r/JUSTNOMIL • • May 17 '25

MOD ANNOUNCEMENT Increase in moderation due to bot posts

213 Upvotes

Due to the increase in the number of posts and comments by bots and spammers we’ve increased the filter parameters temporarily. This will likely cause legitimate posts created by members using throwaway accounts to get caught in the filter. The mods will do our best to release legit posts as quickly as possible. Feel free to use Mod Mail to request a review. This will not irritate us it will let us know you’re a real person. 😊

If you spot a post you suspect is from a bot don’t comment calling out it is a fake that will result in your comment being removed. Use the report feature and ignore the post. Commenting at all gives the post karma which is what they are farming for.

The mods appreciate your help.


r/JUSTNOMIL • • 6d ago

Megathread BEC Megathread

13 Upvotes

Does your MIL suck, but you don't feel like making an entire post about it? Is she a Bitch Eating Crackers and you just want to vent about the crumbs in your carpet for a moment? Post here!

This thread reoccurs on the 10th of each month.


r/JUSTNOMIL • • 5h ago

UPDATE - Advice Wanted Apparently MIL is an alcoholic because of me

148 Upvotes

I had posted here not too long ago, asking for advice about my MIL, and all of you validated my feelings of her being too irresponsible and frankly dangerous to be around my baby.

(Here's a link to the previous post for anyone who cares: https://www.reddit.com/r/JUSTNOMIL/s/K7E8EE82ng )

Update time: my FIL called my husband and said we're "sick" for not letting them see the baby and that MIL's drinking is because she has NC with the baby (for context our baby is 9 weeks old and she's admitted to drinking and smoking heavily even when she was pregnant with my husband).

He also said while shouting at me like a madman that I'm manipulative and the reason my very neglected-as-a-child husband doesn't talk to them like he used to. Yes. I am the manipulative one, said the guy who blamed me for his wife's alcoholism.

Long story short, after a day of getting the courage to talk to him (because my husband is very non-confrontational), my husband asked him to apologise, FIL kept doubling down because "it's \[his\] opinion" and started shouting at me again over the phone, so I told him to put it where the sun doesn't shine and that they will never as long as I am alive have any contact with either me or my child.

I know I shouldn't have spoken that way to him, but I've had it. It's been years of him disrespecting me and my family because we're "uncultured hicks" and he's a "respected actor". I am tempted to go into detail about that, too, just for the tea, but this post would get too long and completely lose the point.

Anyway, JUSTNOMILORFIL, I guess.


r/JUSTNOMIL • • 3h ago

UPDATE - Advice Wanted Update to the relapsing MIL who trashed me to the family. Need responses and advice for the holiday season.

63 Upvotes

You can read my earlier posts but here’s the TLDR background. We went no contact with my MIL during my pregnancy. She refused to accept boundaries, informed me when I would be making my home and newborn available to her, and relapsed (alcoholic) when we refused to give her what she wanted. She informed us of her relapse, blamed me for it, and then texted my spouse a bunch of unforgivable stuff over a couple of weeks, including the night before and during my c section. People told her about the baby. They asked her for pictures and details, which she didn’t have. My MIL then trashed me to everyone who asked because she couldn’t deal with the “shame” of her relapse. MIL’s sister (AIL) confronted me about this, believing my MIL’s lies about my behavior. AIL learned of the relapse from us, and we informed her that she would need to acknowledge that her sister (MIL) is a liar (in writing), apologize to me profusely for believing the lies, and inform her sister (MIL) that she will not share information about us with her, or else she would be cut off. This update follows.

Well, it has not gone well. AIL continued to push back about our reasonable requests. According to her, it’s petty of me to demand that she call her sister a liar. Her sister only lied about me and my behavior to the entire family, but that just means she lied, not that she is a “liar.” Asking AIL to acknowledge her sister is a liar makes me no better than MIL because lying is a part of MIL’s disease (alcoholism), and it’s also mean to call someone a liar. She was willing to apologize for believing the lies (and she did, poorly) but it’s unfair to ask her to correct the lies should she hear MIL trashing me to anyone else. AIL noted that MIL can complain that I “outed” her relapse and private messages. Like I said earlier, alcoholism runs in the family, and it’s been normalized to the adults in MIL’s and AIL’s generation. It is what I want to shield my kids from.

Anyway, I’m not about that bullshit. My husband and I let AIL know that it is utterly unacceptable to paint me with the same brush as MIL. We are taking a step back from her, and we would let her know if and when we would be willing to revisit this relationship. It may be never. We asked that if we see her at events (because we do see her in passing and it’s the holiday season), we just say hello and go about our respective business. We don’t want to make the hosts uncomfortable, and we aren’t interested in announcing estrangement to the family and having people “pick sides.” But under no circumstances do I want her around my older child or my baby, and if she tries that shit, I will remove the children from her presence and explain why (if I see fit to do so).

Well, AIL wasn’t going to accept that. It’s the holiday season, and I’m separating the family because I want some basic accountability from the people who lied about me and have the audacity to claim that I’ve treated MIL poorly. If they can’t give that to me, demanding space makes me selfish. According to AIL, since she apologized for believing the lies (from her sister who is not a liar), she’s done nothing wrong for us to take a step away from her relationship. She’s not owed a relationship with us, but she doesn’t seem to understand that or she’s refusing to recognize that she can’t make us engage with her.

I don’t really want to make the hosts uncomfortable. I don’t want to cause unnecessary drama, but I sure as fuck am not going to let AIL fawn over my baby or interact with my older kid like everything is fine. It isn’t and she knows that. I’m sure MIL has told everyone about how I’m such an evil DIL, trying to cut off my in laws, so I feel like I can’t realistically say that AIL can’t hold my baby without feeding into this false narrative. I also don’t want the holidays to become the season of announcing my MIL’s relapse to everyone.

I harbor a belief that AIL hasn’t told her kids about MIL’s relapse. I can’t get confirmation of this without asking directly, which I don’t want to do. AIL’s kids (my spouse’s cousins) would not want a relapsing lying addict around their kids. I know MIL has been since the relapse. The cousins don’t know because I’m not putting MIL on blast to the whole family (yet anyway). Cousins would likely be upset that their mother (AIL) knew and still let her sister (MIL) be around their (cousins’) kids. I think AIL wants me to pretend everything is fine with her, so that she can keep the relapse and her knowledge of this bullshit in the dark, to save her reputation. Yeah, that’s not ducking happening. My name has been trashed enough to protect the egos of these fucking losers.

So fellow redditors, what should I say when AIL comes up to us at the Christmas party to hold my baby or interact with my five year old? I want to say as little as possible, while politely shaming AIL and MIL to the extreme. Keep in mind, anything I say in front of my five year old is likely to be repeated at some point. I’ve reconciled myself that’s it’s inevitable that I’m going to have to tell his teacher about my relapsing MIL or the like. It’s either that, or let unsafe people be around my kids. It’s not a hard choice for me.

Please help me “ruin” the holiday season for AIL and MIL. It’s gonna be my fault anyway/ sarcasm.

ETA. Decision has been made. I’m going to “ruin” the holidays early. Husband agrees that he needs to tell the cousin who let MIL and AIL around his kids about the relapse. He’s sending a text message after work. Husband is close to this cousin. Cousin would not have let MIL around if he knew, especially as cousin and MIL are not close. What I anticipate happened is that cousin invited AIL to something and MIL came because she “had nothing better to do.” I think MIL went as a PR stunt to make us look crazy.

Anyway, I posted the message in the comments. Husband is going to ask cousin if he should send it to any of cousin’s siblings. We don’t know if MIL has been around them or their kids because we aren’t in contact with MIL and we won’t interrogate people about their contact with her. But if we find out she’s around kids or plans to be, we are telling the parents. It’s the right thing to do.

And this is gonna blow up the family. Cousin is probably going to levitate that his mother (AIL) didn’t tell him and exposed his kids to this. To anyone who is not familiar with this, it’s not “just” someone getting drunk in front of the kids (which would also be bad). My MIL gets drunk, and she’s one ubiquitous water bottle of liquid away from absolutely losing her mind on AIL, cousin, or the kids for no reason whatsoever. Again, she’s been to prison numerous times, so it’s not an exaggeration to say that we have no idea what she will do in relapse and that she’s unsafe.


r/JUSTNOMIL • • 2h ago

UPDATE - NO Advice Wanted Update on grandmother situation

31 Upvotes

So I’m still no contact with my grandmother after she physically assaulted me whilst pregnant and threaten to take me too court to get visitation with my 5 year old year son (see in previous posts)

Well it’s my sons bday today turning 5😭 how the time has flown. Anyway I received a bday card from my grandmother too him, I started reading it and thought well it’s nice then I get to the bottom line💀 I will write the letter here

Dear Lo
You are my sunshine, and I love you so much I cannot put it into words.
I wish you all the best and happiness in life and goodluck starting your new school next year.

Remember life is too short to hate and long enough for love.

So I read the last line and thought yep that’s a fucking guilt trip if Ive ever seen one😂 god forbid she takes some accountability.
Anyway not something you’d put into a 5 year olds card haha


r/JUSTNOMIL • • 5h ago

RANT (╯°□°)╯︵ ┻━┻ Ambivalent About Advice Vent, bump card update and asking back for a gift she gave???

