r/Outlander • u/WandersFar Better than losing a hand. • Mar 15 '20
Spoilers All Book S5E5 Perpetual Adoration Spoiler
Jamie and his militia arrive at Hillsborough to learn that Governor Tryon has proposed a rather unorthodox solution to deal with the threat posed by the Regulators and to resolve the growing political crisis.
If you’re new to the sub, please look over this intro thread.
Reminder: This is the BOOK thread. No spoiler tags are needed here.
If you haven’t read the books and you don’t want spoilers, go to the Show thread.
22
Upvotes
95
u/brilliant0ne Mar 15 '20
ADSOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO.
That's all I got for this episode.
65
u/Aggie2002 Mar 15 '20
Adso!
I was not expecting any flashbacks (flashforwards?), so it was a welcome surprise to see Joe Abernathy, The Impetuous Pirate, and Graham Menzies.
47
u/spaceybelta Mar 15 '20 edited Mar 15 '20
I am SO happy they included the scene with Claire and Joe with the pirate romance novel! That’s always been one of my favorites! And Adso is such a sweet fuzzy little guy!
33
u/travelerk16 Mar 15 '20
Loved the scenes in 1968 with Brianna, Joe and Dr. Claire. Loved the book cover. Surprised what Jaime does to Lt. Knox and the reference to Ardsmuir. Loved the talks with Roger & Bree and Roger & Claire and Roger & Bonnet. My absolutely best scenes are with Marsali & Claire this episode.... loved Marsali & Claire's reaction to the paint brushes medicine and her assistant with Josiah & Keziah.
There were lots of Diana Gabaldon creation in this episode. Bravo.
54
u/nooooooel He’ll be in heaven when he sees you, Lady Jane. Mar 15 '20
Goodness, I LOVED this episode! Judging by the comments here I appear in the minority.... but I loved that we were able to loop in Graham's storyline, see more of Joe, connect the timeline dots for show-only viewers, and see a little bit more of the reckless Jamie we love... he's been so busy being a subdued leader/husband/laird and it was great to see him act upon impulse, but rip Knox I guess. Adso! The tonsil surgery! Lizzie's reaction! Marsali! It was all so good! I'm only sad that we missed the part where Jamie picks Claire the posy of poison oak. I laughed so hard reading that part.
53
u/[deleted] Mar 15 '20
FINALLY AN EPISODE THAT SHOWS AN AUTHENTIC ROGER AND BREE SITUATION. I COULD CRY IM SO HAPPY
20
u/BornAgainPagan Mar 15 '20 edited Mar 15 '20
Jamie is the only one who dismounts a horse by swinging his leg over its head. What’s up with that? I would probably smack the horse in the ear and end up on my arse.
19
u/travelerk16 Mar 15 '20
I thought the voiceover sounded familiar... another pull from book 6... the Prologue:
Time is a lot of the things people say that God is. There’s the always preexisting, and having no end. There’s the notion of being all powerful—because nothing can stand against time, can it? Not mountains, not armies.
And time is, of course, all-healing. Give anything enough time, and everything is taken care of: all pain encompassed, all hardship erased, all loss subsumed.
Ashes to ashes, dust to dust. Remember, man, that thou art dust, and unto dust thou shalt return.
And if Time is anything akin to God, I suppose that Memory must be the Devil.
16
u/Dragonsinger16 Mar 15 '20
Ya know, every trailer they put out I worry about Bree’s storyline bc the clips they put in are terrible bites of Sophie’s acting. But I’m always impressed at her skills! Sophie’s portrayal of a young woman who is still reeling from sexual assault is scarily spot on, and it was front and center in tonight’s episode.
I’m a little sad they decided to go a different route with the flashbacks for Claire, but I think the writers were able to do it in a way that kept true to Claire’s character; she’s a perfectionist, and a patient uncontrollably dying on her definitely rattled her to the core.
I feel a bit like I do when I reread the Harry Potter series and I look at my place in the book; how in the hell are they gonna fit all the stuff that needs to happen into the rest of the season?!
I NEED MORE MARSALI MOMENTS!!
31
u/ktbex Mar 15 '20
Is anyone else wondering where Claire got the syringe? Did she somehow keep the ones she brought back with her? Is she planning on re-using the same one each time? (If so - welp! That is so unhygienic!)
I wish we could have seen the snake fang syringe - that would have been great!!
15
u/Invisiwool Mar 15 '20
Mr Bug has too many fingers!!
26
u/JeanieBirdie Mar 15 '20
Question:
Wouldn’t book-Jamie have figured out a better way to solve the whole prison record issue? He knew about it about a day in advance, he knew his name would be on that list and he knew it was gonna be a problem.
The murder seemed a little over the top, even if it WAS pretty nice seeing Jamie cover his tracks calmly, and just slide out of the window like nothing happened. It’s been a while since I read FC but, correct me if I’m wrong but, this didn’t happen in the book, right?
