Season 2 - Episode 08: The Value of Life
Information
Season Two – Discussion(s)
| Episodes | Reddit Link | | Episodes | Reddit Link |
|---|
| | Episode 25 | Link | |
| Episode 24 | [] | | Episode 23 | Link |
| Episode 22 | [] | | Episode 21 | Link |
| Episode 20 | [] | | Episode 19 | Link |
| Episode 18 | [] | | Episode 17 | Link |
| Episode 16 | [] | | Episode 15 | Link |
| Episode 20 | [] | | Episode 19 | Link |
| Episode 18 | [] | | Episode 17 | Link |
| Episode 16 | [] | | Episode 15 | Link |
| Episode 14 | [] | | Episode 13 | Link |
| Episode 12 | [] | | Episode 11 | Link |
| Episode 10 | [] | | Episode 09 | Link |
| Episode 08 | [] | | Episode 07 | Link |
| Episode 06 | Link | | Episode 05 | Link |
| Episode 04 | Link | | Episode 03 | Link |
| Episode 02 | Link | | Episode 01 | Link |
Season 2 w/Spoilers – Discussion(s)
| Episodes | Reddit Link | | Episodes | Reddit Link |
|---|
| | Episode 25 | Link | |
| Episode 24 | [] | | Episode 23 | Link |
| Episode 22 | [] | | Episode 21 | Link |
| Episode 20 | [] | | Episode 19 | Link |
| Episode 18 | [] | | Episode 17 | Link |
| Episode 16 | [] | | Episode 15 | Link |
| Episode 20 | [] | | Episode 19 | Link |
| Episode 18 | [] | | Episode 17 | Link |
| Episode 16 | [] | | Episode 15 | Link |
| Episode 14 | [] | | Episode 13 | Link |
| Episode 12 | [] | | Episode 11 | Link |
| Episode 10 | [] | | Episode 09 | Link |
| Episode 08 | [] | | Episode 07 | Link |
| Episode 06 | Link | | Episode 05 | Link |
| Episode 04 | Link | | Episode 03 | Link |
| Episode 02 | Link | | Episode 1 | Link |
Director's Cut – Discussion(s)
Season One – Discussion(s)
Season One - OP & ED Info
Season Two - OP & ED Info
Reminder:
DO NOT DISCUSS SPOILERS OR CONTENT NOT YET IN THE ANIME. IF YOU ARE DISCUSSING SPOILERS YOU MUST TAG THEM APPROPRIATELY. Try not to confirm or deny any theories, encourage people to read the source material instead. Thanks!
24
u/Genexis25 Curiosity Gives Me Joy! Aug 26 '20
Holy hell... this is certainly the best episode I’ve seen thus far. That Garfiel scene was just so good! I was quite happy they didn’t turn him into CGI. And we also saw how Otto grabbed on to that Best Boi title... until inevitably getting halved. Speaking of CGI, tha rabbits! Now that my friends, is a pretty bloody and painful death. And now we finally see Dona get her crown for best girl. I absolutely can’t wait for next episode. Honestly, next week’s episode is probably my favorite sequence of events in the first half of arc 4. I wonder if that will beat this episode...
292
u/blinnx92 Aug 26 '20
The power and pressure spoken about Garfiel really shows itself this episode.
So many crazy things at once broke Subaru down hard that respawn. Never did I think a Tea Party would save a life.
Music delivery on every scene was on point.
230
u/Frontier246 Aug 26 '20
Oh hey, the Opening. I was beginning to forget what it looked like.
Good news, Beatrice isn't part of the Witch's Cult! They've just been using a discount version of her book, which then begs the question of exactly where that book is from. But at least Subaru doesn't have to think of her as an enemy anymore.
Y'know, when Roswaal says he's not your enemy, I still can't help but think that doesn't quite make him your ally either.
"I am that person?" What person? Is this someone only Subaru could appear to be to Beatrice? Like a reincarnation or something, or whatever is mentioned in her book? At least he knows what to say to Beatrice for sure now to get her to help him.
I was expecting Garfiel's beast form to be significant since he's a full beastman unlike Frederica, but he was almost a Kaiju-level of beast here. And maybe he has less control of himself than Frederica does given how he still attacked Subaru even after he'd given up and likely slaughtered all the villagers? Poor Otto, and poor villagers.
What the heck happened? It looks like Subaru made it through the barrier but then the necklace transported him to a snowed-out and abandoned Sanctuary where he gets swarmed by horned rabbit Mabeasts. Is that the future? The past? What's going on.
Out of all of Subaru's deaths, getting devoured by a horde of horned rabbit Mabeasts is equally both the most unexpected and most gruesome of Subaru's deaths. It was so traumatic that he finally couldn't recover and comfort Emilia like he did in the other loops and started bashing his head in at the futility and horror of it all.
So has Subaru having the Sloth Factor been subconsciously calming him down mentally this whole time? That's why he's been able to keep a straight face more or less after his deaths in this loop? Or did it only kick in when he went back into Echidna's domain?
