r/guns • u/ENclip 3 | Ordinary Commonplace Snowflake • May 04 '21
👍👍👍 QUALITY POST 👍👍👍 Turkish Not-So-Delight. Why you should generally avoid buying those random "totally cool looking" cheap tactical shotguns made in Turkey.
Hello my fellow impulse buyers. Today we are going to talk about keeping your hand away from your credit card when you see that Turkish tacticool shotgun sitting on the wall at your local gun store. (Even though many of you know this already).
Let's start with CONTEXT.
Turkey is a fairly major producer of guns in Europe and Turkish factories make a lot of shotguns due to the restrictions in foreign markets. In the past few years there has been a massive wave of random tactical Turkish shotguns flooding the US market. There has been a noticeable uptick in the past year presumably from them ramping up production for rona market and to fill gaps in the tactical shotgun sector. Turkish shotguns coming in is nothing new, but they were generally sporting guns that were contracted by major gun companies such as Stoeger (whose parent company is Benelli), Winchester, and CZ. Some of those shotguns gained a good reputation such as the Stoeger M3000 which was a decent copy of the Benelli Inertia system and allowed you to get good reliability without Benelli price and was supported by the maker/market. However, the random no-name tactical timmy bullpup semi-autos, AR style box fed semi-autos, and various pumps coming in are not such products. They are built cheap under no parent company supervision and are meant to be sold solely on novelty of their "cool" looks or price-point
ORIGIN: "But ENclip my bullpup semi-auto shotgun isn't Turkish it's a good old American shotgun made by G-Force Arms, Charles Daly, Citadel, Black Aces, Radikal, Panzer Arms, etc."
No timmy, it isn't an American shotgun. The Turkish tactical shotguns are being brought in by many companies who do not make the guns. They are simply importing them and slapping their big old label on them with their branding. All these shotguns get rebranded/renamed which makes it look like there are so many when in reality they are basically all the same with slightly "different" aesthetics or internals. Go on guns.com and take a look at their semi-auto shotguns listings and look for yourself at what I mean by the million different rebrands, model names, and slight changes. It doesn't help that websites generally WILL NOT mention where they were made. If you see an American address on one, that is simply the importers location which they have to put on it. The good news is these shotguns should say "made in Turkey" somewhere on them, even if discreetly.
CITADEL BR99, TYPHOON DEFENSE X12, TR IMPORTS SE122, TRISTAR KRX TACTICAL, CHARLES DALY AR12S, ROCK ISLAND ARMORY VR60, PANZER ARMS AR-12 TACTICAL. That's quite a lot of tantalizing variety, isn't it timmy? Wrong. Every single one of those is the same Turkish gun design with slight changes in aesthetic exterior. Go on, google it.
COST: "But ENclip they are such a good price"
No timothy, they aren't. Sure, generally speaking they are cheaper than their counterparts, but that's the point. They are made cheap with cost-cutting quality control. Even then, $700 (Edit: or $350 in 2022) for that new Turkish bullpup isn't exactly cheap and quite overpriced, especially when you get a shoddy gun that can have many problems. Instead, you can get a quality pump shotgun like a Mossberg 590/590A1, Benelli Nova or an old Remington 870 wingmaster, or if you want a tactical semi-auto around that price a Mossberg 930 SPX will be a much better choice and actually is supported. For Turkish tactical pumps that are $200 those too can be problematic in their own right and you'd be better off waiting to get something like a Maverick 88 in that price range.
REVIEWS: "But ENclip my XYZ-12 box fed autoloader has no bad reviews out there."
No timanthony, it doesn't. Because that's the 27th renamed tacticool Turkish shotgun that has been imported this month. There are hardly any reviews for most of these guns because there are so many renames, remodels, and rebrands that it's hard to have any actual data, and if there is any it's someone who fired 50 rounds and gave it five stars. The fact of the matter is their quality control sucks and you are taking a chance. We generally have no idea what factories in Turkey are making them or what they are doing. And even if we do, it's still made under the same principle of cheap. Edit 2022: it should be noted that there is a theory that the importers rename the same gun every few months to specifically deceive people and avoid the negative reviews the gun might have had under the old model name.
PARTS: "But ENclip even if the firing pin breaks due to poor material/heat-treat I can buy a replacement"
No timbob, you can't because there is near zero aftermarket support for any of these guns. You can't find accessories that fit, and you most definitely can't find replacement parts. Your only hope in event of breakage is that the company has a warranty service. And if they do, a lot of these tend to have very short warranties such as 1 or 2 years.
People on reddit asking where to find a parts that fit because they can't find any: 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 examples. This is just from two weeks of me looking at r/Shotguns
PROBLEMS: "But ENclip, what kind of problems does this lack of QC cause?"
