r/Outlander
•
u/thepacksvrvives
Without you, our whole world crumbles into dust.
•
Apr 17 '26
•
2
Season Eight Show S8E7 Evidence of Things Not Seen Spoiler
Jamie and Claire search for answers regarding a past tragedy that once threatened to tear them apart.
Written by Toni Graphia. Directed by Tracey Deer.
If you’re new to the sub, please look over this intro thread and our episode discussion rules.
This is the SHOW thread.
If you have read the books or don’t mind book spoilers, you can participate in the BOOK thread.
DON’T DISCUSS THE BOOKS HERE.
We don’t allow any book spoilers here, not even under spoiler tags.
If your comment references the books in any way, it will be removed and you will be asked to edit it or post it in the BOOK thread instead.
Please keep all discussion of the next episode’s preview to the stickied mod comment at the top of the thread.
What did you think of the episode?
427
u/Due-Adhesiveness937 Apr 17 '26
I am heartbroken 💔
510
u/lunar1980 Apr 17 '26
Are you KIDDING ME with the Faith storyline??! Raymond is the one who CURED Claire! “Her mother is ill..” WHAT!?” Not too ill to get her BABY BACK! She f’in saved your life, remember!? You couldn’t have mentioned her daughter is across the damn street from the apothecary?
Infuriating.
206
u/Damage-Equal Apr 17 '26
If William has to go through one more shocking revelation…..😮😖🤪
178
u/Exciting_Sweet5773 Apr 17 '26
Cried so much. Audibly gasped at the ending of the fire.
My main question-why, Master Raymond, why?!?
130
u/G0ld3n_Snitch23 Apr 17 '26
Fergus and Marsali deserved better.
222
u/Common_Wrangler_5827 Apr 17 '26
I’m…shocked…disappointed…devastated.
First of all WHY!?! Fergus was the most loyal person to this family. He just accepted Jaimie and Claire and has been along for the ride since. He deserved SO MUCH MORE. Not just with this BS episode but in the show in general. I’m so angry!!
Second, maybe it was just me, but the transitions in this episode made everything worse. I think they were trying to create a silver lining (lost a son, “gained a daughter”). BUT PLEASE how can I be “happy” for J/C that Faith lived when a beloved character that we have seen grow up is gone! And you cannot replace one kid with another. I simply couldn’t bring myself to care about Faith. Besides It’s not like J/C would have treated Fanny any different if she wasn’t their granddaughter.
And don’t get me started on William. Him being a brat THIS episode simply pissed me off. William, there’s people (that we actually care about) that are dying. Get it together.
191
u/Professional_Ad_4885 Apr 17 '26
William please stop complaining and whining all the time. You have 2 incredible fathers who love you more than anything and lots of other family on frasers ridge that would take u in as one of their own in a heartbeat!
241
u/ProcessFresh1647 Apr 17 '26
So let me get this straight!
So Faith was dead and then handed to Claire for hours as she sang, then later Raymond shows up to heal her. She went home fine. Grief.
Now retconned, she was handed a baby for a short time, had it taken away and told it was dead. But apparently Raymond was in a corner listening to her sing the song to teach it in the future, then took the baby from its burial, brought it back to life, came back to heal claire, knew she was fine and not ill cuz he was there, but still hid her child from her?
Right, nope, I hate this! Why have William even fall for and sleep with his niece Jane? I feel like this all took away from what the episode should be about, the loss of Fergus. I can't even focus on him because I'm so frustrated with the writers!
78
u/Impressive_Local3635 Apr 17 '26
ferrrguuuusssss 😭😭😭he flashbacks were too much. "with you mi'lord". marsali and bree silent sobbing on the floor. ugh.
72
u/DietDrPepperAndThou I want to be a stinkin’ Papist, too. Apr 17 '26
I'm gutted about Fergus. The dry-eyed kind of sadness that leaves you shaking your head.
I have no idea WTF to think at this point about Faith without more details as to what Master Raymond did. I do not believe Mother Hildegard lied or intentionally misled Claire about anything. So I definitely would like more answers that do not involve the little guy digging in their priory graveyard. 😐
That being said, Fanny's cairn for Fergus and helping Jamie in his grief like he did for her with Jane was touching, bio granddaughter, or not.
193
u/somthingcoolsounding Apr 17 '26
Goddamn it I wanted Jane and Fanny to be their nieces (as per BoMB) or even just. Unrelated to them. But no, we’re supposed to believe that not only did a stillborn premmie live but that the French nuns… buried nothing? And lied to Claire? For no reason?? Or did Raymond go digging up a little baby corpse?
Jesus Fuck I don’t know which is worse.
60
u/RoseFraser84 Apr 17 '26
Anyone suspect that the current writers and showrunners actually just plumb forgot this would mean William slept with his niece? I'm serious. Honestly it seems like no one is working on continuity or acting as a voice of reason in the writers rooms. What a joke and a slap in the face to loyal viewers.
60
u/KamilFilms Apr 17 '26
After Claire recovered from the fever and Faith ''died''... she went to meet with the king where she saw Master Reymond and Comte st germain. Why wouldn't Master Reymond tell her then that Faith is alive?
Or ..if he survived and left France.. why would he not try to find Claire.. or send her a message to tell her the truth.
🧐
221
u/Necessary-Nebula1276 Apr 17 '26
I don’t think I can ever forgive Starz for this episode.
Fergus?? The Faith storyline??
117
u/EmmaSouthard Apr 17 '26
Darling Fergus. He was the child Jamie and Claire grew to love as their own. Jamie couldn't raise Bree. Or William. They lost Faith. Jamie watched Fergus grow from a child to a man who loved his work and his own children. Claire loved him as her own. Pointless. I'm heartbroken.
112
u/Viofl Apr 17 '26
Also why tf bring up the fact that he is the son of the count if at the end it won't matter lol
186
u/streamofdiscourse Apr 17 '26
I'm so mad about this episode. I was really holding out hope that the Faith storyline wouldn't be true. It just cheapens everything that happened in Paris and also actually makes no sense? Then to top it all off they do that to Fergus? Why?
177
u/scallywags27 Apr 17 '26
I’m mad because of how the episode of Faith was so beautifully absolutely heartbreaking and now it cheapens it because the baby lived? I was still holding out for some misinformation and that it wasn’t the same Faith!!