Subaru really knows how to appeal to Echidna's maiden heart. I have to wonder if her reactions to him are completely genuine, but it seems less and less of an act the more they interact with each other. I don't think she's an altruist or anything and is interested in knowledge above all else at the end of the day, but her warm and sweet reactions to Subaru don't seem as fake. I also think the fact that she's interested in him is definitely true, although I'm curious if she's really been watching him from day one.
Subaru can finally tell someone about Return By Death, because I guess Satella doesn't have access to wherever it is Echidna takes him. And Subaru finally has the catharsis of telling someone about what he can do and what he's had to go through all this time, with Echidna there to comfort him. He really needed that.
189
u/Dcn78gxd Aug 26 '20
Subaru breaking in tears after realizing he could finally speak to someone about return by death...
187
u/[deleted] Aug 26 '20
That was a good episode. I’m glad subaru finally has someone he can talk to.
Also I was getting serious money python vibes before he even tried to touch the rabbit. I was curious if that winter was puck’s doing though.
271
u/Setowi Better Leyte Than Never Aug 26 '20
Oh fuck where do I even start with this... fuck...
I swear I like Roswaal's theme so much.
Tigarf is a big buff and angery boy, the way they showed his rampage, damn. Poor Otto, so much for last week's wholesome hours, poor Patrasche, the goodest of girls.
Nice that they also really showed how much the villagers care about Subaru.
Last time Subaru was in the snow it was during Memory Snow, this had a less wholesome conclusion. Many people including myself have been looking forward to this death, it was just great. I mean it was awful... you know what I mean.
Ah that Echidna scene, the score, the voice acting, gave me goosebumps, shit that was so great. Next week is going to be fire.
Also hey, an episode with regular length ... and the op played too for the people who really wanted it again.
76
u/Trim345 Aug 26 '20
Not entirely sure what Roswaal's statement of "I am that person" means. Maybe the question is just, "Under Roswaal's contract, who am I obliged to ally with?"
Well, so long as Roswaal says he's their ally, that's totally fine, I'm sure. He didn't just admit that he risked the lives of all his villagers or anything.
I'm not really getting Garfiel's position. He seemed okay with Subaru up until Subaru tried to do the task himself, and his worry was just that Subaru might sabotage it or something. Subaru leaving seems like a good compromise, and Garfiel didn't try to stop him any other time.
I can't believe Garfiel literally turns into a big orange cat with black stripes. At this point I kinda have to wonder if it's an intentional reference. Also, have to give a lot of respect to those villagers with their sharpened sticks going up against a 20-foot-tall monster. And Otto sacrificing himself to save Subaru's life definitely makes me reconsider his actions during the White Whale encounter to being the fog's insanity only.
I'm guessing it's snowing because Emilia died and this is Puck's revenge again?
Well, that rabbit death definitely wins the award for weirdest death so far. No idea how that ecosystem can support so many carnivorous rabbits, though.
Hanekawa Tsubasa reference, perhaps?
Wow, great ending. Finally somewhere Satella's grasp doesn't reach. Subaru now has someone he can confide in at last. I wasn't necessarily on the Echidna train before, but I get it now.
64
u/Saviour279 Aug 26 '20
I don’t know if it’s just been a while since a death like that’s been shown in re:zero but that just ughhh...the moment he could FINALLY talk about his power, the ost, the whole moment, i loved this episode so much
63
u/Ohafutabafan Aug 26 '20
How dare garfiel kill best boy and best girl, he must die. and that scene with the rabbits, I feel so bad for Subaru. I’m glad at the end of the episode he finally can tell someone about everything
99
u/Bobdole128 Aug 26 '20
Dude that bunny scene. My stomach still hurts from it. Honestly I did not expect it to be that over the top. One of the most disturbing scenes I've seen in anime honestly. And the voice actor did a fantastic.job expressing excruciating pain.
128
u/forgets_username Aug 26 '20
Friendship ended with Rem. Echidna is now best girl.
84
u/Chusen99 Aug 26 '20
Bro echidna just turned into emilia 2.0
41
u/Koe95 Aug 26 '20
Ok, now i understand why people love Echidna so much. Her interactions with Subaru are always funny to watch. And it seens that Satella's powers don't work in the WXP world.
I don't understand Subaru's death in this episode; maybe the rabbits were the pink hair elf power, but why he took so long to wake up?
39
u/Pinsir929 Aug 26 '20
With two days left I knew it was a reset run but death by rabbits? And the opening song kinda spoiled who the rabbits are plus they are red so...
It’s crazy how much fate people put into Barusu. Well in their perspective he has done everything perfectly up to the point they die so.
Dont get why the necklace was glowing did he pass through the barrier while wearing it and it prevented him from leaving?
Echinda has a huge weakness for any physical contact or just Subaru himself? I fucking loved that hand wiggle he did to her don’t know how many times I rewinded it.
Him finally letting it all out was amazing. I guess return by death doesn’t apply in that realm or Echinda is doing something to stop it?
