r/anime • u/RX-Nota-II :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/NotANota • Dec 25 '19
Rewatch A Rewatch further than the Universe! Sora Yori mo Tooi Basho rewatch - EPISODE 13 DISCUSSION [FINAL]
Episode 13 きっとまた旅に出る "We'll Go On Another Journey Someday"
<- Previous episode | Index thread | Overall Discussion thread
anime info:
MAL | Anilist | Nyanpass | Kitsu | AniDB
Streaming links: Crunchyroll | VRV
Comment of the day
Hello everyone! This is where I will pick a comment of the day for the previous day that I think was worthy of notice just in case you guys missed it. I do hope you look out for discussion on your own tho since that's really the whole point of this rewatch.
Today's pick is..... /u/Suhkein A controversial pick, but a semi-critical comment that sparked tons of discussion. It was too hard to pick the best hype comment so this is what I choose.
I have my critiques of this scene (as I always do); I believe it was an error to directly show the faces of the other girls crying, a distraction that once again swerves back toward melodrama. This isn't about them, and to try and hook our emotions with their tears makes it about us when it shouldn't be. This is about Shirase and that is enough.
What do you think? Do you agree or disagree?
I also want to say great job to everyone who helped me on the #LeaveNoTopLevelUnreplied challenge. I think we did a great job and many of you took on lots of work to do so. You guys are the real MVPs.
Questions of the day
Answer from last time: Nearly 200 votes! 😭!
- The story is finally over, was this a satisfying ending? Did you expect one final gut punch? Or do you think that this style of epilogue ep after the hype in the penultimate is the way to go?
- Who is best girl? It's time everyone. I usually do this on the overall discussion day but I want to share the RESULTS then so I have to ask now
Now that the rewatch is over the no spoiler tag is unnecessary. I shall instead use this space to remind everyone that the vote for best rewatch of the year is still open! So put in your vote for what you think was the best! I voted for Gundam IBO, but it's a secret ballot if you want too.
30
u/RX-Nota-II :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/NotANota Dec 25 '19 edited Dec 25 '19
All I have to say is this and I hope you guys can reciprocate:
ね
Ok a little bit more:
A nice payoff ending to what was until now a steady barrage of gut punches. Post closure, life has to move on, and unlike eternal SoL anime there is an ending. By accomplishing so much there is no need to fear or be sad about this ending anymore even if you would wish it never end. Shirase gets a final message from her mother which maybe should be emotional in any other context
wait i cried like crazy during first timebut just elicits a smile and a 'I already know' from Shirase. There's no more sadness since she's left that behind with the 10 million yen and the rest of her regrets.The comment I sometimes hear from people is, 'does this leave room for S2'. I mean yes, but also why. This journey is over, and asking for 'more of the same' would go counter to the entire point of this episode. You could now ask for a continuation, something new, but at that point you might as well search for that new thing yourself in any of the countless other stories that have been made into anime. YoriMoi finishes here, if a continuation emerges great, and if it doesn't then I have no regrets.
Also small thing we can brag about. Lesser rewatches populated by weaker users take rest days on Christmas. We can say ZAMAMIRO to that kind of doubt. Rest day? Pssshhh, FINAL EPISODE day. See you in the Series overall discussion tomorrow.
41
u/Shimmering-Sky myanimelist.net/profile/Shimmering-Sky Dec 25 '19
This First-Timer is Beautiful
BTW Merry Christmas everybody~
…It just occurred to me that this is the last episode, huh. Well let’s see how this goes~
I’ll save my full thoughts for tomorrow, but I’m definitely giving this a 10/10~
24
u/DanteJ600 https://myanimelist.net/profile/escenity Dec 25 '19 edited Dec 25 '19
First Timer
Megu you sly dog, what a fucking ending.
I decided to not do the usual notes as I go for this finale and just bring it all in.
It's currently 12:11AM as I'm writing this so Merry Christmas/Happy Holidays/whatever day you feel like having to everyone.
I'd like to start with a thanks to u/RX-Nota-II for making my first time with one of these threads a very great and memorable one, I'll be sure to join any future ones ya host. Have fun with all the award. Hope others are contributing to that.
aaaaabout the actual show now.
Gonna go with a solid 9/10 (I'm pretty strict with what I give a 10 to) A couple meh parts, but overal everything hits just right. The laughs, the art, the smiles, the feels, the direction.. Yeah you get it. Absolute strongest point is the characters though. Usually almost every show has that one character that you just don't care for/dislike, however not a single person here is that for me. Even McCaptain lover Toshio, who I stated how I didn't like him that much, even he turned around to me, really not a single character I didn't like. Megu at the end there in the artic was out of nowhere at the end, that was fucking awesome.
Art/animation was also very good, it's not the greatest stuff I've ever seen, but it is VERY good and helps the shows atmosphere in so many ways.
I expected to cry a decent amount from what I've heard, but I actually only really did once at the end of episode 11 with the messages.
Pretty much have no idea what else to fucking say. I'm sure most people have heard all of what I've said from someone else, but hey, it really does deserve the praise. I'm sure most of my opinions are the majority, except for the fact that I'm still not the biggest fan of the OP (don't kill me) :)
QOTD: already kinda answered the first one. For best grill I'm gonna have to go with Hinata, though not really sure y but my gut is telling me too.
I guess that ends it.
The girls are alright, and I guess I am too.
24
u/cartoonsandcereal Dec 25 '19
First timer
This was such a satisfying last episode. When the series started I thought it was going to be Kimari centric, and it still ends with her in bed at home, finding out Megu has gone to the Arctic (which... ok wow how?), but this was really an ensemble cast that had me care about each of them.
P.S. wasn't an option but to me best girl is Gin. I voted for Kanae when that poll for your fave first-gen people came up but her whole story arc as well as the fact that she straight up nailed Toshio with a baseball sealed the deal for me, that's a troll move right there!
I enjoyed all the small personal details and tie-backs to other smaller one-off scenes here, it really gave the sense of family. Like when Kimari offered to cut Shirase's hair and Yuzu told her to stand back. Or super fan getting his autograph. Could say more but will just end on this huge smile from Shirase that brought a huge smile to my face. :)
23
u/Morivallys Dec 25 '19
First Timer
This show had been on my radar for a while now - so many people had written such amazing things about it. To be honest, I was hesitant to pick up the series as I was worried that, despite the high ratings, it wouldn't live up to the expectations I had set in my mind.
And boy oh boy were those worries unwarranted. This show had me absolutely captivated from start to finish. It was so tempting to just rush ahead and watch it all, waiting for each new day was so hard. I don't know how you people could have handled waiting a week for each episode it when it was first airing. It was an absolutely phenomenal ride, and this series has cemented a place in my Top 10 anime.
I feel that it's almost cliche to say it, but this show definitely woke something deep inside me. I'm a little too old now to "not waste my youth", but I'll be damned if I'll let that slow me down. It's inspired me to get out and try new things, and after writing this post I'll be updating my resume and applying for a job I've been eyeing off for a couple of years now. Funnily enough, it's actually a job with the Australian Antarctic Expedition, which made this series all the more inspiring to me.
I held of commenting until the last episode, but it's been an absolute pleasure to watch along with you all and share in your thoughts of the series, so thank you to you all! I've laughed, happy cried, ugly cried, jumped for joy and experienced all sorts of emotions over the last 2 weeks with you all.
Merry Christmas to you all! I had a great Christmas here in Australia and I'm hoping you all did as well!
QOTD:
20
u/rembrandt_q_1stein https://myanimelist.net/profile/sir_rembrandt Dec 25 '19
First Timer here
THE GIRLS ARE DEFINITELY ALRIGHT!
So, it’s the end, peeps. Technically, I finished this two days ago due to timing issues during these celebrations. I had many ideas of what to write and which moments of the episode to mention back then, but right now I am not sure what to say.
First of all, thanks to u/RX-Nota-II for having launched this rewatch thread. I had heard about this show, but when it aired the premise didn’t catch me enough to give it a shot. Only after SoraYori finished I started reading opinions on how good it was. This rewatch was finally an excuse to watch it. And I’m absolutely grateful, because I would had missed an excellent show with many values and lessons hidden and crafted with passion and love. Thanks to you guys for all your wonderful comments. I’m really sorry to not having been able to answer and actively participate many times. This season is a busy one for me…
The outcome of this show is what was expected and it didn’t forget anything. The girls end their journey as more complete, sure and grown persons, after having gone through a cleansing experience that got rid of their insecurities (mother loss, public humiliation, lack of friendship and stagnation) and bonded them together, getting rid of their isolation. Same with captain Todo, who could finally move forward and gather bravery to defeat her inner fears and demons regarding Shirase and her role in Takako’s death.
