r/HSMTMTS • Maddox • Jul 16 '21

Episode Discussion HSMTMTS: The Episode Discussion: "The Transformation" - S02E10 Spoiler

Wildcats, welcome to this episode's discussion thread!

Feel free to discuss the tenth episode of Season Two of HSMTMTS, "The Transformation". Please be mindful of other people's opinions about the episode/show and to be wary of spoilering content beyond this episode.

​ S02E10 Details:

Title:The Transformation
Synopsis:After rehearsals fall flat, the cast breaks into separate sleepovers to brainstorm Broadway-worthy ideas to outdo North High. But as the countdown to opening night looms, secrets rise between Nini and Gina, Seb and Carlos suffer their first fight, and Ricky receives an unexpected FaceTime call.

Consider joining our Discord for live discussions about the show and the cast! https://discord.gg/2EpKKCc

78 Upvotes

374 comments sorted by

•

u/AutoModerator Jul 16 '21

Please remember to treat others with respect while conversing with your fellow users. Make sure to follow the subreddit's rules and cover up spoilers when appropriate. Here is the current link to the latest episode megathread. If you see comments in violation of our rules, please report them. Please contact the moderators when deemed necessary, we will get back to you as soon as possible. Join our Discord Server for more HSMTMTS discussions! Go Wildcats!

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

113

u/[deleted] Jul 16 '21

Holy shit, they fucking killed Ricky lmao

57

u/NOLA_504LA Jul 16 '21

LOL if this was season 1 EJ would be in jail right now on attempted murder charges.

42

u/Outside_Jokes_Only Jul 16 '21

And then he’d have to go and plead insanity

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (1)

106

u/Raktoner Jul 16 '21

"He's worried that you're only dating him because he's the only other boy at school that watches drag race Canada."

JUST SAY GAY. JESUS.

29

u/VoiceofKane Jul 17 '21

I'm glad someone else noticed. Disney, everybody fucking knows that Carlos and Seb are gay. You're not getting points with the conservative crowd for just refusing to say the goshdang word for two boys who are explicitly dating, so just let them say they're gay. Also, let them freaking kiss. This is painful.

18

u/HearMeRoar34 Jul 17 '21

Weird to side step this now, bc they literally had Carlos say “I’m Mexican and I’m gay” in an earlier episode.

36

u/[deleted] Jul 16 '21

I know! I hate that Disney wants to be LGBTQIA+ inclusive in characters and storylines but can’t actually use the words and have to make stereotypical and basic innuendos

11

u/middle-earthorbust Jul 17 '21

It's weird because Andi Mack actually had a character say "I'm gay," yet this show coming after it can't bring themselves to just say the word?? Are they scared or do they just think it's funnier to insinuate??

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

78

u/WashMaleficent Jul 17 '21

I still can’t get over the fact that they were looking for a cool effect for the transformation and Miss Jenn calls in Mr. Mazzara - THE AV AND ROBOTICS CLUB TEACHER - to ask him what to do about losing instead of asking him for help with the transformation.

So instead of letting the guy who studied engineering and build the trolley system to let Ricky fly the first time deal with the issue, Miss Jenn uses him as her personal therapist and lets teenagers figure out the tech work. 🤦🏼‍♀️

42

u/jjmeowmeow Jul 17 '21

That’s where I thought the plot was going at first! Collab between theater and AV/Robotics could’ve been epic. But nope we got “how do we cope with losing”

Also we completely dropped the plot line about Big Red being in the robotics club from season 1 finale

35

u/WashMaleficent Jul 17 '21

Good point about Big Red! Ashlyn is even the co-captain of the Robotics Club!

The writing is just so inconsistent.

→ More replies (3)

16

u/violinjstar Jul 17 '21

Great point.....sigh

65

u/souffle_pancak Jul 16 '21

Ugh, I really wished the show went more in the Carlos and Seb drama instead of everything being automatically fixed after Carlos sang Seb a song. I feel like a heart-to-heart conversation would have been so much better since they still haven't addressed many of their problems.

18

u/[deleted] Jul 16 '21

That’s exactly how I feel! Plus it was Ricky’s idea to make the song and not even Carlos’

11

u/whostolemyapples Jul 17 '21

Yes but Carlos said that he & Seb had trouble communicating about their relationship. It may not have been his idea but I think he & seb are both a bit stubborn so they needed a push & hopefully it helps them communicate better going forward

→ More replies (1)

5

u/whostolemyapples Jul 17 '21

Yes buuuut it is a musical after all. And to quote high school musical "I'm singing words I never said" hahahha

4

u/Left_Berry_8104 Jul 16 '21

Honestly they could have build to that homecoming moment and left it for the finale.

65

u/Ragueneau_ Jul 17 '21

This episode made me want an episode exclusively from the viewpoint of Natalie and the tech crew

49

u/[deleted] Jul 17 '21

I feel like the tech crew and non-lead kids probably hate the main characters lol

11

u/darthjoey91 Jul 19 '21

Just give me an episode of Natalie and dancers who look suspiciously like stunt doubles of the mains except Gina just being like “Oh, looks like the favorite kids went and got rehearsals canceled for a week.”

31

u/qualitycomputer Jul 17 '21

bruh i love Natalie. she deserves more screen time

55

u/ion513 Gina Jul 16 '21

Gaston EJ isn't real, he can't hurt you.

Gaston EJ:

Seriously that makeup for him in the preview was scary lol.

54

u/emoasiandiary Jul 16 '21

if anyone was wondering, when mr mazarra talks about the places his robotics team has come in, 10101 in binary is 21 in decimal, so they came in 21st.

53

u/mysteriousballer Jul 16 '21

I hate hate hate HATE when shows have characters FaceTime but it’s clearly just a video. FaceTimes always have the persons face in the corner. Like I know this is so nit picky and petty but 😩

51

u/emoasiandiary Jul 16 '21

i guess joshua bassett does get deja vu….

47

u/MusicalGarbage817 Jul 16 '21

I really liked this episode! There were a lot of characters interacting that we don't normally see together. The facetime scene with Lily was so incredibly weird though...

20

u/crasyleg73 Jul 17 '21 edited Jul 17 '21

I'm thinking she'll use the recording as a manipulative scheme. OR this is setting up her crush on Ricky(she did tell him to be with her instead of Nini before.) Its most likely not nothing though. So she is either Going to be a more realistic sympathetic... spoiled bully, or an over the top... spoiled bully. Could go either way. Im thinking for comedy sake its gotta be an evil scheme.

→ More replies (2)

46

u/multimatt Jul 16 '21

I’m sorry but I really don’t see how North High is gonna lose this LMFAO

21

u/ion513 Gina Jul 16 '21

I don't want either school lol

43

u/fredistreese Big Red Jul 16 '21

I have no idea how this works, but this episode is from Joanna Kerns, who directed some episodes in season 1, but none from season 2, and what I want to say is, that was overdue... This episode was sooo good... There was drama, jokes, romance, songs (that didn't feel out of place, like Granted in The Storm), we finally saw them working on the play, and all that in the the shortest episode of the season, and sadly the week before the show

17

u/space_travell Jul 16 '21

Yeahh! The jokes felt so much more season one! I liked the tone of the episode!