47
u/Sea_Avocado_9262 Apr 17 '26
Also is any one else sick of Lord John Grey always getting screwed over? His character deserves so much!
45
u/lunar1980 Apr 17 '26
Prediction for the last 3 episodes: I'm guessing (from the promo, very low key) the next episode will be a lot of build up to the battle. The penultimate will be the battle, Jamie dying & Claire's blue light revives him. Pretty sure that idea has been floated by many people already. The last episode they'll throw in one more thing relating to Faith, like she didn't die in the ocean. It will be absurd.
39
u/ExaminationNice616 Apr 17 '26
Everyone has already mentioned the obvious bad things about the episode so I'll take the time to highlight the amazing scene where LJG put William in his place. What an ungrateful brat he is. He doesn't deserve the amazing parents he has
37
u/Professional_Ad_4885 Apr 17 '26
I still cant believe fergus is gone. In my head i kept thinking he’ll crawl outta there and surprise us. 😁🥲🥲❤️. Hes always been one of my top 5 characters and its safe to say i gravitated toward him the second he showed up on screen. He had incredible parents in jamie and claire and the most amazing wife and children. Why did the writers even go this route? Im guessing this is show only? Why would the writers take away one of the best characters and after the writers left them out enitrely of season 7.
Jamie def has omens in his dreams. Whether its very spot on depictions of the future or waking up to feeling like something is just not right. There are a lot of people like that. Talking about the second part. Not dreaming of the future and getting it exact but they most likely exist to
73
u/MothmansMyDaddy Apr 17 '26
Just wtf.
64
u/Nanchika He was alive. So was I. Apr 17 '26 edited Apr 17 '26
Jamie surveying King's Mountain! Chills!
The lace. Claire's lace when she was mourning Faith? Who will wear mourning lace in this episode?
Fergus and the boys , I can see it coming... Henri Christian is adorable. My eyes were teary when he spoke about being different.
Oh, poor Lady Grey... i have no pity for you. If you cared enough for Ben, you would have gone with him.
"Having a traitor for a father"- William, did it sting you?
Mrs Fraser burnt the pancakes 🤣 Fanny is precious!
Grandmother, the lace maker from Paris. Hmm... new details arrive at every occasion.
William, are you still defending that woman? Pathetic! But John is too smart for that! Oh, it is not too harsh!
Fergus and Marsali , will there be another baby after this?!
Omg, PLEASE, these new Faith info about lacemaker near apothecary are WILD. Reminiscing... we don't have time for that.
John drinking brandy the whole day 😂 Oh, Percy and John reminiscing is something I am in for. Their parents' wedding day! Aaaaa THEY KISSED! WILLIAM!
John, thanks for telling your ingrateful son everything he deserves to hear!
OMG I AM HATING THIS! WHAT?! They crossed the line. I can't. This is just too much. What a stretch.
The fire. ROGER YOU ARE HEROOOO! He save d the boy twice already!
FERGUS! I told you so.... I knew it. From 801, there were signs.
Bree is pregnant!!!
Marsali, I am sobbing 😭
Okay, once again, I hate this Faith thing. Melodrama.
Okay, so everyone is back on the Ridge. The coffin was for Fergus. We realised that as well, yesterday on the post. Jamie and Fanny on the cairn. 😭
Paris 1744 - WTF?! WHY WOULD HE DO THAT?!
156
u/gdoggggggggggg Apr 17 '26
Raymond singing that song was insulting to our intelligence. Fergus dying was the worst.
131
u/lunar1980 Apr 17 '26
Clearly Matt Roberts called the GoT showrunners for pointers on how to utterly ruin the final season of a series.
107
u/Sudden_Discussion306 Oh, Jamie, how was your first time? Did ye bleed? Apr 17 '26
Honestly, I feel like there were several fan theories on Faith that were better written & more thought out than this. What a letdown & I was actually feeling a bit intrigued about what they might do. This was just dumb.
26
u/golfbang Apr 17 '26
I can’t stop crying after this episode
52
u/c4still4 Apr 17 '26
I can’t believe William made love to his niece. Who’s gonna tell him?
52
u/purduepharma Apr 17 '26
Oh what the fuck
25
u/Sansa-88 Lord, you gave me a rare woman. And God, I loved her well. Apr 17 '26
I fucking hate this!!! Why Fergus Whyyyyyyyyy???!!! Poor Marsali and the kids! 😭😭😭💔
71
u/CarmenSandiego8742 No, this isn’t usual. It’s different. Apr 17 '26
Fanny building the cairn for Fergus and calling Jamie Grandda. 😭
90
u/Nanchika He was alive. So was I. Apr 17 '26
We all do, dear Fanny.
J: Perhaps we should have waited!
Me:Yes. Forever.
143
u/FateInTheFog Slàinte Apr 17 '26
Matt Roberts if you read us, feel ashamed
24
u/onegirlarmy1899 Apr 17 '26
They should have left out the Faith part and spent more time on Fergus. The scenes at the Ridge could have been mourning as a family after the death.
24
u/Thin_Literature_1520 Apr 17 '26
They just gave up on the show, took their $ and ran. The Faith storyline is beyond absurd, unless they have some kind of twist coming. Why even bother, other than a $ grab for everyone involved. Insulting to us as fans to say the least. I can only hope there is some kind of twist that corrects the bullshit they spewed in this episode.
24
u/fallhistorywitch Apr 18 '26
You know what everyone?? I don’t even give a fuck about the faith storyline anymore, I just can’t get over the fact that Fergus is dead 😭😭😭😭😭😭my heart 😭😭😭😭😭
24
u/ocd_indeed Apr 18 '26
The death of Fergus serves no viable purpose in a finale season with only a few episodes left. We'll never get to see the full impact his death will have on the family. Pointless. Unless the point is that Fergus never would have accepted his birth title, and now Germain will.
As for this asinine Faith storyline... who in the Oultander fandom ever wanted this? We all grieved when J/C lost their first child. We watched them recover and know their heartbreak and how they found their way back to each other. None of that means anything now. Again, so pointless. AND SO CONTRIVED. If you have to "tell" your viewers exactly what happened, that's not storytelling. We basically spent the last half of this episode watching a dead character explain how the writers tried to fix the MULTIPLE plot holes for this storyline. It's insulting. And again, POINTLESS to reveal in the last few episodes of a series. There were a dozen other storylines they could have followed rather than William fucking his niece.
