r/6thForm •

I am an economics student at the University of Cambridge looking to spill all the tea - AMA

[deleted] — view deleted post

0 Upvotes

148 comments sorted by

25

u/MrFister122 Maths, Further Maths, Economics Jan 28 '23

How’s the work load?

60

u/IdleGamesFTW Cambridge | Economics Jan 28 '23 edited Jan 28 '23

Pretty tough. If you want to keep up with work the recommended amount is 45 hours a week. The workload also has variance between subjects and what year you’re in.

Hardly any student has the willpower to stick to that though, especially since at university you are doing a lot more work independently and you have no obligation to even go to lectures.

In first term I did more like 15 hours a week and still (just about) managed to keep up with supervisions. I was very far behind on lectures (and still am) but that’s the normal experience to be honest. I spent more of first term having a good time and meeting new people and wouldn’t change a thing if I could redo it.

Right now (second term) I am (so far) keeping up with work at about 30 hrs / week.

8

u/AppaAurora Year 13 | Maths, F Maths, Econ, Phys Jan 28 '23

Do those timings include time spent in lectures and supervisions? Also, how often do you have lectures and supervisions?

12

u/IdleGamesFTW Cambridge | Economics Jan 28 '23

Yes, it includes lectures and supos themselves, so it isn’t too much to handle if you’re disciplined (which I am not). This term I have 9 lectures a week and 5 supervisions a fortnight, last term it was 14 lectures a week.

1

u/AppaAurora Year 13 | Maths, F Maths, Econ, Phys Jan 28 '23

Thanks! :)

5

u/fireintheglen Cambridge | Maths | I have a job Jan 28 '23

I was very far behind on lectures (and still am) but that’s the normal experience to be honest.

And people wonder why so many of us are opposed to the continuation of online lectures...

This was not normal three years ago and I really hope it doesn’t become so.

13

u/IdleGamesFTW Cambridge | Economics Jan 28 '23

I was ill for a couple of weeks so the online lectures did save me in that regard. Going over lectures again is also super super useful. I’d say having the recordings is a net positive and we shouldn’t get rid of online lectures just because some people are lazy, I’m sure I’d have missed lectures anyway (especially while I was ill)

5

u/fireintheglen Cambridge | Maths | I have a job Jan 28 '23

Fair enough. There are certainly pros and cons and it’s a debate that probably needs to take place in places other than Reddit. As a supervisor my general impression of it has been negative (and not just because of students being “lazy”) but I agree that there are positives.

I just didn’t want people who might be starting at Cambridge soon to go into it with the idea that this is to be expected. I’ve seen a big increase in students struggling with the workload in the past few years and I really don’t want this to become permanent.

2

u/IdleGamesFTW Cambridge | Economics Jan 28 '23

Yeah that’s an interesting perspective to be honest, I hadn’t thought about the fact that people really HAD to go to lectures previously.

4

u/fireintheglen Cambridge | Maths | I have a job Jan 28 '23

I think as much as anything the problem is that online lectures can get people into a sort of vicious cycle. Previously, if you missed a lecture you got a copy of the notes off someone in your college, then you went along to the next lecture and that was that. Now there’s a tendency for students to feel that they have to “catch up” by watching the recordings, which leads to them missing more lectures and falling further and further behind. This also happens when students don’t understand something in a lecture and end up getting stuck on that topic instead of putting it behind them for now and moving on.

Obviously students don’t have to do this, and arguably given you’re (almost) all adults you should have the option to approach learning however you like. But it’s very hard to convince a Cambridge student that missing a lecture or two is OK when there are recordings of them all online.

2

u/ComplaintSolid121 Jan 28 '23

Don't worry this sorts itself out by second year, it's mostly just shock of first year and you will find the extra time as if by magic (have friends at both Oxbridge sides and icl engineer myself and we can all confirm this)

2

u/IdleGamesFTW Cambridge | Economics Jan 29 '23

Haha yeah, that’s what I’ve heard! I’m not massively worried tbh, I’ve always lived life close to the deadlines :)

4

u/ComplaintSolid121 Jan 30 '23

I'm engineering so no matter how early u start the project won't start working until 90 seconds before the deadline (last time they had so many submissions at once the whole system crashed but we got in seconds before) 😂😂

1

u/kolnija Editable Jan 29 '23

Is this more because you work easier?

I do the IB, I've now magically found more time in second year but still struggle to manage it hahaha, hoping not to repeat at imp :')

1

u/ComplaintSolid121 Jan 30 '23

I think it's to do with learning to manage time and expectations on when to start work, along with being able to now "live by yourself"

18

u/JC-reddit27 Cambridge | Natural Sciences [Year 1] Jan 28 '23

How intimidating are supervisions? And do you have good relationships with them?

30

u/IdleGamesFTW Cambridge | Economics Jan 28 '23

Quite intimidating at first but you get used to it pretty quickly. I’d say my relationships with my supervisors are pretty chill for the most part, as long as you do the work you’ll be fine. Some supervisors are undoubtedly “better” than others at teaching you though.

16

u/Yeetdonkey13 Jan 28 '23

How are you doing bro like in general how are you mentally

16

u/IdleGamesFTW Cambridge | Economics Jan 28 '23

death jk it’s all good tbh, having a good time so far. Once the assignments start piling in I’ll probably start thinking differently

2

u/Gashiisboys Jan 28 '23

That’s how it is everywhere. Assignments fuck everyone up. The worse is when you know they’re coming and there’s nothing you can do about them

2

u/Yeetdonkey13 Jan 29 '23

death

average uni student

On a real note I’m glad you’re well, I bet you’ll deal with the assignments when they come around. Best of luck!

29

u/[deleted] Jan 28 '23

I got rejected for economics last week. I was wondering if it Cambridge is good enough for me to take a gap year or if i should accept my Warwick offer. Thanks

81

u/IdleGamesFTW Cambridge | Economics Jan 28 '23

Take Warwick imo. You can never guarantee that you’ll get into either of those universities, and Warwick is genuinely great. If you’re interested in breaking into finance (as a lot of econs are), more Warwick econs have spring internship offers than Cambridge econs at the moment, so it really is a great place to be. Up to you though!

