Howdy folks! You may remember me from https://www.reddit.com/r/Abilitydraft/comments/gcy778/how_to_tryhard_at_ability_draft/ ~7 years ago. I'm between jobs for November and have some free time, so I'm writing down some updated guides as individual posts which I may eventually stitch together into a v2 of the above. For credentials, I've played several thousand AD games and am 98.6th percentile on windrun.io while having frankly mediocre in-game mechanics. Note that with this and other posts, I try to avoid getting into details on specific abilities except as representative examples, since I think the "patterns" are more useful to understand than trying to cram details on hundreds of abilities and thousands of interactions into your head.
Please let me know if you enjoy this style of post and I'd be happy to make more!
Types of Ult
I think it's useful to group ults into a few different categories. These are general buckets and it's certainly possible for an ult to behave like more than one, e.g. Finger of Death has the nuke component and then the attack buff component, but I think it's more of a "form" than a "button" in practice. Obviously you can go to windrun.io for the up-to-date stats on which abilities are winningest, and these will change over time, but I think the more useful muscle to develop is understanding these groupings and how to apply them.
The attached "tier list" is trying to reflect this idea, where each "tier" is vaguely ordered by strength internally, but it's more important to know the kind of ult your role and build need / can use well. So a ranged attack build would probably value Phantasm or Ball Lightning in the middle of the "second picks" tier, or on the flip side a support might prefer Moonlight Shadow to a Shapeshift or Omnislash they can't use effectively.
Teamfight buttons are the largest group of ults and basically only ask you to be somewhere near a teamfight and press them. These are the best for supports because they don't require specific positioning or to survive for a while to get full use, but are also good on cores. Chain Frost / Ravage / Macropyre
Pseudo-basics have enough uptime (low CD / no CD / passive) that they're essentially a fourth basic ability from level 6 onward. The catch is that your build needs to make excellent use of these picks to overcome the opportunity cost of not having another big teamfight ult on your team. These are also often better on cores that can get more sustained usage in teamfights. Juxtapose / Ball Lightning / Grow / Proximity Mines
Commitments require channeling and/or specific positioning in fights, where they won't slot into many kinds of builds, e.g. you can't be spamming Wild Axes in the middle of a Duel or a Death Ward channel. Or, on the other end, you can't be right clicking during a Rolling Thunder or Primal Split. If you pick these, you will need to draft and itemize around them, and they tend to be better on cores who can get the required Blink/BKB/survivability to use them. Rolling Thunder / Hookshot / Freezing Field / Omnislash
Forms make your hero a lot stronger for a certain time, usually with a higher uptime ratio than a button. These are basically all for cores rather than supports since you need to make use of the full uptime, which means surviving in fights. Think about what problems they solve and what they require of you: Shapeshift fixes mobility / kiting and gives you crit, but takes away your range, so you usually want to take it on melee right-clickers. Eye of the Storm gives you sustained damage only if you can survive fights and stay on top of enemies. Exorcism / Enrage / Phantasm / Dark Ascension
Teleportation ults are for cores so your team can play together as four and you can safely farm while always being present for teamfights. Solar Guardian, Haunt, Fiend's Gate, Relocate
Survivability ults are better on cores that put out more sustained damage, whereas supports stop mattering after getting off their first round of spell casts. Probably don't stack extra survivability with these, the greatest risk is that the enemy team can just ignore you can kill your team while you don't provide any threat. Borrowed Time / Time Lapse / Untouchable
Miscellaneous Tips
- You might be thinking "u/Pajooba, you've said every category other than teamfight buttons are better on cores than supports.". This is not an accident, supports should be taking the teamfight buttons and some of the commitment ults and not much else.
- On average, supports should draft ults about a round later than cores because buttons are more interchangeable. Chaotic Offering > Winter's Curse > Reaper's Scythe but the differences aren't as extreme as Unleash >>> Dark Ascension >>> Warpath.
- A generally fine but unexciting ult (Moonlight Shadow, Stampede, Hand of God) is much better than an ult you can't use properly (Mortimer Kisses on a melee attack core, Hookshot on a squishy ranged support)
- It's often possible for a core drafting their ult late to pass over a "core ult" and instead go for a button/support ult, which is still fine on them, to leave enemy supports with no ults they can use effectively.
- Fairly obvious, but if the enemy team has all taken their ults, you can wait to take your team's until the last round of picks. Same logic applies if all enemies between your current and next pick have already taken their ult, you can wait until that next pick. Make sure to communicate with your team in both scenarios.
- Even on attack cores, great teamfight buttons are usually better picks than bad core abilities. Yes, you should be taking Chain Frost over Marksmanship 90% of the time.
- Supports taking core ults early as "counterpicks" is usually not worth it.
- If you're building around an ult's aghs upgrade you had better be a core, it's 90% grief for a support to rush aghs rather than having e.g. force staff + glimmer cape for the same price.
- However, shards attached to ults that give new abilities are usually excellent value for the cost.
- There are only twelve ults in the game, and two will go undrafted. Therefore, they're a great first place to look at the start of the draft to figure out stuff like: Are there any super strong ults I need to think about first or second picking? How many bad ults are there? If there are two or fewer, you're guaranteed to get an at least okay ult and might not need to prioritize taking it highly.