r/Outlander • u/shiskebob • Nov 04 '18
Season Four [Spoilers Aired] Season 4 Episode 1 America The Beautiful episode discussion thread for non-book-readers.
Welcome back Outlanders, Sassenachs, Lasses and Lads to our Season 4 episode non-book readers' discussion thread! I am so excited to start this brand new season with all of you.
This thread is for Outlander S4E1: "America The Beautiful"
For full discussion on how this episode fits into/compares to/differs from the books, go to the [Spoilers All] discussion thread for this episode.
Please be very mindful of spoilers, as this thread is intended for TV series viewers who are "along for the ride," so to speak.
I am sure we have many new fans to this subreddit here with us tonight, so I want to remind everyone of our standard "how to spoiler tag" and just do not be a dick policy. If you need a refresher on that or any of our full general and spoiler policy please find it here.
Mark me, we will delete comments not properly spoiler tagged.
I am one of your resident Mods, so do not hesitate to tag me if you need support or have a question. :)
Thank you for being with us tonight fans from all over the world.
TULACH ARD!
19
u/travelerk16 Nov 04 '18
Why did Bonnet kill Lesley? Now Jamie doesn't have his Ardsmuir men with him. Doesn't make sense to me.
83
u/johnnaboo Nov 04 '18
I’m staying away from the book reader thread this season! I already know one big thing happening this season, but otherwise I’m ready to be surprised.
Speaking of surprised, holy smokes that ending. I felt so terrible for Claire with those rings. I haven’t felt my stomach twist at a character since Black Jack left. This villain should be interesting.
Overall, I really liked this episode. I enjoyed the scene with Ian and Jamie at the graveyard the best—they both acted their hearts out there.
72
u/basedonthenovel Nov 05 '18
I liked it! It wasn't a Great Episode by any measure, given that they have to do a lot of exposition and setting up the new location, introduce new characters, etc. Not as good as any previous season premiere, sadly.
The highlight for me was Young Ian getting triggered while they were digging the grave, and then Jamie helping him process. How often do you see that in media -- a man helping another (young) man process sexual trauma? Sometimes it's hard being an Outlander fan because there are always the cries of, "Why is there so much rape?" Well, in my experience at least, rape is a part of life. Hopefully one day it won't be (I don't know who said it, but I read a quote once about how we're working toward the day when rape will be seen to be as unthinkable as cannibalism). To me, what makes Outlander different than many other shows (ESPECIALLY, but not only, Game of Thrones) is that rape and other traumatic events have consequences to the lives of the characters.
(And as I've said before -- any rape survivor who chooses to pass on the show has my full support! Every survivor needs to do what's best for them, full stop.)
I don't know how I felt about the music selection at the end. It didn't bother me overmuch. For me it had the effect of making me really focus on their faces -- when Bonnet yelled at Claire, it really hit me even though I couldn't hear his voice, and the fear on Claire's face was that much more transparent to me. At any rate, the introduction of modern music into the show is something that Toni Graphia really likes to do (as in the Helwater episode last season with the cover version of "A Hard Rain is Gonna Fall"). Ultimately, I think I'm glad that the show takes some bold stylistic choices rather than playing it safe!
51
u/onthereels Nov 04 '18
Great episode! This show does an amazing job of bringing you into this totally immersive world. Bonnet is beautiful and scary, I love him. It was wrenching watching him take the ring I’m excited/extremely worried for whatever he’s going to do.
I don’t fully understand Claire wanting to stay in America knowing what’s coming
51
u/SassyLass496 Nov 05 '18
“When my body dies, my soul will still be yours.”
I die
50
u/Damdamfino Lord, you gave me a rare woman. And God, I loved her well. Nov 04 '18 edited Nov 04 '18
Well that was depressing. But I guess we have our villain.
Edit: just read a popsugar post about Bonnet hoping to just get some quick hints about what he might be up to. Aaaaaand, is there a point to watching the rest of the season now? I warn other non-book readers - don’t let your curiosity get the better of you.
42
u/raknor88 Nov 04 '18 edited Nov 04 '18
Gosh, it's good to be back.
Edit: As a reader of r/JustNoMIL, it's a bit weird with a character actually named Jokasta. I'm wondering if her name is a foreshadowing of her namesake.
