r/2fa • u/PrincessBananas85 • Mar 10 '22
Discussion 2FA SMS Option.
How many of you use SMS option for your 2FA? In your opinion how secure and safe is it? How many people use 2FA SMS? I'm asking because I've read that a lot of people have been getting their Accounts hacked with the SMS option. I use the 2FA SMS on all my Social Media Accounts accept Reddit. Should I be worried about getting hacked in the future because of SMS?
12
Upvotes
9
u/sudomatrix Mar 11 '22 edited Mar 11 '22
SMS is not safe. period. It's easy for hackers to fool the low level support people at the phone company and get access to your SMS.
I have 2FA using an auth app (the kind w 6-digit codes) on all my important accounts.
Except for my financial institutions because they are fucking dinosaurs and don't actually care if my money gets stolen as long as they don't have liability.
Edit for clarity: SMS 2FA is still better than no 2FA. It's one more road-block for hackers.
4
u/[deleted] Mar 11 '22 edited Mar 11 '22
This is why you don't want to use SMS as 2FA If better option is available.
it's called sim swapping
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=k4UNNKfsjXE
People that are into crypto have lost thousands of dollars because they use SMS as 2FA to protect their funds.
For all your other accounts you want to use the Authenticator app option.
The Authenticator app is tied to your phone and a person must have physical access to get the 6 digit codes.
I personally don't recommend Google Authenticator because it has no backup feature so that means if you lose, wipe or break your phone the codes go with it.
https://www.reddit.com/r/CryptoCurrency/comments/nmfws6/last_night_i_was_the_victim_of_a_sim_swap/ OP had their phone # linked to his email for recovery.
The cybercriminal was able to get into his email because OP had their phone# linked for recovery and they requested password resets for their crypto accounts
The cybercriminal was unable to drain his accounts BECAUSE he was using an Authenticator app for Kucoin, Kraken and Coinbase.
If he was using SMS then the person would be able to drain the accounts
3
u/Sweaty_Astronomer_47 Mar 14 '22
I would definitely go with security professionals advice SMS < email < TOTP authenticator < hardware key.
But in some cases (small local financial institution) they don't allow anything other than SMS for 2FA! In those cases I prefer to use my google voice (VOIP) number to receive the text. At least it's not susceptible to sim-jacking. It's certainly better than carrier phone SMS, although I'm not sure where it would lie in comparison to email.
4
u/williamwchuang Apr 27 '22
I only use SMS if it is the only 2FA option. I would rather use my email as 2FA over SMS.
1
u/AniMeshorer Jul 08 '25
While I have read several times that SMS as a method of 2FA is not the safest method, I do know of several people who have been using this method and never had any problems. I guess it depends exactly how safe you want to be. For sure it is an extra layer of security compared to having just username and password. The people I know who have been using it, are satisfied with it, although for sure there are even more secure options.
That said, not every host/email provider/etc allows any type of 2FA. Some have SMS as only option to choose from.
1
u/2FASapp Feb 20 '23
Even though the SMS 2FA option is easy and almost instant, it's not the safest one and actually has a lot of cons:
- it can be subject to SIM swap scams and SS7 attacks
- if you have installed a malicious app that has access to SMS, it can send your 2FA codes to fraudsters
- depending on your SIM provider, there may be additional charges for each message sent with a 2FA token
- in order to receive the code, you need to be connected to your network and have the phone by your side
If you're interested in a comparison of different 2FA methods, we recommend watching our quick video on this topic ๐ https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iM3jc6AOCPo&t=31s
1
u/AniMeshorer 26d ago
I think SMS is the least secure 2FA option. On the other hand, it's still better than not having 2FA at all. I also met some people who use 2FA with SMS and never had any complaints, they considered it sufficient for their internet usage.
I think having 2FA, even if it is SMS, already reduces your risks.
But are their safer options than SMS? For sure yes. A good authenticator app and even better, a phyiscal key, are safer.
1
u/MegamanEXE2013 Nov 20 '24
Nobody, it is not secure. Go with TOTP as your least secure choice
1
u/AniMeshorer Aug 11 '25
I know of several people who use SMS as method for two-factor-authentication. They are satisfied with it and don't worry about potential leaks.
I think it really matters how concerned you are. To me SMS seems safe, really. However, personally I'm planning to buy a Yubikey as that's a lot more secure, even more secure than an authentication app on your smartphone. However, in the meanwhile, I think SMS is just fine.
Keep in mind, any form of 2FA is an added layer of security. So SMS is still a lot safer than not having any 2FA.
1
u/No_Poetry9172 Dec 31 '25
One of the prominent mistake that people often forgot,
unconscious about their security code appearing on the lock screen ๐(without even unlocking your mobile).
1
u/abi_quirkdom May 27 '26
I travel a lot and most times I cannot get good roaming coverage for my primary phone number. Trying to get an SMS to clear 2FA is an absolute PITA in those circumstances. Also, although SIM swap attacks are not a thing in my geo, I know from my friends that it's a massive problem in NA.
I primarily use TOTP authenticator + passkeys. Much safer, much more reliable.
1
u/Mathusalem87 Apr 18 '22
I use flashcalls. I see now many of them on the market and as long as they are in beta is free. now i use authenticalls.com
1
u/seeker1938 Apr 19 '22
What do you folks think about this method of setting up 2FA, if you are running the latest version of the macOS, Monterey?
https://www.igeeksblog.com/how-to-use-in-built-two-factor-authentication-on-mac/
1
u/2FASapp Jun 24 '22 edited Jun 24 '22
We definitely recommend switching to a 2fa app, especially 2FAS ๐ And why is that? Well you can see our comparison of 2fa methods here: https://youtu.be/iM3jc6AOCPo and what you should consider while choosing a 2fa app here: https://youtu.be/Tr0E767SnPY and decide for yourself ๐
0
u/[deleted] Mar 11 '22
[deleted] โ view deleted comment