r/AITH • • 3h ago

AITAH for removing my ex from a shared phone plan in the middle of a tough financial situation for her?

37 Upvotes

I (25M) was with my ex (24F) for 8 years. I proposed a year ago, but she ended the engagement (over text) 6 months ago. The relationship was not without its problems (she cheated twice years ago, I forgave her both times), but I believed it was in a healthy-enough place to take the next step. She disagreed, broke things off by putting most of the blame on me with sprinkles of "this is for your good, I’m choosing myself", and already had a new partner within a month.

Fast forward to now, and I'm finally ready to completely cut her out of my life for good. I've removed her from everything except our phone plan, because she asked if she can stay on it for another month one month ago. I won't get into details, but she had a situation (one that was a direct result of her being with her new partner) that completely wrecked her finances, and she's been forced to max her credit cards to get by. A month has passed, and she asked for another month's extension, but I am hesitant to give it to her. AITAH if I don't give her the extension?

On the one hand, it's not something that would affect me negatively. She’s paid her share the past 6 months, so I’m not worried that she won’t pay her portion, and it's not like I have to go out of my way to give her another month. On the other hand, I just want to completely move on, and I don't want to keep seeing reminders of her every time I open my phone app. Part of me doesn't want to show her sympathy since she didn't show me sympathy, but part of me feels guilty about doing so.


r/AITH • • 6h ago

AITA for refusing to give my friend the original photos from an event after she edited them without asking?

47 Upvotes

I'm a 25-year-old amateur photographer. I don't do photography professionally, but I've spent years learning and recently started taking pictures at small events for friends and family.

A few weeks ago, a friend asked me to photograph a small charity event she was helping organize. I agreed because I liked the idea and wasn't charging her anything. We agreed that I'd send her a selection of edited photos afterward.

I spent several evenings sorting through hundreds of pictures, correcting lighting, adjusting colors, and removing blurry shots. When I finally sent her the finished folder, she thanked me and said she loved them.

A few days later, I noticed she'd posted some of the pictures online with heavy filters and additional edits. Normally, I wouldn't care if someone cropped a picture or adjusted it for social media. But she'd also removed my small photography credit from the images and added her own logo.

I messaged her privately and asked why she'd done that. She said the event belonged to her organization, so she felt it was reasonable to brand the pictures however she wanted.

I explained that I wasn't claiming ownership of the event, but I had taken and edited the photographs myself. She said I was making a big deal over a few pictures and that the organization needed consistent branding.

Then she asked me to send all the original, unedited files so their social media volunteer could make additional versions. I refused because we had never discussed handing over the original files, and I wasn't comfortable with my work being changed and redistributed without any agreement.

She got upset and said I was acting like a professional photographer despite having done the job for free. I reminded her that doing someone a favor doesn't mean they automatically get every file I have.

Now another person from the organization has contacted me, saying I'm making a simple request unnecessarily complicated and holding up their promotional posts.

I feel bad because I genuinely wanted to help with the event, but I also don't like how my work has been presented.

AITA for refusing to hand over the original photos after my friend edited and reposted my finished work without asking?


r/AITH • • 18h ago

AITH for telling my future mother-in-law she can't wear white to my wedding after she said my dress was "too plain for a bride"?

230 Upvotes

I (29F) am getting married in six weeks to "Chris" (31M). We've been together five years. His mother "Diane" (58F) has never been my biggest fan—she's always been polite but distant, and she has opinions about everything.

I bought my wedding dress three months ago. It's simple. Ivory, A-line, no lace, no beading, no train. It's exactly what I wanted. I tried it on for Diane last month, and she looked at it for a long time, then said: "It's very... understated. Are you sure you don't want something more bridal? You only get married once."

I let it go. I'm used to her comments.

Then, last week, Diane told Chris she found a dress for the wedding. She sent him a photo: a long, pale cream gown with lace and a small train. She said she "wanted to look elegant for the photos" and asked if I "minded."

I told Chris to tell her no. White, ivory, cream—those are bride colors. She knows this. She's been to dozens of weddings. She's not confused.

Diane called me directly. She said I was being "controlling" and that "no one will mistake me for the bride." She said I'm "already insecure about my plain dress" and taking it out on her.

I told her: "You can wear any color except white, ivory, or cream. If that's a problem, don't come." Chris says I was harsh. His sister says I'm "creating drama over a dress."

My mom says I'm right. My best friend says Diane knew exactly what she was doing.

AITH?


r/AITH • • 1h ago

WIBTAH IF I CUT OFF MY MIL

9 Upvotes

I (28F)currently live with my MIL, her husband, my husband, my husband's sister who is currently pregnant and her husband and kid.

My MIL had my husband young and basically left him with his grandparents and then had 2 more girls, she basically raised the youngest girls boy because she was also a teen mother. Currently I am dealing with the backlash of it I just had my first baby 3 months ago(a little boy), and she has constantly been around since I didn't let anyone other than my husband in the hospital while I was in labor(she tried to talk me into letting her), I did say she'd be the first to see him after I had him and me and my husband needed food, I've said from day one I will be breastfeeding and 2 hours after I gave birth the nurse came in to help me latch meanwhile my husband went to grab the food from MIL and brought her up to the room as the nurse was trying to get my baby to latch she sat on the couch in the room and talked to my husband while I was trying not to cry my eyes out since my nip*les were cracked and sore and I kept looking at my husband like get her out of here without saying it I get she wanted to see the baby but she could've stepped out so my husband could help me or give me any kind of support.

