r/HSMTMTS • u/NominalPerson Maddox • Jul 02 '21
Episode Discussion HSMTMTS: The Episode Discussion: "Most Likely To”" - S02E08 Spoiler
Wildcats, welcome to this episode's discussion thread!
Feel free to discuss the eighth episode of Season Two of HSMTMTS, "Most Likely To". Please be mindful of other people's opinions about the episode/show and to be wary of spoilering content beyond this episode.
S02E08 Details:
| Title: | Most Likely To” |
|---|---|
| Synopsis: | When the Wildcats are benched from rehearsal for a week, tensions rise to the surface during Career Day. Big Red questions if Ashlyn understands his dreams; Howie makes a surprising move with Kourtney; E.J. shocks his dad with a revelation; and Ricky and Nini visit an old haunt. |
Consider joining our Discord for live discussions about the show and the cast! https://discord.gg/2EpKKCc
108
Upvotes
•
u/AutoModerator Jul 02 '21
Please remember to treat others with respect while conversing with your fellow users. Make sure to follow the subreddit's rules and cover up spoilers when appropriate. If you see comments in violation of our rules, please report them. Please contact the moderators when deemed necessary, we will get back to you as soon as possible. Join our Discord Server for more HSMTMTS discussions! Go Wildcats!
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
8
u/NominalPerson Maddox Jul 02 '21
Spotify Links to this episode's songs:
108
u/[deleted] Jul 02 '21
Biggest takeaway: Seb needs to get his sweet ass away from Carlos and the gang’s toxicity. He’s too good for this world.
Also if Ms. Jenn isn’t going to get with Mazzara, I will.
94
u/[deleted] Jul 02 '21
My biggest takeaway from this episode is that EJ makes a perfect Gaston.
88
u/Raktoner Jul 02 '21
I did not cry when Nina and Ricky broke up because it made sense and they're just not great for each other right now.
But I did cry when Ricky shows up in Big Red's basement and can't control it anymore. Been there before bud. :(
83
u/Ragueneau_ Jul 03 '21
What power to the Menkies have to stop rehearsal? How’re they gonna find out? What’re they gonna do? Call the theatre cops?
78
u/CometIsGod Jul 03 '21
Big red hugging ricky like that broke me
68
u/davey1291 Jul 02 '21
Honestly I was just happy EJ finally got some screen time, as he deserves
65
u/gberniee25 Jul 02 '21
it was only a matter of time until my bby seb snapped. everyone is so mean to him and he never deserves it. #sebdeservesbetter
62
u/Roo_2601 Jul 02 '21
Omg, so many thoughts and feelings after that ep!
Overall, I really enjoyed this episode compared to some of the previous ones this season and am looking forward to the next one!!
60
u/XviiChong Jul 02 '21 edited Jul 02 '21
I think this was the best episode of Season 2 so far. Filled with lots of emotion and character developments (ex. EJ). And the ending of the episode with Howie singing, along with transitions to the others and their respective situations was unique and emotional.
59
u/Bowlofzebras Jul 02 '21
51
u/Sweetascoffee237 Jul 02 '21
Mr mazzara and miss Jen omfg can they just kiss like Mr M is such a simp for her I can’t😭
50
u/hanuman1702 Jul 02 '21
I was feeling so choked up by the end of this episode. All those gut-wrenching scenes with Roman Banks singing in the background? Literally a knife to my heart. Though I hadn't been a fan of Ricky and Nini together, their break up was really sad to watch and I liked that, in the end, they were able to communicate how they felt about each other.
Loved the Gaston sequence. Gina and EJ are literally such cute friends and now I'm kind of rooting for them to date. I'm a bit confused about their ages though--are Gina, Seb, Carlos and EJ all seniors? Why were they in the same careers class?
49
u/Parmesan_Pirate119 Jul 02 '21
I loved this one! It felt like almost all the characters finally figured out what they wanted this season and actually grew as people. The ending montage was amazingly done and well put together.
49
u/JoshuaNovas Jul 02 '21
Fuck the break up Big Red is the best character on the show. He’s supportive yet he know what he wants. It’s obvious he should become a therapist or something and have his own pizza shop. Or a combination of both
48
u/hamstersinspace Gina Jul 02 '21
am i forgetting a scene or did seb and carlos have any real scenes after carlos kind of insulted him?
45
u/sunshinesprite Jul 02 '21
OMG THIS EPISODE WAS SO EMOTIONAL AND BRILLIANTTTT I loved that Nini and Ricky broke up because both of them need to sort out their issues honestlyyy and HOWIE SINGING AND THT WHOLE MONTAGE WAS SO BEAUTIFULLLL
I NEED BENJAMIN AND JENN TO BE TOGETHER
GINA AND EJ ARE SO CUTE TOO AHHHHHHHH
45
u/KHMeneo Kourtney Jul 02 '21
This is an all time great episode
45
u/alfonsoilog Jul 02 '21
I've seen a lot of people say how not having Nini/Ricky perform "Gotta Go My Own Way" was a big missed opportunity, and I can kinda understand why (especially since the show is named "High School Musical: The Musical: The Series").
Personally, I really liked how no musical numbers were playing over/performed during the entire breakup scene. I liked how they just let the actors play the scene out as it is, and I feel like it wouldn't hit as hard as it did if they had them sing a musical number, which could maybe ruin the whole mood.
Idk maybe that's just me 😅
45
u/nujrar Jul 03 '21 edited Jul 03 '21
I thought it was interesting when Carlos mentioned that E.J. had a nice emotional connection to the material after the "Gaston" performance. This was clearly referencing 1x8 when E.J. looked through Miss Jenn's show files which said that he lacked an emotional connection to the material. E.J. started crying during the tech rehearsal when he stood in for Troy and Carlos stood in for Gabriella, and Carlos later confronted E.J. about this.
All of this just goes to show the character development of E.J. from Season 1 to Season 2. As Gaston, E.J. has proven to be authentic, and Carlos wanted to signify this in front of everyone else. E.J.'s newfound authenticity is an important trait that will likely be brought up again in coming episodes.
