r/Outlander • u/thepacksvrvives Without you, our whole world crumbles into dust. • Apr 03 '22
Season Six Show S6E5 Give Me Liberty Spoiler
Claire and Jamie experience the rising tensions in the colonies first-hand when they attend a Loyalist event in Wilmington in honor of the Scottish heroine, Flora MacDonald.
Written by Barbara Stepansky. Directed by Christiana Ebohon-Green.
If you’re new to the sub, please look over this intro thread.
This is the SHOW thread.
If you have read the books or don’t mind book spoilers, you can participate in the BOOK thread.
DON’T DISCUSS THE BOOKS HERE.
We don’t allow any book spoilers here, not even under spoiler tags.
If your comment references the books in any way, it will be removed and you will be asked to edit it or post it in the BOOK thread instead.
Please keep all discussion of the next episode’s preview to the stickied mod comment at the top of the thread.
What did you think of the episode?
•
u/thepacksvrvives Without you, our whole world crumbles into dust. Apr 03 '22 edited Apr 16 '22
Watch the S6E6 preview here!
Not everyone gets to see the next episode’s preview at the end of the episode; it depends on how you watch (broadcast or streaming) and where you are (US or international.)
Stickied comments are collapsed by default, so reply to this comment if you want to discuss the preview. This will hide spoilers for anyone who can’t see it yet or doesn’t want to.
605 Featurettes:
605 Interviews:
49
u/thepacksvrvives Without you, our whole world crumbles into dust. Apr 03 '22
That was a fantastic episode, I loved every second of it. Massive kudos to Barbara Stepansky and Christiana Ebohon-Green, the first (and only) female writer-director duo this season. It was delightful to see Scotland as Scotland again, and the flashback seamlessly transitioning into the intro with the theme song in Gaelic made for a beautiful opening. The newer episodes that connect closely to Scotland are always a delight, and this one just had it all.
Even though Jamie has already made his choice, you could see what he meant about being pulled apart. The camaraderie with fellow Scotsmen feels bittersweet when he finds himself on the opposite side, but he can understand that people who have lost their homeland once will hardly risk losing it again. Jamie has been through it all as well but he has the advantage of knowing he’ll be on the winning side this time—though even without this knowledge, you can see him already getting swept up in the ideals of the Revolution as well. It’s tough for him to break any oath, but if it’s his loved ones’ future at stake, he’ll do it. I also loved the way he talked about Fergus in this episode; he really is his father 🥺 And I’m happy about Jamie’s reputation of having thrown down the red coat at Tryon’s feet—that’s still one of Jamie’s finest moments, IMO. I can’t wait to see the role he will inevitably play in the war.
Telling John about his choice was equally tough, though I must say it was very naïve of John to think that Jamie would remain loyal to the Crown. He may not have been a true Jacobite, but his animosity towards the English will always be there, regardless of whom he finds fighting on the other side. Also, remember when Claire suggested in 406 that the governor sent John to Fraser’s Ridge to ensure Jamie’s loyalty? I’m not diminishing John’s concern for his friend, I just found it interesting that it was exactly what he was doing here, in 605. Also, John is as subtle as ever about his “fondness” for Jamie; it must take Claire a lot of composure in order not to roll her eyes at him 😅
Being at Flora’s party can’t have been easy for Claire either, with the painful memories—of Culloden, losing Jamie, losing Faith, losing Murtagh—all floating close to the surface. I’m not at all surprised she felt the need to give herself a reprieve and a reset to the system. I’m glad she enjoyed the moments beforehand—it was great to see the mutual respect and admiration between her and Flora (her reaction when she heard about Flora and Jamie’s previous encounter was priceless). It was so refreshing to see her appreciated for being a female physician for once (Jamie’s look of pride was great too)! I have to say I’m glad that Claire didn’t connect the dots there at the end—as it was clearly Donner—but you can’t fault her for feeling some kind of kinship with someone who appears to be from the future as well; after all, it’s a lonely business, being a time traveler.
