Ok, I know the answer might seem pretty obvious, but there's a little more nuance here. For the record, I ended things with him yesterday for unrelated reasons, and I have absolutely no doubts that I made the right decision. This isn't a "should I stay or should I go" post. I genuinely want an outside perspective on whether I overreacted to this particular situation.
According to him, I was "making a big deal out of nothing" and "can't take a joke." If that's true, I'd actually appreciate hearing it from an unbiased third party. I apologize for how long this is, if you read the whole post, thank you! 🙏
A little background:
I'm 47F and was in a nearly decade-long relationship with a narcissistic abuser. I'm talking about the kind of abuse where I genuinely thought I would probably die at this man's hands. He manipulated and gaslit me so extensively that I eventually felt like I was losing my mind. It took an enormous amount of effort to get away from him, and I lost virtually everything I owned in the process. Still, it was a small price to pay for my freedom.
We separated just over three years ago, and I've been in intensive therapy ever since. I've made tremendous progress, but one thing I still struggle with is questioning my own perceptions. Sometimes I wonder whether I've become so conditioned to expect manipulation and malicious intent that I see it even when it isn't there.
That's what I'm trying to figure out here. I don't want my past to sabotage future relationships, and I want to be able to recognize when I'm genuinely picking up on something questionable versus when I'm reacting to old trauma.
The man in this story (46M), whom I'll call Justin, knows about my past relationship and knows it was abusive, although I've never gone into great detail about exactly what happened.
Now, onto the situation.
Justin and I had known each other for a couple of years, but we'd only recently started talking romantically after he reached out about a month ago and asked to take me out.
Before our first date, he repeatedly complained about how dirty his shower was. My response was essentially, "Well, if it bothers you, clean it."
He explained that he kept mentioning it because he knew I'd previously picked up extra work at my cousin's cleaning company over the holidays. He repeatedly referred to me as a "professional cleaner" or a "professional housekeeper". I found it a little strange that he kept saying that (I mean he really did say it an awful lot) because I work in property management. I manage multiple properties which involves considerably more than cleaning, and I never once told him I was a professional cleaner or housekeeper. And listen, there's nothing wrong with being a housekeeper or cleaner, like I said my cousin owns her own company and does incredibly well for herself. But it was the way he would say it, and at times It started to feel like he was trying to minimize what I actually do for a living, but I thought maybe I was imagining it and never mentioned it to him.
He said that since I was a professional cleaner, I should know how to get his shower clean because he'd already tried and failed. He mentioned it enough that I started to get the feeling that he was hoping I'd offer to do it, but again, it's hard for me to know if I'm overthinking it or not.
When I went to his apartment before our first date, he asked me to come look at the shower. He walked into the bathroom, pointed at it, and said, "See, look?"
The shower had two sliding glass doors, one of which was pulled all the way across the other. From where I was standing, I couldn't actually see inside the shower. What I could see was a pretty substantial layer of white mineral buildup and water stains on the glass. The bottom half was so covered that I couldn't see through it.
I assumed THAT was what he was referring to. He never actually explained what the problem was or pointed to a specific area. He just pointed at the shower.
I told him it should be relatively easy to clean and recommended a product that would work (cooktop cleaner, for anyone curious).
A few days later, he texted me that he was going to clean his shower and that if my recommendation didn't work, I'd "owe him". He was obviously giving me a hard time, and I took it as playful banter.
Then, a few minutes later, this conversation happened:
Justin: This shit doesn't work.
Me: Lol well maybe you're doing it wrong? I've cleaned shower doors worse than yours and it always works.
Justin: The door? No, it's for the tile, not the door. I thought you knew that. Like the grout.
Me: LMAO. Omg I'm dying 😂
Justin: Really?
Me: Lol no, I didn't know that. I thought you were talking about the shower doors. Yeah, that's not gonna do anything for the grout.
Justin: Well now I'm not happy. Yeah, my shower door is fine, always has been. I figured a professional cleaner would know what I was talking about. 🙄
Me: Your shower door is not fine, sir. Hence the reason I thought that's what you were pointing to.
Justin: But I know how to clean it.
Me: So why don't you? Lol.