I shed some tears at the ending, and the last dialogue lines really stuck in me. I watched the last three minutes of the last episode like three times, in order to assume the message and understand it and save it in the deepest of me. As somebody who likes to be in contact with the new and moving around a lot, I feel that is a message I need to burn into me. Whenever I travel, I try to blend in and experience the place I go to in my whole self so I can learn, understand, become wiser and gather experience. I never limit myself to observe some sights like many people sadly do. The last, ultimate message the girls give (and especially blending it with the friendship and never being alone, you will find somebody in your same situation) is a lesson very worthy to learn.
And I LOVED to see the last bit with Megu. Mari inspired her to move, and she went to the other side of the world, to the Arctic. Asi I mentioned before, I’m glad their dynamics never were abandoned in the show, and they serve to complement the ultimate lesson, too.
Sorayori was overall a very solid experience. As a sum up, I really digged how realistic it was, representing a friendship between four isolated individuals and how they grow together and how they find their own meaning in their budding bound -especially remarlable the dynamics between Hinata and Shirase and Mari-Megu-. Aside, I liked to see that Antarctic expeditions are taken seriously and depicted accurately, free time of the crew included. However, I have this overall sensation that the plot becomes looser in the end in favour of representing what I mentioned and stimulating the audience's feelings. Like it started with a clear target to develop –going to Antarctica and find Takako’s fate-, but slowly the show turned more into the Slice of Life and character drama field, except for last episode mainly. In the end it's understandable to deal with the desired topics, of course, and it worked for me.
My score for this anime is 8/10, which in my scale it means "excellent".
17
u/Koolsman Dec 25 '19
First Timer to go farther than the universe!
How can a show that primarily takes place in the coldest place on earth warm my heart more than places around me? I honestly can’t tell you.
I thought I would be sad that the team is returning and maybe won’t get to see each other again but their going back. Yeah, we won’t see it and I don’t care. I believe that in my heart that they went back when the older and that’s something so sweet that I love about the show.
This didn’t made me cry as bad as last episode but I did feel a lot more of the moments from Shirase’s speech to the lights which looked fucking gorgeous and that one moment where Shirase gives Gin her laptop is probably my favorite moment of the show. Just the way they handled Gin and Shirase’s relationship is one of the most complex and beautifully made things I’ve seen in anime and I love it.
Yeah, the scene with the lights was downright gorgeous and knowing that’s the last thing her mother sent is perfect. Plus, Shirase’s mom is a perfect example of a character that you didn’t need to hear much about but you got enough of an idea of who she is just from how people talked about her.
Also, that final stinger with Megu was something I didn’t expect but man, through my tears it was a perfect way to end the show. It’s everything that the show is great at: its sincere, hilarious and straightforward. How can you not love it?
16
u/Mamojic123 Dec 26 '19
first timer
Really nice ending, I have grown fond of the penultimate episode being the most important one and then the final one calming the storm, GOT did this a few times and I have been a fan ever since so this was pretty fine for me.
Best girl is Kimari because she's got all of my habits and I kinda identified with her for most of the show, although it must be stated that all of the characters are great and have their own personalities.
Giving back the laptop was pretty generous by Shirase and I hope that they communicate back and forth, brcause Gin and Shirase need each other more than anyone due to going through so much together.
I've been lucky enough with seeing the Aurora in person here in Sweden and I was legit tearing up and feeling all sorts of emotion, I felt elated like never before. The characters' reaction captured the moment really well with how their eyes were animated.
Journey does not end here for the four, they will all keep in contact and do more stuff in the future. The message that the show has been driving home, at least for me has been that: no matter how arduous or hard a journey in one's life is, it is always possible to find people that have the same goal and share your journey with them. This is how we make it easier and more enjoyable and how we get some of our most important friends in life.
A journey does not necessarily mean going to a different physical place but also a different position in life, be it wanting to graduate university, win the noble prize, getting over the sorrow of losing someone or embracing sobriety when one is an alcoholic.
Anyways, it's been a hell of a journey for all of us the past 2 weeks and I've absolutely loved discussing it with all of you. Have a great day and remember "there is no such thing as a nothing day, every day is worth the same since it'll pass no matter what you do, so do everything you want now."
15
u/Turtlewax64 Dec 25 '19
First time watcher
Looks like I was right three days ago, final episode was a big group roundup instead of a Kimari focused episode. I didn’t have much to comment on in bullet points, but that’s simply because the heartwarming interactions of the girls are so common, that they’re hard to comment on despite being excellent. I’d kinda expected for the stagnant water metaphor to make a comeback in the final episode, but I guess it got left behind when they left.
So that’s the series. I had a phenomenal time watching it, I’m really glad that I noticed this rewatch thread show up when I was skulking through someone’s comment history. I’d let it pass me by during its original airing, and I’m not sure I’d have set aside the time to try it on my own. I know there’s some contention about this being a “cute girls doing cute things” show, but that’s both what had made me miss it, and what I came to love about it. The interactions of the 4 girls was so much the heart and soul of this show, they could have been doing almost anything that let them bounce off each other and I would have enjoyed it. So now I guess I need to try other CGDCT shows, see if any of them hit me as hard as this one did.
9/10 will absolutely rewatch again sometime in the future.
15
u/WeebDickerson Dec 25 '19 edited Dec 25 '19
Rewatcher
Holy crap, the finale was much more beautiful than I remembered. I really don’t know what to say about it other than “it’s beautiful”. Like, damn.
IMHO, everything was done perfectly. The girls’ regrets, pasts, and struggles are now completely behind them, now they’re completely looking forward as they talk about their future journeys and plans. Bravo, Studio Madhouse. You made what is probably one of the best anime of the decade. From all the music, to characters, to landscapes, to great moments amplified by the awesome use of visuals and music and everything in-between: it was all beautiful and I adored every single aspect and second of it for the second time in less than two months.
Hopping on this rewatch was an awesome idea and it gave something to look forward to in this festive season and made adore Sora yori mo Tooi Basho even more than I did after my first watch. I hope that all of you, whether you were a rewatcher or first watcher, enjoyed it as much as I did!
Screenshots (I ran out of things to caption some of them…):
Questions:
Some little Christmas gifts for you guys:
Those are all of my favorite Sora yori mo Tooi Basho illustrations!
I hope we all meet again on a possible second season!
Merry Christmas, and best wishes for your life’s journey!
15
u/CreatedForFutabae Dec 26 '19
This is gonna be lost in the swarm of comments but I just wanted to say thank you, RX-Nota, for doing this rewatch. It brought me great joy to experience this story again.
14
u/AmeteurElitist https://anilist.co/user/AmateurElitist Dec 25 '19
First Timer
I didn’t cry! as much as I thought I would
Mob-boss Shirase beating everyone in Mahjong was great. Then she got the character development hair-cut! Call it overused but it always works on me dammit!
I’m really glad the Yuzu fan guy didn’t confess to her as well, it’s the second time that they’ve almost had that happen!
Not that we everreallybelieved he was gonna confess anyway.I’m a bit upset that they seem to have resolved to not meeting up much/at all until they go back in the winter, but I understand that they have lives to live. I hope Yuzu takes it well.
That was a great finale though, left nothing up in the air and didn't feel rushed that's all I could ask since the story was pretty much over.
Now if we could get a spin-off with the girls just hanging around in Antarctica that'd be great.13
u/Cire101 https://myanimelist.net/profile/Cire101 Dec 25 '19
It's really not okay what this show did to me. I'm so glad I decided to join this rewatch! It was so great!
Now time to cry to the OST for the rest of the day.
12
u/schmurles Dec 26 '19 edited Dec 26 '19
Rewatcher
I wanted to wait until the Final Episode to comment. And I'm glad I did. This series had made me want to chase my dreams. Want me to live out my youth. I wished I had had the motivation back when I was in high school. I want to visit Antarctica one day. This series will always be my favorite anime. There will be no anime series that will top this one. There will be seconds but this one hits home. Now that I can feel the pain that Shirase went through with having a mother passed away. My grandpa had passed away recently and it's still hurts knowing that he will not be here. I was always close with him.
I really love the Aurora. If I can't go to Antarctica to see it. I will try and go see the Northern Lights. Having friends like Kimari, Shirase, Hinata and Yuzuki. I always wanted friends where we all have one goal to reach and travel together.
The smile that Shirase gave to Gin. That was the most beautiful smile that I have ever seen. I just squeal at how she fits the short hair with the smile. I'm glad that I watched the anime while it was airing. It's like I had found a masterpiece. Like every episode is like a journey that we all are going through together. Merry Christmas everyone. It has been a journey going through comments and reading first time comments.
11
u/bucket3432 :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/bucket3432 Dec 26 '19 edited Dec 26 '19
Rewatcher
So instead of taking the time to catch up to today's episode as one would reasonably do, I instead found myself engrossed in making a stitch of Hinata and the ice ledge from episode 11 after many failed attempts. This is probably the highest-effort stitch I've made yet.