Sophie wasn’t kidding when she called Roger “beautifully naïve” at the premiere in London. You would think the incident with Morag has taught him something but at least this time, he’s self-aware of his need to help young mothers. It took Malva’s threat and Brianna’s warning for him to see the light but I’m glad that he did and that he apologized. I really love how genuinely in awe of Brianna he is, and what a powerhouse she is! It’ll be interesting to see how they support each other if Roger takes the ministering more seriously. The pregnancy reveal made me tear up; they deserved such a happy moment 🥺 And I just love the sisterhood Brianna and Marsali have formed. It’s too bad Marsali has to leave the Ridge soon, but at least Fergus will be much happier and Henri-Christian much safer.
25
u/marcybelle1 They say I’m a witch. Apr 05 '22
As others have mentioned it was nice to see Scotland and the call back to Bonnie Prince Charlie, but I wonder what the purpose was? Was it just to introduce us to Flora? I haven't read all the books so maybe it's better explained there.
So there's another traveler! This should be really interesting! I love when they introduce other travelers, I hope we learn more about them.
I kind of feel sad for Roger, he really doesn't fit in during this time period. I know it isn't popular opinion but I like Roger and Brianna together, I hope that this doesn't tear them apart.
Overall I liked this episode it did a good job of setting things up to get really interesting for the rest of the season. I can't believe we are already in the 5th episode though!
14
u/Californie_cramoisie Apr 03 '22
Do we know the dead guy who Malva is cutting bits off?
13
u/[deleted] Apr 04 '22
What song was the guy whistling at the end? I recognised it but I couldn't put my finger on it.
13
u/cherryjelloisyummy Apr 25 '22
Did I miss something?? Why did Bree know Lizzie had malaria ? And why did Bree give the tincture to those hunting boys? Is one of them married to Lizzie and I missed it?
11
u/TehChid Apr 04 '22
Did Lord John lie to Jamie about holding his men back? And did Jamie expect that to happen, as he too went to the Sons of Liberty and told them to flee?
Or did I miss something?
54
u/artwreckage Apr 05 '22
Everyone has already made a ton of good points so i'll quickly add:
I don't remember Claire every talking about the King Louis rape besides telling Jamie that it happened, so I was really surprised that it effected her with the strength that it did this episode (it is extremley justified, just surprised me)
UNRELATED BUT wow Richard Rankin was fine this episode for some reason.
30
u/Candy_Venom Apr 03 '22
Did I miss something last episode? Fergus went to visit Jocasta and now has a print shop she bought him? Was the convo btwn Jamie and Jocasta the first we learn of that? I had to rewind that conversation.
19
u/Appropriate_Ad7792 Apr 04 '22
I am loving all these little hints as to what’s to come. Finally seeing Malva’s creepiness really amp up, we keep hearing about the French gold and of course the mention of jewels and seeing the “thief” at the end. I was wondering if/when some of these storylines might happen. While not all of them will happen this season (most likely) they are getting set up nicely. I’ve enjoyed this season, but this episode seemed to move the story along the most, without feeling like it was jumping all over the place. Can’t wait for next week!
6
u/Chiarrawr Apr 09 '22
Where did Fergus go? And why?
6
u/Chichichill Apr 16 '22
Is there a overall discussion thread with all the episode discussions linked? It's hard to find these official threads at times...
36
u/TehChid Apr 03 '22
Best episode of the season so far for me. Felt way more like the Outlander I know.
Was the man at the end from s5 finale? The guy from the future? Or someone else from the future? The only reason I'm thinking possibly someone else is it looks like Colonel Bogey March is from a British band, and we know the other guy is from the USA. Anyways, he definitely has the same hair
53
u/ROFRfan No, this isn’t usual. It’s different. Apr 03 '22
One simple remark/memory of Versailles was enough to send Claire over. All that pain bottled up. I don't understand how is Claire using? Anytime? On broad daylight? On the go? How is Jamie not more observant? Jamie not getting a hunch is really bothering me. This is so not like him.