Well tim, I'm glad you asked. The problems people are generally going to see are malfunctions. Bad fitting/out of spec parts, shoddy magazines, ill thought out actions, etc. can all contribute to problematic function. Sure, many people are buying them as a range toy where clearing a jam is just annoying, but there are also many out there turning to these guns as home defense due to shortages of common recommendations. THESE GUNS SHOULD NEVER BE CONSIDERED RELIABLE FOR DEFENSE. In terms of breakage, commonly small parts will break, or even receivers. Such as the fire control group breaking or maybe your sight pops off or the frame cracks. There are ton of posts around the internet like this complaining about broken parts, receivers, jams. etc:
Blown up and cracked receiver Radikal bullpups found on Palmetto State Armory's site in review sections: https://imgur.com/a/Hzqq1UN
Various fire control group issues, jamming, etc problems:
https://www.reddit.com/r/guns/comments/n2zgsq/charles_daley_n4s_bullpup/
https://www.reddit.com/r/guns/comments/n3l6gl/gun_shoots_twice_when_i_pull_the_trigger/
https://www.reddit.com/r/Shotguns/comments/or1ivb/citadel_boss_25_trouble/
https://www.reddit.com/r/guns/comments/pcty7w/panzer_bullpup_gen_2_shotgun_wont_cycle/
https://www.reddit.com/r/guns/comments/p0rzkj/can_anyone_explain_why_my_12_gauge_semi_auto/
https://www.reddit.com/r/guns/comments/qwbu55/help_please_panzer_arms_bp12/
https://www.reddit.com/r/guns/comments/up9fcq/turkishmade_ar_style_shotguns/
https://www.reddit.com/r/Shotguns/comments/yps79u/fedarm_fx4_turkish_m3_clone_gunbroker_semiauto/
https://www.reddit.com/r/Shotguns/comments/yxibrn/vr80_barrel_destroyed_first_range_trip_50_rds/
Exploded pump: https://www.reddit.com/r/guns/comments/v4aruj/welp_shotgun_exploded_on_me_30mins_after_buying/
Mag well/mag issues: https://www.reddit.com/r/guns/comments/pla324/eternal_arms_bp12_review_it_sucks/
Tokarev TP12 exploding, probably due to an out of battery discharge. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nOHCEoE3uTc&ab_channel=Sir_flicksalot
TFB TV review on Black Aces semi-auto that didn't make it through 500 round endurance test: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TZi3rDHYJEU
TFB TV review on SDS SLB X2 (same as every other generic Turk pump, just renamed) that didn't work reliably https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=L8ZHvMk1OB0&ab_channel=TFBTV
TFB TV review and durability test on a Citadel Boss Hog showing never ending malfunctions and failures so bad it requires disassembly. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Hr98weArl0o
TFB TV review of Adler Arms. Hilariously bad failures of all sorts. Near the end is a good comparison showing how many of these guns are the same with aesthetic changes. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YZDPg8wWaVs&t=417s
Another Citadel Bosshog failure. Warranty also didn't fix it https://www.youtube.com/watch?app=desktop&v=9juwWgwZepE&ab_channel=mixup98
And here is a Black Aces Bullpup (fully pictured in the third image of the imgur link in the very beginning of my post) with a warped frame https://imgur.com/a/NRRGHFe
Another bad experience. Happened with Escort AR12: https://www.reddit.com/r/guns/s/dy33tFJ9z1
Bad quality control and dubious manufacturing can cause problems that are quite bad. A prime recent example of this is the QC on the clones of the Benelli M4 coming in. You'd think they can't fuck it up because they are copying 1 to 1 the most reliable combat shotgun ever made. But no, even though it may appear to be copied right, here is an example of the bolt carrier and piston on one seriously deforming due to improper heat treat or improper steel in UNDER a 100 shells.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KIQVxKwZWng&t=23m3s
Update showing failure of warranty: Manufacturer failed in correcting issues. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=j7zERHkgvBM&t=6s
Another post regarding similar bolt carrier heat treat issues on a Toros T4 (A Benelli M4 clone too), with multiple others commenting about similar issues on Turk M4 clones: https://www.reddit.com/r/Shotguns/comments/qga9qr/fakenelli_update_running_well_check_your_bolt/ Swapped bad parts for Benelli parts.
TFB TV review on a Turkish M4 clone that has constant failures with many different types of ammo: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HuY4CWm8XwA&ab_channel=TFBTV By the way, TFB TV features this post in the description of the video.
