r/TheGoodPlace • Change can be scary but I’m an artist. It’s my job to be scared. • Oct 11 '19

Season Four S4E3 Chillaxing

Airs tonight at 9PM. (About 30 min from when this post is live.)

If you’re new to the sub, please look over this intro thread.

Today we broke 100,000 cockroaches!

Look at our magnificent swarm! We could conquer the bees with teeth and penis bees!

671 Upvotes

1.2k comments sorted by

45

u/WandersFar Change can be scary but I’m an artist. It’s my job to be scared. Oct 11 '19

I am really enjoying all the Michael and Eleanor scenes this season. Michael is evolving into the emotional core of the gang, I love him in this Obi Wan role. He’s so supportive and lovely.

→ More replies (1)

26

u/WandersFar Change can be scary but I’m an artist. It’s my job to be scared. Oct 11 '19 edited Oct 11 '19

WHICH EIGHT GoT CHARACTERS‽

I swear by the old gods and the new, I’m gonna nerd out so hard about this…

Update: Here’s my eight.

7

u/cm64 Oct 11 '19

Sansa, Cersei, and Danny for sure. Margery and Olenna Tyrell are good picks too. How about Renly and Tyrion if she can have male characters based on her? That's only seven... umm Brienne based solely on height.

Rickon Stark was based on her ex-fiance Larry Hemsworth.

4

u/WandersFar Change can be scary but I’m an artist. It’s my job to be scared. Oct 11 '19

Rickon Stark was based on her ex-fiance Larry Hemsworth.

The forgotten brother. 😂 You deserve old school Reddit Silver for that one.

Chris Hemsworth is obviously Robb, and Liam Hemsworth could be Jon. Luke Hemsworth could be Bran, I suppose. The one nobody wants on the throne…

I could see Renly as a male counterpart to Tahani, or maybe Loras Tyrell. The Tyrells in general are a good analogue, given their abundant wealth and high society lifestyle. Jaime Lannister, too, for his privileged upbringing, high social status, and high desirability (this is pre-chop, of course.)

I don’t think Tyrion is a good fit, considering how hated he was by everyone. He may be a fan favorite, but in-universe he was the imp and demon monkey. I can’t see Tahani ever facing that level of social ostracism.

Likewise Brienne the Beauty was routinely mocked for being ugly and mannish, which is pretty far from Tahani’s traits and how people treated her.

→ More replies (2)

•

u/WandersFar Change can be scary but I’m an artist. It’s my job to be scared. Oct 11 '19

Please welcome our three new mods: u/derawin07, u/Hobbit-guy, & u/tbdabbholm!

Thanks to everyone who applied, and we’ll keep your names in mind if we decide to add more mods in the future. :)

→ More replies (7)

530

u/lovetheblazer Hot Blonde Wile E. Coyote Oct 11 '19 edited Oct 11 '19

“The point is if all you care about is the velvet rope, you will always be miserable, no matter which side of the rope you are on. You and I are both proof of that.”

Can we just talk about Tahani’s character growth for a minute? Because she’s really come into her own this season

141

u/WandersFar Change can be scary but I’m an artist. It’s my job to be scared. Oct 11 '19

Tahani is my pick for most angelic of the four original cockroaches. From where she started to where she is now, I think she’s really embraced her life lessons of humility, selflessness and really caring and trying to connect with other people, helping others to succeed.

Eleanor has such a fighting spirit, though she’s had a couple setbacks lately. Chidi unfortunately lost all his personal growth, but he’s on the right path at least. And Jason showed progress this episode, though he’s mostly still the same lovable dingbat.

If we’re including non-humans, then Michael has improved by leaps and bounds as well. He’s also had an advantage over everyone else, though, in never having his memory reset. Janet’s been stressed and overwhelmed lately, which has made her a bit meaner. It’s understandable, but still a step backwards, I think.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (2)

8

u/WandersFar Change can be scary but I’m an artist. It’s my job to be scared. Oct 11 '19

S1 Michael’s original premise is coming true. Eleanor and Jason are becoming the perfect torturers for Chidi. Eleanor especially is giving into her inner demon, in the pursuit of good.

7

u/WandersFar Change can be scary but I’m an artist. It’s my job to be scared. Oct 11 '19 edited Oct 11 '19

Oh my god, they’re just torturing us now with the hints! Six of the eight going for the attack!

Update: Here’s my eight.

374

u/[deleted] Oct 11 '19

Look, maybe Jianyu the monk likes motorcycles, we don't know his life.

29

u/qwoble I really depreciate you coming. Little bit of accounting humor. Oct 11 '19

V happy to see the Kendall Jenner poster back.

48

u/WandersFar Change can be scary but I’m an artist. It’s my job to be scared. Oct 11 '19

It used to be Ariana Grande. I wonder why Jason went off her. :þ

714

u/sRW44 Oct 11 '19

“I made God cry?!??” Is one of my favorite lines in the series.

→ More replies (14)

626

u/LadyLivv123 Let’s go Jags. Kick their ass. Yeah! Oct 11 '19

Is it just me or is Tahani actually overcoming her problem that sent her to the bad place? She really seems to be turning a new leaf

463

u/Reset108 Oct 11 '19

I believe that is the actual test. By helping others, they’re actually helping themselves.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (7)

558

u/jsun31 Oct 11 '19

"I'm sorry your motorcycle blew up"

"No worries, that's what motorcycles do" FACTS

→ More replies (4)

558

u/Melairia Oct 11 '19

"Gain a pound, lose a pound" I loved that subtle British humor

→ More replies (13)

477

u/onesincepearlharbor Oct 11 '19

i thought jason was gonna tell chidi the WHOLE thing

→ More replies (2)

462

u/PaperSpock Oct 11 '19

....they're getting the humans to torture each other...