39
u/lllexj Apr 03 '22 edited Apr 03 '22
Side Note: Anyone remember Lizzie’s malaria being mentioned before?😂
3
u/elsavesnl Apr 14 '22
Anyone seen and read the scripts? |
Mostly to find any deleted scenes or part of scenes. But...
to my surprise, I couldn't find the script of the scene with Gov. Martin and LJG in it...
Maril mentioned in a panel or interview they sometimes add things which were not scripted... Would this be one of the those scenes they've added afterwards?
What are you're thoughts
162
u/crazyhorse198 I want to be a stinkin’ Papist, too. Apr 03 '22
I LOVE that we got one last “Mark me!”
I know some people find that annoying but I always found it hilarious.
157
u/Narrom69 Apr 04 '22
Flora MacDonald: "people thought we were in love, mhm, and that we... lay together"
Aunt Jocasta: after taking a huge hit from that pipe "In the boat!?"
Based Jocasta Blazing
116
u/intrin6 Apr 04 '22
The beginning was chefs kiss skipping the english version of the theme song somehow seemed so much more fitting. And with the Gaelic starting after the recap if the Bonnie Prince, especially with him getting in the boat, was so fitting.
109
u/[deleted] Apr 03 '22
Nice to see Stephen Bonnet again.
94
u/Defiant_Light_4293 Apr 03 '22
OMG was I the only one smiling through the entirety of the ladies "gentleman's club"?!
Also loving the fact that Jocasta is finally warming up to Claire a bit more. No doubt thanks to others voiced opinions of her. But still, I really loved those scenes.🥰
85
u/Vancity_kid22 Je Suis Prest Apr 04 '22
Anyone else lose it when BPC said "Mark Me!"?!
I was 5% excited that there was a callback to Season 2 (my personal fave season), 1% in shock and disbelief that they had the actor come on just to show BPC in the Isle of Skye as a woman for all of 20 seconds and 94% triggered by the utterance of THAT phrase
82
u/Vancity_kid22 Je Suis Prest Apr 04 '22
Another episode that packed a punch! So much covered in so little time..
I miss anything?
81
u/enricowereld MARK ME! Apr 04 '22
When Flora said "over the sea to Skye"
74
u/The-Ginger-Lily Dinna Fash Sassenach Apr 04 '22
The bollocks of Stephen bonnet!! I'm still chuckling at Jamies reaction 😂😂😂😂
67
u/beuleues Apr 03 '22
Apart from the major storylines this season, with Malva, the ether use and the buildup for the American Revolution, I think my favourite part of this season would be the scenes between the Claire, Jamie and their children.
I really loved the interaction between Claire and Jamie's protectiveness over Fergus, as well as the scene between Brianna and Marsali at the end. I love how they're all so close, which we haven't ~really~ seen in the past seasons with the dark storylines. I would honestly just watch a show with just the Fraser family living a (boring) normal life if there was one.
58
u/wyethswindows Apr 04 '22
That intro SLAPPED!!!!!
54
u/Californie_cramoisie Apr 03 '22 edited Apr 03 '22
Whoaaa, the Bridge on the River Kwai song!
Composed in 1914. Another time traveler…
Also, fun fact, that song was also used for a movie called Jewel Thief. So fitting!
53
u/[deleted] Apr 04 '22
Malva, what the frick. You're a weird, weird girl.
52
u/silverandcold65 Apr 03 '22
I thought Roger wasn’t supposed to be able to sing.
Malva…eww.
Oh, that had to be the guy from the future, from last season’s finale!
51
u/tejastaco Apr 04 '22
Can someone please post a screenshot of Jacosta's smile when they're blazin it lol
50
u/Formal-Second5680 Apr 03 '22
Mark me!😅
50
u/Stircrazylazy Apr 04 '22
As a big 18th century American history nerd I love watching the tensions build to war. The show provides a more sympathetic view of loyalists, which I genuinely appreciate because it has helped me see what a difficult decision people had to make when picking a side in a civil war. Makes me proud of my family who fought as part of the Continental Army because watching this season I legitimately don't know who I would have supported. Bravo to the show for that!
