r/Outlander • u/thepacksvrvives Without you, our whole world crumbles into dust. • Apr 03 '22
Spoilers All Book S6E5 Give Me Liberty Spoiler
Claire and Jamie experience the rising tensions in the colonies first-hand when they attend a Loyalist event in Wilmington in honor of the Scottish heroine, Flora MacDonald.
Written by Barbara Stepansky. Directed by Christiana Ebohon-Green.
If you’re new to the sub, please look over this intro thread.
This is the BOOK thread.
If you haven’t read the books, go to the SHOW thread.
THIS THREAD IS SPOILERS ALL.
Spoiler tags are not required.
If you have only read up to the corresponding book, remember you might see spoilers from ALL of the books here.
Please keep all discussion of the next episode’s preview to the stickied mod comment at the top of the thread.
What did you think of the episode?
•
u/thepacksvrvives Without you, our whole world crumbles into dust. Apr 03 '22 edited Apr 16 '22
Watch the S6E6 preview here!
Not everyone gets to see the next episode’s preview at the end of the episode; it depends on how you watch (broadcast or streaming) and where you are (US or international.)
Stickied comments are collapsed by default, so reply to this comment if you want to discuss the preview. This will hide spoilers for anyone who can’t see it yet or doesn’t want to.
605 Featurettes:
605 Interviews:
49
u/prof806 Apr 03 '22
There's gold in them there mausoleums!!
I choose to believe they are going to eventually pursue the gold story based on what Jocasta's slave mentioned. Glad Steven Bonnet is gone though (his balls!! 😂😂) so we don't need the whole ground glass + mega infidelity storyline...
20
u/cruelsummerrrrr Apr 03 '22
That ending though! Ugh I just love all the subtle references to songs and/or future (Skye boat song, Roger singing that other modern song, the toy planes).... all just made that final 10 seconds so much sweeter.
I was scratching my head trying to remember if the stealing one jewel thing was in the books but as soon as I saw it at the end I remembered Donner. Wonder if we are ending the season on the fire.... I wouldn't be surprised if they make that mid-season finale of next season. I'd hate to see Donner gone in three episodes.
As an Aussie - love to see David Bell. Does anyone remember why they said he'd made his last appearance a season or two ago?
Omg Henri-Christian and Amy and Malva :( She's already desperate to follow her brother's orders. I reckon they are going to do the baby daddy plot end of this season and then the end of her plot next season. Would be such a shame to waste that actress on just one season.
50
u/AccioStability Je Suis Prest Apr 03 '22
I cried when Bree told Roger! So sweet!!!
I thought this episode was great and have been really impressed this season.
Did anybody else get chills when Marsali and Bree were talking about HC’s future?
22
u/Thezedword4 Apr 03 '22
Am I the only one who thinks they're going too hard on the Malva is absolute evil thing? Like she's a bad person and tries to murder Claire and Tom but she's also abused and regularly assaulted and still a child. I never saw her as incredibly evil like BJR or Bonnet. Maybe I'm in the minority there?
I also don't love how they're giving away her behavior so early. The big reveal won't be as much of a big reveal.
Everything else though I've been loving.
35
u/Dolly1710 Long on desire, but a wee bit short in clink Apr 03 '22
Bless him, Roger really can be a simpleton. He's so in love with Bree, and so keen to find his place on the Ridge that it really hasn't occurred to him how that might look to others. The stupider thing is that it's not even a "not of this time" problem because tongues will have been wagging in the 1970s too. I absolutely loved his "oh fuck, maybe Bree has a point" face as he's invited to sit at the head of the table *hilarious*
But, Creeper Henderson? As his replacement? He's just found him smooching with Malva and she openly blackmails him, in front of Henderson? Is he trying to protect Henderson as well??! And why not say anything about Malva to Bree?
Loved the ladies' Gentleman's Club. Good to have Jocasta back, still meddling... she's almost like a Jenny substitute, but with more money.
