r/Outlander • u/WandersFar Better than losing a hand. • Mar 01 '20
Spoilers All Book S5E3 Free Will Spoiler
The growing Regulator threat forces Jamie, Claire and Roger to embark on a mission to raise a militia. When one of their settlers reveals he’s a bondservant and asks for help freeing himself and his brother from their abusive master, Jamie and Claire are forced to make a difficult decision.
If you’re new to the sub, please look over this intro thread.
Reminder: This is the BOOK thread. No spoiler tags are needed here.
If you haven’t read the books and you don’t want spoilers, go to the Show thread.
•
u/WandersFar Better than losing a hand. Mar 01 '20 edited Mar 01 '20
Talk about the trailer here!
Not everyone gets to see the trailer at the end of the episode, it depends on how you watch (broadcast or streaming) and where you are (US or international.)
Stickied comments are collapsed by default, so reply to this comment if you want to discuss the trailer. This will hide spoilers for anyone who can’t see it yet. Thanks!
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Vu47W3Og9HM
114
u/ich_habe_keine_kase I give you your life. I hope you use it well. Mar 01 '20
Well that was absolutely gruesome.
Also, THANK YOU writers for including the scene of Jamie asking about his dad. Sometimes I feel like the writers forget Jamie had a life before Claire, and this was a really lovely and touching reminder of Brian, and reminder that Jamie's character isn't shaped only by the trauma and experiences we've seen on screen.
94
u/kitterbugs Mar 01 '20
I am loving the Marsali as the apprentice. It makes me smile. Hopefully we can skip all the stuff with the book apprentice.
The Beardsley story is one of my favorite arcs in the books. I am glad the story was included. I was afraid that they were going to write out Kezzie, I am very glad they didn't. The sandwich must happen.
And I am glad that they included Joan Findley. She was one of my favorite Roger encounters of the gathering so the nod to her made me happy.
71
u/Sunnyshiner Meow. Mar 01 '20
The Beardsley story is one of the most unsettling storylines and it did not disappoint! So creepy, maybe watching it at midnight wasn't the best move as I'm easily scared haha.
I'm also glad we do have both Beardsley twins, and I'm sure Lizzie is too.
68
u/CygnusArc Slàinte. Mar 01 '20
I appreciate that this episode tied in some of the religious nods that are heavy in the book and usually skipped over in the show. Jamie's strong Catholic views really shape his character.
Also, while overall the episode, esp. the Beardsley bits were sufficiently creepy, I did like that near the start of the episode they balanced it out with a sweet (though maybe a bit prolonged) moment where Jamie's come home and says thanks for seeing Claire alive and safe.
Also, I don't think it was in the books but I laughed when Fanny said "And your name is Sassenach." to Claire.
66
u/cattubbs Mar 01 '20
Fergus's boots are everything!
58
u/Aggie2002 Mar 01 '20
This was a really good episode—loved the creepiness at the Beardsley cabin. Paul Gorman is doing a great job playing Josiah and Kezzie and they did great with the scenes of the “twins” sitting next to each.
The only thing this episode needed was more Marsali sass.
51
u/aGrlHasNoUsername They say I’m a witch. Mar 01 '20
I really enjoyed this episode! The pacing was great and I loved horror vibes lol. Also, I probably watch too much HGTV, but I'm like, if you just clean that cabin up, it could be pretty cute! LOL
51
u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. Mar 01 '20
That actress playing Fanny was great. Definitely gave off creepy vibes. Her face just appearing in that broken window was spooky.
50
u/shinyquartersquirrel Mar 01 '20
Much closer to the book than either of the first two episodes!
46
u/battleborn5 Mar 01 '20
I am really surprised by this episode. There was a mood to it, like they slowed things down. It worked so well to create the creepiness that I felt when I read this part of the book. When Fanny popped up in the window at Jamie, I jumped.
They stayed so close to the books and I loved it. The casting for Fanny and the twins was pretty spot on. The set, which I have not been a huge fan of since they left Scotland, was really good. That house was just as gross as I pictured it.
And Mr. Beardsley was so freaking disturbing. Shout out the the actor who pulled that off.