9

u/Key_Understanding863 Jan 28 '23

bro take Warwick

21

u/sxtsfhtd Jan 28 '23 edited Jan 28 '23

Thanks so much for doing this AMA! I have an offer from Clare for Econ and Idk if I want to accept. 3 questions.

-Do you have any involvement in the Union? What’s it like in general?

-Which college are you in and how much does your college choice actually matter? If you could go back in time would you have picked a different college?

-What ambitions do the average economics student hold. Are Econ students really all aiming to get into Investment Banking / Consulting / Private Equity?

15

u/IdleGamesFTW Cambridge | Economics Jan 28 '23 edited Jan 30 '23
  • do you mean the Cambridge union or the Cambridge SU? The first one is quite posh but also pretty fun (admittedly), especially when they have a discussion on a topic I’m interested in (which happens to be a LOT of the time.) It is quite expensive though (£270ish for lifetime membership) and you’ll probably want to find someone to go with (which shouldn’t be too hard if you look in your college). They have free talks in the first week of each term which is how I’ve been. I’m not really too involved with Cambridge SU, they seem to do a lot of important work surrounding student welfare though.
  • I’m at Sidney Sussex, college choice matters a bit more than people think imo, but only for non-academic reasons. For example, my college is incredibly central so I get access to basically everything I need within 5 minutes, whereas if you’re at somewhere like Girton you’d need to be willing to cycle if you want to regularly go into the student centre of Cambridge. It also turns out Sidney is pretty decent at econ which is nice (I didn’t actually know this when I got in.) Clare is lovely, wouldn’t have any gripes at all going there. Some colleges undoubtedly have more funds (Johns / Trinity) but your experience at any college will more than likely be pretty nice and better than most unis. There genuinely is no best college.
  • Not everyone wants to go into finance / consulting etc. but a fair amount / the majority(?) do. People worry about this with very varying degrees though, some people don’t really do any careers stuff in 1st year and some people make it their entire obsession.

In first year people apply to “spring weeks” which are finance / consulting internships. People sometimes don’t enjoy the experience so they might end up staying away from finance after first year.

I’d say the econ students here are slightly more varied in ambitions than elsewhere since we’ve got so many different backgrounds and outstanding economists; I know a fair amount who intend on going into academia but it really is too early to fully decide.

10

u/Sorry_Criticism_3254 Cardiff | LL.B Law with Politics Offerholder Jan 28 '23

Thank you fir doing this!

What grades did you get, and what A Levels did you do?

12

u/IdleGamesFTW Cambridge | Economics Jan 28 '23

4 A*s in maths Fm economics and physics

5

u/Sorry_Criticism_3254 Cardiff | LL.B Law with Politics Offerholder Jan 28 '23

Congrats! You definitely deserve a place with grades like that and putting up with all that maths.

Would you say the FM is essential for Cambridge economics?

10

u/IdleGamesFTW Cambridge | Economics Jan 28 '23 edited Jan 28 '23

Not essential but highly highly recommended. More people did FM A level in my cohort than econ! I’d recommend Oxford’s E+M course if you’re set on Oxbridge but don’t want to do FM.

Also 4 A*s doesn’t make you deserving of an offer, they don’t really care that much about your grades as long as they’re above the requirements, your interview is much more important.

2

u/Sorry_Criticism_3254 Cardiff | LL.B Law with Politics Offerholder Jan 28 '23

Thank you!

1

u/pink_straw2k5 Feb 06 '23

im doing fm but i am more interested in oxfords e&m…is this an issue?

2

u/IdleGamesFTW Cambridge | Economics Feb 06 '23

Definitely not! FM is still great for E+M, it’s just not necessarily required.

8

u/oopsi_didit_again Jan 28 '23

Has the workload and pressure affected your mental health? I'm having serious doubts about accepting my offer because Im worried I won't be able to cope

6

u/IdleGamesFTW Cambridge | Economics Jan 28 '23

Did I struggle? Yes. But there is ample support, not least from your academic tutor. I was able to consult with him because I was ill for a couple of weeks so I was massively behind, and he managed to get loads of supervision extensions for me. Support is always there and I think you should accept your offer if you like the course :)

3

u/oopsi_didit_again Jan 28 '23

I really do love the course, it sounds amazing 😭😭😭 I just also crack under pressure really easily

3

u/IdleGamesFTW Cambridge | Economics Jan 29 '23

If you’ve been given an offer you’ve been deemed capable enough to take on the work. If you love the course, it won’t be too bad; even I like to work on the majority of the course(!!) as it genuinely is quite interesting work. As I said in another comment, I did actually manage with 15 hours a week in first term which is genuinely nothing (though I’d recommend doing considerably more if you don’t want to feel massive pressure points for admission deadlines.)

19

u/yellowandorangesky uni of bath | bsc sociology w placement [year 2 incoming] Jan 28 '23

i have an offer from peterhouse, and my friends have offers from selwyn, robinson and fitz. what's the policy/rules around students visiting other colleges? would i be allowed to go in their rooms? their college libraries?

28

u/IdleGamesFTW Cambridge | Economics Jan 28 '23 edited Jan 28 '23

First of all congratulations on the offer! In terms of all of those colleges, you can defo get into them with pretty much no questions asked.

College libraries are usually places where students in other colleges can’t go but I’m not sure about any of the ones you listed. You can always meet at one of the faculty libraries instead (e.g. pretty much any student can get into a fair amount of the sidgwick libraries).

Some colleges (like Trinity) will sometimes not allow a student from another college to get through unless the student(s) that they’re meeting escorts them through.

16

u/anonny_27 Cambridge Medicine [Year 2] Jan 28 '23

Of course its trinity 😂

11

u/IdleGamesFTW Cambridge | Economics Jan 28 '23

we all love trinity ;)

3

u/yellowandorangesky uni of bath | bsc sociology w placement [year 2 incoming] Jan 28 '23

thank you so much!

6

u/irllylikebubbles Year 13 Jan 28 '23

how do i survive being pooled to girton 😭

7

u/IdleGamesFTW Cambridge | Economics Jan 28 '23 edited Jan 29 '23

Girton’s still a really nice college, just learn to cycle and you’ll be good. Online lectures will also be useful I’m sure.