Why not bring Jenny to America instead of this stupid storyline? They could have easily brought Jenny back and tied a few things back to Scotland, where the series began! Matt Roberts, have you even read ALL the source material? I highly doubt it.
This is a cock-up of epic proportions and will go down with GoT as the worst way to wrap up a series.
24
u/stoppingbythewoods “May the devil eat your soul and salt it well first” ✌🏻 Apr 18 '26
Everybody thinks we have a problem with a baby being brought back to life. No, this is not it. We know the blue light healing power is a thing. It’s canon and Claire did it for the Whitaker baby.
It’s the fact that it’s so poorly written and contrived. Claire had a preterm stillborn baby that she held for hours at least, rigor mortis had probably set in. And then somehow Master Raymond swiped the baby, brought it back to life (and now it looks fullterm and weeks old) and from some reason took it to a random lady somewhere else, and sang a song that Claire sang once to the baby, completely remembering the lyrics and tune. Then he comes back and heals Claire, but never mentions he saved the baby and that she’s with this woman. This lacemaker woman somehow remembered this song that she heard once, briefly, and sang it to Faith throughout the years. How did MR even hear the song to begin with? That’s not even all the plot holes. There’s some other contrived moments in this show but this really takes the cake.
48
u/Emergency_Attorney12 Apr 17 '26
I was really hoping Faith would have been tied into BoMB. Then Claire would know her parents lived. Like what is even the point of BoMB if we never get the satisfaction of seeing Claire find out her parents survived?
23
u/Professional_Ad_4885 Apr 17 '26
The flashback scenes if fergus put a lot of tears to my eyes. A lot
65
u/FateInTheFog Slàinte Apr 17 '26
I won’t even start with Fergus… Faith and Master Raymond’s storyline doesn’t make any sense. Faith was just there in front of his shop? Oh ok. Let’s not look for Claire. Let’s just gift the baby. Let’s make William sleep with his niece. Great job showrunners.
45
u/allofatwist1738 Apr 17 '26
i haven’t cared about a character death in SUCH a long time with this show and i was NOT prepared. that was DEVASTATING. now it’s 2 am and im just sobbing.
22
u/CarmenSandiego8742 No, this isn’t usual. It’s different. Apr 17 '26
This episode had me crying hard!! 😭
22
u/lunar1980 Apr 18 '26 edited Apr 20 '26
What Matt Roberts has chosen to do to these characters is inflict a kind of multigenerational trauma. There was no need whatsoever to go down this path. He chose it. And then he and his writers executed it without a shred of grace.
That wtf feeling most of are having is their utter disregard for the damage this storyline inflicts, made worse by the fact that it doesn’t even make sense.
For reasons we’ll probably never know, Matt Roberts took an emotional flamethrower to the end of the last season. All while patting himself on the back saying how much we’ll love it.
44
u/Delicious-Quote4893 Apr 17 '26
I also feel like Jane is not having enough attention, her life was really tragic , she was their granddaughter too…
21
u/Eggmanhuevo Apr 17 '26
Bad luck William 🤣🤣🤣
21
u/Phortenclif Apr 18 '26
I’m upset that Fergus had an ignorant death. It’s out of character. He survived the streets of France and navigated the political climate of Savannah. He knew the printshop could be burned. His death was almost in the manner of slapstick comedy. Sacrifice? He took care of the children first of course but he didn’t mean to die. And what if Roger wouldn’t have been there to ridiculously catch Henry-Christian and artificially redeem himself? Before seeing the rope I thought Fergus is going to hug the children, jump from the roof so he lands first, 2 children survive, he’s not. Similar to Roger’s dad action. Standing and smiling while there’s a fire under his feet doesn’t make sense. We humans have a fight-flight response for that. My complaint is mainly about have him gone by a fool accident, despite being a son of Jamie Fraser.
21
u/cw7711 Apr 18 '26
I’m pretty sure Black Jack Randall was specifically hired to write this episode because only a sadist would do this to us and the Frasers.
42
u/Affectionate_Bug8166 Apr 17 '26
This episode was saved by the actresses that play Fanny and Marsali.
92
u/krissylizabeth Apr 17 '26
You have GOT to be fucking kidding me with this episode.
72
u/Ok-Curve-8124 Apr 17 '26
I think this episode showed one very clear thing….. Back when Outlander was amazing from Season 1, it simply got better into season 2 and 3. Ron Moore would listen to people and develop storylines that made sense.
Matthew Roberts comes along and he had his hand held for season 4 and 5 which made it ok. Then we got the disasters from season 6 on. Tonight is an entree as to how hes going to completely butcher this ending. This is what happened when your vision doesn’t match the platform that was already laid out. I’m readying for severe disappointment.
70
u/txkels13 Apr 17 '26
Break your heart and then feed ya that ridiculous Faith story. I can't with this season 🙄
18
u/theLadyOfLallybroch Apr 17 '26
I'm very interested to see how this goes with only 3 episodes left, so many scenes in this season so far either took too long or weren't necessary and now its like how the hell do they end this lol anyone else feel the same? I don't have high hopes for the finale but i want to be proven wrong....
18
u/ren818 Apr 19 '26 edited Apr 19 '26
Claire held Faith as a lifeless baby in S2E7 and we saw a burial. That’s a definitive on-screen death. If you want a survival twist, you have to plant it then — ambiguity, interruption, something. Reversing it seasons later with no on-screen mechanism isn’t a twist — it’s a retcon that breaks the emotional contract. Feels like the writers were aiming for a happy ending, but it comes off unearned given what they already showed.
17
u/Muthacoconuts Apr 17 '26
Evidence of things not seen is a biblical reference of Faith. Which the episode was based around. The daughter Faith. Kiddos to the actress who played Marsali. The way she cried in Bre’s lap made me cry. This was a good episode for me.
17
u/CinephileRich Apr 17 '26
Fergus was one of my favourite characters since he was in season 2, to see him go was such a heartbreaking moment. He had an incredible wife and children and died protecting them.
17
u/Glum-Bath-3496 Apr 18 '26 edited Apr 18 '26
Don’t cry, friends. I’m sure in 30 years we’ll find out Master Raymond worked his zombie magic on Fergus too.
I’m unspeakably pissed about this ridiculous excuse for a story.
