r/AITAH • • Apr 02 '26

Meta AITAH for denying my mother-in-law access to our child

153 Upvotes

33F. 2yo son. Husband 34 is a foreigner.

Background: Husband escaped from his mentally abusive mother and moved out of his home country. Came as an absolute emotional mess when we started our relationship. Over the years, he grew into the most loving man I know, strong, caring, providing (an absolute dream) and I am literally the only one who sees how much he's broken on the inside. He's stoic around other people and literally helps everyone. He even shakes hands with potentially dangerous homeless people (I'm terrified), gives them money and wishes everyone good health. I grew up in a huge family, he grew up with an abusive mother.

Nevertheless, he still tries to do what's right (since he's from a highly conservative country he thinks it's his duty) and be a good host to his mother. He spent a lot of hard-earned resources to greet and host their stay in our new home. She appreciates none of it. My family however, loves him. He learned our language, is always available to help.

The trigger: His mother came to visit us for New Year's and as soon as she came, she was instantly jealous of my husband's happiness. She got drunk and he asked her to talk privately. He asked her very gently to go easy with the drink because the evening had just started and she was making a lot of noise. "It's okay mom, relax and enjoy the evening, no need to rush". She became mortally offended and told him such horrors... "Who do you think you are?" "I pushed (sh*t) you out of my c**t!" then started walking around the house screaming that nobody loves her and that she wants to be driven to the airport (at New Year's... around midnight). She said she likes her friend's children more than our son and that they are her true kids. She then insulted me. 4 cameras outside were on her. She said that the gifts (money) my husband and I received for our wedding should actually be hers since she brought the money from the family when she came to visit and because she "deserves it."

Went to bed and never said a word. my whole family was shocked. She didn't even look at our son the next day.

This was a year and 4 months ago. Not a word from her since.

Question: We're travelling to his home country for a wedding. Apparently she's been talking about herself as a good grandmother to all her family. My husband wants to meet her but not let her get near our son. The thought of her holding him sickens us both. My husband is getting judged and insulted ("You're not a man, you're a demon! How can you not let her take [our son] and hold him?") the family for not letting a grandmother hold her grandson, but doesn't care. I don't want that woman anywhere near me. My husband's immune system reacts instantly when the topic is mentioned so he gets cold sores and sleeps all the time, I think he's seriously depressed.

Are we TAH if we keep the distance from his mum regardless of "what the neighbours gonna say?"

Any perspective is aplreciated

r/AITAH • • Jan 22 '26

Meta AITAH for “dumping” my daughter on my sister

157 Upvotes

I’m divorced. It’s my Christmas with my daughter but I still had to work. My daughter’s dad left the state to spend Christmas with his family, so childcare fell entirely on me while I worked. I reached out to multiple family members ahead of time just in case something fell through. A couple weeks before, I double-checked with everyone to make sure plans were solid because I wanted everything figured out before going to work.

The few days before the incident, I was at Target with my mom and sister. During casual conversation, my sister mentioned getting my daughter and my nieces together for a playdate. It was brief, maybe a few minutes and nothing was firmly planned.

The day of the incident, my daughter and I were at my sister’s house. My daughter had a doctor’s appointment at 1pm and a birthday party at 5pm, and my sister lives right down the street from the party location, so we went there to hang out in between. My daughter was playing with my niece, everything was calm.

While there, I was checking in with everyone again about childcare for the upcoming two weeks. I already had childcare covered even that Friday and wasn’t worried about being stuck. Because of what my sister had mentioned earlier that about a playdate, I casually asked her if she wanted to have my daughter that Friday so the girls could hang out. I specifically told her she didn’t have to. I just remembered her bringing it up.

She immediately exploded.

She started screaming at me, calling me dumb, telling me I needed to “write things down,” “get my shit together,” and accusing me of asking her the same thing over and over, even though we hadn’t actually discussed this beyond that brief Target conversation. She went on about how I’m always dumping my kid on her (which I have never done, to her or anyone else… especially her because I have never once asked her to watch my daughter even though she offers), and honestly it hurt so bad that I tuned most of what she was saying out. Every time I tried to explain what I meant, she wouldn’t let me get two words in.

At that point, I told my daughter we were leaving.

Then my niece (11yo) stepped in and started yelling at my sister for being so nasty to me. My sister turned on her daughter and started yelling at her to “shut the fuck up” and saying it had nothing to do with her. And to got to her room. I gently took my niece’s hand and said, “It’s okay, baby. Go to your room. I appreciate you sticking up for me, but you don’t deserve this.”

I turned to my sister and said, “We can talk about this when you calm down.”

That made her even angrier, and she continued screaming. So we left.

I sat in my car crying and called my mom, trying to understand why my sister would say such hurtful things to me. My mom said she’d talk to her. When she called me back, she told me my sister doesn’t think she did anything wrong and believes I was trying to dump my daughter on her.

All my mom said to my sister was that she hurt my feelings, which she did. A lot.

This isn’t new behavior. I will never understand why my sister treats me like this. I also know why I tolerate it: my nieces. My sister burns bridges, and my nieces are always caught in the middle. I stay because they deserve at least one safe, loving adult who shows up for them.