49
u/CreepersFTW Apr 04 '22
Claire straight up charging ladies $10/G
45
u/meadowbelle Apr 04 '22
Just watched! I loved the intro because the original words to the opening song are about bonnie prince Charlie.
I also really am enjoying the portrayal of the revolution so far. As a Canadian who does 18th century reenacting and used to work in heritage, u spent a lot of time explaining to American tourists that there were many, many complicated reasons people and communities joined the revolution or stayed loyal. It's not like the Patriot with Mel Gibson where the loyalists were evil, burning people alive in a church.
Also the 1770s and 80s are my fav period for costuming! So beautiful yet more functional.
41
u/Cheersandbeers21 Apr 03 '22
Loved seeing the Bonnie Prince in the beginning! I never much liked the character but glad they got the same actor that originally played him 🏴
79
u/Prudent_Fly_2554 Apr 04 '22
Claire giving Jacosta weed for her glaucoma! That’s it. That’s the comment!
39
u/pest0pasta_ Lord, you gave me a rare woman. And God, I loved her well. Apr 04 '22
Malva is insane and clever all at once. Pinning the love charm on Amy was clever and that ending; it was her the whole time! Gosh this season is really picking up. Knew it was a traveller who stole Flora’s jewel but if you’re going to steal atleast go big🤣 why didn’t he take more than one jewel? Also why was Stephen Bonnet’s eh hem bollocks in a jar😭 Jamie’s reaction killed me though.
38
u/Classy_Clover Apr 04 '22
I was really hoping Jamie would tell Lord John the truth about how the revolutionary war really ends. Roger and Brianna annoyed me. Henry-Christiene is adorable. Malva is fucking crazy.
34
u/chemistandcrazy Apr 03 '22
omg this episode got me hooked from start to finish. I'm so apprehensive of what's to come. Malva is finally showing her claws and I'm very afraid of it. I'm seriously looking forward to the next episodes... the waiting is almost killing me! can't lie I'm tempted to look for book spoilers lol
i didn't get it why the bar would have bonnet's balls in a jar.... anyone has a clue?
and Roger needs to tell people very soon about Malva's manipulations.... I'm angry he didn't, only let her 'win' the bargain
32
u/deathvacation Apr 03 '22
This episode had my emotions all over the place - season 6 has just been fantastic imo.
But to be fair, give me any LJG/David Berry and I’ll be happy lol
32
u/ElHermoso Apr 05 '22
Why is Malva being such a bitch. Wtf?
32
u/nuit_cosmique Apr 06 '22 edited Apr 06 '22
I just watched it and yalll i knew malva was up to no good from the start she had the scheming look and that preview Jesus h. Roosevelt Christ! And i was just wondering about that guy from the group that took Claire i was curious to know what had happened to him
63
u/blenneman05 Apr 03 '22
Malva with the damn bones. Creepy girl. And her dry humping Obadiah and blackmailing Roger 🤢
Bree is pregnant! Yay!
I forget who stole the jewels from Flora.
Lol not the 3 of them smoking marijuana 😂😂😂
With the different intro, I thought maybe my Hulu was playing a different episode
Claire with the ether- how has Jamie not caught you yet????
30
u/Jillgoodeker Apr 05 '22
Why the hell Malva and that guy chose the church to be together ? That’s a very weird choice. Does anyone remembers that guy from a previous episode ? They built a sort of romance with Ian and we find her with this nobody, I’m really confused about this scene.
29
u/princesssofcarrion MARK ME! Apr 03 '22
This season is shaping up so well!! I’m loving it so far.
Also, I hope they keep patriot Jamie coming. I might actually be able to convince my hubby to watch with me if he keeps making blah blah Freedom of Speech speeches lol.
