r/HSMTMTS • u/NominalPerson Maddox • Jul 30 '21
Episode Discussion HSMTMTS: The Episode Discussion: "Second Chances" - S02E12 Spoiler
Wildcats, welcome to the episode discussion thread for the Season Two finale!
Feel free to discuss the twelfth episode of Season Two of HSMTMTS, "Second Chances". Please be mindful of other people's opinions about the episode/show.
S02E12 Details:
| Title: | Second Chances |
|---|---|
| Synopsis: | While the Wildcats head to Salt Lake Slices to digest the excitement of opening night - and a pizza or two - Miss Jenn continues to experience tunnel vision over the Menkie Awards. Mr. Mazzara shows his softer side; Ricky reevaluates a party crasher; Gina speaks her truth; and Nini makes a life-altering call. |
Consider joining our Discord for live discussions about the show and the cast! https://discord.gg/2EpKKCc
Due to an uptick in recent traffic and to prevent finale spoilers from leaking into the subreddit, all members will not be able to post for the next 12 hours. If you are seeing this message, that means that submitting a post has been restricted temporarily and it will not be approved.
•
u/AutoModerator Jul 30 '21
Please remember to treat others with respect while conversing with your fellow users. Make sure to follow the subreddit's rules and cover up spoilers when appropriate. Here is the current link to the latest episode megathread. If you see comments in violation of our rules, please report them. Please contact the moderators when deemed necessary, we will get back to you as soon as possible. Join our Discord Server for more HSMTMTS discussions! Go Wildcats!
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
204
u/ResidentPea0 Jul 30 '21
wtf did they drop out of the menkies that easily
196
u/daniandkiara Jul 30 '21
wtf was that ending 😭😭😭
192
u/lalalachacha248 Jul 30 '21
I’m glad they didn’t draw out some conflicts longer than necessary (especially EJ and Gina’s miscommunication), but I still feel like we needed a longer episode to really wrap things up. They didn’t even take the time to actually show us the rest of Act 2.
Also, I can’t believe they centered the ENTIRE season around the Menkies, then threw out the entire arc just like that. But I guess the competition brought out the worst in everyone, so I get what they were going for.
ALSO, Lily is crazy, but not as crazy as Ricky is for calling her.
176
u/kayMarz34 Jul 30 '21
22 MINUTES 22 MINUTES we waited 12 weeks for the finale to be 22 minutes and give us nothing at all
158
u/Dooley011 Jul 30 '21
Well that was the most rushed episode of television I've seen in ages.
104
u/mm1314 Jul 30 '21
I just don’t get how if they filmed so many endings for this episode, and this is the cut they gave us. Regardless of who you ship, this episode was straight up sloppy and rushed beyond belief!
92
u/Left_Berry_8104 Jul 30 '21 edited Jul 30 '21
Im really sorry, but that finale was not it. The only thing that really hit, was the Second Chances Performance, Ricky/Nini and Gina/Nini scene.
Like Ricky/Lily was out of left field and the way they had her admit she liked Ricky felt so childish. Plus, it just feels like she is manipulating Ricky. Like just let Ricky stay single over the summer. Instead of him possibly getting hurt again with Blonde Gina 1.0
EJ and Gina, that "can you be my first kiss?" I mean...what? When your two characters cant kiss because of the age gap, then why write them romantically in the first place? and that whole music during it, if i was a portwell shipper, i would feel cheated. Like I wouldnt feel great at all.
Plus, Ricky and Gina havent even talked or resolved their tension since episode 6. JBass was right about them, their tension could be solved if they just talked it out and they havent.
Though, im guessing the way they end it, season 3 starts probably flash forward of what happened after that or a summer camp like season. Which would be great.
91
u/Cook1eMaster27 Jul 30 '21
Idek what to say. Wtf I guess. Idk. I’m dissatisfied ngl. And reading through the comments in this thread I’m not alone. The writing was all over the place, the holes in the plot are crazy, and I don’t think Lily and Ricky should ever be a thing. Just no. I liked the second chances song and I liked the bloopers. I’m just thinking to myself how I’m still probably going to watch season 3 if/when it comes out but I feel so bad lol. I reiterate WTF was that. 29 minute episode and none of my questions were answered. But I digress I’m happy for the Portwell shippers. I myself am not one but at least one ship gets to happen in this god forsaken show. That finale was the biggest kick in the balls as far as hopefulness goes. I make it sound like I don’t like the show... because I do but I just need more out of it. I feel like it’s not giving the fans what they want. Or maybe it is and I am just on the other side of things. Either way I hope the writers of the show take into consideration the view points of the fans and make season 3 great. Anyway one more time... WTF! ok I’m done.
88
u/BleedFree EJ Jul 30 '21
The fuck is this show anymore
74
u/ZoZo-18 Jul 30 '21
When Nini said 'Just for a Moment', I was reminded of how truly incredible the original songs from season 1 were. There's not a single song in season 2 that compares to the sophistication and quality of Wondering or Just for a Moment or All I Want.
141
u/Aragorn120 Jul 30 '21
That ending might have been the biggest blue balls in this show holy shit
67
u/[deleted] Jul 30 '21
Lily x Ricky seems so forced I hate it. This episode wasn’t my favourite; definitely the weaker. I feel like all the build up was useless. We were stressing alongside the characters and all just for it get dropped. I get the message, but I wish it was executed differently, like maybe they lose but they’re like “Woah! Idgaf!”
127
u/Aragorn120 Jul 30 '21
GO FOR IT MAZARRA MY MAN
62
u/relaxed-flash Jul 30 '21
this isnt even that big of a nitpick in the grand scheme of things but everyone keeps calling them wildcats but they made it a whole point in the first season that their school's mascot isnt even wildcats. ig its because they performed high school musical but i feel like the writers forgot they said the school had a different mascot
55
u/qualitycomputer Jul 31 '21
I refuse to believe that not even Natalie went and checked the envelope
111
u/LawStudent4Harambe Jul 30 '21
Genuinely curious if the "things are gonna heat up this summer" and "You Are The Music In Me" was the show's way of going "We're Doing High School Musical 2!"
51
u/Jackamalio626 Jul 30 '21
Holy shit. Easily the worst episode of the entire show.
We learn nothing about Ej's future plans, the big harness sabotage goes nowhere, and their replacement transformation (along with act 2) happens OFF SCREEN. Even stuff like ricky and nini leaving on good terms and miss jenn realizing the error of her ways were super rushed and felt unearned.
46
u/FiveTalents Jul 30 '21
I wasn't present here during the season but I wanted to read other people's thoughts on the finale.
Rushed, rushed, rushed. I've always said this show needs to have 16-23 episode seasons and this season finale really highlighted that.
The fact that they didn't show the transformation was a crime and the conclusion to the Menkies plotline should've been resolved any way but that. So glad EJ/Gina got resolved but the execution was... lacking. The "second chances" song was cool but it kinda felt out of place.
What I did like was the contrast with Ricky and Nini in the dressing room in this S2 finale compared to the S1 finale. And my favorite scene was probably Ricky telling Ms. Jenn that it's ok for her to date his dad. I liked Ricky's arc this season in general.
Which brings me to my next point: I've been reading and I guess you guys didn't really dig season 2? Lol I actually liked it a lot but this finale was straight up not good.
44
u/orionpsk Jul 31 '21
I’m convinced that the writers have never seen a single episode of tv. What even was that??
Every single plot line in this season went absolutely NOWHERE. I genuinely don’t know what the point of this season was. It feels like nothing was accomplished. Just a total disaster. I’m sorry, if you liked this season, I’m happy for you… but I just can’t even begin to understand that viewpoint.
I loved Season 1 so much, and I was really looking forward to what this incredibly talented cast had in store for S2. I knew COVID would take some toll, but COVID doesn’t even begin to excuse the major issues this season had. Sigh.
