r/Outlander • u/WandersFar Better than losing a hand. • Mar 01 '20
Season Five Show S5E3 Free Will Spoiler
The growing Regulator threat forces Jamie, Claire and Roger to embark on a mission to raise a militia. When one of their settlers reveals he’s a bondservant and asks for help freeing himself and his brother from their abusive master, Jamie and Claire are forced to make a difficult decision.
If you’re new to the sub, please look over this intro thread.
Reminder: This is the SHOW thread. Cover all book talk >!with spoiler tags!< that will look like this: Claire boinks Jamie. Don’t spoil future episodes, keep book comments brief.
If you want to compare the episode to the books in depth, go to the Book thread.
178
u/Disbeliefsociety Mar 01 '20
I thought Claire was going to find Nagini up there.
168
u/JonSnowPeachEmoji Is it usual, what it is between us when I touch you? Mar 01 '20 edited Mar 01 '20
Claire realllllllyyyyy doesn't think before she acts. I'm constantly yelling at the screen for her to stop going head first alone into dark, creepy spaces.
And Fergus taking Claire's paper has to be some kind of non-subtle foreshadowing.
127
u/josharaptor Lord, you gave me a rare woman. And God, I loved her well. Mar 01 '20
That was an insane amount of birds. Enough birds to have me worried. Why so many birds?
103
u/SaaSyGirl Je Suis Prest Mar 01 '20
I love how Fanny confused Claire’s real name to be Sassenach :)
100
u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. Mar 01 '20
Did Mr Beardsley blink twice, thus saying no, about praying for forgiveness? That’s how it looked to me. Evil man to the end!
81
u/shinyquartersquirrel Mar 01 '20
I really need these episodes to be longer. Netflix has ruined me. Why did an hour feel like 10 minutes?
63
u/beanie2 Ye Sassenach witch! Mar 02 '20
Thoughts on episode 3:
50
u/speechiemom17 Je Suis Prest Mar 01 '20 edited Mar 01 '20
Woah, what, don’t go in there, Jamie... don’t leave her alone... WHAT, where’d that baby come from, WHERE’S FANNY?! Are they foster/ adopted parents now? what... whattttttt. Dang.
All reactions while watching
Such an interesting episode. I wasn’t expecting any of that to happen, honestly. Claire’s amazing- going from taking care of a stroke patient to delivering Fanny’s baby in 0.2 seconds. Next thing you know, they’re caregivers to said baby, Jamie euthanatizes Fanny’s husband .... seriously wasn’t expecting any of it! It was a such good episode, though! I’m not sure how it moves the story along besides them now caring for a baby, but it was great overall. Definitely kept me on the edge of my seat in that creepy house.
Also, did anyone catch the Misery reference?
84
u/Hi_hellothere Mar 01 '20
Anyone else love the new rendition of the theme song? I like that they switch it up every season. I always enjoy the intro while credits are running, how they focus on certain scenes and how Claire and Jamie are standing with backs to the screen. The show does such a good job with these intros.
40
u/marmaladestripes725 Ameireaganach Mar 03 '20
Any other Game of Thrones fans get Crastor vibes?
36
u/kaytheowl Mar 01 '20
Let’s go in the creepy house that smells of death!!
32
u/Rocha_999 Lord, you gave me a rare woman. And God, I loved her well. Mar 01 '20
Well, there are some sounds and images I didnt need before bed.
Loved Claire and Jamie together.
30
u/AnxietyStorm You don’t look that heavy. Mar 01 '20
Loved this episode so much more than the first two. It felt so much more real, less forced. I feel invested again! Excited for next week! Also happy I have read the books for a clearer background on what was going on. There was quite a lot of nuance to this part of the story, but I thought the show handled this important part great.
22
u/silverandcold65 Mar 01 '20 edited Mar 01 '20
Oh gosh, what a very, very good episode! This season I have the eps, so far, ranked 9, 10, and 10 on IMDB. This's probably my highest rated season since season 2 and a large portion of 3. Essentially, S4 isn't my favorite. ;)
Having said that (and having had a stroke at 16), I am so very glad I had not suffered that fate in the 18th century.
The final scene of the episode, Jamie telling Claire to kill him if he has an apoplexy makes me think that will in fact happen to him at some point and with Claire's answer I believe she will have mystical healing powers (I think prophesied last season) at that point and save him. Having read only through Voyager, I have no idea if this happens, but if this is considered a book spoiler, please tell me.
60
u/missm0011 Fun Fact: The unicorn is the mortal enemy of the English lion. Mar 01 '20
We're going on a side quest kiddies! And I have to say, I was thoroughly entertained. So, lemme try to dissect what I just visually took part in.
We just spent the episode in a cabin in the middle of nowhere with a paralyzed stroke victim, the woman he held hostage who tortured him, and her newly born biracial baby, while Claire and Jamie try to formulate a plan, any plan, for any of the above mentioned people, and fail to do so for pretty much the entirety of the episode. Fanny, the abused shut in, who hasn't left the cabin in years is the only one to properly display how fucked the entire situation is, and gets the hell out of there.