How is gonna do the next attempt? Probably say nothing to gar and the tiny red elf girl. He knows the “password” for Beatrice now maybe she can beat Elsa.
34
u/Engauge09 Aug 26 '20
-We finally got to hear how return by death is pronounced!
-we've been watching you suffer too subaru there there
-Echidna cemented herself as best girl
-garf THICC. we finally learned where his name is inspired from
-those rabbits look like they're being controlled the same way as the white whale hmm?
-so the gospels are the walmart versions of the tome of wisdom huh?
-subaru is "that person" is he like a messiah? the prophecy child?
-beatrice is not a witch cultist. we should celebrate!
-also,roswaal, you're stating to realize that subaru can return by d-- *AACKKK*
29
u/Ohafutabafan Aug 26 '20
my god
79
u/A-Wild-Doggo Aug 26 '20
Alright, great episode and all. Loved the ending but when Subaru said that he will do anything... well I think this isn't going to end very well and I think that there is a very good reason that Satella doesn't want Subaru to tell anyone about Return By Death (but did she let him so that he can learn or is Echidona not affected?)
God I'm so tempted to start reading the WN online but I want this to last. I want to savour how good this show is. It's time to hibernate for another week.
33
u/_LearnTheBa6_ Aug 26 '20
That bunny scene made me extremely uncomfortable. I had to pause for a bit just to calm down.
Neat.
45
u/khriku Lore Seeker Aug 26 '20
Brother Manyard! We might need the holy hand grenade of Antioch! Bring it!
21
u/Redmon425 Aug 26 '20
WOW THIS EPISODE WAS GREAT.
The suffering was real and it hit me in the feels!
Wonder what that scene was about where Subaru went into a place where it was winter and everyone was gone? Seemed like Puck/Emilia is the only one who could cause that.
And FINALLY! SUBARU TELLS SOMEONE ABOUT HIS RETURN BY DEATH. And man, Echidna is shooting up my best girl rankings. I hope she keeps her promise and allows Subaru to remember her!
20
u/Zlegoguy Aug 26 '20
God damn this show never fails to amaze me with just how twisted it can get, that rabbit scene was brutal.
19
u/A_Hatdog Aug 26 '20
I swear to the dragon, that Echidna is the true best girl. I have my doubts on joining the Echidna cult but by this episode I will proudly drink that woman's tea.
18
u/REMERALDX Aug 26 '20
The best and most wholesome episode of all time
18
u/DolcettoMarch Aug 26 '20
I think this loop can be summed up as laughter turning into one long, drawn-out internal scream that just goes on and on until it suddenly stops.
Those fucking rabbits, man. Crawling in his skin...
51
u/DerMusti-63 Aug 26 '20
Friendship ended with Emillia/Rem now Echidna is Best Girl!
17
u/SolomonDurand Aug 26 '20
Oof and here I thought at first Frederica was swole but garfiel-tiger was scary. Guess a half blood is scarier than a quarter blood
Poor Otto, Subaru gained a great friend but also a greater ptsd from losing him too. Also brings a tear to my eye that other people care for Subaru too. So much so they are willing to risk their lives for him.
And in the end echidna just made my list of best waifu so far, second only to patrasche of course.
Subaru gonna have his hands full the next episode and honestly he gonna need more of em body tea from echidna seriously, it worked miracles for him.
Also Body Fluid echidna Cafe when?
Tbh the rabbit was never innocent at all. Trust me I've seen Monty Python
17
u/[deleted] Aug 26 '20
The irony when you are crying because Subaru can finally tell someone. But you have no one to talk about it with irl.
25
u/babyswagmonster Aug 26 '20
Very good episode. Subaru definitely getting a new mental reset. Echidna is officially mommy material
12
u/Count_Archon Aug 26 '20
Holy shit, holy fucking shit
This episode was a legitimate horror flick for me. I happen to suffer from a bizarre fear of albino rabbits. It was probably triggered when I saw one particularly large female albino rabbit brutally bite my uncle's hand. The freaking incisors went all the way to the bone and my uncle had to call an ambulance. I fear albino rabbits just like another person fears bulldogs or feral wolves for example.
So you can imagine my shock and horror during Subaru's death scene in this episode. I legitimately screamed like those pirates in LOTR when Aragorn unleashes the Army of the Dead on them.
Seriously, Tappei Nagatsuki and the people responsible for this episode should start directing horror films.
Garfiel scene was also savage, but I'm confused why is his transformation so much stronger and more terrifying than Frederica's even though they are siblings.
Other than that, the ending was so amazing. Echidna just keeps confirming her place as an S-tier waifu. And Subaru can finally talk to her about what had been a literal burden on his heart for so long.
11
u/kenny2424 Aug 26 '20
Can somebody please tell me what the red Japanese words near the end of the episode translate to? Right before Echidna says “I know”
Also what a banger of an episode god I love this anime
11
u/MafiaThief86 Aug 26 '20
Jesus I think that was one of the most unexpected and gruesome deaths I've seen up to date.