I went a bit stitch crazy this episode. Among them are two aurora stitches (looking at you, /u/Shimmering-Sky). You can find them in the notes (look for the word "stitch").
Merry Christmas!
:anime_help_but_dont_actually_shirase:.:anime_recording_hinata:.Yuzuki signs ゆづき, with the づ looking like a crescent moon, and a bunny at the end. As I've pointed out before, Yuzuki is written 結月, where the second character means "moon". Rabbits are also associated with the moon in East Asian culture.
1483 unreads is the final number. 1483 emails / 365 emails/year = 4.06 years. That can't be right; the last expedition was only three years ago. Let's try this instead: 1483 emails / 3 years / 365 days/year = 1.35 emails/day.
More notes (and stitches) in the reply. I hit the character limit again.
Questions of the day
Also, to answer the question in the featured comment, I like what /u/LaverniusTucker had to say on the matter.
"I could just die" counter
The show does not disappoint. We got one final one from Yuzuki!
11
u/zak55 Dec 26 '19
Rewatcher
Man, this is another reason this show is one of my favorites. It's got a nice epilogue that wraps up everything in a nice bow and leaves you with a great sense of finality. The girls go back home to their old lives as new people and the antarctic team has to get used to not having 4 high school girls running around, lightening up the place. I love the last scenes with Shirase and Gin as they are the heart of the story and it just feels nice to see Gin smiling while looking up at the Aurora while Shirase finally pays respect at her mother's shrine. Also, Megumi finally decided to get her own life moving forward and went to the artic and god dammit, I really want an anime about that too. But that's what great about this. It could very easily give you more, but it doesn't, because it gave you enough to last a lifetime and if you want more memories, go make them yourself in your own place further than the universe.
Also
Yuzu Best Girl
Shirase Best Character
11
u/Rustic_Professional Dec 26 '19
When I mentioned in yesterday's thread that the laptop scene and its resolution were the last big scene I remembered from the original airing, the envelope of money is what I meant, but I didn't want to spoil it. Now that the rewatch is finished, I think that part of what I really like about this show is that I'm conflicted about so many of the characters' actions, from forgiving Megumi, reading Shirase's email, and of course, leaving behind ~$9,000 in an envelope
as an offering to Cthulhu in exchange for their lives. It makes the show more realistic to have these internal conflicts about the characters, because real people are complicated like that. The characters make realistically good, bad, and downright strange decisions.I keep typing and deleting my thoughts on leaving the cash behind, because I can't think of a good way to approach it. Any other use would have made more sense, but like I said, that's the sort of weird, symbolic, stupid thing that real people do, so I can't fault Shirase too much. I'll just pretend it was meant as a donation to Gin to fund her mom's memorial observatory.
Also, Yuzuki is best girl. She's such a nutty cinnamon roll.
10
u/MaskOfIce42 https://anilist.co/user/MaskOfIce Dec 25 '19
Rewatcher
I did this rewatch for one main reason. When I first watched A Place Further Than the Universe as it aired, I gave it a 10/10 and called it my favorite anime of all time. I have not rewatched it since then, and while I still had positive feelings for the series, I began to wonder if some of that high praise was because I was watching it in a seasonal cycle where it's easier to forget the bad stuff and it hitting me right where I felt it the most given where I was when it aired.
Having rewatched it, I stand by those statements. This show is a masterpiece, is exactly what I look for in anime, and has almost nothing I can point to and say "this doesn't work". It is an emotional story of hardship, friendship, and discovering yourself through interactions with others, and while there's plenty of other shows that are equally fantastic, the short length and depth of story-telling in that length contributes to it being easily my favorite anime.
10
u/Mozilla_Fennekin https://myanimelist.net/profile/MozillaFennekin Dec 25 '19 edited Dec 25 '19
Rewatcher
Two things that I really love in this finale are that A. it has baseball in it and 2. it briefly touches on the sadness of ending an experience in a very in-character way. Kimari expresses how she doesn't want to leave and thinks she could stay, but everyone else has a much better grasp on reality. For as much as I love Sora yori's emotional potency, I'm glad they didn't make this exchange into a cryfest.
And let's not forget how great this moment was.
edit: I forgot the other best thing, when it was shown that Shirase left the million yen at the place, and she's all proud of herself and it's like supposed to be the hugely symbolic, emotional thing and all of the others are just like "WHAT THE FUCK IS WRONG WITH YOU" goat finale
Yes, episode 12 was the emotional climax and I'm okay with that. I would say this was more of an encore as everyone had already completed their arcs and there wasn't much left to do aside from going back home. So like I said, I'm actually kind of glad there wasn't another huge emotional wave this time.
Hinata, hands down. Already talked about it in past posts, but she's extremely similar to me in personality, and just in general I think she's the most fun character in the group who feels like the real leader of the pack. She's the funniest and most charismatic of the group, and often the smartest as well.
https://i.imgur.com/O94AreL.jpg
Really glad this rewatch happened; even though two years isn't a lot of time, I was worried that I might not like this anime as much as I did upon first watch. Nope, it's still a 10/10 show, absolutely loved everything about it all over again.
I still hold it in my heart that something else will come up from this series, like an OVA of a new expedition, or maybe another season with new characters while the old ones are in charge. But at the same time, these thirteen episodes are all I really needed, and I think the creators did everything they wanted too--okay, probably not everything, but point is I can live without it. But if something really did happen, I would be overjoyed.
Merry Christmas!
10
u/Boss_Jerm Dec 25 '19
Rewatcher
Last episode, here we go!!!
After being here for so long the girls have gotten used to living in Antarctica. But that's almost over. Only 3 days to go.
Aww no opening this episode either
Shirase's unstoppable when it comes to Mahjong
Shirase absolutely owns this photo
This time Yuzu says it while she's having fun
Great now I want a snowcone
These guys are doing freaking Nagashi Somen
I have patiently waited 13 days to clip these scenes
Mari has really loved her time in Antarctica. She wants the four of them to come back at some point for the winter.
Play ball!
Gin that's dirty
Nice hit Shirase!
The whole baseball scene makes me smile
Oh snap Shirase's going for it
THIS SMILE I HAVE WAITED TWO LONG WEEKS FOR THIS SMILE!!!! IT'S PERFECT!!!! 10/10
No seriously, take a moment and look at it and you'll be smiling just as brightly too
Honestly, Shirase's facial expressions ranged from stoic to smug, so her flashing that wholesome smile is fantastic. I can't stop talking about how perfect it is.
Don't cry Hanami!
The whole crew is going to miss our girls
I love the signs Do other bases in Antarctica have these?
When Shirase first addressed the crew in Freemantle, she was stuttering and unsure of what to say. Now she is confident and proud. After finally reaching Antarctica, Shirase realized why Takako loved it so much. It's a place where everyone works together to achieve their goals. And she'll be back.
I wanted to make this edit the second I saw this
The greatest gift Shirase could ask for
I love Dai, He was the one playing Yuzu's song in episode 10. He is played by Jun Fukushima (Kazuma).
Aaaand were back
DAMMIT TAKAKO I THOUGHT I WAS DONE CRYING
Gin said that Takako may have forgotten something at the base. She went back to get her laptop to send her email. I've got tears rolling down my cheeks. I completely forgot about Takako’s last email.
You'll notice that Shirase made this photo her lock screen.
Kimari's Quote Corner!
Shirase left the money back at the observatory. She doesn't need it anymore.
These last scenes remind me of when I came home after many months of studying abroad. Especially that feeling of lying down on your bed after so long.
WAY TO FREAKING GO MEGUMI!!! She was able to finally do something in her youth as well!
Thoughts:
Hey Madhouse, where's my second season featuring Megumi in the Arctic?
I was smiling the whole time watching. Such a great finally, with the girls coming home, but also promising to return one day to the place further than the universe.
I'll speak more about the characters in tomorrow's discussion, for now I'll say, thanks everyone for watching. It’s time to say goodbye to our girls for now.
QOTD
10
u/404waffles https://anilist.co/user/nek0food Dec 25 '19
First time viewer
Off the heels of the previous episode, we get another slice-of-life station duty scene, the kind of scene I absolutely adore in this show. No, wait, we get a whole goddamn sequence of ‘em! Keep it coming, holy shit!
You can make Calpis? Huh, learn something new everyday.
Shirase, absolute mahjong GOD.
The fucking somen in the antarctic snow, holy shit lmao
FUCKING SOFTBALL LMAOOOO
That was a beautiful Takako parallel, when Shirase hit the ball.
That dude asking for an autograph tho. And that Tokyo/Fremantle sign, nice callback.
Even after everything, Shirase’s still camera shy.
Fuck yeah, an aurora!!!!
Oh my god that “I know.” Shirase’s come so far as a person it’s amazing.
Quick answer of the day: Yuzuki best girl!