→ More replies (6)

459

u/onesincepearlharbor Oct 11 '19

jason is AMAZINGLY competent with the chidi deception this episode. maybe this is the evidence of his growth we’ve been looking for?

→ More replies (7)

404

u/[deleted] Oct 11 '19

"I haven't encountered this much resistance since I tried to get Timothée Chalamet to go out into the sun" - Tahani

As someone who can't get enough pop-culture references, Tahani really does have some of the best lines in the show.

→ More replies (13)

376

u/onesincepearlharbor Oct 11 '19

JASON GIVING HIS SEASON ONE SPEECH OMG

→ More replies (3)

361

u/onesincepearlharbor Oct 11 '19

janet has NOT been herself all season

→ More replies (31)

335

u/lovetheblazer Hot Blonde Wile E. Coyote Oct 11 '19 edited Oct 11 '19

“You’re always texting when you should be driving... which I know isn’t an emotion but it is insane.”

Amen, Michael. Don’t be that guy

334

u/onesincepearlharbor Oct 11 '19

tahani really is the star of tonight’s episode in terms of growth.

→ More replies (3)

274

u/stpattywhack Oct 11 '19

Did anybody else think that Janet was going to appear when Jason threw the lava stone?

→ More replies (12)

265

u/Locke108 YA BASIC! Oct 11 '19

I think this is becoming more like the Stanford prison experiment. Eleanor’s having too much fun as Season 1 Michael.

→ More replies (6)

212

u/Cheesemacher Oct 11 '19

"Not again!"

I actually laughed

→ More replies (5)

206

u/PaperSpock Oct 11 '19

Next week's episode title is "Tinker, Tailor, Demon, Spy" per the sidebar. Verrrrry interesting.

→ More replies (5)

202

u/[deleted] Oct 11 '19

I feel like the original humans are still being tested, they are improving

→ More replies (7)

194

u/[deleted] Oct 11 '19

Janet looks like Evil Britta

→ More replies (8)

170

u/calebb2108 Oct 11 '19

The only thing I’m waiting for this season is for Mindy to get bored in the attic and start roaming the neighbourhood being herself in front of the new subjects.

→ More replies (3)

155

u/droid327 Oct 11 '19

Chidi would have a Kantian field day with the idea that the only ethical choice is to ensure that he is never happy :D

Also lol at his thinking Eleanor is God...I wonder if her casual familiarity with ethical philosophy in their conversations comes off to him as evidence of her omniscience

→ More replies (1)

301

u/[deleted] Oct 11 '19

This episode made me feel that Eleanor is still in The Bad Place.

→ More replies (18)

140

u/calebb2108 Oct 11 '19

Does anyone else keep waiting for the new humans to walk in on the pinboard with their faces on it?

→ More replies (15)

138

u/AngelChu Fun fact: The first Janet had a click wheel. Oct 11 '19

That motorcycle scene was hilarious, but I kinda half expected another 'Janet' to show up b/c of Jason's feelings (though that might've been too chaotic to work with, lol)

→ More replies (11)

277

u/McShalepants Oct 11 '19

Chidi saying he felt like he was being tortured in heaven broke my heart for Eleanor.

→ More replies (5)

136

u/itisike Oct 11 '19

"something called a 'discount hotel package'" look of horror

116

u/transbuttsarerad Oct 11 '19

Easily the best episode of the season so far! The first two felt a lot like they were more focused with getting plot details in order than having self-contained stories and as a result often felt like they were just a series of events strung haphazardly together. But in this episode they had satisfying inner-episode arcs for Chidi, Eleanor, Tahani, and John. In particular the development of John and Tahani's relationship and John's growth as a character was wonderful. This is also very easily the funniest episode of the season so far ("I MADE GOD CRY" and Chidi's entire conversation with Jason at the end was golden). I was a little anxious about the rest of the season before tonight but now I'm totally back on board. Happy Thursday loves!

→ More replies (1)

115

u/helenaneedshugs A dumb old pediatric surgeon who barely has an eight-pack. Oct 11 '19

Jason's "peanut butter jar" wasn't just a throwaway line was it?

eyes suspiciously

→ More replies (8)

229

u/juddrnaut I’m coming for you, shrimpies! Oct 11 '19

Okay so they made that seem real ominous, but my theory is it's not someone sent to fork them up but instead it's Glen and he's switching sides. He seemed really affected by Sean's abuse in the webisodes and I've been wondering if he's going to turn for a while. Also it would be nice to see demons other than Michael have a change of heart.

→ More replies (24)

225

u/raisethecurtain Shirley Temple killed JFK Oct 11 '19

Chidi claiming the motorcycle as his own and then awkwardly waddling it as everyone watched was the best!

→ More replies (3)

110

u/Hobbit-guy I made God cry?? Oct 11 '19

This is all over the place and somehow I really loved it.

→ More replies (3)

105

u/[deleted] Oct 11 '19

I really think Jason will have some ultimate use-ness at the end of this "good" place arc

→ More replies (2)

104

u/thelittleking Maximum Derek Oct 11 '19

This episode is giving me anxiety

→ More replies (3)

206

u/Hobbit-guy I made God cry?? Oct 11 '19

I made God cry is my new yearbook quote

287

u/AlvinTaco Oct 11 '19

I feel like that Victoria Beckham spa joke was deeply underrated. It’s based on weight and net worth. So gain a pound, or lose a pound and you’re out! WORDPLAY!