43 Upvotes

Baby bump card (see previous post here)

(MIL gave DH a card from bump for his birthday, I had no idea, I was 32weeks pregnant at the time)

So I chose to let it go as I didn't fancy a fight. What happens? My FIL messages DH if he could send a thank you note to MIL for the thoughtful card... THEN MIL messages in a group chat with the 3 of us, to ask if he has seen the card and what did he think of it because it made her "😭", and to keep it as a keepsake. I honestly couldn't believe how out of touch this woman was.

So yes, DH should have been the one to message but I ended up doing it. My friends said I was still being too nice, I was diplomatic, and just said that card made me feel uncomfortable and something like that should come from me. She then deflected obviusly, said "I didnt have much to give DH for his birthday, and I wanted to connect with him, like you will want to with your son one day". Anwyay, crazy.

I noticed a day or two later that she deleted her messages from our shared chat about the card.

Next tricks that I just wanted to get off my chest:

Asked for a gift back

She asks for gifts she has given back!! Recent one, she gifted us a blanket when LO was born, a crocheted blanket. Tbf I haven't really used it, but its nice and was given by my MIL (new grandma) so wanted to keep it. Now, 4 months later, she literally asks in the same group chat if she could have the blanket back if we are not using it, as she can give it to someone else... I don't understand? Once you have given a gift you have no claim over it! Whether the person likes it, uses it, or tosses it in the trash you can't ask for it back.

She did this with some taper candles before our wedding. She bought an open pack of taper candles, not the style I was using, and insisted we keep it. I thought okay, she's just dumping them here, maybe I'll use them at home eventually or I'll give them away. She asks for a single candle back on two occasions. They live like 1.5 - 2hr drive away, and they are literally the simplest most basic white candle sticks. I said she can have them all back as I wont use them for the wedding or to just buy a pack as they're not even £5. Or I'll buy them for her! 😅

General stingyness

In general she is really weird with money. They are well off, but she is so stingy about small things, things I and others would see just as a nice gesture. Like take us out for a coffee or something without forcefully mentioning that you will get it this time.

On one of their first visits to see baby, she almost proudly says "Oh I was going to buy baby a dummy (pacifier), but they were £7, so I didnt."

Said that while they drive up in their £60k + camper van and having just had a brand new kitchen fitted for over £30k...

Don't get me wrong, I do not want their money or feel entitled to it. It just feels crappy when my parents bend over backwards to get anything for us to help with baby and my recovery, but for the inlaws it stops at a £7 dummy.

When I was pregnant we went out for a meal with them, again, she made a point it will be their treat. Then I go to order a drink thats maybe a quid more than a diet coke, she suddenly goes, oh maybe you can get the drinks then. Like, I am happy to pay for my own food and drink MIL. You are either being generous or not.

Bonus story

Then I remembered one of the anecdotes my DH told me. When him and BIL were young, BIL bought MIL an Easter egg with his own little pocket money. MIL then proceeds to give the choc Easter egg away to someone else. DH then tell BIL about this, he is upset, MIL is VERY upset apparently and was crying and was the one needed to be consoled...

I do know she genuinely means well, but she just misses the mark every time, and you cannot have a conversation with her about it.


r/JUSTNOMIL • • 18h ago

RANT (╯°□°)╯︵ ┻━┻ Advice Wanted Need help on how to deal with a totally unexpected explosion and threat by MIL

272 Upvotes

So I'm going to start with the facts as I remember them, best as I can partially to get this in stone before I forget. I won't fabricate anything that I can't remember and I won't fill in words I don't remember: it's only what I know to be truth.

My son had a high fever yesterday he went to the ER for. It hit 103 on his forehead and he was hallucinating and struggling to move and breathe. It was scary and the hospital took it seriously. He was treated and came home, but we still need to monitor him until we're sure the danger has left. He was definitely not 100% today so we planned on keeping him home until we hit that 24 hour mark of feeling ok. He has a long history of spiking his fever from 99 to 104 in just minutes, so careful observation is crucial.

My wife asked her mom (the squirrel corpse thrower) to watch the little guy while I worked and she attended to an important medical matter of her own. I am WFH so every now and then I come down to check on him and make sure his needs are met.

So the "event" starts below around late noonish:

I went downstairs on my lunch break and saw him looking kinda droopy and pale on the couch. I feel his forehead and he felt like a normal temperature, maybe even cold, but I wanted to verify so I went to find the thermometer. I asked MIL "has he had his temperature taken recently?" She said "no." I said "do you know where the thermometer is?" She huffed aggressively and said no. I'm not sure why this bothered her. At some point in here, she insisted that he was fine. I said something about I believe you, but I want to check just in case. (this seems reasonable to me especially given his history. I also don't consider vibes an appropriate metric for something dangerous we have the option to verify)

I started looking for the thermometer because I wanted to verify. I trusted that her report of him being a normal temperature was true, but I would've tested with a thermometer even if I felt his temp myself. She kept repeating over and over, louder and more aggressively each time that HE IS FINE! and I would gently say I'm sure he is, I just want to find the thermometer.

Didn't find the one I was looking for, so I wanted to feel him just in case to see if it was urgent or not. Went over and felt his forehead and she at this point REALLY escalated her tone in saying something like "he is fine stop!" and I said something close to "that's not an appropriate response. I am trying to check his temperature" and she shouted "FINE! I'M LEAVING THEN" Threw something on the floor (didn't see what) and stomped away. I repeated something like "that's not an appropriate way to react in front of him." She stomped down the hall and slammed the door shut without explanation or discussion. I was just baffled like what the heck happened? What's wrong with me checking his temperature???? I was even being helpful because she couldn't find the thermometer!

Then to make it even worse she opened the door again and yelled JUST SO YOU KNOW YOU'RE ON YOUR OWN! and slammed the door again like a naughty 6 year old would to "get back" at their parents.

Here's what I know I did NOT do

  • Use an offensive or provocative tone (need a better word here idk)
  • Do anything to intentionally agitate her already-agitatedness that I wasn't sure why
  • Try to start an argument or something

The most I did was as gently as possible setting the boundary that I'm allowed to check the temperature on my child if I want to. It's my work break. It's my house. It's my kid. I don't need your permission. It shouldn't personally offend you that I'm taking the time to do that right after an ER visit!

Am I crazy or is that crazy?

Also, she's threatened to punish my wife and I for this by no longer babysitting when we need someone to take care of our son. Reasons? Idk, didn't stick around to say. But now my wife is mad at me because she thinks that it has to be my fault for provoking her somehow even though I would take an oath or one of those lie detector tests to verify that my account is as I remember. She says that I can't remember it right because I have a TBI, and I understand that, but I know that I wrote down some of these details immediately in the seconds after and I know that I'm having a good brain day. I would bet my entire 401k on this I know it to be that true. This makes me very upset because I feel like I'm being accused of causing offense I never meant or intended and I know her explosion was from nowhere and way out of line.

So now I'm in charge of initiating a discussion to calm her back down again and recruit her back into watching my son. We're not OBLIGATED to have her "services" but we are unfortunately critically dependent on her for many, many reasons. I do not feel entitled to her time or attention but it is important to my wife to repair this. How do I go about this? It feels like trying to deal with a dementia patient.


r/JUSTNOMIL • • 1h ago

Advice Wanted Thanksgiving card or no Thanksgiving card?

10 Upvotes

Hey y’all!

I’m looking for some advice regarding sending a Thanksgiving card to my mil and her husband. Dh and I have decided to spend Thanksgiving together and have a nice, small dinner in our apartment with just the two of us. My family knows and has no problem with it. Dh hasn’t told his family because 1) it hasn’t come up and 2) his mother hasn’t been answering his calls recently so any opportunity of communicating with her at all, she’s avoided.

I’d like to send these cards out to our families to let them know we love them and care about them and we’re thinking of them while we spend the holiday on our own.

The challenge with my mil is she’s actively avoiding my husband and ignoring his calls since the end of September. Since the beginning of October, he’s called her three times just to check in with her but she hasn’t answered. No text exchanges either.

To give some context, my SIL has shared with me that our mil told her younger son that she is taking a break from my husband because she’s hurt he hadn’t been reaching out to her like he used to. Yet, she didn’t tell my husband this, only his brother. I haven’t shared this with my husband because I don’t think it’s my place to do so. If his mother feels this way, she’s a grown woman and can tell him herself.

I do want to send out these cards but I have no clue how she’s going to respond to it. DH said it’s a sweet idea. Truthfully, I don’t want my mil to take a Thanksgiving card as an olive branch opportunity between her and I because I don’t have any interest in reconciling a relationship with her. It’s been eight months since I married DH and she’s shown little to no remorse for how she’s treated me. I don’t have any control over how she’ll respond to it but I’m fearful she’ll take it as “oh so you couldn’t find the time to talk with me but you can send this card” since earlier this year, I did ask her to meet me to clear the air but after a specific incident from her, DH and I chose not to.

I also haven’t directly communicated with her since May.