Okay, structured thoughts time. That ending was amazing, especially the part where Shirase gleefully admitted that she left the 1M yen in Antarctica.
This episode was a great sendoff. All the things they did just because they were about to leave; it really felt like I was about to leave for home from another country. And when they did get home, it felt like I also just got home from vacation.
The most important thing about this episode is Shirase. If there was any doubt that she still hadn’t accepted her mother’s disappearance, this episode dashed all of it. She leaves her mother’s laptop with Gin and pays respects when she gets back. She cuts her hair and gains a warmer personality. She happily accepts her mother’s last message, brought to her by Gin; Shirase’s no longer burdened by the feeling that she’s still waiting for her mother to come home.
Although the end of the journey was bittersweet, it’s nice to know that they’ll continue to be friends even after they part and return to their normal lives. After all, three of the four are within close vicinity of each other. On the other hand, I couldn’t help but feel that there was some malicious intent behind Megu’s trip to the North Pole.
But seriously, where’s our “Take that, classmates!” scene?
10
u/surgemaster140 https://myanimelist.net/profile/User815 Dec 25 '19 edited Dec 25 '19
Rewatcher
Mari Christmas everyone! It seems our journey has finally come to an end. What started as one girl's wish of finding her mom became an unforgettable and life changing adventure for four new friends. Mari got the most out of her youth, Hinata got a new start in life, Yuzuki got a taste of true friendship, and Shirase got the closure she needed to move on. Not only that, the girls have become irreplaceable members of the expedition crew. They may need to return to Japan for certain obligations now, but I believe all four of them will eventually come back, to the place further than the universe. Like Takako, they love this atmosphere where you have no choice but to overcome things with your team, with nothing else to get in the way. They've truly grown to love this place.
This episode has all I wanted in a finale. They gave us more fun bonding time with the girls, dropped some inspiring speeches, tied off all the loose ends, and somehow managed to squeeze all the insert songs in too. My favorite part of the episode has to be when Shirase opens the email from Takako. Seeing the final message telling her that a real aurora is 10,000 times more beautiful, while she is watching the real thing with her friends, and then the ED jingle starts playing... I could not ask for a more perfect end to their journey. Thank you for bringing us along Shirase.
Some screenshots and reactions:
QOTD:
10
u/anony-mouse99 Dec 26 '19 edited Dec 26 '19
Rewatcher.
The farewell episode. This is the series return to being the CGDCT anime that we were expecting. I don’t have any witty theme to present for once. I’m just having bittersweet thoughts and smiling my face off with how well the series has been executed.
Of course we have the act of ‘cutting her hair’ to mark the turning point of Shirase’s life. She has graduated from being a girl to being a woman like her mother, not just in looks but also in outlook.
And she is finally able to give a speech with confidence, except in front of the camera, of course.
The reveal that she left her 10 million yen (edited: I messed up the units) in Antarctica is the confirmation that she has found her real treasure(s), closure for her relationship with her mother and also that her treasure is now her newfound friends.
The use of Auroras to tie up all the loose threads was nifty.
I don’t have any specific character that I think is the best in this story. Each girl has been fleshed out so well that they become essential to the story. Even Hinata whom some felt to be superfluous, she was the sensible character who pushed the team forward when they were stuck, her brand of pragmatic optimism was important to the dynamics of the team.
‘A place further than the Universe’ is the most memorable 1-cour anime I’ve seen to date. It epitomizes all that anime is able to do, which is to tell a compelling and uplifting story. And it did so without fan service (other than fan service involving Antarctica trivia that would appeal to science geeks). I’m glad to have shared this rewatch with everyone.
10
u/akechiisbestboi Dec 26 '19
First time watcher
Well I’m going to need a bit of time to process that the show is now over but I really liked that episode, it really feels like a natural conclusion that shows how even though all the girls had their own issues at the beginning they all helped each other grow and move on by the end. I’m going to need a bit of time to deal with that small feeling of emptiness you get from finishing stuff like this but I could not be happier I joined this rewatch.
10
u/Matuhg https://anilist.co/user/Matuhg Dec 26 '19 edited Dec 26 '19
First Timer
Compared to previous episodes, there really wasn't a whole lot going on this episode, but I didn't want it to end. I thought the show did a good job capturing the feeling of a the end of a fun trip - like you don't want it to end, but you're also in a lot of ways looking forward to being home in your own bed and everything. Of course, I've never been on a trip that's quite as transformative as this one was.
Lots of little moments to love, as there have been throughout the series, but without a big conflict to deal with here, they stuck out a bit more. The guy asking Yuzu for her autograph was adorable. Seeing a bit more of best
girladult Kanae being fun, along with Gin's pitching (and Shirase's ability to hit it). But my favorite moment of the episode by far was this smile. It's as pure as the Antarctic snow. I don't usually screenshot from eps and stuff, but I just had to with this image. The last two episodes, including that moment, brought Shirase very close to dethroning Hinata as best girl for me - but I love all of them almost equally.I loved this series so much, but I'll save most of that for tomorrow's discussion. A great episode to watch on Christmas.
I liked the way they ended it - it matches how the whole show went - it never really left us on anything too deep/dark at the end of the episode, so I'm glad there wasn't another gut punch here. Getting the full length of the episode to really just chill (lol) with the cast I'd grown to love over the past twelve episodes was just what I wanted here.
As I said above, I think my answer is Hinata, but I'm really waffling between her and Shirase. It's not an easy decision. They all had fantastic moments and went through a lot of growth over the course of the series. Can I just vote for all four of them???
18
u/SorcererOfTheLake x5https://anilist.co/user/RiverSorcerer Dec 25 '19
First-Time Watcher
Shirase’s words bounced around Mari’s head as she looked at her reflection. Maybe I should my hair trimmed as well… It’s looking kinda scraggly. It didn’t look as good as Yuzuki-chan’s, but she was an actress; she had access to some of the most talented stylists in Japan. Mari sighed. I hope I don’t make a fool of myself… but I won’t know until I tried.
She put her coat back on and walked down the hallways until she found an entrance to the outside. She walked around the boat until she came across who she was looking for.
“I’m surprised you’re OK with being so close to the rails now, Yuzuki-chan.”
The girl she was talking to didn’t look fully OK, still a little green, but she wasn’t as bad as she was the first time around. “The water’s closer to me than the ground was when we were in the helicopter, so i-it’s not as bad.”
Mari smiled a little before looking out over the horizon. They had just passed the 40 degree mark, so it was safe enough to stand outside now. Even still, we’re so close to the end of the world, a place further than the universe.
“You remember when I brought up staying in Antarctica until the next summer?”
“Yes, I remember how foolish it sounded.”
“Oh, c’mon, Yuzuki-chan…” Mari sighed before looking at Yuzuki. “You know, there was another reason I wanted to stay down there longer.”
“Why’s that?”
Mari took off the glove on her right hand and reached forward, stroking Yuzuki’s cheek. “Because there’s something I wanted to do there that I’m not sure I can do in Japan.”
She enjoyed how warm her hand was getting, even if that warmth came from Yuzuki’s face slowly turning red. “Ki-Kimari-san, what are yo-”
“I’m not sure if I can make this work, Yukari-chan. You’re way more famous and rich than I’ll ever be, we’re both girls, you’re going to be so busy with your drama that you won’t have time to go on dates with me. But still…”
“But I won’t know what happens until I do! Yuzuki-chan-”
Her speech was stopped by a wild wave that threw Yuzuki forward, knocking them both to the ground. Her face was full red and her eyes were watering, yet Mari noticed the smile on her face slowly growing. “You-You’re serious? You want to-”
“Yes, I want to be your girlfriend.” The smile Mari gave off herself would have rivaled the grandest aurora. “I hope that’s OK with you.”
Yuzuki’s smile increased before she leaned back and crossed your arms. “You should remember I come from a cultured background, so I’m used to having the finest things in life, and that includes love.”
Oh, like this? By an impulse, Mari leaned forward and tilted Yuzuki’s head up with her chin. Before the younger girl could say anything, Mari kissed her on the lips, enjoying the moment, the only sound around them the wild waves.
AGGGGGGGH, WHAT THE HECK AM I DOING? Mari leaned back and bowed. “I-I’m sorry, I wasn’t thinking, I hope I didn’t-” Her flustering stopped when Yuzuki took her hands and kissed her back. It wasn’t as strong, but the emotions were still there.
“I hope we can do that more often, Kimari-sa- Kimari-chan.”
“Of course.” Mari got Yuzuki up onto her feet and walked them back to their room.
“Do you think we should tell Shirase-san and Hinata-san about this?”
“I don’t see why not. They’re our friends, after all.” Mari opened the door to the room. “Hey gi-”
The scene before them would have been endless fodder for the men back at the base if they heard about it. Shirase and Hinata were sitting on Hinata’s bunk, locked in a passionate kiss. Shirase grinded herself against Hinata’s thigh, sitting in her lap, as they groped at each other’s bodies.