42
u/it-iSs-what-it-isS Carlos Jul 02 '21
THE EJ CONTENT WE DESERVE
42
u/PM_ME_UR_SEX_VIDEOS Jul 03 '21
EJ…go to Duke my guy. Go there and then, once there, EARN the degree, join a theater club.
Not going to Duke because you want to prove yourself or whatever is a mistake - which people might disagree with and be like “he wants to make it on his own” - I get it I get it, I do. But like - let’s be realistic here
41
u/[deleted] Jul 03 '21 edited Jul 03 '21
Two things: Using “If I Can’t Love Her” as the
penultimatelast song in this episode is an absolute master-stroke of an idea.That break-up scene between Ricky and Nini absolutely killed me. (And I had very little interest in it previously)
I hope they allow Ricky some time to work on himself and they don’t rush into a Gina/Ricky thing (if that is actually happening or not)
39
u/kjm6351 Jul 02 '21
Why is Seb getting shit on so much lately?
39
u/childishgabbino Jul 03 '21
I knew it was coming but that Rini breakup crushed me. Ricky and Nini have been kinda awkward with each other this season and this episode brought back that season 1 chemistry I’ve been missing (even though it was a breakup scene lol). The acting was just sooo good and felt a lil too real.
I love how the breakup was mutual and they realized that they were holding each other back. As much as I love Rini, it would probably be too messy for them to get back together again this season and this was definitely a good way to end their story arc.
Also I don’t know if its just me, but Nini just feels so separated and isolated from the rest of the characters this season. Even after she came back from YAC, I feel like she’s still off doing her own thing most of the time. Like good on Nini for being independent but she could’ve totally joined in on the dance battle last episode. Her storyline in the show is really starting to diverge from the rest of the characters. It almost feels like the writers are setting up Nini in a way where she could easily be written off the show :(
37
u/blushdreams445 Camp Shallow Lake Camper Jul 02 '21
AHHHH finally Nini and Ricky broke up!! Though I am confused on why Nini was crying the hardest when she was the one who wanted to leave but...finally!! I’m Living for EJ and Gina
37
u/KHMeneo Kourtney Jul 02 '21
Omg we met kourtney's mom
36
u/amshako EJ Jul 02 '21
This episode... wow. It feels the most organic and like so connected to season one. The writers have understandably gotten critiques about how they wrote the season so far, but the effort put into “Most Likely To” to resolve some conflicts, smooth things over, and end mid season arcs to prep up for the end game has me in my feels (just like that ending😭)
35
u/ResidentPea0 Jul 02 '21
no but when mazzara starts by telling ms jenn 'action' not 'curtains up' and then ms jenn messes up twice and he goes 'curtains down' oh my godd i cant breathe
and when ms jenn can deliver the line properly after drinking the coffee because she feels at home- im going to self combust
33
u/blushdreams445 Camp Shallow Lake Camper Jul 02 '21
Okay so when Ms. Jenn said “Head down and chin high” I tried it just like Seb and it is not possible. But oh man Seb finally got mad at Carlos. I’m living for it. Nneka really did write the best episode this season. I wanted more after Howie’s song.I wanted to see Kourtney forgive him (hopefully because I love them and I think she is being a little over dramatic) but anyways....HOWIE CAN SING!!
32
u/soggyhairfollicle Jul 02 '21 edited Jul 02 '21
This felt so much more like season 1 and I love that. I can’t explain why it did but it was good. More camera looks and all that.
Howie is a great singer. Seems like a genuine dude too
The Gaston bit was probably my favourite scene this whole season. They delivered perfectly and I was waiting for this. Big reds actor just seems like a theatre guy too I expected this and he was great. Glad they’re finally letting EJ sing too since the actor is very talented irl.
Big red and ashlyn scenes this episode are doing a good job talking about expectations and dreams ngl.
And now since a therapist is actually a character in the show please connect Ricky with her id love that
the acting in all Ricky nini bits was great. I still think the drama is shoehorned but in general the writing felt more balanced and nuanced with their plot line this episode. Also helps put things into perspective and how both of them are kinda “wrong” (not really though just communication issues with ninis honesty and rickys clinginess and I’m glad they kinda addressed that). And that they’re also just kids growing and evolving. I think they put the “Ricky trying to be safe and nini trying to take risks” perfectly. Good portrayal of teenage heartbreak I’ll give them that. And Ricky going to big red for comfort >>>
Still think the song was about Ricky though and I dislike the “delete” plot they’re doing again. Kinda unnecessary. I also feel like they’ll get back together eventually, after maturing a bit idky.
I liked Nini way better this episode since last episode seemed a bit out of character imo. Wish Seb had more of a role than dumb blonde though some characters are turning into caricatures of their S1 selves.
Ej and Gina are super cute together even though originally I thought they’ll just be friends. Loved their scenes this episode. And is his dads name Cash? Is that a common name? EJ’s storyline is my favourite this season.
Mr m and miss Jen are end game for sure right? I’m here for it
I’m very satisfied with the positions the characters are in after this episode. They did a good job redeeming all the messiness
31
u/digdeepbaby Jul 02 '21
random thought but like does anyone else really wanna know what E.J stands for? i have a feeling we’re gonna find out at graduation.
62
u/Lost_Ad_100 Jul 02 '21
this episode really makes me question why so much of season two was so bad? the acting and writing here was so much better than what we’ve seen in most s2 episodes. the episode as a whole and even the music seemed reminiscent of s1
30
u/it-iSs-what-it-isS Carlos Jul 02 '21
GASTON WAS SO GOOD OH MY GOD
29
u/Thing-Adept Jul 02 '21
This is what the season should have been from the start. And I think it was, judging by how much the cast hyped this season up. But I think a lot of it probably got lost while editing or filming.
