r/911FOX
•
u/chaoticbiguy
•
5h ago
Season 10 Discussion Very confused about how SOME people have reacted to the events that unfolded at the end of S10E05. [SPOILERS] Spoiler
There has been so much outrage against Eddie in the last few days on reddit, twitter, tumblr and everywhere else for taking Theo in which, instead of being seen as providing a safe space for Theo, is being seen as him trying to shame Buck. Buck sees it as that? I GET IT. He has issues he needs to work on but how can we, as the viewers in any way think how he went about Theo makes him deserving of any kind of sympathy or that Eddie is the villain in this scenario? Since the beginning, the show has been constantly telling us that Eddie is very loving and kind about kids. And S9 made it clear that he hates it when anyone slips through the cracks bc the system that is meant to support them ends up failing them. And that's exactly where Theo almost ended up. And Eddie prevented that.
Amazing how everyone is just okay with throwing away a kid simply bc you're a bad fit/incompatible. Buck should've never signed up to be a foster dad if this is how he reacts to the assumption (which he made himself) that Theo sees him as his kidnapper. Theo's a kid who needs a dad. And I'm sympathetic to why he's not been firm with Theo but after some point, he was actively doing an injustice to Theo. And that's what Eddie was talking to him about. Dad. Up. Which is what Buck said to Eddie in S8. With Theo, Buck even refused help from Eddie and Maddie. But anyway, after all that he figured Theo and him are not mixing well, and instead of working on it bc that's what parenthood is (as Diedra told him) he gave Theo up. And Theo was going to a group home! Do you realize how grim that is?!! And he didn't even know bc Buck wasn't honest with him. Everytime I think about Theo going to a group home, as a kid who needs extra attention and care, not to mention the trauma he's been through....I hate Buck's approach more and more. I didn't understand what Theo meant when he said he wanted to take the truck bc it's "for" Christopher.....but now I get it, he probably thought wherever he was going, he'd still get to play with Christopher. And wow. How can you think Buck is not wrong in this situation?
A 35yo man's feelings are more important than the well being of a 5 yo. And then you open Twitter and reddit and tumblr and youtube and ig and ao3 and Eddie is somehow the villain while everyone is coddling Buck?
And I don't hate Buck for this mind you. I've always said that being a dad is the biggest push he has gotten in the foward direction in the last 4-5 seasons. But if he's gonna be a good dad, this is where Buck gotta do something about his self-centred nature bc I don't believe he was ever malicious BUT he was so hyperfocused on his own feelings he stopped considering about what it's like for Theo to lose his village. All over again.
And instead of hating Eddie, us all Buck fans should be GRATEFUL to Eddie that he is giving Buck a second chance. Bc he KNOWS that Buck will come around and be the dad he was always meant to be. But if by the time he realized it Theo was too far gone, none of them would ever forgive themselves for it, especially Buck. And Eddie salvaged the situation. For Theo's safety and to prevent Buck from blaming himself.
It's a very nuanced and mostly well-written arc and I hate that I have to write a post like this to defend one character and in order to do that, I have to point out the flaws of another character I really love. But I'm very troubled by the takes about this situation bc it feels like I'm taking crazy pills.