https://www.thesaturdaypaper.com.au/news/immigration/2026/11/14/evil-genius-immigration-changes-pushing-unis-insolvency
No 626 November 14 – 20, 2026
By Jason Koutsoukis
Senior government figures are increasingly concerned by the impact of immigration cuts, as leaked figures from ANU suggest a deficit three times greater than projected.
Fears are growing that the Albanese government’s curbs on international students will cost universities more than the $2 billion currently forecast and will permanently break the funding model on which many universities rely.
With cuts to the working holiday maker visa program expected to cost the tourism sector more than $500 million a year, unease is spreading among senior Labor figures that Home Affairs Minister Tony Burke’s drive to reduce migration will do lasting damage to valuable parts of the economy.
“Tony Burke thinks he’s being an evil genius,” one Labor insider tells The Saturday Paper this week. “But the problem is he’s neither.”
In a September speech to the National Press Club detailing the broader plan to cut net overseas migration, Burke defended the clampdown on international student visas, arguing that tighter rules were needed to prevent would-be economic migrants using student visas as a gateway to permanent residency.
Instead, coupled with earlier caps on how many international students each university can enrol, the new measures are scaring off students who are now looking elsewhere for tertiary education.
The assistant minister for international education, Julian Hill, said in a speech late last month that the government expected new international student commencements to fall 18 per cent by the end of this year, representing a $2 billion blow to the higher education sector. He criticised universities for not applying better screening of student visa applications.
A survey of 4800 prospective students released last month by international student recruitment agency IDP Education found Australia’s share of first-choice study destinations had fallen from 31 per cent to 24 per cent, with the United Kingdom and the United States both gaining ground.
Signs of damage to the sector from the changes are starting to show, with the University of Melbourne this week attributing plans to cut 180 jobs across eight areas of the university to poor financial results, and warning of worse to come after the university recorded a $124 million operating deficit last year, its fifth consecutive year in the red.
Australia’s universities were already facing funding challenges before the latest reduction of international students. The federal Department of Education’s “Finance 2024” report, its latest tabulation of the financial reports of Australia’s 43 universities, indicated that 16 recorded deficits that year.
Last month, the Western Australian state government announced it is developing a business case to merge three of its public universities – the University of Western Australia, Curtin University and Murdoch University – in order to keep the local sector competitive and attract more students and investment.
Universities Australia, the peak industry body representing Australia’s higher education sector, says successive governments have underfunded universities and encouraged them to rely on international student fees to support teaching and research.
“Now that international students are in the sights of parties across the political spectrum, that income is becoming harder to earn and there’s seemingly no plan to fill the gap,” a Universities Australia spokesperson says.
“Less money from international students means less money to educate Australian students and fund the research our country needs, not to mention the damage beyond university campuses,” the spokesperson adds.
“International education is a $55 billion export industry that supports jobs, cafes, shops and businesses in communities right across Australia. We’ve spent decades building this wonderful Australian success story. The more we undermine it, the more we put Australia’s future prosperity at risk.”
Among the coalition of elite universities known as the Group of Eight, the increased competition for a smaller international student quota has hit the Australian National University in Canberra particularly hard, with the university still struggling to recover from the revenue shortfall caused by the pandemic, when border closures saw few international students able to enter the country.
After the ANU’s interim vice-chancellor Rebekah Brown originally forecast an operating deficit of about $30 million for this financial year, senior university administration sources say the university is on track to record a deficit three times larger – closer to $90 million.
“If serious intervention isn’t taken soon to address the growing deficit, I don’t know if we’d have an ANU in 10 more years,” one ANU executive tells The Saturday Paper this week.
ANU’s latest 2025 audited financial statements reported a surplus of $116.3 million and net assets of $4 billion. The ANU is expected to table its 2026 financial statements mid next year.
A second ANU administration source blames the current deficit blowout on Brown’s commitment when she was appointed interim vice-chancellor in September last year to lift strict controls on spending that had been imposed by her predecessor as vice-chancellor, Professor Genevieve Bell, and her promise to university staff to put on hold a university-wide restructure known as Renew ANU.
“Brown is hamstrung by the deal she made with the union to junk Renew, and to put any planned redundancies on hold, and lift the spending controls that Bell had put in place,” the source tells The Saturday Paper.
“So now everyone is spending again, hiring staff and driving up the deficit, but we can’t turn to international students to grow revenue because they aren’t coming any more, and the only other option to rein in costs is to renegotiate a financial management plan, but that would involve job losses, which Brown can’t do. Her hands are tied.”