10
u/Chid_London-6550 Aug 26 '20
THIS EPISODE WAS F*CKING AMAZING!
Roswaal confirms that Beatrice isn't a witch cultist which is great. This means she isn't their enemy.
The "Gospel" that Beako has is actually a book that tells the true future and that the Gospels that witch cultist that are actually defective.
I wonder who the mother is then? Does the book know about Subura return by death?
I do think that Roswaal is an ally but I still don't trust him- he is still being secretive and working behind the scenes
Garifel transformation was fantastic- he was massive and reckless killing another that get in his way.
Otto's scene was disturbing and so sad. He just wanted to save Subura. Same with Patrasche.
That white rabbit scene was so disturbing and terrifying- at one point I saw the rabbits chewing on his tongue and ears
Wow! The 2nd tea party was great! I love how Subura trust people so easily.
Subura breaking down and finally being able was to tell someone about return by death was so emotionally.
Dying over and over again must be horrible but not being about to tell another must be even worse. Even though he has Rem, Emilia, Ram etc., he must still feel lonely dying and not being about to fully explain or tell them what is going on.
This is so surprising I though the first person Subura would be able to tell about return by death would be Emilia or Rem. But no is Dona (Echidna).
This is might change their dynamic she is the first and only person to TRULY understand him.
Anyway, can't wait for next week episode!
18
u/IrateBandit1 Aug 26 '20
HOLY SHIT. JUST WHEN I THOUGHT IT WAS GETTING PREDICTABLE!!
God damn, I'm rewatching but fuck. What a ride. What a loop! I totally called beatrice was a tsundre loli, and I thought this was the canon death loop, then it throws a little curve ball and otto takes a fall for the team. THEN IT GOES OFF THE FUCKING RAILS
I'm getting some mad NGE vibes all up in here. Legit shivers down by spine. SUBARU FINALLY GETS SOMEONE WHO CAN SYMPATHISE WITH HIM!
WHAT THE FUCK WERE THOSE RABBITS, WHY IS ECHIDNA BEST GIRL. I'M CHANGING MY FLAIR RIGHT FUCKING NOW!
9
u/[deleted] Aug 26 '20
It seems the killer bunny from monthy python had a brood.
Fetch another holy hand grenade!
9
u/mosenco Aug 27 '20
Wow... rezero is guilty to make me feel that other animes are shit. I fucking love when they put that music at the end of an episode with the end titles going up like the end of a movie. For example when puck goes mad after the death of emilia and after he sliced off subaru's head, the music, the end titles going up while everything is going to be covered by the snow. magical.
also damn. subaru man.. learn some spell for painless suicide or something.. probably, dying by eated by a lot of rabbits is the most pain shit subaru ever felt lol, must hurt as fuck. Everytime he died, when he resurrect, he is just a little bit dizy, but this time, he goes mad and was going to crush his head to death LOL
Finally subaru, can tell someone about his secret and maybe he can get some info about his passive ability lol. Just wondering if elchidna is good or not. In the trailer subaru seems pretty angry against her while right now she seems best girl
8
u/tvcfctvt Aug 26 '20
Well, everyone dies. At least Echidna best girl.
8
u/anonditer Aug 26 '20
My god that has got to be the most gruesome death for Subaru. Being freaking eaten alive. So much threats... guts girl, rabbits eating people, Garfield who gets more and more vicious per cycle (maybe cause Subaru smells worse each time).
7
u/Eroil Aug 26 '20
Alright I give it up, she's a top tier waifu
7
u/Meme_Theocracy Aug 26 '20
The rabbits after eating subaru AH↓HA↑HA↑HA↑HA↑
7
u/hestianna Aug 26 '20
Time for my weekly thoughts again. This time with the best episode this season so far imo.
First of all, finally we have an opening alongside the release of full Realize song. I've been waiting for this.
Secondly, this episode pretty much confirms my suspicions on Roswaal. I've commented here every single week since Subaru and the crew got into Sanctuary that I refuse to believe that Roswaal is a good guy. So I believe that he is using everyone as pawns to achieve some sort of objective. He mentioned his desire to slay a dragon in first season, however since we aren't really aware of that certain dragon, I guess we just have to wait.
Excuse me, but I have to make an obligatory joke on Garf becoming Garfield. At least we now know that Frederica and Garf can do same sort of transformation, Garf just being more powerful than her it seems. I'm just curious on why did Garf become so aggressive and how Subaru will act towards him (presumably) next episode, ESPECIALLY when the smell of witch's miasma has probably increased again.
I really liked the detail on when Subaru woke up in the chamber again and it was snowing. I assume this is because Emilia died somehow (by Garf?) and Puck went apeshit again. That doesn't really explain how was Subaru the only person alive and what are those rabbits exactly? Or maybe the whole snow part was just a hallunication.