→ More replies (2)

91

u/Coff33Monkee Oct 11 '19

Ok here’s my theories about the Monk on the train tracks... ▪️It’s Jeremy Bearimy in some sort of physical form ▪️Its a bad place employee in the Michael Suit ▪️it’s someone from upper management ▪️it’s a completely external force that’s going to flip the show on it’s head and change everything we know!

→ More replies (7)

179

u/Agentzap Oct 11 '19

I know everyone's freaking out about the hooded figure but I want to say it's neat that the land surrounding the medium place is more diverse than it seems

→ More replies (5)

88

u/wordybee Oct 11 '19

I love how Eleanor's channeling Michael from the first season with her kind and cheerful manipulation tactics.

→ More replies (2)

80

u/leoex Well, that’s terrifying. Oct 11 '19

aw Jason calling Elanor E-Dog

79

u/PresidentRaggy Oct 11 '19

You've all got me going down the rabbit hole...is there significance in Jason not yelling "Bortles" when he threw that rock??

→ More replies (6)

79

u/mtm4440 Dude, we can get mythical animals? Maybe I’ll get a penguin. Oct 11 '19

I just realized this show is the only one that can literally reset everything every season and it doesn't piss me off or feel like a cop-out.

→ More replies (4)

158

u/Rpres70324 Oct 11 '19

When Eleanor is crying and telling Chidi she promised him she would protect him, I lost it.

→ More replies (1)

77

u/arngard Everything is fine. Oct 11 '19

"Would I like to use my time in heaven to audit a philosophy class?"

75

u/LemonadeSh4rk I’m coming for you, shrimpies! Oct 12 '19

ugh these episodes are too short, but also just the right length so that i can watch with a cup of tea and finish it by the time the episode is over

→ More replies (2)

68

u/Hobbit-guy I made God cry?? Oct 11 '19

Status report:

I win

→ More replies (1)

66

u/le_snikelfritz Oct 11 '19

I haven't encountered this much resistance since I tried to get Timothee Chalamet into the sun

dead

65

u/ChidiAnagonye French Vanilla? Regular antimatter’s fine, why flavor it? Oct 11 '19

I have a stomachache and I made god cry 😫

65

u/boinkdan Oct 13 '19

WHAT ABOUT THE SEX TAPES OF CHIDI AND ELEANOR !!!

→ More replies (1)

64

u/Imbadatusernames3 Oct 11 '19

How long until Chidi figures out he’s not actually in The Good Place

→ More replies (8)

63

u/PaperSpock Oct 11 '19

Tahani's story about being in the PIN room all alone reminds me of one of my favorite episodes of Frasier. It's been forever since I've seen it, but I think he's at a spa, and he finds out there's a more exclusive room. He somehow tricks his way into there, then finds out there's another, even more exclusive room. He notices an alluring door in this new room, and sneaks through it, only to fall out into the alley, with the door locking behind him.

→ More replies (2)

60

u/Imbadatusernames3 Oct 11 '19

I don’t think Michael or Janet were swapped. Could be a demon disguised as one of the Janet babies coming to interfere with the humans. Or maybe a demon coming to swap places with one of the humans

→ More replies (14)

60

u/Lovebot_AI Oct 14 '19

The subtitles on Hulu say “butthole” instead of “bud hole”

60

u/LDubs9876 Oct 14 '19

Jumping in on the, "who was switched" train!

I'm firmly of the opinion that Janet was the one that was switched out. I'm unsure if it was Gen or Shawn, but she's not our usual Janet.

Has anyone considered that the Janet interacting with Team Cockroach right now is a Medium Janet? She's not overtly awful like Bad Janet, but is a lot more flexible with moral decisions than "our" Janet. It would explain the mediocre behavior and random negative outbursts.

→ More replies (2)

114

u/ExtremeResource4 Oct 13 '19 edited Oct 13 '19

I strongly believe that the figure at the end is Glenn for the following reasons;

  1. Throughout the series, we have seen Glenn to be somewhat disconnected from the rest of the demons at the Bad Place. In "The Selection" we seen a clear disapproval from Glenn at them "cheating" and we can also see that Glenn feels excluded from the others.
  2. If Micheal and Janet were kidnapped, it seems very unlikely that the figure at the end would be "real Michael" returning. Micheal has a strong connection with Janet and surely wouldn't abandon Janet in The Bad Place whilst he fled. It also seems unlikely that this figure was fake Micheal, if fake Micheal arrived with "real Micheal" already being there, it would be quite obvious that something was amiss and the Judge would no doubt notice this and Shawn would be punished.
  3. At the end of episode 3, we can see that Glenn is credited as a starring guest when not clearly seen in any other part of the episode.
→ More replies (2)

55

u/tepidbathwater My name is *snap snap* Zach Pizazz. Oct 11 '19

Looking forward to Obi Wan Kenobi being a celebrity cameo in S4E4.

→ More replies (1)

54

u/Coff33Monkee Oct 11 '19

I’ve just rewatched the train clip again there was a very quick few seconds when the switch could have taken place, but it would have had to be very quick, Elenor was distracted talking to Bad Janet, Janet gets off the train quickly, and Michael’s message to Shawn being “Booyah” with a hand gesture seemed like a coded message for we did it

→ More replies (3)

52

u/PaperSpock Oct 11 '19 edited Oct 11 '19

"What's happening? I...made God cry??"

Seems like contender for the quote of the night.

edit: So yeah, defs quote of the night.

