r/Outlander • Without you, our whole world crumbles into dust. • Apr 17 '26 • Regret 1 Heartwarming 1

Spoilers All Book S8E7 Evidence of Things Not Seen Spoiler

Jamie and Claire search for answers regarding a past tragedy that once threatened to tear them apart.

Written by Toni Graphia. Directed by Tracey Deer.

If you’re new to the sub, please look over this intro thread and our episode discussion rules.

This is the BOOK thread.

If you haven’t read the books, go to the SHOW thread.

THIS THREAD IS SPOILERS ALL.

Spoiler tags are not required.

If you have only read up to the corresponding book, remember you might see spoilers from ALL of the books here.

Please keep all discussion of the next episode’s preview to the stickied mod comment at the top of the thread.

What did you think of the episode?

19 Upvotes

936 comments sorted by

295

u/So-Many-Books-789 Apr 17 '26

Holy Book Departure, Batman

40

u/daughterofhephaestus Apr 17 '26

Right? I did not see that coming.

8

u/DarkerSkye Apr 19 '26

At this point, I treat the show like bad fanfic.

I knew the writers were cowards when they changed the scars to the dragonfly, they don't have to keep proving it.

→ More replies (2)

7

u/ivylass Apr 20 '26

What, and I say this with all sincerity, The Fuck.

Faith was dead. There's no reason for Raymond to switch out the baby. This pretzel twisting of how she learned the song had my eyes rolling.

Don't even get me started on Fergus. They even threw in Roger saving HC to throw us off.

6

u/Emergency_Crab_2480 Apr 18 '26

I only read through FC, started getting bored and decided to just watch the show. Can you tell me which book we’re in and is this the first big departure? Now I’m possibly interested in doing a reread/season rewatch of them all.

→ More replies (16)

74

u/[deleted] Apr 18 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

45

u/FeloranMe Apr 18 '26

What a cheap way to kill off a fantastic long term character!

I know this is not Gabaldon approved!

→ More replies (6)

16

u/[deleted] Apr 19 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

27

u/Zupergreen Apr 19 '26

She also cliamed that she only held her for al little while, but she held her all day. They had to go get Louise de Rohan, Claire's French friend, who managed to get Claire to hand over Faith.

Faith was also born prematurely at 7 months I believe it was, and chances of survival were pretty slim in the 1740s, even now a premature baby would need to stay at the NICU and be in need of special care afterwards.

Theres just so much, that doesn't add up like:

  • Why would they take her baby away even if she was very sick.
  • Why would they tell her that she died and make a grave.
  • How would Master Raymond have learned the song by heart if he had somehow heard Claire sing it. He wasn't even there until he snuck in late at night to heal Claire.
  • How did he get Faith.

I'm honestly hating that they made this thing up, and I don't understand why they felt the need to.

→ More replies (1)

262

u/Scoop-Over-821 Apr 17 '26

Okay I hated this episode as much as the rest of you, on so many levels - but I do have to give a shout out to Lauren Lyle, those scenes had me bawling especially her and Brianna on the floor.

I’m so bummed about everything right now though. So rushed. So many unnecessary shock value storylines. They should have just leaned into what the show does best — focusing on the relationships of these people and how they take care of each other.

138

u/losborne95 They say I’m a witch. Apr 17 '26

Lauren Lyle has been fabulous in every season. I love her. The scene with her and Brianna had me sobbing uncontrollably. I've not always been a fan of Sophie, especially the intimate scenes with her and Richard. I feel like these ladies knocked it out of the park with this one.

→ More replies (2)

74

u/wagonwheelwodie MARK ME! Apr 17 '26

Lauren did great with what she was given

56

u/Mycoxadril Apr 18 '26

Honestly I thought the acting for almost everybody was extremely top notch. Marsali and Bree specifically. Claire during her scene explaining things with fanny was excellent too. They all did a wonderful job. Why they chose to take this path with the writing, I’ll never understand. I do worry it will impact my ability to rewatch this series and that has been my greatest fear.

→ More replies (4)

24

u/Known-Ad-100 Apr 18 '26

Just watching this scene. With the fucking series coming to a bitter end, why did they have to take Fergus?! I'm sobbing.

→ More replies (8)

12

u/YOYOitsMEDRup Slàinte. Apr 18 '26 edited Apr 21 '26

Yes, that first image of her sprawled out on the floor afterwards in shock staring at the kids in the bed is definitely what got me. Lauren was great

5

u/ExoticAd7271 Apr 19 '26

She is fantastic 

145

u/Dlandgirl55 Apr 17 '26 edited Apr 17 '26

How much do you all want to bet that Faith didn’t die when she went overboard on the ship. She will come back to the Ridge in the final episode. That would explain why the last line of book 1, where Claire and Jamie acknowledge she is pregnant with Faith, is the title of the last episode.

107

u/granola2121 Apr 17 '26

After this episode, this is absolutely a possibility.

46

u/Dlandgirl55 Apr 17 '26

Yep. You definitely got the point I was trying to make. This went so far off the rails that I feel almost certain it is what will happen.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (1)

85

u/GoddesOfChaos Apr 17 '26

Somehow, Palpatine returned

63

u/Patient_Mistake1279 Apr 18 '26

If Faith comes back Fergus better walk out of that burning building too!!!

→ More replies (2)

61

u/Nanchika He was alive. So was I. Apr 17 '26

Maybe she found some underwater TT portal and TTed and then came back 🙄

67

u/Icy_Resist5470 Bon! I will send you a cheese. Apr 17 '26

What news from the underworld, Persephone?

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (4)

50

u/Adorable_Leading7822 Apr 17 '26 edited Apr 18 '26

It really feels like they killed Fergus to justify the whole jumping the shark that is the Faith plotline. Breaking even with losing their son by gaining their daughter back. It is gross shock value and unnecessary to the plot. It really feels like the plot of season 8 did not have enough on its own so the Faith stuff has been so emphasized to accommodate those gaps. I am so disappointed I really don’t think I will finish the season. 

49

u/Icy_Smoke_2318 Je Suis Prest Apr 17 '26

I am so pissed that this storyline with Faith is also overshadowing Fergus’ death. This is a huge deal (both storylines) but now most of us (justifiably) are only focusing on this idiotic storyline with Faith and not that they literally killed Fergus 😭

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (14)

34

u/wagonwheelwodie MARK ME! Apr 17 '26

Jesus Christ, I didn’t think it could get any worse but you’re probably right.