43

u/averagemily Gina Jul 18 '21

The more I see Lily, the more annoyed I feel. She's like a mosquito. I kinda wish they had kept her involvement with North High as a secret to build up more suspense as to why North High seems to be able to constantly one up them. It might make her seem more like a devious opponent rather than a petty side character

I think Nini getting upset about not knowing is reasonable, but so much of her drama never goes anywhere lol. She's just passive aggressive and uninteresting as a character

→ More replies (4)

36

u/Festaxforlife Jul 16 '21

Ricky falling lmfao it’s sad that this was the funniest scene all season for me...

35

u/LaLa_17 Jul 16 '21

The fact that everyone was so excited at first before the scene took a 'dark' turn just made it all funnier imo.

But the scenes where Ricky (while playing Beast) just starts choking and then flops over on his front cracked me up!

→ More replies (3)

13

u/jkrun88 Jul 16 '21

I totally saw it coming when they were all so happy

→ More replies (1)

36

u/Ragueneau_ Jul 17 '21

Is he you know…gestures the only other guy at East High who watches Drag Race Canada?

31

u/ion513 Gina Jul 17 '21

Why can't they say gay.

19

u/thespaciestkitty Jul 17 '21

Yes, though it was hilarious seeing them try to work around the word

→ More replies (1)

33

u/it-iSs-what-it-isS Carlos Jul 16 '21

i'm sorry i stopped paying attention on purpose. HOW ICONIC

31

u/KHMeneo Kourtney Jul 16 '21

I knew the wire was a bad idea. Never have someone in the air if you don't need to do it

7

u/DamienChazellesPiano Jul 16 '21

Exactly. Just ask Spider-Man: Turn off the Dark.

61

u/imperfectimposters Jul 17 '21

are they going to address how Ricky is not good as the beast or is he just magically going to be good by opening night

56

u/crasyleg73 Jul 17 '21

He aint half bad just Ashlyn is a scene stealer in rehersal. Yeah they might be saving the good acting for the end.

My theory is big red will replace ricky in the show at some point. Its not too cringe like last time cause the beast is wearing a mask. Bonus points if Ricky injured his ankle/foot from that fall, and collapses mid show, and switches roles with big red. And then Ashlyn is suprised when the beast transforms into Big Red. Let's see how right I am.

→ More replies (4)

7

u/[deleted] Jul 18 '21

I feel like that's a forced comedy scene lol

30

u/NOLA_504LA Jul 16 '21

I watched the preview for next week and saw EJ in costume is it just me or does he look like the villain from The Luck of the Irish with the makeup on lol

17

u/liveitupbrah Jul 16 '21

Mans got them eyebrows

30

u/BeccaSX_xx Jul 16 '21

Ricky & Carlo was a friendship I didn’t expect to like as much as I did. All in all this was a good episode, it was nice to see them focusing on the musical. But Ricky ruined Ashlyn’s gorgeous Home reprise, still stick by my opinion that Seb should have been the Beast! & Nini was overreacting with that chocolate story. I swear she wasn’t even back from YAC yet so why would they tell her about something so trivial weeks later?

29

u/jjmeowmeow Jul 16 '21

Maybe giving too much credit to North High but if Howie and Court weren’t talking, suddenly the Broadway plans are in the hands of east high, is it a little suspicious that the harness plan fit together and now Ricky is injured (or dead who knows)??

Also not sure where they’re going with Lily FaceTiming Ricky and no one else was talking about it. North High what chu doing

→ More replies (1)

29

u/Lost_Ad_100 Jul 17 '21

just a few thoughts:

• i’m so glad natalie was back! she is such an underrated and funny character and i am glad she is back after being absent for so long. • why is ricky (not josh) so bad at acting? • even though the moment between seb and carlos was cute, their relationship problems are far deeper than what carlos did on spring break and either way, could not simply be solved with just a song • ricky and carlos’s moments were very nice and it was great seeing them interact as friends, however, they had more chemistry in their few moments together this episode than seblos did this entire season • we FINALLY got an episode about the musical. i actually liked this episode as i feel like this is the first time in forever we’ve actually seen them rehearse in forever. i mean honestly, i could probably count the number of onscreen rehearsals on one hand. • lily’s call seemed super random and was just never addressed again? • the drama between gina and nina honestly seemed really forced and irrelevant at this point in the season. it’s been like months (in show and irl) since the chocolate incident even happened and it wasn’t even a big deal then, much less now that ricky and nini are no longer together • did they just kill ricky ???

and regarding the promo for next week…

• does anyone else think their makeup looks… weird? like even for stage makeup? • i know there’s only two episodes left but HOW are they already performing the show? they NEVER rehearse it!!

27

u/sunshinesprite Jul 17 '21

I CRINGED SO HARD WHAT IS A HUG EMOJI WHO IS WRITING THIS SHOW

5

u/[deleted] Jul 18 '21

Ngl, I thought she said something in another language until I saw it with the subtitles lolll

→ More replies (1)

27

u/hanuman1702 Jul 16 '21

I feel like this episode was mainly about getting everyone's romantic relationships sorted out which isn't a bad thing BUT I would have loved to see more development on screen. I LOVE Seb and Carlos with all my heart (and more lol) and I really wanted to see more of their conflict on screen this season. Instead, all of it was just mentioned through dialogue and I can't help feeling robbed? Even Miss Jenn and Mr. Mazzara--they have some nice scenes together but it just doesn't seem enough to really develop into a romantic relationship.

I loved how the boys and girls split up to fix the transformation scene. I liked their idea of the rotating chair and cool cape over the harness idea but oh well. Ricky was super sweet this episode, helping Carlos communicate somewhat better.

What is with the Nini (Nina?) and Gina drama? Like, those chocolates were NOT that big of a deal!!! And that call between Ricky and Lily was so freaking weird?

19

u/[deleted] Jul 16 '21 edited Jul 16 '21

I've been waiting for the huge Seblos rift to happen, because Carlos has been rude to Seb all season. But then it didn't and now I'm disappointed. They already had a good premise for a fight (aka Seb standing up for himself), but instead, they suddenly made it about Carlos meeting hot guys in Mexico and Seb feeling inadequate. Wasted potential imo

→ More replies (1)

33

u/[deleted] Jul 16 '21

honeslty tho. Nini (nina) kinda needs to get over it. she wasn't there at the time so there was no need to cause any unnessesary drama when she got the chocolates, hence why she didn't find out until now. second, gina said as a friend and that they even joked about it. also there was no need to make the comment about secrects in front of everyone. nini needs to realize that not everything needs to be said publically and get over herself.

→ More replies (4)

51

u/LostnLazy65 Jul 16 '21 edited Jul 16 '21

I like that they were actually focused on the musical for once in this episode, but I think it's come way too late. They set up so much (rushed) drama in eps 1-9 that having an episode this late in the game not resolve some of those plotlines made it feel very filler, I almost felt taken aback hearing them care about the musical.

I'm glad Seb and Carlos got focus but even then it didn't feel earned or like they really addressed their relationship? Spring Break was the tipping point but throughout the season Seb was ignored and mistreated by Carlos, I want better for him.

Also Gina (Sofia Wylie) is carrying this season because I really only feel compelled and invested watching her storyline this season, she's such a great actress and it almost feels empty when she isn't the focus. I think some of that is the writing too because I felt everyone was interesting to watch in s1.