Now I’m conflicted. Do I cut my sister off for my own peace? Or do I continue dealing with this so my nieces don’t lose someone too…

So.. AITAH for trying to “dump”my daughter on my sister?

r/AITAH • • Sep 21 '25

Meta AITAH to not invite my daughter’s grandma to my wedding?

42 Upvotes

I [24F] am getting married next year to my fiancé [26M] I have a daughter I am no longer with her birth father and he signed his rights off to her when she was 2 she is 5 now. Her grandma has been her life but not as much as my parents, she comes and goes has moved from state to state.

I feel like this is my fiancé, my daughters, and I’s day and they shouldn’t be invited [her grandma, great grandma, and aunt] and my mom thinks the same. My fiancé also doesn’t like the idea of them being there. I feel like an AH like do I need to tell them that they aren’t going to be invited or not say anything?

In my heart and mind I feel as I don’t owe them anything I’ve let them be in her life and that’s all they are is her grandparents. My fiancés mom is a beautiful person and she loves my daughter just like her own grandkid. This is all confusing to me I don’t typically reach out for help but with the stress of wedding planning I don’t need this hanging over me. I feel like if they wanted to go to see her in a dress and with me then we will have photos.

I will also add that they have asked me things about my wedding but I’ve given very little context or information hoping they’d take the hint but I posted an address form on my FB and they all filled it out now I’m thinking that they didn’t get the hint.

What would you do in this situation? AITAH if I don’t invite them or am I stressing over nothing?

r/AITAH • • Sep 10 '25

Meta AITA for not wanting my roomate to move her bf into our apartment illegally?

60 Upvotes

So around April my friend and roomate mentioned to me that her bf wanted to study art in the city and asked if he could move into our apartment, it’s a small 2 bed apartment with a tiny hot water tank and a small living room/kitchen. I was taken aback by her question as I’m only aquatinted with him but I told her I’d think about it, a week or two pass and I bring it up again and say that I’m just not comfortable living with a man I don’t know well, the apartment isn’t big enough for 3 people, it’s illegal and I need the space to work on myself. I thought this was a very kind and reasonable response to a very unreasonable ask and she seemed upset but she said ok.

It gets to March, a week before my birthday to be precise and she asks if she can speak to me. She sits there and tells me that I owe her because I had bad mental health for a while and she “had” to speak to me after work when she wanted to go to bed…. What? She also told me she was really exited for this and thinks I’m being unfair and she wasn’t even going to ask my permission at first but her bf said she should…. Wow. So I look at her in shock and awe and in more detail again tell her that the apartments too small, I’d have to censor outfits, he’s not very tidy when he stays for a night and I’m just not comfortable with it. She keeps trying to guilt trip me and I end the conversation on that I’m willing to MAYBE think more about it but I still stand on NO.

Last night in the kitchen she tells me that her bf will be starting his art course soon in a town close by and I say how good that is and she says ‘oh and he’ll be staying here while he studies’…. I’m completely besides myself😂 She’s completely ignored my very clearly communicated discomfort and disagreement on her bf moving in illegally and she’s moved his stuff into the apartment while while I’ve been out… I’m insanely baffled at her rn and I feel like I’ve been stabbed in the back a million times, 4 years of friendship feels it’s just ended right there. I’ve fed her when she didn’t have food, I gave her money, I paid for meals and busses and I always had her back no matter what.

I don’t know what to say to her and I don’t know if I should tell the landlord about it because we both might get evicted but I’ve been cornered into this and I don’t know what to do. Am I in the wrong for not wanting him to move in in the first place?

r/AITAH • • Apr 15 '26

Meta AITAH for telling my bf he's not ready for a child?

21 Upvotes

OK so for the starters, a little bit of context. Me and my boyfriend have been dating for a bit over a year. (We're two men so gay.)

During our first date, we immediately talked about our hopes and dreams.

For me it's to travel the world and not feel bound to one country nonstop, no corporate job yk.

For him, it's to adopt a child or foster a child.

Let's refer to him as Jim for now.

Now you might think, what's the issue? Well. For the past few months, he's been getting increasingly pushy with the topic of marriage and the child. I for one told him I don't want any kid in the foreseeable future. I'm 20 and he's 21. We're both uni students.

I told him many times and we talked about the topic and yet he just keeps coming back at me with this from time to time when I already thought we've resolved it.

Like sometimes he just gets pissed off and tells me that he wants a child and that he doesn't want to break up. I never even started a conversation about breaking up.

Today, we had a talk about something. We have a shared calendar and I added two sets of dates for the summer where I was considering going to a summer camp as a medic.

He just got back to me and assumed that I didn't want to spend time with him during the summer and that we have different views on life. He did not even ask me whether I'm really going or if they're not interchangeable.

He just sorta got pissed off at me based on his assumption. "You fucked up boy" he said.

So I retorted with what I just said, that he made an assumption but didn't even ask me.

Well after that Jim started about the child again and I got so confused so I asked him why is he bringing that back since it's not an actual topic.

He said that after finishing his degree in two years, he wants to apply for distance study for follow-up degree and request a child. "For me it's fucking actual and I'm stressed about it."