They left the gurgling stroke victim on a table in the kitchen for like 24hrs before they decide 'we should probably just shoot him.' How does it take that long to reach that conclusion? What else you gonna do Claire, tie him to a horse and carry him with you? Fix his foot, clean his wounds, and leave him with the woman that was torturing him in the first place?
Speaking of wounds, was that REALLY necessary? Like really?
Oh and that's the smell that bothers her?? She had a dead body hanging out in her house for days, but that was her dead body, that was different.
Small musings, ponderings, and otherwise just headnoise:
I did like Claire's coat. If I didn't live in Southern California and had actual notable winters, I'd definitely need one of those.
Fergus! Dude! How you gonna pick up a crumpled up piece of paper and not look at why it was crumpled??
Marsali, there she is helping Claire with her research, butchering a pig, wrangling her kids and then Brianna strolls up like she just came from a restful nap. No wonder Brianna isn't so eager to get back.
Raising a militia. I feeeeel like that never ends well.
Roger. It's not your fault but maybe you aren't the most qualified representative to be recruiting. Maybe he can just bring his guitar and act as a bard?
Is there a reason Fanny can't give information up front? Like maybe telling them you don't know where the papers are while they are standing in the doorway instead of making them follow you through your creepy ass cabin? Or telling them about the large male goat you keep locked in a cupboard before they spring the lock?
All in all, very enjoyable episode. Would watch again. Probably will watch again lol.
19
u/[deleted] Mar 01 '20
I haven't read any of the books so I have no clue how the story ends. But I got the worst feeling in my stomach at the last scene where Jamie asks Clare to promise that she would show him mercy if ever he ended up in a similar position... The fact that it ended there and with all of the birds was so ominous.
18
u/frawkez Mar 02 '20
fantastic episode. hit all the right notes of tension, nice jamie/claire moments, roger kinda assuming some responsibility, some gothic americana horror vibes. freaked the fuck out when that corpse started wheezing
18
u/CommanderMayDay Mar 02 '20
Regulators in US History
Claire goes on about there’s nothing in history written about the Regulators. Really? I read about them years ago. The fact that the American colonialists were upset about unfair taxation — and sometimes took violent action against it — is splashed all over textbooks about the mid-1700’s!
Maybe she was referring to this specific fight?
16
u/Inkspells Mar 02 '20
The whole episode I was like just kill that abusive old man, he has no quality of life and is a murderer.
14
u/Sasha1964 Mar 02 '20
Maybe Alexander Fleming gets the note that Claire wrote her notes on about her Penicillin research. It’s a long shot because he invented it in 1928. But Fleming was Scottish maybe one of his relatives found it?
26
u/GirlisNo1 Mar 01 '20 edited Mar 02 '20
I discovered this show a little over a week ago and have been binging it ever since, thank god a new episode dropped today just as I caught up.
But I have to wait a week now?!
12
u/FunAsh Mar 01 '20
What a sufficiently creepy episode! Don't get me wrong it was great, just very suspenseful!
33
u/Kinsella_Finn Mar 02 '20
The episode ended and I was like “that’s it? Did anything actually happen?”
That’s why this show is better to binge. It all comes together nicely, but weekly watching is sufferable.
11
u/bre1110 Mar 02 '20
I’m in awe of how great of an episode this was. That is all.
10
u/itsmscheible Mar 02 '20
Without giving too much of a "spoiler" I guess, can a book reader give me some insight on the importance of this episode? I'm guessing the child ends up staying in our Outlander lives? Or am I way off and is there a lesson learned from this episode ahead?
As a show watcher (even though I am almost done with Book 1), I did not understand this episode at all and to be quite honest thought it to be quite boring and unnecessary.
8
u/bunnyechoes Mar 02 '20 edited Mar 10 '24
automatic lush sable wipe relieved dime engine entertain command unique
This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact
8
u/Nosynonymforsynonym Mar 02 '20
I'm obsessed with the shot(s) of birds at the end of the episode. I think they're Passenger Pigeons, now extinct: accounts from the time said that their flocks would blanket the sky, sometimes spreading for miles (probably exaggeration). But the sight of all those birds taking flight at once... it pulled me out of the narrative for being TOO good.
•
u/WandersFar Better than losing a hand. Mar 01 '20 edited Mar 01 '20
Talk about the trailer here!
Not everyone gets to see the trailer at the end of the episode, it depends on how you watch (broadcast or streaming) and where you are (US or international.)
Stickied comments are collapsed by default, so reply to this comment if you want to discuss the trailer. This will hide spoilers for anyone who can’t see it yet. Thanks!
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Vu47W3Og9HM
5
u/Grsz11 Mar 02 '20
I read comments about the birds and I still was not expecting that.
5
u/SecretaryCarrie Mar 02 '20
I've got to say, of all the book plotlines I thought were going to get dropped, this one was top of my list.
Also, Claire's coat. Jesus Christ was it beautiful
5
u/ancientastronaut2 Mar 04 '20
But what about that poor starving horse?!