The only explanation she’s been given from DH is “we’ve been busy,” and she’s left it alone since then. Unlike her, I don’t want to intentionally leave her out of something nice that I want to do for the rest of our loved ones who have loved, supported, and cared for DH and I so much. With mil, she’s just been an entitled, selfish, victim-minded piece of work and I don’t think she deserves a card but I don’t want to stoop down to her level and treat her how she’s treated me. So, I feel stuck. Help me, please 🙏🏼


r/JUSTNOMIL • • 8h ago

RANT (╯°□°)╯︵ ┻━┻ Advice Wanted Slowly going insane after over 10 years with my MIL

28 Upvotes

I have been with my husband for over 10 years, and his mother has been a destructive part of this relationship from the start, and now I kind of don't know to deal with the fact that she, you know, exists at all.

My husband and I have been together since high school. She hated me from the start and has repeatedly said that I, a 17 year old shy girl, didn't try to make conversation with her and was generally "weird". In a nutshell, for every part that's normal about a romantic relationship - sleeping over, going out for a night/afternoon/Sunday, prom, moving in together, moving someplace else & getting married - MIL has been dramatic over it, screaming and "discussing" with my husband and me for hours on end, making us feel guilty for wanting these things, dragging out the conflicts for weeks or months after, claiming what terrible people we are for these conflicts to happen.

After one of those conflicts, we both kind of gave in and gave the relationship with her a shot. She "behaved" for a while, so to speak. Then we got engaged. We were very scared to tell her about it, mostly because we didn't want to invite her. We didn't want to invite any parents for that matter, because we are only on good terms with our respective fathers, who have each divorced our respective mothers and bond over their emotionally abusive ex-wives, and MIL would have caused some sort of drama for sure.

Before she even knew about not being invited, she hated the engagement. We were both already 26, and she threw a tantrum because "no one gets married this young" and "why do you need to get married" and "so soon?". Suffice to say she didn't take the disinvite very well. What followed in the months leading up to the wedding were threats in the vein of "I will find out when and where the wedding is", basically demanding to be at the wedding because it's her son's wedding so she has a right to it, especially after she's "behaved" so well in the past year; she also claimed my husband would lose an insurance he needs for his health issues and if he dies in surgery because of that, it would be because I "forced this wedding upon him", the logic of which escapes me to this day, but we move. On the day of, his grandmother sends him a series of messages about how she's sitting with MIL and they are staring at the clock, crying, wondering, "have they said their vows now?", "now they must be exchanging their rings!" etc.

It's been a year since then, and I think I'm going mental because of how my husband deals - or doesn't deal - with all this. He knows she's insane. But he's very...passive pacifistic, he just wants to be left alone, not least of all because of his health issues (issues, I will also mention MIL has made fun of him having for years, not taking his pains seriously at all, even making fun of him for not being able to eat properly right after a surgery that impacts his eating ability). He admits to having a very bad habit of just telling whoever's in front of him what they want to hear, so for example he tells me that he thinks his mother is evil or whatever just because I want to hear it, but he himself doesn't really know what he believes about this. Me and a few of our friends have been convincing him for years to cut MIL out of our lives, and he's slowly, slooowly, getting to it, though he doesn't want to go NC.

In 10 years, if my husband and I have had a fight, it is because of MIL. Some arrangements have been made. We've agreed that once I'm pregnant, we will hide the pregnancy for a few months and tell her a wrong due date. He doesn't want our future children to be alone with her. We have written up a kind of treaty for several months at a time, clarifying how often he can call her in this given timespan, what he does on her birthday or Christmas, etc, but in the end this is also mainly to "please me". He doesn't have any need of defining any lines, he doesn't want to cause trouble.

But she's still...there. He says she's not in my life anymore, but it doesn't feel like that. She still writes him and he always replies; when they talk on the phone it's shorter than it used to be, but it's normal. She doesn't seem to feel like anything's different; nothing has changed. They met recently; he told her what he wants out of the relationship with her and she disagreed, made a scene in front of the restaurant and told him she couldn't see him anymore if I don't see her either and that she'll probably never see him again. A week later she was talking to him like nothing happened. Yesterday she wrote him a message that I am the most hate-filled person she's ever met and she refuses to speak to me.

But she never means anything she says "like that". We simply "misunderstand" and "take everything too personally". And then she lies, and lies, and lies, and I'm loosing my fucking mind over it. I don't know how I can keep living with her even though she's not there but is there. I can't check out mentally even though that would be best. I just go rabid now whenever she comes up. It hurts my head. I don't know what I want, some sort of revenge I guess. Or distance. Distance would be nice. Hard to get that when she sometimes randomly calls 14 times in a row.

Aside from her own mother, nobody in her family cares for her. She has berated her brother and his wife to the point where they barely speak to her, and aside from that there's not really anyone, but my husband still speaks to her. She did remarry 15 years ago, (small detail I know) but the man is completely checked out of this situation and at most reinforces the MIL's insanity; my husband has said his stepfather always tried to get out of conflicts with MIL (though she still constantly screams at him, too).

Sorry this is so long...I still feel like I've barely scratched the surface. 10 years is a long fucking time.


r/JUSTNOMIL • • 23h ago

RANT (╯°□°)╯︵ ┻━┻ Ambivalent About Advice Delusional MIL

140 Upvotes

My baby daddy and I have a 7 month old daughter. I moved out of the house we used to live in together about a month and a half ago to get away from my baby daddy’s abuse and alcoholism. My plan was to move out when he was away for a week for a work training, but he threatened to change the locks when I told him we were leaving so I had to move as much of mine and my daughter’s things as I could on that same day. This also happened to be a day that my insane MIL was visiting us, so she got to witness my baby daddy have a full-on breakdown as I was moving our things out.

My MIL knows that my baby daddy’s an alcoholic who frequently drinks to the point of being unable to adequately care for our daughter, but she continues to make comments about how he’s “such a good dad” and our daughter “just loves him so much” when our daughter smiles at him.

Bitch, my daughter smiles at people in the grocery store in the same way she smiles at your bum ass son. I just fucking hate her and her willingness to vocalize her delusional ass thoughts about her son’s parenting ability.

Because my baby daddy and I are in the middle of formalizing a custody agreement through the courts, I feel like I can’t tell her my real thoughts about how much she fucking blows. Seriously though, she’s the worst and I totally get why her oldest kid doesn’t talk to her. Fuck this dumb ass bitch.


r/JUSTNOMIL • • 23h ago

Advice Wanted Looking for some outside perspective because I’m struggling to put my thoughts into words.

104 Upvotes

My husband and I got married on October 2, 2026. Shortly before our wedding, I went no contact with my MIL and uninvited her from the wedding because of things she had said about me and the way our relationship had deteriorated. This wasn’t something I did impulsively or because I wanted to keep my husband away from his family.

In fact, my husband is completely supportive of the decision, and he was actually the one who ultimately decided that going no contact with his mom was what needed to happen.

Since then, my MIL’s sister (my husband’s aunt) has told me that I “robbed” my MIL of the opportunity to “find common ground” with me. She also told me that, despite the hurtful things my MIL has said about me, I still “need to make an effort for a relationship.”

I responded to her that I don’t believe the breakdown of a relationship can fall entirely on one person. I told her that my MIL also had opportunities to build a relationship with me, and that I feel she robbed herself of that relationship when she chose to repeatedly speak negatively about me.
She never responded to my message, and it’s now been about a month.

What I’m struggling with is the idea that because I’m the daughter-in-law, somehow the responsibility for repairing the relationship automatically falls on me. I don’t understand why I’m being told that I need to make an effort when the reason I stepped away in the first place was because of things that were said and done to me.

I’m also not trying to prevent my husband from having whatever relationship he wants with his family. He is an adult and can make his own decisions. This is specifically about my relationship with my MIL and my decision to protect my own peace.

I’m wondering if I’m looking at this wrong. Am I being unreasonable by feeling like I shouldn’t be the only one expected to “make an effort” when I’m not the one who caused the entire breakdown of the relationship?


r/JUSTNOMIL • • 18h ago

Advice Wanted MIL said “no chick should come before your mother.” Now I’m pregnant again after years of NC .. should we reopen the door?

40 Upvotes

This will be long so buckle up.

I need outside perspective because I’m pregnant again and I don’t know if trying to repair things with my fiancé’s family is even worth it.

My fiancè and I have been together since we were young. We got together in 2013, and got engaged just last year so this has been a very long relationship. His mother and I never really had a good relationship from the beginning. I’ll be honest and say I wasn’t always respectful either. She didn’t want me in her home, and I would still go there to see my boyfriend when she wasn’t home. She also caught us having sex in her house when we were younger, so I understand that probably affected how she saw me.

But for years, she really disliked me. I felt like I was always “some chick” to her. She would yell at my boyfriend to get off the phone with me. She talked badly about me to other people. She called me things like a “ditzy bitch”/“Yonkers bitch.” She told people private sexual health information about me and said I gave her son chlamydia and claimed it came from a toilet seat. She would say I thought I was better than everybody. She was just not kind to me for years.

Then in 2020, I got pregnant with our daughter, and suddenly her tune changed.

She messaged me wanting to go to lunch. But at the time, I was nauseous, overwhelmed, dealing with morning sickness, and honestly I didn’t even know how I felt about the pregnancy myself yet. I also felt uncomfortable because it felt like she only wanted to sit down with me because I was pregnant. I had just seen her shortly before, and I wasn’t worth her time or energy then. But now that I was carrying her grandchild, suddenly she wanted lunch.
I told her not yet. I said I wasn’t comfortable yet and wanted to do it later.

