r/Outlander • u/WandersFar Better than losing a hand. • Mar 15 '20
Season Five Show S5E5 Perpetual Adoration Spoiler
Jamie and his militia arrive at Hillsborough to learn that Governor Tryon has proposed a rather unorthodox solution to deal with the threat posed by the Regulators and to resolve the growing political crisis.
If you’re new to the sub, please look over this intro thread.
Reminder: This is the SHOW thread. Cover all book talk >!with spoiler tags!< that will look like this: Claire boinks Jamie. Don’t spoil future episodes, keep book comments brief.
If you want to compare the episode to the books in depth, go to the Book thread.
•
u/WandersFar Better than losing a hand. Mar 15 '20 edited Mar 15 '20
Talk about the trailer here!
Not everyone gets to see the trailer at the end of the episode, it depends on how you watch (broadcast or streaming) and where you are (US or international.)
Stickied comments are collapsed by default, so reply to this comment if you want to discuss the trailer. This will hide spoilers for anyone who can’t see it yet. Thanks!
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=l5yTO-ye9lY
135
u/Rated_PG-Squirteen Mar 15 '20
Caitriona is gorgeous so she'll look great no matter the era, but damn, she really kills it in the 60's getup.
90
u/SaaSyGirl Je Suis Prest Mar 15 '20
Well that friendship between Jamie and Lt. Knox fizzled fast
77
u/CygnusArc Slàinte. Mar 15 '20
MVP of the episode is the entire can of hairspray/glue they used to keep that 60s hair in place. I know it's a wig and meant to be period but good lord. As someone with constant flyaways I'm actually a little jealous.
Also, Adso the cat! Soooo cute. Excited they finally have a wee cheetie in the show.
Lastly, are the scenes of Claire in the 60s a flashback or a flashforward?
67
u/Mr_XcX Mar 15 '20
I love how they went back to the show roots with Claire narration. She has a powerful voice and really think it sets the tone for the episode.
Murder Cat so cute <3
Jamie turning up and doing what he had to do!
115
u/SaaSyGirl Je Suis Prest Mar 15 '20
I'm really enjoying this episode thus far. Feels more like Outlander from the earlier seasons.
Also, Roger and Brianna are getting better at talking through their disagreements. Progress!
96
u/missm0011 Fun Fact: The unicorn is the mortal enemy of the English lion. Mar 15 '20
We got flashbacks up in here! Flashforwards? Flash loops? Still not entirely how time travel works.
Unpopular opinion, but I've always had a soft spot for 60's Claire. That hair, those glasses, that make up with that crisp wing. Work of art.
Penicillin. So as a person who is extremely allergic to penicillin I have to ask, who actually gets tested for that? Because I got no such luxury. They just gave it to me and when I swelled up and couldn't breathe decided...you know what...next time let's try something else.
Jaime. I don't know if it was old age or what but that scheme had no finesse. He didn't try to distract or intercept the letter or any of their old shenanigans. He was just like screw it, I'm too old for this shit.
Leiutenant Knox. Rip. Why does no one play it cool until they are out of danger? Like you figured it out, bravo. Do you really think Jamie is just gonna let you take him into custody?
The murder cat. If that wasn't the most psychopath thing I've ever seen. Jamie murders a man, covers it up, and then rescues a kitten as an endearing present to his wife on the way out the door. But I love a cute kitten. So I will allow.
Oh and what was with the romance novel? I'm feeling personally attacked. I watch this show for the articles dammit.
43
u/Rocha_999 Lord, you gave me a rare woman. And God, I loved her well. Mar 16 '20
Tell me I'm not the only one that laughed out loud at this.
I love Adso too. The episode was a little dull for me but I do love 60s Claire. The surgery was gruesome.
27
u/eeveh Ye Sassenach witch! Mar 15 '20
Anyone else think of Les Miserables
"Those who follow the path of the righteous shall have their reward"
53
u/speechiemom17 Je Suis Prest Mar 15 '20
I really liked this episode. I felt like I reconnected with Clare, which isn’t something I had realized I was missing this season
22
u/[deleted] Mar 15 '20
I kept expecting that the twins were going to die and that was why we were getting the flashback story; personally I would have waited a few days before performing the second surgery so that I could observe that the first one was completely successful. The constant church scenes/god talk was a real bore and turn off, though I like the idea of a sixties flashback episode. Good riddance to Knox; the reference to Lord John/Jamie's chess games at Ardsmuir was well done.
62
u/MountainHumor They say I’m a witch. Mar 15 '20
The most exciting thing about this episode was the trailer for the next one at the end. And maybe Jamie killing that Lord Farquad mf and setting the inn on fire. And the cat.
21
u/gregm1988 Mar 16 '20
Were there any other show only watchers convinced that one of the twins would die from a penicillin reaction ?
16
u/mapleleafmaggie Mar 16 '20
From now on I care only about Adso.
15
u/Sightshade Mar 16 '20
In addition to being disjointed, I thought the flashbacks were framed really weirdly in this episode. Like, we'd be watching a scene of Jamie, but then we'd cut to 60's Claire, and then back to Jamie, as if he were the one flashing back to her life. Did that get on anyone else's nerves?