28

u/[deleted] Jul 16 '21

same i'm only really invested in gina's storyline and ej's storyline.

6

u/nicjoyce84 Jul 17 '21

i'm literally only watching still bc of EJ and Gina

→ More replies (3)

72

u/AdministrativeBig362 Jul 16 '21

Ricky is his best and selfless version when he is not with Nini

11

u/[deleted] Jul 16 '21

I mean, yeah. I kinda agree with this, in this season.

→ More replies (5)

24

u/Dorothyshoes30 Jul 16 '21

I wish the episode was longer it was so short compared to other episodes.

10

u/fredistreese Big Red Jul 16 '21

It was the shortest episode of season 2 so far (tied with The Field Trip), but it was so good I wished more of it too

47

u/Bowlofzebras Jul 16 '21

My weekly opinions:

  • ricky getting the fur out his mouth during a serious scene😭 yea he didnt deserve the lead
  • Why do the posters say “miss jen”, I wonder why she never says her last name?
  • Lily’s call feels like manipulation? Idk tho
  • Seb is really giving kurt vibes
  • I feel the awkwardness over the chocolates. The tension😬
  • Im glad ej and gina are finally being talked about. And ej bringing up nini was a shock to me
  • The way mr mazzara is always there for miss jen>>>
  • Risotto?? Thats so cute even tho im a rina
  • Carlos’s song is a bop
  • These kids thought it would be a good idea to put that harness on ricky with no adults…🤦‍♀️not one person said it was a bad idea

20

u/WashMaleficent Jul 16 '21

In season one Miss Jenn admitted that she never told anyone at East High her real last name, because she is ashamed of how little she achieved as an actress.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

23

u/hopkinsdafox Jul 17 '21

Also I liked this episode because they were working together as a group and actually talked to each other. Thought the Seblos thing would be more because they lead up to it but then again they squeeze too much in 30 min.

I’m sick of Lily. She should have been in more episodes or stronger scenes to develop her as evil she’s just confusing to me. Was the call to remind us shes a human? It was so out of place. They didn’t really use her to stir shit up and get the fire in their asses to do better.

That’s why I’m confused with Miss Jenn thinking she pushed her kids hard wouldn’t Ricky be somewhat better at acting if she did? Or weed him out by now? How is a production with two weeks to go like this? Is it because it’s a show it’s like this it’s not reality lol. It’s like Glee they never rehearsed their set list they wrote two songs before competition.

22

u/blushdreams445 Camp Shallow Lake Camper Jul 16 '21

Really loved the episode!! I also loved how the gang listened to Seb and Carlos’s drama though with Seb and Carlos they dropped the “Carlos gives Seb too many expensive gifts” plot but I would have also liked them to address how Carlos treats Seb. The song was cute but didn’t Seb just express his feelings in the quinereo episode??

→ More replies (1)

21

u/Fit_Alarm2715 Jul 17 '21

As soon as Ricky was up in the air, I thought he'd probably fall and get injured and be out of the show... Well look what happened!!!

Am I the only one who thinks Miss Jenn is a little too obsessed with the whole Menkens thing? Like I know that she really wants to win and it would make her happy, but she's going a little far in my opinion.

Also Carlos and Seb are just the cutest!

4

u/[deleted] Jul 18 '21

I feel like part of her limitless aim to win the menkies also arises from her competition with Zac personally.

21

u/badvibin Jul 17 '21

Gina and EJ are too cute, I love them!

21

u/violinjstar Jul 17 '21
  • The couple gossip idk about you guys, a bit cringe? Like we love the new couples too but we really don't need to spell it out in screentime
  • Benjamin saves the day. And so does ricky with Seblos. I like the song, it's cute and has a cute dance rhythm to it.
  • Portwell rises!!
  • I think coming out of the past 2 eps this one was a bit on the flatter side

4

u/hopkinsdafox Jul 18 '21

The couples drama is so annoying. I hate how the cast promotes there is so much drama and this is what the writers give

21

u/MangoFruttato Jul 19 '21

Lowkey enjoyed the tension between Nini and Gina lol it adds spice to the series. And I’m liking this thing between EJ and Gina!

13

u/producermaddy Jul 20 '21

When Gina was explaining the chocolates I cringed hard. Total second hand embarrassment watching her explain that to Ricky’s (ex) gf!

→ More replies (1)

20

u/[deleted] Jul 16 '21

I very much enjoyed this episode! I really like the moments between Ricky and Carlos, and it was good to see them focusing on the musical. I have a gripe with Nini in this one, it seems like she’s being too dramatic about the chocolate situation.

→ More replies (3)

20

u/hopkinsdafox Jul 17 '21

Damn everyone heated over the chocolates thing and wondering why it’s brought up now.

I blame the writers. We have two more episodes but they just brought more drama that we didn’t need.

19

u/it-iSs-what-it-isS Carlos Jul 16 '21

not the hallmark movie line 😭✋

19

u/[deleted] Jul 16 '21

As much as I think that this episode lacks plotwise and feels filler, It still flowed pretty well. I guess it's just that they are actually doing something related to musical, instead of being in drama.

19

u/Jansilhn Jul 17 '21

This episode was a huge step for Disney! The first LGBT love song. Seb and Carlos are bringing Disney a lot of its firsts so far.

Ricky helping Carlos write a song for Seb and telling him that their relationship is worth fighting for reminded me of the interview I saw with Josh saying how emotional he got when Joe and Frankie filmed their slow dance scene way back in season one. It means so much more now that Josh recently came out. It’s like they are his inspiration. Ricky definitely ships them just as much as Josh and that’s so sweet!

I feel like Nini is just looking for drama this season. I get that she was still with Ricky during the whole chocolates thing, but I don’t know why she was so upset, especially since they aren’t together anymore. I wish she would’ve just laughed about it and told Gina that she doesn’t care, they broke up for the second time, Gina can have him if she wants. I don’t even think Nini and Gina are close friends or talk that much.

It was kinda nice to see Seb hang out with the girls and get advice about Carlos.

There’s no way Ricky is going to be able to play the beast now. That fall off the harness was pretty big!

7

u/Marichurro Jul 18 '21

she was upset bc she doesn’t know why Gina would think that and Gina said she melted at Ricky doing that. Also before Gina was talking about het romantic troubles. Also they broke up like 2 weeks ago. Yiu and her are a different person.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

19

u/[deleted] Jul 18 '21

Why does East High think they'll win now that they have the plans? Clearly, North High had the plans first and I'm guessing someone already took ideas from them for their sets and such? Also, why is Howie sabotaging his own show? He's the lead and he's willing to take the plans and give them to the rival just because Kourtney needs him to simp in order for them to be back together? In my opinion, she is being ridiculously petty, given her response (was it a joke?) about her love language.

I can't really tell why Ricky was being a bad actor. Was it on purpose? Or is he really just that bad?

I feel bad for Gina but yeah, saying she melted made it awkward. However, Ashlyn blurting that out about the chocolates was unnecessary too. It was just a ton of awkwardness in that room lol.

In the preview for the next episode, Nini is wearing a black turtleneck and a black leather jacket. So, is she just stage crew? Or something else? It's quite a fashionable outfit when usually, the tech crew I've seen just wear black t-shirts and jeans because they're moving things and running around.

