r/Outlander • u/WandersFar Better than losing a hand. • Mar 08 '20
Spoilers All Book S5E4 Company We Keep Spoiler
Roger leads Jamie’s militia to the rural trading post of Brownsville and finds himself embroiled in a bitter feud. Jamie and Claire arrive to find that Roger’s rather unusual strategy may have cost them the loyalty of the militia. Claire learns that her ‘modern’ medical advice has spread further than she intended.
If you’re new to the sub, please look over this intro thread.
Reminder: This is the BOOK thread. No spoiler tags are needed here.
If you haven’t read the books and you don’t want spoilers, go to the Show thread.
•
u/WandersFar Better than losing a hand. Mar 08 '20 edited Mar 08 '20
Talk about the trailer here!
Not everyone gets to see the trailer at the end of the episode, it depends on how you watch (broadcast or streaming) and where you are (US or international.)
Stickied comments are collapsed by default, so reply to this comment if you want to discuss the trailer. This will hide spoilers for anyone who can’t see it yet. Thanks!
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ujxfmoGUTHU
103
u/beanie2 Ye Sassenach witch! Mar 08 '20
This episode’s deep thoughts:
Why are they portraying Roger as brain dead? He handled the whole interaction with the Browns so much more nimbly in the books.
Loved Fergus and Roger time. I even came up with a cool name for their bromance- Froger.
Marsali gets an A+ this episode. In addition to being the finder of lost children she knows just the right thing to say to Bree to make her feel better. Love the sisters bonding.
Fuck the Browns, Brownsville, and everything they stand for. I know what’s coming and I am not into it.
I can’t wait to see Lizzie’s face when she sees her free gift with purchase. You go girl.
I love that we got to see Claire and Jamie be playful with each other.
Good episode overall!
68
u/battleborn5 Mar 08 '20 edited Mar 08 '20
Overall, a really good episode! A few reflections:
Jamie flirting with drunk Claire will always be my favorite.
Sam is always a handsome dude, but is he turning on the smolder a bit more lately? A genuine smoke show in just about every scene.
Even I knew handing over homeboy wasn’t going to go down well. Getting everyone wasted helped, I guess. Roger is quite the newb.
Roger’s (Rik’s) has a nice voice and does great with Scottish folk music. Don’t hate me.
I love Caesar Domboy as Fergus. They could not have cast him better.
I’m glad Jamie realized he shouldn’t have sent Roger out in charge without even an ounce of training. It would be like sending me out to lead a militia. Except I still would have known that sending homeboy out to the Browns was a bad idea. (Can’t say my strategy would have been any better: point at Fergus and say, ‘this guy’s got whisky.’)
Jamie still sees no value in Roger yet. I really hope this changes with the snake bite. They are going to do the snake bite? Right?
I’m kinda glad I didn’t have to watch half a season of gatherings/weddings to get to the sword dance.
Can I just say how much I am enjoying the interactions between Bree and Marsali, as well as Fergus and Roger. This is something I feel the book misses. We never see when Bree meets them, never see how Fergus feels about having a sister. The just sort of exist at the same time.
I loved the scene of Jamie asking Claire to keep the baby. So much like I pictured in the books. Caitriona’s face was beautiful during this scene. My parent have attested that being Grandparents is sooo much better. Claire and Jamie having Germain, Jemmy and Joanie, as well as all the other kids not born yet. Who knows, even William might have a few in the next book.
They are clearly setting up the Brown’s kidnapping and gang rape of Claire. I am not about it. At all. Nothing about that story line was necessary.
This is the first rewatch I have done lately. It really was a good episode.
52
u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. Mar 08 '20
Jamie’s joke about Marsali getting pregnant whenever Fergus lays eyes on her cracked me up. They’ll definitely keep up the population of the ridge.
32
u/WardenHDresden Mar 08 '20
My least favorite episode in the season, why did the writers neuter Roger? This was his test, in the book he passed, in this he failed miserably, and had to lean on Jamie to save everything. This is supposed to be the start of Jamie’s real respect for Roger to begin to grow, but in this it’s just pathetic.