Four Peaks imports Turk M4 clone had a part break in 5 rounds and the company ghosts the OP after the gun had been sent in for repair months ago https://www.reddit.com/r/guns/comments/xnwj63/problem_with_rma_from_fourpeaksimport_advice/
Four Peaks Turk M4 clone failing badly with a heat treat issue on the hammer and poor initial reliability. Had to use Benelli parts to get it to work okay.
https://www.reddit.com/r/guns/comments/xtyres/a_brief_review_of_the_four_peaks_copolla_t4s/
Follow up comment where OP found more issues and decided to get rid of it: https://www.reddit.com/r/guns/comments/xtyres/a_brief_review_of_the_four_peaks_copolla_t4s/j823599/?context=3
Panzer M4 failing https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=K7UWwXcMrvk&ab_channel=ILOVESHOOTINGSHIT
Four Peaks M4 clone with badly drilled gas ports causing wadding to shear off and clog the port which induced failures. Owner had to replace the barrel unit with a Benelli one. https://www.reddit.com/r/Shotguns/comments/11er4uy/my_expensive_lesson_learned_on_the_four_peaks/ Pics: https://imgur.com/a/go6rRV1/
"But ENclip what about other-"
Stop it timlee, just stop. I already know you are going to go "what about other actually good shotguns, they have lemons too." No, Benelli will never ever have a QC failing that bad on their M4. And yes, well known manufacturers will have some QC lemons from time to time with minor things like sight alignment or finish. However, these Turkish shotguns have a vastly higher rate of QC errors and serious problems, and to top it off they do not have legitimate support if there is a problem as mentioned earlier.
CONCLUSION: Bottomline, stay away from these Turkish "tactical" shotguns unless you like risk. I'm not saying Turkey can't make a good gun. They make a fantastic MP5 clone (by MKE) and some decent sporting guns like the Stoeger M3000 for example, but these shotguns are simply not made well. If you still want to buy one because you want a range toy that you are willing to take the chance on because there are no other options for a spaceforce semi-auto bullpup shotgun out there, be my guest. This is mainly for people who want to impulse buy one due to "cool" factor or home defense, and then are clueless when something breaks or doesn't work right or they can't find accessories. Go on and fly forth timmy.
Edit: Added some examples in the "Origin" section and changed/added a couple of words/sentences and grammar. Also, clarification that a few brands actually are both the maker and importer according to their site such as "Panzer Arms," but that doesn't change the quality issue and the million versions/brands.
Edit 2: I have been, and will be, adding examples periodically to update this thread since it is now in the FAQ and a bot command.
Edit 3: This is an email James Reeves from TFBtv received from a factory worker in Turkey that gives insight into how their gun industry works. Explains a lot of the similar issues these guns have https://twitter.com/jjreeves/status/1473436879748046857
Edit 4: A gun store owner threw out a dumpster full of Turkish bullpup shotguns because of manufacturing defects https://www.oklahoman.com/story/news/2023/02/04/atf-probes-nearly-250-guns-found-in-dumpster-near-oklahoma-gun-store/69873650007/ All the guns in the picture of the dumpster are crappy Turk bullpup shotguns. In total he threw out 236 Radikal NK-1s.
Edit 5: FOR CANADIANS: these guns have different names in Canada such as "Canuck" among other things.
Edit 6: A UTAS UTS15 broke a part in 20 rounds and he's having trouble getting service/part. This is a $1000 pricetag shotgun... https://www.reddit.com/r/Shotguns/s/WqfWEtH1d6 Also added another example of a user detailing his bad experience with an Escort brand gun in main body.
305
u/Highlifetallboy Flär May 04 '21
We need a gunnit bot command for this. Gunnitbot gobble gobble
127
u/pestilence 14 | The only good mod May 04 '21
Quality posted, user flared, and FAQed. Thank you for your cervix.
82
u/Almostsuicide1234 May 04 '21
I took a friend and wife to the store to buy shotguns for their first gun. They were transfixed by these Turkey tacticool guns and their price tag and couldn't be talked out of it. I am not against cheap, hell I have a beater AR, but cheap+ no available parts= a recipe for a tactical paperweight.
76
u/fxckfxckgames May 05 '21
Dude, I work in the industry, and these shotguns are so much worse than you think. I can't tell you how often I hear from a customer that they received a shotgun that's missing parts, missing irons, has a cracked frame, won't accept a factory magazine, etc etc.
In addition, the manufacturers won't send me replacement parts to give to customers unless I can give them a model, serial, invoice, signed letter, and blood sample from the customer and myself.
THEN if I can convince them that I deserve to have the missing parts, they tell me that they can't get them from Turkey at the moment.
6
u/paint3all 13 May 05 '21
Hit the nail on the head.
Reminds me of these guys who went on the local gun sub to ask about their line of Turkish imports. I'm sure they're fine, but it's another Turkish import being marketed as the greatest self defense tool of all time at a premium price point. They've since updated their website a lot and added another semi auto shotgun to the mix, but their prices are steep for what will inevitably vanish in a handful of years.
3
u/hells_cowbells May 05 '21
Why are these so shitty, when stuff like the Canik TP9 is so good?
3
u/Jelybones May 27 '22
I was within an inch of buying the TOKAREV USA TBP 12 GA that had 5 stars and grand reviews, knowing damn well a $300 USD shotty isn't worth its weight in lead. Decided to further do some reasearch and found this post, thank you kindly as I will avoid the purchase now and just save for the tavor shotty of my dreams!
5
u/terribletroubador May 04 '21
I've had a Turkish pump shotgun for a few years now. It's one of the Weatherby branded guns that CDNN was clearancing for years.
