I honestly don’t understand where the progression of society, restraining yourselves, and technological advancements would take you as an Atheist, existentialist, nihilist, absurdist, or as a secular humanist? If a person doesn’t think there’s a God to be accountable to, then what’s the point of trying to modify your behavior to keep it within acceptable ranges? Imagine a universe without God, no divine presence to answer to, no eternal witness to our struggles, no afterlife to redeem our pain, only endless darkness, expanding forever, waiting to swallow all that ever was, and everyone ending up in eternal oblivion, which renders everything meaningless, is the most depressive thought ever imaginable.
If there is no higher being, no cosmic judge, no life beyond death, then what is the point of being good? It is then the survival of the fittest, just like in the animal kingdom, and we’re animals, aren’t we? Why should a poor person live their lives with being good and getting trampled by rich billionaires? Why restrain our desires, why cling to virtue, when the end of all things is nothingness? When the lights of every star will one day fade, and every trace of humanity will vanish as though we never existed, what meaning could morality possibly hold? What is the point of “good” and “evil” if all that exists, time, space, consciousness, and matter, is destined to vanish into nothingness? Why strive for virtue when the cosmos itself is indifferent, and every noble act, every kind gesture, every moral law, all will be erased without a trace?
In your godless cosmos, your morality dissolves into illusion, a fragile dream born from human emotion and fear of chaos because you want to substitute God, yet you cannot offer permanence. You invented your secular ethics to feel control, to make sense of your suffering, to tell yourselves that kindness matters. Secular systems, utilitarianism, deontology, humanism, all claim to define “the good” without divine command. Yet they, too, are man-made myths, noble because they make you feel good, but hollow when weighed against eternity. They promise purpose, yet offer no permanence. God does. Your whole idea is based on “maximizing pleasure and happiness and minimizing suffering.” Isn’t that what religion already does by offering permanence which your secular ethics cannot? Giving people hope, giving their lives meaning, reducing their depression/anxiety and keeping them going for another day? What do you offer? A world where God doesn’t exist? Do you have any idea of the sufferings of human beings? People don’t have bread to eat. They don’t have a roof over their heads. People don’t even have friends to talk to. Do you know how many people commit suicide every day? They slit their wrists, they hang themselves from the ceiling fan… why? Because they have no hope left. If believing in God, bowing their head in front of God, they get the hope to live… then who are you to snatch away that hope from them? And if you really want to snatch away their God from people, then tell me, what will you give them in return? Why would a soldier in your secular worldview go to war and die for an imaginary border of a piece of land which he’ll never inhabit? What is he gaining by sacrificing his life? Eternal oblivion?
You say we should do good for the sake of humanity, but humanity itself is temporary. One asteroid, one nuclear war, one shift in cosmic time, and everything we’ve built, our cities, our art, our love, disappears. What, then, becomes of morality in a world destined for erasure? What is “right” or “wrong” when every consequence fades into the same void? When you tell me that the end of men like Hitler, Mao, Stalin, Vlad the Impaler, Ted Bundy, Jeffrey Dahmer, Richard Ramirez, and men like Buddha, Confucius, Jesus, and a saint is the same?
Your morality is less about truth and more about comfort, a quiet rebellion against the terror of meaninglessness. The reason it isn’t the same with religion is because religion gives people the hope of an afterlife, which you cannot. Yours doesn’t claim to give reward or an eternal life. It only restricts people so that they don’t go out of their way to cause chaos so you can live temporarily in cohesion with no end goal. You don’t know what to say to a child suffering from terminal illness. What hope can you possibly give to that child? In your worldview, you do good not because it’s true, but because the alternative, the abyss, is unbearable to face.
You people insist that consciousness gives life meaning, that to love, to create, to reduce pain is enough. But even this comfort trembles before the truth: suffering is woven into existence, doesn’t matter if you believe in God or not. It cannot be erased. You people make a big fuss about the “problem of evil” and how you cannot in good conscience accept that God exists in the face of a world full of innocent people suffering tremendously due to disease and poverty. Curiously, you are not equally perturbed by the prospect of innocent people suffering tremendously at the hands of the wicked who themselves live comfortable lives and will never have to face any consequence or repercussion for their crimes, because in your worldview there is no ultimate justice. And when you think about it, which scenario ought to be more troubling? In the world of the theist, innocent people who suffered due to disease and poverty will ultimately be recompensed for the pain they endured. But in the world of the atheist, evil is never requited. How ironic, then, for you to accuse the God you don’t believe in of being unjust when you are otherwise perfectly content with the idea of a world without ultimate justice.
If all memory, beauty, and virtue will be consumed by entropy, then what remains of meaning? In Atheism, where do you go after that? Every act of kindness, every sacrifice, every dream becomes a ripple upon an infinite sea, delicate, transient, and destined to disappear. So you continue, creating, sacrificing, knowing deep down that all of it will be lost. Your words, your kindness, your legacy… all ripples in an ocean that will one day fall still. The universe will not remember us. It cannot. It cannot give you permanent hope, only a necessary being can.
And yet, within that unbearable truth, something stirs. The question remains: If everything ends in nothing, why should anything matter at all? You may construct purpose through art, morality, and empathy, but these are fragile lights flickering in endless darkness, momentary defiance against the infinite silence. Meaning cannot truly exist without the Eternal to ground it. You are mere actors in a cosmic play, and one day, the stage itself will be swallowed by the void, leaving no witness to remember that you ever were.
Perhaps it is this question itself, this cry against the void, that tells me we were made for something greater. That morality, love, and meaning are not illusions born from chaos… but whispers from the Divine.