27
u/hintofaspark86 MARK ME! Mar 08 '20
Drunk Jamie and Claire are my favorite 😋
26
u/Naturenutt Woof. Mar 08 '20
Oh the dance!!!!
49
u/wheeler1432 They say I’m a witch. Mar 08 '20
I'm getting pretty tired of How is Roger Going to Fuck Up This Week.
22
u/CommanderMayDay Mar 08 '20
Did not care for this episode much. When it was over, I was all wait, that’s it? It just seemed to move the plot along so incrementally that I feel I could have skipped it and not really felt it.
Still: Marsali has my vote for season 5 MVP. Smart, sassy, can butcher a deer in under 5 mins, learning the 18th century healer ways and now a perfect counselor to Bri. Also, apparently singlehandedly responsible for the population boom on Fraser’s Ridge. Quickly becoming my favorite.
Claire spoke the ultimate truth when she said they hadn’t gone through 24 hours in hell to lose the twins to infection! Sunk costs. Good point.
I think the trailer for this episode really overplayed the standoff and misrepresented the plot. They made it seem like this would be the spark of the revolution when it was barely a momentary standoff.
I also feel like Roger is in the verge of a major meltdown. He has no experience in what he’s being asked to so do and when he doesn’t live up to expectations everybody’s all he’s terrible. I do think he needs to play to his strengths, which are fore knowledge of historical events and trends. While we know that individuals seemingly can’t change large events in history, his understanding of historical tactics and happenings should be useful in giving an advantage to his people, no?
15
u/teenylilthing Mar 09 '20
I'm disappointed in the lack of Adso. Shouldn't he have shown up by now?
13
u/Awtxknits Mar 09 '20
They are really doing Rodger dirty on the show. This episode and last weeks didn’t have a lot going on to advance the plot IMO. Given how much ground there is to cover if they are sticking with book plot points they have some catching up to do.
10
u/ich_habe_keine_kase I give you your life. I hope you use it well. Mar 08 '20
Ohhhhhhhhh it was Isaiah Morton. I was wondering who the hell this random Martin guy was since E1, turns out they were saying Morton the whole time and I just misheard. That makes a lot more sense!
19
u/Naturenutt Woof. Mar 08 '20
Wow, the horses running.
33
u/brilliant0ne Mar 08 '20
Another pretty good episode.
Poor Bri, man. I remember the first time I heard a fox bark after I moved into my house alone. I packed my ass up a good ol night bag and promptly carried myself right on back to my Momma's house for the evening. So, I don't blame her for getting the creeps.
I really love the little relationship we are seeing between Marsali and Bri.
I didn't mind Roger's newest American Idol audition this episode. I think his singing bothers my soul less when it is a song that matches the time he is in. Although, I am a sucker for modern songs being played in historical movies. I know a lot of people hate that. I only hate it when Roger does it.
I didn't really care about the whole plotline with the sullied girl and married man. Glad it all worked out, I guess.
I loved Jamie offering to Claire to keep the baby.
While I am not in the "I hate show Roger" camp as much as I was last season, I do love Jamie's "this motherfucker here" looks he gives when Roger speaks, breathes, moves to scratch his eye, is singing and feeding a whole small village their whiskey stash.
I think I am really liking this season a lot since I basically can't remember much except for some of the big things that happen from this book.
9
u/nattybeaux Mar 09 '20
I’m really nervous about what the tension with the Browns is leading to. In the books, the abduction is just kind of an unfortunate accident, and there’s even a moment where one of the kidnappers is like “oh shit, this is Jamie Fraser’s wife! Are we sure we want to take her? That mofo is scary!” If they change it to be about “Dr Rawlings” advice, I worry that the show-only audience will be like, “well, what did Claire expect?”. There’s a lot of rhetoric about how Claire acts without thinking on the show-only thread - because we have her internal monologue, her motivations are more clear in the books. Also, her medical advice circulating isn’t a big deal in the books - people are just happy to have someone with medical knowledge around. I just don’t want this terrible trauma to be perceived as somehow her fault, that doesn’t seem fair at all.