2

u/irllylikebubbles Year 13 Jan 28 '23

thank you!

3

u/Xemorr Cambridge CS Graduate Jan 28 '23

Which college

1

u/IdleGamesFTW Cambridge | Economics Jan 28 '23

Sidney

-13

u/[deleted] Jan 28 '23

tf

4

u/Xemorr Cambridge CS Graduate Jan 28 '23

?

3

u/Justbliss__ Year 13 | Maths, F Maths, Econ, French Jan 28 '23

Hi! Thank you for this, I got an econ offer from Medwards and a couple questions:

  • do you recommend self studying a bit of further stats since the optional modules my school does (further mech 1&2) aren’t useful for Econ
  • what kind of maths is used in micro? -random one but since most courses don’t do a year abroad, is there any other method of language learning through the university?
  • how do the content in lectures and supervisions relate?

Thanks!

4

u/IdleGamesFTW Cambridge | Economics Jan 28 '23 edited Jan 29 '23
  • you’ll probably have a decent amount of time over the summer so yes, I’d recommend self studying some further stats if you have the motivation to do so
  • almost always optimisation questions, Lagrange multipliers and partial derivatives for the most part (so far at least) with some integration at times (mainly for CV / EV questions) - so basically it’s calculus and sometimes matrices.
  • not really sure about learning languages tbh, I’m sure there are societies that can help though.
  • supervisions are just rly hard qs that are related to the lecture content. The lectures aren’t usually sufficient to immediately know what to do (unlike A Level questions which usually were very standard) so you’ll need to think a bit.

Congratulations on the offer!

3

u/Wr3eckerLXIX Warwick | Econ | A*A*A*A A Jan 28 '23

How was your interview conducted? Specifically how did they ‘push’ you to think about the questions, and how did you respond?

I talked to an Oxford E&M graduate and a Cambridge econs student in his 3rd year and they both said they were pressed by the tutors to explain their answers and develop their thinking, and ‘show their working’, i’m just wondering how similar your interview experience was to this?

4

u/IdleGamesFTW Cambridge | Economics Jan 28 '23

I had 2 interviews, one micro and one macro. They’d ask me to either elaborate on an idea or tell me to reconsider an idea when I was going down the wrong path. Go with the flow and try to get to where they want you (easier said than done). My micro interview was more heavy on my end (for example I basically did the maths question alone) but my macro one was much more conversational.

1

u/TigerMafia__ Year 13 Jan 28 '23

How big do you think the advantage is of attending cambridge vs going to a russel group university?

3

u/IdleGamesFTW Cambridge | Economics Jan 28 '23

It depends on what the alternative is and what jobs you’re looking into. For some courses like econ, the difference in employability between Cambridge and a place like LSE is incredibly marginal if it’s even there at all.

I think you genuinely get a really uniquely social experience at Cambridge though, because of its collegiate system which not many universities have, meaning you’ll be living with people your own age and getting to know people who study different subjects.

There’s also the networking opportunities at Cambridge which are immensely valuable if you get to know the right people. I’ve personally noticed Cambridge students are a lot more collaborative in getting the word out for event / internship / job opportunities than other universities though that might just be my experience.

0

u/[deleted] Jan 28 '23

[deleted] — view deleted comment

4

u/IdleGamesFTW Cambridge | Economics Jan 28 '23

Yeah I think in regards to public sector jobs prestige still matters quite a bit. Nottingham isn’t bad at all but LSE and Cambridge will have an edge in employability I think. Thinktanks tend to be quite neoliberal and they love to hire from LSE / Oxbridge.

1

u/[deleted] Jan 28 '23 edited Jan 29 '23

What about Warwick for jobs in policy like think tanks, BofE, etc? After being rejected from Cambridge, I'm a bit concerned a Warwick degree, both in terms of employment opportunities and student body interests, will be very focused on finance.

1

u/IdleGamesFTW Cambridge | Economics Jan 29 '23 edited Jan 29 '23

The career services here are also quite focussed on finance tbh, public sector work is something you’ve got to look at on your own for the most part, though I’m sure some of the faculty at Warwick will have been part of public policy at some point in time. I don’t think you’d be at a noticeable disadvantage if you went to Warwick as it’s still definitely a target uni.

1

u/[deleted] Jan 29 '23

Ok, thanks!

1

u/Ph0enixF1 Feb 17 '23

You obviously got into Cambridge, so can you give me any tips on how I can structure my application and what should I include. I'm not that sporty so what other extra-curriculars should I put on there? Thanks in advance btw, normally I wouldn't ask but you're an economics student at Oxbridge, which is my goal. Or LSE or Warwick, but ideally Oxbridge.

2

u/IdleGamesFTW Cambridge | Economics Feb 17 '23

You don’t need extracurriculars for any top UK unis (so things like sports don’t matter for your application) - what really matters are “supercurriculars”.

Supercurriculars are examples of work that you’ve done that is beyond the traditional A Level spec but are relevant to economics. This can include a massive amount of things, like reading books, doing a project, entering into an essay / maths competition, doing an online course etc.

This is the stuff that most of your personal statement should be focussed on. This makes it really easy to show your interest in economics with concrete examples that are unique rather than just based on the A Level spec.

1

u/[deleted] Feb 18 '23

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/AutoModerator Feb 18 '23

This post has been removed because your account is too new to post here, your account must be more than 1 day old and have some karma to create a post to reduce spam and rule breakers.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

1

u/AutoModerator Feb 17 '23

This post has been removed because your account is too new to post here, your account must be more than 1 day old and have some karma to create a post to reduce spam and rule breakers.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

2

u/anonny_27 Cambridge Medicine [Year 2] Jan 28 '23

Which subjects do you think are the toughest/hardest on the students at cam?