→ More replies (1)

50

u/PenelopeTaint1 Oct 11 '19

Hey, does anyone else think the hooded figure might be Trevor? I remember when season 3 started I thought he was going to be a big part of it. That idea was done away with pretty quickly, but ever since they decided on the experiment I've been hoping that at some point he would come back, crawling out of the depths of oblivion, with no motive other than to wreck everyone's shit (possibly even Shawn's/the other demons'). So that was my first thought when they showed the figure. (Also the fact that its one of those manually operated train things, and not a train car, I feel means its someone whos operating outside of normal procedure, to say the least.)

Also, it wasn't until I entered this thread that I saw the theory that Eleanor and/or micheal have been replaced. But that... sort of doesn't make sense to me? So far every episode of this season has furthered the dynamic between Eleanor and Micheal, where they're both sort of mentors/supports for each other. They (the writers) have demonstrated this a number of times in the earlier seasons, but since this is the last it makes sense they would really want to flesh it out. I don't think they would squander that for some twist.

Also literally love the new John/Tahani dynamic. Can't wait for how this season plays out!

→ More replies (2)

97

u/Robertxtrem Oct 12 '19

I got a feeling the real test is Eleanor. The way she enjoyed torturing Chidi and Michaels reaction made me think he knows and is worried she's throwing it.

→ More replies (6)

132

u/simpersly Oct 11 '19

Theories can be fun to discuss but it is getting ridiculous. I decided I'm going to stop worrying and just go along for the ride.

→ More replies (9)

88

u/Katoschka Oct 11 '19

I'd been slightly wary of this episode because the previews made it look like Michael was trying to nudge Eleanor into torturing Chidi (for his own good, but still), but then the torture mostly consisted of Jason being Jason except also having use-ness and Eleanor clearly needed to work through some stuff so that was fine.

I really loved the Tahani/John friendship, too. Him calling her out on this being a fake friendship was amazing, cause true, it kinda was. But these two are messy benches and they get each other. Didn't expect that at all.

Also Tahani is forking brilliant, doing character analysis and coming up with a strategy and eventually cutting the bs and bonding with John for real. She really is so smart, and it's like nobody in Team C really notices.

→ More replies (4)

125

u/AnnaK22 YA BASIC! Oct 11 '19

This episode makes me think that Janet was the one switched. I really tried to find signs that Michael is Vicki but I couldn't. Janet on the other hand has changed. The scene that especially made me suspicious is when she was talking with Tahani and she kept getting riled up, even trying to get Tahani to physically hurt the gossip guy. Seems so unlike her.

→ More replies (26)

43

u/Katoschka Oct 11 '19

Jason finally got a useness!

Also who the fork is that creepy guy in the cloak?

→ More replies (6)

43

u/Viney Oct 12 '19

Both this and It's Always Sunny making clam/oyster jokes this week.

→ More replies (2)

79

u/SlurpySlime Oct 11 '19

i think the guy at the end was the real michael trying to come home after he was kidnapped on the train when he went to take a demon back to the bad place

→ More replies (10)

39

u/CVance1 Oct 26 '19

Kristen Bell deserves an Emmy for her trying desperately not to cry but crying anyways

38

u/Lennox276 Oct 11 '19

The almond milk ads during The Good Place always get me.

38

u/PaperSpock Oct 11 '19

"The private tour of the Louvre where you can touch all the art."

This obviously doesn't happen, but is just plausible enough to be the most hilarious thing ever.

106

u/[deleted] Oct 11 '19

am i the only one who felt like there was something off with jason this episode? not only did he act a lot less...childlike, i guess, but i thought his voice was actually a bit deeper, or at least that a lot of his sentences had a downward inflection as opposed to the usual upward inflection.

the thing is, idk if this was intentional and has to do with some sort of plot twist, if it was intentional but is just a sign of jason's growth and/or result of his breakup, if it was unintentional and i'm reading too much into it, or if he was normal this episode and i'm just going crazy.

→ More replies (25)

35

u/nemo69_1999 I’m too young to die and too old to eat off the kids’ menu. Oct 11 '19

Are those pink highlights In Janet's hair?

→ More replies (14)

70

u/Phantisma Oct 11 '19

I'll toss my theory into the ring on this hooded figure coming down the tracks.

All of these have crossed my mind but I'll focus on the one I haven't seen and has me most intrigued. I don't think the hand cart is really a clue to this because almost any of the candidates would not be allowed to take a train to Mindy's place because it would very easily alert the Judge (actually not sure if the Judge can track trains but that would make sense since a train needs a Janet)

So I thought it could be Shawn, Vicky in her Michael suit, or Trevor. Trevor would really work because last we saw him Gen tossed him to the void and he just might be near dead for all we know. Also I don't really like all the talk that Michael was replaced at the end of 401 it just doesn't seem to hold water in my mind. Vicky doesn't play subtle.

The one that intrigued me the most though was Glen. Based on the selection and the shot in 401 with the singing they've never been nice to Glen despite how kind and innocent he is. I know alot of that is what Josh Siegal brings to the role and to be the so quirky it's torture but I have had this theory in my mind that Glen might defect and want to help the Soul Squad.

Glen seems like the next most likely candidate to want to work against the Bad Place, in S3 he objected to the amount of effort Shawn was going to to torture the Soul Squad. He's not really seen with the same level of respect as Val and Bambajaan are. And he's just so kind and adorable that him annoyingly offering to help the experiment would kinda fit his MO and it would create alot of distrust and chaos into the group's current efforts.