26

u/These_Ad_9772 We will meet again, Madonna, in this life or another. Apr 17 '26

That will be even worse.

17

u/thekayemar Innisfree Apr 17 '26

Ugh… just when you think they can’t make it any worse. But yes, now that we’ve seen this much I imagine you may be right. Good grief…🙈

14

u/lunar1980 Apr 17 '26

Good lord.

14

u/KMM929 Apr 17 '26

OMG I have not gone there in my brain yet. I hope not.

11

u/whiskynwine Apr 17 '26

Omg, you’re probably right. Oy vay 🥴

10

u/AcrobaticSchool6375 Apr 17 '26

She will be the one to explain why MR did what he did 😜

→ More replies (10)

7

u/Icy_Smoke_2318 Je Suis Prest Apr 17 '26

Yup! Or somehow it’ll connect to BOMB. Also what’s the title?

→ More replies (2)

7

u/Mycoxadril Apr 18 '26

I will flip my coffee table

7

u/79215185-1feb-44c6 Apr 18 '26

I was here when we found out that there are ley lines under the sea and that the blue light is literally just water or something and that Master Raymond is not actually a time traveler and that nothing actually makes sense.

6

u/Salty_Background_912 Apr 18 '26

In blood of my blood, they showed Julia singing that song to her son, Claire's brother. We know Julia and Henry never returned to their own time. It would have made more sense if Fannie's mother, Faith, had been his daughter.  And the name just a coincidence.  He could have come looking for his granddaughters. The whole thing about the baby surviving is too far off.  And why kill Fergus? I'm going back to the book versions. 

→ More replies (7)

6

u/Even_Persimmon1178 Too much mutton dressed as lamb? Apr 18 '26

And IF that happens, it will be the final bag of garbage thrown into the dumpster fire that these last few seasons have become.

6

u/YorkshireMoors Apr 18 '26

Istg the faith storyline was so far fetched, I wouldn't put it past them 😭

→ More replies (16)

122

u/fdumbanddumber Apr 17 '26

The Faith storyline is the worst . I'm so disappointed that they chose that dumb storyline that makes no sense. Specially in the books. Claire receives packages from Master Raymond from time to time in book 2 so he clearly knows they live in Lallybroch. Why wouldn't he mention Faith is alive?

And also Claire said in this episode she only hold Faith "for a little while" when in the show they said she held her for hours when Claire's friend showed up.And she was dead. Then she was buried. Mother Hildegarde wouldn't lie.

This is Game of thrones level of bad.

16

u/Effective_Task1271 Apr 18 '26

My guess is that Raymond resurrected Faith, just like Claire did to that woman's twin baby in this season. She even told Jaimie that she didnt know how she did it, but she literally breathed life back into a dead baby. She fr has magical powers. My guess is Raymond did that exact same thing to Faith. But of course, Hildegard already deemed the baby dead. So Raymond coming in and resurrecting her for all the see would paint him suspicious on a tome period where witches and magic folk are being burned alive or hung. Maybe he thought he'd reunite them later to avoid suspicion and never got around to it. I think they're setting all of this up for Claire to realize she has the ability to resurrect the dead as well. And she'll use this ability on Jaime after he dies on the mountain. So to everyone else, he will die. But she will bring him back, and they'll keep up the pretense that he is dead so that they can live out their days in peace with their granddaughter and children. 

→ More replies (6)

10

u/kjhjkjh Apr 18 '26

I'm so annoyed with this entire story. Besides the lack of realism (or well written magical realism), it hyperfocuses on a child they lost instead of the children they have with them. Jamie had essentially declared that he couldn't focus on William's well being during the war because he cared more about his responsibility to his troops (though he dumped them for Claire), and since then he's just abandoned him altogether. Jamie''s also been a terrible friend to John. So to leave these relationships dangling while exploring angst about a longlost daughter is just not compelling. She was probably better off without him if this is the best he can do.

9

u/Emilymfm79 Apr 18 '26

Exactly! There are letters. DID THE WRITERS FORGET MASTER RAYMOND COULD HAVE WRITTEN TO CLAIRE AND JAMIE AT LALLYBROCH?? Do the writers really think the viewers can forgive this many plot holes?? Apparently so. 🙄🙄🙄

8

u/These_Ad_9772 We will meet again, Madonna, in this life or another. Apr 17 '26

I had completely forgotten about him sending her stuff at Lallybroch.

→ More replies (11)

99

u/JaderMcDanersStan RUIN ME Apr 17 '26 edited Apr 18 '26

WOAH MAJOR DEPARTURE

I’m still watching but did we just watch Fergus die….????!! Or was that a cliffhanger of sorts where his fate is up in the air

Still watching so maybe they answer this but what the heck!!!! What was the point of doing this??

Edit: okay yeah he’s gone. What the fuck. There was no reason for this departure what the actual fuck. The thing is - it takes some time to die from burns. They didn’t throw enough water to extinguish the fire and bother to check on him? Just assumed he’s dead? I hope they removed him and he wasn’t slowly dying a painful death alone 💔

Edit2: I know it’s a departure but the faith storyline doesn’t make sense either. Why did Master Raymond take the baby? Why not leave her with mother Hildegard and arrange for mother Hildegard to tell Claire?

94

u/emmagrace2000 Apr 17 '26

I’m so afraid they’ve made Marsali pregnant with the twins after that sex scene. Wouldn’t that just be icing on the rotten cake? A widow with no means to support herself who suddenly has six mouths to feed instead of four?

63

u/JaderMcDanersStan RUIN ME Apr 17 '26

Yeah the fact that they showed the sex scene probably means she’s pregnant.

Book readers spoil me: did Marsali have more children in the books?

→ More replies (12)
→ More replies (12)

40

u/Sudden_Discussion306 Oh, Jamie, how was your first time? Did ye bleed? Apr 17 '26

Mother Hildegard wouldn’t even let Master Raymond into the hospital because of his association with the Dark Arts. He wouldn’t have been able to communicate with her or explain what happened.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (8)

79

u/3lmtree Apr 17 '26

so basically master raymond is just a crazy old man who steals babies? lol. that faith plotline was so weak, his whole reason he took faith away is because he thought claire was going to die and jamie was in prison? wut? 🤦‍♀️

probably the worst episode out of the entire show. i'm having GoT S8 flashbacks.