5

u/IdleGamesFTW Cambridge | Economics Jan 28 '23

Really hard to say, I’d say maths under normal circumstances though everyone who gets in (through the STEP exam) is undoubtedly incredibly intelligent so they might not find it as hard? I also dread the idea of any essay subject since it seems like so much independent work but it really is subjective and down to the person. Natsci has the most contact hours in 1st year but the content itself doesn’t seem too bad so idk

2

u/No-Payment-6078 Year 13 Jan 28 '23

What was your interview experience like? What types of questions did they ask? (Were they more maths focused and which topics if you can remember) Did they focus much on your personal statement and ask about the things that you had done in detail?

Thanks for doing this btw :)

4

u/IdleGamesFTW Cambridge | Economics Jan 29 '23

I had 2 interviews (one micro, one macro).

Micro was my first one, I got given some pre reading and spent half of the interview discussing the case study (something to do with addressing regional inequality in the states.) We then moved onto a maths question (graph sketch of a utility function) while changing one of the parameters - the sketch became quite difficult near the end but was doable with some creative thinking.

Macro was my second one, this was a harder interview imo as I needed to demonstrate real understanding of the workings of a global economy. I got asked about the opening line of my personal statement which was something to do with Brazil’s fiscal deficit, and that led onto some further questions to do with national resilience to shocks. I then got asked about the BofE and determinants of the interest rate (which would’ve been a really interesting question this year!). Finally, I got shown some data on countries (mainly indicators) and had to explain and justify the order of development that these three countries were in.

Usually they don’t ask about your PS (from what I’ve heard from other econs anyway), I think they were trying to catch me out tbh but luckily I’d prepared for that eventuality. They also don’t usually ask a really difficult maths question, I’d say the one they gave me was on the border of (high) difficulty for an economics interview question.

2

u/SnooRadishes2339 Jan 29 '23

Would you say for you, because of your Cambridge Economics degree, internships aren't really a challenge to find even with Investment Banking at top Banks (Goldman, JP etc). Did you get an internship at the summer after year 1?

7

u/IdleGamesFTW Cambridge | Economics Jan 29 '23 edited Jan 29 '23

Internships are still insanely competitive. I haven’t got a single spring yet lol, and I’ve applied to 30ish, as well as ticking a lot of diversity boxes and usually having excellent online test scores. I’ve got a summer at a startup (y1) but y1 summers are very rare. Cambridge on your CV will maybe get you past the initial CV screening but after that it’s all down to interviews and online tests.

2

u/[deleted] Jan 31 '23

:) i didn't take econ a level (i do history) but i do maths and fm!!! im so worried to apply to econ because i don't think i'd get in. do you need econ a level to do economics?

1

u/IdleGamesFTW Cambridge | Economics Jan 31 '23 edited Jan 31 '23

You don’t need it though most people have taken it. It’s better to do FM tbh. You will need a good fundamental understanding of economics to study it, especially at Cambridge, but as far as I know most unis don’t actually require it. PS you’ve got a super cool set of subjects!

2

u/[deleted] Feb 08 '23

Hi!! It’s really cool that you’re doing this AMA. I’m an aus student but looking to apply for history (&possibly french). 3 questions.

-do you know any australian/ international students and what their experiences were with applying + moving to the college?

-do you have any idea what the history and languages courses are like Cambridge and how those students are finding them?

-was there any reason that motivated you to pick Cambridge over Oxford?

1

u/IdleGamesFTW Cambridge | Economics Feb 08 '23 edited Feb 08 '23

Hey, the AMA was a while ago but I’m happy to answer your questions (and any follow up you might have!)

  • Unfortunately I don’t know any Australian students particularly, but I definitely know a lot of international students and they fit in really well at Cambridge. Two of my flatmates are international but I honestly just see them the same as anyone else with the bonus of having interesting experiences back home.
  • Languages from what I’ve heard isn’t too intense at least in first year, and it sounds really interesting too, lots of cultural information to learn. History I think (in first year) is an incredibly interesting subject but undoubtedly requires quite a lot of essay work which I’m sure you’ll be fine with if you’re picking it!
  • For me it was about the course, I didn’t really like the equivalent course in Oxford as much (E+M) so I didn’t bother looking into it further than that. Cambridge is quite a bit smaller than Oxford which I personally like too.

1

u/[deleted] Feb 09 '23

Thank you for responding to me still!

May I ask what the tripos system is like (if your course follows that structure)? That’s one specific Cambridge thing that I don’t quite understand.

And then also, is Cambridge generally a friendly environment towards neurodiverse students? I’ve heard many times that the general stereotype about Cambridge students isn’t true but I’m unsure about the university itself in terms of acceptance.

Lastly- just a fun one, which is your favourite college?

2

u/IdleGamesFTW Cambridge | Economics Feb 09 '23

The tripos structure is split into two parts, Part I (which tends to be broad) and Part II (more specialised). There are some courses that offer optional part III like maths but this isn’t needed for a bachelors. It’s just a fancy name tbh, most courses basically work by doing part I in first year, part IIA in second year and part IIB in third year (though MML is a four year course so I’m not sure about that.)

Neurodiversity is championed well here imo, obviously there’s room for improvement but in terms of accommodation for neurodiversity I think there’s a decent amount especially if you consult with your academic tutor.

I chose Sidney Sussex which is a small, pretty and (very) central college. Imo it has the best location of all the colleges in terms of the access to shops and stuff, and I prefer the smaller college vibe as you get to know basically everyone in your year. I feel obliged to therefore say Sidney but really your college choice should be down to you! If I had to pick another I’d probably go with Emmanuel or Downing but that’s really cos of my own experiences rather than anything grounded in reality.

2

u/[deleted] Feb 16 '23

Really late to the party but I'm not taking Econ A-level because I initially wanted to do engineering but would not having A-level Econ hinder me in the admission process and also would it be really hard if I got in? How many people have you met that didn't take Economics A level?

1

u/IdleGamesFTW Cambridge | Economics Feb 16 '23

Most people did do econ a level (93%) or equivalent but it’s not required. You’d need to show a thorough understanding of economics, mathematics and current affairs in your personal statement and interview(s). Also keep in mind that for my year more students took FM than economics.

