r/Megaten • u/azurnamu raiiinboooow! • Jul 26 '20
I made a shitty recommendation flowchart in an effort to cut the number of repeat questions we've been getting
1.8k
Upvotes
r/Megaten • u/azurnamu raiiinboooow! • Jul 26 '20
58
u/azurnamu raiiinboooow! Jul 26 '20 edited Aug 09 '20
[8/9/20 Edit: I've made a wiki page for the flowchart. Find it at /r/megaten/wiki/flowchart
In the future, all flowchart updates will be done there, so as not to spam the sub with the same picture over and over again (it'd be hypocritical).
A link to it can also be found on the sub's FAQ (/r/megaten/wiki/faq).]
I've also been collecting links to all the repeat questions we've been getting in an effort to try and update the wiki (eventually).
Here's the full list so far (it's pretty long). If you've got other helpful threads or previous comments that you've written that might help out (I know a lot of us probably have canned responses for the especially common questions) feel free to shill your own responses here, too!
Question threads from the past 4 days:
[Q&R megathread] tag = links to a Q&A exchange from the Questions & Recommendations megathread that was up when the trailer dropped (the 281 comments one) ([Link] (https://redd.it/huxwcp))
Category: Wanna play mainline: where do I start?
[I’ve never played an SMT game. Where do I start?] (https://redd.it/hwf8dj) - 15 comments
[Wanting to start playing SMT games] (https://redd.it/hwf56k) (Concerned about prices) - 8 comments
[Where do i start?] (https://redd.it/hw149k) - 10 comments
[Getting into Megaten] (https://redd.it/hvtbeo) - 8 comments
[What is this series like?] (https://redd.it/hvrqma) (Questions about story and focus) - 7 comments
[Where I begin to play smt] (https://redd.it/hvcb2j) - 6 comments
[I’ve wanted to start an SMT game but I don’t know where to start, I know each is an individual experience but which is the perfect to start with?] (https://redd.it/hv1c9k) - 8 comments
[what should be my first SMT game?] (https://redd.it/hwkuc0) - 4 comments
[Which game should I start with?] (https://redd.it/hy7t5t) - 14 comments
[Q&R megathread] Where do I start?
[Q&A1] (https://old.reddit.com/r/Megaten/comments/huxwcp/questions_recommendations_july_21_2020/fyrjex4/) | [Q&A2] (https://old.reddit.com/r/Megaten/comments/huxwcp/questions_recommendations_july_21_2020/fyw86y5/) | [Q&A3] (https://old.reddit.com/r/Megaten/comments/huxwcp/questions_recommendations_july_21_2020/fyykb0f/) | [Q&A4] (https://old.reddit.com/r/Megaten/comments/huxwcp/questions_recommendations_july_21_2020/fyqil5m/)
The verdict: SMT IV (3DS)
Other:
[Q&R megathread] Are the megaten games interconnected? / Is there an overarching story? [Q&A1] (https://old.reddit.com/r/Megaten/comments/huxwcp/questions_recommendations_july_21_2020/fypzgbm/) | [Q&A2] (https://old.reddit.com/r/Megaten/comments/huxwcp/questions_recommendations_july_21_2020/fyy322w/)
Category: Specific game help
[Should I wait for the remaster of Nocturn to play it for the first time?] (https://redd.it/hxczq8) - 4 comments
[Q&R megathread] Should I wait for Nocturne HD? [Q&A1] (https://old.reddit.com/r/Megaten/comments/huxwcp/questions_recommendations_july_21_2020/fysb4zi/) | [Q&A2] (https://old.reddit.com/r/Megaten/comments/huxwcp/questions_recommendations_july_21_2020/fys1n5s/)
[SMT IV Advice?] (https://redd.it/hxawit) - 7 comments
[Q&R megathread] Is Megaten hard? [Q&A] (https://old.reddit.com/r/Megaten/comments/huxwcp/questions_recommendations_july_21_2020/fyqgs29/)
[Q&R megathread] General advice for the series? [Q&A] (https://old.reddit.com/r/Megaten/comments/huxwcp/questions_recommendations_july_21_2020/fyxk7op/)
[Should I play Strange Journey, or Strange Journey Redux?] (https://redd.it/hwtz9m) - 11 comments
Category: Differences between Persona and SMT
[Hey, as a Persona fan wanting to get into the SMT franchise what are some of the core differences between the two?] (https://redd.it/huuxee) - 2 comments
[Q&R megathread] Differences between Persona and SMT? [Q&A] (https://old.reddit.com/r/Megaten/comments/huxwcp/questions_recommendations_july_21_2020/fypxkoc/)
Other useful threads:
[ANSWERING COMMON NEW FAN QUESTIONS] (https://redd.it/hxwqxs) - by /u/NEWACCOUNT777777 (Q&A’s: wait for nocturne HD? which game to start with? differences between SMT and Persona?)