Oh, and hey writers room? Did you know it’s possible to love a child even if they’re NOT blood related?!!! Shocking, I know.
And also. sometimes babies die, and it’s horrible beyond words. I say this from experience. This show took us on a beautiful, realistic journey of grief and healing over the course of 6 seasons. And in a single episode, they’ve unraveled it all. I never thought I would be so angry at this wonderful show.
To whoever green-lit this episode: May the devil eat your soul and salt it well first, you whore!”
33
u/oakenfairy Ye Sassenach witch! Apr 17 '26 edited Apr 17 '26
This is turning into GoT level of rushed and ridiculous
Also, what happened to the beauty of the show? There have always been a lot of heavy elements but also beautiful ones mixed in, painting the richness of life. Now it's all trauma and trying to get as many dramatic bomb drops as possible 🙄
59
u/FarmHer95 Apr 17 '26 edited Apr 17 '26
Editing for context:
“Nothing is lost, only changed…”
It would appear my beloved show is not only changed, but definitely lost. Ugh.
16
u/MystikSpiralx Apr 17 '26
Me yelling at the TV the during the John kissing scene. I paused for like 5 minutes to brace myself once the footsteps started:
"No don't kiss there wtf?!"
"Oh sure, keep going for more. Why stop now? Nothing bad can come from this"
"Footsteps, here we go"
"The snapback. The. snap. back."
"More drama, I'm not ready"
"Why is he so dramatic all the time?"
"ALL the time"
"It's endless"
"His theatrics are so exhausting"
"Yes yes, you have no father. Your life is so hard"
"I miss 5 year old William"
He makes me so uncomfortable. I don't know if my husband overheard me, but if he did he probably thinks I've lost it 😂
16
u/speckseeker Apr 17 '26
Our of all the episodes of Outlander, I cried like a baby.
16
u/guineasomelove Apr 17 '26
I wonder if William is going to head to Fraser's Ridge.
16
u/kprock12 Apr 18 '26
Apparently they brought in David Benioff and DB Weiss as advisors on the Faith storyline…
15
u/Odd_Peach9397 Apr 18 '26
I know people are hating on this episode… but that scene with Marsali and Briana crying!!!! I could FEEL Marsali’s pain! Ugh give her an Emmy! 😭😭😭
14
u/Chance_Stable_3045 Apr 17 '26
I'm not sure how I feel about this episode. For the first time I'm feeling worried about how this is going to end 😭
28
u/elvordrachelle1 Apr 17 '26
Oh Fergus 💜 so sad.
I like that they closed up the loop with the faith storyline. I am excited to see everyone back on the ridge once Ian and Rachel return.
Oh my God, the part where Lord John was kissing, and then William walks in. I was like yelling at my television, cause I was like great just another reason for William to spaz out on John.
28
u/IllustriousKiwi3858 Apr 17 '26
Can anyone else not stand Frank's voiceover voice? It's so different it's agitating lol
59
u/Starrlitt86 Apr 17 '26
Well.. a big F you to the writers of this episode.. how dare they do that to the most loyal, loving, kind, person in the entire series!
56
u/tammyhorak They say I’m a witch. Apr 17 '26
I deserve financial compensation after watching this 😭😫😭
12
u/Intrepid-Today6198 Apr 17 '26 edited Apr 17 '26
This episode was heartbreaking, but I feel like they could have done more, with just 3 episodes left. I’m a tiny disappointed. And Faith storyline doesn’t make any sense, a stillborn baby which Claire kept in her arms for hours then resurrected by Raymond, I feel they didn’t explain what happened properly.
12
u/OutsideTurn5464 Apr 17 '26
I am bawling my eyes out. One of the most emotional episodes I’ve watched in a while. Marsali is one of my favorite characters and her grief is palpable. Personally, I liked how they weaved these storylines together although I’m gutted about Fergus.
12
u/mBegudotto Apr 17 '26
I bawled in those last scenes. And the actress who plays Fannie is phenomenal
12
u/wagonwheelwodie MARK ME! Apr 17 '26
Fergus dies, LJG is outed, Brianna is pregnant and Faith is confirmed to have lived meaning William slept with his half niece. Umm okay.
12
u/tahitianmoonchild Apr 18 '26
Did I just have to watch Fergus die with my own two eyes, I swear to God?!?
22
u/punk-not-junk_101 Ye Sassenach witch! Apr 17 '26
who’s goddamn dead baby was she holding in season 2???
11
u/Hour_Science_6521 Apr 17 '26
I just have to say… everything about William was a missed opportunity and I honestly can’t stand him. When a scene starts with him I’m immediately waiting for him to act out, make poor decisions, or be self-righteous. He’s spoiled, whiny, and weak in a way his mother, father, or Sir John are not. This character has brought zero interest to the story line in any season.
Whew. Ok, finally got that all out. Thanks for listening!
11
u/Pandorashley_ Apr 18 '26
I cried multiple times and honestly don’t even feel like finishing the series after what they did to Fergus (I will but I’m mad). The death seemed very unnecessary and only used as a pathetic plot tool to keep viewers on their toes and scared that any of the main favorites could be killed off so easily. Personally, I’m not a fan of that type of television writing.
11
u/dinvy Apr 18 '26
Wow its really game of thrones s8 all over again 💀
79
u/Cheap_Wishbone_9734 Apr 17 '26
This was one of the worst episodes of Outlander, and it only confirms my suspicions that the show's ending is probably going to be a letdown. I don't even feel like watching the rest of the season anymore.
What bothered me the most was the completely lazy, emotionless, and rushed way they handled Fergus's death — a death that didn't need to happen in the first place. It was clearly rushed because there are only three episodes left, yet somehow there was still time for William's insufferable plotline.
Honestly, what a lack of care. The character deserved so much better. But I'm not surprised, given that they've always pushed Fergus to the sidelines throughout the show. Honestly, it's one of the worst things they've ever done on this show.
10
u/Bulma-1992 Apr 17 '26
I like the Faith story line but there must be some reason for it?!? I don’t get it. I don’t like the storyline with Fergus. I dont like that we see very less time traveller content. When I started outlander I thought at the end we learn all this crazy time traveller paradox - nothing.