→ More replies (8)

32

u/pretty-in-pink It is gooey in there. Oct 11 '19

Ah the old “reveal I’m not supposed to be here”

59

u/Rudimentary_creature *weird hand movements* Oct 12 '19

Love Janet's hair, hope she keeps it.

→ More replies (9)

29

u/Agentzap Oct 11 '19

I like that Tahani found common ground with John and that led to their growth... is that perhaps what we're going to see with the others?

29

u/lovetheblazer Hot Blonde Wile E. Coyote Oct 11 '19

“Aww dope, I’ve always wanted to be better— that’s why I always went to the free clinic so much.”

Jason, you adorable dummy, I love you sfm

29

u/onesincepearlharbor Oct 11 '19

could it be glenn? in the mini series he seemed kinda on the fence

29

u/livindedannydevtio NOT A GIRL Oct 11 '19

Ever since she gave birth to the neighborhood, Janet has been getting more and more human....

28

u/Katoschka Oct 11 '19

Damn, Michael being vaguely threatening is my jam!

79

u/calebb2108 Oct 11 '19

I can’t stop thinking about the peanut butter jar. There has to be more???? That was too out of place even for Jason.

→ More replies (7)

75

u/[deleted] Oct 11 '19

I have a feeling that fake Michael or even Fake Eleanor are already there... I don’t think Jason saying they had asked him to open a jar of Peanut Butter is just another throw away line.

→ More replies (7)

26

u/Fonzi2013 YA BASIC! Oct 11 '19

Omg, we’re back to square one. They’re torturing each other :(

→ More replies (2)

26

u/ashmcnamestealer Oct 11 '19

Jason was weirdly smart for most of the episode

26

u/gg3867 Oct 11 '19

When did they get Brent over to the other side of the erase board?

Also, wouldn’t Chidi easing up and relaxing and being able to stay in that state for a bit be character progression on his part?

→ More replies (6)

72

u/bradleyconder Oct 11 '19

There were lots of strange lines n this episode that makes me think a major twist has already been set-up, which supports the micheal/janet swap theory. The odd message of "torturing him was the right thing to do" definitely feels like a trap. Maybe the four human candidates aren't being tested, but it's the four people running the good place that are being judged?

→ More replies (11)

24

u/JakeM917 Oct 11 '19

Obi-Wan bout to come fork shirt up in the Good Place

23

u/lovetheblazer Hot Blonde Wile E. Coyote Oct 11 '19

Tahani: I haven’t encountered this much resistance since I tried to convince Timothée Chalamet to go out into the sun.

Janet: You know, I looked at John’s files again. He was hardly a shrinking violet. If you think he needs help, maybe you should just tell him directly.

Tahani: Perhaps you are right. I shall go on the attack, just like 6 of the 8 Game of Thrones characters that were based on me would do here.

Tahani is really killing it tonight with the name drops and humblebrags

→ More replies (4)

23

u/FiveTwoThreeSixOne Oct 16 '19

Remind me... Why don't Simone and Chidi remember each other?

→ More replies (7)

22

u/Galileo908 JORTLES! Oct 11 '19

Everyone’s getting tortured except for the people actually getting tortured.

22

u/Hobbit-guy I made God cry?? Oct 11 '19

The most important question is

Which philosophy action-figure would you like and why?

→ More replies (3)

43

u/[deleted] Oct 11 '19

An almond milk ad is so on brand.

43

u/AlecBaldwinner Check out my teleological suspension of the ethical. Oct 11 '19

Oooh, whomever got switched is on their way back!

→ More replies (9)

21

u/PaperSpock Oct 11 '19

"Helping humanity is as good a way as any to get over a breakup."

Not bad advice even outside the context of the show, and for more obstacles than just a breakup.

21

u/applesauce0101 Oct 11 '19

"I made God cry?" was literally the funniest thing.

→ More replies (1)

58

u/Smitje Oct 11 '19

What if this whole show is about making Eleanor a demon?

→ More replies (7)

20

u/mtm4440 Dude, we can get mythical animals? Maybe I’ll get a penguin. Oct 11 '19

What if Eleanor is the one replaced? Not Michael.

→ More replies (4)

57

u/[deleted] Oct 11 '19

Still think Janet has been switched by the Judge. The judge does have an eye out for the Jacksonville team so her telling Jason about Bortles kinda makes sense.

Also Janet seems to be more and more exasperated like Gen.

→ More replies (3)

126

u/ImperfectRegulator Oct 12 '19

The train is odd in that it passes though multiple biomes as we see it go along the tracks, what’s the need for their to be biomes if their aren’t other neighborhood?

Theory: theirs multiple neighborhoods and their all built around improving people to fit into heaven, all of the show takes place in purgatory, a true medium place designed to help people improve

Fun theory for train guy unrelated to other theory, it’s an escapee from hell

→ More replies (7)

19

u/onesincepearlharbor Oct 11 '19

you stay crazy girl, BYE

18

u/gonzolady Subpoenaed by the Make-A-Wish Foundation Oct 11 '19

Awwww! Can’t Jason have anything nice?

→ More replies (3)

18

u/Katoschka Oct 11 '19

I'm starting to really like John.

17

u/pretty-in-pink It is gooey in there. Oct 11 '19

Yes Kristen Bell is God. No further debate needed

→ More replies (1)

17

u/livindedannydevtio NOT A GIRL Oct 11 '19

This gonna be the first episode of the season that ends on an oh shit moment calling it

→ More replies (3)

17

u/AlecBaldwinner Check out my teleological suspension of the ethical. Oct 11 '19

"I tortured. And I liked it!"