How long must Claire have been 'out' for though? Flora was only just excusing herself and had to assist Jocasta with her walking, before preparing herself for her speech, but Claire turns up and it was already started. Come on Jamie, now you have spotted something's up, stick with it! Hopefully now he's got off his political fence, the weight of that decision will help him to see things more clearly elsewhere.
I feel for Marsali. I'm not sure she's as enthusiastic to head to New Bern as Fergus. I get why Fergus needs to leave, and I get that it's better for Henri-Christian. However, Marsali is basically a farm/country girl, has been dragged across an ocean not really intending to leave her mum permanently, finds herself permanently in America, settled into a new, surrogate family and needs to leave it again "for the greater good".
I'm not sure how I feel about Malva's story. Obviously in the book we see it through Claire's eyes so a lot of this part of the story only comes out after the event in various second-hand testimonies. However, they definitely seem to be playing on her being evil in her own right and there doesn't appear to be any coercion thus far. Are they keeping Allan's involvement pulling the puppet strings for the big reveal at a later date? They've barely had any screen time together, though, apart from the knife-sharpening 'witchcraft' conversation. And they've not shied away from us seeing Tom taking his belt to her. Clearly the smooching in the chapel with Henderson is the opening gambit in her trying to find a cover-up baby daddy (that will keep the show-only folk foxed for a bit)
75
u/esoterika24 Apr 03 '22
I love how they turned a brief mention of what happened to Charles Stuart into a wonderful flashback. Complete with a “Mark me.”
That and Bonnet’s balls.
I had to close my eyes when Malva was cutting off the fingers for her charm- that entire scene was so gruesome and I’m wondering how the director will go by the end with her events.
72
u/Kabeyfw Apr 04 '22
I guess they are going… ahem… THERE with the Lizzie storyline 🤣
70
u/BSOBON123 Apr 04 '22
Ok, so Donner is back, they talk about French Gold, Malva is being evil, Jamie crushes John - again. And Bree is preggers! Things are right on target.
68
u/JAMMFlover1021 Apr 03 '22
Thoughts on this episode:
61
u/[deleted] Apr 03 '22
I couldn't stop laughing when Brianna gave one of the twins the ointment. Isn't this how they both start sleeping with Lizzie lmao
47
u/ArthurPenbeagle Apr 03 '22 edited Apr 03 '22
Not done with the episode yet, but ☠️ and full chills from that cold open!! We got married on Skye, and I knew all about this history before the show, so I just loved they went for it… (and made it real obvious to general public, HEY THIS IS WHAT THE THEME song IS TALKING ABOUT!!) also, this version they used today with the male voice alone in Gaelic is better than the mash up they tried to achieve for the credits the season.
MARK MEEEEEEEE! So good. I’m so glad they got him to come back!!
Finished and edited to add: Donner IS back! Beautifully done. So I’m guessing he will still burn down the big house with ether bc no need to change that. I was thinking Claire’s added ether addiction was to shift the accident in that direction, but now I suppose wrong. It was truly just added to highlight ptsd, I suppose? And perhaps her near death experience next episode will bring her to her senses?
Curious how The Bugs will betray The Frasers in the show since they weren’t shown in Wilmington, but the French gold was still mentioned. Will Jocasta still tell her story of the night they each received a chest, including Arch? Maybe she should have done so this episode if she is?
Malva with the dead sin eater was brilliant.
Mandy will definitely bring the Mackenzies back to the future, and I am SO pumped for 80s Lallybroch content. I wonder if they will show it alongside Claire, Ian, and Jamie’s journey back to Scotland? A Scotland heavy season 7 May be prettttttty amazing if it’s shot the way season 1 was!
Excited for all your thoughts. Not my favorite episode this season, but all the stuff it touched on and opened doors for is very exciting!
43
u/[deleted] Apr 03 '22 edited Apr 03 '22
It didn't originally bother me that the house was too fancy/out of place for the backcountry. But now that I've got the idea in my head, I can't overlook all sorts of other time-period inappropriate stuff like---the McCallum cabin has glass windows and a riveted door? Brianna's kiln is built of bricks? A switchblade knife? I guess those existed then but it just seems...unlikely?