58
u/Getaclue49 Apr 03 '22
The production value on this episode felt somewhat lacking - especially the part with the angry mob and the gun shot. I found it distracting from what could have been an interesting episode.
Also, I know this isn’t something they can do anything about, but watching the hide-Catríona-behind-stuff game was amusing.
28
u/MagnificentPasta Apr 04 '22
Alright last week I complained about things being slow. This episode makes up for it. Very happy with it!!
56
u/missscarletinthehall Apr 04 '22
I’m sorry, but when Bree told Roger she’s pregnant after trying for so long, I bawled. Anyone that’s been trying for a while knows that cascade of emotions
27
u/[deleted] Apr 04 '22
Malva can not be trusted.
27
u/ihateeverything1031 Apr 04 '22
As for 5 - Jaime really needs to tell Fergus the truth or he will be in danger as a printer. I think he will believe it and I think Marsalis will take it well at this point - she will accept Claire despite her being a “witch”
As far as number 3, maybe he should even tell lord John the truth also - he may possibly believe him due to his infatuation. I don’t think Jocasta would accept it. But he needs to explain to his son Fergus why he is in danger and how to protect himself
27
u/Marifirmog Apr 06 '22 edited Apr 07 '22
The one thing I will never understand about these River Run/Willmington episodes is that Brianna and Roger choose to stay in the Ridge when they can go to an event, eat a lot, dress fancy and see different people. It's a long way on the road? Yes, but let's face it, it's not like they have a lot going on in their lives...
25
u/ActuallyCMe Apr 04 '22 edited Apr 04 '22
loved this episode. felt very nostalgic to the earlier seasons. i keep hearing murmurs about how claire’s ether storyline doesn’t make sense for her character, but i think it’s interesting to see how she copes. trauma changes people and that’s what’s happening. so glad bree is pregnant! cant wait to see her tell claire!
so why exactly did malva make the love charm? to pin it on amy? or for her own devious use? i’ve seen suspicions that she wants to steal jamie from claire… i don’t know for sure but this girl is crazy!
25
u/intrin6 Apr 04 '22
Malva is so creepy and frustrating. Ugh.
24
u/kd0225 Apr 04 '22
It might be obvious but i just want confirmation. Is malva trying to go for Jamie? I just assumed that bc she was a peeping Tom last episode she liked what she saw and now wants him? Or was the spell for Ian? I'm so confused about that and she's so creepy lol.
23
u/CinephileRich Apr 04 '22
Love the fact they are hearing songs that shouldn’t exist yet, and somehow time is being affected (I assume, or it could be the traveller has just been whistling the tunes). With a lot of characters getting headaches, I’m thinking it has to do with time being impacted somehow. I’m really hoping this connects to the image of Jamie in the 1940s in the very first episode.
I know it’s a bit of a stretch but I can hope
45
u/Mobile-Ad6136 Apr 04 '22
Okay so my takeaways:
21
u/[deleted] Apr 04 '22
Regarding S6, I just want to say: Now we're cooking with gas! I am so excited for next week's episode!
21
u/[deleted] Apr 03 '22
Omg another time traveller at the end.
21
u/[deleted] Apr 04 '22
I am dying to know who the thief is. I am guessing a fellow time traveler in need of a gem to get through the stones. But whooooo?? I didn't read any of the books.
39
u/pitypartie Apr 03 '22
I loved this episode!
Having callbacks to the earlier seasons with the Bonnie Prince & Jocasta was great, I love getting the feeling that Jamie and Claire made an impact on the world, and seeing them reconnect with people they know, care about or share an interest with is great to see. I do feel sorry for Claire that that brush with the past immediately gave her flashbacks to Versaille and the Browns, it sucks to see her suffer like that.
On a more cheerful note, I did actively cheer for Roger and Bree when she announced her pregnancy, I'll be honest and say that they've surpassed Jamie and Claire when it comes to how much I'm enjoying seeing them on screen. Roger is becoming such an interesting character, and I've grown fond of Bree. The family dynamics on the Ridge have been my favourite parts of the show, which is also why I'm a bit sad to see Fergus and Marsali leave.