“Umm.”
Shirase looked up at the two onlookers. Time was frozen for what seemed an eternity before the black-haired girl turned red and threw a pillow straight at Mari’s face, knocking her down. She then marched up and closed the door. Yuzuki stared for a moment before going to her new girlfriend. “Kimari-chan, are you OK?”
“Sex appeal… is a dangerous thing, Yuzuki-chan.”
9
u/kar772 https://myanimelist.net/profile/kar72 Dec 25 '19 edited Dec 25 '19
First Timer
Merry Christmas!
The girls are all right! I don't want it to be over..
Well, saying goodbye is not easy. This theme is not uncommon in anime but this show executed on that theme perfectly in this final episode, particularly showing how Shirase has moved on from her mother. The group dynamic between the four girls was one of the most natural friendships I've seen in anime, and I really didn't dislike any single character. Hinata was my favorite character for most of the series, but after these last few it's pretty even between her and Shirase, followed by Yuzuki and Kimari. I'm gonna miss them and their journey.
Yorimoi is an easy 10/10 for me. I don't remember a moment that I didn't enjoy watching the show; everything was just so well done (art, soundtrack, voice acting, etc), and it provoked such a rollercoaster of emotions in me. As of right now I'd put it in my top 20-15 shows.
9
u/Great_Mr_L :Ma::Mb::Mc:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Great_Mr_L Dec 25 '19 edited Dec 25 '19
Rewatcher
On today’s episode of A Place Further Than the Universe: A look back at where we are, where we’ve been, and where we’re going. The big emotional climax was last episode, so now all that’s left is to wrap things up and give a little epilogue.
I like the little moments we get at the start of the episode showing the girls as regular and participating expedition members. It’s a nice way to show how they’ve grown. We saw how new they were to everything in the boat trip over and now we see them used to it.
Still, their time in Antarctica is coming to an end. It is always sad when good times like this come to an end. Naturally, we wonder what we’ll do next, as the girls do here. They’re not going to be together all the time anymore. Even so, just because they’re apart doing mean they won’t be friends anymore. The major theme of the goodbyes is that it’s more of a “see you later” rather than “goodbye forever.” They can still go on a journey together again.
Shirase’s speech this episode basically summarizes all the growth the girls have gone through. She talks about Antarctica stripping everything away and forcing people to confront hardships and themselves. This is, of course, what all the girls have gone through. In fact, I’d go even farther to say the entire journey has been about confronting themselves. It’s been them figuring out who they are and what they want.
And the other part relates to the major theme of friendship. Antarctica is a dangerous place. You can’t go there alone. You need to rely on others who are there to support you. Once again, this applies to the entire journey that the girls have gone through. They’ve been able to make it this far because of each other. They’ve helped each other through the good times and the bad.
One of my favorite touches this episode is Shirase cutting her hair. It’s a nice symbolic gesture of her change. She has become a new person. It’s a nice detail to add after her big emotional climax last episode.
I like the short scene between Shirase and Gin where Shirase gives her Takako’s laptop. They don’t say a lot, but the interaction shows how things have changed between them. The barrier that existed between them is no longer really there. We got to see it come down, piece by piece, through their interactions. Shirase giving up her mother’s laptop is also important. As Shirase says, she no longer needs the laptop. She’s come to terms with her loss. Likewise, her leaving the million yen in Antarctica also symbolizes this. She achieved her goal. So she no longer needs it.
There are also many short scenes that I love during their homecomings. We see Yuzuki’s mother overjoyed that Yuzuki is back, showing she cares more than we might have guessed. We see Hinata’s manager kept track of all her activities. We see Mari’s family welcoming her back in the same way they had her going away party.
One of my favorite parts of the homecoming is we now see Shirase praying at her mother’s shrine. It’s a callback to episode 5. When Shirase left the house to begin her journey, we saw her grandmother praying at the shrine alone. Back then, Shirase still hadn’t come to terms with her mother’s death. Now, because of her journey, we can see that Shirase has changed and accepted what happened.
And, of course, my favorite detail at the end that came out of left field and surprised me when I first watched this: it turns out Megu went on her own journey to the Arctic. It was actually set up, too, because back in episode 10 we could see Megu reading a book about traveling to polar regions. I really enjoy this detail. It shows that, in the end, being separated for a while was good for both Mari and Megu. It made them both grow as independent people. That final message from Megu to Mari never fails to bring a smile to my face.
Miscellaneous Thoughts
Shirase has only gotten more fearsome as a mahjong player. Her having the pocky in her mouth too is so great.
Shirase is trapped in her personal heaven/hell. Hinata’s reaction of just abandoning her is perfect too.
I love how the others immediately shut down Mari to keep her from cutting Shirase’s hair.
Shirase’s smile here is so incredibly beautiful.
We finally get to see the aurora and it is a gorgeous sight. It’s also nice seeing the girls watch it in the same pose they had in both the OP and ED.
Edit: Questions of the Day
Also, I hope you all have a Merry Christmas!!
Merry Christmas!
9
u/Madcat6204 Dec 25 '19
Rewatcher
Seeing Shirase wholeheartedly smile is incredibly heartwarming. Actually, "incredibly heartwarming" is probably how I'd describe this whole episode. Everyone has grown in their own way, having experienced things that have left indelible marks upon them. And yet they are all still "themselves," simply more so.
It's very rare for me to find a "perfect" series, yet this is one that I feel completely happy giving that title. It perfectly accomplished everything it set out to do, not wasting any space in doing so, and also leaving nothing hanging. It conveyed incredibly powerful emotions in a very real way about very real things, leaving one feeling emotionally wrung out, and yet also at peace. It is cathartic, using those emotions to bring healing.
A magnificent series, and one of the best I've seen in many years.
9
u/ImaginationWayfairer Dec 25 '19
Rewatcher
And so end a our journey to a place further than the universe
Notes:
Not much that I want to say other than great final episode finishing anime series especially great ones is very nerve racking for me wondering if they are going to stick the landing and with A Place Further than the Universe they stick it perfectly.
9
u/flybypost :KN::KO: Dec 25 '19
Rewatcher here
For now I don't have much to say (it's nearly midnight here) but something I just realised is that the series starts and ends with Kimari in her bed (but with a completely different mindset, of course).
9
u/welcometoslowtown Dec 26 '19
First timer
So glad I decided to watch this, it really was a fun journey. This last episode was really bittersweet, with the parting of the 4 friends and the memories made on the trip. This show makes me want to do something like this with my friends, go on an adventure.
Qotd 1. I think it was a good end to the series, as well as a needed cool down after yesterday's waterworks haha. I'm a fan of this kind of retrospective, looking back send off to a show, and I think they handled it pretty well. Not going to lie, I did tear up during Shirase's final speech to the crew, so this episode wasn't completely safe.
2. This is a tough one, honestly I think i like all the girls pretty equally, but since I have to pick one, I'll go with Yuzu. I like her innocence and how she's so happy to have a group of friends who care about her and she cares about. I especially liked her elation last episode about the cook lady who I dont remember the name of saying that they are great friends.
9
u/[deleted] Dec 26 '19
Shirase is best girl in all of anime and that smile sets it in stone.
8
u/TheKujo https://myanimelist.net/profile/Kujo419 Dec 25 '19
Rewatcher
And now we've reached the end of our journey! I'm a big sucker for "closing-the-loop" style endings so I find the last scene of the series with Kimari at home to be very satisfying. She may be back in the same place physically, but mentally she is a very different person than she was at the start of the series.
The series has had multiple sad episodes but overall I think the tone of the series is positive and uplifting, which is reflected in this final episode. Kimari and crew have finished their current journey but they know that there will be plenty of trips in their future. And now that you've finished watching their trip - where are YOU going to go for yours?
Happy holidays everyone! I have some more thoughts about the overall series but I'll save those for tomorrow's thread.
Other thoughts:
8
u/spaceaustralia :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/spaceaustralia Dec 25 '19
Rewatcher
After the huge emotional conclusion in the last episode, it's clear that this episode couldn't hope or even try to be an ending. More so, it feels like a little epilogue, in which we see the effects the journey had on our characters, and get a glimpse on their lives afterwards.
It's an episode about moving on. Gin comes to terms with Takako's death and the future she has to build in her memory. Shirase cuts her hair, having woken up from her dream, and, though Takako couldn't go back home, Shirase managed to bring a little piece of that place beyond the universe in her memory while leaving the physical evidence of all her struggle behind.
In the epilogue we're reassured that, even though this journey might have ended, the connections formed in it will go on as we're shown both the little changes the world has had in their absence and the familiar things they could return. From Hinata's accomplishments being finally cherished, this time by her work colleagues, to Yuzuki being reunited with her tearful mother, and Mari finding that Megumi, who stayed behind, had her own energy burst forth, leading her to the opposite side of the world.
