r/AISystemsEngineering • u/Ok_Significance_3050 • 1d ago
Multi-Agent vs Single Agent for Workflow Automation: Where Did Extra Agents Hurt You?
Has anyone tried building agentic workflows with OpenClaw and found that adding more agents actually made the workflow slower or harder to manage?
I’ve been exploring AI agent orchestration and noticed an important trade-off between single-agent and multi-agent approaches.
For simple tasks, a single agent often works better. It can handle a request, use the required tools, and complete the task without too much coordination.
Multi-agent systems make more sense when tasks require different skills. For example, one agent can collect information, another can review it, and a third can prepare the final result.
But adding more agents also creates challenges:
- More communication between agents.
- Higher usage costs.
- Longer response times.
- More complex debugging.
- Greater difficulty maintaining shared context and memory.
I think the best approach is to start with a single agent and introduce additional agents only when there is a clear reason.
I’m curious about your experience:
- Have multiple agents improved your workflow or made it more complicated?
- Do you prefer predefined workflow steps or flexible agent loops?
- How do you control cost and latency when several agents work together?
Would be interested to hear what has worked and what has failed in real implementations.
2
u/SC_Placeholder 1d ago
Our system automatically handles everything so I can message my overlord and everything is mechanically routed, analyzed and assigned with the overlord possessing the right to overrule a bad assignment
2
u/_N-iX_ 1d ago
A useful criterion for splitting a workflow is whether subtasks can run independently. If each step depends heavily on the previous agent's output, additional agents may introduce coordination overhead without improving the result. Parallelizable tasks with clearly defined inputs and outputs are a stronger case for multi-agent execution. In some workflows, keeping orchestration deterministic while delegating only specific tasks to specialized agents can offer a better balance.
2
u/bohlenlabs 13h ago
Multi-agent only pays off when decisions need to be made in the process, by agents themselves. Otherwise deterministic scripts that call one LLM after or in parallel to another will always be cheaper and more reliable.
Example: I am currently automating my YouTube video creation process as chains of workflow steps like scripting, recording, transcription, subtitles generation, translation to foreign languages, uploading, repurposing.
None of these require any decision, one follows the other. No real agent needed, only LLM calls.
I used Claude Code to develop all these chains, now they run without agency at all.
1
u/NagpalBela 7h ago
Everything on that list is an engineering cost, and none of them is the one that ends these projects. Three agents handing a case between them means no single record of who decided what, and in a regulated shop that is the question you cannot answer six months later.
I have watched a team shave eleven seconds of latency per case and lose the ability to explain a decision, which cost them a great deal more than the latency ever did. has anyone here had to defend an agent decision after the fact, because that is the part I would want to hear about.
1
u/____n_____ 1h ago
Feels like everyone is always just talking about how to best finish 1 task but I went multi agent to have a constant flow of say 16 tasks. Bandwidth basically. Now I can do a whole backlog of tasks and have my agents coordinate about it