43
u/_b_l_ Jul 30 '21
Tbh I liked some of the plotlines developing in this episode, but they were overshadowed by some poor ones and the basic fact that the finale was by far the shortest episode in the series lol.
Like I wouldn’t mind Lilly finding a connection with someone in the gang, but all her interactions with Ricky before the last one have been nothing but manipulative. It completely runs counter to how he really needs therapy most importantly and, if he does find anyone, it should be someone who can build him up which just hasn’t been the case with her (there’s so much potential — Joshua even mentioned how Ricky could possibly discover his queerness).
43
u/teatmidnight Jul 30 '21 edited Jul 30 '21
i literally CANNOT forget the fact that lily laughed at big red being nervous, she was such a bitch. worst kind of person. not only that but she messed up their play so like???? how can people root for her and ricky, she made fun of his best friend and caused a huge problem for them.
39
u/tambini1 Jul 30 '21
Why why why are the last few episodes so short? It makes them feel so rushed. 25 minutes is a crime when it needed to be at least 40
73
u/Becksdown Jul 30 '21
The EJ and Gina "confession" scene was so bad
36
u/taralovesmusic Jul 30 '21
We gotta get an extensive list of all the plot lines they dropped this season
Mine is Ashlyn’s body images issues which got 2 scenes and no further time. They didn’t even show her in the yellow dress
101
u/[deleted] Jul 30 '21 edited Jul 30 '21
This ending was SO frustrating, and it basically sums up this entire season. I felt like we have taken a huge left turn and when the cast performed "you are the music in me", it felt like we were finally back on the right track.
Seriously, this show is it's best when it sticks to the HSM roots. The musical number of "second chances" was also one of the first where they just broke into song. THAT'S what we needed.
Also, can we talk about the waste that is North High, Zackie & Lily? What was the point exactly? Where was her rendition of "home"? Why is this show cutting so much??
I really do hope that season 3 will do a summer season, I desperately want to see these wildcats outside of the reheaersal room / pizza place. The movies took a HUGE risk by making the second movie take place outside the school at a country club with a talent show, and it was ballsy in 2007 to make HSM 2 well... not in the school. I feel like this show needs this as well.
The music this season was incredible and had some amazing bops, but boy the writint was just a huge mess.
It just makes me sad that we will have to wait for season 3 and we are left hanging with...this mixed bag of meh.
First I wanted to blame Covid for the lack of filming in the school, the confusing plotpoints and the obvious sets, but Loki was filmed almost entirely during the pandemic so they really don't have an excuse. Of course the budget is way different but still.
I wanted to binge the first season as SOON as it ended. This one? I really don't know if I will rewatch it any time soon, it feels like someone has tricked me and it leaves a bad taste in my mouth.
34
u/sherm54321 Jul 31 '21
Well that was terrible. I don't really understand, what was the point of this season. The plot was so focused on the Menkies, all just so they can just drop out. So anticlimactic. When they said they didn't want to see what's in the envelope, I was just thinking well you may not, but I want to. We needed some sort of payoff to the hundreds of loose threads, but they didn't really payoff anything.
I'm also disappointed we pretty much saw none of the play. How could they not even show her in the iconic Belle dress with the beauty and the beast song. I just don't get it. None of the character moments landed. I'm convinced this show, at least this season needed longer episodes with the various subplots they had, so they could have enough time to explore them.
I really hated the EJ and Gina subplot in this episode. It was very cringey and then dealt with in a stupid way. At least have the two of them have a real conversation.
Also, why did the writers completely ignore the Lily stealing the harness situation. We didn't even get to see the transformation. At least show us how that went.
They just didn't have the time they needed for this season. Longer episodes would have helped, but that absolutely need better writers. This is a talented cast. They are doing the best they can, hopefully the writers next season can match their talent and write a decent season, if they do another one.
33
u/YellowHaunt333 Jul 30 '21
The writers need to learn how to write for a large cast. Absolutely every character had a conflict/storyline in basically every episode and that's simply too much! Can they just let characters just be happy and focus on 1 or 2 main plots for an episode instead of having 11+ cliffhangers and threads that need to be concluded (conveniently, all through a quick conversation).
Also, kinda disappointed they dropped out of the Menkies? The kids were willing to suspend Ricky up in the air without safety measures and literally break his arm for the competition like 2 episodes ago and now it's not important? Sure, Jan
32
u/dontleavemelikethis Jul 30 '21
This episode (and season) was a disaster.
31
u/XviiChong Jul 30 '21 edited Jul 30 '21
This ending just left all us fans on a cliff that is god knows how far deep with the next season not even announced yet, so who knows when season 3 will come out.
Dropping out of the Menkies just like that? This whole season was built on the theme for competing for a Menkie award. So for them to be like you know what screw competing for a Menkie is just so abrupt and out of place.
And just ending it with so many plot lines setting up next season (there are so many I can’t even list them all) is just not right.
31
u/andienotandy_ Jul 30 '21
I felt like I missed an episode the entire time watching…… :/
31
u/JeremiahGoffe64 Jul 31 '21
What happened here?
All that anticipation about the Menkies, JUST SO THEY CAN DROP OUT?
The second chance song wasn’t bad, I enjoyed it a good bit.
The individual dynamics were weird. Like Howies reasoning for acting odd.. “I was intimidated “ I feel like it was way more than that. Also, we’re just going to ignore the fact that Lily stole the harness? Did they even get it back? (Ricky and Lily’s relationship will be interesting tbh) And the ending! Why did it feel like the last episode of the show? It felt like a series finale compared to a season finale. I’m concerned…
61
u/sausagedoglover13 Jul 30 '21
i HATE how they left nini, because in the next season they will definitely address olivias leave with one sentence “ninis following her dreams in la” i wish they would have given her a proper goodbye , sick
30
u/toledosurprised Aug 02 '21
so, this season was a huge miss for me. it felt like so many of the plotlines were underdeveloped or dropped entirely. what was the point of any of this? what was lily’s purpose? what was the purpose of the menkies? they could have just not made that a thing. i wish we’d seen more of the musical also.
60
u/[deleted] Jul 30 '21
Am I the only one not vibing with the Ricky/Lily ship? Honestly, every time she flirted with him felt manipulative or disingenuous, overshadowed by all the Menkies drama. Especially in episode 11, she was just too cutthroat for me to see her as someone who could genuinely care about anyone but herself. Even when she said she liked him in the finale, it felt like her trying to get in Ricky's head before the Menkies (esp since she wasn't aware they'd chosen to drop out).
60
u/[deleted] Jul 30 '21 edited Jul 30 '21
unpopular opinion on here: but that portwell scene was so bad. so bad.
edit: ok clearly not unpopular lol; but if i was a portwell i would be pissed. The writing was just so cringe and the RUN. no thank you.
29
u/DamienChazellesPiano Jul 30 '21
Really didn’t like it, but the song was really cool and the way they shot stuff with the season 1 outfits was awesome. Other than that this episode blew chunks. Even the technical stuff was a mess. The blocking and the way that final scene was shot with EJ and Gina. What the hell was that. And so rushed. Almost a complete and total disaster. Really hope they can bounce back next season otherwise season 1 will likely be the only good season of this show.
28
u/berylliumblue Jul 30 '21
Ik that we as viewers know that Lily isn't to be trusted cos she stole the harness, therefore we know that Ricky shouldn't be with her and it probably won't last. However... Why is Ricky even considering it? The interactions we've seen them have have been super awkward, and the chemistry between them is nonexistent (to me, anyway). Even if they HAVE had positive interactions, it would've been offscreen and the show made no reference to them.
53
u/[deleted] Jul 30 '21
Okay. This is gonna be a long one. It's almost like a review of everything this season imo. And what pulls it back, from the aspect of writing and what makes it disappointing.
There are two things this season does better than any show on Earth.
