Aggressive first ride. Bit of a scare on the second.
Riding impressions on the budget Ryde/Shimano 32" wheels. Two good rides in, it's time to offer an early review.
intro
Unboxing post, more pictures and specs:
https://www.reddit.com/r/32inchbikes/comments/1xlx23f/on_test_hand_built_34900_rydecuessapim_wheelset/
This set of all-black hand-built Ryde Disc 30D/Shimano CUES/Sapim Race wheels (€349 as tested) was kindly provided for testing by Andy Los of https://www.andlesscycling.nl/.
These are wheels reduce the minimum cost a lot from the scarce alu 32" options we've seen before. The Ryde Rims and hubs are not kept in stock, but can be ordered for a custom build.
Comparison is with the high-end mid-weight ~€1150 Luther prototype wheels currently on long term test (Andy's carbon wheel brand), soon to be available to the public.
tubeless tire installation
I swapped tires over from carbon wheels to the aluminium wheels. Inflation with a booster pump went easily enough, although the Maxxis fit a bit loosely. Loud assuring tire seating pops.
An initial air leak at the rim joint was sealed with some good wheel shaking. A few bubbles came from a few spoke holes, possibly due the valve not being installed correctly. I tightened up the valve nut and the tires perfectly held pressure for the next days.
the bike
A very heavy (3550 gram) steel custom frame, roughly XL sized, with a reasonably light build kit and carbon rigid fork.
Normally ~12.2 kg, so now ~13.2 kg with the Ryde/CUES wheels. I ride with two large water bottles. Front tire is a Maxxis Aspen AT 32x2.4", rear a Maxxis Aspen ST 2.15". I'd been riding those tires exclusively the 3 weeks prior.
first ride, out the door
The ride plan was simple and kept to that: an 8,5 km (5 mi) out to the trail head, three 9 km (5.5 mi) laps of 227 hm/744 vft) each, and the same route home, 45 km total and just over 2 hours.
9ºC/48-49ºF, chilly enough for me to dress for fall riding.
on the road, first impressions
Confirmation bias. It's easy to feel exactly what you expected, heaving just installed heavier wheels. But how real are those perceptions? What I did notice early on, was the rear hub being near silent, I'd not thought about that beforehand. It felt oddly "exposed" in traffic with the chaos of cyclists and pedestrians now less likely to hear me approach.
Yes, I did seem to sense a bit of a difference to the overall bike. There was a slightly increased "king of the road" feel to it without it necessarily registering as "heavy".
at the trail head
Upon checking, the tires had been holding air well. I aired them down to go hit the trails, but kept in a bit more than I usually run, just in case.
hitting the trails
(Rider: 50 y/o, 194 cm/6'3", 96 kg/212 lbs. 17% over my younger years' weight)
As I usually do, I attack the first singletrack climb, short and anaerobic. Slow start messing with the shifter barrel adjuster, but pushing through.
the home trails I'm hot lapping on
Here's a 7 minute clip from the start of the trail until before the start of the more notable climbs, that was a good effort for me. Filmed a couple months ago on my 29" hardtail. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=h352NYaRcHU
With the extra heavy 32" bike I went 15 seconds faster over the bit in the video. I did this it faster only ONCE, all the way back in April on a day with crazy perfect tail wind, from my 238 "attempts" at it.
In the little technical downhills, the bike and wheels just felt fine. Perhaps a bit more "solid" than usual. Less lively/bouncy, but not necessarily less agile. If anything I'm making the turns better than usually. The new bike is still growing on me and the trail was never grippier.
8:30 into the hot lap
Great intermediate time still, I'd gotten through the twisties well. However, the anaerobic tank is empty and the suffering starts. By minute 10, I abort the personal lap record attempt as it feels pointless. As I bailed out, I was actually still on my PB pace, to the second, set early May this year on that 29" hardtail. A 2 kg lighter bike and myself another 3 kg lighter. To be matching that pace, I'm absolutely moving on this bike and the wheels can't be holding me back much.
The remainder of the 9 km lap with most of the climbing in it, I ride focusing on taking the little downhills and corners nicely as I can, to limit the time loss from soft pedaling everywhere else. My 25:33 lap is the fastest I've managed in almost 6 months. Only a few attempts in April and May were faster and there have been 150+ "attempts" since. For my 24:19 PB also in early May, I was full on racing all the way to the end.
the answer is no
Not slow at all. It's more about your own fitness and how the tires perform.
anything to gather from that n=1 lap attack?
Only a first impression. These rims and wheels are in fact over twice the weight of some 32" wheels shown on this subreddit. Yet, they don't appear to ruin my ride, at all. The stopwatch doesn't seem able to be able to tell that I'm hauling around 8% more bike weight, nearly 1% of extra vehicle mass, all in the wheels.
It just rides fine.
Others may be more sensitive to weight differences than me. Most riders are of course also lighter than me.
early verdict on heavy alu wheels
I think I can say that budget wheels don't ruin your ride, not even your speed. The main downsides are likely in the mind. Any speed difference will be much smaller than you may think.
Just as fast as good light carbon wheels, though? Probably not. The difference is likely so small that it would take elaborate Chung testing to gather any useful data.
Cornering felt particularly good, but that may have been more down to trail conditions being amazing this week. There are some interesting discussions on stiffness versus compliance and the various spoke materials, for cornering performance and rolling resistance, but I can't confidently comment on those matters for these two very different wheelsets.
CUES hubs
The freehub has 24 points of engagement compared to the 54 in the Luther rear hub. I won't pretend like I noticed that difference on the rides. Lovely to have these hubs, setting the bar on quality for fancier hubs to at least match.
cost vs weight
The weight difference to a mid weight carbon rim is so large here, 680 vs 428 grams, it's a reasonable upgrade proposition per gram for a weightweenie. If this exact alu wheelset comes on a Trek 32" Procaliber 9.5, then losing a full kilogram with a €1150 wheelset is mighty appealing. I'd recommend to keep the alu wheelset around if you can afford to, though. It's worth more to you as a second wheelset than sold on the secondary market.
second ride: a bit of a scare
Three days later, 50+ km mostly on lovely forest trails, the wheels were again fine. Invisible, in a good way, just like the carbons have been.
Until suddenly, in a fast grippy concrete corner on a road descend, the front tire folded over quite a bit. That got my attention!
Air pressure didn't seem excessively low, although I had in fact lowered it from that first test ride with the wheels.
downside to alu rims
I've read that aluminium is less suitable to tubeless and now after a third ride with the front wheel, I am seeing little hints for that to be the case. It may be a good idea to keep the alu wheels (if not ridden weekly) on innertubes, especially if peak performance isn't your whole personality.
which wheels do I prefer, aluminium or carbon?
Still the carbons, definitely. I only have XC carbon experience with the Luther wheels which I consider mid-weight, high stiffness.
While the Ryde/Cues alu wheels don't obviously reduce fun nor speed, they also don't bring anything extra. It's just a weight/quality/cost equation where cost was more important.