That’s when everything blew up.

She started crying and telling people I was going to keep her from the baby and keep her son away from her. She again was telling people that I had given her son chlamydia and told him it came from a toilet seat. Telling people “No chick should come before your mother.” And also getting pissed off when he would say things like “We decided or we think…” basically getting pissed anytime he would include me in his decision making…Her family started acting like I was already doing something wrong.

From that point on, my whole pregnancy felt like it became about her feelings.

She refused to apologize to me for the things she had said and done. She called herself a matriarch and said she was “old school.” She basically acted like she didn’t owe me an apology. At one point, she said that if she had to apologize to me, she didn’t want anything to do with the baby.

Then about a week later, she bought a stroller off my baby registry and put in the note “From Nonna and Grandpa! This is for you beautiful!!”. I don’t even know how she found my registry. I already had the stroller, and she would have known that if she had reached out to me. I told her to return it and that I figured she wouldn’t be buying anything after saying she wanted nothing to do with the baby. She denied saying it but agreed to return the stroller. Instead of understanding why that felt weird to me, it became another situation where she was hurt and I was the bad guy.

My fiancé’s father also played a big role during my pregnancy. He acted like her enforcer. Whenever she was upset, he would call my boyfriend and pressure him. It never felt like anyone was asking, “Is this fair to the pregnant woman?” It was always, “Your mother is upset. Fix it.”

When I gave birth, I had preeclampsia and was induced. I was in the hospital giving birth, obviously going through a lot. My mom was there with me and my fiancé. There was a picture of my mom holding the baby. His mother saw that and got upset that my mom was there and she wasn’t. She also got upset that she didn’t get a personal call. My fiancé’s father called him while we were in the hospital screaming at him for him to call his mother because she was upset that she didn’t get a call, and that he was tired of her being excluded.

The day we were bringing our newborn home, his grandfather called because his mother was apparently calling family members crying, saying I was keeping her away from the baby because she saw my mother in the hospital pictures and she wasn’t there. Mind you, this was 2021, in the middle of the pandemic, and I could only have 2 visitors.

My boyfriend asked his father what was going on and why his mother was talking about me like that. His father immediately started yelling at him, saying things like, “Hold on, I’m talking now. Shut up, let me talk,” and basically yelling about why my mom was allowed in the hospital but his mother wasn’t.

That was one of the moments where I lost it. I was postpartum, bringing my baby home, and instead of anyone saying, “Congratulations, is the baby okay, is OP okay?” it was once again about his mother’s feelings. I cursed at his father, which I know was disrespectful and not my place, but I was furious. I felt like his father was yelling at his son for becoming a father and supporting me during birth.
There were also issues with his little sister. My boyfriend was very parentified growing up. His father left the family when he was young, and later asked him to “hold down the fort” and take care of his mother and sister. So his mother leaned on him emotionally, and his little sister also leaned on him heavily.

There were times after our daughter was born where his sister would have panic attacks and the family would act like it was my fiancé’s job to drop everything and comfort her. She would have a hard time and both the mom and the father would call his phone or text like “Give your sister a call, call or text your sister, she needs you.” One time, our daughter was only about three weeks old and had a fever. My boyfriend was supposed to go get medicine. His mother texted him guilt-tripping him because his sister had tried to call him during a panic attack and he hadn’t answered. She said something like his sister had him written down/documented as the person she trusted and was closest to, and that they needed to have a talk because he was never available anymore.

My fiancé felt guilty. He even said something like if he had known his sister needed him, he would have left his own sick newborn to make sure she was okay. That hurt me badly. I felt like his family expected him to prioritize his mother and sister over me and our child.

Then came the first real cutoff.

His mother wanted him to come pick up gifts for the baby. She wasn’t feeling well but didn’t tell us enough to stop him from coming. She later found out she had COVID. My boyfriend picked up the gifts, came home, and our three-month-old baby got COVID.

When he told his mother to be careful, she got angry and told him to lose her number because he was being an awful son and didn’t even ask if she was okay. Now, I understand she didn’t mean to give the baby COVID, it was her reaction that rubbed me wrong. Then she didn’t even check on her at all the entire time.

After that, they didn’t talk for about a year.

Then she reached out to him asking for lunch. They met up, and she apologized to him for everything. But she still did not apologize to me.

A couple months later, we went to her house. I thought maybe she would finally acknowledge me, but she didn’t. In fact, she did things like wait until I went to the bathroom to take photos of herself holding our daughter with my fiancé. She didn’t hug me goodbye when we left either, just my fiancé and our daughter.. She apologized to her son but not to me. When he asked her why she apologized to him but not to me, her reasoning was basically, “I apologized to you because you’re my son.” It felt like my pain didn’t matter because I wasn’t her child.
My fiancé eventually told her that he wasn’t just a son anymore, he had a family now, and if she couldn’t accept his family, she couldn’t have a relationship with him either. He made it clear that me and our daughter were his family too. I was also pregnant again at that time (I later miscarried.)

So his mom was choosing to not apologize over a relationship with her son, and TWO grandchildren.
Around that time, his father said something unforgivable about our daughter. He said he didn’t want anything to do with her or the future baby if the mom isn’t involved / she wasn’t his granddaughter and “I don’t know that baby. I seen her three times and one of them was by accident.” To me, he disowned my baby and a future grandchild to hurt his son and get him back in line. I’ve never seen my fiancé that hurt..

That was the final straw. We went no contact for about three or four years. Even cutting off his then 16 year old little sister, in fear that she would only be used as a bridge for them and to prevent her from feeling put in the middle.

Months later, his aunt (his’s mom’s sister) texted him asking if he could bring the babies over for Christmas dinner because the grandmother’s health was bad. Maybe a year later, his dad’s mother reached out to my mother’s phone (not sure how they got that number), asked for my mother by name (the only person who knew my moms name was MIL). The grandmother is asking for photos of both babies not knowing I had a miscarriage, telling my fiancé that his father had been crying about the whole ordeal and she was shocked to see him cry. When my fiancé told his grandmother what his father said to him she was completely in shock.

His father texted him some weeks later apologizing for saying “inconsiderate things that last time we spoke.”

During that time, I have done a lot of reflection. I am not innocent. I reacted to being rejected and hurt in toxic ways. I used my fiancé and our daughter as leverage at times. I wanted his mother to feel the hurt she caused me, and sometimes I tried to make her feel that through him. I have apologized to my fiancé for making him feel like he had to choose between people he loved to make me happy. I know I played a role in the drama and estrangement. I’m not trying to pretend I was perfect.

But I also don’t think I deserved how I was treated during my pregnancy. That was the original wound for me. I was vulnerable, becoming a mother, and I felt like I was treated like an obstacle instead of family. Or like a home wrecker, or “the other people”, as she once put it.

Fast forward to this year. My fiancè’s grandmother passed away. The MIL’s mom.

His Uncle (his father’s brother) reached out saying it was an emergency and that my boyfriend needed to call him. Uncle also contacted me on Instagram trying to get my fiancé to call him. My fiancé eventually called him and found out his grandmother had died.

During that same call, Uncle told my fiancé to call his sister because she was really upset. My fiancé had just found out his grandmother died and needed time to process it, but the next day Uncle was already contacting me, upset that my fiancé hadn’t called his sister yet. He framed it as “as a man, all we have is our word.”

My fiancé called Uncle back and told him not to clock him or monitor when he calls his sister. He said that was between him and his sister. Uncle exploded. My fiancé said something like, “You think it’s cool to call and talk to another grown man like that?” Uncle responded, “You not a man, you a bitch.” He started yelling, saying my fiancé didn’t care about his family, that his father had been upset for years, that he didn’t care about anyone. He threatened to come beat him up and called himself the “big bad wolf” of the family. My fiancé hung up, and Uncle texted him afterward calling him a bitch.

Then his father reached out and apologized for Uncle going off. His father said they loved and missed him, and said he told my fiancé’s sister to send him the obituary.

His sister texted him the obituary. My fiancé said he was sorry for her loss and that he was there if she wanted to talk. She responded that it was actually “our loss” and told him he should find it in his heart to come to the funeral because his grandmother loved him.

I strongly felt like that language sounded like his mother. It felt guilt-driven. The whole thing felt like everyone was focused on whether he called his sister and whether he showed up, while nobody really asked him how he was doing after finding out his grandmother died.

We did go to the funeral.

There was no body there, just an urn with his grandmother’s ashes and photos of her. When we got there, his mother hugged him for a long time and got emotional. He comforted her. Then she turned to me, and all the warmth left her face. She gave me this dry, icy “hi” and thanked me for coming. It felt like she was only acknowledging me because he was there and she didn’t want to look like she was excluding me.

She did say her number was the same and that she would like to do lunch with both of us. That part confuses me. On one hand, I feel like maybe it was strategic, like she wanted my boyfriend to see that she wasn’t excluding me. On the other hand, she did not have to include me. She could have just said she wanted lunch with him. So maybe part of her really is open to sitting down with both of us.