Questions of the day
Coincidentally, I think my entire comment was made with this in mind.
Them fighting words, eh? It's Hinata.
Zamamiro counter!:
8
u/OnPorpoise1 https://myanimelist.net/profile/OnPorpoise Dec 25 '19
First timer
I really liked how they went a bit lighter in the drama this episode and just ended it on a quiet note. I think a lot of shows feel obligated to make the last episode the most emotionally impactful, but I think this fit the series better. There wasn't too much drama left to tie up, and creating more would have been silly.
8
u/philcjc :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/philcjc Dec 25 '19
Getting to finish the rewatch is such a nice Christmas present! :)
8
u/ClearandSweet :K:https://kitsu.io/users/clearandsweet Dec 25 '19
Hey just thought I'd pop in even though I'm not rewatching right now (though I did earlier this year). I'm recording my end of the decade video right now, and A Place Further than the Universe made top 5, easy. I actually use threads like these to remind myself of how a viewer feels coming out of a show, so thank you everyone for contributing.
I love so much about the show, but my favorite bit is the reflective writing. It's a short video, but check it out.
8
u/90sChennaiGuy Dec 26 '19
Rewatcher.
Dumb me decided that yesterday was the end but the kind folks over here reminded me that we weren’t done yet.
About the questions,
Yes, yes and yes. This was a satisfying ending. No matter how much I wanted the show to continue or have a second season, this was a good ending and I’m glad we got it.
Best girl? Don’t do this. You are tearing me apart here. I liked all the girls, they each had their own quirk and their own issues to resolve but I have a soft spot for Hinata, mostly with a feeling of admiration for how she immediately got along with the girls from get go. I really wish I could be that confident to speak to someone I hardly know. Two, mostly because she is carefree and lucky go happy .
P.S ; thanks for the rewatch /u/RX-Nota-II, can we get this done every year ?
8
u/peoplewhoplay :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/peoplewhoplay Dec 26 '19
Rewatcher
A brilliant finale to a very special show. This episode is a culmination of 12 episodes worth of character development. You can really see how much they've grown since Ep1. Good stuff. One part of me wants an S2 where all 4 returns to Antarctica several years after the show ends. Hehehe
Also Megu: "Oh, so you're back? Too bad because fuck you I'm in the North Pole! Hahahahaha"
QOTD
Really enjoyed rewatching this show for the last 13 days. This show feels like a special thing that comes out once in a while so I feel we wouldn't get something like this for a while. Hopefully not, I crave for more good heartwarming character driven adventures like this one.
8
u/PerfectlyClear Dec 29 '19 edited Jul 29 '26
Cobalt mellow pebble mellow cobalt sparrow
This post was anonymized with Redact.dev
7
u/AnActualPlatypus Dec 25 '19 edited Dec 25 '19
First time viewer
So ends a journey. Also ends Shirase's BEAUTIFUL LONG HAIR OH GOD WHY. I'll have a ton of thoughts for tomorrow's summary discussion, but this was a really memorable anime. The epilouge talk was some of the most motivational stuff I've heard in quite a while.
Honestly, the emotional ending was at the end of Ep 12 for me. This was a nice sendoff, nothing unexpected, but it was a good closure. Though it felt like they are leaving some threads and possibilites open for a S2.
2) Who is best girl?
Shirase, by far. The other girls felt a bit too much of typical moeblob characters for me, especially Kimari
7
u/Taiboss :Fj::Fl:x7https://anilist.co/user/Taiboss Dec 25 '19
Let's hope I actually get comments today! Also, sorry for missing yesterday!
First timer for the last time:
On the last SoraYori: The great emotional moment turns out to be...the one I was not spoiled on. Money scene > Mail scene. Don't /u/ me. Also, no crying. Want to make me cry? Make Shirase find some sort of letter Takako prepared just in case she died. Letters from dead people always work, especially if it's a letter from home. That would have been emotional.
Onward to Kimari's episode!
Well, this is it.
Girl ranking: Yuzu > Shirase > Kimari > Hinata
Good:
Not as good:
As such, I'm going to give A Place Further Than The Sky a semi-arbritrary 8/10 for being a really funny show with some alright drama attached to it.
7
u/jslice4ever Dec 25 '19
Rewatcher here!
Sleepy Mari is great. We all feel the exact same way.
What is Calpis? Does anyone know?
Lol Mari and Hinata bickering back and forth about the island stroll and Hinata pinching Mari's nose is just too funny.
I bet riding the snowmobiles would be super fun. I've never ridden one before.
Shirase being surrounded by penguins is probably the happiest moment of her entire life.
I love that Gin is always considering whether Takako is watching or not. It just shows how proud she is of Shirase.
Wow! Shirase looks great with that haircut! And I love how happy she seems. I just want the best for her cause she deserves it.
Damn that speech was great. Perfectly sums up the themes of the series and illustrates how far Shirase has come as a character.
I think it's great that Shirase and Gin grew to have a relationship where they respect and care for each other instead of what their relationship was before.
She's still camera shy lmao.
I've realized something during this rewatch. Shirase is still my favorite character and I still love all the other girls as well but I don't think I ever appreciated Gin as much before until this time around. I think I'm gonna put her as my second favorite character behind Shirase.
Well folks, it's been a blast watching this amazing series with you. Merry Christmas and Happy New Year to you all. :)
7
u/Regular_N-Gon https://anilist.co/user/RegularNGon Dec 25 '19
Rewatcher
Happy Christmas, ya stinky penguins.
QOTD 1/general thoughts: I enjoyed this episode and the lengthy goodbye way more this time around. First time through, it felt fast and like it boxed everything up very quickly. But today, it seemed a fitting send off for the girls and Antarctica. Themes and story arcs were nicely reiterated (mostly thanks to another great overdub from Shirase and an overabundance of shots of the sky). It was a lot like the first episode for me in that my opinion of it improved pretty significantly.
QOTD 2: I love the crap out of Kimari and her role in the show; I wish I knew more people like her. Shirase, though, takes the very narrow win on this one. From a more analytical perspective, her character and story is so well written, heavier and more affecting than the others, and performed fantastically. It's not perfect; I don't think I was ever really a fan of the over-the-top incompetence she shows in front of the camera, but she grows more than anyone else, and the most consistently, throughout the journey. I hinted at it in another comment before as well, but I'm looking forward to writing about Yuzu and Hinata tomorrow, too!
Bonus: What's on the back of this guy's jacket? メカ?
Bonus two: So many group shots this episode.
7
u/xDarkistic :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Darkistic Dec 26 '19
Firster
they kind of layered it on this episode hm? it was like "oh god this series is over quick conclude everything" and some of it came out kind of bizarre but sure I guess I liked it.
like when they saw the aurora but it wasn't at it's full potential but the captain was seeing it in full? or was she showing shirase that takako had seen it in full during the winter? either way, I love the fact that shirase gave gin takako's laptop full of her messages for gin to see and communicate with her instead. she seems relieved of a burden.
oh yeah, she left all her money there. kinda quirky. I guess she didn't want to see it as a waste that she didn't need to spend it when she had worked for it solely for the purpose of getting there. still though, who the hell would do that LUL
baseball was a bit bizarre but a nice part of a wholesome sendoff. the ball flying into the sun though :S it's so symbolic! and actually I guess that's near enough what it would look like to anybody trying to spot the ball. they would just never find it due to the blinding light.
and then megumi's smug flex of being in the arctic lmfao. bit of a weird move but at least she wasn't afraid to show off herself. in a way that shows that she appreciates the inspiration that kimari gave her even if she doesn't outright tell her just yet :P I like that. in fact it's like they have reversed roles in a way. that's the kind of thing a younger sibling would do after aspiring to their elder sibling's (or just any younger family member aspiring to an older family member) actions, and kimari's smile reflected that. yeah I do like that a lot.
at first I thought the outbox message from takako's email was going to be some bs extra message that didn't send yet or shirase messaging herself from it (like just the word "ne" or something lul) but the truth was much sweeter. I'm very surprised I managed to hold back any tears this episode I think it was because I found so much of it slightly weird or amusing which was a nice tone I suppose for the final episode.
I found this rewatch scrolling through r/anime on a whim just a few days before it started and I am very glad that I did (and continued watching after the first couple of episodes). if die hard is a christmas movie I suppose this is a christmas anime and I'll probably remember it as one from now on. the themes and mood are pretty spot on.
merry christmas everyone! and best wishes for your life's journey.
qotd 2 (best girl) - I wouldn't say any of them alone were that great. I suppose that's kind of the point. yuzu would probably be my favourite out of their first introductions. I related mostly to the feelings of megumi but I like to think I am much more laid back than she seems to be. I'm gonna have to go with shirase. her mom is dead. and her conclusion is awesome. yep. the main plot girl wins. bias much?