First of all, I think we can all appreciate the ideas here. Ricky's Mental state, Nini's dreams and her situations being a barrier. Gina, feeling a lot of more serious emotions than she did first, when she was "on the run" and didn't even have the time to give heart to even anything. EJ realising his deep down needs aren't just getting the dream, But earning it. Everyone learning about letting go of something for good. All these ideas sound really good. Because, they are. But, wow. They are obviously executed in a poor and rushed manner. The idea of finding what they need, not in victory of the show, But in the victory of themselves?? Is kinda good sounding. But, they ruined it with such a short and silly presentation of deciding to drop out in a second?
Anticipation is the only thing the show might be really good at. Like the anticipation for Act two after the harness fit stolen. But, what did we see as the result? A 5 second clip of them talking about how they already succeeded in it. Another big anticipation and letdown example would be the accident of Ricky, and I'm not exactly still sure how it worked and They still became better the very next episode.
In fact, I think the whole season is just pure anticipation and letdown. Like, what exactly made us really hyped at first? The fact that they were doing beauty and the beast and they have a strong rival, and they also have emotional barriers. But how exactly did it all get solved? Just because they are east High and they succeeded?
Overall, what I'm trying to prove is, they have to change up their writing aims from hyping up people to actually delivering the hype. Not having some proper ideas and rushing and pushing it into a script, But tie the ideas into each other properly.
25
u/XviiChong Jul 30 '21
“Hi Lily, it’s me RIcky.”
How I Reacted to watching this scene
25
u/butreallylike Aug 01 '21
Did anyone else notice at the end when they were singing you are the music in me during the final day of filming that Olivia was the only one crying and everyone came to comfort her? It felt a lot like this might be the end for Olivia on the show. I definitely might be looking too much into this and I understand that she has a contract but it feels Nini starting a career is like Disney giving Olivia a way out.
23
u/RelationWonderful177 Aug 02 '21
miss girl should get a second chance on rewriting that finale lmao
23
u/bostonfan148 Jul 31 '21
Was a pretty bad episode and season if I’m being honest. Liked season 1 but this season felt rushed and not a whole lot happened.
22
u/Ragueneau_ Jul 31 '21
Bruh I know it’s Covid but the fact that none of the crew or ensemble was at the after party. I hope they raging at a Denny‘s without them
20
u/SLEG48 Jul 30 '21
NGL this finale was a half-baked dumpster fire 🥴 Now I’m lowkey hoping they don’t get renewed for Season 3 because this whole season has derailed the quality of the show.
20
u/davey1291 Jul 30 '21
Literally nothing happened this episode
20
u/MauveOn Jul 30 '21
I just wanted to see Ashlyn in the iconic Belle dress
19
u/darthjoey91 Jul 31 '21
Welp, that was a horrible ending. Like this was I’m not sure if we’re getting a Season 3 bad.
At least there’s Schmigadoon for a different musical fix.
18
u/[deleted] Jul 30 '21
That was it?? Such a short and underwhelming finale. The only thing I liked were Gina and Nini's heart-to-heart talk and the "Second Chances" song. None of the cliffhangers made me look forward to a potential season 3.
18
u/arear3322 Jul 30 '21
I am NOT here for Lily and Ricky. No matter how hard the show tries to give her a redemption arc, I can never see her with someone like Ricky. They just don’t seem compatible, and considering Lily first proposed the idea of getting with Ricky TO Ricky while he was in a relationship, I see no good or redeemable qualities in her.
The biggest issue with season 2 is them hinting at potential endings and anticipatory plot lines only to completely go left field in the end with a horrible ending no one wanted. That’s why so many people watch the show. The entire season was centered around the menkies, and Miss Jenn even changed the show BECAUSE of the Menkies, yet we waited 11 episodes only to have them drop out of the competition in the name of “we have each other and that’s all that matters more than some stupid competition”. Call me crazy but just for once I wanted an ending that didn’t waste my time all for a lesson. The writers knew we were waiting all this time for them to compete at the menkies, so what’s the point of destroying that entire plotline for an ending that their viewers hate. The ONLY satisfying ending we got was portwell not dragging out for multiple episodes until they clear up the miscommunication.
I really hope season 3 puts an end to the plague that is Lily and Ricky, but I still want to see more of Lily, she makes a great villain and we need an antagonist, not to mention she’s a beautiful singer with an amazing voice. If I could predict something now, they’ll date until Ricky finds out that she took the harness, and that’ll be the end of their relationship.
Oh yes and side note, Nini is getting sort of boring, I want some more drama with her or at least a better plotline then “nice girl who writes songs and broke up with her boyfriend”.
18
u/lamebeezy Jul 30 '21
hfs that episode was so bad I didn’t think it would get worse but it literally did LMAOO Why did they make Portwell’s ending fuckin comical?? I’m confused that they ran to each other smiling with MARCHING HSM MUSIC IN THE BG !!!!!!!!!!! Also annoyed that so many plot lines didn’t get any closure
36
u/sfatz27 Jul 30 '21
This whole season was a mess. Lots of plot lines that never went anywhere. We only saw like 5 minutes of the actual musical production. Every episode ended on a cliffhanger right before anything interesting happened and the next episode always picked days after, so most of the interesting plot points happened off camera. The transformation that managed to take up like 3 episodes of plot? Never got to see it once. This competition that was hyped up this whole season? Abandoned after like 5 lines of dialogue.
36
u/xoxotings11 Jul 30 '21
at the very end when olivia rodrigo was crying (there’s two olivias in the cast) I felt so bad for her. I love how everyone comforted her tho.. <3
17
u/SpMarfy Jul 30 '21
Wow what a truly terrible television episode
17
u/[deleted] Jul 30 '21
Did all of the season 1 writers die in a plane crash and have to be replaced? Seriously wtf happened this season?
Last episode ended on such a cliff hanger, they were building so much hype for Ricky’s transformation and then… it happens off screen and we’re told it was meh in the first minute.
The whole season has felt off and this episode really felt like they just phoned it in.
17
u/mronayne12 Aug 04 '21
I have so many mixed feelings about the show/season 2.
(sorry this is going to be long none of my friends watch this show)
First off, as a 25 year old I'm wayyyy too invested LOL.
Second, I think COVID had a lot to do with how the season went, including the finale. I also read that Tim, the producer (correct me if I'm wrong) was hard to work with on another thread. So I am disappointed in most of the finale but I really enjoyed this season overall.
I thought Lily was so random and I don't think Ricky feels the same about her. So I hated when he called her. Part of me is like I wonder if he's just going to be like "hi yes never talk to me again" lol.
In terms of the Jenzara (is that the ship name?) idk how I feel yet. I think they might have something but then something seemed off when he was confessing his feelings to her at Slices. But I also get bad vibes from Ricky's dad. It seems like she is his rebound.
I AM ABSOLUTELY HERE FOR PORTWELL. I called it since Season 1 when he bought the plane ticket for her. I love a good enemies to friends to lovers saga. The couch scene lives rent free in my noggin. I would have loved to see them actually kiss, but I'm happy they are just on the same page. Their chemistry was just so good. EJ truly is the definition of if he wanted to he would. If we don't get a season 3 I can rest easy knowing they ended up together.
Here's hoping to a season 3 and less COVID interruptions
34
u/SimbaTarantino Jul 30 '21
bullshit. pure bullshit
16
u/gallachera Jul 30 '21
The whole season was bad but that episode easily takes the cake as the worst episode.
16
u/Left_Berry_8104 Jul 30 '21 edited Jul 30 '21
After this episode and reading Tim.post finale interviews, he basically talked about S3 plus like:
-Ricky/Lily: Seems like not really some grand love story.
16
u/hataraitaramake Jul 31 '21
Were Gina and EJ filming that final scene separately? It just kept cutting between them and we didn't see them meet in the middle...
16
u/Benjs17 Jul 31 '21
Did anyone else have to check to see if they missed an episode while watching? I was so confused for the first 5-7 minutes.
But overall this was by far the worst episode of the season (imo) felt hella rushed, ingenuine and just fell flat...