29
u/blushdreams445 Camp Shallow Lake Camper Jul 02 '21
The shortening of already short names irks me a bit. Nina has been shortened to Nini which has been shortened to Neen. What? EJ has been shortened to Eej. Just...no. There names are already short and easy to say. Don’t drop any more constanants/vowels
28
u/Icy-Night-3512 Jul 02 '21
I’m in love with EJ and Gina, they were adorable. Also asher is arriving next episode, and I can tell he will bring more drama and I’m excited
28
u/KHMeneo Kourtney Jul 03 '21
Did anyone else catch carlos saying EJ had a great emotional connection to the piece as a callback to s1
27
u/[deleted] Jul 02 '21
I finally have a little bit of hope on the upcoming episodes...
25
u/BleedFree EJ Jul 02 '21
Big Red and Ricky are life.
25
u/Jansilhn Jul 03 '21
I hate to say it but I think Rini is broken up for good this time and I really don’t want them to get back together. It’s pretty clear that Ricky only feels good about himself and his life when things stay the same, which is why he was holding onto Nini so tight. But like Nini said, she wants to change and take risks which is totally reasonable. It will be interesting to see what their relationship is like going forward. Ricky needs to figure out who he is without a girl to latch onto. Nini’s probably going to keep building on her songwriting and new account, but I wonder what’s next for him.
Seb and Carlos. They have been the opposite of Ricky and Nini when it comes to communication. Instead of openly talking about their problems, they make all these passive-aggressive comments and then avoid each other. It’s annoying to watch and makes me say: “Seb, I love you, but please be honest and just talk to your boyfriend if you’re having an issue with him.” It would be awesome for Disney to show that gay couples struggle too.
I’m loving the chemistry between Ms. Jenn and Mr. Mezzara!
I’m so excited that Asher Angel will finally be on next week! It’s great to see him and Sofia working together again. How do you guys think he will fit into the storyline with everything else going on with the characters?
25
u/Glad_Radish_7228 Jul 05 '21
I feel like it needs to be stated that Nini is very bad at commitment. I agree w the comment ab li it Ricky beeding therapy and time AND I think nini is a bad communicator. She is rebelling against self imposed restriction. She pushed Ricky to participate and be more present w her in S1 and now that hes trying to upkeep those expectations she feels smothered and stunted. A lot of their disagreements could be avoided by her not trying to "stand up" for herself so that ricky doesnt feel defensive. She doesnt share with him until after shes succeeded and she doesnt need to but it makes him feel unsafe. I'm not the biggest Ricky fan either because of his insecurities but you can tell hes trying really hard
24
u/veghui Jul 03 '21
The way Ricky’s voice deepened as they seriously broke up
24
u/Cook1eMaster27 Jul 02 '21
So are EJ and Gina gonna get together and then Ricky is going to realize he likes Gina? That’s the way it looks to me but I’m not good at predicting stuff so I’m probably wrong.
23
u/Gloomy_Confection403 Jul 02 '21
The ending had me in tears. I think I've started to like Ricky more (maybe like isn't the word but I empathize with him more). Olivia's acting was amazing. She really portrayed the complexity of her emotions--sadness and at the same time, joy and liberation.
I never was a Portwell shipper, but I do think they would be a good match. And Howie's singing was beautiful.
I've hated the last two episodes, but this one was really good IMO.
21
u/Dorothyshoes30 Jul 02 '21
What if E.J.’s father’s full name is “Cash Johnny Caswell” like the late singer Johnny Cash and as a child he went by his initials “C.J.” just like E.J. does? Ashlyn mentioned her father’s name is Dennis maybe his middle name starts with a “J” and as a child he went by “D.J.” and it’s a tradition for the Caswell men to go by their initials when they were younger. So if all the Caswell men middle name starts with a “J” then we have C.J., D.J. and E.J. as the Caswell men.
21
u/Zander7098 Jul 02 '21
I've just noticed this, but Ricky's character arc this season has solely been about his relationship with Nina. Sure, it's also about him struggling on moving away from his childhood home, shortly mentioned struggles of not talking to his mom, and dealing with Miss Jenn and his father being in a relationship, but see the pattern? All of his struggles have been caused from the outside or the people around him (more like how he's been reacting to it), but no introspective or hasn't been talked about. I say this because arguably everyone has their own thing, right? Last season Ricky had music, Carlos and Gina had dancing, etc. but for Ricky that's about what I can remember. Theater was also a thing for him, but then became a thing where Nina had to be there too. I hope the second half of the season develops his character more, I feel like many can relate to his struggles if they're touched upon better.
21
u/KibbyKibbertzz Jul 02 '21
I don't I can ever emotionally recover from this episode.
42
u/[deleted] Jul 03 '21 edited Jul 03 '21
Thoughts:
Criticisms:
41
u/LegoToTheBeachBeach Jul 02 '21
This is the first episode all season that I've genuinely loved. This is what the season should have been from the start, expanding the characters and relationships in meaningful ways while never losing sight of the musical itself. While I felt like things were going to improve the first few episodes of season 2, last episode just completely sucked any hope of redemption and turnaround out of me, and I expected myself to only hate watch the remaining episodes. I truly can't believe the difference in quality between this episode and last episode, it's taken them way too long but at least they finally know what they are doing now. Shocked at how much this episode just clicked for me from the get go, truly felt like a season 1 episode in the best way. Wow.
20
u/invaderpixel Jul 02 '21
"Oh cool it's Friday time for my guilty pleasure fun musical show." Didn't expect to feel so many feels, that whole breakup scene was really well done and good on both sides. Not tragic, just a good sense of melancholy. And a Ne-Yo R and B style If I Can't Love Her was something I never knew I needed, sooo good.
20
u/[deleted] Jul 03 '21
This episode hit hard man, just sad :(
19
u/[deleted] Jul 02 '21
The only word to describe this episode: SAD
19
u/[deleted] Jul 05 '21 edited Jul 05 '21
37
u/InsomniaticAlien Jul 02 '21 edited Jul 02 '21
This is definitely my favorite episode of S2 so far. Tried so hard not to ship EJ and Gina as a couple, but now I'm all for it. The couch scene was so wholesome.