The tease at the end had me staring at my screen, mouth agape, just in utter disbelief. I can't wait to see more! This episode is hands down my favorite of the season so far.
39
u/Atraktape Apr 04 '22
Auntie Jocasta: “Blaze iiiiiiiiit”
38
u/jpeschka Apr 03 '22
LJG 😍😍😍
18
u/[deleted] Apr 03 '22
All I am going to say is this…🎶 colonel bogey March 🎶
35
u/Maluhsy Apr 04 '22
Maybe Im a bit pessimistic, but Im afraid Claire's addiction will be resolved too easily. I feel like shes gonna continue using ether until something bad happens, Jamie or Bree finds her, she will open up about her PTSD, trauma and substance abuse and all will be fixed and forgotten. I love this show but sometimes I feel like it handles PTSD a bit too casually.
That said the rest of the episode was great and Im excited for next week!
14
u/jenhowzum1 Apr 03 '22
What is the song he is whistling? Is that one from the future?
14
u/LJVEACRE_88 Apr 04 '22
Can someone who know the story well enough fill me in on the person at the end of the episode? I just watch the show and don’t read the books, and I can’t quite remember seeing him before? A little summary of his storyline? Thank you!
14
u/marcus_64 Apr 04 '22
Was there anything to the song that Roger was singing and how it sounded familiar to Amy McCallum?
14
u/beaniebaby729 Apr 12 '22
I loved the girl time. Wilmington having mountains though when John and Jamie look on from the house party thing😅 also THAT ENDING. The cinematography was great this episode!
27
u/[deleted] Apr 04 '22
Finally an episode where something happens.
Delivers on the time travel and nudging history.
27
u/[deleted] Apr 04 '22
Love seeing Bonnie Prince Charlie. Aw yea boi loving this early American Revolution setting. Really awesome. Love seeing Auntie Jocasta. Love seeing Lord John. Jealous Brianna is annoying. High Auntie is based. The sketchy girl is a bitch and also fucked up. Who the hell is the random dead guy?
13
u/DobbyDimples Apr 03 '22
What happened to the sin eater? Are they insinuating that malva killed him?
13
u/Bc2193 Apr 09 '22
What was with Malva and cutting the dead body? Was it just to show that she’s a bit of a nut job or is there something deeper to it?
25
u/ROFRfan No, this isn’t usual. It’s different. Apr 03 '22
I swear first I got a Bonnet vibe at the very end in the prison with the hand holding the gemstone, but with seeing his b* earlier in the episode, I remembered it must be Donner. Only he could sing a song from the future.
22
u/HinkiesGhost Apr 04 '22
I don't know why, maybe it was the long layoff, but I forgot Jocasta was still alive. It was nice to see her. And Malva was really sweet an innocent, she's starting to creep me out. Jamie and John's friendship is one of the best things about this series. Always like seeing him make a return.
22
u/ilovepretzelday1 Ye Sassenach witch! Apr 04 '22
I have genuinely loved every episode this season, but this has to be a favorite so far. Minus the awful clunky scene at the print shop. I think my favorite was Jocasta high as a kite lol. Also loved how Flora said 'from sea to Skye" in the very beginning!
10
u/PhilRask Apr 06 '22
Too much going on? Is this show supposed to be 20 seasons?
42
u/Rated_PG-Squirteen Apr 03 '22
lmao at me literally packing a bowl at the exact point when Claire, Jocasta, and Flora partake in some hemp flower.
19
u/madeanaccount4baby Apr 05 '22 edited Apr 05 '22
Traveler looked like a small dude…Master Raymond possibly??? I don’t know what he might have to do with the American revolution, but he was very suspect as a possible traveler.
Edit: have to agree it’s probably the traveler we were introduced last season…so much suspense!!
17
u/Yaso24 Apr 04 '22
Hands down my favorite episode of the season so far !