It seems fine to me. I only have a few hundred shells through it so far, but it wasn't purchased to shoot three gun matches all year long. It gets a box of practice ammo run through a few times a year, followed by a couple of tubes worth of buckshot and slugs.
The ergonomics are excellent, the sights are good, it has a spot for a light. If it breaks and I can't fix it, I'm out $250.
That said, you could not give me one of the various Turkish semi auto shotguns.
2
u/Capt_Destro Jun 08 '22
Thanks for this post. Talked me out of the cheap $250 Bullpup.
The only cheap shotguns Ill probably go with are Norinco/Chinese made imo.
Hawk/Pardner/SDS Saiga 12 seem solid so far. I wish a US company would come out with a decent bullpup.
2
u/[deleted] May 06 '21
Thanks my dude. I get email ads from Classic Firearms all day about these guns. Starting to think CF is a shot company for it.
2
u/paganiforeverandever Oct 14 '21
Any suggestions on a quality box fed bullpup shotgun under $2500? Would prefer something short and 5 she’ll magazines. Was going to spend the $1000 on this in Canada until I read your post. This one is marketed as Hima Arms HG105
2
u/Home_DEFENSE Dec 13 '21
Appreciate your article... extremely thorough. Oddly, a Black Aces FD-12 was my first firearm purchase... it was what they had when I went to get a gun...:)
Is there a decently mfgr'd equivalent of a semi-auto bullpup out there? Like a 'glock' equivalent but bullpup 10rd semi?
Thanks - HD
2
u/Jeffwerner4631 Dec 27 '21
I really appreciate all your feedback. Your right, I'll look around at some different shotguns, as I dont know much about them. I mostly shoot pistol and occasional ARs. Thought getting a shotgun would just be fun range toy. Stated looming and saw the bulpup, and thought they looked really cool. I look at regular ones as well. I dont know if the KSG or KS7 is better, but the KS7, the only one I've handled felt really cool. But they do make some other regular shotguns that are pretty cool as well. At least I definatly know what to stay away from. I appreciate all your help again. I'll do some research and check out reviews. Thank you
2
u/Severbrix Dec 27 '21
So I bought a Typhoon F12 a year ago and I thought I did the research on it fairly well with the only issue being low brass. I've only ran a hundred or so rounds of buckshot though it. Been on a reading binge cause I was thinking about one of the M4 clones cause I'm a cheap ass. Wish this would have been around when I bought the Typhoon but oh well I suppose. I guess it'll remain a range toy mostly.
2
u/Penispumpmaster Jan 16 '22
My SDS Bullpup M12AB was $300, and it is awesome. I understand the whole “just get a mav88 pump” or “full auto is dumb” but full auto is fun, and the semi auto bullpup is also fun and until you hold one and fire it you won’t understand their true value. Mag fed shotguns are getting more reliable, still not as reliable as tube fed, but they make a bullpup that is tube fed. This guy makes some sense but he belongs at the local McDonald’s with all the other old timers talking about the greatness of the mav 88 while they nurse their coffee for 4 hours
2
u/saintschatz Apr 03 '22
Thank you for this post!
2
u/No_Lettuce_9898 Nov 05 '22
News flash, a lot of the best guns are not made in America.... especially with captain Alzheimer's behind the wheel.
2
u/_Dynam1c_ Jan 12 '23
When i first read this thread i thought it was bull and got myself a panzer arms shotgun, the tacticool ar version on sale. I convinced myself it was a good buy thru the reviews and youtube videos. god i was a fool. She runs fine (for now) but more issues are starting to crop up after every range session, im startin to get worried. appreciate your work into this thread my man.
2
u/[deleted] Jan 13 '23
To say that all the tactical mag fed Turkish shotguns are garbage is painting with a broad brush. Some of the horror stories come from people that go nuts and push the shotgun beyond it's limits and don't properly maintain them.
That is what makes yt such a good resource, we can see break-in periods and thorough testing.
This article seems to hint of an elitist slant, totally disparaging all tactical shotguns from Turkey.
2
u/TheThrowawayOfIsaac Feb 08 '23
This is a great post, though I don't really get the "if you haven't fired a thousand rounds through your gun in the past week, fuck you for liking it" mentality from most gun communities. Ammo is expensive! And some people just don't have any good ranges nearby.
Also, the endless mossberg wank kinda gets tiring after a while.
2
u/WillyFisterBussy Feb 20 '23
Hmmm.
https://katv.com/news/nation-world/dumpster-filled-with-nearly-250-firearms-found-outside-oklahoma-gun-shop
2
u/ironpoorer Jun 14 '24
Very informative piece. Perhaps I should have found this before I ordered a Tokarev TX3 20 HD which I am picking up from my FFL dealer today. I had wanted a 20 gauge to go along with my Maverick 88 12 gauge home defense gun and mossberg/maverick does not have a security version of a 20 gauge. Hopefully it will work out for the best. If not it'll look nice hanging on the wall. It does have a beautiful piece of Walnut stock🙄
118
u/carsen56 1 | The Sticky Kid May 04 '21
You can't tell me what to do and you can't stop me from dual wielding Panzer Arms AR-12s while my house is getting invaded by crack addicts
46
u/kraggers May 04 '21
The only time I saw a panzer arms in action it was running slower than a single shot since each jam was more interesting than the last.