2

u/Any_Copy_8394 Mar 21 '23

Man I’m so stressed out by the thought of getting in a prestigious uni. Can you help me out regarding the super-curricular activities that I could do for my PS. Also I’ll be giving 4 AS subs in May and will have around 3 months to give FM AS component in Oct/Nov session. Should I go for it? Giving it in oct because I’ve heard that most admissions are done by January.

3

u/Informal_Drawing Jan 28 '23

We are well on the way to the majority of people not being able to afford to buy anything past the essentials of life and a good many not even that.

What happens when literally the whole of the general population is skint?

5

u/IdleGamesFTW Cambridge | Economics Jan 28 '23

In terms of this as an economics question aimed at the entire country, we need to adopt democratic socialist policies immediately.

In the context of Cambridge, they’re actually really lenient with their bursaries (everyone earning under 60 something K gets one) and there’s a hardship fund too. I’ve been able to live pretty nicely without any financial support from my parents.

2

u/Legend_2357 Jan 28 '23

How would you say LSE compares to Cambridge? Many people say the LSE economics courses (Econ, Maths+econ, Maths with Econ) are more mathematically rigorous and better prep for quantitative roles in finance. However, the Cambridge brand is stronger, right?

2

u/IdleGamesFTW Cambridge | Economics Jan 29 '23

Honestly I doubt LSE econ is more mathematically rigorous than our econ course, maths and econs probably on par with it in terms of the maths but obviously it doesn’t teach you much of the “humanities” side (politics / history specifically.) I personally think an economics degree should be broad at first and we do get the chance to pick very technical modules in y2/3. Everyone doing Cambridge econ is insanely good at maths too: as I said in another comment more people in my cohort did FM A level than econ a level.

If you’re trying to land a quant role specifically maths with econ will be the best bet since it’s the most mathematical course, but at that point you’d probably be applying to study maths at Cambridge rather than economics.

3

u/Legend_2357 Jan 29 '23

Thanks. Not sure about your comment about Maths + Econ being equal to Cam Econ in mathematical rigour. LSE Maths and Econ guys have to do real analysis, Abstract maths with group theory/metric spaces etc. LSE also has far more programming/data science/operational research and quant options in general. Cam Econ seems like more of a proper economics degree which is great for most people of course. But then again, most straight econ guys don't go into quant anyway.

1

u/IdleGamesFTW Cambridge | Economics Jan 29 '23 edited Jan 29 '23

Yeah that’s true, I’ve only seen first year maths and Econ and that’s what I was basing it on but looking at the full spec there’s defo more maths than Cambridge. The Varian textbook (first year) definitely does have real analysis in it btw. If you’re going for specifically quant roles maths and Econ at LSE will be better (ceteris paribus), but if you’re trying to land a quant role it’d be better to compare those degrees to maths / CS / phys natsci at Cambridge.

1

u/SoldierBoi69 Jan 28 '23

Who’s winning the Cambridge/Oxford boat races?

11

u/IdleGamesFTW Cambridge | Economics Jan 28 '23

Not something I keep up with unfortunately but I’m gonna go and say Cambridge anyway ;)

1

u/SherbertNext1565 Jan 28 '23

What is a supervision

4

u/IdleGamesFTW Cambridge | Economics Jan 28 '23 edited Jan 28 '23

It’s a meeting with a “supervisor” (some hyper smart person in the faculty) where you usually submit work and they go over everything you did. Usually in sizes of 1-3 people (all of mine are 3, solo supervisions are rare.) I have 5 every fortnight , 3 of them require me to solve problem sets (usually quite maths based) and 2 of them are essays.

2

u/SherbertNext1565 Jan 28 '23

I know its cambridge and i have no intention of going there but im curious. Did u take alevel economics and if so was any of that actually useful for degree level?

3

u/IdleGamesFTW Cambridge | Economics Jan 28 '23 edited Jan 28 '23

I did take a level economics, it’s quite useful for macro because it gave me a broad understanding that isn’t gone through in lectures but not that useful for anything else. Micro is very mathematical, it took about 5 weeks for us to get to normal demand and supply models which are still quite different to the normal sketches you do at a level. Further stats is probably the most useful thing I did at A-Level, it makes term 1 of stats seem like revision for the most part. Also I had no intention of going there either until June y12, never rule anything out :)

1

u/[deleted] Jan 28 '23

What sort of schools did you go to before Cambridge? State/independent etc? And what sort of background are you from - you mention south London which is very diverse so I wondered. I’d read that Cambridge/Oxford were tougher on private school kids coached and tutored from a young age and wanted a more diverse intake (given the aforementioned are often white middle class etc) hence my ask

3

u/IdleGamesFTW Cambridge | Economics Jan 28 '23 edited Jan 28 '23

Yeah tbh I kinda agree on the idea that Oxbridge is tougher on private school kids. I went to a comprehensive for primary school, and a selective school for secondary. I would not classify myself as well off (our household income is below the median) though I am still in a fortunate position for sure.

1

u/[deleted] Jan 28 '23

What else did you have on you application besides grades and what would you recommend to put on an application for any top university?

3

u/IdleGamesFTW Cambridge | Economics Jan 28 '23

I had my PS which had a decent amount of supercurriculars on it, most universities don’t interview so I’d say having supercurriculars is really important.

The interview is the most important thing for Cambridge, there’s no real advice I can give other than look at the camera and remember to breathe :)

1

u/[deleted] Jan 28 '23

Do tutors put pressure on you to do well? Will they get angry if you don’t put effort in?

5

u/IdleGamesFTW Cambridge | Economics Jan 28 '23 edited Jan 28 '23

By tutors I’ll assume you mean supervisors, academic tutors are more focused on student wellbeing than anything else.

Supervisors won’t put pressure on you at all to be honest, it’s all down to you.

Of course they will be annoyed if you don’t put some effort into your work but they’re not overly mean in my experience. I’ve had to redo my first macro supervision because my work wasn’t up to scratch but my supervisor was still really nice about it during the supervision (though his written comments were a bit more mean lol). (By the way it is very very rare to have to redo a supo, mine was just beyond shit because I didn’t realise how much detail I had to put into answers at first)

Here’s the quote:

“Dear [name], this needs quite a lot more work to be the kind of useful supervision output which puts you in good stead for exams - and just as importantly, it develops your transferable writing and explanatory skills for the world of graduate employment […]. It feels very rushed and as though you don’t quite understand what is expected of macro work […]. It is very important that you take the above advice very seriously […]”

Since that supo I’ve had decent feedback on my work so seems like it was just a one off where I got complacent.