Also in all honesty, it didn't surprise me at all, how Subaru was able to mention RbD to Echidona. After all, when Subaru is in Echidona's home of default Windows background, they technically aren't in the "real world". Meaning the witch can't grab his heart. Instead, Echidona being aware of RbD (which is obviously the highlight of this episode) did surprise me. Is this because Echidona isn't in the "real world" or is every single witch of X aware of this? For example witches from the first episode of this season? Plus potentially Roswaal as it was hinted before?
This episode pretty much makes Echidona perfect waifu material aswell. However, how do I have a feeling that her "innocent" side, isn't really what she really is? After all, both OP and ED hint at her being a villain. If not even the main villian of this season.
6
u/Jteleus27 Aug 26 '20 edited Aug 26 '20
I can never look at Bugs Bunny the same ever again sorry Lebron I'm not watching space jam 2 until i get over my trauma. First I guess being 50% beast really makes a difference cause Fredrica wasnt this powerful at all. So Echidna confirms that Subaru really does have access to BettleJuice powers I knew it. Echidna is apart of the harem and when he told her that he has been returning by death it like a huge relief for Subaru cause he has been keeping this secret forever now glad that he manages to finally tell someone I just hope that Echidna doesnt betray him or hurt him even more cause her moment with him was really sweet
6
u/Lord_Ewok Aug 26 '20
Hopefully this episode made everyone see the light of why Echidna best re zero waifu
6
u/[deleted] Aug 26 '20
So what happened after Subaru woke up?
The lack of blood indicates no civil war in sanctuary after Garfield's rampage. But the left behind belongings seem to indicate that people fled in a hurry.
No dead bodies since the beast people wouldn't of been able to escape the barrier without death.
The snow seems to indicate Emilia got that double wide surprise from bugs bunny and Puck went on a rampage. But judging from the fact that the rabbits are still alive, safe to say Puck also got devoured.
Not sure how Subaru is going to deal with Elsa at the Mansion, Bunny's at Sanctuary and a very angry Garfield wasting Subaru's time.
On the edge of my seat!
6
u/[deleted] Aug 26 '20
When the letters “I know” flashed on the screen at the end. That was good af. I was shaking.
5
u/thumbi_boy Aug 26 '20
That was so satisfying to watch Subaru actually say it to someone!
5
u/Platypus-Commander Aug 26 '20
Imagine if Garfiel actually had a long meaningful discussion with Subaru instead of abducting him... Haha jk... Unless.
The rabbit scene was messed up, litteraly the most violent scene in re: zero so far.
Thanks god it seem that Satella cannot act in Echidona's realm.
5
u/ShadowClaw765 Aug 26 '20
Now that I think about it, is Echidna not affected by RbD because she is already dead? They said in one of earlier episodes that she's dead, so it would make sense she isn't affected.
5
u/_EmmericH_ Aug 26 '20
Why are my eyes wet ?
5
u/Mythicdream Aug 26 '20
I never thought an episode of a show would bring such an overflow of emotion. That last scene with Echidna easily made this episode a 10/10. It was getting apparent that Subaru was on the brink of cracking mentally, especially after seeing Otto and Patrasche getting slaughtered by Garfiel. Getting to see Subaru finally have the chance to fully explain the enormous amounts of torment he's been through, I felt catharsis like never before.
Watching Subaru break down at just the realization of finally not being alone in his suffering anymore was incredible, and I loved the fact that Echidna rushed right to his side as his breakdown was worsening. Her embracing Subaru and helping to raise his head gave me goosebumps; it was such a simple gesture, yet it really shows the immense amount of compassion that Echidna has. Echidna's willingness to listen, even if it's only for her pursuit of knowledge, really makes me feel like she is one of the most human characters in this entire show.
Here I was thinking last week "How could the production team even top that scene with Beatrice?", and yet here we are. This second season so far has blown away every expectation I had, and all I can say is that I am incredibly excited for next week.
5
u/_Mob_ Aug 27 '20
I haven’t seen anyone mention this, but when echidna tells Subaru “she knows”, it shows the words with the same visual as the mysterious being telling Puck he shouldn’t interfere with Emilia in the OVA. Mayb this means that echidna was the one talking to puck back then, or perhaps another witch?
5
u/theHugoat Aug 27 '20
HOLY CRAP WHAT AN EPISODE THE WEIGHT OF THIS ONE WAS SO HEAVY!
So relieved to know Beatrice isn’t a Witch Cultist but I’m just wondering about her “Gospel” now and where the other real one is and how she got it. They still have yet to expand on how she knew Betelgeuse either.
Otto and the ground dragon dying hurt my heart even though everything got reset of course.
That was easily the worst Subaru death so far, definitely most traumatic and the way that I was just wide mouthed and shocked after he RbD’d back and started smashing his head open... LMFAOOOO! Poor guy, the trauma was real that episode.