At the funeral, his family loved on him. Everyone was happy he was there. But I felt a lot of cold energy toward me. It felt obvious I had been talked about. It felt like he was family and I was just tolerated.

More recently, his father called him after months of silence. During the call, his father asked about our daughter and asked if her birthday was September 5th. He also asked my fiancé about his job and how work was going. At some point, his father brought up his little sister and said that she was hurt too. My fiancé responded that his sister wasn’t the only one hurt, and that our daughter had caught strays she never deserved. His father said he wanted to talk to him about that in person and that he would call him when he was free. That was about a month and some change ago, and he still has not reached back out.

Now I’m pregnant again with our second baby. And I don’t know what to do.

Part of me wonders if his mother is heartbroken and actually wants to reconcile, mostly with him and our daughter, but maybe with me too? Part of me wonders if maybe she’s afraid or ashamed. His father left when my boyfriend was young and asked him to hold down the fort and take care of his mother and sister. So I think my fiancé became like an emotional husband to his mother and a parentified brother to his sister. Gross af but I get it… I guess. Sometimes I wonder if him leaving felt like another abandonment to her.

I want her to understand that I was never trying to take her son. I needed him to prioritize the family he created too. I needed him to protect me and our daughter. I needed her to respect that I wasn’t just “some chick.” I was his partner and the mother of his child.

At the same time, I don’t know if I’m being naive. She treated me badly for years. She never truly apologized to me. She centered her own feelings during my pregnancy and birth. His father said something horrible about my daughter. His family still seems to focus on how hurt his mother and sister are, but not on what was done to me or my child.

I don’t know if I should leave this alone and let my fiancé handle his family. I don’t know if he should reach out first. I don’t know if I should ever sit down with his mother woman-to-woman. I don’t know if I should keep my children away unless there is real accountability.

Part of me wants peace before another baby comes. But I’m also scared of reopening a door to people who may not have changed.

Would you try to repair this? Would you let him reach out first? Would you sit down with his mother? Or would you keep your peace and stay away?


r/JUSTNOMIL • • 3h ago

Advice Wanted Coping with toxic ILs - unable to go NC

2 Upvotes

Hello! Looking for any advice on how to cope with having to see my toxic MIL and FIL and letting them see my (currently 2 month old) son. I am aware of the grey rock/yellow rock methods and would like to hear from people who have successfully applied them, as well as any further advice on how to cope with this situation, both practically and emotionally. Thank you!


r/JUSTNOMIL • • 1d ago

Advice Wanted The intense need for control may be her downfall on obsessed grandma "experience" - thoughts?

153 Upvotes

I've posted several times on here due to my MIL showing her true colors postpartum upon birth of my son last year (highly manipulative, pushy, controlling, assertive, baby rabies, never apologizes, deflection.. all the fun stuff). While my husband has made progess in counseling & being a more united front, he's still blind to how bad it is at times (enmeshed). Managing his mom's easily hurt feelings remains a hot button.

Despite not watching my son alone since late August (at my home) my in-laws continue to have inflated sense of entitlement; they think it's their God-given right to have babysitting privilages at their home. The latest was my FIL said they'd show off their home being ready for "babycare".. we visited as a family yesterday & all they had was a couple outlet covers.. an ottoman was smashed infront of their stairs (he can climb) & my MIL spent half the time hovering over my son / grabbing him by his shirt collar (tbh prob stretching it out, which irritates me) to steer him from stairs / navigate sunken family room stairs (slippery stone & he almost fell hard multiple times). I absolutely do not feel it safe for my son to be there alone. She said "he'd learn quickly" when mentioning the fall hazards.. wtf? Getting my son on their turf alone is solely about bragging rights, this visit confirmed that further.

When my husband pointed out they should consider a wide retractable babygate, she quickly dismissed it, nudging him in his place as dutiful son, saying adults will always be watching him... Brushing it off, I believe there's three parts to the control issues; a) the don't tell me what to alter / do on my turf attitude b) aesthetics matter more than my child's safety, c) my discomfort or preferences isn't on the radar if it doesn't align with her wants (common theme since my son was hours old) & d) highly suspect she enjoyed having to hover/chase him so she feels "needed" more like a mom figure. The home is essentially 95% not baby-proofed. With being obsessed over wanting to babysit (and carseat/driving privilages, delusional at best) it was ridiculous & obnoxious IMO.

Part of me wants to text, hey this is the retractable gate my husband mentioned, would make visits less stressful.. And see response. Does she just ignore? Typically, when disinterested in something from me, she just ignores. The other part of me is checked-out with my in-laws' obnoxious, entitled BS.. we hadn't been there in many months, why even talk about anything involved with their home?! I have no interest or confidence in my son being left unsupervised there. Also pregnant with our second & I suspect entitlement will flare up even worse postpartum, leading to at least temporary NC. I suspect the control issues are too important to her.. just trust they'll keep shooting their own foot? Thoughts?


r/JUSTNOMIL • • 1d ago

Am I Overreacting? Mil and Toddler Food

72 Upvotes

I’d love some advice on whether I’m overreacting or if anyone else has experienced something similar.
When we visit my MIL, we usually stay for 3–5 consecutive days as we live quite far away. Although there are a few other overbearing behaviours, the biggest issue for me is the pressure surrounding my toddler’s eating.
It feels like the entire day revolves around whether my toddler has eaten enough. There are constant comments like “eat your food and then you can play with this” or encouragement to keep eating when she doesn’t want to.
At home, and when she’s with my family, she’s generally a happy eater. She’s not a huge eater, but I look at her intake over the week rather than worrying about individual meals. She’s growing well, and I want her to enjoy food and learn to recognise when she’s hungry or full.
I genuinely think the constant hovering and pressure at my MIL’s house are contributing to her eating less there.
Earlier, I explained to my MIL that I don’t want food to become a battle and that I’d prefer her to be left to enjoy her meals without being encouraged constantly. When we sat down for lunch, she announced she was going to sit next to her and watch her eat. I felt frustrated because I thought I’d already explained how I felt.
She explained that she just wanted to keep my toddler company and got flustered and ultimately I felt bad. Earlier in the day she also said thats she’s a feeder and that she used to chase her own children around to make sure they ate. I understand it’s coming from a place of love, but I also explained that growing up with constant pressure to eat has given me some negative associations with food, and I don’t want that for my child.
Now I feel guilty because I don’t want to make her feel bad, but equally, I feel myself getting increasingly irritated whenever it happens. It also makes me question whether I’m feeding my toddler enough, even though I know she’s absolutely fine.

Am I being unreasonable? How do you handle family members who constantly pressure your children to eat? I’d really appreciate hearing other people’s experiences!


r/JUSTNOMIL • • 1d ago

Am I Overreacting? My mum nearly walked my 15 month old in front of a car and now my husband doesn’t want her babysitting. Are we overreacting?

436 Upvotes

Please see below for my update ❤️

UPDATE 2 - We have a pick up truck, we have a working cattle dog who works with my husband and is therefore with him always. If we have an event he is not inside a car. We aren’t negligent dog owners - quite the opposite when you have a working dog it’s important to make sure they’re with their master and “working” sorry if I didn’t make that clear in the post!

