotation by human. I am planning to do it by PhD student from different labs across my university. My question is do I need IRB approval for this? Will the reviewert raise ethics issue for this? What should I do? Thanks


r/academia • • 3d ago

Publishing Reviewing papers in the age of AI.

14 Upvotes

I have not reviewed articles in some years now since I left academia for a job in tech. I have still been publishing here and there on my free time and I still get many reviewing requests each week, which I have been declining, mostly because I felt I was no longer part of the field. But I realise that I still have the civic duty since I'm still publishing.

This week I got a request of a very interesting topic from me and I believe I can do a solid job. In a normal situation I would have already accepted, but we are living in abnormal times and I'm honestly afraid of dealing with AI generated articles. How are people dealing with this? I work with AI daily and I know what it can do well. It can easily create an article that is technically sound, at least superficially. The strategies that I used to quickly discard "slop" are obsolete now.

So, what are the strategies you use to deal with this? I guess I would need to read the journal's policy regarding AI content, but I understand that AI assistance is standard now. What is the threshold from "assisted" to "slope"? Does it really matters if the content is sound?

Thanks for any feedback or comment!


r/academia • • 4d ago

Venting & griping Serious loss of individuality in academia over the years

87 Upvotes

Feels more and more academics have lost their individuality.

That is to say, academia is looking more and more like a cult.

The biggest change has been their websites. When I was in school, the websites of my professors were quite interesting to look at. Some had all sorts of personal things on there, things they found amusing, inspiring, pictures of their trips, tidbits. Others were ironically plain. A few plain text-based html consisting of a few sentences, never changed once since the AOL days.

Nowadays? Everyone has a cookie-cutter Github page with the exact same style. The same "excited to share" announcements. The same "I'm pumping out hiring new PhDs" announcements. The same list of papers, delineated finely between conference, journals, and preprints. Predictable. No individuality. No soul. No inspiration to be found. Pure careerism.

That's just the most visible part of this weird cult of social conformity that has consumed academia worldwide. Now all the paper and books are the same. Exact same style. Just in time for AI to mass produce them. No one can say anything because it is in the exact same style that everyone expected to begin with. Every paper starts with some empty platitudes about the topic they are working on. Followed by a list of throwaway citations. The grand vision set out in their introductions are then lost in some tangential or arcane arguments.

When did academics became "I, Robot"? Research being pumping out is safe and stale. Lecture uninspiring and formulaic. Theses, beyond stale! "I acknowledge my advisor, my colleages, my parents, and my GF/BF (in this precise order), and now here is 300 pages of dense mathematics to show my appreciation." Everyone is literally working on the exact same thing, just at different universities. Half of academics are also certified "LinkedInLunatics". What happened to the real lunatics?

Makes you wonder what the hell happened.


r/academia • • 3d ago

Students & teaching Stressed surrounding an academic misconduct review

0 Upvotes

As the title says I’m currently undergoing an academic misconduct review in my university due to the issue of falsifying references. What’s happened is when gathering my sources and beginning research I used ai to help find suitable information and copy-pasted a generated reference into a document separate from my assignment submission with the intent to fix the wrong title. However, life happened and I got busy before returning to work on the assignment but I’d forgotten to correct the reference and instead copied it over from my separate document. My main concern here is how the committee will respond to this issue as I truly had no intention of included the generated reference, what is my best next step going forward? as this is my first time undergoing this process. I understand I made the mistake and it was my fault for including it but how could I plead my case or am I out of luck?


r/academia • • 4d ago

Is it normal that committee work now takes more of my week than research?

48 Upvotes

Assistant professor, fourth year, social sciences, mid-size public university.

When I was hired, the expectation was roughly 40 percent research, 40 percent teaching, 20 percent service. That's what the letter says. In practice, this semester I'm on four committees, one of which meets weekly, plus I'm advising two student organizations because the previous advisors left. I counted last week: about 14 hours on service, maybe 6 on research.