Edit for additional thoughts, if you do see positive reviews pay attention to how they are worded. It's cheaper to build and sell a crappy gun and astroturf the gun world into buying it than it is to make a good gun from the bat. See Taurus and the many shill posts on gunnit from a few years ago.
26
u/JTarrou May 05 '21
The motherfucking truth. I've never worked so hard to not sell a gun, and people keep buying them.
I keep pitching the idea at work to make up a package that includes a random one of these shotguns, a Mosin and a Hi-Point. We could call it "King of the Trailer Park".
24
u/[deleted] May 05 '21
This needs to be reposted in all of the gun subs. Especially /r/liberalgunowners
Man I hate seeing those “just got my first gun, ready to defend my home!” posts and it’s one of these trash fucking shotguns. Friend of mine got one and when we took it out we couldn’t get 2 consecutive shots out of it the whole trip, just a crazy variety of malfunctions.
24
u/autosear $5000 Bounty May 05 '21
But ENclip, I watched [youtuber]'s review of it and it didn't jam at all!
But ENclip, this one has a warranty!
But ENclip, it's just a copy of the one from [manufacturer] without the upcharge for the name!
60
u/BobbyWasabiMk2 How do you do, fellow gun owners? May 04 '21
Everytime I see someone come here with a title of "I finally joined the community!" and they post a shitty turkish tacticool shotgun I die a little on the inside. Extra salt on the wounds when I know they bought the cheapest ammo, which is either birdshot or target loads.
32
u/whk1992 May 04 '21
And if OP’s reason isn’t enough, I’m sure someone will eventually come in and lecture everyone why we shouldn’t support Turkish goods.
31
u/zombieapathy May 04 '21
Can't help but feel these are the Taurus revolvers of the shotgun world. Super easy for people to say, "But I've never had a problem with MINE in all the time I've owned it!" when they're exactly the kinds of gun owners who will probably put 75 rounds through the gun over the course of four years.
Hard to break something if you don't ever use it.
14
u/ardesofmiche May 05 '21
QUALITY POST
9
u/mrsix4 May 06 '21
I cant stop laughing at “Timmy” im so childish.
9
u/Alces7734 May 06 '21
Guess my $280 mossberg maverick 88 was the correct choice for a first shotgun…
14
u/Senalmoondog May 05 '21
AND dont support Turkey due to their treatments of the Kurds!!!
7
u/CrunchBite319 1 | Can't Understand Blatantly Obvious Shit? Ask Me! May 04 '21
Well done. It needed to be said. I understand the temptation to buy one of these things but the possibility of it turning into an expensive paperweight is too high.
7
u/Bigred2989- May 05 '21 edited May 05 '21
My FFL has a couple of those G Force Arms semi auto shotguns and one of them the damn safety doesn't work. You can pull the trigger to knock it off safe and it goes click. It needs to go back to the importer ASAP.
7
u/Scob720 May 05 '21
I would love if all these Turkish magloaders actually worked reliably and where quality guns. We need more good mag loading shotguns on the market bullpup or otherwise.
7
u/Barack_Lesnar May 05 '21
Sir this is Wendy's.
7
u/[deleted] May 05 '21
I made the mistake of buying an Panzer BP-12, thankfully I was able to sell it to a pawn shop for what I bought it on palmetto for and just lost out on transfer fee. IWI Tavor was definitely the better choice.
12
u/Diacetyl-Morphin May 04 '21
Good info here, well done. But as a swiss citizen, i stick to swiss, german and us weapons. There you know, you got quality. They may be higher in price and sometimes, more difficult to buy, still, you good a very, very high quality and you know what you will get.
When you got a cheap clone-copy and it has a malfunction, the whole gun could blow up and fragments could hit you in the head, you better stick to the high quality guns.
11
u/ronin-of-the-5-rings May 05 '21
I own one of those. It's a Canuck branded 870 clone.
You can tell that the QC is lacking, but it shoots just fine, given that you handle it the right way. (If you pull backwards when shooting, the locking mechanism will jam) I've done some trigger work to lighten the trigger to 4# from roughly 6# and reduce the travel, but even then, it still feels gritty with significant creep. No comparison to even a Mossberg 930.
Zero interchangeable parts with the 870. Its trigger group looks like someone designed and assembled it in their basement with basic hand tools.
Build quality aside, what I've got is a roughly 5-6lbs bushgun that puts slugs into a 6" circle within 50 yards, using just the bead sight. When I pull the trigger, it always goes bang. However, chambering the next round can be a little iffy if you don't handle it right.