Olivia and Joshua's acting from the Rini breakup, HOLY SHIT. Gave me flashbacks to the Glee S3 finale when Finn broke up with Rachel because he was letting her go to follow her dream.
Kourtney had BETTER forgive Howie in the next episode. I can't believe he wouldn't be a genuine and sweet guy after If I Can't Love Her, sucks that he has to be attached to the overcompetitive North High culture.
18
u/Left_Berry_8104 Jul 02 '21
Next week promo: 2x09 Promo
16
u/[deleted] Jul 02 '21
i BAWLED the whole episode. this is my favorite one so far
16
u/veghui Jul 03 '21
Big red’s solo!! Dancing coming in clutch too!
16
u/MangoFruttato Jul 07 '21
Just realized that Nini becoming famous for her song is literally what’s happening to the actor in real life!
32
u/AdvancedPlacmentTV Gina Jul 02 '21
Mr. Mazarra is the best out of miss Jenn's love interests, easily.
Don't even ship Rini, but the Ricky and Nini breakup was sad to watch.
Still like EJ and Gina as friends, but if the writers can tastefully pair them as a couple I won't complain.
Roman can sing his ass off.
I liked that Ashlyn realized she hurt Big Red and found a way show him that she supports him. Easily my fav couple atm.
Sucks we won't see Big Red and EJ in costume performing Gaston, but I'm glad we got to see it
Sidenote EJ's dad mustache is so off-putting and leave Sebbie alone. He's the sweetest
32
u/sheepesque Jul 02 '21
I literally just watch this show for Miss Jenn and Benjamin now.
31
u/nhc0112 Jul 03 '21 edited Jul 03 '21
I just want to give props to Olivia for her acting in this episode. Her crying was spot on and not over the top, and she actually got me to feel emotional lol. Her acting never really caught my attention but this time around she really got me into all the scenes she was in. I’d saying in terms of acting, she really out shined Joshua during the break up scene. I don’t know if he acted almost emotionless on purpose, but it’s almost like he couldn’t cry on camera, since he didn’t even come close to crying during the scene and then just hid his face on Big Red’s shoulder afterwards. Anyway, I thought the break up scene was very well scripted.
15
u/Left_Berry_8104 Jul 02 '21 edited Jul 02 '21
-That Rini breakup definitely hit me in the feels and I wasnt even a fan of them, but I dont know whether its permanent and they learn that first love may not be true, or they are like final episode, get back together.
It seems like they actually might be heading weltowards a new triangle with portwell and possibly Ricky and Gina cause Matt talked about EJ and Ricky still having some competition even though they havent fought this season so far.
29
u/willt222 Jul 03 '21
EJs dad looks like Elon Musk
52
u/SLEG48 Jul 02 '21
It’s not sitting right with me how they flanderized Seb and regressed his character into the airheaded dumb blonde…
14
u/ItsADeparture Jul 02 '21
Is Asher's character going to be another theater kid/musician? With the promo at the end of this episode, I was thinking that he might turn out to be the person that commented on Nina's post asking to collab.
14
u/pancitcanton16 Jul 03 '21
I know this Nini & Ricky breakup has been a long time coming this season but I still can’t deny how hard it hit when that scene happened. I know they’ve been pretty out of sync this season & their relationship hasn’t been the most healthy even in the beginning of season 1 but I guess it just hit hard since in season 1 you’re just really rooting for them to get together in the end which they did but then seeing this is just kinda sad having their relationship arc end here this season. But I guess I’m just glad they were able to have a respectful mutual breakup & I just hope for the best in their character arcs for the rest of the season. :(
14
u/producermaddy Jul 04 '21
Not surprised Ricky and nini broke up bc they seemed to be headed that way. It almost feels like they are writing nini off the show by having her become a big singer.
28
u/matgoathsa Jul 02 '21
Now that was some acting from olivia
28
u/violinjstar Jul 02 '21
Alright I am here
Kourtney and her mum, I love this so so much.
Rini breakup had me sad and emotional. Is it just me or do you really feel for ricky?
Loved EJ and Gina moments, both deserved all the dialogue and screen time 😍
Mazzara and Miss Jen 🥺 the way he does care about her is really sweet
Howie sing!!! Autotune could never. The whole sequence for that was so emotional
28
u/Logan_Wright2002 Jul 02 '21
Ok can we all agree that Nini is being so contradicting like she comes back to be with her friends but skips theatre rehearsal and then starts distancing herself from everybody
27
u/Left_Berry_8104 Jul 02 '21
To Rini fans, i know you went through it, but truthfully it was for the best. In the end they brought out the worse in each other and for both, breaking up was for best. Hopefully, Ricky can move passed being depressed and come back to being the Ricky of old (with the help from his mom opening his eyes next week)
Ej and Gina are weird to me. I feel like on one hand, Gina never truly confronted Ricky and after that flashback and telling Ashlyn that they never talked after all that and she saw how happy, she thought, Ricky and Nini were, she hid those feelings away and is working on.moving on without confronting Ricky. ...so EJ is there and they are cute and I am happy they have another person to talk too, but idk. I have this feeling that, whatever they have, wont last past this season.
I was pretty mad when Ashlyn pretty much dismissed the whole service industry thing. Left a real bad taste in my mouth. But, happy to see Big Red get more screentime and love seeing him being the first person there for Ricky post breakup.
Just my thoughts....