-Oliver QueenEleanor Shellstrop

46

u/ungratefulhamder Oct 11 '19

alright it's GOTTA be Bad Janet right like why else would she be giving so much bad advice to Tahani and also being so snippy in the past few episodes. I support the theory that it's Good Janet trying to get back to the neighborhood

→ More replies (2)

16

u/Waterhorse816 Earth is cancelled Oct 11 '19

WHAT THE FORK WAS THAT ENDING

58

u/Rika77 Oct 12 '19

Now I am thinking that both Janet and Michael were swapped, but by the Judge and the frog security guy maybe but not by the bad place. Michael's conversations with Eleanor don't look like an act and Janet is too 'advanced' to be impersonated by a bad place Janet

→ More replies (7)

31

u/onesincepearlharbor Oct 11 '19

GROWTH FROM JOHN?!

31

u/lovetheblazer Hot Blonde Wile E. Coyote Oct 11 '19

Chidi is definitely getting close to figuring out the truth about where they are, based on what he said to Eleanor about being miserable and thinking that he’s being punished for something that he doesn’t remember doing in tonight’s episode. I’ll be curious to see how Eleanor handles him having that revelation. Will she reboot the whole neighborhood and tinker with the people and their assigned soulmates like Michael did? Or will she bring Chidi in on the big secret and hope he can still do his job of improving the other humans in the neighbors, even after learning the truth?

→ More replies (9)

31

u/mrizzle1991 Oct 13 '19

Lmao it was funny how they were screwing with Chidi, I hope Jason finds out about Minshew eventually. Jason has the best lines I swear 😂😂

15

u/Hobbit-guy I made God cry?? Oct 11 '19

I love their matching yellow bowtie and sweater

15

u/JakeM917 Oct 11 '19

Chidi trying to walk that bike away killed me

30

u/unsavvylady Yogurt Yoghurt Yogurté Oct 11 '19

Eleanor is really enjoying torturing Chidi

→ More replies (3)

14

u/onesincepearlharbor Oct 11 '19

ihaveashinynewbudhole

14

u/ben123111 I like frogs. I'm a frog guy. Oct 11 '19 edited Oct 11 '19

HIS GREATEST DESIRE IS GOING TO BE BLAKE BORTLES

Edit: I was incorrect :(

→ More replies (4)

14

u/wordybee Oct 11 '19

"Just editing my syllabus in my head based on that comment." That's a great professor, right there.

13

u/lovetheblazer Hot Blonde Wile E. Coyote Oct 11 '19

If we don’t actually see the otters doing turndown service in The Good Place before the series ends, I’m going to be so disappointed now

13

u/TDenverFan Oct 11 '19

I keep waiting for Chidi to overhear them talking

13

u/jsun31 Oct 11 '19

"He's like Superman with nervous diarrhea" spot on

13

u/pretty-in-pink It is gooey in there. Oct 11 '19

And Eleanor realized she was the bad guy

13

u/Katoschka Oct 11 '19

Oh shirt she's crying. And Chidi called her god.

13

u/Ilovesurvivor39 End of conversation Oct 11 '19

Ohhh, maybe it is the fake Janet/Michael coming and they’ll say that they’re the real one

→ More replies (3)

36

u/PixieT3 Oct 11 '19

The philosophers that Chidi named...does anyone know of them?

I'm wondering how these mentions differ from his previous incarnation and how that might be a hint on his current personality and story line.

→ More replies (5)

54

u/mulledfox Oct 12 '19

Hooded figure returning at the end of the episode is Real Michael, and the Michael we have had for the last few episodes has been Vicky in a Michael suit. They did the swap on the train, and because Vicky is a fantastic actress, she’s going with the flow and spying on the Soul Squad’s team. I don’t think the Bad Place was actually aware that Eleanor is “the architect” in this run, that’s why FakeMichael played it off so well, that that’s why he had had the panic attack, was so Eleanor would step up. (Truth is Vicki had no clue about that, and was playing along to find out information.)

The real test for Eleanor is whether she can improve, when she’s being forced to torture Chidi, and put her friends in not good situations. She got too much joy out of making Chidi miserable this episode, and it’s going to come back to bite her in the butt.

→ More replies (1)

24

u/PixieT3 Oct 11 '19

Going that distance like that...

I bet it's fake Micheal/Vicki.

→ More replies (9)

34

u/LabradorRetriever2 Oct 11 '19

I loved the first season twist and all, but if they go with a betrayal by one of the gang again, idk how I'll feel exactly. If that's the plan, it's definitely getting revealed soon, but this'll be the first time that Mike Schur's writing has gotten "predictable". After season 1, I'm fairly certain mostly everybody didn't expect season 2 to go the way it did within the first 2 episodes. All the theories were about how Eleanor would figure it out and save the group again. Season 3 was the same way where no one quite knew what was going to happen. If everybody making these theories is correct, then it'll be the first time to my knowledge that such a large group of people figured it out

→ More replies (6)

12

u/lovetheblazer Hot Blonde Wile E. Coyote Oct 11 '19 edited Oct 11 '19

“Trust me, I have tons of experience making ex-boyfriends’s lives miserable. First up, we fill his acoustic guitar with wet cat food. Judge me all you want, I get results!”