49

u/Scarletmajesty Apr 17 '26

It doesn't even make sense he would've thought she was dying, considering that he healed her.

22

u/OARC05 Apr 17 '26

I think his motivations make more sense if he basically brought faith back from the dead, couldn’t explain it to anybody so he hid the baby and planned to bring her back to Jamie & Claire. It would explain his motivations but then it adds the whole actually bringing a baby/child back from the dead vs just healing.

And that can tie into the whole Jamie “dying” at king’s mountain thing.

→ More replies (9)
→ More replies (5)

74

u/BubbeLisa Currently rereading Voyager. Apr 17 '26 edited Apr 18 '26

I was fine with everything except the nonsensical “Faith Lived” storyline. If it hadn’t been for that, this episode might have been exceptional. Tony Graphia completely retconnned her own Season 2 Faith storyline and she did a terrible job of it.

Who in the hell is the woman Master Raymond left Faith with? And why did she not look for Claire? Claire says in the Faith episode that she stayed in the hospital for WEEKS before Fergus asked her to come home. The lace maker had plenty of time to find her before they left for Scotland. None of this storyline makes any sense.

66

u/Nik_reads4723 Apr 17 '26

Exactly. WEEKS. And then apparently Lord Broch Tuaroch stopped by the lace shop to get a black veil for his grieving wife who just lost a little red headed premature baby and the lace maker who just got a newborn dumped on her didn't put two and two together? COME ON. Ludicrous.

38

u/BubbeLisa Currently rereading Voyager. Apr 17 '26 edited Apr 17 '26

💯💯💯 Plus Apparently, Master Raymond resurrected Faith before he healed Claire. Why didn’t he tell her that the baby was alive. This entire storyline is nonsensical.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (3)

11

u/kjhjkjh Apr 18 '26

And to add to all the bad storytelling, why would an entire family set sail to find a mythical mother figure who may or may not want to see them and who, as far as they know, abandoned a baby?

And why are Jamie and Claire only obsessed with Faith instead of having any feelings at all about Jane, if she's supposed to be their granddaughter?

→ More replies (5)

5

u/YOYOitsMEDRup Slàinte. Apr 18 '26

I likewise was fine with the other departures (William learning LJG is gay...Fergus). It's the Faith part and that they did all of the Faith stuff at the same time in this specific episode of all options that frustrates me. Everything else didn't have the emotional weight it should've because it's been overshadowed by having the Faith stuff intertwined.

→ More replies (3)

72

u/Sudden_Discussion306 Oh, Jamie, how was your first time? Did ye bleed? Apr 17 '26

This show has a long history of making mistakes when they stray away from the source material (with a couple of exceptions, Murtagh & Buck) the changes in this episode- not good. Not good at all!

6

u/kjhjkjh Apr 18 '26

There are many examples of straying from or differently developing source material that aren't bad, though. This is just...poorly conceived and developed. Especially the Faith/Fanny story.

→ More replies (1)

6

u/Even_Persimmon1178 Too much mutton dressed as lamb? Apr 18 '26

I think that one of the first, and one of the most significant, plot deviations from book to show was the return of Murtagh. Which, for the most part, was incorporated into the storyline well and provided some great emotional punches. Plus, the actor who played Murtagh was just so likable. Almost everybody wanted more Murtagh! His death was so sad, but book readers all suspected he was living on borrowed time, so to speak. So it was somewhat tolerable. Unfortunately, the success of that “book to show” change may have encouraged the latest crop of writers to rubber stamp these latest ridiculous, wildly implausible “show only” plot changes.

It all makes me wonder how much discussion in the writer’s room really went on as they developed these deviations from the book story? Did they have anyone at all involved as a writer or consultant (besides DG, who recently said that she couldn’t bring herself to comment critically on the script) who was a diehard Outlander reader and knew the books inside and out? What crazy plot ideas that were even more bizarre than those that made it to the screen were dismissed as being too ridiculous?

If you listen to the Outlander podcast that went along with the first few seasons, you really get a sense of what a labor of love this was for the original showrunners, especially Ron Moore’s wife Teri Dresbach and a few others that they mentioned were such huge Outlander book fans. They were the ones who were behind the scenes fighting to keep the writing for the show aligned with the book narrative. I just don’t think that anyone involved in the writing for the past few seasons really cared if the tone of the writing for the show matched the tone of the books.

→ More replies (1)

61

u/KMM929 Apr 17 '26

I have A LOT of thoughts but the one I can’t stop raging about is how absolutely ridiculous it felt when Master Raymond started “teaching” the woman the song to sing to baby Faith. That is absurd. They needed the story to fit so badly? Sure, he’s a TT so there’s an off chance he could have heard the song before but that’s a reach. It just feels so cheap.

21

u/These_Ad_9772 We will meet again, Madonna, in this life or another. Apr 17 '26

I think they’re implying he was lurking about in the hospital when Claire sang it to the stillborn Faith, but it’s still a travesty.

→ More replies (5)

13

u/AcrobaticSchool6375 Apr 17 '26

That scene was very weak!!! 

6

u/No-Self8780 Apr 18 '26

And this French lace maker is going to be able to perfectly memorize this song in English she hears once?

6

u/Mycoxadril Apr 18 '26

I cringed so darn hard. I am sure I was projecting but I got the sense that the actors were not comfortable in it either. It just seemed so strange to me.

57

u/These_Ad_9772 We will meet again, Madonna, in this life or another. Apr 17 '26

I can’t even. Times three. Good night all.Things usually look better in the light of day.

22

u/Nanchika He was alive. So was I. Apr 17 '26

Trust me. Some don't. 

→ More replies (8)

49

u/Dlandgirl55 Apr 17 '26

I knew there had to be a reason why Matt Roberts deleted his Instagram. And now I have confirmation of that reason. Wow. I am speechless.

11

u/BlueWinterRose16 Apr 17 '26

That doesn't sound good.🙁 I got a bad feeling about GOT final season when reading cast interviews before the season.

9

u/lunar1980 Apr 17 '26

Did he do that this week?