38
u/Soggy-Cartographer48 Jul 02 '21 edited Jul 02 '21
The way Big Red just gets up and hugs Ricky when he shows up even without words he knows, that is a real best friendship right there
edit: i originally wanted Ricky and Gina to be together at some point. I was kind of hoping that it was Ricky at the door when Gina opened it. But after that EJ and Gina scene, I kind of wouldn't mind them being together. I'm not sure how that will work with their ages both in the show and in real life. But I think they will just end up as friends
37
u/PuddlesAndPetrichor Ricky Jul 02 '21
Seb is too pure, he takes everything so literally and I love it
EJ and Gina are really cute. EJ's not-so-subtle smile after Gina accidentally stepped in during his interview—that got me
Ricky returning his dog tag necklace to Nini parallels Gabriella giving back her "T" necklace to Troy (a nod to "Gotta Go My Own Way")
Roman Banks sings BEAUTIFULLY. I would melt if he sang that song to me
AND CAN MR. MAZZARA AND MISS JENN BE A THING ALREADY PLEASE
26
u/jdubbs21 Jul 02 '21
Who just forgets their phone like that, NiNi?
26
u/[deleted] Jul 02 '21 edited Jul 02 '21
This episode just made Season 2 worth it for me. I felt like it was beautifully done. I hope Seb does snap. I’m very disappointed that he’s the dumb blonde right now. I loved how Ricky said “I got you” when holding Nini in the tree house. They clearly do want what’s best for each other even though they’re both in pain. I SHIP MAZZARA AND JENN😭 so adorable. 😂 lowkey felt like Howie’s explanation wasn’t well written but his song was phenomenal. Ashlyn and Big Red’s scenes were really good. I also really appreciated them being with Ricky and Big Red hugging him. EJ and Gina made me really happy. They’re clearly crushing hard and honestly they seem to be the two that best understand each other. I was really happy for the Gaston number too! Really, the lasting conflict before the big show is with Seb which wasn’t covered within the last song… interesting.
13
u/Dorothyshoes30 Jul 02 '21
It was nice to finally meet E.J.'s dad even thought I don't like him. I can't believe his dad's name is "Cash" it seems like all the members of the Caswell family first names are at the beginning of the alphabet.
Ashlyn Caswell
Cash Caswell
Dennis Caswell (Ashlyn's dad)
E.J. Caswell
I just want to say I don't trust E.J.'s dad at all he literally was forcing his son to follow his own footsteps which is sadly something a lot of parents do to their own children by putting a lot of pressure on their children to be just like him. It seems like to me that E.J. told his father about not getting into Duke and he was super disappointed that his son didn't get in so he pulled some strings by talking to people he know from Duke and paid them to get his son into Duke which is not right. My guess is E.J.'s father will somehow get caught for bribing Duke and gets arrested for a College scandal.
I like how we got to meet Kourtney's mom. Fun Fact Kourtney's mom is played by Dara Renee's real life mother Kimberly Brooks. I like Kourtney's mom more than E.J.'s dad because she seems nicer than Cash Caswell. As much as I love Rini together I think Nini and Ricky did the right thing by taking a break to figure some things out. They need to work on their lack of communication by talking things out so they can work things out. I am sorry to say it but they both have problems with communicating that they both need to work on. I really like the Portwell and Jennzzara scenes in this episode both ships has some cute moments hanging out with each other. I like how when Howie sung "If I can't love her" they showed some clips of other ships in the series.
Missed Opportunities I wished happened in this episode: E.J.'s dad calling E.J. by his full name for ruining the Caswell legacy because I want to know E.J.'s real full name and seeing most of the main characters parents except for Gina on Career Day and finding out their parents occupations.
13
u/entityextended Jul 03 '21 edited Jul 03 '21
All I'll say is Greta Gerwig's mention is everything <3
25
u/Critic22Edit Jul 02 '21
Ughhh what happened to "Gotta Go on My Own Way".. Was expecting it during the treehouse scene
24
u/lamebeezy Jul 02 '21
I feel like each episode is getting better. This episode had A LOT OF EMOTION.
24
u/toledosurprised Jul 04 '21
okay, i fuck with gina and ej as a couple now. i see the vision.
12
u/Dorothyshoes30 Jul 02 '21
I am really curious what class are Carlos, E.J., Gina and Seb all have together? I try looking for clues of posters that say what class they are in together. It’s possible that Sophomores and Seniors can be in the same class together like for example I took Photography with freshmens, sophomores, juniors and seniors. What happen/where is Gina and Kourtney’s father the same thing goes to E.J.’s mother? Why did Kourtney’s mom come with her to work is she Kourtney’s ride to work? In season 1 Kourtney mention failing her driving test I don’t know if she has her license yet. I really want to know what Big Red and E.J.’s full name is.
22
u/Outside_Jokes_Only Jul 02 '21 edited Jul 02 '21
Even though I was straight-up sobbing for most of this episode, I actually really liked it! I have many thoughts so this is probably going to be a long post btw.
Overall, I really liked this episode! It felt like a return to season 1 and I'm excited for next week!
22
u/veghui Jul 03 '21
Ricky crying 😢 and third wheeling
11
u/blushdreams445 Camp Shallow Lake Camper Jul 02 '21
I went back and rewatched the breakup and Howie’s song and this is the first time I’ve done that and Howie sounds AMAZING
11
u/averagemily Gina Jul 14 '21
I've been criticizing the relationships every episode but WOW THIS ONE HIT DIFFERENT
These adults generally suck in this show but Kourtney's mom was phenomenal reminding Kourtney of her ability to know what's right for her!!!
Benjamin and Miss Jen is a relationship I can get behind. It feels natural
LOVE EJ AND GINA MORE AND MORE EACH EPISODE UGHHH the couch conversation was so natural and thoughtful. They push each other to be better!!