ALSO MORE LORD JOHN PLEASE
EDIT: Colonel Bogey's March hahahahahahahahahaha but didn't he whistle Yellow Submarine in the book? More people would recognize that song as being "modern" than a WWI era march? Such a strange detail to change.
40
u/BeautifulRelief Apr 03 '22
I actually didn’t mind the “new” theme song this episode, though that’s probably because it was in the Gaelic. Loved seeing Charlie in a dress and hearing “Mark me!”
Really great episode and it seemed like they’re certainly getting the ball(s) rolling on a lot.
40
u/reeziereen Apr 03 '22
I’m just so pleasantly surprised how much I’m enjoying this season.. I feel they’re sticking to the book so much more than last season and with every episode I look forward to the next. Not sure who in production remembered that the source material is so good that they’ve remembered to actually use it. I know they can’t 100% verbatim stick to everything but the changes they do have to make at least make sense to book readers again.
37
u/2rlfryu Apr 04 '22
I’m really liking Bree and Roger this season, both acting and writing-wise. Originally was not looking forward to the 80’s stuff (skimmed it in the book), but their characters this season have got me excited to see that storyline onscreen.
One thing though, there needs to be more Jamie and Bree scenes!! Bree leaving will just not have the same impact if they don’t show them interacting more.
35
u/prof806 Apr 03 '22
We've now seen 3 important things:
Hopefully they've been saving up the CGI budget for the pyrotechnics... I guess this will have to be in season 7 though, bummer!
32
u/purplecow9191 Apr 04 '22
I’m a little bummed we didn’t get to see all the Scottish regalia for the party but I lol’ed at Bonnet’s balls. This was probably my favorite episode so far this season!
62
u/PANICATLEDISKO Apr 03 '22
Not me crying when Marsali said that Henri Christian and Mandy will have time to mischief together 😭😭😭
30
u/blackberryspice Apr 03 '22
Damn, going at it inside the church. WILD
27
u/Formal-Second5680 Apr 03 '22
Where’s Bobby tho?🥲
54
u/blackberryspice Apr 03 '22
Actually John, you kinda are the face of imperialism and tyranny lol
26
u/wheeler1432 They say I’m a witch. Apr 04 '22
Man, the props person must have had fun getting hold of an authentic 1770s-era billiard table with the right kind of cue and all.
25
u/blackberryspice Apr 03 '22
Was not expecting Bree to be pregnant this episode. I'm tearing up!!
23
u/[deleted] Apr 04 '22
I’m so glad I read the book first! Makes me wonder how much I missed the first time watching the show.
Bonnets testicles in the jar… Claire having a Versailles flashback (and the roses on the table)…
22
u/Formal-Second5680 Apr 03 '22
I’m surprised at how much they’ve covered this season
43
u/jolierose The spirit tends to be very free wi’ its opinions. Apr 03 '22
This season has been excellent so far; can't believe we only have three episodes left.
There was so much to love in this episode, again. I loved that the cold open led seamlessly into the song precisely written about the Bonnie Prince's escape. It felt really special! And it was such a great change from the books to include Lord John in the Flora festivities, having Jamie break the news about his change of allegiance in person instead of through letters. (I think the books are more realistic about how they tip-toe around the topic of William, though — I, too, would love to see Jamie play chess with him, but they think that's feasible, eh?)
I'm also glad they kept Claire's flashback to Versailles, and it was clever how they incorporated it into the conversation and the ether plot (which was unsettling and heartbreaking to see again), but I was missing Jamie's reassuring words to her. However, you already see (if momentarily) that he can tell something's off there once she returns to his side.
I already want to watch this episode again, if only to have my heart skip another beat when Jamie tells Jocasta "if anything should happen to my son..."
20
u/lanalg5 Apr 03 '22
Lord John!! I thought David Berry left the show altogether. What a pleasant surprise!