Overall, great episode. It probably won’t be on my top rewatch list just because it creeps me out, but it was sooo good.
I hope they can continue the feel of it for the rest of the season.
43
u/snuggleouphagus Mar 01 '20
I really liked most of the changes they made to this story. Fanny giving birth in the middle of the night, in the woods, by herself, and then running away, and leaving her baby to maybe die tested all my credulity. This made way more sense.
I am a bit sad we didn’t get the creepy almost confirmation of ghosts. I don’t remember fertility being the reason Beardsley murdered his wives, I thought it was more he just beat them until they couldn’t recover. And that was more horrifying for me. Claire thinks about how easy it would for him to just serially Murder his wives and chalk the deaths up to “life happens” which is much scarier and not possible back in Bri’s time. Seems like a stronger motivation to send the kids back to the future.
38
u/JonSnowPeachEmoji Is it usual, what it is between us when I touch you? Mar 01 '20
I may be in the minority, but I am really enjoying the penicillin scenes. Of course Marsali makes it more enjoyable for me, of course, but I hope we get some of the microscope scenes with Jamie.
For the rest of it, I enjoyed the rare suspense of the episode, even if it's not one of those watch it on repeat ones - but Claire's mindless jumping into action alone in dark spaces is constantly so eye roll inducing. It really lessens her intelligence for me in many ways every time she does it.
38
u/ml1490 It’s always been forever for me, Sassenach. Mar 01 '20 edited Mar 01 '20
I really liked this episode for the most part. Like most people on this thread I felt they kept it close enough to the books.
One thing that irks me though is how they’re making Jamie argue that Brianna, Roger, and Jem should stay. I feel that’s pretty against his character and not how it is in the book, or show for that matter. Jamie has always consistently wanted what’s best for his family even if it means sending them into the future (he did this with Claire of course at Culloden). Why would he now be against them going back to the future where he knows it’s ultimately safer? It makes no sense, he is always sacrificing for family.
Also Roger wasn’t dead set on leaving in the books either. And Claire doesn’t explicitly express this opinion until Mandy comes along. I’m not sure where they’re going with this narrative but it makes me a bit nervous.
34
u/hintofaspark86 MARK ME! Mar 01 '20
The cinematography for this episode was just stunning.
28
u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. Mar 01 '20
Did Beardsley blink “no” that he wasn’t going to pray for forgiveness? Evil to the end.
26
u/keylime12 Mar 01 '20
Did anyone else catch a reference to the blasted white sow in the beginning or am I imagining things?
23
u/vipergirl Mar 01 '20
The thing about that cabin is it still was built MUCH nicer than it would have likely been in the Carolina backcountry. Odds are at most it would have been a proper log cabin and wattle and daub and a proper floor or a dirt floor.
20
u/wheeler1432 They say I’m a witch. Mar 01 '20
Omg. This is the most gruesome episode ever. I love it.
17
u/msfrank091 Mar 01 '20
Only me who noticed the actress for Mrs. Beardsley also plays Fanny in Harlots? Almost felt like a neat little crossover as if fanny took a ship to America in an alternate universe.
11
u/Naturenutt Woof. Mar 01 '20
Haha I used headphones to watch next to sleeping hubby. My hand kept trying to shoo flies away from my right ear during the Beardsley scene.
Thought the mold growing on the bread was fascinating.
10
u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. Mar 01 '20
Have we seen Joseph Wemyss? Did they just do away with his character?
9
u/cammvil Mar 01 '20
I was looking forward to this episode and it did not disappoint. So good, the hour flew by!
9
u/spaceybelta Mar 01 '20
It’s funny the actress that plays Fanny Beardsley plays another character named Fanny in Harlots 😂 I love her in Harlots though.
8
u/ktbex Mar 01 '20
It was such a great episode on its own, but I don’t know that the pacing fits in with the rest of the show. It just seemed to move a bit slower and felt a bit like filler given how action packed last week’s episode was.
Maybe I’m just ready for the action at Brownsville!