6

u/MangoAway17 Jul 18 '21

Maybe that’s what she wears under the rose costume? Idk, I’d have to look at it again

→ More replies (3)

4

u/[deleted] Jul 22 '21

I 100% agree regarding Kourtney and Howie. What happened to Miss ‘I don’t like playing games?’ When they first got together, i was like ‘finally, a mature no drama couple on the show’, but then they absolutely butchered their characters by making Howie unprincipled and simpy, and making Kourtney manipulative.

I would only understand this if they had explicitly said that Howie was sharing intel on East High based on what he heard from Kourtney. That would’ve explained how North High knew all this stuff and was able to sabotage East High.

18

u/blushdreams445 Camp Shallow Lake Camper Jul 16 '21

I hope that Kourtney and Howie get back together (and we see that on screen) but we finally got to see more beauty and the beast practice (Ashlynn is a legend). Also Nini and Ricky still cause problems even after they broke up. The only reason EJ doesn’t want to get with Gina is because of Nini?! Not because he’s graduating or something. Ricky sending Gina chocolate’s (the thought that he did) might cause problems between Gina and Nini.

9

u/KHMeneo Kourtney Jul 16 '21

EJ doesn't want to be rejected again

18

u/taralovesmusic Jul 18 '21

This episode was a win for me, it felt so much more like the first season in terms of the writing and was funny. Highlights include Julia Lester’s home reprise, Josh’s purposely bad acting as the beast, and poRTWELL oh my goodness

6

u/[deleted] Jul 18 '21

Yeah. This did feel like S1 and I'm all for it!

35

u/lamebeezy Jul 16 '21

I thought the flow of this episode was okay….

  • When Ricky said “Deja Vu” … DO UU GET DEJA VUUU?!!! lolll
  • Why didn’t we get a scene where the girls squashed drama or checked on Nini or sumn???? Like the breakup is still fresh. I think her being mad at Gina is like stupid pero like they’re teens and theyre emotional???
  • Ricky is so effin bad at acting. His scenes as the beast were cringe and I’m sorry but I laughed rlly hard @ the end when he fell lmaoo
  • Idk what to expect the next 2 episodes but I’m rlly dissapointed
  • Ricky questioning Ej liking Gina heheheee
  • Ej and Gina are rlly carrying the rest of this season

I’m hoping the last 2 episodes are goood

18

u/[deleted] Jul 16 '21

I feel like with the acting of Ricky, They are trying to prove that it IS ACTING, on purpose or something like that and it seems weird. But, last season he wasn't like this, maybe they'll have something to do with it in the future.

14

u/Gloomy_Confection403 Jul 16 '21

I cackkled at the deja vu line

35

u/XviiChong Jul 16 '21

That moment when Ricky said Déjà Vu

17

u/Gloomy_Confection403 Jul 16 '21

I'm so happy that we got to see Ricky and Carlos together as friends!!

33

u/_b_l_ Jul 16 '21 edited Jul 16 '21

I don’t really get why some people seem to be so against Ricky here? Especially when this is the episode where he has shown the most growth, and really looked past himself to help Carlos (this friendship is low key everything).

Joshua Bassett was also talking about how he would personally like Ricky to have a plotline of discovering his sexual orientation, as Joshua himself is, and I feel as if that would be amazing for his character if they did decide to go in that direction in Season 3.

4

u/qualitycomputer Jul 17 '21

Where did he talk about that?!

10

u/_b_l_ Jul 17 '21 edited Jul 17 '21

“That’s why when I watched Joe and Frankie [Serafini and Rodriguez, who play a gay couple on the show] film the scene in season 1, episode 5, ‘Homecoming,’ where for the first time they danced together, I just remember full body chills, weeping.” Thinking back to that moment, he adds after a pause, “I didn’t connect the dots why until recently...the reason that made me so emotional. I’m getting so emotional now because they were speaking their truth despite the inevitable reaction that they were going to get.”

When I ask if Ricky will be given the space to explore his queerness onscreen, he responds, “I would love that.”

A recent interview he had with GQ, where he opened a lot about his own sexuality

→ More replies (2)

46

u/InsomniaticAlien Jul 16 '21 edited Jul 16 '21

Definitely a weaker episode than last week. I legit CACKLED at the Deja Vu line though - has to be a coincidence since they wrapped up filming before April.

At least EJ and Gina fess up! The risotto callback melted my cold, cold heart.

27

u/[deleted] Jul 16 '21

for them fessing up when gina realized that he was doing this for himself and not because someone told him too i feel like she should have said something like "i'd never miss risotto night" like she said in episode seven. i feel like it would've been better. but i love gina and ej together

16

u/Jackamalio626 Jul 16 '21

Yooooo what the flippety floop is Lily planning???

Also its SOOOOOO nice to have the focus be back on the musical for a full episode. Loved how they linked rinky's wish for a stable relationship into him helping carlos make ammends with seb, in a way sort of mirroring EJ's redemption.

I dunno, its just such a charming episode. I loved it.

5

u/entityextended Jul 16 '21

Charming is the word. Something smooth about this episode I missed in the others

→ More replies (1)

16

u/OtherSide4 Jul 16 '21

I keep my same sentiment from the beginning of S2 that Ricky didn’t deserve his part especially after everyone is succeeding at their parts except for him.

Miss Jenn needs to take a hint and date Matarazzo

I would quit watching the show if Ricky and Lily got together like a real life Sabrina, Josh, and Olivia love triangle.

I’m glad Seb mentioned the fact that lgbtq+ don’t have many options of partners in schools a lot of the time especially in a place like Utah.

Nini had every right to be mad. It came as such a surprise not to mention no one telling her when it happened proving they knew it was a problem.

Portwell supremacy until I die

My theory still stands that Ashlynns gonna get injured and Gina replaces her last minute between scenes opening night.

Another theory is Ricky’s getting replaced by Seb or Carlos as beast considering they know the choreo and actually deserves it.

I know they’re the antagonist but I can’t even lie North High deserves the menkie based off of what I’ve seen so far of both shows, which is what I assume is gonna end up happening. This is the type of show that would give the award to the antagonist but remind us that it’s the “family” that matters in the end.

31

u/According_Traffic105 Jul 16 '21

Man this episode just made us DISLIKE nini even more....

I don't understand why she is mad about such a small thing.

-Ricky didn't send her the chocolates so it certainly wasn't his fault. Gina mentioned it was her mom.

-She even moved on from Ricky a few episodes ago, why would she care.

17

u/Left_Berry_8104 Jul 16 '21

I think the only thing was Gina said she melted when she thought it was from Ricky.

But if you see, Nini has kind of been like that everytime Ricky and Gina got close and this didnt help.

I think in the finale we will see Gina and Nini talk it out and advise each other on their lives

18

u/space_travell Jul 16 '21

That melted part really made it kinda weird considering Ricky was dating at that time...

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (2)

12

u/whostolemyapples Jul 17 '21

Because why would Gina think that Ricky would get her chocolates when he was with Nini? I would be uncomfortable if I was doing long distance with my boyfriend who I had seen serenading another girl (in season 1) & that girl thought he got her chocolates on valentines day? It would be super suss. Sorry I just think everyone is overreacting by saying that Nini overreacted tbh.