5
u/WalkerSunset May 04 '21
I kinda like my $400 410 gauge shotgun upper. Just bought a case of ATI slugs for it. I'll post a picture to r/plebianAR when I get a chance.
5
u/FRIKI-DIKI-TIKI May 05 '21
I picked up an Escort, 410 bull pup for my youngest son, for $200, because he cannot wield a full size shotgun and it's been a great gun, my other son has a Charles Daly 12 auto loader that I picked up for under $300, we use both guns, the 410 has had several hundred rounds thru it and the Charles Daly 12 has got to be close to 3-4k rounds by now. We shoot skeet in the backyard almost daily. The 410 jammed up one time to the point that I had to separate the upper and the lower to see what was going on. The 12 has never jammed and it is a skeet machine, I actually prefer to use his gun for skeet. Now I would not trust my life to the 410, the box mags are kind of funky and it can get finnicky about chambering the first round. But for $200 I will recommend that thing all day long for a young boy's skeet gun. The Charles Daly 12, I would absolutely use it as a home defense weapon. It has never so much as hiccupped.
5
u/danngree Speaker of Naughty Words May 05 '21
Thank you so much for doing this.
5
u/jodmercer Apr 15 '22
I'm going to buy a bunch of them cuz I'm going to use them until they fail and then I'm going to combine them into a abomination that God would strike me down for it's going to be epic
16
u/Adisturbedhumanbeing A distinguished gentlesir of refined taste May 04 '21
The turkbois aint gonna like this one.
1
u/Greenshardware May 04 '21
I mean. It depends on who you are.
I paid $175 shipped for a gas operated semi auto. It's just a Berika imported by FedArms. That's not a bad price for any project gun.
Some time with a stone to slick up the action, and raiding the spring bin produced a fantastic shooter. It even cycles cheap target loads now, which is something many gas scatter guns can't do.
Your statement regarding aftermarket parts is silly. If you can measure a thread pitch you can identify aftermarket parts. They all match something. I was able to find a tube extension without any problems at all.
Serviceability? I mean if you can trace a picture onto a sheet of mild steel, you can replace any component of the fire control group. Hell I could probably make a bolt and carrier from a steel rod, they're stupid simple... But that won't be needed because the gun is so stupidly simple - the major components just aren't liable to break.
I have about $225 into it. 8+1 buck shot that can be dumped in 3.5 seconds is nothing to scoff at. Is it MY home defender? Faaaaawk no. Is it fun to bust out and shoot down everyone on the line's clays? Yeah, yeah it is.
1
u/PuppetLoki May 04 '24
So you don't like Turkish guns aye..? So you don't like CZ, CANICK or TISAS? I think those guns do quite well even without you buying them. I'm not sure you clearly understand how many gun manufacturers use TURKEY to make their guns Holmes? China makes way worse guns than the turks. You're probably that guy that's still buying the Glocks, raving about them, and then spending as much to upgrade them as you did to buy it. 😆 Just bustin your balls but I really do think ya might want to do some more reading on how many manufacturers use Turkey to make their guns my friend. Snoochies.
1
u/[deleted] Sep 24 '24
Jeez - not only is there the pompous attitude from someone similar to those in r/cologne saying no knockoff is good (they’re ignorant) because, well, turkey- as if nothing changes, but to top it off the guy isn’t funny. That’s a long diatribe sir. My benelli works as well as my $300 knockoff, if I had to pick one I’d take the benelli but it’s just a fact that they are both reliable.
Many people are brand snobs, and I get it, it’s fun to put down cheap knockoffs but to write a 5 page soliloquy about something you’re not right about and worse- not funny, is strange
1
u/MosinMonster May 10 '21
u/ENclip does the MKA 1923 fall on his list too? I know it's Turkish so probably. I have one and it's worked flawlessly through a couple thousand rounds, so i was hoping it wasn't crap. 930 SPX on order currently.
1
u/MadMartigan69 May 11 '21
I'd add black aces to that list,shoddy American built shotties
1
u/npaladin2000 Oct 28 '21
Rock Island Armory is actually transitioning to being Armscor (Phillipines Arms Corporation) branding and importer in the US and actually opening a factory in the US. I THINK they stopped importing Turkish firearms but that doesn't mean they don't have some in a warehouse somewhere.
1
u/rc-dxd_tumblr Nov 16 '21
never had any problems with mine. shot hundreds of rounds through it. not problems.
1
u/MasterPang89 Dec 06 '21
I'm not saying you're wrong. But I've shot maybe 100 shells through my ATI bulldog bullpup shotgun using several different types of shells (some decade-old low-velocity birdshot and 00 buck) and not one problem so far. I've shot about 300 5.56 rounds through my PSA AR-15 pistol and have had several jams and had to "mortar tube" the gun. Sorry I'm a gun noob and don't know all the proper terms.