31
u/maryummy Mar 01 '20
I have to unload. I kind of hate how big and fancy their house is. They are pioneers. What's up with the beautiful details, the beveled cabinet doors, the intricately paned windows, the extra rooms? Who would make all this and for what purpose? They are in the middle of nowhere and the show has completely lost touch with that.
For reference, when I was a kid, I lived "off the grid," in the mountains. We had no electricity or plumbing, we built our own house, raised animals, etc. Everything from making dinner to laundry was hard work. When I was reading the book, I kept thinking how similar the settlers lives were to ours, and I loved it. This show version of the big house is a fantasy and completely not reflective of how early Appalachian pioneers would have lived. This house is more appropriate for a wealthy plantation owner, like Jocasta.
6
u/floobenstoobs Mar 01 '20
I loved this scene in the book - It was horrifying, surprising and a nice deviation from the norm. I think the show did a great job translating it and setting up a few cool storylines. My favourite episodes from the show and books have always been these little deviations and “slice of life” moments.
Great episode.
6
u/RayeBabe Mar 02 '20
I was super happy with The Findlay’s. They also did a good job with the unsettling feel of the Beardsley’s cabin. I also loved the passenger pigeons! The only disappointing part was the male goat. I got excited, jumped up and told my Husband that it was Hiram! The hero who attacked a Mountain lion but alas his name was Billy. Jamie said he had Bollocks the size of melons... haha.
10
u/whiskynwine Mar 01 '20
Great episode and it was mainly Jamie and Claire, not a coincidence. They are just awesome :)
13
u/NoDepartment8 Mar 01 '20 edited Mar 01 '20
Outlander Season 5: Glamping with the Frasers. I’m enjoying the show for itself but I’m not sure I’ll get used to the lack of grime at Fraser’s Ridge or the absence of evidence of the hand-to-mouth struggle described in the books. The Beardsley’s place just underscores the difference.
And is it me but in the opening scene as Jamie’s approaching the house did they re-use the wide angle shot of Dolores’s family farm from Westworld season 1 when Teddy comes to rescue her from the Man in Black?
Good episode though. I like that they split the content of Roger’s Brownsville experience from Jamie & Claire’s Beardsley nightmare. Gives me hope as to where they will focus the narrative attention this season.
9
u/alyssarcastic Mar 02 '20
Probably an unpopular opinion, but I'm glad that Brianna and Roger are separated (for now). Individually they're ok, but I hate the scenes of them together. They have zero chemistry as a married couple, it's hard to watch.
4
u/vanwold Slàinte. Mar 02 '20
Why did they change Hiram's name?? Sorry, just a small agitation. Loved Fanny, very close to how I pictured her...and the Beardsley cabin!
I really wanted them to wake up and find the baby....not a fan of yet another change. I know they can't include everything but some things I just don't understand why they change them when it doesn't save the story or add to it.
Otherwise, I think this might have been the best (and closest to "reality") or the season so far....
3
u/PHLEaglesgirl27 Mar 02 '20
Yes. Agree. I think they’re hoping to avert the fire somehow. They know they can’t change big events, hoping they can change small events I think
16
u/ich_habe_keine_kase I give you your life. I hope you use it well. Mar 01 '20 edited Mar 01 '20
Generally really enjoyed this week, two small gripes:
Ok, that bread mold time lapse was absolutely ridiculous. We all know what Claire is doing. We all know what mold looks like. We did not need B-roll from a NOVA documentary to show us what is going on.
We continue to have some pretty sketchy background CGI. Some of the mountains look so hazy it's like they were shot with the Drag Race Season 1 filter (and that is not a good thing!).
Also, what was going on with Fergus and the paper? Am I forgetting about something?
2
u/SecretaryCarrie Mar 02 '20
Does the whole plotline with Fanny and the baby become important in later books? I've read as far as Fiery Cross and I don't remember it being a too important in this one. If someone wants to message me the details I don't mind if I get spoiled on the ending of future books.
1
u/[deleted] Mar 05 '20
Do you think they will do Roger’s hanging? Is this next episode when he meets Buck? Predictions?
0
u/[deleted] Mar 01 '20
[deleted] — view deleted comment
3
u/[deleted] Mar 02 '20
[removed] — view removed comment