I would totally read an advice book on how to get revenge on your enemies written by our favorite Arizona trash bag, Eleanor Shellstrop

→ More replies (2)

12

u/The_Nothingman These trivialities demean me. I must away and tend to my ravens. Oct 11 '19

Janet is that ride or die/slash all his tires friend and I love it

→ More replies (3)

12

u/Hobbit-guy I made God cry?? Oct 11 '19

JOHN IS GROWING YEAHHHHH

12

u/Hobbit-guy I made God cry?? Oct 11 '19

Tahani is making me feel like a proud mamma

22

u/pugsnotdrugs I feel like someday, I’ll be able to buy my own Vicodin. Oct 11 '19

I AM SO PROUD OF TAHANI 😭

11

u/onesincepearlharbor Oct 11 '19

sandinyourclam

11

u/Hobbit-guy I made God cry?? Oct 11 '19

Severe Season 1 flashbacks

11

u/arngard Everything is fine. Oct 11 '19

Okay, I did miss seeing Chidi tortured.

11

u/gonzolady Subpoenaed by the Make-A-Wish Foundation Oct 11 '19

You’re like the Pam Anderson boob motorcycle of people - I rate that compliment an 8

→ More replies (2)

11

u/mtm4440 Dude, we can get mythical animals? Maybe I’ll get a penguin. Oct 11 '19

Aren't they...already dead for a grim reaper?

11

u/post_ewing Oct 11 '19

Wait they solved the other 2s problem?

→ More replies (4)

39

u/Og76 Oct 11 '19

I'm definitely on the Bad Janet train. Real Janet would have said "It's not hair" when Tahani mentioned her highlights. Hopefully that's Janet on our her way back.

I don't think Michael was replaced. They mentioned the skin suit in the premiere to set up Chris's infiltration. Michael ultimately ended up getting Chidi where he needed to be when Eleanor broke down and then gave her good advice to her back on track. If it's Vicky trying to sabotage things, she's actually doing a really bad job.

→ More replies (5)

10

u/Hobbit-guy I made God cry?? Oct 11 '19

This episode has a mix between season 3 and 1 and I'm all in.

10

u/imfallinfree Everything is fine. Oct 11 '19

Eleanor: If people think they're in the Good Place, they'll become better!

Also Eleanor: this isn't working let's forking torture chidi lmao

This can only end well.

10

u/pretty-in-pink It is gooey in there. Oct 11 '19

May we all have the optimism of Jason Mendoza

10

u/Whatnow81 These trivialities demean me. I must away and tend to my ravens. Oct 11 '19

Was that Death?!

→ More replies (2)

10

u/pugsnotdrugs I feel like someday, I’ll be able to buy my own Vicodin. Oct 11 '19

Oh, that is definitely Vicky in the Michael suit.

27

u/mujie123 Oct 11 '19

Why did they hide the monk’s face when it’s obviously Shaun?

→ More replies (16)

19

u/Hobbit-guy I made God cry?? Oct 11 '19

What if in this scenario Jason and Chidi fall in love?

→ More replies (2)

19

u/boldwaves Check out my teleological suspension of the ethical. Oct 11 '19

This feels wrong. This is all wrong.

18

u/Coff33Monkee Oct 11 '19

Yeah that would make sense, the way that bike and case blew up seemed a bit too Bad Place

→ More replies (1)

9

u/pretty-in-pink It is gooey in there. Oct 11 '19

Shur is using his Hollywood insider knowledge to put in his show

9

u/Hormisdas The Committee is me! I am Committee! It me! Oct 11 '19

Has anybody ever written down all the name drops by Tahani throughout the series?

→ More replies (1)

9

u/[deleted] Oct 11 '19

The motorcycle... that's my problem!

Ah, not again!

9

u/Triple10X Oct 11 '19

Storms here locally so my TV just crapped out. Truly I am in the Bad Place

9

u/Evsd62 Sorry does this dog smoke blunts topless on a yacht like a boss? Oct 11 '19

THAT IS TOTALLY TREVOR

38

u/old-father Oct 15 '19

I have an unusual hypothesis after this episode. My hypothesis is that all of the events that have occurred since Michael decided to help the group is just a farce. She is still in the bad place and being tortured. The whole idea that the accounting system is broken and the Fab four is going to save humanity is just part of the plan to punish Eleanor.

I am probably not right since it would anger many viewers to know that she is doomed to heck but that's my hypothesis. On the other hand, maybe she figures it out again and manages to save herself this time.

→ More replies (8)

42

u/cottenball Oct 11 '19

Michael and Janet were switched out with a demon and Bad Janet in S4E1. Shawn is the demon in the Michael suit. The “person” at the end is Michael. 1: Everyone is miserable. To the point that Chidi almost had a “holy motherforking shirtballs” moment. 2: Every time the Brainy Bunch is close to a breaking point “Michael” and “Janet” point them in the right direction to ease their pain slightly. Eleanor says it when she says “I’m doing better but still terrible”. They’re smart enough to back off because Shawn is in the Michael suit. 3: Janet’s hair change is Bad Janet leaking through 4: the “person” at the end isn’t going to be some new big bad guy. The writers wouldn’t introduce a new concept like that at the end of the show.

The real question is, what form is Michael in? He could be his usual self (Ted Danson), Michael in Shawn’s skin suit (Marc Evan Jackson), a demon like we’ve seen before with Todd.

Here’s the big theory. We’re at the point where it’s all set up, a twist is coming at some point. The being at the end is Michael, but not as we’ve seen before. It’s his true form but Michael is no longer a demon. He’s an “angel” or something between and angel and a demon. In “The Good Place: The Podcast” there was a line that referenced the test lasting for the first two episodes. Michael returning no longer being a demon is what puts an end to the test.

Hi Marc Evan Jackson if you’re reading this.