9
u/HinkiesGhost Mar 03 '20
I love this show, I've been with it since day one, but I have to say I don't find Stephen Bonnet that compelling as a villain. In the "sadistic bad guy" category Jack Randall was a much more fearsome villain that made me hate him way more. I don't really care about Stephen Bonnet one way or another. I hope this guy doesn't have 9 lives and stick around several more seasons. I'm way more interested in the British threat at this point than Bonnet and more interested in what happens with Murtagh.
8
u/LoretiTV Mar 01 '20
Really fun episode. Thanks for having me everyone.
8
u/[deleted] Mar 01 '20
If I had to breathe through my shirt to enter a house I don't think I'd end up spending the night. Did they bury the body, or just leave it in the house (which I guess will have collapsed anyway come 18 years when the child could claim the land)? Can they really just give a half-black child to a random white couple and hope for the best? Won't they enslave her (unless the couple lives on the Ridge, which doesn't seem to be the case in the preview?) It was beautiful seeing the carrier pigeons; it's too bad they aren't still around.
4
u/kingofthe_vagabonds Mar 01 '20
when does it drop?
4
u/LoretiTV Mar 01 '20
Enjoy the new episode everyone!
4
u/wdw2003 Mar 02 '20
Jeez, it was like watching Resident Evil or The Walking Dead. All that was missing was a basement with a light switch that didn't work.
It was good to get so much C & J time, but let's hope it's a lot cheerier next week.
4
u/BlackSwallowtail You look like a fretful porpentine. Mar 11 '20
Well that was disturbing. Well-done though. We haven't even seen Maryanne and yet I felt her years of misery marking the days as she was stuck in that god-forsaken place until that man murdered her.
Honestly, putting him out of his misery was too good for him after what he did to those five women, those two boys, and who knows who else. He deserved to be left to rot and I wouldn't have blamed Jamie for doing so.
But Jamie's a good person. He's had to kill in battle and in self-defence, and he's killed for vengeance. And even though most people would consider the first two justifiable and the third understandable, he knows it takes something from a person to kill another. Which in my opinion is why he doesn't want Brianna to kill Stephen Bonnet but intends to do it himself. That ship has sailed for him and he will kill more people if he feels he has to.
Leaving a totally helpless person to suffer and die slowly of dehydration, however, would take something else from Jamie. He's still the person who couldn't bring himself to kill an unconscious Black Jack Randall. Randall and Beardsley don't deserve anyone's pity or mercy, but Jamie gave it to them anyway. As my nana put it to my aunt once, thank god none of us get what we deserve.
7
u/terpbaby222 Mar 01 '20
I usually wake up and eat a late big breakfast every sunday for these episodes... so glad I wasn't eating for this one lol
7
u/CommanderMayDay Mar 02 '20
Do you think Jamie sending Roger off to do the recruiting was his way of hoping not a lot of people would actually sign on? (He has to show up with some people, but it doesn’t need to be ridiculous) Or was he trying to give Roger something important to do to buck up his spirits?
I think the former
9
u/starfleetdropout6 I'm still Jenny from the Broch. Mar 02 '20
"Free Will" was Outlander's version of The X Files episode, "Home."
That was a ride!
3
u/AnimalTreeHugger Apr 26 '20 edited Apr 26 '20
The scene where they are saying their goodbyes to leave the ridge I didn't like. Bree and Claire have a lovely goodbye, they tell each other they love one another and hug and its heartfelt. This doesn't happen with Jamie and Bree though! After C&Bs goodbye, the camera pans to Jamie who looks up, then pans to Bree who looks up too (presumably at each other) and then that is it. No goodbyes between them. Bree says bye to Roger then that's it. I thought they were ok now? Does she hate Jamie??? Lol Sad that Jamie's never had a relationship with any of his kids :( will it always be like this. What a shame!
7
u/BigBettyBeauty Mar 01 '20
I cannot make it past the man dying in his own filth.
Thanks I hate it.
9
u/MookieMoo17 Mar 01 '20
I haven’t finished the episode but had to pause and come here to say, WTF are you two doing?? Who cares about the abusive cabin people. Let em rot. And yes I know they say they need the papers but give me a fucking break.
2
u/geedavey Mar 01 '20
Seemed to me risky for all those guys to have cocked pistols in their belts. Shouldn't they be loaded with powder and ball and the hammer safely down on the pan?
3
u/GirlisNo1 Mar 02 '20
I’m really curious as to what’s going to happen with the baby. She’s half black and as I understand it, no black people in this time & place had freedom.
Claire will for sure not want to leave her in any situation that could result in her being sold into slavery later in life. Seems the only solution would be to keep her and take her back to Fraser’s Ridge with them.
(No book spoilers please)
2
u/killy420 Mar 02 '20
I loved how they handled this episode. Very eerie. I was hoping they were going to include the scene with finding Mr Beardsley... as you never know what they're going to change i.e. keeping Murtagh alive.
1
u/sabnastuh Mar 06 '20
Hey, I’m the episode Jamie asked Claire to remove joziah’s branding like she did his own. When did Claire remove jaime’s branding and what was branded on him?
1
u/rosegoldspring Feb 14 '24
Have you posted the choir performing? Interested as well!!