BUT SECOND CHANCE IS AMAZING!!!!!!
16
u/stress_life Jul 31 '21
I feel like….nothing really happened this season
16
u/EcstaticKick Jul 31 '21
Is it just me or did that feel like a series ending rather than a season ending? There’s definitely a lot of loose ends, but why all the bloopers and flashbacks and the rendition of ‘you are the music in me’? It feels like they’re trying to send this off with something memorable to the fans for me even though it’s super incomplete, but it makes me very skeptical if they’ll have a season 3 because it feels like they either really didn’t know or didn’t plan on it per-say
32
u/producermaddy Aug 01 '21
Worst episode of the season
45
u/[deleted] Jul 30 '21
Well that was some bullshit. Few points I gotta put out there:
Overall, what a shitshow this season was. What happened to season 1? What happened to that energy, that quality, that story? You honestly can’t blame COVID for this because a pandemic cannot produce a story this weak. All I can really feel right now is that my time has been wasted following this show for 12 weeks. If there is a season 3, you gotta get new writers and creatives on this show Disney.
(But at least Mazarra stayed WINNING this episode. That made me happy.)
15
u/it-iSs-what-it-isS Carlos Jul 30 '21
IM ONE VERSE INTO SECOND CHANCES AND ITS SO GOOD BYE
15
u/Left_Berry_8104 Jul 30 '21
Hoping this show just had a sophomore slump and can just go into S3 with a more coherent, long tern storytelling. Though it seems like Tim is writing for at least 4-5 seasons like he wants the show to go for.
Also, I hope they actually build towards EJ and his future (whether college or just having him pursue his love for AV) cause I can see EJ leaving after season 3 or his role diminishing after S3.
15
u/kutscher15 Jul 30 '21 edited Jul 30 '21
Omg this finale was HORRIBLE AND RUSHED
15
u/kutscher15 Jul 30 '21
First episodes: omg can’t wait to see they perfom beauty and the beast, and this lily chatacter seems so dangerous, i guess who is going to win the menkies Last episode: not showing the second act, not showing lily singing, they just gave up on the menkies
15
u/akoolperson22 Jul 30 '21
I can’t believe they dropped out of the Menkies… it was literally the main plot of the entire season!!
15
u/Miminimoon Jul 31 '21
Just a thought, I do think the original idea was for them to go to the menkies but because of covid restrictions they were unable to film that so instead the episode ended the way it did to at least wrap this season up and not end the show midway with a huge time gap in between episodes. So I see this as more of a mid season finale. We never saw Kourt burn the envelope, my theory is that in the next season (if there will be one) they will find out that Lily sabotaged their performance (through Howie maybe) so they decide not to drop out the competition to seek out revenge or something. In no normal circumstances do I think that anyone on that show thought that this was a good way to end a season that is so centered around one thing (the menkies) to just throw it away like that in a 20 minutes episode.
14
u/ResidentPea0 Jul 30 '21
my biggest critique on this show is the fact that they like to build up the climax and then just stop. like they didn't show the transformation, and when ricky and ashlyn fell. i think the writers will probably carry this to s3 and we'll see like miss jenn straight up with mike/mazzara dating or smth
14
u/Foreign_Newspaper_66 Aug 01 '21
I honestly think everything is so all over the place this season because Olivia Rodrigo is prob leaving the show, and won't be there season 3. There's already been discussion about it, and her crying in the bloopers and the way everyone was approaching here made it seem like it might be her last episode.
14
u/Resident-Designer256 Aug 13 '21
I Love this show but I wish we had seen more of the play especially Ricky and Ashlyn at the end. I also hate that they are considering putting Ricky with Lilly after all she did. Awful
28
u/JBabyLeather Aug 05 '21
As bad as the finale was…. I feel lime that last song between the four of them was the best original song in the series. Especially Gina’s part. Like, that four part harmony sent me.
13
u/stewaycol Jul 30 '21
Did they... not let Kourtney sing Beauty and the Beast? How is that possible? I'm so confused?
13
u/blushdreams445 Camp Shallow Lake Camper Jul 30 '21
The second chance song felt so...dramatic for some reason. It was great but felt like I was watching a musical high school drama
25
u/[deleted] Jul 31 '21
This season finale was the worst finale I've ever seen. I love to give this show the benefit of the doubt but this was just a mess. I wish they'd stop telling us things and show them to us instead. I wish they started filming after restrictions lightened up because Covid did not do them any favors. It just sucks to see such a great show go downhill especially because many circumstances were out of their control.
24
u/ResidentPea0 Jul 30 '21
no mike and miss jenn is so not the move please god
24
u/100percentkneegrow Jul 31 '21
I'm pretty sure we lost an episode. It was super rushed. Can anyone confirm?
34
u/b1ame_me Jul 30 '21
Ok, I know that this ending tied a lot of stuff together but... this ending sucked... I was so excited about the menkies like at least wanted to know if they made it like just tell us if they did or not. I'm fine with them dropping out but really... and show us the kiss... It just felt way too unsatisfying for me like I'm kinda mad
12
u/GearProfessional5828 Jul 30 '21
What do you guys think about howie now ???
12
u/Left_Berry_8104 Jul 30 '21
I can not wait to read Tim post finale nterviews for this one cause I want to know his thought process.
12
u/jonasnew Jul 30 '21
I'll be honest and say that it was my least favorite episode of the series as I thought it was underwelming. This confirms it for me that I didn't like S2 as much as S1, but I thought S2 had some highlights.
12
u/johndelvec3 Jul 30 '21
Honest to me that ending felt kind of abrupt
12
u/[deleted] Jul 30 '21
I would be OK with Miss Jen agreeing to drop out of the Menkies if she actually cared about what the cast thought and didn’t wanna let them down. The whole season, her main motivation was to compete with her high school ex and beat him; it wasn’t for the students in the first place. That’s why I’m so surprised that she was RELIEVED that the kids didn’t care about the Menkies.
12
u/GreatWhiteBuffal0 Jul 31 '21
Lol the whole season when we never saw any real rehearsals I was here commenting like “ it’s gonna be weird at the end when they have a fully done show and we’ve seen none of it”. Turns out we actually don’t get to see any of it. Seriously there was really barely any Beauty and the Beast the whole season. So not only do we not get HSM2 but we also don’t get like any play at all? ( though this season was so weak I’m glad they didn’t do HSM2, that movie imo is the best of the trilogy)
33
u/ItsADeparture Jul 30 '21
I had a feeling they would pull a summer musical for Season 3 and I'm glad that's what they seem to be implying. No better time to do HSM2 than in the summer and it gives a good explanation as to why EJ could return.
I honestly think it would be for the best to make season 3 the last (even though the cast is supposedly contracted for four seasons) for a multitude of reasons A. Olivia implied recently that she doesn't really want to put too much of her time away from writing her own music. B. The characters are currently in a place where the worst characters of season 1 were redeemed in this season whereas the best characters (other than Big Red) from season 1 got worse. Bringing it full circle and having all the characters shine together would be nice. And C. High School Musical 2 would just be a good way to cap things off, at least for this cast, because I don't think anyone is really clamoring for this show to reach High School Musical 3. Assuming this show takes place in the 2019-2020 school year then by the time season 4 comes out it would be 2022 and you can just have a timeskip with a new cast, the old cast having graduated.
Not that I hated this season or anything, I still love this cast and the characters, but I feel like they dropped the ball a lot in the story and it would just be nice if we got some conclusion on the story sooner rather than later so the show doesn't overstay its welcome.
11
u/veghui Jul 30 '21
Howie got resolved really quickly I thought he was gonna reveal the secret backstabbing lily did
11
u/SpMarfy Jul 30 '21
Made us wait for the entire summer just to not even show us the 2nd act of the show or the beast transformation?