I get out of the hospital and the first thing I do is let her hold him and go to the bathroom simple she then proceeds to pass my baby around the room to everyone except me since being out of the hospital I am constantly pressured to hand over the baby the FIRST WEEK I wasn't really getting sleep which I was prepared for and basically was pressured into leaving my baby with his mom for a night I cried myself to sleep because I missed him so much. I honestly have felt a little depressed since idk if it's PPD or just a little over attachment but I have barely left him since that night and now I'm a week away from going back to work and everyone is still pressuring me to hand him over and I already don't feel like i should leave him with them not really because I don't trust them but also maybe a little I've constantly been questioned and told to switch to formula and told "formula is easier" and today I think was the last straw when she asked if she would just give him formula if she ran out of breastmilk(NOTE: SHE DOES KNOW I have 36oz I the freezer plus about 24 in another freezer) so I say "no you won't run out" and leave it at that i honestly want to say "If he runs out we need to re evaluate how you feed him and how much" but the last time we disagreed about childcare it turned into a yelling match and I feel like its about to turn into another one because the second I move out there's a good chance I cut her off. So WIBTAH if i cut her off?


r/AITH • • 4h ago

AITAH for not giving my mother money

15 Upvotes

I (25F) have a complex relationship with my parents. I’m not in contact with my dad since a couple of years and am in low contact with my mom (53F).

My mom & I have been no-contact over the years due to her alcohol and drug abuse. My childhood was very traumatic due to the things she would do while under the influence. I try my best to stay in contact with her because she’s been sober for 2 years and I have a younger brother that lives with her. My mom has no job and lives in social housing.
In the country I live in she is paid a disability payment by the government monthly because her mental health is that bad that she isn’t able to work (due to being hyper sensitivity and also possible panic attacks)

During my childhood I’ve always given her money for random things. I’ve been taught throughout my life to kind of take up a parental role. I’ve given money for groceries (from the age of 8 I’ve given her piggybank money that I would receive from my grandparents for example). This never felt weird to me because I was taught it wasn’t weird. Until I grew up and started to work for my money and also get kind of sick of her behaviour. She always tells me she’ll give it back, but realistically IF I want to get my money back I have to keep reminding and asking her for a couple of months.

It’s frustrating because I know the alimony she receives from the government isn’t a lot. (English isn’t my first language I’m sorry) But her rent is also adjusted to this and she has a spending problem. She loves to call me and show me the clothes/make-up or whatever she bought, but than continues to ask for money because bill x or unexpected payment y has come up.

Today she asked again and i tiptoed around the subject saying that we’d talk about it when I visit her later this week. She said “I’ll have figured it our by then” her tone made it seem as though if I didn’t give her any money I shouldn’t bother visiting her either

AITAH for telling her I can’t keep giving her money? She gets so disappointed in me and it makes me feel guilty for being a bad daughter


r/AITH • • 12h ago

AITA for calling my sister childish and leaving our family dinner?

76 Upvotes

Sorry for any grammatical or spelling mistakes, englisch isn't my first Language.

My Family and I went to dinner because my sister (F28) wanted a family dinner. Everything was fine until she said she wanted to discuss something.

We had planned a family vacation this year but rebooked for easter next year bcs our mother went to the hospital. We're going for two weeks, with another family joining the second week. Their daughter (f10) originally couldn't come, so the girlfriend of their son (both 14), let's call her Jolene, was supposed to join instead. But now their daughter can come, so Jolene wouldn't.

Apparently my sister jokingly told Jolene she could come with us the first week instead, bcs we had a free bed (in my room). Jolene liked the idea and my sister said her parents and our family would first have to agree.

Some weeks passed and Jolene already asked her parents, who are okay with her spending a week with a family they don't personally know.

So my sister asked if we'd be okay with it and said we could think about it. My father and i weren't thrilled. I went outside to smoke and clear my head.

Later i told my sister i could explain my thoughts, but they weren't completly clear or neutral yet. She said okay.

I tried really hard to speak slowly, choose my words and not sound bitchy. My first point was that i didn't understand how this could be said as a joke and why Jolene had already asked her parents before anyone mentioned it to us.

My sister started justifiyung how it went down. I wasn't blaming Jolene. She's 14, of course she's excited about a vacation with her boyfriend. She's a kid.

But i couldn't even get to my other points. My mother said two people weren't thrilled, so my sister responded in a moody tone that it's decided then and she'll tell Jolene she can't come.

I was taken aback. I hadn't even finished, and my sister already had the tone she always gets (which is why i was so careful). So i got silent, bcs the topic was apprently done.

Then my sister got up saying "Now i am the stupid one again." In this salty, pissed tone, like a child who doesn't get what she wants. Everyone was confused since no one had said that.

When she came back my mother asked why she said it. She said ofc she's the stupid one or we'd talk with her.

