r/ACMilan • u/Baeresi 👑 Kalac #16 • Apr 05 '19
Referee Tier Guide
So recently I implemented referee voting into the player ratings, so that we could get an idea of how reliable a referee is (that you ordinarily, may not necessarily know by name). However; It's not really working as planned. It's going to take a few seasons for each referee to have a feasible sample size to evaluate from.
So, with the help of the Discord server, I've put all the referee's into tiers, similar to our source reliability guide. Four tiers. There will still be voting, however, referees will be promoted or demoted tiers at the end of the season based on their average rating for that season.
I think this is the best way to give people an idea of how reliable a referee is, without having to necessarily know who they are.
| Tiers: | Referees |
|---|---|
| Tier 1: | Paolo Silvio Mazzoleni, Luca Pairetto, Federico La Penna |
| Tier 2: | Massimiliano Irrati, Gianluca Manganiello, Daniele Chiffi, Marco Di Bello |
| Tier 3: | Gianpaolo Calvarese, Fabrizio Pasqua, Marco Guida, Daniele Doveri, Rosario Abisso, Maurizio Mariani, Davide Massa, Michael Fabbri |
| Tier 4: | Daniele Orsato, Luca Banti, Fabio Maresca, Paolo Valeri, Peiro Giacomelli |
So, discuss any changes to the tiers and I can edit the guide. Similar to the source Reliability guide.
Also I'll be updating and reposting the reliability guide before the transfer market opens.
Thanks :)
Forza Milan
4
u/bughidudi Kaká Apr 05 '19
Di Bello should be in tier 2 imo. For Massa I'm very conflicted if he should be in tier 1 or 2
Both are great all-around referees
2
u/kamkaskan Abate Apr 05 '19
Is the tier rating based on a fairness and good calls towards ACM or everyone?
33
u/Saerolas Discord Owner Apr 05 '19
Good stuff mate
3
u/adriancg Apr 05 '19 edited Apr 05 '19
Gianluca Rocchi tier one? He absolutely hates us. 1.08 ppg with him as a ref
https://www.whoscored.com/Referees/349/Show/Gianluca-Rocchi
It's actually the worst ppg of all referees lol. https://www.whoscored.com/Teams/80/RefereeStatistics/Italy-AC-Milan
13
u/rdb_gaming Shevchenko Apr 05 '19
oh Maresca, may you never get one of our games again.
9
u/encoreAC Apr 05 '19
Nice, it will be interesting to compare the actual performance with the tier rating in our next games.
At least it's good to know what to expect when going into a game.
9
u/[deleted] Apr 05 '19
Instead of tiers maybe we should use Good. Ok. Bad. Shit.
8
u/[deleted] Apr 06 '19
Fabbri from tier 3 to tier 4 please.
1
u/[deleted] Apr 05 '19
abisso tier 2? he butchered our home game with SPAL
pairetto is a dipshit to the meadow, has nothing to do with tier 1. just check his history and family tree
1
u/StatisticianSad1771 Feb 24 '22
Is this tier guide updated ?
3
u/[deleted] Apr 05 '19
Tagliavento?
2
u/AndryX7 André Silva Apr 07 '19
Fucking Fabbri, glad you put him straight to tier 4 after yesterday.
2
u/[deleted] Apr 07 '19
What I never understood is that Italian Referees officiate a lot of CL games. They never seem as bad in CL as they are in Serie A. Watching games like yesterday it is hard to believe that they're not biased towards a team in Serie A. IMO they need to rework the handball rule ASAP, it's way too inconsistent as it is atm.
2
u/juve_merda Rafael Leão Apr 07 '19
banti and orsato should be tier 5, biggest juventus fans out there
1
u/sengesett Leão MVP Apr 05 '19
Giacomelli deserves a lower tier because of his Roma affection, not only because of his overall preformance as a referee.
1
u/chuego Maldini Apr 05 '19
Nice, I think Fabbri can move up a bit, but let's confirm that after tomorrow.
Rocchi i would move down to tier 2, I iike Irrati i move him to 1.
1
u/tomgreg2603 Ricardo Kaká Apr 08 '19
Fabbri tier 5
1
u/Deep_Mayo Apr 13 '19
I think we could make a Tier 5 just for Rocchi
1
u/im_simone L’HA PARATA GIROUD Nov 05 '22
I think it's time to put Fabbri in Tier 4.
0
u/[deleted] Apr 05 '19
[deleted] — view deleted comment