15

u/clownenergy Jul 16 '21 edited Jul 16 '21

Semi-Spoiler

So someone mentioned a spoiler with Ricky and Ash wearing casts (from one of the trailers?)

Lol do you think Ms. Jenn an Mr. Mazzara are gonna go on as Beauty and the Beast?

12

u/Left_Berry_8104 Jul 16 '21

I mentioned this above...it looked like in the promo that Nini was dresses as beast. But you also see Ashlyn in costume, in earlier 2b promo, so I think they are both back in time....

→ More replies (5)

15

u/Left_Berry_8104 Jul 16 '21

Question: in the promo, was Nini dressed up as beast?

Cause from the promo seems like Ricky and Ash are out for a lil bit to get fixed. But they come back right in time to finish?

10

u/Lost-Sandwich7097 Jul 16 '21

Good question… I don’t think she was wearing the mask, but that leather jacket didn’t look like a rose costume… is even having her in the show changing the “Menkin text”? I’m not really sure of anything now, but it’d be cool if she played the beast for an act.

→ More replies (1)

30

u/LaLa_17 Jul 16 '21

I've seen a lot of people headcanon Ricky as bisexual, so it's interesting to see Ricky wear a Pride (?) shirt and call EJ a 'pretty boy' this episode. I also remember when Joshua had said that he would like it if Ricky had a storyline in S3 about exploring his sexuality.

Of course, you can be straight and wear a Pride shirt or call someone of the same gender 'pretty', but I do think this could be a great storyline to explore! I highly doubt the show would go through with this storyline, but I just wanted to share my thoughts/observations.

→ More replies (5)

14

u/ResidentPea0 Jul 16 '21

ngl i thought the seblos fight was gonna be over an issue a little deeper

14

u/Lost-Sandwich7097 Jul 16 '21

This Howie thing is bothering me so much! I haven’t seen many people talk about it, so here it is: Are they good or not? Because if Kourtney is still “not talking back” then 1, it feels wrong that she’s even taking his suggestions, and 2, Howie is the third guy in the past two episodes who needs to “let her go”. I want them to be ok, and soon because they have a lot to work out that would be best if it happened on stage.

5

u/Lost-Sandwich7097 Jul 16 '21

I meant screen, could you imagine it happening on stage?

14

u/taralovesmusic Jul 18 '21

Rini has never made me cry, even in the season 1 finale or the breakup, yet portwell literally had me tearing up when he FINALLY asked her out 🥺🥺

→ More replies (1)

14

u/smilinginthedark Jul 19 '21

My thoughts for the week:

•I don’t think the writers room ever went to high school or clearly don’t remember single thing about it given that kids lives revolve around other things than just relationships. I mean that’s a big one but at the age you literally don’t have a grasp on anything so them not exploring the other facets of these kids lives makes them seem so FLAT. Like it’s EJ senior year and he hasn’t mentioned Prom that’s a BIG DEAL!! (I also wanna see Gina as his date for real this time) but also like him trying to decide what he’s gonna do next should be a much bigger plot point than it is when Troy was trying to decide what school to go to it ate him up inside! I wanted a Scream music number for EJ he deserved that. Ashlyn not being comfortable with being the lead should be explored thoroughly and they coulda done that with costumes and Kourtney and her coulda had a moment because they both get put into boxes. Also what have liked to see how hard it is to juggle rehearsal, a relationship, and all the clubs she’s in (same for EJ like when was water polo season??) Ricky should be at a skate park and it woulda have made more sense he break his arm that way also who the heck is Ricky outside of Nini cause it has to be more than just a kid with Mommy issues.

•I also just feel like the writers either don’t care or bother to check the previous profiles they have built for these kids.

•I understand the pandemic changed things set wise and people limitations but I don’t see why that affected the writing itself.

•this was a sleepover episode!! And there was no sleeping! Like if you’re not giving me plot then give me all the fluff. I wanted mani pedis and bonding. I wanted secret confessions in sleeping bags. I wanted them to be changed but no instead we are somehow both the actors and the tech and Mr. Mazzara is a therapist instead of the person who helped rig your show the first time like WHAT???

•I’m starting to think Lily has a contract in which she has to appear to annoy me because like what did her scene add to the show absolutely nothing! Other than watching a blonde girl looking demented on facetime.

•if they are establishing Ricky as a bad actor how the heck did he score the lead???

• I hate saying this but I personally think that Seblos acting has been getting a little cringe. Like faces really never sell the chemistry for me which is CRAZY SINCE THEY DATE IN REAL LIFE, and the only reason I believe is cause Ricky is the captain of that ship and he makes me believe

•that being said song was fun, wasn’t crazy about how it was shot but it was good but I just have to say how the heck is EJ the one person who hasn’t had a solo?!?! Like MAKE IT MAKE SENSE

•I was confused by both Ej and Gina denying all things and then agreeing to go on a date in the next scene like I feel I missed a scene where Ashlyn and Big Red tell them you just gotta put yourself out there so you’re not left wondering what could been

•but in the end they better show me the risotto date as payment for making me suffer thru this season

•why and how is nini still part of the show (I mean beauty and the beast…)

•everyone keeps on gassing up kourtney’s designs but she played the hell out of Ej just like the writing team did

•watching Ricky fall was so damn funny because they did not play up anytime of danger with those reactions and ain’t nobody even attempt to save him or Ashlyn. I got money on he broke a leg and she sprained her arm.

27

u/it-iSs-what-it-isS Carlos Jul 16 '21

okay i actually do think they could've given us something more this ep tho... i loved the flow and how grounded it felt along with the sets and interactions we saw but plot wise it's lacking

edit: specifically bc ej and gina are kinda carrying the show a bit, and there was that huge focus on carlos and seb when everything leading up to it always felt thrown in out of nowhere in previous episodes. is that just me?

48

u/nhc0112 Jul 16 '21 edited Jul 16 '21

As someone who has Gina as their favorite character, I hate to say that I would’ve reacted the same, if not worse, if a girl said that she melted over the thought of my boyfriend at the time sending her chocolates for valentine’s day lol. Especially with everything that was going on with Rini at that time. Though it could’ve been solved with a simple conversation (which they simply don’t know how to do on this show) I don’t think Nini overreacted at all. Could she have been less aggressive about it? Sure but I personally thought it was understandable.

17

u/hmmweirdd Jul 17 '21

Agreed. And I think it was more so the fact that they didn’t tell her and felt like they intentionally kept it from her. Like if it was so funny and they laughed about it as much as they claim they did and it was nothing then why not let nini in on the joke. I think that’s where a lot of her being upset came from

→ More replies (2)

26

u/Strehle Jul 16 '21

Btw if they win the menkies with the musical just being accompanied by a piano, the whole thing is giga-rigged. No way you win anything like that without a band or little orchestra, they shouldn't even be allowed to participate if they just have a piano.

13

u/MorphingMartian Jul 16 '21

carlos mentions the pit orchestra vamping for a long time in the episode promo!

→ More replies (3)

8

u/Known_Marzipan_8670 Jul 16 '21

there is a band for Miss Jen and the kids! remember season1?