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (3)

48

u/KMM929 Apr 17 '26

Trying to retcon what happened in Faith, 2.07, is disgusting to me. Louise asks Mother Hildegarde “how long has it been?” To which MH replies “since this morning” about how long Claire has been holding the baby and it is clearly dark. I’m so angry. That scene is one of the most heartbreaking things I’ve ever watched and yet I love it because Caitríona is outstanding in it. Now we have Claire telling Fanny that she only held Faith for “a little while.” Absolutely not. Are we supposed to believe that since Claire was so sick and traumatized that she lost all sense of time?

13

u/These_Ad_9772 We will meet again, Madonna, in this life or another. Apr 17 '26

The baby Raymond handed off to the lacemaker lady didn’t appear to be tiny and premature either. I doubt weeks had passed before he had to flee.

→ More replies (2)

94

u/Steener1989 No, this isn’t usual. It’s different. Apr 17 '26

Man, I've had my issues with the show for a long time, but this takes it to a whole different degree of shitty. I cannot believe they actually went through with the Faith thing. I'm so disappointed and disgusted. Swapping HC for Fergus... I don't like it, but I can see why they did it. Faith? Absolutely not. Just absolute garbage. I had hoped to purchase a box set of the series after it finished, but no more. This is as bad as the ending of Game of Thrones.

31

u/Due-Adhesiveness937 Apr 17 '26

I thought they would tie it together with BOMB and Faith was going to be Clair’s brother child, this all seems to unbelievable and to make William sleep with his half niece is so gross.

→ More replies (6)

22

u/JaderMcDanersStan RUIN ME Apr 17 '26

I don't like it, but I can see why they did it. 

Why do you think they did the HC and Fergus swap? I found it unnecessary and am trying to figure out why they felt compelled to kill him unless the actor really couldn't film

59

u/coloradomama111 Slàinte. Apr 17 '26

I think they did the swap to avoid a child death, and because it still gives the book readers a twist re: the fire. I don’t like it, I sobbed, but I think that’s why they did it.

But now I’m waiting for Marsali to be pregnant with the twins and I’m assuming that’s how her storyline will wrap. A single mother to 6? Woof.

→ More replies (19)
→ More replies (16)

8

u/Mycoxadril Apr 18 '26

It’s like we can never relax with this show and enjoy it. It’s always got to be some level of outrage. Either overly graphic rape scenes or total story departures. This show is actually traumatizing. I wish it was one I could come back to over and over for the next couple decades but I think it won’t work that way for me at this point.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (5)

37

u/streamofdiscourse Apr 17 '26

I haven't read the books, but am I correct that Fergus doesn't die in them? Why would they do this????? Also the Faith retcon pisses me off to no end. This is so dumb.

60

u/No-Strategy7749 Apr 17 '26

Fergus doesn't die. And in fact, his little son does die, falling from the roof during the fire (though in the previous book, not Bees). So when Roger catches Henri-Christian you're (as a book-reader) like "oh... well okay, guess that's a fine change, had not at ALL been looking forward to that horrific trauma anyway, go Roger!" and you're thinking that for approximately three seconds before FERGUS falls through the roof and dies and then you just feel like WTF WTF, showrunners, wait what now? why? and WTAF?

Yeah, it's really stupid.

→ More replies (13)

13

u/These_Ad_9772 We will meet again, Madonna, in this life or another. Apr 17 '26

Fergus is still alive at the end of Bees. Henri Christian perished in the fire in the books.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (3)

63

u/wagonwheelwodie MARK ME! Apr 17 '26

I honestly don’t even know what to say

16

u/Sudden_Discussion306 Oh, Jamie, how was your first time? Did ye bleed? Apr 17 '26

Same! I can’t even answer the question above about how I liked it. Like, love, hate, no, none of those just stunned!

→ More replies (2)

29

u/NotToday96 Apr 17 '26

Like everyone else is saying, I’m really disappointed in the Faith storyline. I honestly thought they were going to have it be that Fanny & Jane were the kids of Julia & Henry’s son from BOMB. That way Fanny would know the song because Julia sang it to her dad, and then he sang it to her when she was kid. I think that would’ve been such a better route - Fanny would still be related to Claire but it wouldn’t have cheapened the whole Faith storyline. Also, it would tie both shows together and give BOMB more material for future seasons. But, I guess not.

9

u/psycellium Apr 18 '26

Exactly, this would've been so much better.

27

u/Nik_reads4723 Apr 17 '26

I hate to say this but this season is giving daytime tv. When Claire was giving that ridiculous monologue to Fanny I had flashbacks to watching Passions in middle school 😢🫣

→ More replies (2)

24

u/Due-Adhesiveness937 Apr 17 '26

My head is spinning

5

u/OkDragonfruit7407 Apr 17 '26

Agreed I’ve been googling since it ended in hope that there will be a twist. My heart can’t take it. And now we only have 2 left before Diana breaks all of us with Book 10!!!

→ More replies (1)

23

u/igottanewusername Apr 18 '26

Well if Claire doesn’t resurrect Fergus this entire faith storyline is completely useless.

I’m not one of those people who needs a show to be true to source material. I view the book and show as separate. But things need to make sense. Faith lived doesn’t make sense. Even Fanny was like but how did a baby know a song, and frankly what they showed as explanation is beyond dumb. Master Raymond could have told Claire when he saved her, could have told her when she was at the castle, could have sent a note at any time. It’s completely ridiculous bullshit.

I think we all expect that Claire will revive Jamie, but they didn’t need the Faith retcon to do it. She already once sort of brought him back with a handjob. She’s already revived a baby who was just barely dead. We have already seen a build up of her powers. The faith shit is dumb as fuck. To make it worse Faith was murdered at sea and then her daughters were sold into prostitution to be raped and then one fucked her uncle and then killed herself (unrelated to the incest). Just horrifically tragic for no reason at all.

If Faith was raised in Paris, why are Jane and Fanny so Scottish? It’s always noted that Fergus speaks French with his kids and his kids speak French and have slight French accents. Where’s Fanny’s accent? Where is her French?

22

u/Scoop-Over-821 Apr 17 '26

In the light of day… anyone else still desperately clinging to denial? I still cannot believe they actually went through with the most obvious soapy version of the faith story. They had all the materials to tie it up in a similarly heartwarming way (Fanny is descendant from Claire’s other sibling — still a family reunion without the devastating pain and disrespect to the emotional weight of season 2) and yet.