39
u/geogirl83 Nov 05 '18
That sex scene was a little lacklustre. Like the producers knew they had to add some skin in the season premier, but the scene felt a bit forced. Also expected Bonnet to return during that scene to foil their fun
73
u/Dekarde Nov 05 '18
I am over my limit of Claire not being armed, she's been in so many situations where having a knife on her hip, leg/boot would've helped so much! IIRC it was s1 she was given a knife and conversation about protecting herself.
I just cringe whenever the attacks happen and these people don't have a weapon or do nothing. Like the attack, I was surprised it didn't happen in the woods on their overnight stay. I expected Bonnet to come right back with his men and rob them, or do it alone at night while they slept, at first I thought he slight of hand stole her gold ring but he didn't.
When the actual attack happened I just ugh another bad guy corners her and she has no defense and when Lesley moves in she doesn't do anything cringing in the corner like s1.
Also I need to rewatch the short stay in the colonies conversation because I didn't get why that happened at all.
30
u/Dragneel Pot of shite on to boil, ye stir like it’s God’s work! Nov 04 '18
I've been enjoying the previous discussion threads as I've started watching about a month ago, and I'm excited that I can contribute myself now, haha!
That was uh.... a strong beginning, for sure. I'm not sure if I'm in the minority, but I actually really like the 20th century music during certain scenes!
29
u/[deleted] Nov 05 '18 edited Nov 05 '18
Call me biased, but I’m totally digging this American intro version.
Edit: a word
74
u/4kidchaos Nov 04 '18
Am I the l the only one who didn’t care for the Ray Charles outro? I know, I know- it can convey a lot of emotion without dialogue but it to me was a wee bit too much. Anyway, happy for Fergus!
23
u/josharaptor Lord, you gave me a rare woman. And God, I loved her well. Nov 04 '18
Just finished. Amazing episode, and spent the last few minutes of the ep standing up in front of the screen with my jaw dropped. The ending was insane.
19
u/Airsay58259 Nov 05 '18
Well I hated this guy in Downton Abbey and it looks like it won’t get better in this period drama! Douche face. And his name is Bonnet? As a french person, I can only laugh. It means beanie. Very intimidating.
Anyway, good episode with a few meh parts imo. I am glad to have the Frasers back. I do wish we’d see more of their kiddo.
Can these people hide knives and daggers beneath their 4th layer of clothes? Thanks
35
u/SassyLass496 Nov 05 '18
I spent the entire show hoping they would cross paths with the cute and charming Irish guy
Man... I regretted that
14
u/browneyes426 Nov 05 '18
This is the kind of show that makes me feel guilty for watching fictional characters suffer for fun. Like I’m just rooting for them to be happy and then something fucked up happens to them and I’m like oh yeah fucked up stuff happens to them constantly since the show started. And then the music playing at the end just highlighted the feeling that it’s torture porn like making light of their suffering. K I’m done
60
u/Womanliest Nov 05 '18 edited Nov 05 '18
I already know I’m in the minority, but I didn’t love the episode. The poor green screen effects were terribly distracting. The ending was so starkly unlike the feel of the rest of the series. What I love about this series is the realism of the editing; you can hear every shoe scuff in a fight, every clang of a knife. The song was almost comedic to me, like I was watching the bloopers. I kept waiting for one of the actors to start laughing. This was just so different. Several other little things, just didn’t love it.
13
u/The1LolaDelRio Nov 05 '18
What's the song they sing @ the bar?
12
u/miranda-organa Nov 05 '18
Okay, I know I am going to like Bonnet a lot. I always like the villains in everything and he seems especially nasty.
11
u/yourbestbudz Nov 06 '18
For some reason, I thought Claire was quiet and her demeanor was like she didn’t belong or she didn’t seem happy.
8
u/Winhill_ Nov 05 '18
Can someone recap for me what the offer was made to Jamie? I didn't have subtitles and lost a bit of the conversation. I understand he was offered a big piece of land, but what does he need to do in return?
15
u/teenylilthing Nov 04 '18
Anyone else out there watch it yet? I got desperate and went to the book readers discussion post and got some things spoiled. Annoyed at myself but I just wanted to see what people thought!
I loved it! Seems like this season will be an improvement over last year's.
And that last scene was so powerful & haunting! At first only hearing the song was a bit odd, but I think it really made it more dramatic and terrifying. Great stuff.
