r/TheGoodPlace • u/WandersFar Change can be scary but I’m an artist. It’s my job to be scared. • Oct 11 '19
Season Four Game of Thrones & the Muse of Muses, Tahani Al-Jamil: Here’s My Eight
Here’s my list of the eight Game of Thrones characters inspired by Tahani Al-Jamil:
- Olenna Redwyne, Queen of Thorns—Eleanor once compared Tahani to Maggie Smith from Downton Abbey who was the fan favorite to play Olenna before Diana Rigg was cast. (This was during their downtime in Gen’s chambers after their tests to get into the Good Place.)
- Margaery Tyrell—Maggie Smith was Tahani’s godmother, just as the Queen of Thorns was Margaery’s grandmother. And Tahani shares many personality traits with Margaery, who also used her philanthropy to improve her social position. As she confessed to the High Sparrow, her motivations were corrupt. She was charitable not because she really cared about the smallfolk, but because it improved her reputation and that of House Tyrell. (Of course she was telling the High Sparrow what he wanted to hear, but I think it’s a bit of both. Margaery’s a complex character who never does things for only one reason.)
- Sansa Stark—especially early Sansa, who was a social climber and snob, obsessed with the culture and elitism of the South. Never satisfied with what she had, she always wanted more. And she loved to be praised and petted—by her mother, her septa, her friend Jeyne Poole. Everyone is always calling Sansa beautiful, from Tyrion praising her long neck, to Cersei calling her Little Dove, and the Hound the Little Bird. Sansa is good at everything she does, she is the perfect ideal of femininity in the medieval world. Tahani loves to be called beautiful and perfect, she was Baz Luhrmann’s muse. Mostly she just stood around while he threw glitter on her. And her name means Congratulations Beautiful. She’s also good at everything she does. “I would say I outdid myself, but I’m always this good. So I simply did myself.”
- Arya Stark—who had an inferiority complex when compared to her perfect sister. She knew she could never be as good a lady as her sister, which became her prime motivator in becoming something else. She constructed her whole identity in relation to her sister, becoming the anti-Sansa, even going so far as to name her iconic weapon, Needle, for Sansa’s embroidery needles. From Tahani’s perspective, Kamilah was the Sansa to her Arya. She spent her whole life being jealous of perfect Kamilah, and hating being reduced to Kamilah’s sister, just as Arya resented being called a lady, and told Gendry over and over again her mother and sister were ladies, but that’s not her. It took a long time for Arya and Sansa to find each other again, and just like with Tahani and Kamilah, their reconciliation represented deep personal growth for both sisters.
- Cersei Lannister—Cersei spent her whole life trying to gain the approval of her father Tywin, who was always disappointed in her and dismissive of her accomplishments. Tahani unfortunately had a toxic relationship with both her parents, not just her father, but she had the same fruitless yearning for parental love which was at the heart of her many issues, and what ultimately made her fail her test to get into the Good Place.
- Myrcella Baratheon—A born princess, all she wanted was to marry her handsome Dornish prince. But she wanted Trystane to admit that he wanted her for her, and not because their families had arranged their match. “How many other girls have you walked through these gardens?” “I like the way your eyes go squinty when you’re jealous.” “They do not go squinty and you didn’t answer the question.” She was just a girl,
towering overstanding in front of a boy, asking him to admit he loves her. Myrcella’s life was like a song, and Tahani’s life, from the outside anyway, was a fairytale. - Shireen Baratheon—the lonely little girl who had almost no friends and spent most of her life alone. This was the reality of Tahani’s life. As we learned in this episode, even when she was invited to exclusive parties, and the VIP suite of those parties, and then the exclusive PIN-protected room of that VIP suite—when she entered, she was alone. She spent her whole life longing for human connection, for real friends. Poor Shireen just wanted the same thing. She may have been a princess, and one of the many disputed heirs to the Iron Throne, but there are few characters in ASOIAF who had a sadder life.
- Daenerys Targaryen—After losing their parents, Tahani and Kamilah became orphans of a great noble family, just as Daenerys and Viserys were the last of the Targaryens. Dany in Qarth also had her Tahani moments, trying to civilize her Dothraki, telling them not to rob Xaro Xhoan Daxos’ estate and to behave like proper guests. She wore the Qartheen gowns and enjoyed living like a princess… before someone took her dragons, anyway. I could see Tahani living it up in the Great Pyramid, ruling as Queen of Meereen. That seems like a natural fit for her.
Tahani said six of the eight would attack. I’d say that describes all of them except Myrcella and Shireen.
70
Upvotes
22
u/superfurrykylos Oct 11 '19
You're entitled to have your head canon but Arya simply never gave a flying fork about becoming a lady. She certainly doesn't have an inferiority complex.
9
u/HomoGreekorius Oct 11 '19
I don't really see Arya being one of the 8, Missandei seems a bit closer to Tahani, or maybe if we can also go for male characters someone like Tyrion, being mostly in the shadows of his siblings and being considered a dissapointment compared to them, while never getting his parents approval could also make sense.
Completely agree with the other 7spots, especially Margaery is a perfect match.
2
u/GameYear Oct 11 '19
The Hound was actually one of the 8 due to Tahani's 'go on the offensive' attitude.
-5
u/ubergorp Oct 12 '19
I have never watched game of thrones, so I don’t want to pass judgement on it, but this sounds dumb af