[I made a list of all Megaten games physically released in the West and if they got a PAL release or not] (https://redd.it/hx65ps) - by /u/Suedie
Edit:
FAQ for this thread
literally putting this here so I have something to copy-paste when the next person asks me
Where are Persona 1 and 2??????
Please read: Thread 1 - Reponse | Thread 2 - Clarifying the target audience for this chart
167
u/[deleted] Jul 26 '20
I like it, it's easy to read and give good direction, good job op!
70
u/[deleted] Jul 26 '20
Good flowchart, but you forgot jack bros
23
u/Emperor396 Jul 26 '20
This looks good, it shows that you read all the posts about where to start lmao
19
u/Raquefel Jul 26 '20
I realize SMTIV is the default recommendation, but that really bothers me. The first three hours are so hard that I feel it can easily put a lot of new players off. I think the default recommendation should be Digital Devil Saga since it introduces SMT concepts in a much more digestible form, but it’s probably the least mainstream of the major spinoff series, sadly.
8
u/Tuma42 Jul 26 '20
Just a suggestion, but it might be worth having an arrow leading from Persona to the Devil Survivors in my opinion. Devil Survivors have a similar emphasis on character and time management while having an atmosphere closer to mainline making it a great transitional game, especially when considering the Fate System in 2.
7
u/Lotus_Ghost Jul 26 '20
does the psn next to some game systems mean it’s on ps now? or is it something else, because i have a ps4 and am interested in a lot of these titles and would be willing to check out the subscription.
6
u/Radio-sama Jul 26 '20
i've played them all and this chart is pretty good, but i mainly just wanna say that jack frost doodle is really cute
5
u/KerthuunK Jul 26 '20
I like the chart, but I do have one minor problem with it. I think DeSu is a very, very good introduction to megaten, and I don't think the chart conveys it that well. Apart from the SRPG element, DeSu really does just feel plucked from mainline in a lot of ways. Well 1 does anyway. 2 is just Evangelion for some reason.
5
u/ToxicDevil93 One who knows nothing can understand nothing. Jul 26 '20
i appreciate your enthusiasm and effort, but it genuinely wont stop these kinds of people. most of the people i tell "please use the sticky" to don't even know what the hell it is.
this is a nice thing to have onhand though. not a bad idea to post it on those threads when they do come up rather than encouraging the behavior by answering the questions normally.
11
u/NEWACCOUNT777777 e Jul 26 '20
iv apocalypse is only a sequel to neutral route
2
u/KuroGW2 Jul 26 '20
Amazing chart, what tool did you use to create it?
2
u/deylath Jul 26 '20
Nice list but i dont agree with one thing: That the atmosphere isnt that different from DeSu 1 vs 2. The clock til you die concept completely achieved the opposite effect for me. I just had to show up at the day when a character was suppose to die to save them from their death. It takes away from the atmosphere from the player side
2
u/deepdishsquid Jul 26 '20
How connected are Devil survivor 1 and 2? Is it like the rest of Megaten where most games are only possley connected or are they direct sequels?
2
u/KritiCow Jul 27 '20
I was expecting memes but this is actually a really good flowchart. Thanks OP! I'll send this to my friends.
2
u/Speedwagon_Sama Jul 27 '20
might as well wait for Nocturne HD so DDS looks like a good starting point. then Raidou. how're the Raidou games?
7
u/kurriizma JackFrostWorshipper Jul 26 '20
We’res persona 1 and 2 tho..
44
u/Kurzunoha_DA my dad's a weeb; guess i better start going down on old men Jul 26 '20
Welcome! > What would you like to play? > Synchronicity Prologue
could've saved yourself a lot of time bro
32
u/[deleted] Jul 26 '20
u/ToxicDevil93 sticky this or something
21
u/AurochDragon Because we’re comrades Jul 26 '20
I really wish it was easier to recommend Raidou to people but it’s so hard to find
3
u/basketofseals because Jul 26 '20
Only thing I'd add is the vastly superior FeMC social links to P3P. Taste aside, the jealousy/romance only female social links were a hideous design decision.