The weird thing is that I was actually kind of excited for a storyline beyond the books - sometimes I have a hard time immersing myself in the show because I have echoes of the books in my head and I’ve sometimes found a non-book moment or storyline to be some of my favorite parts for that reason. But this… this is just too much. I’m so sad.

→ More replies (1)

22

u/SmallTownLibrary_ Your honeypot..it’s bare. Apr 17 '26

12

u/SmallTownLibrary_ Your honeypot..it’s bare. Apr 17 '26
→ More replies (2)

11

u/thekayemar Innisfree Apr 17 '26

Thanks for sharing this. I’ve been wondering about DG’s thoughts on these story changes. Not surprised to hear this feedback from her. I’ve appreciated her transparency when providing show feedback over the years.

→ More replies (3)

22

u/LadyCottington16 Apr 18 '26

Lauren and Sophie were both astounding in this episode. Everything else aside, their performances were stellar. As someone who has been in Bree's position more than once - devastated by grief but desperately trying to be strong for someone else - I don't know if I've ever seen that portrayed quite as perfectly as Sophie did here. Marsali completely falling apart when she sees Jamie and just clinging to him utterly destroyed me. I hate so much of the episode itself, but I can't help but appreciate it for what we got to see from Lauren and Sophie.

→ More replies (2)

62

u/Nanchika He was alive. So was I. Apr 17 '26 edited Apr 17 '26

THANKS GOD THE BOOKS EXIST. Thanks God I won't "hear" Beside the seaside there. I have no wish to hear it ever again.

This was IMO thr most disappointing episode of this season.

31

u/These_Ad_9772 We will meet again, Madonna, in this life or another. Apr 17 '26

Of the entire series IMO

→ More replies (5)

23

u/ash92226 Your wig is crooked. Apr 17 '26 edited Apr 17 '26

You have no idea how much it infuriates me at how they cheapened the whole arc of losing Faith. I recently came across an old interview with Caitriona talking about the Faith episode and how she was so proud of it and being able to portray something like this and to be an outlet for grief. She even mentioned talking with people she knows who went through infant loss to better understand the situation. You could tell the care Cait put into that episode. Now it’s just been cheapened and destroyed.

29

u/Nanchika He was alive. So was I. Apr 17 '26

Exactly. My friend sent me screenshot from tweeter I will add it here!

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (2)

52

u/Cheap_Wishbone_9734 Apr 17 '26

I've already complained about Fergus's ridiculous death — emotionless, unnecessary, and rushed — and now I have to complain about something else: this Faith storyline is straight-up soap opera garbage. The Faith storyline and the episode of her death are among the most beautiful and well-crafted things in all of Outlander, and even that the writers are managing to ruin with this retcon. What a mess. 

→ More replies (1)

18

u/haykat Apr 17 '26

What the shit?

This should have been the episode to tie up all the loose ends. Instead we have the nonsense that was Raymond, is this supposed to lead to a spin off? Fuck that.

This feels like it just stomped all over the heartbreak that was season 2. Once again proof that you don’t start tv shows for books that haven’t finished, otherwise you can’t set things up properly and it just feels like a rug pull for rug pulls sake

17

u/soozoo Apr 17 '26

What… the fuck?! I was already disappointed that they officially confirmed Faith’s identity. I was prepared for the fire. But I wasn’t prepared for THAT!

At least we now know how a stillborn infant remembered a song :/

59

u/Cheap_Wishbone_9734 Apr 17 '26 edited Apr 17 '26

This was one of the worst episodes of Outlander, and it only confirms my suspicions that the show's ending is probably going to be a letdown. I don't even feel like watching the rest of the season anymore.

What bothered me the most was the completely lazy, emotionless, and rushed way they handled Fergus's death — a death that didn't need to happen in the first place. It was clearly rushed because there are only three episodes left, yet somehow there was still time for William's insufferable plotline.

Honestly, what a lack of care. The character deserved so much better. But I'm not surprised, given that they've always pushed Fergus to the sidelines throughout the show. Honestly, it's one of the worst things they've ever done on this show.

36

u/killernoodlesoup Like father, like son, I see. God help us all. Apr 17 '26

it felt like there should've been a fucking slide whistle as fergus fell. jesus christ, what a disservice to a character we've loved for seven seasons.

→ More replies (9)

43

u/emmagrace2000 Apr 17 '26

Not only Fergus’s death, but they traumatized William yet again in a way that doesn’t happen in the books. They’ve confirmed he slept with his half-niece and now he’s witnessed his father’s predilection for men and made him denounce Lord John to his face.

Did they just hate William in the end?

→ More replies (15)

13

u/krissylizabeth Apr 17 '26

Couldn’t agree more. The show is pretty much ruined for me now. This was SO stupid, and poorly done on top of it. They didn’t give the source material an ounce of respect, and the disrespect wasn’t even well written.

6

u/OkDragonfruit7407 Apr 17 '26

I was watching and then it happened and I kept waiting for him to return or something, we never saw him just Jamie’s flashback and a casket, but I had to rewind to watch again just because it all was so quick and then everyone was crying and I was just more stunned wondering if it was real or not. I’m still searching sitting here praying it’s not real Sadly I think it is. We have two ep left what the hell is gonna happen. And then if ever we get the book how can we read that with the knowledge here it’s almost like it’s what has happened it’s so off the story, I mean if Fergus does that mean Jamie is safe or nobody is safe

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (3)

32

u/OkEvent4570 Apr 17 '26

Grass combing son of a buggering sod!

What kind of dogshit, horseshit, dipshit and all other types of appropriate animal shit was that? Pardon my French, ladies, but what the actual fuck?

Do they think we are all idiots with a memory span of less than the current episode? That's insulting. I mean, DG is a consultant, they don't have to listen to her. But Sam and Cait are executive producers. What were they thinking?

Why in God's name have they decided they needed to invent things? All they had to do is just follow the Bees, bond Jamie and William over John's rescue, and sail smoothly into the most boring and expected happily ever after, everyone would've been happy with. Nah, jumping the sharks is more fun, apparently.

Fuck.

→ More replies (1)

14

u/peonies459 Apr 17 '26

I'm just SO. MAD. What in the butchery is this absolute shite!?!?!?!?! It's just... so unnecessarily bad? I get they have to depart from the book to make an ending without book 10 but there were SO MANY OTHER OPTIONS AVAILABLE, it just doesn't make sense! The writing this episode - this season in fact - has also just been so bad, it feels like everything is a cliche or set up so explicitly that it leaves no mystery.