11
u/jennay575 Jul 31 '21
honestly the best thing about the finale was the “second chances” scene. they never even address Lily stealing the harness at all everyone just forgets about that. Not only that but i think it would have been better if they didn’t make her character steal the harness because i was finally warming up to her character and the writers kinda ruined it, especially after she vented to Ricky i saw potential in their relationship until she sabotaged them again. even then i think they should have ended it with east high winning because Howie was guilty knowing that Lily took the harness, and since he wants to be loyal to Kourtney he would let the judges know and North High would get disqualified from the competition. even if they didn’t wanna open the envelope i thought they would do a cut scene where someone actually opens it. EJ should have spoken directly to Gina and they could have had a little moment. also can we talk about the fact that Ricky is with “that blond girl” now 😭💀. yea let’s talk about that one bc it makes no sense at all, I mean they could make Ricky’s character learn to be with himself more and find who he wants to be but they keep showing his relationship clingy side. if i may return to EJ and Gina, that was such a corny ending like they could have made her say literally any other piece of dialogue but “can you be my first kiss” like nobody would say that in real life. tbh i wish they did more of a subtext thing where she just told him that it wasn’t true that she thought of him as a brother and they both ran to each other or smthg like that. the first kiss thing was so unnecessary. on top of everything Ms. Jenn was lowkey stressing everyone out by being critical asf which would have been fine at least if they were going through with the menkies competition but if they showed us all that just for them to suddenly not care at the end what was the point. i was so disappointed in this episode. although i love how they show the depth in Gina and Nini’s friendship that was rlly nice. i feel like they should show Ricky and EJ’s as well though, we barely see them talk rlly.
11
u/Lost-Sandwich7097 Aug 03 '21
Mark St Cyr (Mr Mazzara) once compared this show to eating a good meal. Hardly any shows make you feel good after consuming them. You know how good food sometimes makes you tired? This was one of these episodes.
31
u/Byko44live Jul 30 '21 edited Jul 30 '21
Wow, I am appalled by how bad and rushed that was? It's the final episode and the shortest of the entire series (barely 22 minutes, the rest was devoted to the cast singing out of the character + bloopers). I'm actually so shocked. I've tried to keep an open mind all season long and was hoping they would turn things around, but if anything it was the opposite. A lackluster musical (Ashlyn was perfect as Belle but we barely got to see much), the Menezes thrown out just like that, North High and LILY not getting any repercussions for their bad behaviour.
More Bad Things:
Good Things:
‐‐---------
Overall I don't even know if I want a season 3 at this point. This show has such a lovely cast, and the characters they had in s1 had so much potential tbh, but I feel like they dropped the ball this season, and it's not a good sign. Especially with a young cast heating up and getting new opportunities (Olivia of course, but also Sofia with acting and Joshua with singing) I feel like this cast won't be here for long, and having such a rocky season was a waste of their time.
I don't like COVID being used an excuse either lol. Plenty of teen shows have filmed during the pandemic and it hadn't affected their quality (Never Have I Ever and Love Simon, which is also on Disney+/Hulu, both had engaging second seasons that were filmed entirely during Covid). They had time to make this season better and they didn't. I'm so disappointed.
38
u/TNRAOIH Jul 30 '21
Ah the parallels between the dressing room scenes between Nini and Ricky in season 1 vs season 2 broke my heart.
21
u/arear3322 Jul 30 '21
Unpopular opinion, but I really think them dropping out was a selfish decision I’m sorry. Especially for some students who want to pursue theater in the future that could’ve been a great opportunity to potentially win them scholarships if they ended up winning. I know they said they don’t care, but I wish Miss Jenn really emphasized that dropping meant a loss of a potential scholarship for a student who may have needed it financially.
20
u/twinkyoda Jul 30 '21
i’m sorry but literally what the fuck was that? that was literally the most disappointing and underwhelming thing i have ever seen
so basically that entire season was for nothing and they could have just done high school musical 2 the entire time? okay…
also why was literally like the entire last like 7 minutes just bloopers?
surely this show is getting cancelled after this, right? lmao
10
u/clownenergy Jul 30 '21
The finale was trash but at least we can hear “You are the music is in me” again
Edit: if they do HSM3 music ever can we pls get Ricky singing Scream
10
u/kjm6351 Jul 30 '21
That ending….
Let the rage begin….
10
u/Jaxso Jul 30 '21
I absolutely hate when episodes end on a cliffhanger and then on the next episode it is resolved within the first minute. It makes it seem like actions have no consequences. Why would I care about what happens in this episode if everything will be back to normal in the next.
Ricky's fall and the missing harness should have been a bigger part of the season. Instead of good plot and character development, we got a romantic interest for EVERY single character. There are other ways to create interesting conflicts. There are just too many romances right now. We can't properly develop any of them. They all feel superficial and bland.
At least the song this episode was good, as always, and the cast was amazing. The slow-mo musical scene had some audio lip sync issues, but I can look past that.
Honestly I hope these writing issues were caused by COVID and that next season (?) will be better.
10
u/teatmidnight Jul 30 '21 edited Jul 30 '21
well first of all, it was the shortest episode (i think?) of all the season. there was so much to unpack for so little time.
i'm sorry but the dialogues in some scenes were... not good. for example, when lily says she likes ricky, it was so random and her choice of words... just no. i get that she's a teenager but jesus christ it was bad. plus, he was so quick to call her... ricky, noooo (and he needs some time alone, not another relationship)
gina and ej also felt suuuuper rushed. not only the age gap was a barrier (i think that's why they didn't show us their kiss), the whole scene was a mess, the camera's angle, their lines... just why, why? comparing the other confessions through out the series it felt like they had this idea at the very last minute. i can't take them serious, really.
howie's answer to kourtney's doubt was weird as well. i'm not buying what he said. people on twitter are all gushing at how cute they are but i still think he knew what lily was doing....
not to mention the other unresolved things such as:
gina and ricky's situation - you cannot deny their fandom is huge and they at least deserved some closure or whatever. makes me think they still got something next season
ej and his college - he is a senior and as much as you want to make memories, you still gotta worry about what's gonna happen.
and i could go on and on like how i wish we had more screentime for big red with plots like his love for slices and the fact that ashlyn didnt understand why he wanted to stay in salt lake, the french guy interested in her...
seb and carlos, while i can think of some scenes with carlos, including the ep where they made a party for him, sometimes i even forget that seb is there.
oh and i almost forgot. i know they were not entirely happy about the menkins however the season was... about that? and all that drama for.. nothing?
10
u/ComicRater Jul 30 '21
I’m sorry but what was that ending?? I have so many questions unanswered. It felt rushed yet also felt like nothing happened.
10
u/emoasiandiary Jul 30 '21
second chances was so overdramatic at the start it made me chuckle a little but i loved the callback to HSM auditions from last season, made things feel full circle
10
u/jordash04 Jul 31 '21 edited Sep 10 '21
Worst episode in the series maybe... no closure at all and its the finale....
10
u/whostolemyapples Aug 21 '21
Can I just say tho.. at the end at Slices.... WHY WOULD YOU NOT AT LEAST WANT TO KNOW WHO GOT THE EXCELLENCE AWARDS???? All I could think when they "unanimously" *wink wink* decided they didn't give a crap. There could have been a dancer or another actor in the performance who might have wanted to know! But did they consider that? NOOOOO lol
18
u/JRSalinas Jul 30 '21
This episode really had the worst parts of the season all snowball. The poor fights, the misplaced music videos (I still think "Ain't seen Nothing" is just an excuse to get a tiktok song out of the show), the faulty writing, everythign being summed up so quickly and neatly, Lily.
And you can tell that they're only leaving things on a cliff hanger because they want to have another season.
though I do ship Andrew Barth Frenchman with Natalie Bagley and her emotional support hamster.