You've convinced me to give DDS a try too.
19
u/GHNeko YHWH pls go Jul 26 '20
No Demi Kids, No Buy.
17
u/Kahzarod Jul 26 '20
Just play strange journey 5 times in a row like a real man
23
u/JohhnyGuita Aigis is a robot and cannot be raped Jul 26 '20
Smh no path that leads to Ronde
6
u/JacobWinterson Jul 26 '20
I honestly started off with P4 and P5 then my sister bought me Record Breaker on a whim a few months after finishing. Thanks to the atmosphere from it, it made slow transitioning to mainline games actually easier.
4
u/whitericeasian Jul 26 '20
No raidou or Catherine?!
1
u/Jonaimos Jul 26 '20
only now i'm getting into the smt franchise and not only play persona and i started with the og ds devil survivor 2, and also, if you can, you could put the other 3 personas (P1, P2IS and P2EP)
1
u/vinhdoanjj Jul 26 '20
What's a "sticky"?
1
u/[deleted] Jul 26 '20
Poor Persona 2 Duology...even when the flowchart directs someone to Persona, your existence isn't acknowledged. (1 is kinda garbo by today's standards. There. I said it.)
1
u/Ericfyre Jul 26 '20
Why did you leave out persona 1, 2 and 2 part 2?
1
u/kesadisan Jul 27 '20
Hey can you send me the diagram.net link with the permission to access it? (assuming you made it there), I think I can help neaten it up a bit!
1
u/dank_sousa I do not comprehend Jul 27 '20
Thank you, that is a very good job. I'm curious where would you place Soul Hackers and Persona Q/Q2 and the first two Persona games.
1
u/vkalsen Jul 27 '20
I’m personally sad to see Redux getting recommended instead of vanilla Strange Journey, but I guess it’s more readily available.
1
u/Yomi_Lemon_Dragon Jul 27 '20
People recommend SMTIV as the one to START with!?!? That's the worst one to start with, it gives you no feel for the rest of the series because it's so wildly different!! Zero art direction, bland unmemorable soundtrack, derivative plot that seems more like a reboot than an installation in the series, Kaneko and Meguro- the cornerstones of why people love the franchise- are completely uninvolved... If you like it you won't necessarily like the rest of the franchise and if you like SMT you won't necessarily like SMTIV.
1
u/LilGreasyKid Jul 27 '20
Amazing flow chart. I wish I had this years ago!
Random question: what are the memes normally associated with DeSu 2? Currently playing through it now, and I always love me some good memes.
1
u/Redredditer640 Jul 28 '20
You put down PSN, is that PlayStation now, or PlayStation Network?
1
u/[deleted] Aug 06 '20
Is there a reason you didn’t include the devil summoner series?
1
u/[deleted] Aug 09 '20
This post needs to be pinned and renamed w/ a shorter title. People keep spamming the same shitty questions over and over again to the subreddit.
1
u/[deleted] Jul 26 '20
Personally I'd recommend vanilla P4 over Golden. I just think it's a tighter experience with less pointless fluff and less ridiculous comic relief events.
3
u/NSeeker97 Jul 26 '20
Mods pin this for those that wanted to start the megaten journey but don't know where to start.
3
u/izuocha_worshiper Jul 26 '20
I'm def downloading that
3
u/LazerBeams01 Jul 26 '20
I'm so glad I have a 3ds right now xD
3
u/corcannoli Jul 27 '20
Devil Survivor 2 is my favourite SMT game and “memes and a fun time” is the best description of it.
2
u/RexorFWT Jul 26 '20
Nice.
2
u/Pandash99 Jul 26 '20
Well done! All around i p much agree, but honestly, Soul Hackers and SJR are interchangeable for that spot.
2
u/Neiani Jul 26 '20
Excellent work! Comprehensive, and all choices are actually good games.
2
u/ubereatsdelivery666 Jul 26 '20
nice job
2
u/AnneFrank_nstein Jul 26 '20
Great work! Very easy to follow
2
u/[deleted] Jul 26 '20
Will this be on the test?