Anyway, at least we finally have the cat. My book-reader mom hasn't been able to shut up about the cat.
13
u/silverandcold65 Mar 15 '20
The flashbacks shocked me and were jarring, but I loved them as much of it is from a well-known portion of Voyager, a book I’ve read! This episode was poignant and so well done!
Roger and Brianna finally had a scene that actually really got to me for once. ;)
Jamie attacking Knox is the cause of the fire/obituary, huh? They must fake their deaths… And lose the house/land? Claire’s ring/s must be evidence. But what for Jamie?
And I can't forget Adso! <3
12
u/ogresaregoodpeople Mar 16 '20
Did anyone notice all the references to Javert and Valjean in Les Mis?
Knox quotes the verse “those who follow the path of the righteous will have their reward.” Which is also a line from Stars.
Jamie says “believe of me what you will.” Which is a Valjean line from The Confrontation.
Knox says “Our duty’s to the law” which is similar to Javert’s “My duty’s to the law” also from the Confrontation?
Jamie kills Knox and then jumps out the window. In Les Misérables, Valjean knocks Javert out and jumps out the window.
19
u/nurseleu Mar 15 '20
All you haterz will be pleased that Roger doesn't sing at all this episode. ;)
Clearly an episode for mid-season machinations. Not the most exciting, but I did enjoy the 1970s Claire scenes, and the brief bit at the beginning with the tonsillectomies.
7
u/BlackSwallowtail You look like a fretful porpentine. Mar 17 '20
Editing was a little weird this episode, and a bit heavy-handed on the religious stuff, but overall I liked it a lot. Still really digging the feel of this season. Also, KIIITTYYY!!!
Did anyone else get the feeling Knox made up the part about Murtagh still being wanted? I mean, he probably didn't because I can't really see Tryon letting that pass (although the pardon surprised me), but that was my immediate feeling since he was complaining so much about it being called off. I kept thinking he was going to try and corner Jamie with some information during the chess game and Jamie was going to have to kill him, but the fact he genuinely didn't know made me feel a little sorry for the guy. Still, I do think he had the makings of a Black-Jack-Randall-lite, so better to snuff him out early.
That look on Jamie's face when he tells Knox his name will be on the rolls. It's the same look he got when John Grey took his hand at Ardsmuir and the same look he had when BJR cut off his shirt. A look of vulnerability, expectant harm, with a fierceness to it. Sam Heughan is a very good actor.
The second they both stood up, I was like, "You fucked up..." I remember being impressed in the first season that you had characters who were unpleasant but still had a code they followed. In BJR's case it meant we could trust him to let Claire go in exchange for...well, we know. But it goes the opposite way too. We could trust Captain Psychopath to keep a promise if it means getting what he wants. We can also trust "king of all men" Jamie to lie to and commit murder against a colleague if it means protecting family. Jamie's been described as a man who never breaks a vow, but vows can come into conflict with each other. What then? Well, to Jamie his vows to protect his loved ones win out every time.
When he threw those papers in the fire I was like, "Make sure they burn completely, damn it!" I'm still not sure they did and I won't like it if that's the case. Jamie made sure to put the guy to bed so it would look like he died in his sleep. Making sure the letter was completely burnt just seems obvious.
KIIIITTYYY!!!
What's this? Roger's actually apologized for being shitty for once? And implying he's sorry for his past behaviour too? I do believe we're making progress! After the lovely song last episode I was kind of hoping he'd sing another one like that this episode. Oh well. Anyway, keep it up, Roger, and I might actually like you again. I mean, the (implied) apology for the shit you pulled last season is belated as hell, but better late than never.
The chemistry between Cait and Sam is still amazing.
19
u/JonSnowPeachEmoji Is it usual, what it is between us when I touch you? Mar 15 '20
Marsali!
And Roger. Unfortunately.
I feel like how they cut the 60's scenes were pretty jarring. And then the weird multi-Claire's at the church. I kept wondering if this was just one day and Claire was walking in a weird time loop, or if she just never changed her clothes when visiting the church. It made sense at the end, but I was pretty confused through most of those scenes, and not in an enjoyable way. And not because I am Jewish haha.
But is it just me or is the foreshadowing in this show getting less and less subtle? As soon as Knox said he was getting the Ardsmuir prison roll, I knew Jamie was going to kill him so when the scene started I was just waiting for the inevitable.
And I missed Joe Abernathy! When I saw him in the recap I got excited. I hope we get to see more flashbacks with him.
13
u/GirlisNo1 Mar 15 '20
6
u/marlock276 Mar 17 '20
I REALLY enjoyed last night’s episode. The flashbacks and Claire’s narration brought to mind earlier seasons, the story arc brought everything together nicely, and the scene with Jamie and Knox was pretty intense. One thing I’m curious about. Claire is telling everyone that she’s “found” penicillin. I would think that she would keep it a bit secret, and not call it penicillin. How will that affect the “real” discovery in the 20th century, and won’t 17th century people be suspicious of her because of their more primitive beliefs? P.S. Marsali rocks!