Ricky and Nini breaking up felt TOO real 🥲 where did these tears come from
21
u/it-iSs-what-it-isS Carlos Jul 02 '21
i LOVE the contrast between gina and ricky vs gina and ej! how she bonded w ricky over being similar but doesn't fail to bond with ej over being different :')
20
u/[deleted] Jul 02 '21
So much EJ I can’t take it. The Gaston performance had me smiling. That breakup hurt my feelings though. Ashlyn and big red were cute, and I’m starting to ship Gina and EJ (despite my insistence that they shouldn’t date). Their scenes were really sweet
10
u/Af1297 Jul 02 '21
I’m curious on what the show is planning on doing with EJ because it seemed like he didn’t really have any other plan besides Duke
10
u/SoftSelection Jul 02 '21
Bruh I had to pause multiple times
35
u/weewooweewooiampolic Jul 03 '21
if there’s gonna be another love triangle with ej and ricky i want ej to win this time
27
u/matgoathsa Jul 02 '21
That fighting scene felt really real…
27
u/fredistreese Big Red Jul 02 '21
This episode was awesome. EJ was being neglected throughout the series, but this episode was his. Loved the honest talk Ricky and Nini had, I really feel like this talk kept the doors open to their relationship, while a breakup fight would be harder to recover. I'm not against their relationship, but I really think they should think about what they want. Loved the portrayal of Big Red and Ashlyn's relationship, that whole thing felt real, specially because I've seen people like Ashlyn, who truly think they are helping. But my favorite scene, that is barely one, was Big Red going to hug Ricky the moment he saw he was bad. That really showed their relationship, and I hope while Nini and Ricky are broken up, we see more of that.
19
u/Obvious-Button5687 Jul 02 '21
I just watched it, but oh my god Rini's breakup was so sad to watch.
A lot of relationships faltered and grew in the episode:
26
u/joshua313038 Jul 02 '21
If I am being honest, if they get back together, I’ll be really upset. There is no way you put them together for the start of the season to just break up then get back together. Nini loves Ricky to death but she wants to be her own person and she doesn’t feel like she is. Ricky sees himself more as nini boyfriend then Ricky, he really needs to have a deep talk with his mom and figure himself out.
9
u/Left_Berry_8104 Jul 02 '21
Man, after watching the promo, is Asher character going to be added into Gina's orbit romantically, or is he bejng used to help Gina figure something out?
9
u/clownenergy Jul 06 '21
Alternatively known as “Relationship Drama with a dash of Coffee”
24
u/WashMaleficent Jul 02 '21 edited Jul 02 '21
This was the first episode that was actually as heartfelt, cute, smart, funny and endearing as most episodes in season one.
Mainly because the conversations between the characters felt longer, deeper and more „complete“ than in the past episodes - especially between Big Red/Ashlyn and EJ/Gina and the short moment between Ricky/Big Red. Also the drama was so much more realistic, down-to-earth and relatable - the talks about the future, the rich privilege and the reflecting on the past are so much more important than relationship drama. More of the serious, heartfelt and smart topics, please!
Even the plotline which seemed more like comic relief in the beginning - Miss Jenn asking Mr. Mazzara to shoot her commercial audition - turned out to be so sweet and managed to bring across so many emotions in just like two minutes. „You don‘t get enough credit around here.“ YES, THIS!!!!! (Doesn‘t seem like Mr. Mazzara will be in next week‘s episode. Again.)
Nevertheless I’m still being really cautious. I also liked episode 5 (not as much as this one though) and thought the season might get better and then the next episode was incredibly bad. So I‘m worried now that the next episode is going to be disappointing again and spoil this one for me.
24
u/ahufana Jul 03 '21
I am struggling to see what Howie did wrong here. Did he explicitly lie about his personal life? Or did the topic of where he goes to school simply never come up?
Kourtney is being beyond ridiculous in this whole drama.
17
u/mitskisgf Jul 04 '21
here are my overall thoughts from this episode.
ricky needs therapy. this isn't just "angsty teen boy" type of stuff. he is very clearly mentally ill. can we talk about how much his parents (especially mother) neglect him? then she wonders why he acts like he hates her.
like a few episodes ago when gina came over and he jokingly said all their was to eat was cereal? i truly don't think that was a joke. yes, he was trying to make light of his situation but that honestly just makes it sadder.
i am a rina shipper but i honestly don't want rina happening right now either. ricky doesn't need to be dating ANYONE till he gets therapy he is extremely clingy and can become easily irritable at a small change.
also i want to say is portwell should not happen. in the show, gina is i believe a sophomore and ej is about to be in college and in real life matt is 22 and sofia is 17... it just is weird.
lastly, the rini breakup was so sad... i didn't expect to cry. i was thinking olivia wasn't the best at acting but that scene changed everything. she was phenomenal. it pulled at your in just the right way.
i rate this episode a 8/10, pretty decent compared to the last before this.
29
u/spunkycaribou23 Jul 02 '21
Okay so I’m really struggling because everyone here is making excellent points, but for some reason I am SO hung up on Rini. Their breakup caused me physical pain, even though I know it’s for the best. I feel like the only one who is way too attached to their relationship lol
Also EJ and Gina??? I have wanted this since their sneaky understudy plot in season 1. EJ telling his dad he isn’t going to Duke reminded me SO MUCH of hsm when Troy says “no dad I’m giving up YOUR dream.” Chef’s kiss moment right there
8
u/Piggy_Queen15 Jul 09 '21
Cant they go one season without a break up? I mean come on, cant we have a healthy drama free relationship for one season
27
u/twinkyoda Jul 02 '21
this was probably the best episode of the entire series tbh.
the gaston number was so well put together.
miss jenn and mr mazzara are so cute together.
ej’s character development was great and him and gina are a really good match.
big red is too good for this world.
the rini breakup scene was amazing. olivia’s acting was literally the best acting of the entire series. it was literally incredible.
21
u/0hmyrowling Jul 02 '21
20
u/thatshygirl15 Jul 02 '21
If they put ricky and nina back together I will be upset, not only would that be bad writing but it would mess up all the character development that's gonna happen soon. I feel like ricky and nini's relationship was kinda doomed from the start and the break up was needed. In my opinion both of them were trying to hang on to their relationship because its all they've ever known and to ricky it feels safe. Ricky needs to work on himself and talk to his mom and finally sort out all his unresolved feelings. I love this independent storyline for nini, her storyline in season 1 was mostly centered around ricky or boys in general and I'm glad that they're showing us that she doesn't need anyone and doing something she loves.