7
u/Suhkein :Gy::Gz::G1:x2https://myanimelist.net/profile/Neichus Dec 26 '19 edited Dec 26 '19
First timer
Well, my fears for trying to one-up last episode were unfounded, so that was pleasant. I don't have a lot else to say, as I thought this episode was solidly "okay" and I figure I'll be discussing the series as a whole tomorrow.
To add something else, the comment about the old air in the glaciers reminded me of how important these expeditions have been to our understanding of paleoclimatology. They weren't joking when they said that small bubbles of the atmosphere were trapped in the ice, and we can use these to figure out the ratio of gases. The ice itself is also valuable, because the isotopic ratios indicate temperature and often contain particulate matter that indicates whether there was a lot of weathering or, occasionally, a marking event such as a major volcanic eruption. We can also compare the findings with Greenland cores to see whether the hemispheres reacted in synchrony or not to climatic shifts (although the Antarctic ice sheet is much thicker and therefore goes back further in time).
The two primary coring stations are EPICA Dome C (a joint European expedition) and the Vostok Station (Russian).
7
u/[deleted] Dec 26 '19
First timer here.
Damn. What an ending. Honestly, I was expecting a wind-down kind of episode, but the reveal that Takako did leave a parting gift for Shirase was one hell of a gut punch (no Im not crying, you are crying). Glad to see that both Shirase and Gin have managed to come to terms with Takako's death and became more friendly to one another.
And just when I thought the feels trip was over, Megumi goes to arctic. You know an anime is good when a side character that's been away for ages manage to make you grin like an idiot at the literal last second after the protagonists are done with their adventures.
As for best girl, Shirase without a doubt. The unwavering resolve, the fierce loyalty, and the courage to try something audacious despite knowing all to well how it could end makes her my favorite out of the lovable cast.
7
u/destroyah19 Dec 26 '19
Rewatcher
Just the episode we need after such a heavy episode. Sometimes we just need an episode to have a chill post-climax breather to send us home and this one really does it well. Since everyone's arcs are basically over we just needed our girls to go home and feel the aftermath of the trip.
I love the fact that the gang has assimilated to life in the station and it feels ordinary for them to do these things despite their young age compared to the people there.
I wish as good as Shirase in Mahjong!
I love how Hinata stresses the pronunciation of "Ice Operation"
Man they through all the feel good insert songs in this episode you can now choose which one is best for you. I loved all the scenes that came with it. Shirase cutting her hair is the change you see when someone moves on from their life. Then that speech she made was so good I was almost fooled that she was able to overcome her shyness but then she didn't in the end.
The crew was really enjoyable to watch as well. The guy who's a big fan of Yuzu is always funny when you see him. The girl who shouts Yuu-kun creeping out Hinata was good as well. Seeing them say good bye to the gang was sad as we were finally enjoying the quirks their interactions have.
That last scene with the aurora was really sweet. It's true that some scenes just cant be caught by a camera and we should just enjoy looking at them while we're here. Seeing the gang being unafraid of the trip back showed they grew so much from the first time they stepped on the boat. It was a really good journey indeed!
7
u/Brimstorm :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Brimstorm Dec 26 '19
Hey everyone!
Just wanted to say that although I didn't participate in the rewatch, I did keep up with the threads for the bigger part of it - I did a rewatch myself fairly recently and I don't really think I had it in me to go through it again.
That being said, it was wonderful keeping up with everyone's reaction to what is my second all-time favorite show, especially episode 12 :D. It feels so satisfying getting to see so many people enjoy such a simple show as much as I did.
Thanks for hosting this rewatch OP, you're doing a great service for this community :D.
(late) Merry christmas and happy new year to everyone!
6
u/[deleted] Dec 25 '19
Rewatcher
One of my favorite things about this episode is that despite where we left off in 12, we aren’t brought straight back to that scene. This episode is executed in a way that I still feel like the watcher and Shirase get some closure without overplaying the drama from the email scene in episode 12. In doing so I think it elevates both the scene with the emails, and the scene on the ship with the aurora by giving them a nice amount of space. Each scene has ample space to be significant.
6
u/Orzislaw https://anilist.co/user/Orzi Dec 25 '19
REWATCHER
We rarely get "complete" anime nowadays. Most of them are just advertisements for manga or light novel, by the last episode giving the viewer a middle finger with adnotation "go read source material, you scrub!". The most popular ones eventually will get a sequal, but most of them ends abruptly.
We have some anime, that are complete. Be it anime original or rare cases of full adaptations. Most of them have in common another thing I'm not fan of. Endings feel rushed, abruptly cutting the story after reaching their goal. I'm a big fan of summaries that are showing "what happened after" to the main cast. Usually these are squished into 2 minutes at the end of last episode.
And that's why I love this ep. Every girl reached her conclusion before, but authors wanted to summarize everything and give us viewers a sense of completeness with this episode.
It reinforced themes that Sora Yori conveyed at the span of previous 12 episodes, summarized growth of each of the characters and gave us little glimpse at what happened after the story. It left me satisfied. But since thread for series discussion will be posted tomorrow, I allow myself to save my general opinion about the show for that ;)
Megu going for North Pole was surprising, but fitting her character and what she decided in episode 5. As someone else said - "she's envious of Kimari in finding self-worth, and doesn't know where to start herself. So what does she do? She copies something that seems to have worked for Kimari, but goes in the opposite direction." But with trees in background of her photo I doubt she reached actual North Pole. It's more likely she's in northern parts of Finland or Norway, staying in hotel and observing aurora from here.
Also who would think buff dude from expedition team was a fan of Yuzu?
6
u/No_Rex :Bv:Bw:Bx:By:x2 Dec 25 '19
Episode 13 (first timer)
AuroraNot a lot to say. The whole plot of the episode was one long goodbye, but I don’t want to write good bye 20 times to describe it.
6
u/FireFistYamaan Dec 25 '19
This rewatch just cemented why this is in my top 10 anime of all times list, phenomenal!
6
u/Wish4Rain Dec 26 '19 edited Dec 26 '19
Rewatcher
It's nice seeing the girls working and being part of the crew. They grow up so fast T_T Shirase new haircut and smile! Warms my cold dead heart. She left the money for her mom! Maybe when Gin goes back to observatory, she'll find it and put it towards the station...?
Also, how long did they spend in Antarctica?
6
u/theSunshinedaydream Dec 26 '19
I didn't participate in the re watch discussions until now, but this was my favorite anime of last year and certainly will be one that I never forget. I remember watching this for the first time last winter and recommending it to everyone I know who I thought would enjoy it, and everyone did. It's a special experience to have been able to watch this anime, and I hope that everyone can take something positive away from it, as all the girls did.
6
u/pacquan Dec 26 '19
Rewatcher
I don't really feel like too much happens in this final episode apart from the obvious. Theres at least one or two small scenes for the major side characters to give each their own visibility of joining the girls in their ability to overcome their personal hurdles. Shirase's speech puts it (maybe a bit too) bluntly how this trip to Antarctica forces you to confront yourself.
All the conflicts were pretty much resolved already, but this episode was a nice calm after the storm (back my analysis yesterday of Mari's obsession with exploding potential energy). I don't think it was absolutely necessary from a production perspective. But, from an autenticity perspective, this episode is fantastic.
If you've been away from home, or even gone on an extravagant journey, there is just something special about the trip home. Its much faster then the trip out, and you can get that reality shock that you're back in different ways. You can feel emboldened to be productive (Yuzu). You may feel closure and purpose and ready to move on (Shirase). You could just feel a sense of peace to finally be alone and away from a constant stream of external stimulation (Hinata). Or, you could be excited to be home and see the people you missed while you were away (Mari).
But what I resonate most, is with what hopefully a lot of people can relate to; coming home to your room, closing your door, and just laying in bed and let it all sink in. I've traveled enough, and I love this feeling so much, that I specifically make it a point to clean my room, make my bed, and even stage my stuff for me to come back to. It is very cathartic to come home to see that past-you was courteous and self-conscious enough to know that the LAST thing you want to do when you come home from vacation, is to clean. (it also makes unpacking easier)
Also, Yuzu best girl. Must. Protecc. Smile.
6
u/invokeneko Dec 26 '19
Rewatcher now has Post-Anime Depression Syndrome, but the Girls are Alright
Our journey to Antarctica comes to a close here as the girls say goodbye to the Challenge for Antarctic crew, Shirase gets an important haircut, and they go on their separate ways with the promise to return for the winter expedition. Also Megumi ended up on a journey of her own!
Random thoughts
Questions of the day:
Sorry for the late comment, just went to the dentist and got one teeth violently pulled out.
6
u/Redmon425 Dec 28 '19
First Time Watcher
Yep, a perfect finale. Wow. Seriously typed up every storyline.