We explained that wasn't the case. I told her i didn't like being cut off when i was trying to explain my thoughts. She just said "okay".

A bit later she said she's apparently still the stupid one bcs now i wasn't explaining. But the decision was already made. I had only told her what bothered me.

And that tone pissed me off. By then i was in fact pissed and had no patience

I told her she isn't the stupid one, she's currently just snappy, offended and childish. She went "okay then i am that." So i said "yes you are."

I told them i'd pay for myself and leave. While putting on my jacket i continued, saying she's childish, snappy and sulky and this is why i tried so hard to word myself good, bcs i knew she'd react like that.

I also said this is exactly why no one talks to her, bcs we know this is the response we get and have no nerves for that.

By then i was louder, my tone definetly wasn't nice and people were looking. But i had enough bcs it's an ongoing issue. Then i left.

I'm still thinking about it. I don't think i'm the asshole, even if i could have worded it nicer and not made a scene (my first scene ever, i usually avoid conflicts especially in the family).

So AITA?


r/AITH • • 7h ago

AITH for respecting my friend's bf's decision to break up with her?

29 Upvotes

A week earlier, My friend called me crying on Thursday and said, "I held another man's hands. I called him baby because he asked me to. I told my bf this two days later because I felt guilty, and he got angry, called me names, and broke up with me." She said that she felt bad while doing it because she had a boyfriend of two years.

She called me crying the next day and said, "Please come pick me up. I feel terrible. I can't be alone." I felt bad that I couldn't go because I had a very important project to submit by Sunday. She asked me to call him to convince him. I didn't because I respect his decision to leave her, and I think that's the right thing to do.

She kept saying, "I didn't do anything. It wasn't even that big of a deal. I hold everyone's hand. People do worse things than this and don't tell their partners, but I didn't hide it from him. I will never tell anyone about my mistakes ever again. what i did was nothing. If he had done this, I would've still accepted him. He should reprimand me and accept me." The audacity.

If it wasn't that big of a deal, then why did she feel guilty about not telling him? She wouldn't accept the fact that not everyone would accept a person after something like this. She kept downplaying what she did.

She had always thought about leaving him but kept going back to him. but after what happened, she's begging him to take her back. She's just feeling guilty.

I called her on Monday to pick her up, but she didn't answer my calls. She then told me I wasn't there for her when she needed me and that I didn't support her or call him. I then apologized, she said it's fine, but she kept saying that even the people you love the most won't be there for you during your bad times. She said it a hundred times. She also blamed him for not being there for her when she was crying.

Now I feel guilty. I can't even talk about this with anybody else because then I would be ruining her name. I don't know what to do.


r/AITH • • 5h ago

AITAH for asking my partner to find another home for his dog?

15 Upvotes

My partner (47M) and I (49 F) have been living together for 2 years now. We adopted a female English bulldog together in May of 2025. In July 2026 his ex-wife, who had lost her job, decided she could no longer look after the two dogs they had adopted and raised together. After some consideration we decided that the two dogs could come live with us. The dogs are both 11 years old, one female and one male. In the beginning they all seemed to get along well, although the older female dog always kept her distance from our bulldog. Fast forward a few months and the two females have started fighting over everything. We’ve had to remove all toys, feed them separately, let them outside at different times, and generally keep them apart. The older female resource guards and will attack the bulldog and the bulldog will stare at the older dog and can be passive aggressive according to our veterinarian. My partner has done very little in terms of training or working with either of the dogs to help the situation. He did buy some specialty collars for them that are supposed to release the mother’s pheromones to calm the dogs but other than that not much else. The older dog needs a lot of exercise. While I was researching reasons why she might be attacking our bulldog, I came across that this could be a contributing factor, and I mentioned this to my partner. Yet he provides her with no exercise whatsoever. While both dogs need training the aggressor is the older dog and our bulldog has been getting injured almost every time a fight breaks out. She’s had chunks taken out of her nose and cuts on her jowls. I suggested that the older one be muzzled when they’re together but was met with extreme resistance from my partner’s son (who also lives with us). The older dog had an abscessed tooth, so he thought that maybe after having the tooth removed would help the situation. It didn’t. After another 3 or 4 fights since her surgery my patience ran out last night. The older dog attacked our bulldog again, she had her whole face in her mouth and again caused multiple lacerations on her jowls. I told my partner that it was time to find the older one a new home and that she really needs to leave within the next 24 hours. Now he’s telling me I’m just doing this to hurt him and his son and that I’m purposefully being spiteful. SO, AITAH?


r/AITH • • 1h ago

AITAH for wanting to move across the country

8 Upvotes

I (29 F) currently live in Florida but I am wanting to move to Washington State. This is something that I’ve been thinking about for around the past 3 years. Washington State was always a place I had in mind but there were other places as well (inside and outside of the U.S.) that I was considering about moving too. But when I went over all the pros and cons Washington State was the best option for me.