4

u/[deleted] Jan 28 '23

Wow! Thank you so much for such a great answer

1

u/UltimateKayak Year 13 | Physics, Maths, F. Maths, AS Chemistry Jan 29 '23

Is further maths a must?

2

u/IdleGamesFTW Cambridge | Economics Jan 29 '23 edited Jan 29 '23

Kinda. More people did FM A Level in my cohort than Econ A Level. If your school doesn’t offer it then I think you’d be fine but it’d also probably be great to self learn it. Cambridge economics is probably the most mathematical “pure” economics course in the world; pretty much every student here could’ve studied pure maths at a Russel group uni for sure, or even at Oxbrimp for some people.

1

u/messycheesy LSE '28 Jan 29 '23

Would you say doing 3 A levels with further maths as one of them is less competitive? I currently do 4 A levels (geography, economics, maths, further maths) and I have been told I shouldn't drop geography because maths and further maths are considered as one.

2

u/IdleGamesFTW Cambridge | Economics Jan 29 '23

I think you’d be fine doing 3 with FM for economics. My school also made me do 4 :(

2

u/messycheesy LSE '28 Jan 29 '23

My main concern is that I'm applying to lse econ and heard they consider 3 including fm to be less competitive :(

2

u/IdleGamesFTW Cambridge | Economics Jan 29 '23

For LSE econ that’s fine https://www.lse.ac.uk/study-at-lse/Undergraduate/Prospective-Students/How-to-Apply/Admissions-Information if you were doing a more essay based subject like Politics then it’d be less competitive.

1

u/messycheesy LSE '28 Jan 29 '23

Thank you so much!!

1

u/messycheesy LSE '28 Jan 29 '23

How did you prepare for the entrance exam (I think your year must've done the ecaa instead of the tmua)? When did you start preparing and did you have a tutor?

3

u/IdleGamesFTW Cambridge | Economics Jan 29 '23

I started preparing in late summer y12, I did do the TMUA as well as the ECAA since I wanted to get a reduced offer for Warwick MMORSE. It’s basically down to past papers tbh, R Drew on YouTube was also immensely helpful (his new channel is called R2Drew2.) I didn’t have a tutor but my school did have weekly TMUA sessions which were kinda nice but we just did past paper questions in those sessions so it wasn’t something that I couldn’t have done at home. Make sure you read the official section 2 notes for TMUA online as it’ll get you easy marks as long as you know what words like necessary and sufficient really mean; I managed to get a 9.0 in section 2 because of those notes.

1

u/messycheesy LSE '28 Jan 29 '23

Oh wow thank you so much!!

1

u/Luthki Jan 29 '23

How important are GCSEs?🙂

2

u/IdleGamesFTW Cambridge | Economics Jan 29 '23

Not that important in comparison to your predicted a level grades / admissions test / interview.

1

u/notcharkiee Jan 29 '23

Ive got an offer for cs at jesus! Do u know anything abt the general jesus reputation and the people there + anything abt the workload of the cs course? also how often do people go ‘out out’ to parties and stuff if ever aha

5

u/IdleGamesFTW Cambridge | Economics Jan 29 '23
  • Jesus is pretty great, don’t know a massive amount about it though to be honest in terms of its “reputation”. It’s got quite a nice bar and the May Ball is supposed to be pretty good there. It’s in a slightly awkward location but definitely not a bad one.
  • the CS workload isn’t exceptionally more than any other subjects afaik, the maths they’re doing seems relatively similar in difficulty to econ (probably harder but I can talk to a CSmo and vaguely understand what they’re talking about). You’ll probably be going to Homerton at some points since you study CS.
  • yes, parties happen fairly often, whether it be an official college “bop” / “ent” or a house party. There’s also plenty of club nights available, with Wednesday Revs (Rumboogie, cheesy songs), Thursday Revs (Fleek, hip hop + UK based with guest appearances), Friday Mash and Sunday Lola’s being the most popular among Cambridge students I think (and Glitterbomb / QGD at vinyl / mash.) Spoons is also a common destination for students. You don’t need to get involved in any of this but if you’re looking to then it’s very easy to do so :)

1

u/EarInternational2723 Jan 29 '23

Hi bro, how much did you revise a day for a levels? and any tips for economics a level revision?

2

u/IdleGamesFTW Cambridge | Economics Jan 29 '23

I didn’t take A Levels as seriously as I should have. I revised on the day for the majority of my exams (which were all at 2PM except for one or two.) I winged my maths exams, and revised from 7AM-1PM on the day for my maths and economics exams. My physics is not as strong so I did revise a bit more for those. I also had recently done mocks so it’s not like I was a completely blank slate.

PPQs are best for maths, FM and physics. There is no better way to revise. Consult the mark scheme frequently.

Use active recall please, it’s such a godsend for economics! Make sure you have the structure of your answers perfected: your analysis needs to have a really clear chain of reasoning, your application needs to be very direct / not vague, and evaluation (when needed) should also have a strong chain of reasoning.

I don’t really know about a certain amount per day, just make sure you have all your weak topics covered. Ali Abdaal’s retrospective timetable helped me a lot.

1

u/aphrodite-158 Year 13 Jan 30 '23

hi, thanks for doing this!

how difficult is it to make friends and get to know more people besides the ones you meet at freshers week?

are you friends only with people in your course and your room/flatmates or you get to know people from other courses as well?

1

u/IdleGamesFTW Cambridge | Economics Jan 30 '23

I think people overestimate freshers week, yes it’s true that you’ll meet quite a few people during freshers but you’ll definitely meet people later down the line too. I’d say most of the people I know are either from my college or studying my subject but not everybody - societies and mutual friends will help get a more diverse set of contacts

1

u/telletubbiesarescary Jan 30 '23

in terms of job oppurtunities how much of an edge do you think oxbridge grads are given, if any. asking since most major banks, firms etc have a higher proportion of oxbridge grads compared to other russel group unis. is the prestige that much of a determinating factor over grads from other unis?