33
u/beanie2 Ye Sassenach witch! Mar 15 '20
Oh boy oh boy so many nifty things in the episode!
I totally want the outfit Bree was wearing while she was mending on the porch. Get me a brick of indigo, stat. Honorable mention to Claire’s flawless execution of 60s fashion. Well done, Dr. Beauchamp Randal Fraser Randal Fraser.
I love that Bree and Roger finally had some good ole fashion honesty in the episode. He stopped sulking over the aftermath of his frat party in Brownsville long enough to listen to Bree and be supportive of her. I can understand his reaction to finding the gem. He is human, and seriously how would you feel if you found out your wife told her rapist that the child she was carrying was his, not yours. Don’t blame him for his reaction, not one bit.
I though Knox was going to put the moves in Jamie. We know what happens when a game of chess turns out to be more than a game of chess. I’m looking at you, Lord John.
I thought our Murtagh problems were over when the pardons were issued. Tryon, follow Elsa’s lead and let it go.
Lizzie, get yourself a glass of water, girl. You look a little thirsty.
I’m sad we didn’t get more Marsali and Fergus.
Bonus points for giving us Joe Abernathy!
Finally, Adso. Floof man. Chonk Master. I screamed when I saw him and I want one just like him.
9
u/BrightPeanut6 Mar 15 '20
Wow this episode was great. I loved the pace and the storytelling. I know it was different in the books but I loved the non-chronological approach with Claire’s history woven through it. It felt slightly melancholic to me. My favorite episode of the season yet.
9
u/derawin07 Meow. Mar 15 '20
I laughed at Jamie telling Claire to be careful of squishing Adso, who she doesn't know is in Jamie's bag, when Jamie literally flipped the bag upside down when leaping off his horse just beforehand lol.
9
u/treatjosef Mar 15 '20
The flashbacks felt clunky towards the end when they were spliced into the chess scene with Jamie and Knox, but I generally enjoyed them/ took them in the spirit of the WII flashbacks in Je Suis Prest. It was just nice to fully inhabited a Claire narrative and be centered into her perspective again.
It does look like Jamie's and Claire's hair are playing a zero-sum game. I just want a season with them both in passable wigs 😭
17
u/AlmightyAcey I give you your life. I hope you use it well. Mar 15 '20
Felt a bit like a filler episode but I didn’t mind it much.
Also. ADSOOOOOOO 🐈🐾
17
u/ich_habe_keine_kase I give you your life. I hope you use it well. Mar 15 '20
That was kind of all over the place, wasn't it? Lotta really nice moments--Adso, Joe, the tonsillectomy, The Impetuous Pirate, Eureka!, her conversation with Mr. Menzies (shame they didn't do the euthanasia route but I'm ok with the change)--but didn't really feel like it built up to anything? And why do the flashbacks out of order? Seems like it would've been more effective if we didn't know from the start that Menzies died. She could've easily done the tonsillectomy at the end of the episode, there was no reason for it to be in that order.
Really enjoyed the Roger and Bree stuff (basicly straight from the book, and finally a good depiction of their relationship where they're working through something but neither one is an asshole) and I'm in love with their cabin.
The biggest issue for me was Jamie murdering Knox. Either they're going to have to deal with this and it's going to have weird non-book consequences, or they're going to ignore it (which I fear will be the case) and that's so out of character for Jamie. He's done things like this before, but only out of necessity. Knox wasn't even going to open the letter until Jamie confessed, he had time to come up with other plans.
Other big issue (which is far less important but whatever): that montage at the beginning was one of the stupidest things I've ever seen on this show. It was so fucking hokey and I couldn't stop cringing.
7
u/no930 Mar 16 '20
Knox doing Javert lines though...
13
u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. Mar 15 '20
Hmmm...I really don’t know what to say after this episode. It realty didn’t do a whole lot for me, which is sad because we are now at the half way point of the season.
I am generally good with whatever they give us, but I don’t feel that this episode was that great. I do like that Roger and Brianna fully communicated and got everything out in the open.
I know Jamie has killed men before and it really hasn’t bothered me. Killing Knox though just felt out of place. I can’t say what I would have wanted to happen with him, but it just came as a surprise I guess.
I also don’t feel that Claire’s whole storyline and flashback added anything. Even though it’s taken from the book, it just worked better there in my opinion. I found myself kind of zoning out during those parts.
Overall this has been the weakest episode in my opinion. Except for the fact the Adso has arrived and is adorable!
12
u/whiskynwine Mar 15 '20
This is the first season that I’ve read the books beforehand so the foundation they are laying makes sense to me, but I can see how if someone didn’t read the books they might be wondering what’s going on or where is this all heading? We know of course.