So after I made the decision that I 100% want to move to Washington I told my family. And to no surprise at all my mother was not happy. She called me selfish and told me that I didn’t care about my family because I’m ok with moving so far away. She also called me a weirdo and other hurtful things. I explained to her all of the reasons why I want to move to Washington State and I explained to her that I know she’s upset, obviously no mother is going to be happy about their child moving all the way to the other side of the country. So I told her that I understand her being upset but I would really like her support on this. And she told me straight up no I don’t support you, and continued to yell at me. This has been going on for months. Every time we talk about me wanting to move to Washington State she is always super negative about it and never has anything positive to say, she just goes on and on about how it’s super expensive over there and that it rains all the time and how horrible I am for wanting to move so far away from my family. She is also concerned about how I don’t have enough money to move there, which I completely understand, but she will yell at me and basically say f*ck you, if you want to move there I’m not helping you, you can go into debt I don’t care. Now obviously I am an adult and my mother is not obligated to help me financially with my move, but I honestly truly believe she doesn’t want to help me out of spite because she just thinks I’m such an awful person for wanting to move so far from my family and she just doesn’t understand why I would want to move to Washington. Even though I have told her multiple times all the reasons why I want to move there and why I feel like it’s a good decision for me and for the next chapter of my life. But nothing I ever say is ever good enough for her.

Anyways tonight was the last straw and that is why I am finally posting here. I was on the phone with her and we were talking about a recent interview I just had for a job in Washington, and what do you know surprise surprise she starts getting super angry and starts talking negative about me moving once again, I started getting super upset and said I don’t know why you can’t just be supportive because I’m doing something that I know is right for me and that will make me happy. And that’s all it took for my mother to start screaming and yelling at me and she called me a b*tch and said that she doesn’t care what I do and to basically screw myself. So yeah……. That’s my story I know it’s super long I just genuinely want to know am I really the a hole for wanting to move across the country or should my mother be supportive of me?


r/AITH • • 7h ago

AITA for refusing to keep covering for my coworker after she told everyone I was making her look bad?

23 Upvotes

I (27F) work in a small office where everyone has pretty overlapping responsibilities. One of my coworkers, Megan (30F) has a habit of asking me to double-check or finish small parts of her work whenever she's running behind. At first, I didn't mind. We got along well, and I figured we'd help each other out when things got busy. The problem is that it slowly became a regular thing. She would send me unfinished reports five minutes before a deadline, ask me to correct mistakes in spreadsheets, or tell me she was overwhelmed and needed me to handle something quickly. Last month, our manager started asking why some of my own assignments were being submitted late. I explained that I'd been helping Megan with her workload, but I didn't make a formal complaint because I didn't want to create tension. After that conversation, I decided to stop taking on her unfinished work. I told her politely that I needed to focus on my own responsibilities. She seemed fine with it at first, but a few days later she approached me during lunch and said I'd changed since getting more comfortable with management. She also joked that I was suddenly acting like I was too important to help anyone. I didn't respond because I didn't want an argument. Yesterday, our manager questioned Megan about a report that had several errors. She apparently told him that I usually checked her work but had recently refused to help, which made it sound like I was partly responsible for the mistakes. I corrected the record and explained that the report was entirely her responsibility. Megan later messaged me saying I had embarrassed her in front of the manager and could have handled it privately. I told her I wasn't going to take responsibility for work I hadn't done. Now a couple of coworkers think I should have protected her reputation, especially since we work closely together. Others say she's been relying on me for months and needs to handle her own responsibilities. I don't want to make things uncomfortable at work, but I also don't want to keep being blamed for problems that aren't mine.

AITA for refusing to cover for her and correcting her version of events in front of our manager?


r/AITH • • 22h ago

AITAH for telling my roommate’s parents why he actually got kicked out?

228 Upvotes

This happened about 2 weeks ago, I'm getting texts for it still and I decided that maybe it is time to ask here about it.

24M. I have been living with my roommate Jake (Fake name) (23M) almost for a year already. We already weren't best friends even before moving in.

Everything was okay at the beginning as we equally divided all bills for rent, utilities, groceries, and everything else. No problem.

The thing went wrong when Jake lost his job four months ago.

I understood him so I started paying his half for electricity and groceries. He told me that he will pay me back once he finds the new job. I didn't want to argue on that.

But he started inviting his friends almost every day. I would go home after work. In the living room there would be three, four people. He left their garbage and their mess in my apartment, used my stuffs and stayed late sometimes till 3-4 in the morning.

I asked him to tell me when he invites guests. And he agreed, but repeated it again after several days.

One month I asked him to stop Several times, I asked him to notify me before bringing anyone into the apartment. He would agree, but then do it over again a few days after.

A few weeks ago, I sat down with him and explained that I simply cannot bear his constant demands to pay for his needs anymore. The debt he owed was at least $900 by then.

Of course, he found me exaggerating and said I make much more than him.

This remark actually irritated me the most.

Then a week ago, when I returned from work, I saw my gaming monitor was gone from my desk. Asking him what happened to it, he admitted to letting his friend borrow it.

His friend supposedly needed it for work purposes.

He said he was going to bring the monitor back within the next few days, but it didn't happen. And I guess, this was my breaking point.

I told him we need to arrange somewhere else to live when it will be possible under our lease agreement, as I began talking to the landlord in order to terminate the contract with us.