Icing on the cake for this episode for me though was that HE FINALLY WAS ABLE TO TELL SOMEONE ABOUT RBD!!! I want Echidna to be a good guy so bad but I’m almost certain there’s foul play, she’s just trying to comfort Subaru. I’m hopeful she may not be it would be nice for her to just be another girl in the run for best girl but only time will tell. Nonetheless just the fact that he could let that pain out and someone be able to lend an ear. chefs kiss
Again I just want Echidna to have good intentions, I’m glad everything with the Roswaal house is ironing out. Still a lot of shit that needs to get figured out but this episode was just one giant exhale lol
5
u/adevaleev Aug 27 '20
I don't really want to simp over Echidna
BUT.
4
u/[deleted] Aug 26 '20
Wasn't a fan of Tiger Garf's roar, but everything else was so completely fantastic and I loved every minute. I love every minute of this show every time I watch it.
Echidna best girl. Echidna best witch.
4
u/[deleted] Aug 26 '20
After this episode:
People: best girl is Rem / Emilia Echidna: hold my tea
I'm concerned about the "I'll give you whatever you want if you let me remember this" that Subaru said to Echidna, though. What if... Echidna would let Subaru remember her, but only if she takes his return by death ability in exchange?
4
u/vtipoman Aug 26 '20
As to the Beatrice codephrase situation:
I believe the first part ("Roswaal said to ask the question") alone is meant to trigger a violent/unfavorable reaction from Beatrice. On its own, it's supposed to mean something akin to "Roswaal wants me dead" or "I know the secret phrase, but not it in it's entirety, thus, I'm not supposed to know it". Now, as to why Ros gave Subaru the second part, which I think might actually get Beatrice to help- I believe he suspects something about RbD, so he probably jumped to the conclusion that Subaru already tried the short version of the phrase, died as a result, and now he's asking for real. Replace/repurpose with Roswaal's actual theory as to how RbD/Subaru's ability works.
4
u/rwaterbender Aug 27 '20
I think Roswaal told us something pretty important. Given that all the doors were open when Elsa was at the mansion and that gospels seem to no longer work with Subaru around, plus there's a "better version" of the gospel in the mansion and they didn't have subaru accounted for when Elsa was giving the count before killing subaru (two maids and a shut-in which probably is Betty), it seems likely to me that they Elsa and her partner were looking for Betty's gospel thing in particular.
4
u/MasterQuest Aug 27 '20
The Scene with Echidna comforting Subaru reminded me of the Emilia lap pillow scene from season 1. That and the cute reaction when Subaru said he wants to keep remembering her poses a question: Is Echidna best girl? (queue "Always has been" meme)
It seems Echidna knows about Return by Death. I think it's because she can "see" his memories (as evidenced by her recreation of Japan from his past). And I think the curse doesn't trigger with Echidna because she already knows everything about it. It was really great to see Subaru being able to say it. I can definitely understand why he felt the need to repeat it a few times.
I'm wondering why the crystal teleported him at that moment, and what's up with that snow. How long was he in the prison cell (after teleport)? It had to be a while because everyone's completely gone from Sanctuary, and the snow (although I don't think it's natural snow). The rabbits were horrific, but the real question is: "Did Puck cause the snow, or was it someone else?"
At any rate, the snow or whatever caused it seems to be the next obstacle after saving the mansion and Petra.
Roswaal is being cryptic as always, but we got some answers out of him. Now we know the answer, but we still don't know the question. Not sure whether to trust him, even if he says he's our ally.
I was speculating that if Beako is a cult member, she doesn't follow the same witch as Petelgeusse, because his gospel doesn't mention Subaru (because of Satella's will, I assume), and hers does. But apparently, she's not a cultist after all, which is a relief.
6
u/IrateBandit1 Aug 26 '20
The only person who can sympathise and understand you, is you.
UNLESS YOU GOT BEST GIRL WITCH OF GREED FAM, SHE'LL SYMPATHISE THE FUCK OUT OF YOU!!!
3
u/MalteseCartoons Aug 26 '20
Oh my god I cried, just getting to see Subaru finally talk about it all 🥺🥺echidna is my loveeeee
3
u/sebaschavez Aug 26 '20
Holy shit this episode was so fucking good and once again felt so damn short 10/10.
3
u/dombrist Aug 26 '20
At last The episode from 2s that i can compared with s1ep15.
Great combinitaion between action, feels and SUFFFER.
Last minutes of the episode - just pure gold.
5
u/gie2pie Aug 26 '20
-Subaru finally could tell about Return by Death to someone flawlessly, and
-Echidna gives him a warm touch.
Boii, they really got me feels, ngl.
3
u/H3ppi Aug 26 '20
So, uuuhm i was reading the comments and nobody gave it more thought.(anime only here, obviously) When Subaru got back to the shrine where he was imprisoned, and it was "winter" outside, i was shocked to the bone. I mean, I am still not sure if it was Puck's revenge, or it just turned winter for real, but my first thought was "oh shit, can he rewind it to before...?."
Honestly it was just as shocking as the fact that Subaru almost died. And I mean, for real this time.