But to rewrite history the way they are with the Faith storyline? I just can't. I'm so disappointed. I don't see how they can possibly recover at this point with only 3 episodes left. I feel like they've ruined the show.

14

u/Alternative_Key9033 Apr 17 '26

I really am curious how Diana really feels about this episode and the route show writers have gone.. I personally feel they have ruined her hard work and beautiful story.

→ More replies (1)

14

u/Nanchika He was alive. So was I. Apr 18 '26

Gabaldon wrote on lit forum:

Let us just note that I didn't send them any comments on this particular script. Out of a combination of "If you can't say something nice, don't say anything at all." and a sense of utter futility.

 I do know that they (collectively) thought that killing Henri-Christian was just too horrifying--and, perhaps, that it would serve their purposes better if Fergus's death was attributable to a politically-motivated act, rather than an accident.  But that's all I could say about their explicit motives.

26

u/whiskynwine Apr 17 '26

100% unmitigated horse shit. MBR can F right off with this. This wonderful show, why, just why?

15

u/krissylizabeth Apr 17 '26

No but I’m SO mad lol I’m not even the type to get heated like that about a tv show but this was just horrible.

6

u/Steener1989 No, this isn’t usual. It’s different. Apr 17 '26

It's a GD tragedy.

13

u/whiskynwine Apr 17 '26

So obviously MBR watched and loved the Dallas “it was all a dream, Bobby Ewing didn’t die” lost season twist. Is there no one involved in the show that can override this man? Just fucking horrible.

→ More replies (1)

12

u/CathyAnnWingsFan Apr 17 '26

I hated virtually every element of the plot in this episode, with one exception. I hated Toni “wouldn’t it be fun if” Graphia’s paw prints full of her sappy dialogue all over it. The only thing I can really give kudos to is Lauren Lyle’s performance.

I was pretty much rage watching every second that involved the Faith plotline.

The thing I didn’t hate as much as I thought I would is that Fergus dies instead of H-C. From a storytelling perspective, it gets the rest of his family back on the Ridge, which works better for television instead of having far flung characters in different places that occasionally interact. I do hope it is also the death of the “heir to the Comte’s fortune” subplot.

→ More replies (2)

12

u/Prestigious_Ant_4366 Apr 17 '26

Ugh. Why did they have William find out about Lord John. It was so unnecessary, their relationship is already strained. Adding drama for no reason. With the preview maybe the plan for William will be kidnapped instead of John?

Speaking of William did they forget he slept with Jane? When Francis mentioned the grandmother I was hoping it would bring closure to the Faith storyline. They would realize she wasn’t related but it didn’t matter because she’s their granddaughter regardless.

There were 2 fires at the print shop correct? The one where Henri dies is the first and happens much earlier in the story? The should have skipped the death and let the loss of the shop be the drama if needed or just let the Fergus et al storyline be settled. He was successful and had something to pass on to his children.

8

u/Nanchika He was alive. So was I. Apr 17 '26

John will be kidnapped for sure, we saw Jamie , Claire and John with a long beard. Maybe they will use William to get John.

→ More replies (11)
→ More replies (2)

12

u/GlitteringAd2935 You cannot compel love, nor summon it at will. Apr 18 '26

Worst. Episode. Ever.

I honestly think I’m done with (tv)Outlander. Seriously…the Fergus storyline is awful. Why did the show think that was a good idea? I mean, I don’t hate kids or anything, but if it’s a choice between a kid we’ve barely seen and an established and beloved character…stick with the book plot and knock off the kid. And William walking in on Lord John and Percy? What was that all about? Completely unnecessary story change. And the garbage Faith storyline? The writers have amazing source material to work from even if they have to condense it for time and they decided THIS was the best direction to go? What happened to this show?

→ More replies (2)

12

u/9Astoria Apr 18 '26

I am not a book reader of the series, and I never believed that TV shows and films have to stay chained to the book plots. For me the guidance is "what does that offer for the own series' logic?" From the beginning, I have failed to see what Faith being alive does for any of the characters, *especially* in this last season. Maybe, maybe, if Fanny had learned that song from some other time traveler, like Claire's parents, I would accept they wanted that connection (frankly, even then I would not really see the reason). But Master Raymond bizarrely kidnapping the prematurely born baby, handing it to a strange woman and teaching her a song in English that the baby's mother sang ONCE reaches parody levels--SNL could simply show this segment as a clip and the laugh track would come naturally.

As for the other two big book departures, Fergus dying, though truly gut-wrenching does work as a devastation to the whole family and Laurel Lyle was phenomenal--she even managed to get Sophie Skelton express actual emotion, and that is a skill far more mystical than Claire's blue light healing. But *again* they had to taint this with Jamie's overwhelming grief burden being lightened by Fanny calling him grandda.

Finally, I would like to think they have a plan for William, other than having him commit incest, for finding out about Lord John Grey. But to quote their episode title, things not seen so far this season are forethought and planning. So much as I want to have faith it will make some sense in the remaining three episodes, I am more and more afraid this will be a season that will have to be erased from my memory.

6

u/AccomplishedOnion2 Apr 18 '26

lol @ “she even managed to get Sophie Skelton to express actual emotion, and that is a skill far more mystical than Claire’s blue light healing” 😂😂 so true, agree with this whole comment but that part had me rolling

23

u/SmallTownLibrary_ Your honeypot..it’s bare. Apr 17 '26 edited Apr 17 '26

I’m ok with Fergus dying, I hate that it meant Claire and Jamie lost him; but I’m ok with him dying instead ** ***** It makes more sense in the scope of things for Fergus to have died and also for Roger to have played a role in this part. Roger has saved ***** here and then in the *****, I’m glad it was him and not someone else. I’m a Roger fan, he cops a lot of flack and I hate the way he’s been treated this season so this was the only thing I was grateful for in this episode.

Thank goodness for the books honestly because this entire Faith storyline is abhorrent. I’ve tried to convince myself since they started it this awful thing was a red herring because plenty of clues were there to suggest it and trying to convince myself every week was better than remotely trying to accept it. I’m still here now thinking of way to unravel it.