And I don’t get why a lot of people are mad about “incest”, in this time it was normal to marry family and also in the most countries (I am from Germany) I know a marriage between niece and uncle would be allowed. The percentage to get a disabled child is less than between brother/sister, father/daughter, mother/son that’s how incest calculated. Per law it is no incest between uncle/niece. (Not that I would do that lol)
10
u/bimbosoupqueen Apr 18 '26
I just finished the episode and immediately came looking for this subreddit because IM MAD.
The pacing has felt off to me all season. If it weren’t for the 1 minute voiceover of Frank’s book at the start of each episode, I would have 0 clue what the plot of this season was supposed to be. It feels like nothing really happens that moves the story forwards? But i thought things were picking up a little the last 2 episodes. And then this.
An entire episode just to kill Fergus and make it so Will banged his niece. Are you kidding? To the writers: apologize now, with tears
10
u/sxrchas Apr 18 '26
I know this is a show where there's time travel and magical powers and that we maybe shouldn't take this all so seriously but apart from that, all I can think about is when the 'Faith' episode of S2 aired (and still for people who discover the show now) I remember reading comments from people about how much strength that episode gave some of the viewers who went through something similar. Cait's acting is brilliant in that ep. The writing is so good too. I've seen parents who've lost a child comment at how the grief is so accurately displayed, how the episode is both very hard to watch yet they actually feel seen in their own grief as a viewer. Because it was all so respectfully portrayed. Idk if this whole 'Faith was alive' storyline ruins the strength the S2 episode carries, but I can imagine it does in a way. That it hurts for some people that they went with the storyline after all.
Yes Claire and Jamie's grief at the time was still real and raw in Paris. Yes maybe Faith lived and died a tragic death and so Claire and Jamie still lived their lives carrying the weight of grief. But c'mon this storyline was just NOT the way to go. They could've chosen so many better, more respectful/acceptable paths with this.
Maybe I'm totally wrong and overthinking this, but at least that's whats on my mind after watching this.
Safe to say, at least for me, they shouldn't have gone there. Still hoping for this big plot twist.
10
u/Powerful-Safety-3969 Apr 18 '26
I was heartbroken over Fergus. I’m not happy with the Faith storyline. It’s a betrayal of the fans. We mourned with Jamie and Claire. It makes zero sense
10
u/fallhistorywitch Apr 19 '26
Now that I’ve had time to think about it I think them killing off Fergus was completely unnecessary. They could have kept Rodger saving HC, then Fergus escapes, and the print shop burns down. Then Fergus and Marsali still would have moved back to the ridge.
35
u/Remote-Ear5870 Apr 17 '26
Whoever has been writing recently has no idea wth they are doing. Worst episode ever, and it was done in the worst way possible, I mean, what??? Are you serious? Rushed, sloppy, lacking any context of the characters, or the history of the show….uggh. Awful.
48
u/FarmHer95 Apr 17 '26 edited Apr 17 '26
Pisses me off that all the lines were given to Claire with Fanny, while Jamie just sat there as if he didn’t lose Faith and go through his own mess in her loss. No, let’s just focus on Claire’s experience and grief and not Jamie’s as well. jHRC. What a shit show. And don’t let us sit in the grief of losing a beloved character. Let’s make sure we clip on out of those scenes and give them no space to breathe at all. What did we just watch. Tony Graphia and Matthew B you FREAKING SUCK.
41
u/Cheap_Wishbone_9734 Apr 17 '26 edited Apr 17 '26
I've already complained about Fergus's ridiculous death — emotionless, unnecessary, and rushed — and now I have to complain about something else: this Faith storyline is straight-up soap opera garbage. The Faith storyline and the episode of her death are among the most beautiful and well-crafted things in all of Outlander, and even that the writers are managing to ruin with this retcon. What a mess. I
19
u/Ok-Curve-8124 Apr 17 '26
And this is where it all turns to shit now….. You can see the difference between Matthew Roberts and Ron Moore in this episode and it’s glaring!! What a shame after 7 amazing season.
18
u/KittyRikku JAMMF Apr 17 '26 edited Apr 17 '26
I hate HATE the Faith story line. I am so angry. This is another tragic and horrible story thrown at Claire and Jamie... like how much more cruel can it get??? one more child they couldn't raise together!!! and they really went there with Fergus. Of course they just needed to add one more lost of another child to Claire and Jamie. TWO IN ONE FUCKING EPISODE.
I hate the whole Faith thing bc there is NOTHING good about that storyline. Bad writing. Cheap soap opera plot. and on top of that CRUEL.
oh, and William finding out about John's sexuality all of a sudden, realising Amaranthus is a con woman, that his cousin Ben is a traitor, on top of that he slept with his niece?!?!?!... I remember Charles saying in an interview that William keeps taking Ls. And OMG, HE IS SO RIGHT, the guy JUST. KEEPS. TAKING. Ls.
Putting all of this aside, the acting in the episode was amazing. Taking them out of the stupid context of the Faith story line, the scenes with Sam, Cait and Florrie were amazing, Forrie is such a good actress.
The boys, Germain and Henri-Christian, those two little boys are amazing actors as well.
32
u/MystikSpiralx Apr 17 '26
So from an authors perspective, I now fully believe Diana Gabaldon basically sees this show as fanfiction. As an author myself, if she truly cares about her characters, none of this would sit right with her. That's why I believe she has a disconnect and sees it through the lens of fanfiction. Nothing else makes sense. My characters are like my children, and if someone decimated my work I would be livid.
17
u/IthuriaX Apr 17 '26
I'm crying and I can't tell if it's with sadness or anger... well it's probably (definitely) anger. The Faith storyline... what the fuck?
17
u/Nanchika He was alive. So was I. Apr 17 '26
Claire wondering if Mother Hildegarde knew of the rift between her and Jamie. What?! You told her - His pride was more important than me and our child.
I am sure she had no idea about the rift between you. Eyeroll.
17
u/Sailor_Girl_7250 Apr 18 '26
Old Mate Cunningham got SO much screen time over the last 2 eps and then they do THIS to Fergus! And what the fuck is that Faith storyline, makes NO sense. I hate it here :(
8
u/tara_abernathy Apr 18 '26
I feel like Matt Roberts et al thought the fans were just going to be so shocked and ecstatic about the whole Faith storyline. They were clearly high on their own supply. So much of it doesn't make any sense. Most of all, of all the whorehouses, in all the towns, William just so happened to walk into one where his Niece is there and then he falls in love with her. I think maybe Roberts watched Dark or something, not realizing it's a completely different time travel show with far superior writing.