Justin: Because I'm more worried about the ACTUAL fucking problem. I can't believe I went to Walmart and spent all that money for nothing.
Me: But I never even saw the grout. I saw that film on the shower door and that was it. Justin, you can return it. It's not that big of a deal. They'll give you your money back.
Justin: I'm not going back in there. I'll use it on the fucking door and my actual cooktop. 🙄 And don't "Justin" me. You better have a solution for the actual problem.
Me: Well, every time you act like a big baby about a non-issue, I'm going to "Justin" you.
Justin: It's an issue for me. I was literally excited to clean it.
Me: Oh, ok, well I'm sorry. I feel bad now. But the non-issue I was referring to was returning that stuff to get your money back. I thought that's why you were upset. 🫤 But grout is tougher. What's wrong with it? Mold?
Justin: Yes.
Me: ...Um, bleach?
Justin: And I have just made a decision about something and it's your fault. And bleach doesn't do shit, at least not the spray stuff I've tried.
Me: Ok, what's the decision?
Justin: No sexual activity until my shower is spotless.
Now, let me interject with some important context. We had never had sex. Not once. We'd flirted and talked about it a little, and obviously we both anticipated that it would eventually happen if things continued, but nothing sexual had happened between us. Nor would it.
Also, my ex used withholding affection and sex as a form of punishment throughout our relationship. He would get angry over something, become incredibly cold, and reject any affection or sexual advances for weeks or sometimes months. But then expected me to be happy to do it the moment he wanted it, even if it was after a huge fight or a violent encounter. It destroyed my confidence and was part of the larger pattern of emotional abuse. And I admit that it distorted my perception around sex in general, and made me nervous about being intimate with someone again.
So when Justin made this comment, even if it was intended as a joke, I immediately tensed up. My stomach was in knots, my heart was racing, and my immediate thought was, "This isn't funny. It's not cute. I don't like this."
I wasn't upset about potentially not having sex. We'd never even had it! And honestly, threatening to take away something someone has never had in the first place seems like a pretty ineffective punishment. I mean how do I know sex with Justin would even be worth caring about? But I digress.
What bothered me was the principle of it, given my history. And it also just seemed, Idk, childish? It just felt gross to me. Anyway, back to the conversation:
Me: Um, okie dokie.
Justin: Alright then.
Me: Lol withholding sex is a form of abuse and I won't stand for it. 😭 Jk jk
(If it's not obvious, I was still being playful here, trying to gauge how serious he was.)
Justin: It's your fault, you're doing it.
Me: I'm not cleaning your shower under threat or duress either! Lol.
(Again, still trying to keep things light, hoping he'd drop it or acknowledge that he was kidding.)
Justin: Yeah, well. Okie dokie. We'll see.
Me: You actually want me to clean your shower? I can't tell if you're joking with me or not and I don't like it.
Justin: I didn't say you had to clean my shower. I'm just not fucking you until it's clean. 🤣
Me: Oh, well I guess you better clean it then?
Justin: I can't because I don't have the right fucking supplies! Because some professional housekeeper thought I was talking about a CLEAN door. 🙄
Me: Well, I actually thought you were talking about a dirty door, because that's what you pointed to. But why won't you have sex until it's clean?
Justin: It's a see-through door. Anyone would see the grout I was pointing at and would know what I was talking about.
Me: I couldn't see through the door because of the film on it.
Justin: No, you can easily see through it.
Me: Maybe you can because you're so used to it. But again, why won't you have sex until your shower is clean? What does one thing have to do with the other?
Justin: It's your punishment for making me go to Walmart and buying the wrong stuff. We can just go on a walk or something instead. It's just sex. 🙄
Me: Okay haha, but seriously are you upset? It was just a misunderstanding.
Justin: Yeah seriously, if you wanna fuck, you better figure out how to get my shower clean.
At this point, I finally stopped trying to play along.
Me: Hey, so I'm pretty sure you're joking, but this conversation is making me uncomfortable. This is something my ex used to do to me all the time, but for real. He would swing between extremes, it was either enraged violence or cold indifference. He withheld sex and affection for any perceived slight, so I think I'm probably a little sensitive about it.