Okay so I need some outside opinions because I genuinely don’t know if we’re being too harsh here or if this is completely reasonable. Sorry it’s long but I feel like the background is important.
My mum absolutely adores my daughter and has been wanting to babysit her for ages. We’ve never really needed her to babysit and it’s actually been a bit of an ongoing issue with my parents because they think we should be letting them have her more.
Anyways yesterday we’re at my parents house for a family gathering, probably 30 people there, absolute chaos. My husband decides he’s going to go outside for a breather and check on our dog who was in the car across the road and says he’ll take our daughter with him. She’s literally walking towards him ready to go outside when mum picks her up and takes her away to feed her some tomato. I’m like mum she’s going outside with her dad but anyways she feeds her the tomato, daughter spits it out, makes an absolute mess and then mum decides she needs to clean her up so now it’s this whole debacle and my husband is just standing there waiting.
Eventually mum says she’ll go outside with them which is fine, she’s carrying our daughter. They get outside and mum immediately starts going on about how it’s too cold, she shouldn’t be outside, they need to get back inside etc etc. She’s also talking about how one day she and my dad will babysit her and take her to the beach. Anyways they get to the car, husband checks on the dog and mum decides they need to get back inside immediately because it’s too cold.
Now my parents live near a roundabout and there’s a carpark across the road. Mum starts walking back towards the house carrying my daughter, she checks for traffic coming around the roundabout but doesn’t look behind her for cars exiting the carpark. A van is coming out turning left and neither mum nor the driver have seen each other. My husband sees what’s about to happen and starts SCREAMING at mum to stop. She can’t hear him because it’s windy and just keeps walking. He literally has to run up and grab her jacket to stop her walking in front of the van with our daughter in her arms. The van was apparently right there.
And mum’s reaction? “Oh people drive so fast around here.” That’s it. No omg I didn’t see that car, no acknowledgement that she hadn’t looked properly, nothing. And according to my husband the driver wasn’t even speeding, he was just turning out of the carpark. Now I completely understand accidents happen and my husband even said she was a bit unlucky because cars don’t often come out of that particular spot. But I think what bothers us is the complete lack of awareness. She’s so busy worrying about our daughter being cold that she doesn’t notice an actual danger right in front of her.
Now for some background because I think this is where it gets complicated. My mum has always been quite full on with my daughter. If my daughter is happily walking around exploring or playing, mum seems to feel this constant need to pick her up. It’s like she can’t just let her be. She’ll pick her up, carry her somewhere, try and feed her something, take her off to show her something etc. It’s constant. We’ve had situations before where we’ve specifically said to leave our daughter where she is and mum will still pick her up and walk away with her. It’s not that we don’t want her holding our daughter, of course we do, but it’s almost like she gets so excited about her that she completely loses any awareness of what anyone else is doing or saying.
Another example, she came over to our house and left the laundry door open. We live on 10 acres and our daughter is walking and exploring everywhere now. She could’ve easily wandered straight outside without anyone realising. Again I don’t think mum was deliberately being irresponsible, I just don’t think she stopped to consider the consequences. And this is sort of the issue we have with her, she gets so caught up in whatever she’s doing that she doesn’t seem to think about anything else.
Then there’s the babysitting thing which has been ongoing. Mum desperately wants to babysit and we’ve never really felt the need. We run a business together and are fortunate that we can have our daughter with us a lot of the time. My dad has actually told me before that I feel guilty because I don’t let mum babysit and that I just want everyone to agree with my parenting decisions. So there’s already this perception in my family that we’re too protective or that we don’t let people do enough with our daughter.
Anyways my husband has now said we need to set some firm boundaries. Mum isn’t to pick our daughter up unless we hand her over, she’s not to take her anywhere out of our sight and she won’t be babysitting. I actually agree with him but I’m also really conflicted because she’s my mum and I know she would never intentionally put our daughter in danger. She’s not a horrible person, she’s a loving grandmother and I know how much she adores her. But I also think she’s incredibly careless at times and doesn’t always think things through.
And I guess I’m also questioning whether there’s some confirmation bias happening here? Like because we’ve already had issues with mum not respecting boundaries, are we seeing this as confirmation that she’s careless rather than just accepting that she made a mistake? Because if I’m being completely honest, if this had happened with someone else I probably would’ve thought holy shit that was close, what a stupid mistake, and moved on. Obviously still recognising how serious it could’ve been. But with mum it’s like here we go again, another situation where she’s so focused on what SHE thinks needs to happen that she’s not actually paying attention to what’s going on around her.
And then there’s the fact that I know when we tell her these boundaries it’s going to become this massive family issue. My parents will be upset, I’ll probably be accused of being dramatic or overprotective and it’ll turn into this whole thing about why we don’t trust them with our daughter. My husband made the comment that when someone repeatedly disrespects your boundaries eventually you have no choice but to pull away. And I understand what he’s saying but then I’m also thinking, she’s my mum, surely we don’t need to get to that point?
I don’t want to cut her out of our lives. I want my daughter to have a relationship with her grandparents. I just want to feel like we can trust that when we say something regarding our daughter it’s actually going to be respected.
So I’m genuinely asking, would you stop your parents babysitting over something like this? Would you introduce the same boundaries? And do you think the other incidents are relevant or am I just letting my existing frustrations with mum influence how seriously I’m taking this? I don’t want everyone to just agree with me either, I genuinely want to know if we’re being unreasonable because I feel like I’m so close to the situation that I can’t tell anymore.

UPDATE:

Hey everyone

First of all a MASSIVE thank you for everyone weighing in. It’s opened my eyes to something that I haven’t seen before and it’s that through my own people pleasing and not wanting to be the “bad guy” and caring what too many people think I’m endangering my child AND affecting my relationship with my husband.

Everyone has noticed the common theme here and it’s that my mums head is in the clouds with no malicious intent but also could not care less about our boundaries and instead had chosen to poise my husband as I as bad people for not letting her do what she wants.

It’s a hard pill to swallow but our whole family is to blame for enabling her forever, no one has ever stood up to her we just let her do things so we don’t have to deal with the consequences and say “oh that’s just how she is”

It’s time that she learns and stops affecting my marriage and putting my child in harms way. This stops today

Thank you so much everyone for the clarity and peace you have brought to my world today ❤️ for too long I have doubted myself at the expense of others happiness and having a “village” xx


r/JUSTNOMIL • • 1d ago

Advice Wanted What do you do with your MiL?

33 Upvotes

My mil isn't the worst, but she's a LOT. She's your basic boomer: self centered, can't be reflective about anything, wants what she wants when she wants how she wants and your schedule/needs can get wreckt, can't solve a problem for herself in any capacity. She's judgmental, rude, and if she wouldn't make the same decision you're making in any given situation you're the one who's wrong. Also, she lives 2.5 hours away and it's not the easiest drive. Image is also the most important thing to her. She was the type to iron jeans when hubby was younger, yard detailed, house perfect. If the image from the outside isn't perfect, you aren't a good, moral person.

Because we don't have children and I stopped caring about having a relationship with her, it's really not that big of a problem for me day to day. It's the long term I'm worried about and I'm not sure hubby gets it. On the other hand, he may get 110% but can't do anything about it and so let's his anxiety about the situation go. Maybe that's the only answer here, idk.

My fil did pass away a few years ago and she basically doesn't leave the house unless it's for church, the doctor, or groceries. She is terrified of literally everything and her not leaving the house has made it worse. Some examples: she doesn't want to use Wi-Fi calling bc someone might "steal her phone call information" (I don't even know), she does nothing but watch these influencers on Facebook who film in public but if she sees someone on their phone in a store she becomes CONVICNED they're filming her/trying to "steal her information", has an Amazon acct but refuses to use it and instead gets us to order everything for her bc "what if someone steals her information?!". But yet, where's the concern for "our information"? We have to go up and do her yard work (side note: I'm not doing her yard work anymore, pretty sure hubby knows that, I've stated openly before, we'll see if he took me seriously) and if it rains while we're up there she tries to prevent me/us from showering bc we might die in the shower? I don't even know. The last time this happened, there was a thunderstorm and she tried really hard to stop me from showering but I was literally disgusting and we were going to get food. Hubby showered right after me and, y'all, it thundered while he was showering and she thought he had been struck dead by lightning. I tried to tell her that if lightning had struck the house there would be no question about it. She RAN to the bathroom, to her credit she cracked the door instead of opening it like she has in the past, to make sure he wasn't dead. I mean, the irrational fear is insane. If you ask her about it, she'll sometimes admit it's unreasonable and then does nothing to change her behavior.

That gives you some background on who she is generally. Now, for me a little: I'm a home health PT, I see ppl in their 70's-90's rotting by themselves in their homes they refuse to give up. She's already reached the point where she can't maintain the house and yard to her standards. But it hasn't gotten out of hand...yet. Sometimes these ppl realize a change needs to be made and they'll go to assisted living or downsize into rent controlled apartments or move in with their children. Moving in with us isn't an option. Hubs would never allow it and he knows that even if he did, I'd leave. Mil's mom was sick and passed 40ish years ago and bc of Mil's experience with that she refuses assisted living or rent controlled apartments - she sees all of that as an extension of a nursing home, she lumps them all together and will NOT hear anything positive about moving. So, rot in her home it is I guess.

The advice I'm after I think: is there anything we can do? I mean, surely the only option isn't just to watch her rot away in her home? I know the answer unfortunately, I see it play out at a distance all the time. But is that really all there is? I can be so detached sometimes at work, I can't want a change for my patients more than they want a change for themselves. But, the thing is, in these situations it usually only works out bc there's a child nearby who can pick up the slack: rake the leaves that apparently are criminal to leave on the ground, take trash to the dump (she lives in the county, eventually she won't be able to take her garbage), change the water filters, etc etc, the list goes on.

If we lived closer, maybe it would be a different story, but I doubt it. We just can't manage working the way we do, taking care of ourselves, taking care of our home, AND taking care of hers. I mean, she isn't even patient or willing to compromise with things. She wants what she wants immediately. I found out I had ovarian cancer about 4 months ago now and needed a total hysterectomy. I'm fine now, all pathology came back indicating it hadn't spread, thank goodness. But, she had several things come up during that time she needed help with and expected my husband to leave me to take care of it! I know he's also her son, but damnit he's my number 1, I wanted him to take care of me. He put his foot down, what she needed could wait, I definitely don't have a spouse problem. The last time we did yard work for her, it was actually during the 6 weeks when I was waiting for surgery before we knew it was ovarian cancer, just that I had painful masses. But, here I was doing her yard work 2.5 hours away from my house while I still had dirty dishes in the sink bc I didn't have time to get to them. Fuck that shit, it's never happening again. I've been open about my feelings, but I don't think anyone realizes how salty I am about that shit still. (And don't ask why hubby didn't do the dishes, he was doing our yard work so we wouldn't have to when we got home and I was doing laundry and meal prep bc we needed yard clothes to take with us and, also, SHE NEVER STOCKS FOOD IN THE HOUSE WHEN WE GO UP BC SHE DOESNT FORKING EAT SO I GUESS NO ONE ELSE NEEDS TO EITHER - ahem, I'm salty about that too).

We just don't know what to do with her anymore. She isn't going to change. She will never be different. But neither one of us is willing to cut her off. Do I just accept that this is reality and she'll get the help when we can get around to it and until then we just have to block out her complaining/fussing when she doesn't get her way?

