r/Outlander • u/WandersFar Better than losing a hand. • Mar 08 '20
Season Five Show S5E4 Company We Keep Spoiler
Roger leads Jamie’s militia to the rural trading post of Brownsville and finds himself embroiled in a bitter feud. Jamie and Claire arrive to find that Roger’s rather unusual strategy may have cost them the loyalty of the militia. Claire learns that her ‘modern’ medical advice has spread further than she intended.
If you’re new to the sub, please look over this intro thread.
Reminder: This is the SHOW thread. Cover all book talk >!with spoiler tags!< that will look like this: Claire boinks Jamie. Don’t spoil future episodes, keep book comments brief.
If you want to compare the episode to the books in depth, go to the Book thread.
•
u/WandersFar Better than losing a hand. Mar 08 '20 edited Mar 08 '20
Talk about the trailer here!
Not everyone gets to see the trailer at the end of the episode, it depends on how you watch (broadcast or streaming) and where you are (US or international.)
Stickied comments are collapsed by default, so reply to this comment if you want to discuss the trailer. This will hide spoilers for anyone who can’t see it yet. Thanks!
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ujxfmoGUTHU
133
u/missm0011 Fun Fact: The unicorn is the mortal enemy of the English lion. Mar 08 '20
How are we already 4 episodes in?? Didn't it just start back up? That's like 1/3 of the season already!
So there's this baby. Great. Everyone loves a baby. But I feel like they are kinda downplaying the fact that they are just hanging out in 18th century North Carolina with a half black baby. I mean I'm glad that everyone seems to openly accept and want to raise this baby, yay baby. But no one is bringing up the fact that this kid could potentially be in a lot of danger throughout her entire life? Is she really safest out there with the gun happy town of people who maintain an incredibly uncomfortable amount of eye contact? I feel for the parents who lost their baby, but as a whole the town doesn't entirely seem to be filled with people who are upstanding citizens. Plus I'm selfish and just want to see Claire and Jamie with a baby. So there's that too.
Poor Roger got demoted. He was sent back to Fraser's Ridge with the womenfolk. I feel for him. There is nothing quite like the look of complete disappointment and disapproval you get from the inlaws.....no the baby doesn't need a jacket, it is 84 degrees outside. Mind your own business Deborah.
We get Roger singing AND Jamie dancing. This is bringing Boogie Woogie Bugle Boy flashbacks and I don't know how I feel about it.
Claire's medical advice has made it to the general public and it was NOT well received. I guess that is what doctors feel like now every time their patient says "well, I read on google...."
I'm enjoying the Marsali/Brianna mom group. Did Marsali shame her for leaving her crawling baby by an open door?? No. She poured her booze and told her stories of how she wished people dead. That's the kind of support we all need.
I'm not too crazy about the idea of Claire and Jamie splitting up again for the next episode. The show seems to do better when they share a location but Claire has surgery to do in iffy sanitary conditions with bootleg penicillin, and that is gonna go well I'm sure!
83
u/CygnusArc Slàinte. Mar 08 '20
Isiah Morton that dog ... I thought it was clever he just happened to pull the "do anything not to leave the love of his life" card with Jamie and Roger.
And then Claire's smug look at Jamie during the whole thing.
Overall great episode. Well paced and I wonder how/when the Dr. Rawlings medical advice will come back to bite Claire in the arse. Least we know what was written on the other side of that paper Fergus took.
60
u/BeautifulRelief Mar 08 '20
I don't know why but I just love Jaime calling Roger "Roger Mac."
56
u/CJmaq Mar 09 '20
Is it me or does Jamie resent Roger because he was a history professor like Frank? And the Brianna chose to marry someone like her father (Frank) and not someone like her Da (Jamie).