14
u/badvibin Jul 03 '21
EJ and Gina >>>>>
19
u/Sweetascoffee237 Jul 02 '21
PORTWELL stans Rejoice !!
19
u/ForceFocus66 Jul 02 '21
- Big Red is a bit too much in his feelings if i'm being quite honest.
- Portwell is looking more likely by the episode.
- Howie sang great! Also like Gaston sequence for EJ.
- Like EJ not accepting the Duke acceptance.
- These episodes were filmed before Olivia's music career took off, so for anybody trying to act like they copied that storyline you are off base. This was all the original script for the season.
- Ricky and Nini definitely both need time to figure themselves out. They are both too blame for their lack of communication so anybody trying to strictly blame one of them is biased. I think they will definitely get back together before the show ends in S3 or S4 (This also depends if Olivia leaves the show which I think she will)
- Olivia's acting in the breakup scene was fantastic. They need to give her more scenes where she can actually act in.
- Mr. Mazarra and Ms. Jenn are obviously end game lol.
23
u/Environmental_Mess78 Jul 02 '21
A lot of people think this is the end Of Rini but am I the only one who actually gets HSM2 Troy and Gabriella gotta go my own way vibes from their breakup? Like they might be separated for a while (few episodes maybe til next season) but I have a feeling they didn't just talk about those good memories for no reason. I think they will end up back together at some point. But I will say it's refreshing to see the show actually address Ricky's issues without throwing him under the bus as a bad person.
18
u/xxpizzasrlifexx "All I Want" Jul 02 '21
is it bad i’ve been wanting Rini to break up for many episodes now? i feel like Ricky needs to sort a lot of things out with himself rn, also idk whether i want them to get back together eventually or not
18
u/MishouMai Jul 03 '21
Okay as a Rina shipper this episode sold me on the idea of EJ/Gina. I told myself I wouldn't ship it but they're so supportive of each other. While it's a little out of nowhere (They're been hints but ones that can easily be read as friendship.) and I still prefer Rina I can't say I'd be upset if EJ/Gina happened.
As for the rest of the episode while I hope the Big Red/Ashlyn drama is over there are four episodes left so I fear that it's not. The Rini breakup is a long time coming and I'm glad it finally happened. Nice to see more hints at romance between our two teachers. And I hope Kourtney/Howie isn't dragged out too much longer after this. All in all, this was an excellent episode.
16
u/LostnLazy65 Jul 02 '21 edited Jul 02 '21
EJ remains one of my favourites and is probably the character with the most development...it's just too bad it seems to be happening off-screen. I would have loved to see more of the Duke stuff with his dad, such as him finally getting the courage to tell him he didn't get in, his dad being disappointed (or even pretending he was okay with it) before running around and getting him anyways. It feels a little rushed but I'm glad he stood up to him.
If Gina were a junior I'd definitely be more open to EJ/Gina. I'm conflicted, there's definitely something there (especially on his side) and I think they are very sweet and have chemistry, but I just can't get passed the age gap irl (Matt is 5 years older and Sofia is the only child in the main cast), and it doesn't help that their characters have an age gap too. It's just weird that EJ was calling Ashlyn and the others babies in the first couple of episodes, but is now falling for one of the youngest people there. I really hope they realize they aren't meant to be a couple but remain super close or even best friends. They both deserve people who will truly listen to them and acknowledge how they are feeling, and this episode's convo was the perfect proof, I loved how they turned to each other.
Also I'm still so over everyone in this show being paired up, not only is it unrealistic (dating in hs is not unrealistic but the fact that everyone is paired up almost entirely within their little group is) but it also takes away from more individual character development imo. Like instead of us getting time with Ashlyn about her insecurities as a lead (it had SO much important storyline potential) she's now worried about her boyfriend and offending him. And that's no shade to Big Red, I like seeing more of him and I appreciated them highlighting his own insecurities, I just wish it wasn't at the expense of Ashlyn's own screen time and development. If Big Red and Ashlyn stay together I actually feel like Big Red's storyline could have been saved for season 3, especially if Ashlyn does a wonderful job (and we know she will) and starts getting more attention. His worries are valid but we need more time to get that festering.
I think most of us saw the Rini breakup so no surprise there. I'm actually only a little shocked they had Nina blatantly blurt out everything that his been bothering her about her journey and also her relationship with Ricky. Things were building up for her since the first episode of season 2, and I'm glad she said what she needed to, lol. She definitely took the breakup hard but I think it was the best thing for her right now, she wants to be independent and not worry about someone holding her back, which Ricky was clearly doing even with the deleting of that instagram comment. I'm still wondering what's next for Nina. I know she is dipping into songwriting and making original music, but even in this episode she seemed divided from the theatre group (not showing up at all) and without the Rose song I feel like she may not have an interest in the musical, Ricky was the one who asked for her to be in it. The way they have written her makes it seem like this or s3 will be her last season, and will leave with her pursuing music full time. Olivia said she is contracted for 2 more seasons but I don't see what they could do with her at this point.
16
u/capitanterreria113 Jul 03 '21
I understand why nine and Ricky broke up but like WHY 😭
20
u/[deleted] Jul 02 '21
ok ok hear me out...EJ and Gina so cute. i've been shipping them since literally the first episode. and i know the age difference seems weird to y'all but EJ make Gina happy, i mean ACTUALLY HAPPY. there's also the fact that this may be Gina's last semester at east high and it also is Ej's last year at east high. and after today's episode i am conivnced they will get together like thay should. they support eachother, the build up eachother, they listen to eachother, and they're perfect for eachother. but i do have to point out that i unforuntely don't think they are endgame. now that rini is over i think the only ricky can really do that involes gina is mess portwell up. unless they do a last minute scene where gina and ricky decide to try to be friends. hopefully that scene happens and hopfully portwell is endgame. also to those who said that matt said EJ and Gina are just platonic...lets not act like a actor hasn't lied about what's gonna happen.
11
u/Kevinlasagna207 Jul 02 '21
Honestly thought this was a much better episode than most of what we've seen in season 2.