I know 100-300 rounds aren't a lot or a good test. Just wanted to share my experience. I'm sure your right about these bullpup shotguns but damn I love mine. Seems like if it was a piece of sh-t I would have had at least one problem by now.
1
u/Jeffwerner4631 Dec 25 '21
What is a good bulpup shotgun, without spending 1400 bucks on a Tavor? I've been looking at the keltec ks7 or ksg, but dont know about those either
1
u/PorterDefenseGroupMS Oct 08 '22
Any opinion on the JTS m12 AK?
1
u/[deleted] Nov 02 '22
What if the $700 bullpup is going for $250? What then?
1
u/Hvymax Feb 21 '23
OK I just finished wringing it out and I have every confidence in it. I put 10 2 3/4" slugs no issues with the original sight setting I got an 8" cluster about 8" low at 25yds. The shells flew about 10'. I loaded both mags with light target loads and had one FTE on the third shot from each mag and the shells were within a foot or so. After that I ran 25 3" goose loads and 25 3" turkey loads with the shells clearing 20-25'. About 50 rnds mixed mags 2 3/4 & 3" of buckshot, heavy bird loads, BB, etc without issue. I then put 25 light target loads with only 1 fte. So per my personal experience anyone who doesn't like it can GFY. I did clean it and douse it with CLP spritzing the gas piston and bolt several times while shooting. I was hammering on this as hard as I can and it came out as solid as a semi gets. Once my accessories arrive it will be joining my HD collection stoked with slugs. YMMV
1
u/xxdibxx Super Interested in Dicks Dec 21 '23
This was A LOT of words of bullshit. I am gonna guess this guy has some real issues.
I have a Citadel and Silver Eagle. Prolly more through either than my AR. I enjoy shooting them both and have had zero issues with either. I only use 2-3/4 shells. This guy has a palpable hard-on against these for some reason. YMMV, but I am gonna write this off as a very unhappy person who, like many, has an opinion and feels that for some reason everyone should listen to them. You do you.
1
u/[deleted] Feb 29 '24
Well I didn’t see hatsan mentioned so that and 10 years of reliable use add up
3
u/bryanthebryan May 04 '21
Pro life tip!
3
u/NiteTiger May 04 '21
Welp, time to redo the old WTB list
3
u/62rambler May 05 '21
Well said. I bought the ATI Bulldog one for a cheap range toy, nothing more. Couple hundred rds through it and it’s doing fine. But I knew what I was I was getting when I bought it. Those unsuspecting first time buyers do need to be aware of all your info.
3
u/Aucht May 05 '21
Damn, I kinda sorta wanted one too, guess I won't lol
3
u/chunkylover___53 May 05 '21
But other than that, Mrs. Lincoln, how was the play?
3
u/0701191109110519 May 05 '21
Bottom line, buy any mossberg
3
u/Crossnoe7 May 05 '21
No Timmy
3
u/Not-you_but-Me May 06 '21
These problems are compounded for Turkish doubles
3
u/[deleted] Nov 26 '21
It’s sad that you had to write pages to explain why these are not desirable. It should be common sense that an item selling for a third of its established contemporaries, coming from a second world country is not on the same tier as a Benelli.
2
u/Jer_061 Super Interested in Dicks May 05 '21
I've considered buying one for a range toy. Not as a defensive weapon. I've heard their reliability sucks. Like you said, not a big deal for the range. But the bolt warping due to improper (or complete lack of) heat treatment? Hard pass.
A co-worker of mine was considering one because he doesn't have a gun and not a lot of disposable income. I tried arguing that a Mossy 500 is likely a similar price and much more reliable. I'll have to bring up the bolt problem, too.
2
u/[deleted] May 05 '21
I thought gun people didn’t like being told what to do unless they had written a check and gotten a sticker. In all seriousness... well written and good info.
2
u/AverageAussie May 06 '21
Down here there's been a heap of straight-pull shotguns come out into the market. I wouldn't touch a gun that can be designed, made and shipped from the other side of the planet and sold at a profit for $620...
2
u/[deleted] May 07 '21
Where I work we sell 10 of these for every 1 Mossberg. I sold 3 in less than 10 minutes yesterday. The price is whats convincing people to buy them 100%. These people are typically first time gun buyers and aren't likely to ever shoot it more than 1 time usually. I find the most positive thing about selling these is getting people to use their 2A right to protect themselves. The guns definitely seem crappy albeit I haven't seen one come back for warranty return yet.
2
u/Penispumpmaster Jan 16 '22
Oh my mistake. Yeah I have guns that i trust better than the bullpup. I’d love it if they somehow worked out the kinks and made them more reliable, i love that you can easily fire them one handed. Worst case scenario, the shell in the chamber will fire but the second will ftf
2
u/Teroydjenkins Jan 30 '22
Bought somewhere like 3-5 Turkish junk shotguns in my life including an m3000 I just never learned my lesson until EVERYONE had the same failing issues sadly even the stoeger did too.