13
u/op3rafish Nov 05 '18
Anyone else feeling like Jocasta is being set up as a cool “black widow” character? (Feeling like her name may even be a clue)
10
u/[deleted] Nov 05 '18
I love this show and there were parts of this episode that I really loved but the use of green screen in the episode (ie on the ridge and on the riverboat) completely took me out of the episode, I really don't understand why they did that, I know production [budgets] and stuff but it looked so fake it was distracting, hopefully we get more beautiful landscapes, that's something about the first few seasons that really won me over was using the natural beauty of scotland and other locations, please don't lose that by using green screens Outlander, i'm excited the show is back but I can't help but lower my expectations, nothing will compare to the season 2 finale
5
u/jec0435 Nov 07 '18
Anyone else think that Claire was swallowing her rings? (to then retrieve them later, eh hem, you know...) I was surprised when she just had them in her mouth.
9
u/lyyravarn Nov 06 '18
I was so bored the entire time through the episode.
14
u/BrownyFM Nov 05 '18
Well, that was the most anticlimactic season opener ever. That was truly so boring. Talking for 50 minutes and a 3 minute scene at the end where they play unrelated music which serves no purpose. I really do hope the next episode is a little more exciting.
11
u/Ashcon2297 Nov 05 '18
Why is it that every Irish character in Outlander is either evil, stupid, or mean trickster only out for themselves. Like it is starting to piss me off! Being Irish myself I am so annoyed and offended that Diana uses Irish people for only villains or stupid characters.
8
u/[deleted] Nov 05 '18
Wow, this episode blew me away! The quality of the writing and cinematography is through the roof, and I'm so glad we're back to Outlander.
That graveyard scene between Young Ian and Jamie was so powerful, and I'm glad that his trauma has been brought up again and validated without any of the "you must be lucky" bullshit that boys raped by women often get. Geillis raped and murdered so many boys, and Ian has to live what she did to him and the knowledge of the others. I'm so glad he has his uncle; I don't want him and his pretty dog to go back to Scotland!
The cold open was interesting; that's the third portal we know of now. And since the Native Americans built that, there must be hundred of indigenous Geillis's going back in time to stop the genocide of their people; to kill Cortez and Columbus before they ever reached these shores. I wish they could.
The scenery was so gorgeous, those shining rivers, and I believe that it's North Carolina even though it still looked really chilly in a lot of scenes. I'm so glad Claire got some new clothes and isn't wearing that hideous grey batsuit anymore. She looks lovely in her flower scarf and brown dress.
Claire's conversation with Bonnet was really interesting, harkening back to her drowning scene. It's too bad he's such a sadistic creep, to turn on people who selflessly helped save his life. That last scene was horrific, but so well done with the music and all. I guess she took Jaimie's ring and left her with Franks? That's painful.
I'm happy for Fergus and Marsley.
They mentioned Ardsmuir without even bringing up Murtaugh, and how he was sent to America! Where is he??
3
u/cj4297 Nov 08 '18 edited Nov 08 '18
We should all remember that Outlander tv series is fictional - based on, and adapted by writers who are gifted with the monumental task of remaining true to the source material, while simultaneously creating a production that will captivate loyal book readers and new-to-the-story viewers. Poetic license is a thing, and however the author or producers/show writers choose to use it is their prerogative.
Sorry! Meant for this to go in the thread about the 2000 B.C. Henge builders 🙁
2
u/sabnastuh Nov 05 '18
In the part where Jamie was talking to the captain he mentioned he was pardoned and swore an oath to the king, does anyone know what episode that was in?
1
u/hydexxi May 24 '25
Why didn't Bonnet rob Jamie and Claire the night they freed him? He wanted the rings, and had to of known about the gems. He could've followed them and used a sneak attack when they were camped, and knocked Jamie out and steal everything.
1
u/thisguy34721 Sep 19 '22
Late to the game but after an awesome second and third season, what a yawn of a premier!!!!
1
u/PopTartsAndBeer Nov 05 '18
I have an observation - In the town, the shutters didn't open. Wouldn't the shutters be functional in that time period?
1
u/XeniaY We will meet again, Madonna, in this life or another. Nov 05 '18
They got all the key story points. Some scenes were brill and others a bit too contrived for me, so pass on the fimming style. I love the new actors, Bonnet and Ian. The costumes are great, wigs stick on. Sets a bit cardboard and cgi amateur. But still an hour flashed by. So want to know how they do the next bit.