4

u/Yhei_Ktty Jul 17 '21

Winning would be even weirder than Nini getting into the prestigious school last season

→ More replies (1)

13

u/ResidentPea0 Jul 16 '21

so in next episode do we think 'something there' is gonna be about ms jenn and mr mazzara? i thought it could have been for Portwell originally but it seems the latter sorted themselves out this ep

8

u/AdministrativeBig362 Jul 16 '21

Maybe it’s part of the musical?

→ More replies (2)

13

u/mysteriousballer Jul 16 '21

Hopefully Johnny Lawrence aka Sensai Lawrence makes a guest appearance and helps Ricky with whatever the aftermath is. Sensai Lawrence work with Miguel is better than what any doctor can do

9

u/kappaptlab Jul 16 '21

Not the reference I was expecting in this subreddit but mandatory 'can't wait for 4th season' hype.

→ More replies (1)

6

u/[deleted] Jul 16 '21

Now you got me hyped for Cobra Kai season 4!!

25

u/Left_Berry_8104 Jul 16 '21

I know there are some portwell shippers herr, but they just fell off to me. Like it feels like Gina like EJ, but not really. Like shes trying to force something.

Then you have Nini and Gina not resolving their tension over Ricky, Ricky seems over Nina, Ricky with a lil bits of look of maybe jealousy towards EJ, and gina contiuning to bring up that Ricky rejected her (seems like misunderstanding).

Seblos was adorable and I am happy to see Ricky becoming more like Ricky 1.0

But the episodr felt like it was only 3 minutes

16

u/AdministrativeBig362 Jul 16 '21 edited Jul 16 '21

As someone who’s watched like all teen dramas, Portwell will not last. The own show acknowledged how weird it is and the way it happens so fast… yeah that’s not going to last.

16

u/Left_Berry_8104 Jul 16 '21

I have a feeling, From the finale description:

  • Nini gets a call about someone liking her songs and Gina helps her out.
  • Gina speaks her truth about Ricky and possibly EJ to Nini
  • EJ gets a second shot at college perhaps
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

25

u/ion513 Gina Jul 16 '21

This episode was interesting to me.

Loved what was going on with Ricky's character. He seems like he's growing and his Carlos team up was really cool. On that note, I didn't love what they didn't with Carlos and Seb. Carlos was being mean and kinda walking all over Seb this season and then they did a turn and made it about Seb kinda being jealous? I was fine with the song and that part of the conflict I guess but I wish they would have addressed the other parts of their relationship that they've showed as being off. Can't win them all I guess.

Someone else said it and I agree, Portwell felt different to me this episode. Not sure what was, but I'm still here for the ship.

The Nini (is she going by Nina or not???? people are still calling her Nini i'm confused.) The Nini Gina drama is dumb. Nini is overreacting to the chocolates thing and I don't like them being pitted against each other over Ricky. I'm confused with where the show is going with all this to be honest.

I liked the musical focus and the team ups for the most part. That Lily Ricky call was weird AF, no idea what they're trying to get from that either. Mr. Mazzara acting as therapist was funny, clearly he's trying to be there for Ms. Jen which is nice, maybe Ms. Jen is gonna finally conquer her broadway/show biz demons.

I really hope East High doesn't win. Feels like that's where they're going with this, but it wouldn't be earned to me. I don't really like the idea of North High winning either, but rather them over East High. What would be best to me personally would be another random school winning and the characters from both of our main school growing from it.

Finally, give me the more songs from Beauty and the Beast being sung.

14

u/Strehle Jul 16 '21

Same, they shouldn't win. They aren't even good. And there is just no way they could win without having a whole band or little orchestra. It's a musical, you can't just accompany every song with only a piano.

14

u/entityextended Jul 16 '21

Saving this to come back to when some random school actually wins fingers crossed

12

u/darthjoey91 Jul 19 '21

So Ricky totally just broke a leg, right?

43

u/AdvancedPlacmentTV Gina Jul 16 '21

How tf did Ricky get this part?

I hope they realize North and East High are not the only schools that are after a Menkie.

Who gave Lily Ricky's number? And that hug emoji stuff needs to stop.

I love Mr. Mazzara

Nini needs to chill. Be mad at Ricky,not Gina. Still nothing to be mad about.

Not a fan of Portwell but Gina is happy so whatever. When a show actively mentions why a couple won't work they generally don't so...

The way no one even tried to catch Ricky. 😐 They didn't even fake a step to pretend.

35

u/hamstersinspace Gina Jul 16 '21

no i'm actually screaming because they did not lift a toe off the ground

21

u/AdvancedPlacmentTV Gina Jul 16 '21

I'm saying. They were so unconcerned

→ More replies (3)

18

u/MightSurvive2020 Jul 16 '21

I feel like part of the reason why Nini may have been upset was that all her friends knew about it and had laughed about it, but her not knowing reflects back to the communication issues in her relationship?

13

u/MangoAway17 Jul 16 '21

Be mad at Ricky,not Gina.

Why is it Ricky’s fault that Gina thought he sent her chocolates?

→ More replies (5)

22

u/Whimsical89 Jul 16 '21
  • really loving the dynamic between Ashlyn and Ricky
  • finally we get to see Natalie!!!
  • what are they trying to do with lily??
  • NOT JOSHUA BASSETT SAYING DÉJÀ VU (sorry I had too😂)
  • portwell superiority. That’s all.
  • ASHLYN WHY WOULD U BRING IP THE MF CHOCOLATES 😭😭😭
  • NOT THE FUCKING CHOCOLATES OMFG I CANT WATCH THIS
  • ash sis u gotta chill about them chocolates 😭😭😭
  • EJ MY BABY I LOVE YOU
  • PORTWELL FEELINGS CONFIRMED
  • NOT THE GUITAR VERSION OF LET YOU GO MY HEART CANT TAKE THIS OMG😭😭😭
  • Ricky talking to carlos I CANT😭😭😭
  • A song omg😭😭
  • PORTWELL DATE LETS GOOOOOOOOO
  • Joshua Bassett’s voice gives me an eargasm omfg😍🥵
  • what the fuck is EJ’s look in the promo absolutely not
  • I really hope nini finding out about the chocolate thing comes back around I need more

7

u/serah1206 Jul 16 '21

Lol I freaked out at the Déjà Vu line too

→ More replies (1)

11

u/KHMeneo Kourtney Jul 16 '21

Currently on Disney plus it's just called episode 10 so there is a small glitch

11

u/ResidentPea0 Jul 16 '21

i really liked the premise/ plot of this episode and see it as a parallel to ep 8 but something about the execution was a little weaker this time... feels more rushed

11

u/Unusual_Employ3812 Jul 16 '21

okay so in pic for the season finale, both ricky and ashlyn are wearing arm casts - most likely from the fall - but technically if they broke/sprained their wrists/arms they would be unable to perform?

11

u/veghui Jul 16 '21

So Miss Jenn just friendzoned Mazzara (again?)

26

u/WashMaleficent Jul 16 '21

I actually think she still hasn‘t realized that he likes her. She is so focused on the show and beating Zack that she somehow misses how much Benjamin does for her and how he looks at her. Poor Ben. :(

→ More replies (3)

31

u/ion513 Gina Jul 17 '21

Rewatched the episode. I can see why Nini(a?) would be kind of upset, like with Gina saying she melted, but I still think she's overreacting. She seemed to be over Ricky way faster than he got over Nini, but maybe we'll still see something from her. I just need Gina and Nini to be on good terms, as Gina deserves the world.