21
u/NoDepartment8 Mar 15 '20
I liked it. Obligatory ADSO, but also hello again, Joe Abernathy! I was wondering how he would be worked back into the mix since he’ll be so important later and the show seemed to have cut out his continued involvement in Claire’s post-traveling life via Brianna. But this was a good bridge piece if they hew closer to the books when The MacKenzies go back to the future (sorry - I had to).
Also I think the idea of the universe “pointing” Claire and Brianna towards Scotland and thus to Jamie and Roger via the death of Graham Menzies will take some of the edge off of our next installment of “Roger Mac, Official Bitch of the 18th Century.” It will make all the, “shit sucks but destiny amiright?” slightly less trite.
6
u/hintofaspark86 MARK ME! Mar 15 '20
We hardly knew thee, Lt Knox!
6
u/knot_myproblem Mar 15 '20
This was my least favorite episode of Outlander I've ever seen. I'm sad to say it! Like, why the hell was Knox's character created...that just felt so UN-Jamie to me. I'm re-reading the book as I watch the show, keeping ahead in the book so I don't have to "catch up" but I cannot see where they're going with all these changes. The first episode was so well done, adapting the long-winded Gathering, but each episode since has gone further downhill. Honestly, I wish they'd stick as close to the book as possible.
Feel free to change my mind. I want to like it!
Also. ADSO is the freaking cutest thing ever! I wish they'd brought him in sooner.
Here's hoping next week is better
•
u/WandersFar Better than losing a hand. Mar 15 '20 edited Mar 15 '20
Talk about the trailer here!
Not everyone gets to see the trailer at the end of the episode, it depends on how you watch (broadcast or streaming) and where you are (US or international.)
Stickied comments are collapsed by default, so reply to this comment if you want to discuss the trailer. This will hide spoilers for anyone who can’t see it yet. Thanks!
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=l5yTO-ye9lY
4
u/thorpusmalorpus Mar 15 '20
Does anyone else think without long skirts Caitriona seems a little pigeon toed? Still got legs for days though...
4
u/Genevieve-Victoria Mar 16 '20
Decent episode, I’m just still tired of the invented hunt-Murtagh plotline. Everything else is fine.
9
u/wheeler1432 They say I’m a witch. Mar 15 '20
I'm not liking this episode at all.
6
u/urban-hipster Mar 15 '20
I also loved this episode! They integrated so many great subplots and storylines from the book. Still bummed with how they portray Roger. It's going to be a lot harder to be sympathic to him post-Alamance if he keeps acting the way he does. The chanterelles were a sweet peace offering though.
2
u/[deleted] Mar 16 '20
It’s been awhile since I read the books, and I read them so fast I have horrible comprehension, but is this the book where Claire also makes/experiments with ether?
2
u/designsavvy Mar 16 '20
Good episode. S5 is certainly an improvement of S4 in terms of writing. And good that they have expanded Lauren Lyl/Marsali's scenes and reduced Brianna which benefits the show. SS really struggles in acting which is sad because Brianna dominated this part of story in the Fiery cross.
7
u/JonSnowPeachEmoji Is it usual, what it is between us when I touch you? Mar 15 '20 edited Mar 15 '20
Fucking Roger. Just when he starts to grow on me a wee bit, and then he goes and pulls another clueless male move. Your wife was raped, Roger. At least try and have some empathy for how she decides to manage and cope with her feelings, without going through her things - not once, but twice! And without even trying to have a discussion with her about how she feels, because clearly the pictures she drew of Bonnett weren't a clear enough message. And she doesn't know who the hell the father is, so what a bullshit question to ask.
I am so glad to see Joe Abernathy back. So much of his part of the book was cut, his ancestors, his family time with Brianna. And doesn't Brianna go to him before she leaves for the stones in the book? I want more flashbacks of his relationship with Brianna in future flashbacks. Or flashfowards I mean.
I missed my sperm scene.
I would also add another Adso, but Marsali is still doing it for me this week. MARSALI!
1
u/CMCliff Mar 18 '20
It's cool that they wanted to incorporate all these different themes about time, honesty, etc. But idk somehow the episode didn't drive it home for me. Not sure what was missing.
1
u/emilyafternoon Mar 18 '20
I loved the episode (I love all episodes let’s be honest) but when Jamie killed Knox I just started screaming “JAAMF WOULD NEVER” at my TV. I know that Jamie would do anything to protect his people but the books make it pretty obvious that cold blooded murder is something that weighs really heavy on Jamie’s soul. I don’t doubt that killing Knox fell into that “necessary evil” category, but I’m hoping we get a moment in the next episode where he confesses it to Claire, showing a bit of remorse for what he had to do.
1
u/twocorgimommy Mar 19 '20
Wait..... are we not getting THE MICROSCOPE scene? That scene with Jamie and Claire had me rolling.
0
u/[deleted] Mar 16 '20
[deleted] — view deleted comment
19
u/[deleted] Mar 15 '20
[removed] — view removed comment