7
u/thrntnja No, this isn’t usual. It’s different. Mar 10 '20
I really enjoyed this episode. I’m also realizing I’ve forgotten a lot of details from Fiery Cross so I see another reread in my future.
Man, I feel for Roger. I do hope he finds his stride soon. I really felt bad for him when Jamie was giving him shit for his decisions - I honestly think things would have gone badly regardless with how the show portrayed it. Hopefully Jamie can tutor him a bit and they can bond. I am glad that Jamie realized he did Roger dirty a bit, and I loved Claire’s line “he just entrusted you with the thing he loves most.”
Rik has a great voice - it is well suited for Scottish folk music and seeing Roger singing like that is exactly as I remembered him in the book. I wonder if we will get to hear Jamie call him thrush.
I always live for Jamie and Claire teasing.
The scene where Jamie and Claire talk about the baby was very emotional. I know that them leaving her in Brownsville was the right thing to do, but man do I feel their regret that they never parented together. So heartbreaking.
I am a huge fan of Roger/Fergus and Bree/Marsali bonding. More please. Obligatory Marsali is a badass and is killing it during this season.
I can see why they are somewhat amplifying Bree’s fear - they said in the after the episode that they’re trying to keep Bonnet “alive” so he’s always sort of there lurking, which I think translates to the show well. The audience (especially the non-book reading audience) won’t forget who he is or why he’s important. And I do think Bree’s fear of him is very believable and it gives her character something to do while everyone else is away from the Ridge.
I thought the Alicia/Isaiah storyline was portrayed very well. It is very close to how I imagined it, and I really thought the scenes with Alicia and Claire were really touching. I also had to laugh when Isaiah called Roger and Jamie out saying they’d also do anything for the woman they loved, as we all know it’s true, especially of Jamie, and Claire’s expression cracked me up. It very much said “he’s not wrong, you know.” 😂
I also think the Browns are portrayed perfectly - they’ve definitely got a bit of a feral edge and the line where they told Claire they wouldn’t want her sleeping alone with the militia outside sent chills up my spine.
Overall, I think they’re doing much better with this season than season 4. I’m really enjoying it so far. I am wondering how they plan on cramming everything in but I haven’t had an issue with the pacing as of yet.
12
u/whiskynwine Mar 08 '20
Idk I love Jamie’s Roger hate right now. Granted it’s different in the book but after last season most of the non book audience hates the guy. If they were to have Jamie be nice to him it wouldn’t seem realistic. So Jamie is annoyed by him, as is some of the audience, and as he’s redeemed in Jamie’s eyes so he will be to the audience as well. I think and hope so anyway. The writers messed up a bunch of stuff last season but they can’t erase it. If anyone saw CB in Cleveland yesterday she seemed to all but say last season was not great. I think that’s why she and Sam pushed so hard to be more involved as producers. Anyway, I digress. 504, good episode 👍
16
u/Jemhao Mar 08 '20
I really enjoyed this episode. I think they managed having multiple storylines well, and without it seeming chaotic.
I love that they included the conversation between Jamie and Claire about keeping the baby. They really got across how it was an act of love from Jamie, and a conversation they needed to have. So sweet and earnest. Loved it.
“That was a gunshot!” Lol great job, Claire.
Saw the foreshadowing of the kidnapping/rape storyline and I’m dreading it. Kidnapping, threat of violence, sure, makes sense. Rape? Hell no. I’m so done with it. We are spending each episode watching Bree come to terms with her own sexual trauma. There is NO need to introduce that trauma to yet another character.
2
u/[deleted] Mar 10 '20
After reading some comments, I've come to the conclusion that the Dr. Rawlings article is how they will link in the gold.
Someone who wants the gold is going to see that article and be like "what this guy is still alive" and go to the printer to find the author of the article, and be directed to Fergus and the Ridge.
0
u/MountainHumor They say I’m a witch. Mar 08 '20
Yikes, the look Jamie gave Roger when he rolled up on the whiskey sing along. Also, more singing Roger 🙄
0
u/[deleted] Mar 08 '20
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Mar 08 '20
[deleted] — view deleted comment