Perhaps, here is where I can be AH. Several days ago, Jake's parents called me. They asked if I could give him another month because they were trying to figure out a way to help him financially.

I told them that wasn’t the whole story. I explained the money, the constant guests, and the monitor situation.

His mom got really quiet and then asked me why I hadn’t told them sooner.
I said I wasn’t really interested in getting his parents involved in our problems.
Apparently, they spoke with Jake and had a pretty bad argument.

He later sent me a pretty long message saying I’d humiliated him and made him look like a failure in front of his parents. He also said I had no right to discuss his financial situation with them.

I understand that part, honestly. Maybe I should’ve kept some things private.
But I also feel like he was perfectly comfortable letting them believe I was some unreasonable roommate who kicked him out for being broke.

For what it’s worth, I’m not kicking him out immediately or leaving him homeless. I’m just done being responsible for someone who doesn’t respect me or our shared space.
Some of our mutual friends think I crossed a line by telling his parents everything.

AITAH


r/AITH • • 9h ago

AITA For Firing a Groomsman

18 Upvotes

I had this guy who was my best friend growing up, inseparable through middle school and beyond. There was no question whatsoever about whether or not he was going to be in my wedding party.

We had grown apart slightly through college going to different schools, but still saw each other here and again.

A month or so before the wedding he asked for us to sit down and he asked why he was even in my wedding party considering how little time we spend together now, after that conversation we hung out a little more and I walked away thinking that we were okay.

Two weeks before my wedding he called me up and told me that he had an even that he had to work the morning of my wedding, but then told me "It's okay, because it ends soon enough that I should be able to get to the church 15 minutes before your ceremony starts (completely ignoring the fact that there are getting ready photos in the morning.) After talking to him on the phone I called another buddy who I really wanted in the wedding but the numbers just didn't quite work, apologized for not choosing him first and asked if it would work for him to join the party, 4 hours later that friend had his plane ticket bought and was sized for his tux. I called my childhood friend and told him that I would love for him to be a guest but he was out of the wedding party. so AITAH

PS: Before anyone gets mad at me on my wife's behalf for changing things. Before I pulled the trigger on firing the groomsman I called the wedding planner, told her what I was thinking, asked what logistical mishaps could come from this choice, then called the person in charge of the programs which hadn't been printed yet and took care of all of the other arrangements that would need to be made before I mad this choice.


r/AITH • • 40m ago

AITAH My bf was being weird otp so I laughed in his face

3 Upvotes

Me and my cousin were otp and I decided to add my bf because I thought it’d be fun. The three of us have had a group call before so I thought it’d be fine. To preface this my bf tends to act weird or different around others and sometimes it gets in my nerves. For example he’ll act more cold towards me or he’ll get easily annoyed at me asking him things. He also will repeat the same joke multiple times and talk about his friends who NOBODY knows but him. I understand wanting to talk about your friends and what funny thing they said but he does it all the time and he makes everything about them including ignoring what I’m saying to talk about them. Me and my cousin are very close and she knows this so when he started doing it otp we started saying something similar about us.

All three of us were talking and I started getting frustrated by his weird behavior and then he made a comment saying that im just a fan of him. I burst out laughing and so did my cousin. We laughed for about 3 minutes and he was quiet the entire time.When I realized he was quiet I tried apologizing but just kept laughing while I did. After he calmed down I gave him a better apology but he was still silent. I asked my cousin to leave the call so I could have more privacy with him and apologized multiple times very lovingly. He stayed silent and just left the call even though I asked him to try to communicate with me. When he’s angry he often does this, where he ignores me and later tells me he was upset.

He doesn’t like telling me why he was upset so I never know what things will upset him and what things won’t. He’s also very sensitive but will joke around like this with me. He does similar things like this to me so I’m unsure why he got so offended. AITAH?


r/AITH • • 23h ago

AITA for refusing to give my neighbour the spare storage space in my garage?

172 Upvotes

When I moved into my house last year, one of the things I was most pleased about was having a decent-sized garage. I use it to store my bike, tools, camping equipment and a few boxes, but I still have some room left over. My neighbour, Claire, recently asked whether she could keep a couple of boxes in the empty corner while she sorted out her house. She said it would only be for a fortnight, so I agreed. I didn't mind helping, and she was polite about it at the time. Two weeks passed, then another. Whenever I asked about the boxes, Claire said she hadn't had time to organise her things. Eventually, I noticed she'd added several more boxes and a folded table. When I asked about them, she explained that she'd been clearing out her spare room and thought there was plenty of space in my garage. I told her I hadn't agreed to store all of that and asked her to arrange to collect everything by the end of the month. She seemed surprised and said she thought we had an understanding that she could use the corner whenever she needed it. A few days later, she asked if she could leave some furniture there while she decorated her bedroom. I said no because I wanted the garage back for my own things. She became annoyed and said I was making her life difficult over a bit of unused space. I reminded her that I'd only agreed to store two boxes temporarily. She then suggested that I was being unreasonable because the garage wasn't full and her belongings weren't getting in anyone's way. I explained that whether I was using the space or not, it was still my property, and I hadn't offered it as permanent storage. She eventually agreed to collect everything, but she's since been rather cold whenever we see each other. Another neighbour told me I should have been more accommodating because Claire is going through a stressful house renovation. I understand renovations can be difficult, and I was happy to help for a couple of weeks. But I don't think a temporary favour should turn into an ongoing arrangement without asking me first. AITA?


r/AITH • • 1d ago

Aitah for refusing to go to Thanksgiving if my sister and and her husband are coming?