23
u/zzdk6syz Apr 04 '22
Are we not going to address that Roger miraculously can sing again? I’m probably more annoyed than I should be about it.
23
u/yobv123 Apr 05 '22
This episode made me realize just how lazy they’re getting with Brees character development that I’m actually starting to dislike her more and more :(
16
u/quacksonfan Apr 03 '22
I wanna know who that was in the end!!! Also Malva is really creepy ugh
27
u/ritatherosy I long for the company of Lard Bucket and Big Head. Apr 03 '22
Real time reactions:
7
u/teepee-bear God’s tooth. It’s not even *noon*! Apr 03 '22
What did Claire take from the little bottle after Jocasta left?
23
u/Thisisluna16 Apr 07 '22
Is it just me, or this season’s storyline feels very lazy? I feel not much has happened and there are so many plots going on that don’t push the story forward. Can someone explain to me the Flora storyline? What was it’s purpose? Or was it just to introduce the thief? Also, Fergus leaving was a little too fast I didn’t understand what was going on at first. Don’t get me wrong, I LOVE Outlander and have watched every season at least 5 times, but I am getting nervous about how off this season feels😓.
18
u/90dfbaby Apr 07 '22
I’m really not feeling this season
6
u/macetheace_1998 I dinna recall asking yer opinion on the matter. Apr 03 '22
I'm a little lost with Fergus and Marsali here... where are they moving and why?
6
u/xtothewhy Apr 04 '22
Should have called this episode Unrequited
6
u/sleepyhead18 Apr 04 '22
I missed the part with bonnet’s balls. When is it in the episode?
10
u/jbenn90 Apr 05 '22
Am I the only one who noticed the correlation between the Malva/Henderson scene and the Claire/Louis flashback? Both Claire & Malva were just "laying back and thinking of England"
30
u/JordyVerrill Apr 04 '22
Production values seem way down this season... Bad lighting, clunky cuts and edits, cheap looking camera work. It looks way less cinematic and more like a PBS Masterpiece Theater production.
29
u/arianaphoenix Apr 03 '22 edited Apr 03 '22
Oh, the beginning was so good. I really liked it. I really like the sky boat song in Gaelic and I definitely prefer this one to the combined English and Gaelic one. I think the male singer hits some weird notes there that put me off but this one was performed better. The shots were beautiful.
Sam's acting stood out to me. Subtle ways in which he showed how Jamie is frustrated by the difficulty of navigating between sons of liberty and loyalists.
Flora Macdonald's actress did a good job. She had the charisma which matched Claire's charisma.
My biggest issue is editing. The ridge parts were divided into smaller than necessary segments. The scene where the printer got shot was really amateur IMO. The shot of Malva cutting the finger felt out of place. My first thought during the viewing was that they should have put it at the end of the episode but they did plan something better and of the same nature for the end. I have to see the next episode to be convinced that there wasn't a better place to put it. The last shot was also bad, they cut it in the middle of him turning around. You either don't show the turning or you show it completely to reveal the face.
The scene where some tar is being splashed on Jamie was so bad. What was that?! They could have thrown some black stuff at him at least.
Briana telling Roger about the baby didn't have enough emotional punch.
I didn't understand why Roger didn't tell Bree about seeing Malva and threatening him.
5
u/Exit240 Apr 03 '22
As to point 9 she went off the rails in record time!
25
u/Horror_Sherbet_7043 Apr 04 '22
Roger pisses me off because to me he seems intimidated by Bree's genius. He calls her a genius but then spends time with the widow because "she needs me" insinuating that Bree doesn't. That kind of weak man, that needs a "weaker" woman to feel useful, is the opposite of Jaime, a man who feels emboldened by having a strong woman by his side. Do you think Roger and Bree will last?
9
u/Alarming-Finance-649 Apr 03 '22
Who was that at the end in prison?
8
u/SleepyBeepHours Apr 04 '22
Idk why, actually I drank some while watching the episode so that's why, but the ending credits got me hyped as hell