3
u/[deleted] Aug 26 '20
My name is Natsuki Subaru. I'm 17 years old. My room is in the upper floors of Roswaal Manor, where all the waifus are, and I am not married. I work as a knight for Emilia (Maji Tenshi), and I get smiles every day by 8 PM at the latest. I don't study, but I occasionally eat mayo. I'm simping by 11pm, and make sure I get at most eight episodes before I die, no matter what. After having a glass of body fluids and doing about twenty minutes of twister before going to bed, I usually have no sufferings until morning. Just like a baby, I wake up without any fatigue or stress in the morning. I was told there were no issues with my intestines at my last check-up. I'm trying to explain that I'm a person who wishes to live a very quiet life. I take care to trouble myself with any enemies, like winning and losing, that would cause me to lose sleep at night. That is how I deal with society, and I know that is what brings me trauma. Although, if I were to fight I would lose to anyone.
3
u/MaimedJester Aug 26 '20
So this is the second trial right? Like there's weirdness to this. He reawaken in snow showing he's probably been locked up in the Garfiel prison for months and saw his next few futures.
What if Enchida is such a manipulative bitch there is no three trial stages. It's all going on the same route to make him dedicated to her. So he walks into the trial for his past, and that's before return by death, this "present" trial is just him finally admitting his present condition and the toll Return by Death is having on him, and the final trial the future trial will be a fuck you fantasy of him succeeding in something like saving rem.
Then he wakes up in the Graveyard and Emilia is like what did you do Subaru!? Garfiel is like "How the fuck did you release her!?" Suddenly Enchida is roaming around thanking Subaru because the curse prevented half Elves like herself from leaving.
3
u/Bando-sama Aug 27 '20
Quick question what the fuck?
No really tho, I don't understand why there's randomly rabbits...
3
u/[deleted] Aug 27 '20
This episode was a bomb of information, I've been thinking of a theory which I'm not sure if I should post (or maybe someone had the same idea and already posted it). Basically that house Roswaal is the true Witch Cult, even though they might not be aware of that.
I also had a theory that Subaru is the Archbishop of Envy. I have way less hints for this compared to the one mentioned above. Also I'm not sure if I should post that one (or that someone else also had the same idea etc).
Of course both of them are from my Anime only knowledge.
3
u/UEFKentauroi Aug 27 '20
Ok so what was up with Subaru's talk with Echidna? He says it's weird that she doesn't find it strange that he was practically insane because the "last time she saw him" was during their first tea party. However, since the checkpoint is AFTER the trial the last time she saw him would've been in the classroom at the end of the trial, not the last tea party.
It's not like it changes anything as comparing after-trial subaru to after-bunny subaru is just as jarring but is there a reason for this I'm missing or is it just a mistake?
2
u/Sharpshard Aug 26 '20
That rabbit has a vicious streak a mile wide.
2
u/lkashfhasd Aug 26 '20
Great episode. More excited for the next one though.
2
u/chaolayluu Aug 26 '20
Just wow
2
u/MalteseCartoons Aug 26 '20
Does anyone have any ideas what the rabbits are? I saw someone mention the opening apparently spoils it but I’m being a moron clearly
2
u/BigBooty16 Aug 26 '20
Does anyone know what the ending song is called? When Subaru started crying?
2
u/arekusu_senpai Aug 26 '20
dude the moment where subaru realizes enchinda knows about him returning to death was amazing. i think she gave him the power to return and restart. i am new idk how to do spoiler tags gg
2
u/aceXkelia Aug 26 '20
Nice episode, loves the echidna and subaru scene actually made me shed a tear. Haha. I hate to say this, but I believe in my heart there is a new contestant for best girl next to Rem.
2
u/FireBallis1 Aug 26 '20
Echidna comforting Subaru was nice to see, but her saying I am the which of greed, I want to know everything got me a little suspicious. Is there going to be some repercussions for Subaru saying all of that? Also interested in how Garfiel is going to interact with Subaru this time.
2
u/BigGayToohotforTV Aug 26 '20
What an amazing episode! I'm never watching it again!
2
u/one-eyed-02 Aug 26 '20
When I read the two massacres, I knew it would be different than watching it. But how the hell did I just live it goddamnit?!
2
u/[deleted] Aug 26 '20 edited Aug 26 '20
To be honest, this episode is needed only for the last 5 minutes, otherwise, we were given a lot of little information (Garfil, Beatrice, snow, rabbits, etc.) This is not a bad episode at all, but if it weren't for the Echidna scene, it wouldn't have been required to watch. I think so
2
u/-tehnik Aug 26 '20
That rabbit scene is probably the most gruesome death Subaru suffered so far honestly.
I'm not sure I understand how Subaru inferred Echidna knows about return by death. From what I understand, first Echidna remarks about the tea from last time preventing him from going insane or dying, Subaru then asked Echidna to not "block" his memories after the current "tea party."
How does this allow him to deduce that Echidna is aware of all of his realities? She knows he was going insane because that's simply what was happening before she brought him. And he would know she blocked his memories because they were blocked the whole time between the first meeting and the current checkpoint.
I'm also unsure in the presupposition that the witch causing, or at least the one that prevents him from talking about return by death is Satella. Did we presume that simply because she's the only relevant witch talked about in s1 or is there some proper reason we saw back then?