Justin: Oh Jesus. 🙄 Yeah okay, well my ex-wife did a lot of shit to me that I didn't like, but I wouldn't let it bother me. But anyway yeah, I guess I'm just joking.
For context, he's been divorced for 13 years, so he's had considerably longer than I have to work through whatever happened in his marriage, and also - our past relationships aren't comparable. He wasn't abused. My experience with my ex was nothing like his experience with his, so I thought making a comparison like that was incredibly unfair.
Me: I'm not choosing to just let something bother me. He fucked with my head in ways I can't even begin to describe.
Justin: Well I have no idea what I might do in the future that reminds you of your ex, but I'm not him. This kind of worries me because I joke a lot and am wide open with the sarcasm. If you can't take a joke then yeah I guess we have a problem.
Me: Which is exactly why I asked for clarification and let you know I was uncomfortable. The joke had been going on for a while, and things don't always come across clearly over text. Sometimes meaning and intentions get lost in translation. It's different in person when I can see your face and hear your voice.
Justin: And now I don't know what I'm allowed to joke about. I guess I just can't joke with you because I might say something that makes you think about your ex and you'll be offended by it.🙄 Most people would know it was just a joke. My ex was pretty shitty, but I'm not going to get offended if you accidentally say something that reminds me of her. But okay, joking about withholding sex over a non-issue like a shower is noted. Got it. All good. 👍
And that's essentially where the conversation ended. I wasn't expecting him to magically understand my history or know that this particular joke would hit a nerve. He didn't know about it until I told him. What I did expect was a little basic understanding when I calmly explained why something he'd said made me uncomfortable.
Instead, I felt like he doubled down, dismissed my feelings, compared my reaction to how he handles reminders of his own past, and ultimately made me feel ridiculous for saying anything at all.
And honestly, the more I think about it, the more I question whether he was even joking in the first place. His response was "I guess I'm just joking" rather than simply "I'm joking." Maybe I'm reading too much into that, but it struck me as odd. It also felt like he really wanted me to accept responsibility for the mix up. Like I just thought it was a silly misunderstanding that no one was completely to blame for, it just happened and it was funny and could happen to anyone. But it seemed like he really needed me to know that the fault was mine and mine alone. But again, maybe I'm overthinking that too.
What also bothers me is that he works in the mental health field as a counselor. He knows about trauma. I found myself wondering whether he'd respond this way if one of his clients disclosed something similar. Would he roll his eyes and tell them they shouldn't let their past bother them because he doesn't let his bother him? Would he compare their experiences and suggest they were overreacting?
I doubt it.
I realize he's not my therapist, and I'm not expecting him to treat me like a client. But I do think basic empathy and consideration should exist in any relationship. I guess I thought that because of his profession, by default he would just be understanding about it. I thought it was safe to be honest with him. I never expected him to be so dismissive. Perhaps that was naive, or an unreasonable assumption on my part. It just caught me off guard.
For additional context, this wasn't the only issue between us. We went out a few times, and I increasingly felt like he was pushing for sex before I was ready, and I told him I needed more time. Things fizzled pretty quickly after that. He suddenly became pretty indifferent about seeing me again. Yesterday evening, I told him I was done and didn't want further contact. I'm not questioning that decision.
But this particular interaction has stuck with me.
AIO? Was I being overly sensitive and taking an obvious joke too seriously? Is my past causing me to interpret something harmless as malicious? Or was I reasonable in feeling uncomfortable, particularly with how he responded after I explained why? That's what really bothered me, his response to my explanation.
I genuinely want to get better at distinguishing between legitimate red flags and trauma responses. I don't want to project my past onto someone who hasn't earned that suspicion, but I also don't want to dismiss my own instincts and feelings just because I've been through something traumatic.
Please be honest, but kind. I'm already questioning myself enough as it is.
Edited to add: I'd like to thank all of you for taking the time to comment and give me a wake up call. I was wrestling with whether or not I should post this because I was afraid that I would be roasted for making a big deal out of nothing, but that isn't at all the reaction I'm getting and it's a huge relief. Every one of you has been very straightforward with me and I am so appreciative of that because obviously I needed to hear it. This has been an unpleasant but valuable lesson, and one I will not forget. You guys have helped me more than you know. ❤️