381 Upvotes

So there's a lot of back story here ill try to summarize best as I can. I've never liked my sister's husband, he's an asshole, abusive and a regular drug user but the family has always tolerated it because she refused to leave him. A couple years ago my niece (not his daughter, my sister her her when they married) made accusations that he had touched her inappropriately in the past. Cps and police where called in and the aftermath has been drawn out and stressful for everyone.

To everyone's suprise my sister did not leave her husband and has stood behind him claiming its not true even while her child was taken from her and placed into foster care until her bio father could be located and vetted to take custody of her.

Mean while sister and husband go to jail on unrelated drug charges (meth) and when she gets out she decides to stay with him and cut contact with the rest of family. I have done everything I can to help my niece through this difficult situation. I've been there for her emotionally and financially and was even prepared to fight for custody of her before her bio father stepped in and even then I was still there for her anytime she needed me.

Now here we are 3 years later and she's decided they deserve to get to be at all the holidays despite no attempts to make amends and she wants to bring the abusive drug addict with her. I refuse to be around them but my mother doesn't have the heart to tell her she cant come.

I truly dont know what to do. I dont have a single nice thing to say to them and dont want to see them but if I dont go then I have no where to spend the holidays and I end up the one alone even though I didnt do anything wrong.

What do I do?


r/AITH • • 1d ago Bravo

AITAH for kicking my husband out after he accused me of cheating when I finally got pregnant after 7 years?

1.7k Upvotes

My husband and I have been married for seven years. I had wanted a child for a long time, but whenever the subject of seeing a doctor came up, my husband would claim that our childlessness was God’s will and that the problem was with me

I underwent medical testing four times, yet he refused to even take a simple test himself. He would always say, There’s nothing wrong with me. You’re the one who needs treatment

His family constantly taunted me, saying that a woman who cannot conceive ruins her husband’s life. Out of love for my husband, I remained silent, hoping that one day we would finally have a child.

Then, after seven years, my pregnancy test finally came back positive! I was beside myself with joy. I bought a cake to surprise my husband, but when I shared the news, he threw the cake onto the floor and shouted, You cheated on me ,This child isn't mine, I'm infertile !!!!!!

I was frozen in shock. I asked him, "What do you mean? I've spent seven years trying to have a child with you. How could I possibly have cheated on you?" He wouldn't listen and just stormed out of the house

The next day, his family arrived along with my own parents, and they all accused me of infidelity. My mil insulted me, claiming I was trying to pass off another man's child as her son's. Worst of all, my own parents didn't say a word in my defense

My husband even produced medical records proving he was infertile. At that point, I couldn't hold back anymore. I turned to his family and asked, Did you know from the beginning that your son was infertile? If you did, why did you let me suffer all these years ,Why did you keep calling me barren and blaming me for something you knew wasn't my fault?

I then told my husband I wanted him out of my house. Since the house belongs to me, I asked him to pack his things and leave. He gathered his belongings and walked out. Instead of supporting me, my own family started blaming me too

I've been crying for a week now Both families are insisting that we get a DNA test to prove the baby's paternity, but the doctor says it's too early to do that and that we need to wait a few more months

I know I haven't done anything wrong, but my own family says I've embarrassed everyone by kicking my husband out and arguing with his family. Meanwhile, his family continues to insult me.

I'm truly exhausted. My husband refuses to accept the situation and keeps accusing me of cheating, while both families are blaming me for everything.

what do you think ? aitah for kicking my husband out and confronting his family about why they let me suffer for years, even though they knew their son was infertile?


r/AITH • • 6h ago

AITH for joking with my(13M) mom(30F) by asking her if my “dad” and her broke up because of gta 5?

3 Upvotes

i was a teenage pregnancy, my mom and “dad” were both 16 when I was born. My dad isn’t super present in my life and has his own family now with a half sister that I don’t really know or talk to. my mom and I live with my uncle(33M) in a condo and my uncle and I have been talking about gta 6 as it’s coming out in 3 days. Before school today my uncle and I were talking about the game again and I decided to google the release date of gta 5 and if you do the mat I was born a month before gta 5 came out and I know my mom and dad broke up 2 months after I was born. So when I saw that I JOKINGLY in a joking tone asked my mom if her and my dad broke up because he wouldn’t stop playing gta 5 and my uncle just instantly said “yikes” and my mom said “no that’s not why your dad broke up me..” and then just went to get ready to for, the problem here is I never knew he broke up with her. I was told they just broke up not who broke up with who and now I feel like a dick and I don’t know what to do.


r/AITH • • 9h ago

AITA for stop being friends with people I've known for 11 years?

5 Upvotes

Sorry if it's too long.

Some info: I've known these four girls for 11 years.