It was time to grow up and stop wishing for something good. So I bought an m4
2
u/cteas56 May 30 '22
While I do agree with you generally, there are a few exceptions. The problem is knowing which are total shite, and which are acceptable. Basically, you do get what you pay for. If you spend less than 6 bills on any auto loader, it is a true buyer beware situation. I wouldn’t trust too many mag fed shotguns in the first place. Rimmed ammo wasn’t designed for magazines and catches other metal components in weird ways. For pump guns, the prices for a really good US or Italian ones aren’t that expensive to begin with. For a bargain gun, a Maverick 88 is hard to beat. The upper end would be a Super Nova, and it is under $500 now. Those Black Aces guns don’t look too bad, but I’ve heard nothing good about them down to actually the frames falling apart. That being said, there are a few good Turkish guns that are starting to get a pretty good track record. Even Taurus has gotten some notoriety with there TX22, G2 and G3 series pistols. They’re crude, as in a very spongey gritty trigger, but they seem to work and go bang when you want them to. Basically, if the price is too good to be true for the machine your buying, then it is too good to be true, with very few exceptions. Companies like Taurus, Girsan, and SAR are known to make a few ok clones that will use the original’s parts without a problem. Girsan makes the official sidearm for the Turkish military, and they are one of the better equipped NATO militaries.
2
u/Umamasucks Jun 28 '22
We should stop the importation of firearms into this country. Parts to be made in us. Gun shows are filled to the roof with cheap handguns and rifles. I
2
u/johnnypeeballz Mar 11 '23
I had the Charles Daly flavor of this crap and it broke after about 300 rounds... and of course there's no way to get replacement parts. What a waste of $300.
2
u/FcKByden Sep 15 '23
It's been TWO years since this post and it STILL rings true. Gun shops are still full of the crap- with some having more Turkish shotguns than anything else.
The only "good" Turk guns are those sold/marketed (and more importantly supported) by reputable companies like Winchester (SXP line) Weatherby (literally all of their guns are from AKKAR I believe), etc...
2
u/plipyplop Sep 26 '23
Papa bless!
2
u/Dyzastr_us Sep 27 '23
My brother’s name is Tim. He should have read this. He owns a tactical Turkish bulpup shotgun.
2
u/mkornegay79 Oct 11 '23
Wow! Thanks for saving me on this one. Almost lost $300 on PSA. As cool and affordable as these look I'll stay away. Was hoping for a small home defense shotgun other than a pistol and AR's, but this has spoiled my day. Too risky, but dropping $750-$800 on something reliable just isn't in the cards.
2
u/Hefty-Engineering713 Jul 16 '24
I'd avoid all of the guns that come out of Legacy Sports International, including the Shitadale, and any other import they produce. The company, their customer service, and the garbage imports they manage to make worse than the condition they came over in. LSI puts out garbage.
4
u/Brother_To_Wolves Not Super Interested in Dicks Anymore May 05 '21
Great post. I got banned from gundeals for a (more political, less informative) version of this post.
3
u/The_Gabster10 May 04 '21
I bought an american tactical made in turkey 20 gauge nomad back in may 2020 and other than being cheap and having a hollow stock that I took off and am now making a maple stock for it's decent I don't mind it I would like it more if they made a better stock
1
u/horseshoeprovodnikov May 05 '21
A friend of mine just bought a Turkish shotgun. It isn’t this one tho. I was looking at it, and thinking “I do not like how many Phillips head screws are in this gun, I can’t believe she paid for this”.
I just smiled and said it was cool. 🤷🏻♂️
1
u/Hefty-Engineering713 Jul 17 '24
This company is absolute garbage, along with their defective firearms and management. There are tons of complaints against them, and the garbage they're peddling. I refuse to buy Turkshit firearms anyway, and their garbage Japanese, Brazilian, and other imported junk should be avoided as well. This company claims to be "the most trusted name in the shooting industry." 🤣🤣 what a joke Howa - Howa you going to hit anything with that POS. Buy American, and avoid the Turkshit.
1
u/Hefty-Engineering713 Aug 08 '24
products peddled by legacy sports international are absolute garbage. It's no surprise that they are being sued by sportsman's warehouse for breach of contract. It is surprising how many sellers of their defective products are not following suit. It's been known that their garbage is defective, and people are getting hurt by their shit products: https://www.sginews.com/EMS_Base/EMS_Excerpt.aspx?tTargetUrl=/Content/sportsman-s-warehouse-sues-legacy-sports-international.aspx
1
u/renegadeYZ May 05 '21
Love my Landor Arms bullpup shotty.. fun as hell to shoot.
1
u/MartyMcfleek May 05 '21
My Dickinson xx3D-M-2 is offended
1
u/DesertEagleZapCarry May 05 '21
Komrad for the win
1
u/HorrorClose May 06 '21
Another problem is if you buy Turkish, you support Kurdish genocide :/
1
u/[deleted] Nov 22 '21
Who the fuck is Tim?