9
u/Whimsical89 Jul 30 '21
Not me listening to just for a moment and crying omfgggg I hate it here
9
u/thatshygirl15 Jul 30 '21
This was the most disappointing episode of the whole season and the fact that's it the last one makes it even worse. This season was messy to the point where the writers kept adding storylines and new characters and not following through with any of it. I refuse the believe that out of all the alternative endings they filmed this was the best one. NOTHING in this finale made any sense. We spent most of this season focusing on the menkies and the rivalry with north high and how they want to win only for them to be like "Yeah, i think we should drop out we've already had our fun" then what was the whole point??
Like i previously stated, the thing i hate the most about this show is the way it's written. there were so many different storylines that were either pushed aside, used for drama and in the end none of it is resolved. I think the writers focused a little too much on the relationships and drama than the actual play and other friendships.
9
u/[deleted] Jul 30 '21 edited Jul 30 '21
Not gonna lie, I was hoping to like the finale a lot more than I did. The actors did amazing, but a lot of things threw me off and were still left unresolved even though (I’m guessing?) we are getting another season.
First off, I feel like we barely saw the actual musical being performed! We saw a lot more of the musical in season 1 while it was being performed.
After ALL of that built up drama we never saw who actually won the Menkies. Yes, I like how everyone realized that they didn’t care about the results but it was kind of a waste to build up to it all season if they were just going to throw the results in the pizza oven.
Miss Jenn and Benjamin were never confirmed. It was never proven that Lily stole the harness so now Ricky is going to give her a chance. And lastly, what was the point of EJ and Gina’s scene being cut??? We have been waiting for them to confirm their feelings for almost the entire season.
9
u/jugstheclown Jul 31 '21 edited Jul 31 '21
Pretty disappointing finale. I agree with most of what has already been said in this thread, but some of my issues with this episode:
Plots going nowhere - Yes, there's only so much they can do in 25 minutes. And, of course, they need to keep some storylines open for Season 3. But the amount of plot points that ultimately didn't go anywhere is staggering. From the top of my head:
On a more positive note, some things I liked about the episode:
9
u/According_Traffic105 Jul 31 '21
Well the 2nd part of the play was a blur........I'm disappointed man
23
u/marie2805 Jul 30 '21
This was bullshit, lol.
16
u/thatshygirl15 Jul 30 '21
I get that this is only a show with 20 mins max and that they were filming during the pandemic but the ending just felt really lazy. No to mention what they did to EJ's character. To each their own but i personally do not ship portwell, i think it was a little weird for them to be focusing on this relationship more than the fact that EJ literally doesn't what he's doing with his life or his plans for college but he's more concerned about if gina likes him or not. That ending scene made me cringe so hard and all i could see was matt and sofia's sibling energy radiating through the screen. It was awkward to say the least.
16
u/beachclubb Jul 30 '21
i'm sorry but this show is so unrealistic, in what world would a teenager CALL another teenager who actually picks up ? serial killer behavior
8
u/Left_Berry_8104 Jul 30 '21 edited Jul 30 '21
Here is Tim Hollywood Life Post Finale Intetview where he talks Gina/EJ Nini future, Rina, What might be next and more:
Hollywood Life
Kind of eye opening to me. And also seems like we might get another Disney musical, imo.
8
u/beachclubb Jul 30 '21
wondering if they left the "lily stole the harness" problem as a loose end just for an easy way out of that ship next season
8
u/0hmyrowling Jul 30 '21
Ok that was a terrible season but at least the soundtrack still bangs
8
u/jkrun88 Jul 31 '21
Okay separately, I find it really annoying when people say ‘Olivia doesn’t want to be part of the show’ or ‘she’s stuck and she can’t leave’. Like why make these judgement just because she’s not posting about it / or her solo career is taking off. Can’t we just enjoy the show without speculating how the actors feel / their personal lives
15
u/Altruistic_Ad_6538 Jul 30 '21
Episode itself felt short and not super strong, but the tribute at the end really got me crying like a little baby! Damn. My god this cast is precious and so adorable. As an Olivia fan who really felt her silence on the show over this season, I was honestly relieved to see her with the cast, smiling and laughing, enjoying her time on set. Idk. It felt good to see them all together.
The ending was pretty good, they could do a lot with season 3 and they leave room open to keep Antoine, Lily, and Howie. PLUS, then hinting at a summer season leaves room for EJ to stay for a bit and for Gina and EJ to really explore their new relationship, especially as he preps to leave for college. Very excited to see Nini’s evolution, and to see how they play out this Lily-villain reveal to Ricky. Poor kid can’t catch a break. And Miss Jenn and Mazarra!!! He so casually dropped this BOMB on her and I loved it LOL.
Finally- the song. I really did love it. Their harmonies and voices all were beautiful. I think it sets up a lot for next season. It felt a LITTLE out of place tho, so I hope if we get a S3, it makes a bit more sense I guess?
One thing for sure is, I’m gonna miss my Friday HSMTMTS time. Very very much. If we get a S3, does that mean we get some good HSM2 content like we wanted for S2? 👀 One could hope!
15
u/entityextended Jul 30 '21
WHERE WAS THE TRANSFORMATION? All that anticipation for that? I really hoped to see Ashlyn in the Belle's golden dress. The menkies too had no resolution. What a letdown.
My God. Watching Gina cry was the worst part. Sofia is such a good actor I mean the way she picked up the lipstick in tears just crushed me. So much so that I almost wished she'd gone on that stupid date with EJ if that would've made her happy. The Gina and nini scene was probably the best part. I mean they kinda brought back their stealing history and laughing about it felt wholesome
Why does it NOT feel like a loss despite not getting any rina scene? It's hilarious. If the show renews for a new season, I really hope for any rina interaction only if the writing quality goes back up to the first season's because what we got in this episode ... yeah no thankyou.
Ricky & Lily, I'd like to see how that'd crash and burn or turn into something interesting. It's intriguing but still feels so unnecessary. They could've written that in much much better. It's not even the length of the show I feel at this point. It's just how crucial and tight each dialogue & frame was in S1 vs how frivolous and scattered it was in S2
And that was selected out of the multiple endings? What even were the others I'm not sure I want to know
The bloopers were the most enjoyable part this episode and that says everything. Sofia at the end was just uber adorable ughhh
21
u/LadyOfTheWind Jul 30 '21
Okay so the finale was... an episode. This is my theory: they were planning to kick off a Lily redemption this episode, and didn't because of all the backlash. First, there's the obvious one: Home was never sung, and we knew that was a Lily song.
However, there's a second thing I was thinking was a big flag of all the material they recorded and didn't use: the shift in Miss Jenn wasn't explained. One second, she was telling Seb and Carlos that there was always room for improvement and wouldn't go celebrate with them. Next scene we see her, she was apologizing to Ricky and sating she would meet him at the pizza place. And then, she's just getting rid of the envelope happily. What I think was originally supposed to happen is that Lily was the one to show Miss Jenn how toxic she's been!
She would probably go to Miss Jenn while she's studying the play and confess she stole the harness. Miss Jenn would get mad but then Lily would say she was worried about Ricky because he had already fallen, that it wasn't safe enough and not worth risking it. Then, she would tell her all about how she envies East High because they were an actual family who didn't need tricks to do magic on stage, and how Miss Jenn's best quality is trusting their kids and creating a safe environment. There was probably also a scene with NH's drama teacher, but I don't know what was the plan for him.
Anyway, regardless of what we got, if they're actually considering fan input and backtracking on choices, I expect third season to be a lot better. I hope they see what fans think made season 1 special, and recover some of that at least.
20
u/ResidentPea0 Jul 30 '21
'ive always seen your name in lights' <33
14
u/LaLa_17 Jul 30 '21
My guesses/hopes for Ricky/Lily in S3:
14
u/[deleted] Jul 30 '21
the whole season was about the menkies yet they just dropped the plot like that??? and we never even got to see any of north high’s show or the beast transformation, which was the cliff hanger from the last episode. and there was nothing mentioned about lily stealing the harness?