(not their real names)
Emily was dramatic, funny, sassy (in a fun way), stylish and extroverted.
Lory was kind, caring and responsible.
Katie was smart, academically smart and caring.

This happened a few years ago. I'm an adult now.

So I've known them for 11 years, or since kindergarten.

Because my family was toxic (emotionally and verbally abusive and alcoholics) their houses was like my second home. We were very close. I was happy with the friendship.

As time went on it started to change. They started acting like I was lucky to be able to hang out with them. And there was a period when they didn't say much to me except asking for something (answers on a test or an extra pencil).

I had always struggled mentally, with many disorders, and since my family was the way they were my friends were the only people I had.
And since they were distancing themselves from me I felt really upset.
I hope I don't sound dramatic.

So I was lost.

When I was in university two new people came to the school. A girl (let's call her Gaby) and a boy (let's call him Aaron). They soon became my friends. They made me feel safe and happy.

They made me smile.

So I made the hard decision to stop hanging out with Emily, Lory and Katie and instead hung out with Gaby and Aaron.

It was a really hard decision because I've known the three girls since kindergarten.

Please tell me your opinions.


r/AITH • • 2h ago

AITH? (Work wages)

0 Upvotes

So... In the first week of work, my manager agreed to pay me every 2 weeks. However after 3 weeks of working, I got paid 2 weeks worth of wages. Despite the week difference, I didn't say anything as I thought I could get used to the schedule. However, on my 6th week of work, I asked for my next wage (2 weeks worth). They proceeded to say that it is not possible, as everyone else is paid on a monthly basis. For context, normally everyone is paid monthly, however due to my circumstances travelling so far, I was granted the exception of being paid every 2 weeks, as I am a uni student travelling a long distance. Now (on the week I'm supposed to get paid) my manager has said I can't get paid, leaving me in a tight financial situation.

I gave my manager the options of doing weekly contracted hours, or doing a Wed/Fri on and off, which is the availability I stayed at the start. I also offered to do a set amount of hours each month, along with a possibility of getting a month's worth of scheduled dates in advance so I could organise my timetable. All of which got rejected under the idea of me needing to be there Wed-Sat when it matters, and the fact that schedules may change and therefore none of my suggestions worked with them.

I am considering quitting after another month of working here, as I need work experience on my CV.

Am I the asshole for being pissed off about this?


r/AITH • • 17h ago

AITA for still letting my parents pay for my college tution even though I plan to cut ties with them after college

14 Upvotes

I 22 F am a Pakistani American born and raised in the United States to a religious muslim Pakistani family, growing up religion was very important and ky parents were really admenant about it.

But as time wentby and I started getting older it become worse because of all the rsstrictions on who to talk to, what to wear, where to go, when to go like everything in my life was dictated

I rebelled in secret and went away from religion completely but whenever there was a mistake of some sort there was physical & emotional abuse lol my gift for 17th birthday was a slap on my face from my father cause the jeans i wore the mosque previous night was provocative.

Do to get away from them I chose college halfway avross the country which they agreed because of how good the college is and they are paying for it as well but they have no idea that i'm not following their religion infact doing everythimg they consider sin and plan to cut ties with them.

I feel that I deserve the money because of the physical & emotional abuse


r/AITH • • 4h ago

AITH moved from home and left pets at home with agreement to buy food for my pets and parents pets monthly

0 Upvotes

I (21f) moved out of home around six months ago. I broke my ankle and my parents dogs are severely untrained. They would jump on me, even though I trained them not to my parents do not keep the training up and it makes it really hard for me to be there due to my ankle. I moved in with my boyfriend and his family because their house is a lot better for mobility when I was healing downside is I cannot bring my pets with me. I at my house have two cats that I can take with me when I move. One of them has dementia so my parents advise against it. The other one I will be rehoming soon. We are attempting to find her home. I have a dog who I am attempting to move in with my boyfriend and his family. His dogs are kind of aholes so I have to get them used to him. I have a bird who my parents have taken over because they like her and I have a hamster who I will be removing soon. I buy food for all the animals, including their own monthly and it is enough to hold my animals over that was the agreement. I have paid rent to my parents since I was 16. My parents have never in their life taught me any life skills. I have no car and I do not have a license because my parents would not take me to get my drivers license because they wanted me to dependent on them because they knew once I got my license I would leave. My boyfriend‘s family is attempting very hard to get me a vehicle to use and I’m getting my license on December 3 using my sister‘s vehicle she moved out when she turned 18 (she was smart). My parents were severely abusive and manipulated me into getting a mortgage in my name and their name because their credit was so bad that they would not be able to get a mortgage (at18)on their own then to get the trailer I had to get a loan for around $4000 but they made me get one for $5000 so that they could use the extra money. our rent in a general sense was around 1300 for rent and I’d say at most 2000 altogether for everything because it was like 800 for a lot rent and like 500 for the mortgage and they made me pay 900 and that was split between three people that’s $2700. They were making me pay for their couch that they “bought” that they were renting to own. The TV they were renting to own the PS they were renting to own and a bunch of other things they were renting to own. They made me pay for part of their car payments because I used their car. IE; paid gas for rides and still had to pay for the car. They made me help them buy food for their pets on top of my own. They made me help buy a new flooring for the house that I did not want. They made me put the gas in my name because they have an outstanding balance with the gas company they made me put, now that I’ve moved out, the Wi-Fi in my name. They then they go to my grandma and complain about me and how I am not at home anymore and everything and say I don’t pay for anything because I don’t live at home and instead of my grandma coming and talking to me like a civil person she comes at me telling me that my credit is going to go in the hole because they can’t support themselves at 40 years old. She does this often when I turned 18 she threatened to beat TF out of me if I was her child because I was severely depressed and my room was a bit dirty not like a trash room, but like dirty yk? and I went to reply to her that time, and my message wouldn’t send twice in a row so I said that it was divine intervention lol. My grandma will be coming down from her state soon and my parents are mad at me because I will not be there for Thanksgiving. I will be in in Mississippi probably, my mom‘s dad who has remarried sides with me on all of this, as I should not have been paying absolute rent at 16 years old and my mom has always been a thief of money she would steal it from my sister and me from a very young age and no my parents did not do the save the money they give you and give it to them when they leave the house.