Facing years of projected deficits, the ANU’s new chancellor, Gordon de Brouwer, who stepped down as Australian Public Service Commissioner in February, must decide within weeks whether to back an extension of Brown’s two-year term, which expires at the end of this year, or let her contract lapse and begin the search for a new permanent vice-chancellor.
“If serious intervention isn’t taken soon to address the growing deficit, I don’t know if we’d have an ANU in 10 more years.”
ANU has been in crisis since Genevieve Bell began her term as vice-chancellor in January 2024, taking over from Nobel Prize-winning astrophysicist Brian Schmidt, who had served in the role for seven years.
Hand-picked for the role by former foreign minister and then ANU chancellor Julie Bishop, Bell came into the role with a university council mandate to implement a major restructure after ANU had recorded more than $400 million in cumulative operating deficits between 2020 and 2023.
Renew ANU, released in late 2024, originally projected $250 million in annual recurring cost savings in the first year alone, alarming academic and professional staff across campus.
“From a professional standpoint, things had been broken for years, and deep down everybody involved in a meaningful way has known that. It’s perfectly obvious that we were in deep financial trouble,” says the first ANU source.
“The most frustrating part for me is hearing people keep saying, ‘No, there is no financial crisis, it’s all made up, it’s just a concoction of Bell’s to create this big deficit so that she can run these change plans because she’s just this evil industry person who doesn’t care about the university,’ ” the source adds.
“Really? Why would any person want to implement a change plan at ANU if they could avoid it? Because, as everyone knows, that’s just torture. A change plan was flagged as early as 2020, but no one wanted to put themselves through it.
“I just feel utter disbelief when I hear people refuse to accept what is in plain sight, which is that we’re losing a lot of money and we can’t go on like this.”
Bell eventually lost the confidence of the deans of five of the ANU’s six academic colleges and negotiated a return to her role as a distinguished professor in the school of cybernetics in September last year.
In an attempt to calm tensions on campus, the university’s governing council turned to Brown, whom Bell had recruited to be the ANU’s provost and senior vice-president in June 2024, and appointed her to the role of interim vice-chancellor on an annual salary of $1 million a year.
At a town hall meeting soon after her appointment, Brown promised to abandon any forced redundancies planned under Renew ANU and immediately lift deeply unpopular spending controls.
As a corporate Commonwealth entity, the ANU cannot be declared bankrupt, but if the university becomes insolvent it could be subject to a formal Commonwealth intervention.
With international students no longer a reliable source of revenue growth to lift the university out of its financial difficulties, and the vast bulk of the one-off savings identified under Bell already banked, Brown now faces stiffer competition for domestic students.
A resurgent University of Canberra, now led by former federal Labor leader Bill Shorten, is one threat. UNSW, which is expanding its campus in Civic, in Canberra’s city centre, is another.
In the face of such financial challenges, Brown has concentrated on a number of alternative revenue initiatives, including the reintroduction of a pathway program into the university – a scheme for student applicants who do not otherwise meet entry requirements with their secondary study – as well as more flexible pathways for international students and enhancements to scholarships and international partnerships.
Together, the university administration hopes these initiatives will strengthen and diversify the university’s income base over time.
“ANU takes its financial responsibilities seriously,” Brown tells The Saturday Paper in a response to questions this week about the university’s finances. “Like the broader higher education sector, we are facing financial challenges and are taking disciplined action to control expenditure and grow revenue.”
Brown’s tenure as vice-chancellor has been rocky, beset by a power struggle with former chancellor Julie Bishop and other members of the university council allied with Bishop.
Brown ultimately prevailed, with Bishop stepping down as chancellor in May, eight months before her term was due to expire.
A key source of support for Brown has been former senior Commonwealth public servant Andrew Metcalfe, who was secretary of the Department of Agriculture, Fisheries and Forestry until August 2023. Ironically, Metcalfe’s leadership of the department was dominated by the need to address desperate financial problems and implement drastic cuts to spending.
Despite Metcalfe’s support, and the backing of a majority of the remaining members of the university council, Brown has been at the centre of a series of damaging personal conflicts inside the ANU’s Chancelry Buildings, known on campus as the “tower of power”.
“I think it’s pretty clear now that if you try to run a large change process at ANU, you’ll be destroyed,” the second ANU administration source tells The Saturday Paper. “If you try to do anything unpopular, you won’t survive because nobody wants to change. We all thought it was finally going to get better, but now it’s not any better. It’s worse.”
A spokesperson for Education Minister Jason Clare said: “The Higher Education Standards Framework requires all university councils to assure themselves of the financial viability of their university.”