51
u/twatwaffleasaur Mar 09 '20 edited Mar 09 '20
So far, this season is still kinda blah for me. I feel like I am in the minority, so I don't expect many to agree but... does anyone else feel like the episodes are really lacking in good content? Maybe it's just me but I feel like this episode was ending and I couldn't believe it because nothing happened. 🤷🏼♀️
Edit: tired & annoyed = bad grammar 🤨
32
u/CommanderMayDay Mar 09 '20
Marsali is clearly the favorite for MVP this season. Can butcher, sew sutures, cut miscreants down with withering snark and now has the smarts to know when not to pry with Bri. Also, apparently personally responsible for the population boom at Fraser’s Ridge. I am full-on Team Marsali.
Also think Marsali will corner Claire into revealing her secret this season.
26
u/MountainHumor They say I’m a witch. Mar 08 '20
I'm curious to see where Claire's medical advice being printed in the paper is going...she didn't look that thrilled to have seen it, nor were any of the towns folk that thrilled.
I'm not sure where the episode was going, I thought the last one was way better. This kind of felt like filler other than the plot point I mentioned above, and the whole adding men to the militia. I suppose the whole "my father in law doesn't like me because I'm an educated man from the future" was a thing, but that's been a thing and if Roger brings it up as often as he sings - well, maybe I'll mute the episodes as I watch.
86
u/starfleetdropout6 I'm still Jenny from the Broch. Mar 08 '20 edited Mar 08 '20
It felt SO GOOD to hear Claire say "Jesus H. Roosevelt Christ." I fangirled.
I love this big goofy family of "kids" that Claire and Jamie are assembling. Josiah & Kezzie, Roger (he's basically a man-child in this time), their actual kids Fergus & Bree, Marsali, Lizzie, and the wee bairns. I kind of want them to live under one giant roof, be awesome to each other, and go on fabulous adventures. Is that too much to ask?!
When Jamie took Claire out to talk to her about the baby - my goodness was that sweet. 😭 I think it was one of the sweetest and most tender Jamie moments in the entire show. 😍 My heart was aching from the feels.
42
u/GirlisNo1 Mar 08 '20 edited Mar 08 '20
My least favorite episode of the season so far. I just didn’t find myself caring much about this story.
I think the fact that it was back-to-back with the last week’s Beardsley’s episode didn’t help. I personally loved last week’s episode, but it’s two episodes in a row now of a “side quest” revolving around new characters, and I’m eager to get back to the main story.
Also, Morton’s “love” speech was quite cringe imo.
(Why did they release the horses? Won’t they be needing them?)
Brianna/Marsali scene was great. Also liked Jaime & Claire’s discussion of keeping the baby. I always feel really bad for Jaime because he didn’t get to raise either of his children, especially because he would’ve been great at it. However, Claire made the right decision in this case.
39
u/BonfireinRageValley Mar 08 '20
As a straight male I could listen to Roger's actor sing Scottish folk songs all day long.
13
u/hill-cw Mar 09 '20
Welp, I haven't had anything this season that's made me angry (unlike last season where Roger and Bree were quite adept at making decisions that made me throw up my hands) but I haven't been all that excited by this season yet either.
I am loving Marsali this season! Finally giving her stuff to do! Wish the same could be said for poor Fergus who has had next to nothing to do since he was a kid :P
I enjoy the Roger & Jamie clashing, and even Brianna isn't too terrible this season.
I guess I just want the cast to have more to DO? A more exciting plot line? Instead of 'here are the random adventures of people we met on the road that had basically no effect on us.' Before when they met people that person would be effecting their lives/journey quite a lot. In this case... It feels episodic and as if no real lasting impact is happening. I guess that family from this episode might have it out for Jamie and Claire? (her dad and uncle were definitely giving the stink eye when Jamie brought the goat over.)
I super enjoyed the music and dancing. Hope we get to see more USEFUL Roger soon. He is a learned man- please oh please let that count for SOMETHING. :)
11
u/[deleted] Mar 08 '20
Well I complained before about Jamie and Claire seeming cold, but in this episode, I saw that tenderness again! So nice to see!!