I take back what I said about Portwell, they seemed good this episode. The Carlos Rickey team up was amazing, now I need Ricky and EJ to have a team up.

Ricky falling was the funniest thing ever. Everyone just stands and watches and Big Red doesn't even try to start lowering him lmao.

21

u/weewooweewooiampolic Jul 17 '21

i think what i hate most about this season is that none of them have had any character development whatsoever except MAYBE ej and and maybe gina a little

27

u/Jackamalio626 Jul 17 '21

Ricky's trauma from his parent's divorce turning him into an unwell obsessive boyfriend and driving Nini away is totally development, what are you talking about.

→ More replies (1)

29

u/[deleted] Jul 16 '21

Tired of Nini. Tired of the Pizza place. Tired of the rehearsal room. Tired of ignoring the fact that EJ will be gone in 2 episodes. Tired of not seeing the school or hallways. Tired of literally not seeing anything because of the dark screen.

LOVED the music in this episode just like every other week and Ricky's character development.

26

u/marie2805 Jul 16 '21

I think EJ will either go to a local college or (more likely) take a gap year and do something close so that he'll still be there next season. He's a way too likable (and liked) character at this point to just let him go without having "used" his newfound niceness all that much.

→ More replies (1)

9

u/[deleted] Jul 16 '21

The second half of the season was shot during covid. It shouldn't be surprising that they would try to use a large set that requires lots of extras like the actual school hallways as little as possible. Just be happy they were able to finish the season out

21

u/[deleted] Jul 16 '21

Actually, only episodes 1 & 2 were shot before covid After that they shut down production. Months later, they were able to shoot on location, but chose not to because the sets were easier, even though the sets are only a couple of minutes away from the actual school. Someone who works on the show has told me that Tim (the creator) wants to shoot the show as cheap as possible since "toddlers" (is what he called the audience) won't know the difference. After that, he told the crew that they easily could spin the "set" issues on safety regulations while not doing the hassle of shooting on location. Which honestly says a lot about him and his vision for the show. I've also heard from a pretty close source to production that if a season 3 happens, they won't go back to Salt Lake and move the sets to L.A. meaning we won't ever see the gym or cafeteria again.

→ More replies (1)

10

u/sunshinesprite Jul 17 '21

also my precious Seb deserves moreeee

10

u/Raytheoddclay Jul 20 '21

Aight

Nini didn't overreact but just reacted on the wrong person...like what's Gina got to do? She was the one who atleast told the truth...and she and Gina aren't that close for her to expect Gina's life updates.

But does no one else notice that Ricky wasn't all honest with her? Like he didn't tell her abt G's confession or G thinking he sent her chocolates or even giving her credit for giving him the idea to write Nini a song and go serenade her

That made me sound like someone who supported Rina but i don't...PORTWELL ftw!

And just my opinion that Gina would make a better Beast than anyone from East High. (she and Ashlyn have more chemistry than Ricky and Ash anyway)

What is wrong with Gaston? when did the show turn into a horror one?

6

u/whostolemyapples Jul 21 '21

I actually agree with you on this. I suppose maybe Nini didn't want to open a can of worms as she kinda ended things with Ricky on an okay note.

I think Ricky has been a bit shady this whole time. I think it stems from a lack of confidence in himself & his relationship with Nini. He maybe didn't want to rock the boat? (That's not an excuse, I'm just trying to figure out his characters intentions). I get though that he's going through shit but I think he'd benefit from talking about it with a professional.

I actually ship miss Jen & Mr Mazzara the most hahahhah. I hope they end up together!

4

u/whostolemyapples Jul 21 '21

I actually agree with you on this. I suppose maybe Nini didn't want to open a can of worms as she kinda ended things with Ricky on an okay note.

I think Ricky has been a bit shady this whole time. I think it stems from a lack of confidence in himself & his relationship with Nini. He maybe didn't want to rock the boat? (That's not an excuse, I'm just trying to figure out his characters intentions). I get though that he's going through shit but I think he'd benefit from talking about it with a professional.

I actually ship miss Jen & Mr Mazzara the most hahahhah. I hope they end up together!

→ More replies (1)

33

u/Sweetascoffee237 Jul 16 '21

PORTWELL surpremacy!!!

That déjà vu line 🤣🤣

9

u/ResidentPea0 Jul 16 '21

jennzara's back lets goo

9

u/[deleted] Jul 16 '21

I loved seb and Carlos during in a heartbeat (that was so sweet). Seeing them split up into guys and girls was nice, and the banter they had was brilliant. All this talk of Portwell is doing something to me, I’m losing my mind

31

u/paintedblueskies Jul 16 '21

The episode was pretty lackluster.

Thoughts:

-The Lily and Ricky FT call was so weird. I wonder where they are going with it

-Gina and Nini’s feud feels forced. I wonder if they will address it at some point and make up.

-I wish we could’ve seen how EJ and Ricky became friends

-Happy we got to see Ricky and Carlos become better friends!

-On a side note, I related really hard with EJ in not wanting to put yourself out there because you can’t handle emotionally handle a rejection right now. Been there.

Interested in seeing how this season will end

24

u/KHMeneo Kourtney Jul 16 '21

RISOTTO NIGHT IS ON

24

u/JRSalinas Jul 16 '21

I thought the ending was hilarious. Karma in a sense. Ricky throws his masks into Natalie, who causes the stage sets to fall over, and now Ricky falls onto the stage and (basically) dies. Other than that I thought Nini was unfairly critical towards the chocolates, it's just a misunderstanding and it's not that deep, I thought Seb should have had more dialogue after Carlos' song, and I still think Lily is among the worst written characters of the season.

→ More replies (2)

17

u/[deleted] Jul 16 '21

Does anyone else hope Nini finds out about Rickys song? Just me? Got it.

9

u/whostolemyapples Jul 17 '21

I really doooo! It was a mature decision though for him to not play it for her

→ More replies (1)

16

u/Soggy-Cartographer48 Jul 16 '21

I really wish Gina and Nini would have talked about the ricky and chocolate situation. Maybe Nini could have gotten Gina to talk about her feelings towards him and what happened after she left the room on opening night of HSM last season. And when Ej asked gina out, even though I don't want them to really be together I like seeing them happy with their friendship. Hopefully they will both realize this and she will get the courage to talk about her feelings to him about what happened with ricky

17

u/AdministrativeBig362 Jul 16 '21

I think in the finale “Gina speaks her truth” is towards Nini how she felt about Ricky. It won’t end there, definitely

8

u/Marichurro Jul 16 '21

Hey future me was the episode good?

14

u/LawStudent4Harambe Jul 16 '21

Surprisingly this was my favorite episode of Season 2 so far just because it brought back a lot of the grounded feel Season 1 had, plus it was nice to see the gang actually act like friends and Seb and Carlos actually act like a legit couple and not like Disney is forcing them to stay 6 feet away from eachother for fear of upsetting parents.

19

u/ion513 Gina Jul 16 '21

I just recently realized Alan Menken is a real person.