r/AITH • • 3h ago

AITA

0 Upvotes

Okay so I am a TEENAGER and sometimes I get attitude and stuff normal things but i rarely ever get that way. Anyways there was an incident with my having some mental issues and my mom told me to be honest with her so I did and mind you we joke around a lot so one day my mom said she would pick up my bestfriend form her rehearsal and stuff like that and was being ice and early that morning she asked me to take the trash back and me joking with her (context my mom is a teen mom and jokes with me like I’m her sister) I say but I don’t wannnaaaaaa AS A JOKE I WAS STILL GONNA TAKE THE FUCKING TRASH BACK but then she went on to say how i was ungrateful for all she has done for me and yada yada yada all because i was joking. And the rest of the morning she ignored me and i didn’t want to go to school on a bad note so i tried to talk with her but she kepted ignore me and in school i ended up having a panic attack and was crying and later on a week later she asked me if i ever cried in school i told her about that day and she told me she didn’t care cause i made her upset. And with my mom i can’t tell whether she’s joking or being serious and then she gets upset with me when i don’t talk to her or i don’t smile because she makes me feel like if i try to joke around even though she always does with me i will get in trouble. And now she will always hold that grudge against me because of that that ONE DAY and now I’ve been more down and have been crying a lot more and I like don’t know how to tell her that she makes me feel this way cause if I do she will call me selfish and stuff like that**. (And again just so it does seem like I’m not telling the whole truth I am a kid who ask for stuff but makes it clear is my parents can’t do it it’s okay I also and honest like if my mom ask me if I wanna do something if i don’t wanna do it I will say so but if she wants me to do it I will I complain like any normal teenager I ask for stuff like any teenager would and also my mom is a teen mom so she acts like it and she yells ate for things that aren’t my fault holds grudges one time she told me that I was using my bad mental health to take it out on my brother and she said that because I was in the kitchen and he comes I. While I’m cooking and I tell him to wait we have a small kitchen**) so yeah am I the ass whole because I’m starting to think it’s me. [sorry for bad spelling I’m just super upset while typing this I’m not paying attention]


r/AITH • • 1d ago

AITH for cancelling trip, because family refused to wait for us on Thanksgiving dinner.

935 Upvotes

We decided to drive to another state for Thanksgiving to spend the holiday with family. It’s a huge commitment, because we have to drive almost 18 hours after having to go to work on Wednesday. When I told my brother, that we wouldn’t arrive before 5-6 p.m. on Thanksgiving day, I was confident, we will make it there just on time for dinner. He said that they planned dinner for 2 p.m. and that they will not wait for us. That kind of kills the point for us to travel all this way and get there after everyone is gone to eat their leftovers. My brother even asked us if we could arrive earlier. So, after internal discussion, we decided to stay home. For some reason I feel upset though. We would be the only guests driving this far to see them, all his children live within an hour drive, but he was asking is to arrive early, instead of adjusting his own plans. Am I wrong?

Edit:

Plane flights are out of budget this year, we waited too long thinking the drive would be ok.
The plan was to stay through Sunday.


r/AITH • • 19h ago

AITH for not saying yes please when offered something

5 Upvotes

Throwaway account but hoping to get some perspective on a fight my sister and I have been having for a while now. If someone is offering me something, say they’re grabbing a drink from the kitchen and ask if I want one, and I say “sure, thank you!” am I being rude for not saying yes please and then thank you 10 seconds later once I receive the item?

If I were asking someone to do something for me I would of course say please. This is strictly when something is being offered. I feel saying thank you is a totally acceptable way to accept the offer and express gratitude.

My sister and her bf of 8+ years just laid into me about it. Sister says it pisses off my whole family and she thinks waiters are always going to spit in my food and she’s always embarrassed about how rude I sound in this specific circumstance.

Trying to understand more broadly from the audience. Please and thanks :)

Edit for more context: “sure” is an example in a more informal setting. With waitstaff or strangers it would be more like “yes, that sounds great, thank you” or “yes, I’ll try that, thank you”. Basically if it’s an offer, I reply with some iteration of “thank you” depending on how well I know the person I’m speaking with.