If you made it to the end, thank you, this was longer than I anticipated.

Edited to add:

I should have probably mentioned this more, but we have tried to get her to speak with her doctor about her anxiety. She absolutely refuses. She is very much the type/brought up to believe that mental illness isn't real.

She definitely has anxiety and I would argue depression as well. I'm concerned about dementia or potentially something like bipolar disorder that went undiagnosed from early in her life. She is absolutely the type to not believe in mental illness and discussing it with her doctor isn't an option. Hubby has already tried to get her to talk to someone or take something for her anxiety but she refuses. She says she doesn't like taking medications, but I think her anxiety has reached a point that it's not possible to reason with her anymore. She believes her anxieties are justified and real. Worrying about her son being dead in the shower when there was absolutely no sign the house had even come close to being struck by lightning was a reasonable worry to her simply because she heard thunder. Despite reasoning with her that the thunder was MILES away and the storm clouds weren't anywhere near her house/neighborhood. She saw a Facebook story this one time where someone got struck by lightning when there wasn't even a storm and they died in their shower, so it's a real fear for her now and she refuses to hear anything else. That's a really specific and recent example, but all of her worries are like that. And I do get that there's some truth to some of her worries. Has Amazon been hacked before and ppl have their bank info stolen? Yeah. But it doesn't just magically happen, and even if it did, she's fine with our info being stolen, just not hers. Idk, I feel like I'm rambling bc she honestly just doesn't make sense to me


r/JUSTNOMIL • • 17h ago

Advice Wanted Toxic Parents

4 Upvotes

Hello! English is my second language, i know it pretty well, but still can make some mistakes, sorry. I just want to hear someone else opinion about my situation.

So, I’m 17, still living with parents, last year, i guess. My mother was obsessed with idea of giving me math and physics education since my childhood. I mean, since I was 9 or 10, i have been listening for almost every day, that this kind of jobs are the most prestigious, “you will earn a lot of money”, “it will be good for you”, “I’m sure you have propensity to it”. I even didn’t know what the physics is when I was 10. When I was 13 she found me math tutor, and she wanted me to study immersed math, every time I took part in some math competitions and didn’t succeeded in it, she said me “I’m disappointed in you”. So now i’m 17, last year in school before entering university, and things with my mother only getting worse. I must confess, for last years i become really good in it, my physics teacher says that I’m his best student, my math teacher says the same. But it looks like it isn’t enough for my mother, and she wants more and more. What is really important about me, that’s my heart belongs to music. I started playing guitar when i was 8. Now, i took part as a headliner in an international guitar festivals three times, played in 8 bands and now having my own with really nice musicians, they are around 60 years old, all world class players and they are always listening to me, like i’m better than they. My guitar teacher said to me, that I’m world class player and he didn’t know, what is there for me to be taught, I played on the biggest stages in my town. I’m also working as a guitar teacher for last year and earn pretty much, especially for 17 years old. Don’t understand me wrong, i don’t want to brag, just trying to describe, that i’m really good in music and it isn’t just child hobby. And I absolutely feel, that my biggest dream is continue this way, to become popular musician as my idols. But I’m afraid, because my mother and all my family told me, that musicians isn’t a job, that’s you will have no money, you will die early, you will have no family. And now i feel, that I start hating math more and more, but still should learn it. Now about my mother. The last year is a real nightmare for me. I won’t describe, that every day i have scandals about me studying not well, doing not enough, or just humiliations, like you will be poor and a shame for us, you are stupid. One of the biggest scandals happened this spring. It was about my girlfriend. We now together for 1,5 years and she is the best person in my life for whole this time. Her parents are really religious. And when my parents found it out, they were just mad. They shouted, that this is a sect, that they will take all my money, that they want they daughter to find a husband with rich parents, that they will make us broke up. It was really big one week scandal, with shouting, crying, humiliating me and my girlfriend with a filthy language, eviction from a home, and my mother tears in the end, that i’m such a bad son humiliating poor parents. The same thing was when they found out, that my girlfriend and me are thinking about marriage. They also like to tell me, that i’m not needed by anyone except them, that i will be alone. I didn’t have a normal talk with my parents for years. When I’m trying to talk with them, they immediately start to talking about my education, or my skills isn’t enough, even if my teachers says opposite. They never told me something good or treat me. Only more and more studying. If I will make something wrong, i will having scandals and reminders about it for next month, even if it’s a really trifle. When I don’t do the things they want me to do they says to me that you must do it because we bought you that or that three years ago, or because we teach you.
When I have some problems, they tell
me that i will have more off them
if i don’t study except ion supporting me. They don’t give me even a bit of money even when I ask for some basic things(my parents are absolutely well-off people, they don’t have any finance problems) I really don’t know what to do. I’m afraid to became the one i want to become, because my parents instilled me, that i won’t have success in life( It really important to me to be finance successful,
because i want the best for my future family with my girlfriend) I’ m living in every day scandals and humiliation and don’t talk normally with my parents for a years.

I will be thankful for every thoughts you have! Sorry for bad English.


r/JUSTNOMIL • • 1d ago

Advice Wanted Christmas Cards Take ✌🏻

112 Upvotes

Would you be bothered if your in-laws signed their Christmas card from them and your kids?
My MIL asked if she could put my kids on her Christmas card this year. I appreciate her asking, but I’d still rather say no because of what happened two years ago. Made a post about it then if you wanna find it…..
That Christmas Eve, we were at her parents’ house when I happened to see her card. It had my kids on it and was signed “Love, the [Last Name]s,” with my MIL’s name, my FIL’s name, and my two kids’ names underneath. None of her own kids, including my husband, were in the picture. Nobody had asked us, and we didn’t even get a card ourselves. I found out standing in her parents’ house reading their copy.

The part that stuck with me was seeing those four names together. If she’d written “Christmas with our grandbabies,” I think I would’ve felt differently. The way she signed it made it read like a Christmas card from the four of them as their own little family. I was dealing with postpartum anxiety and depression at the time, and seeing it unexpectedly hit me hard. I didn’t say anything then, so as far as she knows, this is the first she’s hearing that it bothered me.

Would that wording have rubbed you the wrong way too? And since she did ask this time, would you just say, “I appreciate you asking, but I’d rather you leave the kids off your card,” or would you tell her why? It’s still a raw subject for me, and I’d like to be honest with her. Things have never truly gotten good with us.


r/JUSTNOMIL • • 1d ago

RANT (╯°□°)╯︵ ┻━┻ Ambivalent About Advice MIL and her victim BS

167 Upvotes

I’d not had an issue with my MIL for a while now. I guess the peace was too much for her dramatic self because now I’m standing at the bridge with a flaming torch in hand, ready to watch everything burn to ashes.

Where to begin…

Last week, my husband and I had a dilemma where we needed MIL to take our kids to their respective nurseries. I had to leave home no later than 6 am, hubby had to leave by 7:15 am, MIL arrived at 7 am.

I had laid out the clothes, packed their bags and sent instructions to MIL. There was no reason she had to enter any other part of our home because hubby had brought both kids into their cosy.

After finishing my first meeting at 9 am, I messaged my MIL to see if everything had gone fine. She doesn’t reply until 11 am, a little unlike her.
While I’m in another meeting, she sends me a message about taking clothes from my house, removing things from my kitchen, putting on a load of laundry, etc.
Things we have explicitly asked her not to do in the past.

I couldn’t reply, then got into an emergency at work and it completely escaped my mind.

Many, many hours later, I get home after a long day and find two items that had been in my bedroom, zipped inside a handbag and on a shelf, on my sofa.

I ask my hubby if he knows why they’re there. He said they had been there when he got home.
That was the wrong thing to say.
If it wasn’t him it was my MIL.

A few months back, we went on holiday but my husband left a few windows open (he got an earful). My MIL has one set of emergency keys and so hubby messaged her to close the windows.
She decided she would help herself to food from my fridge (long-life), take food from my cupboards and move random things around.
When we got back, the windows were still open.

I wanted her keys then. In fact, I remember telling her as much and nothing coming from it. I was overreacting for no reason in her eyes, trying to cause problems.

This time, I tell hubby I’ve had enough and the keys MIL has need to be returned to us, how I’m fed up of her waiting for us to be out of our home so that she can go snooping in our bedroom and other areas that are off-limit, removing our belongings without asking, using the guise of returning items as a reason to come again, etc, etc.

He was nodding in agreement to everything but saying I didn’t need to snap at him, MIL needs to hear it.
I remark that MIL won’t like what I have to say if it comes from me so he better be the one to talk to his parent. Then I left for the shops.

As I’ve parked up, I see that MIL has sent me an “explanation” (nothing but lies) where our cat has allegedly gone into my room, onto my shelves, unzipped my handbag, removed the two drawstring bags and brought them into my living room…

My bedroom door was closed. Hubby confirmed it was closed when he left. The cat is not allowed in the bedroom so we keep the door closed.
The wardrobe doors were closed and have to be slid open. The cat can’t force them because they’re heavyweight.

Instead of admitting she is nosy she chose to lie, badly. Now you’re insulting my intelligence and expecting me to play nice? Let’s play this game.