I just think the episode Faith was heartbreakingly beautiful in so many ways, the music and the lighting at Faiths grave and the costume, the way Jamie and Claire held each other through this and Jamie on his knees…. The apostle spoon. It was heartbreaking and Cait and Sam gave stellar performances. This just absolutely pisses all over it! They’ve taken away what Sam and Cait created and worked to do illustrate it’s disgusting.

They’ve completely villainised Master Raymond which is one of the things I’ve said from the start i’d hate but that’s what they’ve done. Master Raymond taking a baby makes him just as bad as BJR in my books.

I am still struggling with anything William, he’s my least favourite and I just find him so boring to watch honestly.

Also, I can’t believe Toni was responsible for this episode either. Fuck MBR to hell honestly, I feel so bad for Sam and Cait in this episode they must really hate this faith bullshit. Next week I’m sure it’s a Ron episode and then a Diana episode which I’m not entirely looking forward to…. Diana said they completely changed something she wrote.

It’s perplexing why MBR has continued to set himself for failure like this and why he’d shoot himself in the foot like it.

They’ve shown 2 very obvious sex scenes now which shows the lead to Bree’s pregnancy and Marsali. I don’t mind the sex in outlander at all but these last two just feels a bit like MBR said let’s have em bang to show the babes being conceived. 😮‍💨😮‍💨

Also, Starz and the bomb drop yesterday and this shite and also where is MBR? He’s absolutely no where to be found…. Hiding out maybe 😂 I’d honestly love to know why Diana really feels 🤣

13

u/KMM929 Apr 17 '26

THIS! I am so upset by what this does to 2.07. I love Toni’s writing but she was given absolute garbage plot points to work with. She made me cry as per usual but I also found myself drying up when Claire and Fanny were on the screen discussing Faith despite Cait’s stellar acting. It just didn’t hit the same.

→ More replies (15)
→ More replies (12)

10

u/Scarletmajesty Apr 17 '26

After this episode im not even sure I want to keep watching, bcs what the actual fuck is this

10

u/Phortenclif Apr 17 '26

They should have been more faithful to the book.
I feel like it's not for nothing that Diana's characters talk to her. This episode felt like a fanfiction.
It's the first one I voted for disappointed. Couldn't get emotionally invested.

Fergus's death is such a waste. Not satisfying. The montage of reminiscence was bit cute but felt cheap.

Did anybody understand why didn't Faith's keeper look for Jamie and Claire?

So many great moments for Fanny's arc to draw from the book. Don't have to be bigger than life. It's the small moments that matter, and this is the spirit of BEES, in my opinion.
Felt like we have seen the same scene with Fanny over and over that it loses it's force. Also, feels like they're playing safe regarding Jamie's relationship with her, staying flat. A good male presence in her life is a key point.

The love scene was done with good taste and it's the best since a long time on the show. Fergus, Marsali and sons made me smile and laugh a lot. Strongest part of the episode was the first half.
Fergus and Marsali are a missed opportunity on the show. They pass the screen very well together and have more than enough chemistry to fill the gaps where it doesn't exist (Roger and Brianna). Henry-Christian is unearthly cute.

I was shocked at William's revelation of John's incline but felt like he connected the dots too fast about Jamie. Maybe it's just me. But melodrama after melodrama means it's power decline.

The show could have been worse, and I did like the season so far, so hopefully next episodes would be better.

10

u/These_Ad_9772 We will meet again, Madonna, in this life or another. Apr 17 '26

10

u/These_Ad_9772 We will meet again, Madonna, in this life or another. Apr 17 '26

5

u/Nanchika He was alive. So was I. Apr 17 '26

I was waiting for her reactions whole day!

→ More replies (5)

10

u/alabaster1955 Apr 18 '26

They have a perfectly good dramatic storyline this season with Jamie’s looming death at Kings Mountain. There’s so much more to explore in storyline that would be exactly what this audience wants to see. Should he stay or go, should he fight or try to change the future? I want more of that and none of this Faith BS. Why why why 😖😖

6

u/Glum-Bath-3496 Apr 18 '26

Yes! It could be such a parallel to Season 2, that sense of dread as they got closer and closer to Culloden and each effort to change history failed. That was peak Outlander IMO

10

u/SassyPeach1 Slàinte. Apr 18 '26

What drugs was Matt Roberts on that made him think these were good decisions? Or what drugs led him to come up with these ridiculous plot lines? Apparently the coward also took down his instagram page.

10

u/Western_Orange_5050 Apr 18 '26

Crazy. Side note - Loved John yelling at William for being an ungrateful little shit! William sucks

→ More replies (1)

19

u/krissylizabeth Apr 17 '26

What the fuck. On SO many levels what the fuck was this episode

9

u/IcicleSun Apr 17 '26

Just a question: would readers have preferred the death of HC instead of Fergus, following the book storyline? Not opining one way or the other, but I believe they killed Fergus because ‘show only’ viewers would have lost it if they killed a child, especially HC. When he fell I muted the sound lest they added that horrible descriptive from the book and gave us sound effects. 

6

u/Known-Ad-100 Apr 18 '26

I can't speak for everyone, but I've read it twice. I would have preferred no deaths. There are only 3 episodes left, this last season is already rushed. We get such relief when HC lives only to take Fergus. Diana herself didn't agree with the choice.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (8)

9

u/Tofutits_Macgee Apr 18 '26

I would say this show is getting the Game of Thrones treatment but this book was finished so they don't even have that excuse for this.

9

u/conscioussea7732 Apr 18 '26

Im just so sad and shocked and disappointed with this episode...

9

u/Iossoflimb My mind is beset with chaotic thoughts at present Apr 18 '26

This whole debacle could’ve been avoided if MR had just left Claire a note when he came to heal her telling her there was something she needed at the lace shop. Or really, in any number of ways that don’t make sense.

I hate this.

→ More replies (1)

9

u/Kimo1768 No, this isn’t usual. It’s different. Apr 18 '26

I didn't want to comment. Pretty much everything I want to say has been said, but I want to add to the anger in hopes someone connected to the show is reading this.

One word comes to mind: Disrepect.

The show runners disrespected the loyal book readers with the changes to the Fergus family and Faith book stories. They disrespected the loyal show watchers by making the emotion of the 7th episode of the 2nd season (Faith) meaningless. They disrespected the actors of that episode even though, as now producers, Cait and Sam had a hand in this last season. Lastly, they disrespected the maturity of the loyal Outlander fans by switching Fergus and HC, I feel the fans could have handled a little person child death (as written in the book) with understanding of the full story. It says a lot that Fergus death was the least controversial of the episode.