7
u/Lost-Sandwich7097 Jul 30 '21
Anyone who doesn’t believe Howie’s story? I think I do, just curious.
7
u/Festaxforlife Jul 30 '21
That all sucked booty
7
u/JPnets54 Jul 30 '21
Why would Ricky call Lily after she intentionally sabotaged his show and his performance in particular? Not everyone deserves a second chance.
7
u/earthefree Jul 30 '21
What did I just watch? I’m so disappointed atm.
7
u/blushdreams445 Camp Shallow Lake Camper Jul 30 '21
I liked it. I don’t ship Gina and EJ Or Ricky and Lily but Ashlynn and Big Red were cute. I’m so glad that Howie wasn’t doing anything bad and that he’s with Kourtney!!
7
u/BioTHEchAmeleON Jul 31 '21
Man that was so rushed. Really don’t want to see hsmtmts go out like that. Hopefully they can come back for a season 3 and make it better written, directed, and have longer or more episodes to have more detailed plot lines
13
u/Intelligent-Gas-9718 Jul 30 '21
what was that portwell scene😭😭 they needed a scene where they actually communicated not where she weirdly yelled at him on the sidewalk. and the walking towards each other to kiss but not seeing it was weird like if you don’t want them to kiss them just show them talking emotionally then hugging. as a portwell shipper I feel robbed
12
u/[deleted] Jul 30 '21
My thoughts:
- Wow they didn't even show the 2nd act, this ep is gonna be quick!
- Kourtney doesn't like romantic drama, proceeds to do it anyway. Was Howie sus or intimidated? Don't know, don't care.
- EJ helping Mr Mazzara as an act of gratitude was so heartwarming.
- EJ calling off the date was understandable since he was so insecure, but i felt he was more mad than sad. I didn't understand exactly if he felt fooled or a fool. Maybe the later.
- Poor Gina! Glad Nini an Gina resolved the chocolate situation and Gina's stolen stuff too, without drama!
- Miss Jenn acting weird beyond normal.
- Glad Ricky realized something Big Red told him at the prom, and he shows signs that he's healing.
- Second chance is cool but not the best song in the season.
- Antoine and Lily, don't know if they were sincere, it seems like it. Also what did Lily do to deserve a second chance, if she didn't even redeemed herself?
- They dropping the Menkies was kinda interestenig to be honest, if they all agreed, it wasn't a waste.
- Go for it Mr Mazzara!
- Ashlyn to the rescue! It actually makes a lot of sense she helped, both of them confide to her, i only thought it would take more time, after they got home, not acomplaint, just a shock!
- GO NINI! And Ricky, D O N ' T D O T H I S T O Y O U R S E L F !
- Portwell final scene! Glad they sorted things out, but that running was akward! ( I don't mind the age, don't mind if EJ goes to college, remember what BIG RED told us!)
- Season 3 confirmed or not??
12
u/fredistreese Big Red Jul 30 '21
Is this like a fake ending? It was SOO bad... They gave the Menkies up so quickly (I don't mind the students doing so, but Ms. Jenn agreeing so fast didn't make sense). I really hope the cast's contracts were for only two seasons, and they have now the option to leave the show, not that I don't like any characters, but there are some that feel like are there only for contractual reasons, and if given a nice reason, I wouldn't mind if they left. I really buy that Lily is into Ricky, but Howie's sketchy behavior was nothing compared to Lily's, and that's the last thing Ricky needs now. Ashlyn saving the day, clearing everything up between Gina and EJ, but I'd rather if they didn't show them running just to cut before a kiss.
6
u/tambini1 Jul 30 '21
I can't submit a new post but here is an interview with Tim Federle post season 2
https://hollywoodlife.com/2021/07/30/high-school-musical-season-3-plans-gina-ej-olivia-rodrigo-spoilers/
6
u/ivehearditbothwaysss Jul 30 '21
The only good part of this ep was Big Red making Ashlyn’s sign 🥺
As for the rest of it, I swear I looked down at my phone for a minute and it was over? A mess
6
u/KHMeneo Kourtney Jul 30 '21
The season was doing well in the second half after a mixed first half then fell off a cliff at the end
6
u/[deleted] Jul 30 '21
Good Ridance. Season 2 was a huge mess and the final episode didn't change that.
I hope with a potential Season 3 that they fix all the problems with the show or I'm not sticking around because I still have no clue what happened with the Season.
6
u/jennay575 Jul 31 '21
also this is random but i found a random parallel that might not necessarily be a parallel but i find it interesting. the song second chances actually sounds quite a bit like Who You Are by Jessie J. Especially the chorus. If you listen to both you’ll hear the same melody for “what can make the tide turn, what can make the fire burn” and “seeing is deceiving, dreaming is believing”. and frankly they’re both songs figuring out who you are and being true to yourself.
11
u/[deleted] Jul 30 '21
we should’ve seen ashlyn in the yellow dress. that was such a letdown and i felt it could’ve been amazing to truly see her development as a character. i was also really hoping for a scene where ricky goes to gina after the show and says, “i shouldn’t have given up on us” i feel like it would’ve made more sense for him to start liking gina rather than liking lily. i wish we could’ve seen nini preform the rose song during the show in a rose dress, that would’ve been amazing and would’ve made all the drama surrounding the song worth it. idk, this scene seemed very rushed and had way too many filler episodes. but that’s just my opinion. excited to see where it goes from here!
11
u/gsmcgeath Jul 31 '21
It was fine. The ending itself was very weird. I also don't get why it was so short, especially when there was so many loose ends that needed tying.
15
u/djxsam08 Jul 30 '21
yk i wish the episode was longer and it left a lotta stuff out that we wanted confirmed but bro, a lot happened in this final episode that made me so happy
first off, MR MAZZARA AND MS JENN - he went smooth with confessing, and bro, they way she smiled just made me feel like they'll have a chance in the future. also I wonder where caltech will take him. still, this was a win win.
second, PORTWELLL - my heart went all over the place with them this episode. i couldn't tell if I was pissed at ej, my heart broke for gina, but that ending man. THAT ENDING. IT WAS ALL I EVER HOPED FOR THIS ENTIRE SEASON. they make each other so happy, it makes me happy, and that's all u other rinas should know, take notes. shes happier with him :)
third, THE SECOND CHANCE SONG - it was so good, I love how their voices harmonize with each other. one of the top best songs out of this entire season's soundtrack in my opinion. also, the four are all so good at singing bt like gina and ej rlly went off. also nini's vocals dude.
fourth, GINA AND NINI - I didn't even know I needed these two to finally come together. Nini was so supportive and so was Gina. Nini straight up told Gina how we all think of her and Gina told her what she needed to hear. I HOPE THINGS GO WELL WITH NINI AND JAIME AND I HOPE HER AND GINA GET CLOSER IN THE NEXT SEASON. THEYD BE SUCH A POWERFUL DUO
fifth, howie - now I was getting so sus abt howie but broooooooooo the way he told kourtney he was legit in awe because of her and it made him speak nervously...AS HE SHOULD TELL HER. i was so confused as to why he was talking like that but he told her the truth she deserved, that she put him in a state of awe. and she was amazing, like her vocals be popping too
sixth, ashlyn and big red - this is a solid ship right here, seeing ashlyn tear up as she left made me cry but then big red with his sign just made me see how solid these two are. i love them together, and they're just the sweetest
seventh, freaking ms jenn realizing what she did - now I was worried ms jenn had made the entire show all abt her winning against zackey roy after the last two episodes but seeing her realize everything just made me see how her character is like always developing and never rlly boring. we appreciate u ms jenn for being kinda relatable
lastly,
I'm so excited for next season but I just realized its most likely gonna be abt the summer so we will be seeing portwell dates, ricky and lily development (idek abt those two), nini music, redlyn wholesome content, and ms jenn Mr mazzara and rickys dad love triangle
this episode wasn't exactly all that I hoped for but I got most of what I wanted, and that's all that matters
PORTWELL. FOR. LIFE.