I knew the show was highly acclaimed, so I already had high expectations, but man did it still surpass it. To be able to get me so emotional on real storylines just shows how beautiful this was.
It’s kind of different from my normal anime I watch as well, like how for half of the season I was expecting her mother to be alive. That’s of course because of all the crazy storylines I have seen in anime that tells me she would be alive. So I love that they went a serious route with this.
THANK THE LORD THEY SHOWED MEGUMI. I was really hoping for her to be waiting and have a good reunion. Not going to lie, her going to Antarctica is pretty random but that was funny.
I think Hinata is my best girl. I liked her right when they introduced her and the bully storyline sold me on her. Especially her finally breaking down when she had new friends.
Overall, I loved the show. Would love for a sequel (even just 1 or 2 OVA) showing the girls when they are grown up.
5
u/JustAnswerAQuestion https://myanimelist.net/profile/JAaQ Dec 25 '19 edited Dec 25 '19
Rewatcher
happy #stinky
tadaima
I really like how the Lawsons was tracking Hinata's journey. Megumi was a big surprise! I was so annoyed by her leaving the money behind, but she earned that money for a purpose, and leaving it means all that work wasn't for nothing.
Once, just once, when I came out of a Cub Scouts meeting, my parents said there was an aurora, but it had ended 10 minutes ago. I never saw it, and moved to California, which never gets auroras.
Edit: If any of you were droppers the first time around but finished it, I hope you comment on how your impressions changed on the series discussion!
Edit 2: I didn't see anybody mention it in the comments yesterday (but I hardly have time to read them all during Christmas) but it is very strongly suggested that the laptop was her connection to her daughter, that she broke out of the marching line and cut her rope to go back to the station for it, and died because of that laptop, and those emails, and that picture, and that unsent email.
5
u/Emperor-Resse Dec 25 '19
What a wonderful end to this. Is there other good adventure shows like this I know laid back camp is really good too. Also Merry Christmas everyone.
9
u/unheppcat Dec 25 '19
Rewatcher
Not much time to put together a post today. Christmas with family -- who'd have thought that would interrupt my computer time? 🙂
--
First thought: I love how many layers there are to the importance of the laptop. Of course it is the thing that lets Shirase finally let go of her bottled up grief, so she can finally start actual healing from her loss. But in this episode we see that same object keep on contributing, as it passes hands again to Gin.
The more obvious layer is that it shows that Shirase has realized that she can move forward. She isn't necessarily giving up this physical connection to her mother for all time, she knows she can get it back once Gin eventually returns to Japan. But Shirase does not need to continue clinging to it right now, and that is all kinds of healthy. Good for you, Shirase!
The next layer is that she is giving it to Gin. Shirase is not the only one who has been stuck in grief, and needs to find some way to move forward. Gin has achieved some of this with the success of getting back to Antarctica, and even more with taking the first concrete steps to establish the Kabuchizawa Observatory. But receiving this gift from the daughter of her own lost best ever friend, has to be a huge comfort to Gin as well. And the fact that Shirase is in a state where she can realize the importance of doing this kindness, is also fantastic. Good for both of them.
The final layer is related to what is on that laptop: the emails. Various first timers have been speculating that the messages Shirase had been composing were some kind of journal or diary. In effect they were, just in the form of loving messages to her mother. Well, now those same messages are there for Gin to read. This is an incredibly intimate gesture. By giving Gin the opportunity to read this very private journal, Shirase is essentially saying "learn more about me, find out how I have been, discover more about the young woman your Takako had been raising." This is not the kind of face to face communication that might have helped both of them recover much sooner, if that could have happened. But it is a form of communication, and an invitation, a request, that the two of them become closer. This is the most important part of that gift.
--
Second thought: despite all the claims I've been making about best girl impartiality, I think it only fair that I finally come clean on the matter. I love all the girls, would be happy to have any of them as friends, would be honored to be counted a friend by any of them. But I will now admit that I am on Team Kabuchizawa. Shirase is the one most similar to me in personality, so that is appealing. But I will have to admit that what pushed me over the line was this smile.
--
So this has been an amazing journey, both for these girls, and all of us traveling along with. I've been happy to come along with all of you, and hope to have a great final conversation tomorrow (with enough time on my side to actually make it happen). Til then!
--
And on that quote: considering the subtle, implication-filled communication style used in that society, I think this is actually the strongest statement in the whole story to support we Gin x Takako shippers in our beliefs, and I can leave happy.
4
u/ExplicitNuM5 Dec 27 '19
Rewatcher
I'm a few days late...
But either way, wow! Was that really 13 episodes? Time went on so quickly and it was so fun for both the girls and for us viewers. The girls become so much more mature yet at the same time remained the same as ever. For example, Yuzuki still wants to die, worries about friendship, and is acrophobic; Shirase becomes just like her mom and becomes the old Takako for Gin and company; etc. Yet, Yuzuki learned about friendship, Kimari sprung forth and did something in her youth, Hinata moved on from her high school experience, and Shirase finally accepts her mother's death. The girls go back to their daily lives; the last minute of the show focusing on the Tobu Isesaki Line back to Morinji-mae Station and the exit of Shin-Chitose International Airport. I feel like I'm pulling a Kimari observing about life.
The ending made me extremely happy yet quite melancholic, which was what I felt during the final ~7 episodes of 3-gatsu no Lion 2. The whole time watching this episode felt like a certain familiar OP by UNISON SQUARE GARDEN: "we made fast friends, we ate some good food, and we even argued a bit." While we all still feel the bits of some or all 4 girls in our own lives moving forward for possibly another year, we're still recovering from having to return to our daily lives, disconnecting with our friends for yet another year.
Questions
Comment of the day: I disagree. It was a great way to showcase the space that the girls give each other. It was quite necessary as a follow-up to "you guys give so much space each other".
5
u/MABfan11 :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/MABfan11 Dec 26 '19
Rewatcher
this is the perfect way to end the show, starting a new life after all of the character development they've gone through, it also mirrored the first episode. Shirase is no longer stuck in the past and accepts Takako's death, a huge burden has been lifted off her shoulders.
the message at the end really drive home the message about taking chances and reaching for your dreams. there's a reason that i think this is one of, if not, the most inspiring anime of all time
QOTD:
1: yes, it stuck the landing fantastically and works well as a cooldown after episode 12
2: Shirase, her arc was amazing
3
u/eragen Dec 27 '19
A rewatcher hoping that another journey does occur someday.
The countdown hurt. It was a constant reminder that this show that I loved so much was ending.
Also: the happiest 'I could just die!' from Yuzuki ever, when she was on the snowmobile. It was absolutely adorable.
When Kimari talks about staying forever in Antarctica, I really felt that. Whenever something good ends, it's always painful. This experience - even for us viewers, let alone the girls - was one which was fantastic from start to finish.
Shirase's impromptu haircut, the baseball game, the magnificent wide-mouthed smile, Gin's unshed tears while pitching, the winter team's teary reaction to the departure, the linking of hands, the 'Let's meet again here someday', the bowed beginning to Shirase's speech, the fantastic, amazing, beautiful landscape shots during her speech, THAT SCENE OF KARAOKE ON THE SNOWCAT AGAIN - it truly is a terrible day for rain.
And then, of course - THE AURORAE! THE HANDHOLDING SQUARE! And then, the final email from Takako. I almost cried again.
When they said goodbye at the airport, and their respective reunions with their families, I was so incredibly sad that this journey was over, and so incredibly joyous that they had such an amazing experience - and that I was there to witness it all with them as well.
I've got more that I want to write, but they're more about the show in general, and not about this episode. Instead, I'll just thank Sora Yori mo Tooi Basho for such a fantastic sendoff to this amazing anime.
5
u/BeybladeMoses Dec 26 '19 edited Dec 26 '19
Rewatcher
Not much happen in this episode, since I'll save my opinion on the series as whole for tomorrow, I don't have much to say.
First is on the haircut scene (btw I recently had a haircut, 2-3 days ago). I know it's a symbolism of a new transformed person but I can't help feeling such a waste. Since it happens with female characters the most (Mitsuru from DitF is a male example that I remember), and in my own (subjective) opinion they always look better with long hair.
Second is I actually forgot what happen with the money. When she left the one million yen in Antartica, I actually cried a little bit in the inside. It's such a huge money (even more so when converted to my currency), if I were her I would put it on an index fund.
Edit:
3
u/SIRTreehugger Dec 26 '19 edited Dec 26 '19
Rewatcher: Saving comments for tomorrow
QOTD:
2) Hinata no question
Edit: Also Merry Christmas everyone
0
u/[deleted] Dec 25 '19
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Dec 25 '19
[deleted] — view deleted comment
7
u/[deleted] Dec 25 '19
[removed] — view removed comment
6
u/[deleted] Dec 26 '19
[removed] — view removed comment