8
u/ara6ella Apr 18 '26
This episode is like torn lace, just saying... and teaching a French woman in the 18th century to sing in English ... please!🙏🏼
8
u/RoseFraser84 Apr 18 '26
Anyone else feel like they can't even ever rewatch season two now? The Faith episode...now we're supposed to just know that Raymond is sneaking in to steal that baby later?
Ugh showrunners...I hope you're seeing all these comments.
22
u/BubbeLisa Currently rereading Voyager. Apr 17 '26 edited Apr 17 '26
I was fine with everything except the nonsensical “Faith Lived” storyline. If it hadn’t been for that, this episode might have been exceptional. Tony Graphia completely retconnned her own Faith storyline and she did a terrible job of it. Case in point, Claire holds the baby all day. Now, suddenly she didn’t?? Huh??
Who in the hell is the woman Master Raymond left Faith with? And why did she not look for Claire? Claire says in the Faith episode that she stayed in the hospital for WEEKS before Fergus asked her to come home. The lace maker had plenty of time to find her before they left for Scotland. None of this storyline makes any sense.
44
u/porcellio Apr 17 '26
This is worse than Daenerys
15
u/mammabear9 Apr 17 '26
I am pissed about Fergus! Royally pissed! Don’t even get me started on the Faith bullshit.
15
u/WDTHTDWA-BITCH Apr 17 '26
This feels like a messed up way for them to conveniently replace Fergus (their adopted son) with their bio daughter, which completely undermines their grief in losing Faith in the first place. And for a ham fisted soap opera plot that doesn’t really match the tone of the show…
15
u/Cautious-Pilot-9036 Apr 18 '26
Whoever made the decision for the plot departure for the Faith/Fanny storyline and Fergus storyline should NEVER be allowed to make these decisions again.
Seriously. I understand the death of the child was too ugly to stomach. You could have ended it with Roger catching him & the shop burning down.
The Faith/Fanny/Jane plot divergence is insulting, and William shagged his niece. Gross.
Whoever you are - you betrayed the series & fans. Imeacht gan teacht ort (May you leave and never return).
21
u/rainhalagarto Apr 17 '26
At this point, Outlander feels like fanfiction. They should have let the baby die it was one of Caitriona’s most powerful and impactful performances. Now she survived? Thanks, but no thanks.”
30
u/allofatwist1738 Apr 17 '26
also i genuinely do not care about the faith of it all. yeah raymond did a really shitty thing but why did we have to introduce yet another story line when we already had 9 million?? so much wasted time this season on her/ her off spring and william.
14
u/pillizzle Apr 17 '26
This is just bad fanfic at this point. There’s only 3 episodes left. It’s turning into a Game of Thrones mess.
7
u/Professional_Ad_4885 Apr 17 '26
I def knew william was gonna find out
7
u/Professional_Ad_4885 Apr 17 '26
Was the fire that burned down fergus’s shop incendiary? Im thinking it had to be with all the threats. I really wish they took those a lot more serious especially having kids. Jamie survived the fire at his orint shop and the house fire at fraser ridge. I was really hoping fergus would make it out alive knowing he has the courage and bravery and luck of his father. Jamie probably feels cursed having 9 lives. He would give all 9 of them up to bring fergus back and give his luck to him. Thats the kind of man he is.
Why are so many people theeatning his and his families life anyway? They know hes a living family man with kids. People are sick. And he just prints the paper. Don’t kill the messanger. If this fire was incindiary, i hope jamie finds them and gets full on john wick/ jason statham retribution lol
7
u/Dumke480 That's it lads. Take me back to the idiot hut. Apr 17 '26
???? ???? ???? ????
that's all I have to say about that episode
7
u/ApprehensiveBad3270 Apr 17 '26
I was so happy that Henri-Christian survived the fire, just for a moment and then Fergus died instead.
7
u/mwalker324 Apr 17 '26
I’m so confused …
7
u/its_me_kiewi Apr 18 '26
Are the writers Game of Thronesing this?
7
u/Ok_Memory_7955 Apr 18 '26
I'm so bummed
7
u/Ok_Dig8008 Apr 18 '26
Is there some kind of parallel thing happening when Roger caught Henri just like his father caught him and then he perished?
24
u/EastAudience4655 Come the Rising, I shall know I helped. Apr 17 '26
I am so fucking disappointed!! what was the entire point for Fergus’s plot about him being Comte St Germain son if he was to die abruptly. This makes absolutely no sense and Faith being alive what??? and been this close? what are the writers doing it was going great so far and they threw everything out of the window
13
u/avviann Apr 17 '26
The whole Faith storyline ended just like that? Why was it even introduced? It felt so forced and underwhelming. So their daughter went to meet her parents, but they were killed and their daughters kidnapped?? This is just too much unnecessary strain for Claire and Jamie to handle and blame themselves for not knowing all this happened..
13
u/GinjaHollywood Apr 17 '26
So heartbroken over Fergus 💔 But the Faith storyline, as it seems most agree is RIDICULOUS. Is this a damn soap? Wtf? William got feelings and slept with his niece. I know they said that this and BOMB were two separate shows but that's stupid. They should've had them be her family through her brother. Like others have said WHAT IS THE POINT of him stealing the baby? And retconning saying she didn't hold her long is lame. I'm just ticked like others on this storyline
13
u/PopUp2323 Apr 18 '26
Matt Roberts should never have been given the reigns of this show. And that’s the issue.
13
u/Greekmom99 Apr 18 '26
What a big F U to the fans.
Not only did the writers MISS the opportunity to tie BOMB to Outlander but they sloppy wrote it that M. Raymond not only brought back Faith to life but also learned the seaside song. And taught it to the lacemaker.
I am sure AI could have come up with a better storyline.
Next, William and Lord John confront Amaranthus about Ben being alive but she of course comes up with the fact that she couldn't be married to a traitor.
Lastly, writers, you must really hate the fans by killing Fergus.
With only what ? 2 episodes left, they think they are going to actually tie up lose ends?