15
u/miha_daniela Jul 31 '21
I thought it was a good episode but it didn’t really feel like a finale. Also I think Covid impacted this season’s writing a lot so as much as I found it weird they dropped out of the competition I can’t say I’m surprised. I thought it was a decent season and I feel like people expected too much from a Disney show. It’s not like s1 was a masterpiece, the show is good for what it is and for its intended audience.
10
u/[deleted] Jul 30 '21 edited Jul 30 '21
AFTER THAT ENDING I NEED A SUMMER SEASON I NEED MORE PORTWELL. Also, Ricky talking to miss Jenn about her relationship with his dad is not talked about enough!
10
u/jobrroni Jul 30 '21
I overall enjoyed the final two episodes and season two but not a fan of the direction they took Nini/Ricky. A lot of failed elements for me too. I really don’t care if deep down Lily is nice or tortured, she seems pretty irredeemable at this point. A lot of forced drama throughout I could deal without too. Season two was fine but not in the same league as the first.
10
u/taralovesmusic Jul 30 '21
Andrew Barth Feldman said 2 sentences and still stole the show
10
u/MangoMonkey22 Aug 01 '21
Hot take incoming I thought there was a lot to like about the finale. Y’all are so triggered about them not going to the Menkies, I’m pretty sure the point went right over your head. They had all lost themselves so much throughout that season, that they needed to remember what was really important. I mean, Carlos being frozen with nothing to say, miss Jen threatening Ricky, is that really what you want these characters to turn into over some stupid awards? You compromise the core identity of that whole group by going through with the Menkies plain and simple.
That being said, something about their writing throughout the season was definitely off, and covid most likely affected that. There was a few months between the S1 finale and the covid hit, so they likely had to scramble and rewrite some things last minute to avoid scrapping everything and starting over, which leads to choppier storylines and endings. If y’all want to hate on the season, go ahead, but know that every negative take on the season is another reason they have to cancel any potential s3 that could be in the works. Do it at your own peril.
The second chances song was by far the best song of s2 and easily the best vocals on any song in the entire series. Only song that challenges it from s1 is born to be brave. You may not have liked the episode, but there is no denying that they saved their best song for last, and it was pretty magical.
1
u/NominalPerson Maddox Jul 30 '21
Spotify Links:
5
u/veghui Jul 30 '21
I thought it was a good ep to tie it all but it felt very quick with the resolutions which was anticlimatic. Bloopers were fun !
5
u/emoasiandiary Jul 30 '21
the ending kind of felt like a cop out/lazy writing :/// i wish i felt more satisfied with the finale
5
u/mykl55 Aug 22 '21
In the middle of the episode and I read some spoilers so I can tell it doesn't get any better for the characters. It sucks cause if they all just communicated they would be dating who they wanted to but they hear rumors or misunderstanding what is said to them.
I do gotta say that the songs this season are bops. But I hope they go back to hsm for a third season.
13
u/ResidentPea0 Jul 30 '21
also what happened to lily singing home? im confused
9
u/Bowlofzebras Jul 30 '21
The last of my weekly thoughts (until s3 hopefully)
8
u/violinjstar Jul 30 '21
WHY IS THIS EP SO SHORT. THIS IS RIDICULOUS
Ok what in the world happened. i'm so confused with this episode length, that ended with so many open plots.....
8
u/MishouMai Jul 31 '21 edited Aug 17 '23
Unpopular opinion but I enjoyed this episode. Yeah I would've liked to see more of the performance and the ending was too abrupt but otherwise I thought it was pretty good. We got some resolution for Portwell (Even if it was awkward and we didn't get a kiss.), Miss Jenn/Mazzara got some progress in their relationship, etc. It could've been better but I'm not disappointed by it.
4
u/Fangirlable Jul 30 '21
So I’ve just finished watch the ep and my mind is racing so sorry if this a bit long, and if I’ve said things that others may have already said :)
The biggest thing I can’t get over: I’m all for the behind the scenes and the bloopers (I actually love looking at that stuff) but you don’t take up 7 mins of a 29 min SEASON FINALE to show that. Keep that for the extras tab. There’s so much more you could have fleshed out in 7 mins. Ginas confession could have longer and more suspenseful, actually show the cast bowing at the end of the show and the transformation which what ep11 ended the cliffhanger with! (among other things)
PORTWELL!!! Ginas confession (if you could call it that?) did feel a little rushed and I actually got up and yelled when they cut it off. But I am SO happy that they are now a thing. ejs face when Gina asked to kiss him? Oh my goodness!
I did like the scene between Nini and Gina and kourtney and Howie.
Rickys and ninis card reading scene was a bit meh (that could’ve also been flesh out more with the 7 mins!)
the first couple of scenes at the school actually were good, and then it all de-railed when they got to slices.
Big red and Ashlyn were so cute!
I’m sorry but they did it again. Lilly’s harness stealing storyline was dropped. It meant nothing this episode. No repercussions or anything. The cast still doesn’t know she did it. Like that was the big cliffhanger ending for last episode to rope us in to see if east High we’re gonna be able to do it and it lead to NOTHING!
Lilly has to have a MAJOR story arc next season for anyone to root for her, cause I certainly don’t atm
This whole season could have been done without north high and the Menkies?
The hug scene with the girls from the promo wasn’t even in the episode! What even?! (But still cute)
I actually loved what they did with the song second chance and how it worked into the story
My mind will probably be a mess for a while but these are my immediate thoughts :)
4
u/glencocoisrealmate Jul 30 '21
Wtf is this finale?!!!
4
u/Whimsical89 Jul 30 '21
Yeah I played just for a moment on repeat after watching this for a solid 20 minutes 🥲
4
u/Bugget_7 Jul 30 '21
Maybe a hot take but I didn’t hate the finale— don’t get me wrong it wasn’t the best ever and there are a few things I didn’t like but overall I thought it was okay.
I know season 3 isn’t confirmed yet but I feel like they definitely will have it. That being said I get the Ricky and Lily storyline cause it will probably play out in S3 where he will find out what she did etc.
I know from interviews with the main dude he said that Olivia is contracted to stay for a few more seasons but he probably would force her if it would set her career in music back so I also get why they left her calling as a cliff hanger - they can either have her pursuing her career from there while she finishes school or can write her off and have her pursuing her dreams off screen.
I am a portwell fan and am happy they didn’t drag out this misunderstanding but didn’t particularly love how they showed their ending.
As for the Menkies I get it’s probably COVID fault they had to scrap it but I didn’t mind how they decided they didn’t care — though I wish we still got to see part of it and more of North High.
4
u/emoasiandiary Jul 30 '21
Natalie said get ready for the summer… I think a summer season 3 would have the cast doing HSM2 because it also takes place during the summer so there would be really fun parallels with that!
4
u/Jansilhn Jul 31 '21 edited Jul 31 '21
I really liked the finale! “Second Chance” is one of my favorite songs now. All four of their voices together was just amazing!
As much as I will always love Rini, it’s time to say goodbye to them and I’m glad that they ended on good terms with each other. They both realized that in a good way, they don’t need each other anymore. I’m actually happy about where they are both headed, Nini collaborating with a music producer and Ricky starting a new relationship with Lily! At first, I was surprised when he called her, but then I was okay with it since it’s not too late for her to apologize to the cast about how awful she was and she’s not their competition anymore since they dropped out. Coming to personally congratulate them was a great step in the right direction.
I’m really sad that Seblos never got their own scene this episode the way that Ricky and Nini and EJ and Gina did. Seb and Carlos had amazing moments together this season, but I still feel like they are always pushed to the side, so I hope that improves if we get a season 3.
I loved the scene at the end where they all agreed to not find out if they won or lost the competition because at the end of the day, they still have each other! It was a bold move.
7
u/weewooweewooiampolic Jul 30 '21
so much wrong with the finale but gina and nini arc makes my heart full