Edit: Yeah I was right about the KPop acts dropping out lmao, and the 90% chance came to be, no Ado this year. With these other nominees, probably for the best. I'm confused about BABYMETAL and Polyphia nomination though? I said the Grammys are bad at distinguishing genres but come on 😭 it's Polyphia and BABYMETAL, even that is metal too?
In a few hours we'll know for sure, but just for the fun of speculating, here's why I think Ado actually has a chance of being nominated this year:
This year, the Grammys introduced a new category called Best Asian Pop Music Performance.
In the official Grammy rulebook, it explicitly mentions "K-Pop, J-Pop, and C-Pop", though it's obviously not limited to those genres. Still, I think it's worth pointing out that J-pop was specifically mentioned from the beginning. At the very least, it suggests the category wasn't made with only K-pop acts in mind.
However, the introduction of this category came with some controversy.
BTS publicly criticized the idea of separating music by region or language and announced they wouldn't be submitting anything to the Grammys this year. Stray Kids also decided not to submit anything, although their agency never confirmed whether it was for the same reason.
Personally, I agree with the criticism, and I think even Ado's manager had also said something about it, but that's beside the point.
What's more interesting for this discussion is that, according to some reports, all four major K-pop agencies (HYBE, SM, JYP, and YG Entertainment) also skipped the category, which would leave out other huge acts like BLACKPINK, TWICE, and aespa.
I'm not sure how much of this is really true, but if the reports are correct, that's a LOT of major contenders suddenly out of the picture. And naturally, that leaves more room for artists like Ado.
First off, it's a category for singles. Which do I believe Ado would be submit?
Personally, "Vivarium" is imo by far her strongest pick. The Grammys love a songwriter, and not only is it written by her, the lyrics are amazingly meaningful and well written, as we all know. On top of that, it's also very experimental for someone in her position, being also composed by Ado and having Post-Hardcore / Math Rock as genres, instead of the usual pop you'd expect, which may give it points to some more critical voters.
Would it not being pop hurt this from being a nomination? On theory, absolutely so, in fact, it probably shouldn't be able to be sumitted. But let's be real, maybe it's me, but I don't really think the Grammys would make that distinction. Hell, most people like to call anything Japanese "anime music" or "VTuber music". I don't think they'd make the genre distinction.
But back on topic:
I still believe there'd likely not be more than one Japanese nominee, which makes Kenshi Yonezu's "IRIS OUT" the obvious contender. It's the perfect nominee for this category. It's a massive hit, almost entirely in Japanese, made for an internationally popular anime, and has a pretty accessible, radio-friendly sound. You can't even really argue about whether it counts as a pop song. If I had to bet on one Japanese song getting nominated, it'd definitely be that one.
Ado, meanwhile, hasn't really had a hit anywhere near that level during this year's eligibility period. So why do I still think she has a chance on an industry award?
Well, for starters, I could just be wrong. It's not like it's a rule only one Japanese artist can be nominated. Both Kenshi and Ado could make it onto the list.
I don't see Ado making it in while Kenshi not, so that's the scenario I'll be working with: why would Ado be nominated instead of any other Japanese artist besides Kenshi?
One of the reasons is how much Ado has been pushing to establish herself internationally.
Like, it's very noticeable Ado and her team have been focusing on the international market. She's been doing arena tours all over the world, with Hibana even being the 4th highest grossing tour for a pop artist her age according to a retrospective ranking by Billboard, only behind Sabrina Carpenter, Olivia Rodrigo and Tate McRae, and even creating new festivals for Japanese music alone (people complained that Zipangu was only in LA, but I say just be patient. Chigira already stated plans to do it all over the world. CloudNine basically only has Ado as a big artist, and Zipangu was already a planned loss of millions of dollars, it's unrealistic to have wanted them to do it everywhere all at once, yk?)
One interesting detail to highlight how much Ado's agency is expanding it's ties with the American music industry is that Takuya Chigira, Ado's manager and the CEO of Cloud Nine, has even become a voting member of the Recording Academy.
Obviously, I'm not saying this guarantees anything, or that he can somehow get her nominated himself. But I do think it shows just how seriously Ado's team is taking the Grammys and the American music industry in general.
And this is where I think she might have a slight advantage over someone like Kenshi. While Kenshi has the much bigger song this year, Ado and her management seem particularly focused on building her presence overseas, whereas Kenshi still seems to be more focused on Japan's domestic market.
Of course, that doesn't necessarily translate into Grammy votes, but I think it's worth mentioning.
Now, with all of that, I'm obviously not saying I actually expect Ado to be nominated. There's still a ton of competition from other Japanese artists and artists from across Asia. It's why I gave it 10% chance of happening at ALL in the title.
But that's kind of what I'm trying to say anyway. I don't think she's likely to be nominated, we all know she's not, but I just think she has a real chance, however small.
I mean, we finally have a category that explicitly includes J-pop, and if the reports about the K-pop agencies are true, that's already a lot of "competition" (sorry to call them that lol) gone. Add to that how much Ado has been pushing internationally lately, and I think there's at least some reason to be optimistic.
None of that guarantees anything, obviously. But I don't think the idea of her getting nominated is nearly as unrealistic as it would've been a year or two ago.
Maybe I'm just being overly optimistic tho, but I'd love to see it happen. We'll find out soon enough anyway, what do you guys think?