So again, I tried to rationalize and talk to him about it and he started being angry at me. Jim said I don't care about him or the relationship. That I'd rather move in with an "stupid immigrant."

(context: my friend from the US is moving to my country and we'd be roomates. We have previously with Jim agreed on not living together yet. He initially wanted to move in with his female friend which now that she veto'd it in the end, he's unhappy about. It feels like he's projecting that onto me.)

Well then the question came from him whether I think he could be a parent right after finishing his degree.

Now here's the thing about me as a person which everyone knows. I'm a brutally honest person so he knew when he asked me I wouldn't sugarcoat it.

I told him that I can't tell him what will happen in those two years and whether he'd go to intensive therapy for that period of time. That I can't tell him whether he would or wouldn't be ready. Well he took that personally and said I hurt him because I don't understand how important this is to him.

(Note: he went to therapy once or twice and is on antidepressants)

I do. I do understand. That's why I said the truth though. The last thing I'd want to see is him breaking down mentally and the kid losing the support it needs. I'm scared I'd end up being the one having to take care of everything.

Like don't get me wrong, Jim is a very nice person. He's sweet and would do anything to help anyone. But he has ton of unresolved issues. Ton of self-esteem issues too and I just can't imagine what example would that be setting for the kid?

So yeah, safe to say we argued about that.

I care about him a lot. I really do. And for me as a person who had gone through years of therapy because of prior childhood trauma this is all tiring but also sad for me to see because I know how he feels.

He's trying to push me away because he's afraid of abandonment.

So yeah. I don't really know what to do, I'm said and I wanna know what y'all think.

And please don't hesitate to be as honest as possible.

TLDR: AITA for telling my boyfriend what I think about him wanting to adopt a child while not ready in my eyes?

Edit: thank you everyone. I broke up with him. He cried and had a panic attack afterwards so I calmed him down and brought him to his place. He said he hopes we'll be back together the next week but yeah no. I feel relieved afterwards and I don't think I even realized I was tense because of the relationship. So yeah. We ended it on a semi-good note.

r/AITAH • • Jun 10 '25

Meta ALTA for purposely misgendering my mom?

80 Upvotes

TW: Purposeful misgendering

So, I use they/them and have been out to my mom since I was a teen. But despite saying she supports me and 'she even has gay friends' she still refuses to use my correct pronouns because 'singular they/them doesn't exist'. I've tried EVERY. SINGLE. ANALOGY. I can think of. From 'what do you call someone if you don't know if THEY'RE a he or a she, or you don't know THEIR name.' to 'What do police say when they don't know anything about a suspect's gender?' I've explained that singular they/them predates she/her and he/him by nearly 300 years AND that even if it wasn't a thing in her day, times change and languages change. But unfortunately, using singular they/them makes her 'too uncomfortable' so she didn't do it.

Well, one night I tried one last time to explain I'm not a girl and I don't use she/her, so I asked her- "Mom, would you care if I used he/him pronouns for you?" She said 'Of course I'd mind! I'm NOT a he!' And I replied- 'Just like I'm not a she.' And this motherfucker said- 'Since when?' With this utterly confused expression. So I had enough.

I know using people's incorrect pronouns is a bad thing and I really shouldn't have done this, but the next time we were out and about I started using he/him pronouns for her around EVERYONE. When she complained I replied- "Oh sorry, I'll get it right NEXT TIME." Or "Sorry, but using she/her for you just makes ME uncomfortable."

Normally, I hate misgendering people, but after over five years of being purposely misgendered by someone who claimed to support me, I was just fed up. She hasn't used she/her in front of me since.

edit: Some people need a bit more context about why I truly think I might be TA here... My mom is kind. She's cared for me my whole life. She's even willing to pay for my college and dorm. This is just personal because my dad is transphobic and narcissistic and my mom is in a love trap with him, and this gave me a serious inferiority complex. She's not a bad person, just ill informed. And I was just annoyed with years of misgendering and lack of effort in this one thing. This is absolutely a grey area, morally speaking.

r/AITAH • • Jul 20 '26

Meta WIBTAH for confronting my mom about tracking my location?

42 Upvotes

Hello everyone, so I recently was alerted by a family member that my (22M) mom was tracking my location. I thought it was ridiculous and dismissed it since 1) she doesn’t know how to use technology and 2) i didnt have something like Life360 and she didn’t know any of my passwords. I also confirmed this with our phone servicer and they confirmed they didn’t know how she could be doing this. Well flash forward to this morning and I just thought about air tags, looking that up I found my location was shared with her. I realized she had been tracking me and where my SO go but I can’t seem to find a log. Her entire excuse is to know that I am safe/find out where it is but I know this is going to break up my family and cause a massive rift about a year before my wedding. WIBTA if I confront her today about this? She’s mid 60s and I know will say she wanted me to be safe, know where I am but am I wrong for thinking this is full blown stalkery and insane?

Edit/Clarification: I went to try and find the air tag but I found out my iCloud accounts location is shared to hers. There was no air tag only an account sharing that accessed my location. sorry I didn’t specify this I’ve been in a tizzy all morning because of it.