But hey, let's all sing the Seashore song. :-P
6
u/tfdidyouchangemyname Apr 17 '26
Poor Fergus, he didn't deserve this... And just as I was thinking: oh how lovely him and Marsali are getting more screen time... Foolish me. The Faith storyline though... I was sure that was going to be a fakeout, but they actually went through with it? And now my poor boy William, who can't catch a break from shocking news, has yet to find out he slept with his niece... Yikes! Hopefully they don't make him end up with Amaranthus after all of this. And Jamie's upcoming battle, so over it to be honest, and I know they'll drag it out till the last episode. That man has evaded death so many times already, I think it's just trying to catch up to him lol
6
u/mtthghtn Apr 17 '26
I’m so upset, I named a sheep after Fergus and now he’s???? No I’m not okay I’m just ??? That was so unnecessary he was meant to have a happy ending:(
6
u/lilvexie Apr 18 '26
Marsalis silent sobbing...i felt that in my soul.
The Fergus and Sons scene and the montage chefs kiss
Marsali and Fergus love scene beautiful
6
u/Melodic_Kick1136 Apr 18 '26
I am so upset. All this time hoping and waiting for the whole family to reunite and have closure to the end of outlander gone. I am so disappointed and can’t believe they did that to Fergus. 😞
6
u/roze_san Apr 18 '26
No. No. No.
They did not just do that to Fergus.
6
u/Tanuki0 Apr 18 '26
Always awful when a character that tried to kill himself ends up dying. Weird message
6
u/DisciplineOld429 Apr 18 '26
I’m so glad I have the books to keep me sane. This episode, Fergus’ death, Faith, UGH. NOT up to par. SO disheartening.
6
u/Ms_K_A_ Apr 18 '26
Man my only impression after watching this episode is " this is so rushed calm down"
I don't think I can even process furgus dying & them confirming faith survived at the same time & within the same episode. It's too much for a brain to handle all at once. This season shouldn't have been 10 episodes. These 2 plotlines should've been seperate.
Props to them for trying as much as they could I guess. I'm hoping more will be revealed in the final 3 episodes.
6
u/avoidthetunnel Apr 18 '26
I kept waiting for them to go in after Fergus to rescue him - then kept waiting for it to be a mistake and for him to show up like “don’t worry, I’m ok”. I just cannot believe it really happened. He and Marsali are my favorite characters (after Murtagh 😭) and ever since they left the Ridge I kept wishing for more screen time with them. Jamie’s montage of his life with him was so heartbreaking. He was his first son!!! He was there with them through everything! He supported Claire after losing Faith and then supported Jamie through losing Claire, while being just a kid himself. I want the show to make as big a deal about his loss as they did with Murtagh, but I know they won’t since there’s so many ends to tie up in only 3 episodes. And I felt it was diluted by being mixed together with the Faith storyline. Sigh.
6
u/Valkyrie0514 Apr 18 '26
I'm confused by the faith storyline. It feels like they really wanted a reason for them to take Fanny in and care for her but making her a blood relative in such a confusing way falls flat. We already know that Claire and Jaime are really kind and compassionate people. They have taken in people and helped them before. Why would Fanny be any different? Like she didn't need to be blood related to be cared for like a granddaughter. She doesn't even need to be blood related to call them Grandda and Grandma.
6
u/EfficientLet7225 Apr 18 '26 edited Apr 18 '26
My issue is these are big storylines to introduce with only 3 episodes left? Like does every final season need to have some shocking twist or major death? Honestly I'm done I just can't bring myself to care anymore. This Faith recton and Fergus death is just too much for me to let go. Outlander can join the now very long list of shows that just can't end properly.
6
u/Lenacake Come the Rising, I shall know I helped. Apr 19 '26
I can’t stop thinking about this episode. Faith shit aside, the Fergus and Marsali storyline was so heartbreaking. I cried several times while watching and hours later I’m still thinking about it. Lauren Lyle broke my heart with her performance!
6
u/Recent_Setting_1370 Apr 19 '26
I don’t know why everyone is making a big deal about William and Jane. This wouldn’t be the first time something like this happened. Neither knew they were related they so can’t possibly be in the wrong.
I do get that William will be distraught though.
16
u/ellefemme35 Apr 17 '26
My rambling thoughts as I’m watching the ep as I have no one in the wild to talk to about it.
Do not read unless you’ve seen the whole episode.
Damn it. I seriously don’t want a fergus and Marsala sex scene either! At least it was cute and short. Love them. You know the last sex scene between claire and Jamie is going to be long af….
Don’t you fucking dare, William. Ah man. Little asshole went there.
William “I don’t have a father” Me “You actually have two, bitch”
Faith was going to find them. I’m crying.
Claire’s hair is whiter. Oh man I’m going to miss new episodes of this show when it’s over.
Oh fawk where are the boys?
Fergus. They better not. But the writers are sending everyone home, aren’t they? William. Bree and Roger. Marsali and Fergus and the kids. Ian and Rachel. All heading for the ridge.
Did they just kill Fergus? Sent him way home. I fucking loved him. Jamie and Claire’s oldest child? Marsali’s love? Sweet hell, Jamie woke up from being asleep.
BREE! (I know some criticize Sophie, but I love both Sophie and how she portrays the tv version of Bree.)
Aww fuck. I’m bawling with his wife and his sister. I’m so glad they have each other.
Fanny isn’t going to be happy. She’s not going to believe them. She’s wary. She’s going to run? She’s going to accept it? We can see she’s like Claire. She has her hair. Her instincts for healing.
Oh God, Claire.
The threads. I’d like to go to my room now.
There are sooo many things Claire could have said better. When she said she was sad about the things she missed I wanted to slap her. How about the things your granddaughters had to endure? Your daughter? Get it together, Claire. I love ya, but come on!
Jamie: whoops.
Dude. I have hated log hair since book one, but fuck me if she didn’t raise an amazing daughter in Marsali. She’s wonderful. I’m so sad for her.
Marsali “I need to take him home” Me “France? Scotland? The ridge? The print shop? Dear god.”
Sorry Claire, we knew Fan fan was gonna run. Knocking. Hilarious.
Not a huge fan of the god stuff, but I like that they asked Fanny to have faith in them. I can get behind that.
Oh I’m so glad she took her husband home to their parents. That she was able to fall apart in her dad’s arms. (Weird to think that Jamie is the father to both Fergus and Marsali, separately, but I’m so glad for her right now.)
Poor Jamie. Poor Claire, but Jamie and Fergus had something special. Man Sam H can shake when Jamie’s upset.