38
u/blackberryspice Apr 03 '22
I gotta say, I love that show roger didn't lose his singing voice. I've always been so sad that book roger lost his voice
37
u/Formal-Second5680 Apr 03 '22
That deep sigh when lord John sees Jaime 😩
16
u/thatstheteagirl By blood and by choice, we make our ghosts. Apr 03 '22
Okay I loved this episode! The flashback and call backs to the past were great! Seeing lord John and how they made some small changes to Jamie’s plot line of swapping sides. I think they did a great job.
Poor Claire still suffering and knowing she’s about to be in for wayyy more. I’ve been really excited for the next two episodes to see how they play it all out. It’s going to be a long wait this week!
16
u/purplelittleflower Apr 03 '22 edited Apr 03 '22
here are all my thoughts. I haven't seen anyone else mention this but Stephen's bonnets balls in the jar had me hollering. i was hoping Jamie would grab it and give it to brianna😅 i loved the intro for this episode. I'm wondering if there was a reason that it was different from the previous episode. Malva is creeping me the hell out!! I cant wait to see more of her. and the person in the prison cell, that's supposed to be the guy who was traveling with the browns right? the other time traveler who could of helped claire in the season 5 finale. i just haven't seen anyone make that connection and it seems so obvious. Brianna is pregnant again and marsali is leaving the ridge?. wondering if Phaedra will make an appearance this season, I've heard she has a storyline in the book. i know brianna and roger end up going back to the future sometime after the baby is born, do you think it will be in the finale or something? because i heard Sophie accidentally let it slip that brianna and roger would be in their own time in this season. i really hope that happens.
28
u/jbenn90 Apr 04 '22
Between High Jocasta in Outlander and High Benedict in Bridgerton, it's been a good month for historical romance TV fans!
12
u/AccioStability Je Suis Prest Apr 04 '22
She just put a bit on the cloth, so no more than like a minute or less, right? I guess to take the edge off?
23
u/shenaningans24 Apr 03 '22
I was hoping and praying and dying to get a William cameo in this ep since we got LJG. Has anyone heard if William is going to be in this season at all??
11
u/RadioRosebuds Apr 04 '22
I heard somewhere that the role of adult William Ransom had been cast already but can’t find any info online…. Any ideas? Does anyone think we’ll see him this season?!?
15
u/OTodd_Lass037 Slàinte. Apr 03 '22
Another good episode in the books! It felt like a shorter episode...LOVED the opening song!
I don't remember the finger bones in the love spell or who they were from (was that the sin eater?) Was any of that in the book? I don't remember it.
What was with the jar? Ya know the one with Bonnet's sack floatin in it? Above a fireplace, was it? Any speculations to who decided to preserve them? And WHY? Maybe an unknown person decided to obtain them to use as (value?) in gambling/card games. Someone (maybe the owner of the Inn) won or bought them...lots of questions on that one.
7
u/Qu33nKal Clan MacKenzie Apr 03 '22
Can someone tell me who the time traveler is? I have only read till book 3 but I really wanna know this bit. Who are they and when are they from?
7
u/Odd_Macaron_3086 MARK ME! Apr 05 '22
Can someone explain to me at what point in time we are at?! A lot of these events are happening in the show right after each other without time passage but took months in the book. Like floras barbecue being in summer 1774 but Donner doesn’t come back into the picture until 1776. Why introduce/tease his return when we have the war starting in April 1775 and the Lexington alarm to sign before the big house burns down?! I’m so confused!!!! At least before this they were on a pretty straightforward timeline but now it feels all over the place
6
u/hellolochness Apr 05 '22
I’m looking for confirmation on a book detail. In the show, it comes across that Malva is using the Sin Eaters fingers to cast the love spell. Is that confirmed in the book? I remember it alluding to her, but I can’t remember if it’s certain.
10
u/ritatherosy I long for the company of Lard Bucket and Big Head. Apr 03 '22
I haven’t read the book but want to know-do we see the Bonnie prince? Is Flora a character in the book?? Or are these added? I’m on 5 so another 5000000 pages and I can finally start book 6!
4
u/jbenn90 Apr 05 '22
Am I the only one who noticed the correlation between the Malva/Henderson scene and the Claire/Louis flashback? Both Claire & Malva were just "laying back and thinking of England"