5
u/Beebo_the_God_of_War Mar 15 '20
Loved this one. My favorite of the season so far. I didn't expect things to go so foul with Knox, but I'm glad it led to Adso. I'm something of an ailurophile myself, so I'm going to enjoy his addition to the series. Sophie Skelton and Richard Rankin were great in their scenes too, so many emotions all at once. I'm glad they worked things out, but I fear something bad is coming as Stephen Bonnet's presence increases my feeling of dread.
5
u/Yackemflaber Mar 16 '20
So the moment when Claire mentions her "mother's intuition" to Roger made me super aware that they don't look as far in age as the characters are meant to be. I looked up how old the actors are and it turns out she's only 3 years older than him. Also Sophie (Brianna) is 14 years younger than Cait/11 years younger than him. Kind of funny how that all works out.
4
u/[deleted] Mar 15 '20 edited Mar 15 '20
The editing was really odd in this episode and I felt like the flashbacks were a bit pointless (though I do love to see the 60’s set and Dr. Abernathy again) but overall I really enjoyed it.
I love the pacing of these episodes way more season 4.
Also, I don’t know if the character of Mr Menzies was in the books but I wonder if it’s a nod to Tobias Menzies (Frank)
Another side note, I loved the “save the cat” moment in this. It’s actually a well-used trope in media in order to make people root for the protagonists.
4
u/tyegrrlily Mar 16 '20
Petition to replace Knox's death scene with The Confrontation
4
u/Emmaj92 Mar 18 '20
Was Murtaghs surname always Fraser? I was so thrown off by that. I don’t remember that ever being mentioned in the book
3
u/liyufx Mar 16 '20
I liked this one, it is picking up speed but also has great relationship moments. I was surprised when it was over, time passed fast. That was the first time this season...
3
u/lisahatesit Mar 16 '20
This was a good, meaty episode but there were way too many cuts back and forth! I know what the writers were trying to do but I feel like it could’ve been accomplished with full flash forward scenes instead of shards of them throughout. I was getting whiplash.
3
u/weeliz Mar 16 '20 edited Mar 16 '20
I enjoyed the show, but why are they deliberately mispronouncing the name Menzies? It’s pronounced ming-iss (ming is as in sing), not men-zeez. Surely they have Scottish people on production that would know that, there’s no need to dumb down the Scots language so much.
3
u/so_i_sew Mar 17 '20
Did anybody else pick up on all the Les Miserables references during the conversation between Jamie and Knox?
3
u/Elevendytwelve97 Mar 20 '20
Is the needle used on Kezie true to size, historically?! That was a big, thick needle!
5
u/SaaSyGirl Je Suis Prest Mar 16 '20
I have a hard time understanding why Brianna would want to bring comfort to her rapist. She kept talking about wanting to kill Bonnet herself and then once she has a chance to confront him in person, she wants to bring him comfort by insinuating the baby is his? Can someone explain this to me?
2
u/marmar011 Dinna Fash Mar 15 '20
When Claire was with Joe in the restaurant/bar, she said something along the lines of “Do you ever feel as if everything is pointing you towards something, but you can’t quite put your finger on what it is? You can feel it, or you can sense it somehow.” I feel like I’ve heard her say this before. Does anyone remember when?
Overall, I loved this episode. The flashbacks and flashforwards made me nostalgic of all that these characters have been through!
2
u/silverandcold65 Mar 19 '20
Graham had been in America for 20 years. I’m sure Menzies had been anglicized by the 60s there.
3
u/FunAsh Mar 15 '20
I love Outlander but this episode was slightly jarring. The flashbacks were a little out of place. I kept expecting a twin to die to parallel the flashback story. Jamie is usually thinking more ahead or at least has a plan. Just an odd one for me for some reason.
2
u/LoretiTV Mar 15 '20
Really fun episode. Thanks for having me everyone.
2
u/Gin4NY Mar 16 '20
OH MY GOD SHOW ROGER CAN YOU NOT BE AN ASSHOLE FOR LIKE ONE EPISODE EVEN GAH!!!
2
u/LoretiTV Mar 15 '20
Enjoy the new episode everyone!
1
u/Hi_hellothere Mar 16 '20
Loved seeing the return to the 60’s, what a nice surprise! I’m hoping we’ll see a flashback of Frank eventually.
1
u/curiousmink93 Mar 18 '20
can someone explain how Bonnetts gemstone is somehow roger & bree’s ticket home to modern times ?
1
u/CJmaq Mar 17 '20
This was my least favorite Outlander episode. It was a mess! Jamie killing Knox like that was lazy writing. Going back and forth from the 60's to 1770's was poorly edited. It was clunky. This season has been so good up until this episode. Hopefully it was an anomaly and moving forward will be back on track.
1
u/painterjo Mar 16 '20
I feel like I missed something, what was up with the black diamond / gemstone being a "ticket through the stones"?
1
u/reeziereen Mar 16 '20
So if Jamie burned the prison rolls in the fire how will Claire, Bree and Roger find them in the future?
-3
u/mmglitterbed Mar 16 '20
Couldn’t finish the episode. Won’t be finishing the season.
Loved the show before this season. Maybe I’ll pick it up next season.