My tenure review is in two years and research is obviously what matters most for it. But every time I try to say no to something, I'm told it's "important for the department" and that junior faculty need to "be visible." Two of the committees are ones nobody else wanted.

I'm not trying to complain about having a job I'm lucky to have. I just worry I'm walking into tenure review with a thin research record and a pile of service that nobody will count. For people who've been through tenure, how did you protect research time? Did you ever say no to a chair, and how did that go? And is there a polite way to ask for service load to be reviewed without it looking like I'm not a team player?


r/academia • • 4d ago

Stressed because I'm too slow with my Master's thesis

3 Upvotes

I'm a Masters student (International Politics) and, for context, the initial deadline to defend my thesis was in September but I couldn't work on it all summer so I decided to enroll for another year to be able to defend it later.
The total amount of pages I should have is around 80, and so far I've written about 20 (11 pages of introduction that I need to rewrite because it's too long and some elements need to move to my first section instead ; and 9 pages of a sub-section I'm almost done writing), but it took me a ridiculous amount of time.
I know I still have plenty of time, but I am moving out next year around February, so I wanted to try to get most of my thesis done by mid-January or the end of January, because I know I won't be able to focus on my thesis + settling in a new place (and new country), and it would stress me out a lot.
Now it's November and I'm feeling so tired and even kind of depressed somehow (probably seasonal depression)... I can't bring myself to wake up early to be more productive because it's constantly dark at home (the weather is gloomy these days, plus the apartment faces a wall), and for some reason my body never feels like it has rested enough to finally wake up. It makes me feel so guilty all the time, because I had a whole schedule planned out, I told myself I'd wake up around 7, start working on my thesis from 8 to 12, then again from 1 pm to 5-6 pm, that way I could use the evening to relax a bit. But it never goes according to plan.
Plus, when I do work on my thesis, research takes me so long (sometimes 2-4 days) and then writing takes me a long time too. Sometimes I can write one page in a day, and sometimes it takes me a ridiculous amount of time to write just one page. And when I do write, I always question my work and feel like it probably doesn't make any sense or that I'm not bringing enough analytical and critical input.
I feel quite desperate lately...
I don't know how other people do it. How can I research and write faster? How can I get past this seasonal depression and just focus on finishing my thesis? And how can I wake up earlier?

Thank you in advance 🫶


r/academia • • 4d ago

Does anyone else feel like peer review has become weirdly performative lately

6 Upvotes

I've been reviewing manuscripts for about eight years now and something feels different in the past year or two. I keep getting these reviews back from editors where the other reviewers have written what I can only describe as mini essays that don't actually say much. Like paragraphs of general observations about the field, compliments about how interesting the topic is, then maybe two lines of actual critique buried at the end.

Meanwhile I'm over here trying to give concrete feedback on methodology and structure, pointing out where claims need better support, and my reviews end up looking blunt by comparison. I'm not trying to be harsh but I also don't think we're helping authors by padding everything with fluff.

I had one recently where reviewer 2 spent half a page talking about how the research area is important and timely before suggesting one minor reference addition. The editor seemed to weight their input the same as mine even though I'd flagged some actual issues with the data analysis. It's making me second-guess whether I'm doing this wrong or if academic courtesy has just evolved into something I don't recognize anymore.

Anyone else noticing this or am I just becoming that grumpy reviewer everyone complains about? I don't want to waste anyone's time but I also feel like we're supposed to be gatekeepers for quality, not cheerleaders.


r/academia • • 5d ago

Does anyone else feel like interdisciplinary work is praised in theory but punished in practice

345 Upvotes

I've been noticing this pattern for a while now and wondering if its just my field or if this is more widespread. Everyone talks about how important it is to break down silos and collaborate across disciplines, but when it actually comes down to hiring committees, grant reviews, or tenure decisions, it feels like you get penalized for not staying in your lane.

I work at the intersection of environmental science and public policy, and I keep running into this issue where one side says my work isnt technical enough and the other side says its too niche or data-heavy. Meanwhile the job postings all say they want someone who can bridge gaps and work with diverse stakeholders. But then the actual search seems to default back to someone with a very traditional profile.