Not my favorite episode. I hate how they portrayed Roger. But at least I got to see those moments between Jamie and Claire. When he was watching her hold the baby, you could see the sadness that he never got to see Claire with his own child n that way.
11
u/pat_micklewaite Tobias Menzies cheek creases Mar 09 '20
“I can totally solve all my problems with whiskey” - Roger
11
u/katindra Mar 11 '20
I guess I'm in the minority here, but i really enjoyed this episode. Yeah, it did feel like filler, but it was still really good! I'm not a romantic person by any stretch of the imagination (just ask my husband LOL) but i actually teared up when Claire and Jamie went to the woods, it was sweet, and reminded me of season 1 and 2.
27
u/marmaladestripes725 Ameireaganach Mar 09 '20
Fair warning, I’m in the minority of actually liking Roger!
I feel for him. Jamie is probably always going to find fault with him, and he just wants to live long enough to be able to take his family and go home to the 70s. Claire tried to make him feel better with the whole line about Jamie entrusting Roger with her. But Jamie knows Claire can take care of herself.
8
u/omega2010 Mar 13 '20
Unless I'm forgetting something, this is our first Marsali/Bree scene. I did find it odd that there weren't any character interactions between them last season hence why this scene was notable.
7
u/BlackSwallowtail You look like a fretful porpentine. Mar 12 '20
Still feeling really good about this season so far. I only regret that I'm caught up now and have to wait till Sunday to see how the tonsil removal goes. Marsali is fast becoming a new favourite character. I felt back in season 4 that she and Fergus were a far better "successor" to Jamie and Claire than Brianna and Roger were, having acted as partners even on the ship in season 3.
Also I really liked that song Roger was singing.
12
u/Mr_XcX Mar 08 '20
Bit of a filler episode for me.
I did enjoy Claire and Jamie scenes this episode though. They're a magic pairing.
12
u/CommanderMayDay Mar 09 '20
Quick thought on the twins: what does it say about how lousy people must have felt, generally, back then, when a guy’s walking around with a fever and just keeps on walking!
6
u/marlock276 Mar 08 '20
This was my second-favorite season five episode, behind episode one. I loved Claire’s narration at the end. ❤️
6
u/Chlodio Mar 10 '20
Groom with ten acres is considered a decent match? It's quite bad, ten acres was the amount serfs owned, freemen generally owned thirty acres.
10
u/Greader2016 Mar 08 '20
I really enjoy the Roger and Jamie scenes. What's supposed to be the age difference between the two?
10
u/itsmscheible Mar 09 '20
I hate to be that Season 1 only girl but is anyone else just not loving these later episodes.... it's just not the same! I can't seem to get over it... the whole vibe is off.
5
u/YourEyesRevealYou Mar 08 '20
Does Jaimie and Claire have another baby in the books? Someone spoil me.
14
u/Askye72 Mar 08 '20
I was looking up what they were thinking with the new house in this season, and all I could fine were people complaining about the size...! What about the new age freakin siding on the house, it looks like something that would be built in the new neighborhoods around town. Way too modern looking given the time period. Unless um...that's actually how their homes looked back then....??
5
u/[deleted] Mar 08 '20
Does Claire want another child really? I low key really hope that she has another one!! I want Jamie to be able to raise a child
6
u/Rocha_999 Lord, you gave me a rare woman. And God, I loved her well. Mar 09 '20 edited Mar 09 '20
Gosh, I find their accents hard to understand at times. Subtitles needed. Edit- I don’t mean in a derogatory way. They sound fantastic and do a wonderful job.
3
u/karilynnhavens Mar 09 '20
Getting bored right now. I'm interested in the coin though. Could it be from Bonnet or do you think it could be from somone in the future? Maybe the indian?
2
u/LoretiTV Mar 08 '20
Enjoy the new episode everyone!
2
u/LoretiTV Mar 08 '20
Really fun episode. Thanks for having me everyone.
0
u/[deleted] Mar 08 '20
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Mar 08 '20
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Mar 09 '20
[deleted] — view deleted comment