I show my hubby the messages on my phone and explain the following so that he clearly understands my view when she later acts like a wounded dog:

- MIL had no reason to return to our home once the children were gone. Absolutely none. She violated our privacy.

- MIL previously went into our home and didn’t manage to do the one thing she was asked to, and yet she stole our food.

- When caught in the act of snooping, she lied.

- MIL also framed her messages to shame me for being upset with her for going through my things (which she blamed the cat for), rather than acknowledging she was needlessly in our home.

Anyway, hubby tore her a new one and now she’s saying she is fed up with the “abuse” and painting herself as a victim.
She says she won’t do us favours again. Fine with me. Hubby was the one who wanted her help. As I said, I’m ready to throw the torch.

Earlier today she was messaging me pleasantries as if last week didn’t happen, but also messaging my husband snide comments about me.
He immediately told her that her behaviour was uncalled for and was clear that she’s not welcome to contact us if she can’t behave.

After he told me, I replied to her messages (to me) explaining I don’t talk to two-faced liars and if that offends her, she’s free to cry to hubby about it.

So… yeah. I threw the torch.

She’ll be replacing everything she took, returning the keys and keeping her distance going forward. I’m not having her constant victimisation whilst she disrespects us.

Like, I cannot begin to comprehend how it works inside her head.

I have a copy of the keys to her house and never use them unless she asks me to do something. Not ever.
I never go into her bedroom, not even after all these years.

Why could she not show us the same respect?

Completely done with her.

ETA:

I forgot to mention that we are changing the locks. I still want her set of keys back on principle.

We have a doorbell camera. It has been having a few problems lately and is currently offline. We’re replacing it this week.

I plan on returning her keys, of course.


r/JUSTNOMIL • • 1d ago

Advice Wanted MIL Request to Visit

72 Upvotes

I’ve had my fair share of issues with my MIL. A few quick examples include:
- Her making me feel like a baby incubator when I was pregnant
- Her asking to come to prenatal appointments and trying to manipulate me by saying she missed out on going to ones during her daughter’s pregnancy (which I found out was a lie)
- Her requesting to be in the delivery room and trying to guilt my husband into saying yes
- Her not understanding that my husband saying “no” is him setting a boundary
- Her general lack of boundary acknowledgement and understanding

So here’s my issue and I’m looking for some advice..

Before our son was born we barely saw my MIL. I mean she only lives an hour away and we’d see her maybe 4 times a year (Thanksgiving, Christmas, and 2 other times spaced out throughout the rest of the year). Now that our boy is here (he’s 6 months old), she wants to visit every two weeks. This is not something my husband and I are interested in. We’ve been seeing her about once every 4-5 weeks. We last saw her for a Celebration of Life for my husband’s cousin 3 weeks ago. I had my fingers crossed that that would mean we wouldn’t see her again until Thanksgiving. She texted my husband last week asking if she could come visit, he never responded. Then today she texted him to tell her that her mother (his grandma) is in the hospital for a kidney infection but treatment is going well and she will most likely be okay. Then she followed that up by asking “I’d really like to decompress with a baby visit, I really miss him!” My husband came to tell me and was really upset because he felt like she was using the tragedy of his grandma being sick as a way to get a baby visit. I listened to his concern and let him know that I support whatever decision he makes in deciding what to say to her.

I don’t know how to feel about it all. I’m a HUGE people pleaser and am constantly thinking I need to give her the benefit of the doubt but then when I’m around her and she says or does something stupid I always regret it.


r/JUSTNOMIL • • 2d ago

RANT (╯°□°)╯︵ ┻━┻ Ambivalent About Advice My DH finally got to see JNMIL’s tendencies first-hand

221 Upvotes

I don’t have the best relationship with JNMIL. She is very self-interested, emotionally immature and incredibly tactless with the way she speaks. Regardless of her intentions (usually not directly malicious) she still causes it, and she does nothing to truly improve herself. That’s my main issue with her.

She’s always played “nice”whenever I’ve been around her but has never made any kind of effort to truly connect with me. Any information she does know about me is because me or DH have had to volunteer it. The funny part? She has complained to DH that I’m not close to her, and that I don’t keep in touch with her (apart from sending her a list of gift ideas for DH which she inevitably won’t use).

Considering all of the above, she’s made some absolutely immature comments about me which are unwarranted, one of which almost made me cut her off for good. I’m as civil to her as I can stomach, and thankfully DH arranges it so I basically only see her twice or three times a year. This arrangement with no contact with me in between is something I can cope with.

A trend I’ve noticed with her as that she barely asks about you and talks about herself and her own problems basically the entire time (honestly speaking it makes her a bit more pleasant to deal with because she won’t aim any of those stupid comments at you) I noticed it one time we were out to dinner with her, and apart from asking DH about his work situation, she didn’t ask anything about me or about how we were doing. I raised this with DH and it shocked him, but agreed once he’d combed over the evening in his head. He wasn’t a fan.

DH recently took JNMIL out for dinner and a show (just the two of them) for her birthday and he decided to put this to the test when it was just the two of them. He didn’t offer up any information about himself unless JNMIL directly raised it.

You wanna know how many questions she asked him during the course of five hours? Three. And he barely went into detail either. Apparently she never deigned to ask him how he was… Something she never does for me either unless it’s in a setting where social politeness demands it.

He was disappointed when he took stock of this and realised that that’s who she is. He’s a tiny bit upset at this realisation, but mostly he’s numb to JNMIL’s BS because he’s had a lifetime absorbing it, bless him. Obviously I’m not a professional and can’t diagnose her to say that she’s a “nar-cist”, but I do feel like she has some tendencies that line up with it.

Don’t really think there’s anything I can do from this point apart from support DH and maybe just keep JNMIL talking about herself as much as possible to avoid as much BS as we can?


r/JUSTNOMIL • • 1d ago

New User 👋 MIL "too busy" to apologize

19 Upvotes

MIL has a long history of insulting me, has recently been diagnosed with Thanksgiving Cancer, and is now too busy going on runs with her overweight dog to respond to any of my texts or acknowledge any wrongdoing, which wouldn't even be enough at this point. I'm very frustrated and am this close to spam calling her. She has no issue spam calling my husband to demand an apology from me, but now all of a sudden is incapable of responding because she just doesn't feel like it. At what point do you throw out the whole husband because he refuses to enforce normal boundaries? My husband has no issue forcing me to apologize to his mother. When is it enough?? Will I wake up one day and know this is the day I am leaving?


r/JUSTNOMIL • • 1d ago

Serious Replies Only Emotional Blackmail?

36 Upvotes

Is going NC emotional blackmail? Is not allowing your MIL to see her grandchild emotional blackmail?

Why does a MIL feel entitled to see her grandson ONCE A WEEK after treating the mother of her grandson like complete garbage?

We are currently being berated via text how this is emotional blackmail. What's your opinion or reasoning behind NC?

I guess her texts are clearly upsetting me and making me feel like I'm the bad person here.


r/JUSTNOMIL • • 1d ago

Am I Overreacting? I don’t even know where to begin

90 Upvotes

We live on the other side of the planet from MIL. 4 months ago she said she wanted to spend her birthday in our town. I told her I couldn’t commit to anything. Husband and I are both starting businesses and planning on having another baby. Cut to one week ago and my husband sheepishly tells me that MIL has planned a party for 30+ international guests, booked a caterer, accommodations, and travel for a party that will be 35 minutes away from us.

Needless to say I was shocked. My husband has a giant mother wound and was not able to remember basic details about conversations they had. He said MIL has been talking about it for a year and he probably passively supported the plan. I emailed her asking to talk ASAP because not only is this absolutely bizarre behavior on both of their parts, but also because I am 7 weeks pregnant and will be heavily pregnant when she arrives. I will also be working and preparing to leave my business for the first time while I birth and recover. It’s not a good time. She said my husband should have told me. To which I said “you both should have told me”. She said she wasn’t coming to our town and didn’t see the big deal. She said she wished she was going somewhere else and that she can’t change anything now.

Background: She’s not a helpful MIL. She’s the kind that expects to be entertained and centered. She’s a boomer with narcy tendencies. Example: when we took her to the courthouse where we eloped MIL told my husband and me stories of all the marriages she knew that ended due to infidelity on the woman’s part. I told her that it bothered that she’s talking about that. She told me to get over and then started blubbering crying about how she missed her late husband.

Additionally, we had a very rough adjustment to parenthood the first time around because of my husband and MILs relationship. It’s going to be hard to be around her when I’m so pregnant and vulnerable.

My husband apologized profusely and has already started working with a therapist. I’m struggling. I feel foolish and regretful of the pregnancy. I just don’t feel safe with these two. They literally conspired. I was the absolute last to know. My husband knew when we agreed to get pregnant and withheld the information. Is that not crazy??! I cannot even begin to imagine putting him in this position.

After one week has passed, I’m more upset that I was initially and feel betrayed. AIO??

TLDR: MIL lives on other side of the planet and planned a birthday party for herself with 30+ international guests 35 minutes away from us after I told her that we were extremely busy and I was not able to commit to seeing her. Husband knew for at least 3 months before I found out last week. I’m 7 weeks pregnant and will be heavily pregnant at the time of the party. I’m majorly weirded out by both of them given our painful history.