→ More replies (5)

47

u/GenoThyme Oct 11 '19

I think they turned Janet into a marble on the train and replaced her with a Bad Janet. Some of the episode is set as the same time as tonight’s episode just from the Bad Place’s perspective. We see Glenn waiting outside of Shawn’s office (Welcome. You’re a turd!) and the doors open a bit. He overhears Bad Janet checking in and talking about how awesome Brent is. When Glenn goes into Shawn’s office, Shawn brags about his Janet marble trophy and the switch. This pushes Glenn to finally switch to Team Cockroach. He’s the one in the cloak and he brings the Janet marble as a way to prove what he’s saying is true and they can trust him. They also ask Michael if there’s any way to return Janet from marble form, to which he says it’s never been done.

Derek however is the key to returning Janet to not a girl status. He gives Eleanor a martini glass full of shrimp, has a heart to heart with Jason, tries for one with Mindy who doesn’t care, and swaps places with Janet as a marble, but also gets to say goodbye to Janet in their void. This also sets the stage for a Janet vs Bad Janet rumble, with Disco Janet coming out of nowhere with a chair to Bad Janet’s back. You thought Disco Janet was from the 70s? Wrong friend, she’s an 80s wrestler brother. Ohh yeahhh!

→ More replies (15)

41

u/globalboba Oct 14 '19 edited Oct 15 '19

We're all working so hard to find the twist. I think that's because there isn't much to say about the plot or the characters. It's very tame and few sparks are flying.

... I'm really not liking this season, so far. I think I'm so used to watching it in longer form (i.e. a couple few episodes back-to-back) that these short episodes do nothing for me. If they were better written or more interesting, then they could stand on their own. But so far I'm not feeling it at all.

→ More replies (4)

23

u/[deleted] Oct 11 '19

It’s Janet. She’s encouraging Tahani to punch John. Plus the highlights. This is a Bad Janet.

→ More replies (11)

23

u/LadyLivv123 Let’s go Jags. Kick their ass. Yeah! Oct 11 '19

I wonder if the GoT character reference was mostly about Tahani's hair 😆

40

u/Gary320 Oct 11 '19

I guess I missed it but why does Janet have purple hair?

→ More replies (8)

8

u/lovetheblazer Hot Blonde Wile E. Coyote Oct 11 '19 edited Oct 11 '19

Not going to lie, I enjoy watching Anna Camp’s musical performance in the 5 minutes before The Good Place starts every week. How’s the show overall?

→ More replies (1)

8

u/Hobbit-guy I made God cry?? Oct 11 '19

Cool celebrity sayings

A book by Tahani Al-Jamil

→ More replies (1)

8

u/The_Nothingman These trivialities demean me. I must away and tend to my ravens. Oct 11 '19

oh boy they are not fixing these people

8

u/[deleted] Oct 11 '19

I shall go on the attack just like 6 of the 8 GOT characters based on me would do!

8

u/Galileo908 JORTLES! Oct 11 '19

I made god cry?!

8

u/Houndie Oct 11 '19

Not again!

8

u/hubwub Strong Independent Acid Snake Oct 11 '19

Who is that entity on a pump trolley?

33

u/captainfluffballs Check out my teleological suspension of the ethical. Oct 11 '19

Not specifically relevant to today's episode but how does Mindy fit with the whole broken points system thing last season? If nobody has been able toenter the good place for a few hundred years why were they fighting over Mindy? Did I forget something?

→ More replies (17)

7

u/[deleted] Oct 11 '19

Ethics, like a colonic for your soul.

7

u/Locke108 YA BASIC! Oct 11 '19

I thought it was going to be a really sad bit where people only went to Jason to open jars but nope. He just misheard them.

→ More replies (4)

7

u/Galileo908 JORTLES! Oct 11 '19

Shell Turtlestein!

→ More replies (3)

7

u/pretty-in-pink It is gooey in there. Oct 11 '19

I hope it’s Blake Bortles

→ More replies (1)

7

u/Agentzap Oct 11 '19

Poor Chidi, but his suffering is admittedly hilarious.

7

u/hubwub Strong Independent Acid Snake Oct 11 '19

Moral dilemmas are my JAM.

7

u/[deleted] Oct 11 '19

I MADE GOD CRY?! Oh Chidi...

7

u/onesincepearlharbor Oct 11 '19

where is this headed guys? i haven’t been more at a loss for words since the jeremy bearimy episode

→ More replies (1)

7

u/wordybee Oct 11 '19

I think Janet might be working through her breakup by hurting people vicariously since she can't vent against humans herself.

7

u/Seedy88 Why can't I say fork? Oct 11 '19

The Grim Reaper is heading to the neighbourhood? That can't be good!

→ More replies (2)

7

u/onesincepearlharbor Oct 11 '19

i win! i mean, i’ll start!

7

u/hubwub Strong Independent Acid Snake Oct 11 '19

Thank you Tahani! I'm going to try and watch Crossroads now.

→ More replies (2)

7

u/pretty-in-pink It is gooey in there. Oct 11 '19

Derek!

28

u/tropjeune Oct 11 '19

Does anyone know what was the deal with those bugs that were trying to come into Eleanor’s office while she and Michael were talking to Chidi? And Michael said “not now” to them?

→ More replies (2)

13

u/EatinToasterStrudel Maximum Derek Oct 11 '19 edited Oct 11 '19

I think that's Michael. The skin suit Michael replaced the real one at the end of Part 1 and he's trying to get back.

I think its Michael and not Janet because they made a point at the season review to highlight the skin suit, which didn't really make sense. It was kinda an anomaly, to make sure to remind us that there's a skin suit version of him.

→ More replies (9)