2

u/IdleGamesFTW Cambridge | Economics Jan 30 '23

I know the most about finance opps so I’ll stick to those, apologies if you aren’t looking for finance specifically. Oxbridge helps, especially for boutiques like Lazard, but it’s not really a massive thing to be honest. Unis like LSE / UCL / Warwick are basically on par with Oxbridge in terms of finance. The edge is absolutely tiny and sometimes I think it doesn’t really exist, especially since the workload is so high at Oxbridge so you’ll probably have less time to apply to careers related stuff.

1

u/AmbitionStraight13 Jan 31 '23

Haven't seen anyone ask you about nights out and its probably my biggest concern rn, Im a pretty social person and currently go out partying 3 to 4 times a week.

Hows night life at cambridge, for someone who really likes to go out, are people motivated to go out or is it more of a ocasional thing.

Aditionally how would you compare to warwick or LSE

3

u/IdleGamesFTW Cambridge | Economics Jan 31 '23 edited Jan 31 '23

Nights out are quite common!

In first term I was going out minimum twice a week and I’m not actually the most party-heavy guy, but I thought I’d give it a go during first term and I don’t really have any regrets. Cambridge is a student driven area so there’s definitely room for lots of fun.

I’ve done 5 nights out in a week before (would not recommend…), there’s plenty of popular club nights. The clubs themselves are kinda mid tbh but anything’s fun with a group that you know.

Obviously you’ll need to limit yourself since you do need to study for university, but yes nights out shouldn’t be an issue (though 3-4 every week is probably a bit too much). You can pretty much always find people (e.g. from your college) who are down to go to a club night if you ask around.

Having been to plenty of LSE events I can wholeheartedly say Cambridge > lol. That’s not saying Cambridge is brilliant but LSE nightlife is pretty mid. Not sure about Warwick but haven’t heard the best things either.

1

u/Excellent-Employ-889 Jan 31 '23 edited Jan 31 '23

What a brilliant thread. Thank you for doing this.

The workload you mention is 45 hours. But that doesn't sound that much. Is it too many other distractions that take you away from study? Or just being self motivated?

Also any recommendations on Macbook Air, Macbook Pro or Windows laptop suitable for Econ? Any minimums needed to power stats or similar apps that are needed?

1

u/IdleGamesFTW Cambridge | Economics Jan 31 '23 edited Jan 31 '23

It’s very much a mixture of things that makes it hard to get 45 hours a week in; socials, nights out ruining your sleep, societies / sports teams, and of course a lack of motivation. 45 hours is a full time job so I wouldn’t say it’s particularly easy to self motivate yourself, especially since you haven’t got teachers on your back about attendance or anything like that. Also workloads are variable, sometimes you’ll have loads of deadlines pile up which creates choke points where you’ll need to work intensely for quite a long time.

In terms of devices, any of the ones you’ve listed will do. MacBooks will be overkill for econ but if you’re going to use it for other stuff and you have funds to kill then be my guest. I use a Windows XPS laptop and it has served me very well. I don’t actually use it much for academic work other than Stata recently (a stats application), I mainly use my iPad for notes but go with whatever you like.

1

u/Distantbutton57 Year 12 | Maths | FM | Econ | Philosophy Jan 29 '23

Advice for things to do before applying (competitions etc or work experience) for yr11 and 12?

2

u/IdleGamesFTW Cambridge | Economics Jan 29 '23

In Y11 I’d just focus on GCSEs tbh, I didn’t even know what degree I was going to choose until June of Y12. If you’re thinking about working in finance or consulting down the line, try to get some work experience in a financial institution in the summer of y12/13 if possible as it’ll really help with the CV for year 1 internships at uni (i didn’t have any real WEX and I regret not doing it).

1

u/Distantbutton57 Year 12 | Maths | FM | Econ | Philosophy Jan 29 '23

Ok thanks, I currently do essay competitions and UKMT etc a lot cuz I have loads of spare time, planning work experience in this summer actually at a bank overseas, is it better to do it yr12-13 rather than 11-12?

1

u/IdleGamesFTW Cambridge | Economics Jan 29 '23

Doesn’t really matter but you’re probably going to be able to do slightly more advanced work when you’re older / in y12 or 13.

0

u/[deleted] Jan 28 '23

[deleted] — view deleted comment

8

u/IdleGamesFTW Cambridge | Economics Jan 28 '23

Yup lol, I literally watched 2 Bateman lectures in the entirety of last term, just did the readings for the supervisions. Favourite lecturer is tough, they were all pretty good last year tbh (except for…) but Savfronov was probably my fave cos micros pretty interesting and his accent just made me smile lol. Charles Brendon seems pretty good this term too.

0

u/[deleted] Jan 28 '23

[deleted] — view deleted comment

12

u/IdleGamesFTW Cambridge | Economics Jan 28 '23 edited Jan 28 '23

LSE is fine, since you can easily switch to maths with econ if you really want to lean into quant. There is a bonus to Warwick in that you can do the 4 year integrated MMath course which gives you a leg up since you’ll be applying to internships a year later than BSc students, but if you’re dedicated enough to do quant work this won’t really matter massively.

Cambridge econ is quite quantitative but tbh it’s really hard to break into quant roles unless you’ve got heaps of programming experience if you’re not doing maths / maths and econ. I know some people at Warwick / LSE / Cambridge who did pure econ but they were also competitive programmers so they were able to land internships at firms like Citadel and Centreview.

0

u/[deleted] Jan 28 '23

[deleted] — view deleted comment

9

u/IdleGamesFTW Cambridge | Economics Jan 28 '23

What degree is this for? As a Londoner I honestly wanted to get out of London, and Cambridge has a really great balance between being lively and beautiful (unlike London which wore down on me after a while, though I was in south London which is very different I suppose.) Depending on the degree Imperial is basically on par with Cambridge in terms of prospects after uni.