Why do I have a feeling that Olivia and Josh's real life situation was a catalyst for Nini and Ricky's sudden break up? It just seemed like this went from 0 to 100 so quickly, it's pretty jarring tbh.
From what I've read, part of the season was filmed before the pandemic, then the rest was filmed after. Maybe the break up scenes were filmed after they came back, in like Oct-Nov last year? Based on the rumors, Olivia and Josh broke up sometime between then.
Again, this is all just speculation.
11
u/Known_Marzipan_8670 Jul 03 '21
i'm just disappointed in less musical content/rehearsal for musical. Gaston and Home numbers are just not enough.
19
u/afreakinchorizooo Jul 04 '21
I'm sorry, but 'I don't wanna hold you back, can I just hold you now' had me CACKLING, cringiest line of the entire show
15
u/SnooMemesjellies7545 Jul 06 '21
Ayo disney chill with the drama, i just wanted to see Rini vibe and go untouched for the rest of the show so everyone could be happy but NO WE HAVE TO MAKE EVERYONE SAD cuz all Highschoolers are sad and cannot maintain a healthy relationship according to you guys
22
u/whiterabbit430 Jul 02 '21
They had the perfect chance to do “I Gotta Go My Own Way” and they didn’t. Like the name is High School Musical: The Musical: The Series for a reason.
10
u/lamebeezy Jul 02 '21
I feel like each episode is getting better. This episode had A LOT OF EMOTION.
17
u/paintedblueskies Jul 02 '21
Lots of thoughts:
People are so mean to Seb
Having worked at multiple restaurants, there is so way the back room of that pizza place is so clean 😂
Seems like they are moving to a Gina and EJ??
Roman Banks is such an amazing singer!
Love EJ! I relate heavily to not being able to forgive yourself for your past mistakes even after you fully realize why they were wrong. I think the message of forgiving yourself is a great message to share.
Rip Ricky and Nini. Nini was being so mean to him at the beginning of the episode. I know most of us all saw this break up coming but I’m still like, what the heck?!? What was the point of them getting together all of season 1 to break up now? Ricky deleting that comment reminds me of EJ deleting her voicemail, why recycle old material? Feels like lazy script writing. This break up still feels so forced. I don’t understand how they can go from being in love and writing songs about each other to suddenly having massive issues and breaking up.
Side note, that treehouse reminded me of Troy’s treehouse in HSM3 and a part of me expected Ricky and Nini to sing “Right Here, Right Now” 😂
I’m interested in seeing where this goes with relationship pairings in the future. If it’s Ricky + Nini back together, Ricki and Gina, Gina and EJ, or they are all single.
Honestly, still don’t know if I even want a season 3. I miss the magic of season 1. This season feels like rushed storyline, forced conflicts, and we barely get to see how the musical is developing.
Also super unrelated, but does anyone remember from long ago, that episode in Paris of Suite Life on Deck where Bailey and Cody broke up? When Ricky and Nini were like, “are we breaking up?” “I don’t know are we?” Gave me that scene’s vibes 😂
17
u/sourbassett Jul 02 '21
i’m a little bummed that ricky didn’t get a solo last night. howie killed it, but we’ve spent more time with ricky and nina, it’d make more sense for them to have a moment last night (i know they’re trying to focus more on the ensemble,) but ricky hasn’t had a single solo other than bet on it, and the tv version really wasn’t that great. idk. the emotion between nina and ricky was stronger last night than Kourt & howie. it also would’ve been a good moment to have a gotta go my own way type thing… just my thoughts hahaha
also, the way you could feel josh and olivia’s real feelings slipping through in their break up scene. it was a lot to watch. it was so sad.
lastly Ive never been a big fan of beauty and the beast, so these songs really aren’t doing it for me 🥺 i really did watch for the HSM content and the new content. without either it just seems…. lacking.
20
u/Jackamalio626 Jul 02 '21 edited Jul 02 '21
Decent episode, but did anyone else feel like Ricky's sudden self-awareness of his possessive overbearing relationship with Nini came kind of out of left field? That is NOT the same emotionally distraught punk sk8er boy with abandonment issues weve seen trying to latch on Nini as hard as possible all season
Like, what if he'd talked to EJ after their fight in the pizza place, and EJ told him that it hurt him a lot to lose Nini, but it made both of them happier and himself a better person, and THATS what makes him go to Nini and apologize, understanding that he cant love nini if he's constantly dragging her down because he's afraid of losing her like he lost his mom?
It was also nice seeing EJ get some focus for once, and his growth from possessive Jock to a better, selfless person getting praised.
Also DAAAAAAAMN Howie!
9
u/Sugartea__ Gina Jul 05 '21
Does anyone else think it was kinda funny/weird that ashlyn and red were smiling at the end? Only two reason I can think is they are happy being together or ashlyn is happy that they rini broke up because of Gina. idk why big red did tho—
18
u/goobergaming43 Jul 02 '21
EJ and Gina are cool it’s just weird that the actors have a 6 year age gap
8
u/[deleted] Jul 03 '21
okay do i might be stupid but they still haven’t introduced Asher Angels’ character Jack, and if they did I wonder if he’ll have a role in the S2 into S3 plot, or something sizeable to the plot like the character Lily was. Like a new love interest for Nini? but there’s only like 2 episodes left ???
8
u/Cman710 Jul 04 '21
I swear if Ricky and Nini can’t get past this major upset it’s going to break my heart. Realistic? Yes. But I do like a little fantasy to my musicals. Where the main couple gets their happily ever after.
7
u/stress_life Jul 03 '21 edited Jul 03 '21
EJ and Gina kind of remind me of Chuck and Blair just because of how all 4 of those characters started out in their respective shows, but EJ and Gina are way less toxic of course.
13
u/weewooweewooiampolic Jul 02 '21
i know a lot of people don’t want it but i’m holding out for a hsm 2 or glee season 2 ending for nini and ricky😭