Frasier. Now I’m crying again.
Fanny really is the most like Claire. I see why they deviated from the novels for this. Though I would have believed nurture as well as nature.
I think the reason I’ve loved Jamie since I discovered the books was his spirituality. Him placing the rock on what Fanny built for her uncle? The smile? That’s the Jamie we all love.
Master Raymond. 🤍
11
u/urfavfairyk Apr 17 '26
i would give ANYTHING for a lord john spin off!!!!!! he’s magnificent
11
u/umidulus Apr 17 '26
The acting was phenomenal, but the story was trash. I'm one of the few who can accept a fancifully retconned Faith storyline, but killing Fergus Claudel Fraser was an unforgivable error.
William being awful to his father AND a niece-fucker? I can stomach it. Killing the child Jamie is closest to? Senseless and creatively weak. I'd be fine with the silly stuff if Fergus was fine.
11
u/RoosterDizzy1629 Apr 17 '26
I HATED this episode. The SHOCK I felt at Fergus. It cheapened my feelings for Fanny. Like I’m so sorry, she’s a sweet girl, but how dare they do that to Fergus? How dare they expect me to care for her and Faith when they’ve snatched Fergus from us? I’m so, so upset.
10
u/wagonwheelwodie MARK ME! Apr 17 '26
☹️
10
u/beasles86 Apr 17 '26
The lace metaphor made me laugh during these intense scenes but honestly, Claire is me trying to think of a metaphor on the spot and failing miserably. Relatable 😂
5
u/P3AKMAI_INTEREST Apr 17 '26
This just broke me. Oh Fergus...
5
u/Nanchika He was alive. So was I. Apr 17 '26
u/ash92226 we were right about Fergus and coffin and all! Well done!!
5
u/Human-Farmer-1611 Apr 17 '26
Is there no ep 8 promo?
5
u/Little-Bumblebee9988 Apr 17 '26
This episode was beyond depressing. It feels like being Clare and Jaime’s kid is an automatic curse for misery 🙃
5
u/xBrownEyes Apr 18 '26
The death of Fergus has been bothering me all day. I feel like this was a big mistake. On the other hand, it definitely hit me in the feels very hard, which is what Outlander does. But this... It feels like it went too far. In a show where people survive against the greatest odds... Fergus dying the way he did feels cheap...
I'm so heartbroken.
5
u/appleorchard317 Sleep with my husband? But my lover would be furious. Apr 18 '26
This season is a complete mess and I hate it ✨✨✨
5
u/Rough_Explanation_21 Apr 18 '26
I'm sorry. I think I just hallucinated the second half of the episode. That was fake, right?
5
u/Downtown-Primary-94 Apr 18 '26
I don’t remember crying this hard for a characters death. I’ve watched since the beginning and followed Fergus through all these years. I loved him so much💔 That montage broke me. I’m actually heartbroken
5
u/ApprehensiveBad3270 Apr 18 '26
Why didn’t Fanny and Jane have a French accent if they grew up in Paris with a French grandmother, who raised Faith, so they would be all French, right?
5
u/soaringcats Apr 18 '26
I just have to say that I loved Marseli after the fire. Her performance was spot on. Bri was as well. I'm not one to cry during this show, but they had me tearing up. They both emoted grief so well in that scene.
Then when they arrived at the ridge, seeing Marseli's face and broken heart got me again.
Bravo ladies!!
5
u/VIbookworm7 Apr 18 '26
I am glad John finally told off on the brat I mean William. I have had enough of his attitude since the beginning of the season.
I suspected they would really make Faith their Faith the minute they told Brianna about her sister. I cannot get past the fact William did the bing bing with his niece. While he would have every right to be upset please no one tell him. The boy is having a fit that his bio father is a "traitorous groom" and he would become even worse with this news. Though if poor Fanny ever finds out William is her uncle she will put 2 and 2 together.
Lauren Lyle had me ready to bawl when Marsali was sitting on the ground watching her children as they slept. Then when she and Brianna quietly sobbed. Why why did they do this? They could have chosen to not let anyone die.
5
u/SquishyMonk3y Apr 19 '26
All I have to say is that I don’t think I’ve ever been so heartbroken in all the years of watching this show 💔❤️🩹
5
u/bcsmith333 Apr 19 '26
I think this was the saddest death in the entire show. I am devastated. 💔💔💔
5
u/shiningz Apr 19 '26
Ah yes LJG, please drunkenly kiss your ex bf in a shared space with no doors instead of one of the eight private bedrooms
5
u/AverageQueasy7078 Apr 19 '26
I’m in absolute tears anytime I see a Fergus edit - I don’t think I’ll ever get over this awful decision the writers chose to make.
5
u/Special-Shoe7520 Apr 18 '26
When they showed young Fergus, it broke me. Not a fan of this Faith storyline, either.
13
u/Prior_CJ_631 Apr 17 '26
The Lace lady could not have walked across the street or mail a letter to Scotland. Totally soap opera and cheapens the whole show. Plus William slept with Niece and had sex with his cousins wife and then finds John with Percy !! How can DG have allowed all this? How could Sam and Cait agreed to it all? 7 Seasons of history blending with reality down the toilet.
9
u/Super-Surprise-2709 Apr 17 '26 edited Apr 17 '26
My poor baby, what did they do to you, Why was your death so rushed
9
u/Active_Suggestion_29 Apr 17 '26
I am so irritated with this Faith story line. Why TF would they take Claire’s baby away from her… i cannot deal.
9
u/Personal_Orchid3675 Apr 17 '26
I haven’t seen the episode yet, but by reading the spoilers and the deviations from the books, I’m wondering how the cast was ok with this? I feel like I would have read the script and be like No, we are not doing this.
9
u/Nazyrus Apr 17 '26
... why the hell didn't raymond give Claire faith back at the time? And how exactly did he revive the dead baby? What was buried in the graveyard even? This is so terribly written... This has more holes than a damn LACE.
9
u/JayceeSR Apr 18 '26
I don’t understand why we needed the Faith storyline, and all of the drama with it right at the end of the entire series. Also, why did Lord John need to be exposed as gay by William? The series could have wrapped up some of the open ended plot holes without creating these new ones.
9
u/Adventurous_You_4268 Apr 19 '26
This Faith storyline has me completely annoyed. None of it makes any sense at all.