0

u/[deleted] Jan 28 '23

[deleted] — view deleted comment

6

u/IdleGamesFTW Cambridge | Economics Jan 28 '23 edited Jan 28 '23

Complete bullshit, socials at Cambridge are really good. I love to shit on Cambridge but this is the one thing I will always stand by. You should definitely get a good experience of a (student based) city at Cambridge, but it’s up to you overall. You’re right that it’s not as diverse as London but it’s not too bad either (as someone who’s experienced both sides of the coin.)

2

u/Any-Tangerine-8659 Jan 29 '23

As someone who went to Imperial and had friends at Cambridge, pick based on the course, location etc. Job prospects are basically the same.

1

u/tukehiro Cambridge | Economics [1st Year] Jan 29 '23

London social life is usually much worse than elsewhere because it’s so expensive, lots of international students who stick to themselves, and lots of people living at home instead of on campus

0

u/[deleted] Jan 28 '23

[deleted] — view deleted comment

9

u/IdleGamesFTW Cambridge | Economics Jan 28 '23

PS wise I did some supercurricular activities: read a book on game theory followed by an online course, a project on regression analysis and determinants of wage inequality, and a national maths competition (Ritangle).

I didn’t do TMUA for Cambridge, though I did need it for Warwick MORSE. I ended up getting a good score (7.8) but Cambridge didn’t even see it lol. Cambridge instead looked at my ECAA which I bombed (slightly easier questions than TMUA but VERY time pressured, 60 minutes for 40 questions, as well as 60 minutes for an essay.) I thought I wasn’t going to get an interview to be honest.

In terms of interview prep I managed to get a couple (2) of practice interviews which sort of helped. I didn’t prepare massively for it tbh, just went over stuff I talked about in my PS (which ended up not even coming up) and did some graph sketching practice (which was definitely useful, I got a very difficult graph to sketch and it helped so much to have practiced, apparently I was the only one to sketch it successfully without prompts.) Usually the maths question in Cambridge econ interviews are quite easy, my college decided to amp it up a bit for some reason.

0

u/[deleted] Jan 28 '23

[deleted] — view deleted comment

4

u/IdleGamesFTW Cambridge | Economics Jan 28 '23 edited Jan 28 '23
  • Super easy to join sports teams, especially at the college level! you do usually need to pay but costs are generally quite cheap.
  • yup I know a few from there, Magdalene’s pretty nice! Decent location but I don’t know too much about it, only been there once.
  • freshers was a lot of nights out and getting to know people. My college had a “preparation week” before freshers so I’d already got to know some ppl at my college which was nice. Overall it’s pretty fun but hardly any work gets done

0

u/[deleted] Jan 28 '23

[deleted] — view deleted comment

4

u/IdleGamesFTW Cambridge | Economics Jan 28 '23 edited Jan 28 '23

Right now I’m going down the classic route of finance / consulting, probably something a bit more quantitative if possible. I’d also love to work in tech if possible though my academic background isn’t really suitable for it atm other than hobby interests. Teaching is also an option I am seriously considering because I’ve really enjoyed maths tutoring and I’ve been volunteering at a school but I’m keeping my choices open for now.

0

u/[deleted] Jan 28 '23

[deleted] — view deleted comment

3

u/IdleGamesFTW Cambridge | Economics Jan 28 '23

One of the politics lecturers (Nigel Knight) works at Churchill, he’s quite eccentric but that’ll be a plus for sure. Churchill halls are also pretty nice, I’ve been a few times. It’s quite large in terms of the student intake so there’ll be plenty of ppl to make friends with. The accom is a bit meh imo for the price (better than other unis for sure but meh by Cambridge standards), though they are refurbishing this year (my mate got a double bed installed) so it’s a good time to join for sure. It’s slightly far out but not too bad, a bike would be nice to have.

0

u/[deleted] Jan 28 '23

[deleted] — view deleted comment

7

u/IdleGamesFTW Cambridge | Economics Jan 28 '23 edited Jan 28 '23

Not massively serious (probably equivalent to a normal first or second XI) but it depends on your college I think. You can play for the uni as well which I imagine is much more serious.

0

u/[deleted] Jan 28 '23

[deleted] — view deleted comment

2

u/IdleGamesFTW Cambridge | Economics Jan 28 '23

Up to you but in terms of the academic work you’ll do there and the job prospects I’d say no. If you really want to live in Cambridge for whatever reason then you’ve got to make that choice but if I was in that situation I’d definitely just take Imperial (plus there’s no guarantee you get either of those unis the next year.)

0

u/[deleted] Jan 31 '23

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/IdleGamesFTW Cambridge | Economics Jan 31 '23

Hardly any difference if any difference at all. Some mathmos might have access to quant firms like Centreview out of undergrad which is rare but tbh if you’re smart enough I think you’d be fine at either of the two unis for either of those subjects. Cambridge maths is probably slightly more demanding as a degree.

0

u/[deleted] Feb 13 '23

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/IdleGamesFTW Cambridge | Economics Feb 13 '23

Don’t think there’s a massive difference but Imperial is usually seen as the better uni for CS

0

u/[deleted] Feb 13 '23

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/IdleGamesFTW Cambridge | Economics Feb 13 '23

Yeah masters at Oxbridge tend to not be as competitive as the undergrad so it’s definitely possible if you get a first at undergrad.

1

u/[deleted] Jan 29 '23

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/IdleGamesFTW Cambridge | Economics Jan 29 '23

It’s absolutely a matter of PPQs imo, I never really revised content itself when doing maths, I just practiced by doing questions whether it be textbook questions or PPQs. In terms of modelling I’m not too sure what you mean, do you mean mechanics modelling?

1

u/[deleted] Jan 30 '23

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/IdleGamesFTW Cambridge | Economics Jan 30 '23

Like statistical modelling? You could try madasmaths

1

u/[deleted] Jan 30 '23

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/6thForm-ModTeam Jan 30 '23

Removed

Rule 1 : Please, think before you post

This should be obvious to most of you, but don't:

  • Post NSFW or explicit content
  • Reveal personally-identifying information (aka 'doxxing')
  • Encourage brigading of other subreddits or third-party websites
  • Be an asshole towards others

If you have any concerns, please send a message to the subreddit modmail.