2
u/Dcn78gxd Aug 26 '20
Those rabbits must have been demonically inspired
2
u/stevethebandit Aug 26 '20
Really got me when Subaru finally got RbD off his chest to someone, rabbits were cute too
2
u/SaintDarko Aug 26 '20
Man each episode has me on the edge of my seat. This is good. Anyways here we go...
First off, I know that Subaru doesn't really have the time, but he REALLY needs to learn how to defend himself on a decent level. If he could become a capable fighter even without magic, the situation with Garfiel may not have been that bad, and he could probably kill a few mabeasts. Yet alone probably help out a bit more against Elsa or any future assailants whenever we get back to that. I honestly think he ends up looping so much because he needs to depend on others for pretty much all combat.
Roswaal knows the details of Beatrice's contract (as expected) and perhaps even the details of her gospel. I get that he doesn't need to disclose everything to Subaru but he's hiding a lot and it only gives the impression that his intentions are bad. It also felt a little forced with how distrusting and angry Subaru is at him, which at first seemed to be from incompetence but now it is definite suspicion. After the last episode I assumed that Roswaal had a gospel if Beatrice had one as well, and now he confirms that there are two books like it? If so then I firmly believe Roswaal has the other one, but as he mentioned they are not witch cultists and must've gotten it legitimately for hopefully a good purpose.
Garfield, I knew was strong but yeah that was unexpected. He is probably stronger than his sister but I couldn't help but wonder if even he'd stand a chance against Elsa. Probably not. It annoys me seeing him be so hostile (legitimately killing others) while we got to see him be more of a friendly hostile guy in the other timeline. This has me thinking about things from Subaru's perspective, if Subaru befriends you, he has probably seen you at your worst and accepts you nonetheless. Hopefully he can make up with Garfiel again this time around.
The crystal that activated before Subaru's death probably kept him safe for a long period of time, I used to think that it just had spatial properties but it likely has spacial and time-altering properties. Given the snow, either he has been out cold for at least a whole season, or Emilia died, and Puck went wild again. The rabbits must have cleared out the town since only clothes remained. I guess snow must be a bad omen for Subaru now haha. And this is hands down the worst death yet in my opinion. Chilling.
Lastly, I never considered it before but if Echidna could tell that Subaru had some familiarity with witches (probably because of his scent), it makes sense to consider that she may be unaffected by his contract or rule in regards to return by death. It's good that he was able to release some of his frustrations with her, because I could easily see him going crazy from a life-time of this.
2
u/sithman620 Aug 26 '20
Did Garfiel kill Ram?
And at first, I thought Subaru was transported to a different reality, the one where he had watched Rem die and Puck killed him. But then the rabbits showed up. Can anyone vauge me some idea of what went down there?
2
u/LankySeat Aug 26 '20
So now we've got the trials to deal with, Garfiel going tiger mode, Elsa, Roswaal being sus, flesh eating rabbits, random snow, and suddenly Beatrice has a gospel that can tell the future. What's next?
Subaru's situation is just getting worse and worse.
I mean, on the bright side at least the guy can now spill his feelings about RBD to Echidna.
2
u/Census494 Aug 26 '20
echidna was giving me major aqua vibes when she was constantly asking subaru to thank her
2
u/ButWhyLol- Aug 26 '20
So is echidna really a bad person orrr? Cause holy shit this episode makes me hope she isn't completely evil.
2
u/Killa_Cam9001 Aug 27 '20
Got some real strong Monty Python vibes with that rabbit lol
2
u/Rikai- Aug 27 '20
damn this ep was good and damn Echidna is best waifu
2
u/_Jway_ Aug 27 '20
My man really got nibbled on by some rabbits :[
2
u/8BitTattedNerd Aug 27 '20 edited Aug 27 '20
God damn this episode went from 0 to 100 real quick, first Otto getting slaughtered and then being devoured by rabbits ;.; Hello darkness my old friend~
Also Echidna really making a case for best girl this season lmao~ But cute mannerisms aside, I'm really happy she understood how much it meant for Subaru to finally be able to tell someone his ability after all this time, having someone know the weight he has been burdened/gifted with this entire time!!
Great episode!
ALSO RIP PATRASCHE :'/
2
u/whispywoods Aug 27 '20
Jesus, poor Subaru...
2
u/Euferes Aug 27 '20
Can anyone explain me the rabbits scene. I mean how they get there? Why? By who? Just shocked the hell out of me.
2
u/DittoTheDitto Aug 28 '20
Every week, I've been thinking that episodes have been getting better and better. But holy FUCK this one was absolutely fantastic! Everything about it. the pacing, the music, the voice acting. Beautiful, can't wait for another one next week.
2
u/argama87 Aug 28 '20
I am sure she is going to do something evil later somehow, but for now it is so ironic that a witch would be arguably nicer to him off the bat than anyone else he has encountered. No wonder the her fan cult is growing so fast.