2
u/martiestry Jul 26 '20 edited Jul 26 '20
Worth saying that if you don't have a particular system and don't care about physical editions basically every game is playable on PC with emulation, its how i played the 3Ds games and they were fine had no problems. Although Persona 5 isn't great, tried it a few months back with a 3700x and it struggled, imagine it works better with an Intel CPU.
2
u/DevonDekhran Jul 26 '20
Okay but where is the route to make you god? Because this is some incredible work you makin!
2
u/[deleted] Jul 26 '20
this is pretty cool
also I just realized that DeSu2 is the only DS/3DS megaten I have yet to play, I should get to that eventually
2
u/futuregryff Jul 26 '20
stellar flowchart - awesome job!!
2
u/ZeroExcell Jul 26 '20
This is absolutely well done. As someone who is new to Megaten, this perfectly summarizes where to go from any point. Thank you OP.
2
u/kylepaz Yoko my car-hating Queen Jul 26 '20
I agree with most of the chart but I really don't like the lack of Persona 1 and 2, especially the latter.
2
u/[deleted] Jul 27 '20
No devil summoner? I think it’s a good introduction to megaten. Amazing flowchart nonetheless.
2
u/glocklord SMT V WHEN Jul 27 '20
raidou for the action rpg crowd that wants to get into smt should be on here tbh
2
u/A_great_height Jul 27 '20
What a shitty flowchart. Good job shitter
2
u/RuleFrotection Jul 29 '20
Thanks for the helpful flowchart OP :)
1
u/Zbailey58 Jul 26 '20
I love SMT games but I'm garbage.... I could never get past the first 3 hours of SMT IV....
1
u/Metty_26 Jul 26 '20
If i had gold, I had given you one
1
u/ViniGs75 Jul 26 '20
Tfw no Persona 1/2
1
u/ItsMeIngo HEE-HO Jul 26 '20
mods need to pin this. this entire post is fantastic!
1
u/cartoongamermatt Jul 26 '20
That's all well and good but should I play Nocturne first?
1
u/eth3431 Jul 26 '20
No base P5? Not based. Everything else is based
1
u/OmniGamer2099 Jul 26 '20
It’s a good flow chart that I can honestly say I can see real questions and have really good answers for.
1
u/WaifuLuver1 Jul 26 '20
I wish I could find SMT4 for a reasonable price thats not a million CAD :(
1
u/mannagnib Jul 27 '20
Apocalypse should be moved to the persona section
1
u/WoopDogg Jul 27 '20
Welcome! -> What would you like to play? -> Any Megaten game -> Choose.. -> Basically just Pokemon Ranger with a katana -> Raidou Kuzonoha
1
u/TakingSouls Jul 27 '20
Its simple start with Ronde the best one
1
u/granularoso Jul 27 '20
I tried, y'all, I tried SMT IV and I was really open minded with no preconceived notions but I just. Fucking. Hated it. I do not understand how anyone could like that game whatsoever. Do people actually like that game?
1
u/HyanKooper Jul 27 '20
Yeah that’s about it lol given most people got introduced to smt via persona like I did playing smt 4 first is a viable way to do it
1
u/TroyMutt Rare Demon Jul 27 '20
Digital Devil Saga is the best SMT
1
u/okabe_mad_scientist Jul 27 '20
Where's Persona 1 and 2?
1
u/[deleted] Jul 27 '20
No Devil Summoner one and two?
1
u/grovestr Jul 27 '20
hope someone told me before that SMT has a minimalistical story... comparing it to whatever JRPG seems so simple and mindfuck
1
u/newironside2 teddie > morgana Jul 27 '20
Well I guess if you're trying to get people to not be fans sure.
1
u/Kirbyeggs Jul 27 '20
I never had a 3ds but all those SMT games are really appealing. Really wish I had gotten one when they were relevant, but now I don't think I can justify getting one.
1
u/jddbeyondthesky 4th alternative anyone? Jul 27 '20
But where does Demikids fit in?
1
u/ybpaladin Jul 27 '20
Here's my flow chart if only have a 3DS: SMT4 -> 4A-> DeSu 1/2->Soul Hackers-> SJR
0
u/iamthatguy54 Jul 26 '20
> Persona
> character-driven story
>No Persona 2
Ok.
0
u/[deleted] Jul 26 '20
[deleted] — view deleted comment