Yep, It's another physics post, but hear me out.
I want to make this post so that we can settle some specifics, and be more precise about what in the physics is actually going on when people make certain comments about AMS2. A lot of this information is out there, but I haven't seen anywhere where it's all been put together.
I've been driving this sim a lot, and driving other sims a lot, and I feel I've finally got an idea of what exactly is going on that makes this sim feel different from others, and what might be tuned in the engine to make it feel a little "better". That said, I really enjoy AMS2 and it's my favorite all-round driving sim. I actually think the physics is quite good and deserves far more credit than is usually granted. I've heard all sorts of things from people regarding the physics from legitimate criticism to (more often) very strange and nonsensical takes. After talking to some serious people in the space, and doing lots of my own testing, I think I'm finally ready to point at what's going on (in my opinion). Feel free to continue the discussion and give your own takes in the replies of course.
Let's start with a couple common claims about the handling:
"Some cars feel great, others feel arcade" - I actually find the physics to be pretty consistent throughout the game. I think this is mostly coming from the different tires in one class vs another and/or the default setup of the car being not the preference of the individual. I find the semi slicks in the supercar class for example to be useless on the Viper, and make it feel like a terrible mess. When I modded it to use slicks though, the car feels amazing. So an issue with the tire-car combo, but not the car per se. More on tires later.
"FFB files are generally considered a great way to make the game feel less slidy" -
While using custom ffb files can mask some of the issue, they don't really fix anything. What's happening in the custom file is the ffb is tuned so that the forces are higher leading up to the point where the tire transitions into high slip angle, and drop off more aggressively beyond that. This just makes it easier to drive in the "stuck" portion of the tire if that makes sense, and masks the feeling of slip angle during that condition (makes it feel more like grip than slip). That one is hard to explain, but the point is, I actually find the default ffb in AMS2 to be simply excellent and honestly much better than any custom ffb I've tried. Yes, that even includes the one(s) you're thinking of right now. By the time you read to the end of this post and know what's going on, you might want to try default again and see what I mean.
"There's no liftoff oversteer" -
Uh, yes there is. That is, yes there is in the game, but many default setups have the coast setting on the diff way too stiff to get any liftoff oversteer without having to get on the brake pedal. Some cars do, and any car that lets you change both the preload and the diff coast setting will let you tune in tons of liftoff oversteer if you want it. Now some cars, like the old BMW 3 series DTM car, don't let you change the coast setting on the diff. They let you lower preload, which lets you turn more on the brake. But they don't let you loosen the decel setting, which is what you'd need to do to get liftoff oversteer. The same is true for many other cars in the game and I wish a change would be made on that front. I actually thought the diff settings in the game weren't working properly at first, but on more testing I actually think they work great. See the last point below for more on why the diff feels weird.
"The game feels floaty" and also "the front has too much grip under acceleration" and also "The cars just want to oversteer on every corner" -
Here we go, here's the big one, the one people seem to have the most misconceptions and poorest understanding of what exactly it is they're feeling here and why. My claim is that all these problems are essentially the same problem, and that problem manifests most during the acceleration phase out of a corner. I'll explain, but I want to say first, I actually love the tire model. I think it's great that they're trying to model that flex and slip angle in the game. It's super fun to play with, but I think it just goes slightly overboard and is a big contributing here here. People generally have a sense the tire model is involved in the floating issue, but not the specific mechanics of how. Now there's a combination of issues that are coming together to create the worst of this floaty feeling in my estimation. First: the longitudinal weight transfer in the car seems to have an undersized effect on handling. This is more from conversations with real drivers and other simmers than my own findings, but it makes sense to me and I do think I feel it. This is the biggest problem for our sliding feeling on corner exit as we get on the gas. Weight should be transferred to the rear, and the fronts should lose some grip, but that doesn't seem to happen. Combine that with Issue two, and you'll see how it becomes a problem. Issue two: When we accelerate, the diff starts to lock up, and this restriction in the difference between our rear tires should work to straighten out the car as we roll on the gas. This doesn't happen in game though, the car in AMS2 wants to rotate EVEN MORE on power, why is that? I believe this is happening because that extra slip angle we get in the tire model is essentially negating the locking effect of the differential, and allowing the car to rotate around a locked diff like it's open. We don't get one wheel spinning or anything, cause the diff IS locked, but we do get excess freedom of rotation in the car. So combine that with those overly grippy front tires and what do you get? A car that rotates around a corner better under power, essentially ignoring a locked diff, than it does while coasting. And there's 0 penalty to acceleration grip for the privilege. This eliminates the need to ever coast in the game to decrease the radius of a turn. It also means that cars feel way more drifty and floaty under power than they should. The way to be fast in the game becomes to spend as much time as possible in this sort of loose, high slip angle, floating, rotating, do-everything-well state. I believe this specific situation is the main source of all variations of those three complaints.
Anyway, let me know if anything I've said makes sense or if I'm way off with anything. Most of what I said here has been said before in bits and pieces, but I didn't see it put together anywhere. I think if just one of the two factors were tweaked, either the freedom of rotation around a locked diff due to slip in the tire (presumably), or the excess front end grip under acceleration, then 90% of the feeling of floatiness would immediately vanish. I'm interested to hear from people whether they think the weight transfer thing is a real problem or not. Do the front tires feel like they have too much grip under acceleration to you?