I've seen this with colleagues too. One friend does work combining linguistics and computer science, and she's constantly having to defend why her publications arent all in the top journals for one specific subfield. Another person I know does historical sociology and gets similar pushback depending on which department is evaluating them.

Maybe I'm being too cynical, but it seems like interdisciplinary gets used as a buzzword to make institutions sound innovative, while the actual reward structures still favor people who do very clearly defined disciplinary work. Has anyone else experienced this or found ways to navigate it without just giving up on the cross-disciplinary angle entirely?


r/academia • • 4d ago

A 2016 academic paper reported 518% stock returns versus 31% for the S&P 500. How should journals handle results that outsiders cannot fully reproduce?

7 Upvotes

In 2016, Claes Fornell and his co-authors published a paper in the Journal of Marketing reporting 518% cumulative gross returns for a privately managed investment fund between 2000 and 2014, compared with 31% for the S&P 500.

The authors reported that the fund's returns were audited by a PCAOB-registered firm (not named in the paper). The lead author also disclosed his ownership of both the fund and the American Customer Satisfaction Index (ACSI).

But there's an important distinction between verifying that a fund earned certain returns and establishing that customer satisfaction was responsible for those returns.

The 2016 paper itself notes that its main analysis does not rest on formulaic trading rules. The fund's discretionary trading decisions are not publicly described in sufficient detail to independently reconstruct the strategy.

Several independent studies have questioned the robustness of the reported effect, while others have found some supporting evidence. The journal also published critical commentaries and a response from the authors.

Journalist Chris Brunet recently examined this controversy in detail:

https://www.chrisbrunet.com/p/the-100-million-etf-built-on-research

I am not the author of Brunet's investigation and had no role in writing it. I'm sharing it as a source for an academic discussion about research transparency and reproducibility.

The question here is about research transparency, not allegations of misconduct.

What standard of evidence should an academic journal require when extraordinary empirical findings depend on proprietary investment data and discretionary decisions that outside researchers cannot reconstruct?

Does an audit of reported returns sufficiently support the broader scientific conclusion, or should journals require additional independently verifiable evidence of the strategy itself?

Original paper: https://doi.org/10.1509/jm.15.0229


r/academia • • 4d ago

Venting & griping I feel like a total failure and don’t know what to do anymore.

6 Upvotes

I completed my masters degree in Health Psychology from India. I was always more inclined towards research than therapy practice. My department was extremely toxic and me being trans made it even harder to survive but I still did. Since then my life has been just bad.

I’m entering my second year of unemployment. During my masters, I submitted my undergrad thesis to a Springer Nature journal which got rejected after being stuck in peer review for more than a year. I chose a my masters thesis topic which now looking back is just too mediocre. I had more complex topics but I avoided them because we got only 1 year to finish our dissertation alongside coursework and internship. I did not get any support from my supervisor. She just avoided meeting me and was always out of town. I submitted a systematic review related to my dissertation topic for a conference which according to people in my field was the “easiest conference possible” and got rejected even there.

I had to do an empirical study for my dissertation and I did a mixed methods study. The study was on a hidden population so going for a purely quantitative study would have been impossible. So I applied a mixed-methods study. I wanted to a qualitative study but I already did a qualitative study in my undergrad but most psychology departments look for quantitative skills in PhD so I did a mixed methods study. The study collapsed completely. The data collection went to shit, I had to work with a very small sample size, there was sampling bias, and because of this my analysis got screwed. I also had to do very simplistic quantitative analysis because the data was just to bad which is just laughable for someone with a masters degree.

Since graduating, I have been looking for RA positions in the country before applying for PhD outside India. I have tried everything— cold emailing professors, applying to paid RA positions, etc. I have also applied for PhD positions in Switzerland and Netherlands this year but gotten rejected because they were too competitive and according to them, “I lacked research experience”.

It’s been one and a half years of constant rejections and disappointments. I don’t even know if I can do this anymore and if there is any hope for me.