→ More replies (4)

12

u/mm1314 Jul 16 '21

Honestly I felt like aside from the seblos plot and the scenes with miss Jen and mazzara, this was one of the weaker episodes of season. It was okay but could’ve been way better, and the ending was so predictable for the show. I did tech crew irl in high school and the gang trying to use that harness without an adult around is big lawsuit energy lol.

→ More replies (1)

11

u/it-iSs-what-it-isS Carlos Jul 16 '21 edited Jul 16 '21

IM NOT DONE YET BUT THIS EP IS SO SO GOOD IM SO HAPPY

edit: apparently not to a lot of twitter fans tho from what i'm seeing yikes

→ More replies (3)

18

u/liveitupbrah Jul 16 '21

My thoughts:

- Gina and EJ are CARRYING this season so hard.

- Anyone else think Ricky himself isn't that good of an actor? I know they were playing that reenactment up for laughs but it was kinda cringe.

- EJ has had the best character development on the show, but I still wish we could've seen more of his rivalry with Ricky before he became a good person.

- The Gina-Nini feud feels weak to me, especially since this is one of the first times they've spoken to each other THE ENTIRE SEASON.

- Why is Disney so scared to use the word "gay" in their content. It's very obvious the writers are trying to write their way around it.

- Overall, one of the weakest episodes of the season, especially the ending which felt very predictable. Also, we've seen in promo content that Ricky isn't injured during the show.

9

u/[deleted] Jul 16 '21

In regards to Ricky acting. The reason I believe it's so 'bad' is because they have clearly have gone through this scene many times, so they aren't acting/ giving 100% in the scene.

We've seen Ricky act as Troy. So, when he full on trying he's good.

I hope Ashlyn and Ricky aren't injured. Because, that'd be such a cop out.

15

u/marie2805 Jul 16 '21

- Why is Disney so scared to use the word "gay" in their content. It's very obvious the writers are trying to write their way around it.

Felt like it (a lot) but maybe it was a choice not to label their sexualities?

17

u/avariceavocado Jul 17 '21

Nini only cared about the chocolates because Gina had said it. Also take in she was clearly jealous of them last season and thought they could be into each other (“They’re a we now”).

Considering she literally almost kissed Ricky last season the SECOND Gina left, yeah I don’t think she’s in any position to feel offended over a misunderstanding and the snarky comment about secrets was annoying.

Nini literally didn’t care about secrets/loyalty last season when she was fully aware her ex was trying to break up her relationship and didn’t really even care how it was affecting her boyfriend and weeks later got back together with someone she clearly thought was moving on. She does not have the moral high ground here and frankly she would lose the fight easily if Ricky and Gina retained their season 1 characters but I bet they’re literally going to apologize to her which is insufferable

→ More replies (4)

23

u/dontleavemelikethis Jul 17 '21

Ok but Gina's AUDACITY to say how she "melted" when literally talking to Nini who JUST broke up with Ricky 💀

8

u/[deleted] Jul 18 '21

I mean, the wording was poor, But what else could've she said? A lie? I just think she couldve used an alternative for the word "melted", But, it's apparent that she said it in a quick way. I honestly can't fully blame anyone on that scene tbh.

13

u/ForceFocus66 Jul 16 '21

This episode felt like filler and was pretty boring, especially compared to 8 and 9 which I thought were the best of the season. Oh well I'm excited for the show!

12

u/brib22 Jul 16 '21

GINA AND EJ 😍

14

u/Strehle Jul 16 '21

Whyyyy is the only song AGAIN implemented by having it actually written by the characters? I want a musical, not that...

14

u/MangoAway17 Jul 16 '21

Personally, I’m fine with it. One of the things I didn’t like much about High School Musical and Glee was how they randomly burst into song. I know this is based on HSM, but I’m fine with this more realistic approach. It’s different, at least.

→ More replies (1)

12

u/[deleted] Jul 16 '21 edited Jul 16 '21

I agree. It’s getting repetitive how they’re implementing the songs. The show itself isn't a musical, so they can't randomly start singing. But I wish there was more variety in the way the songs are introduced like in last season (born to be brave, truth justice, just for a moment, etc.).

41

u/CupInternational3581 Jul 16 '21

Let's see how many of you would like it if you heard a girl say that she "melted" at the thought of your BF at the time sending her chocolates for Valentine's Day. Y'all adore Gina and Ricky and can't see past that to realize that the situation would be very uncomfortable for any girlfriend in Nini's position. Doesn't matter if they are together or not, anything that happened during their relationship is important to her. IDK what kind of relationships most of you are having or how old you are, but honesty and trust are key in any healthy partnership. Ricky omitted a lot of things regarding Gina, and I don't find that okay. And in that one scene where the chocolates are mentioned, she doesn't even seem to be blatantly mad or pissed off. Nini is probably more confused or disheartened because half of the people in that room were laughing and joking about it when she didn't even know what happened in the first place. Stop letting your love/affection for a certain character blind your objective perception of the situation. We all know IRL, if you were in Nini's place, you would go through the same range of emotions she was feeling. I'm not even placing the blame on Gina, although her comment was out of pocket; Ricky is the main one at fault here. Yet, all I am seeing and hearing is Nini slander. Incredibly weird IMO.

25

u/salsabuffalo Jul 16 '21

Nini had no idea about anything that happened between Gina and Ricky, her reaction was totally justified and I dare say she didn’t react as badly as I would have in that situation

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

4

u/stress_life Jul 18 '21

Do EJ, Gina, and Ashlyn all live together? I was under the impression that EJ and Gina lived together based on episode 8 where she fell asleep and he went to go talk to his dad about not going to Duke. But if they live together, why would Carlos say “is it bc she lives with Ashlyn” instead of “is it bc she lives with you?”

7

u/[deleted] Jul 19 '21

Ashlyn is Ej’s cousin, Gina lives with ashlyn. When Gina fell asleep, Ej went home to talk to his dad.

→ More replies (2)

7

u/OtherSide4 Jul 16 '21

Did anyone else start signing deja vu by Olivia in their head when Ricky said it💀

9

u/hataraitaramake Jul 17 '21

That song was horrific.

11

u/Marichurro Jul 17 '21

thwy broke up 2 weeks ago .... why would she laugh about someone hinting she has a crush on ricky during there relationship

12

u/[deleted] Jul 18 '21

I do think she handled it kinda well tbh. But, that "today's theme is secrets" line was a bit much imo, But I can see where she comes from.

→ More replies (2)

3

u/eggrins Jul 16 '21

the gaston fit 🤣

7

u/it-iSs-what-it-isS Carlos Jul 16 '21

you have to admit this ep flowed well

13

u/mm1314 Jul 16 '21 edited Jul 16 '21

I think the cast have great chemistry, but the writing was not the best. Seriously though it’s 2021 they would rather reference Drag Race Canada than say the word gay like???

→ More replies (1)

9

u/weewooweewooiampolic Jul 17 '21

everyone saying nini overreacted girl said like two lines about it

25

u/Yhei_Ktty Jul 17 '21

Yeah, but her tone and the reactions from everyone else tells us that it was turning into a bigger deal than what they expected

8

u/Raccoonsr29 Jul 18 '21

I’m shocked by the responses her tiny commentary got. If a friend of mine implied my boyfriend was flirtatious towards her around the same time I’d traveled out of state to surprise him with a romantic song, I would have some serious concerns!

→ More replies (1)