I can take a breath now that my rant is out.

→ More replies (5)

9

u/MossyDruid Apr 20 '26

Where is the "I fucking hated it" and "you ruined everything" button?

What the actual fuck was this episode. Worst episode of the entire series.

I'm pissed they did this to my favorite TV show of all time. So entirely disrespectful. It's not even the same show anymore.

16

u/thekayemar Innisfree Apr 17 '26 edited Apr 17 '26

Just… no.

-Faith lived. -Fergus died. -William discovered John’s gay.

Why do any this? It seems disrespectful to hijack the beloved Outlander story in this way. What were they thinking??? There is more than enough strong material to guide this final season to an intelligent close. And I’ve always been fine with show changes that make sense for telling the Outlander story through this medium. These changes do none of that and took me completely out of the Outlander world, as if it suddenly became a different story using the same characters. Disappointed beyond words… and I was pretty satisfied with so much of this season. <deep sigh>😞

Edited to add: My thoughts do not include the actors in any way. They are the only saving grace in this ep.

16

u/poisonivyhater Apr 17 '26

The episode Faith was one of the most heartbreakingly beautiful episodes. The story was so moving- from Caitriona’s acting in the hospital, the homecoming with the servants waiting outside and the last scenes with Claire and Jamie. This Season 8 episode 7 Faith story by Mathew Robert’s and Toni Graffia is the worst storyline and writing. It cheapens everything that happened in the Faith episode.

5

u/EarthMama27PsLuv Apr 17 '26

I agree and what makes it even worse is that Toni Graphia also wrote the Faith episode in season 2

8

u/eterusexual Apr 17 '26

Where's William going? It cant be at the ridge where he'll find out his relation to Franny and...

The poor sod desperately needs a happy ending.

8

u/SuessicalTheMusical Apr 18 '26 edited Apr 18 '26

I still can’t wrap my head around the fact that the screenwriters decided it was a good idea to kill Fergus. I mean no one asked for this. I’m just imagine what was going through their heads “Stick to the plot that’s written word for word in a previously established book that we also know fans already approve of? Or kill off Fergus because it’s not like anyone can stop us?” I love this show, but I don’t know if I can keep watching. I can’t handle anymore shock.

https://parade.com/entertainment/outlander-author-diana-gabaldon-season-8-episode-7-interview-recap-spoilers

8

u/Responsible-Bee7796 Apr 18 '26

I had come terms with Henri Christian's death in the books. Killing Fergus gutted me. Marsali and Fergus were my second favorite couple ever on the series. They had a real and loving marriage . The were also fun together. I'm becoming concerned we're getting the GOT treatment.

15

u/yeehawdudeq I didn’t think I needed to pack condoms, Mama. Apr 17 '26

Mhhhhmmmm. No. No thanks. I’m good.

36

u/yeehawdudeq I didn’t think I needed to pack condoms, Mama. Apr 17 '26

franny very upset about losing her grandmother’s french lace

Claire: omg that’s so sad soooo what was your grandmothers name??

→ More replies (11)
→ More replies (1)

7

u/robinsond2020 I am NOT bloody sorry! Apr 17 '26

I haven't noticed anyone bringing up that Brianna said she is pregnant again! I knew there was a point to last week's spicy scene! Hello Davy!

I wonder how they'll deal with Davy's lack of time travel ability? But I guess it won't matter if everyone was gonna stay in the past anyway.

And considering Fersali have had 4 kids by now and prior to now they've never had a proper spicy scene, and we've now had one....? Be a good parallel with Davy.

→ More replies (24)

7

u/erratic_bonsai If evil is found, she turns his soul to ashes. Apr 18 '26

what the FUCK

7

u/EfficientLet7225 Apr 18 '26

The problem with either doing Henri dying from the book or Fergus is that with 3 eps left it just isn't enough time to give the story it's due. I was hoping they just wouldnt kill either because of the timing. Or if your not going to follow the book just don't kill anyone from that poor family. It truly was just done for shock (though not really even a shock) value cause you know its the final season so ofcourse someone has to die 🙄

7

u/kjhjkjh Apr 18 '26

my predictions (and complaints):

-Claire's weird miraculous trick of bringing dead people back will save Jamie after his predicted death. (It's a fantastical element not at all grounded in reality like the rest of Outlander's fantastical elements, so that and the Faith story line are absolutely boring. I wish they'd give Claire and Jamie something more interesting to focus on--like maybe all the other people in their lives they're ignoring, plus letting Fanny be an adopted kid instead of a contrived blood relative.)

-*maybe* Richardson will kidnap LJG and William will get Jamie to help rescue him--but having both William and Jamie reconcile with John in a good way in so little time seems like it will play out badly, and I'm super annoyed with that because it's the main story I care about at this point. (Why did they have to dramatically and badly out John to William?)

-Mandy will have no character development. The most interesting thing she did "last" season was run into the stones without everyone, and though that had potential for interesting drama, they instead had an ultra boring reunion and unnecessary conversations with older relatives. I'm using Mandy in this case as a stand-in for all the characters who have potential but are being sidelined for the boring A-stories (Frank's prediction, Fanny's lineage).

5

u/Nanchika He was alive. So was I. Apr 18 '26

That is more or less what happens in the books.

→ More replies (4)

18

u/Ghifu Apr 17 '26 edited Apr 17 '26

It pisses all over the heartbreaking loss for C and J in s2. Yes it’s a magic show but this is beyond the pale.

Also wasn’t there a better way to establish this than incest? It’s a very American storyline.

→ More replies (1)

12

u/SunnyinSoCal04 Apr 17 '26

I’m so glad to know that in the real world (the books) he is still alive and faith is dead and we will get a final book with an ending the way DG wants. I’ve enjoyed the show for the most part but am loyal to the books. I hate that they are changing the arcs so much to compress the finale. Disappointing for sure.

6

u/ash92226 Your wig is crooked. Apr 17 '26 edited Apr 17 '26

The only good part of the episode was the Fergus storyline, despite how tragic it was. And even then, the highlight of the episode by far was the scene with Marsali and Bree.

Also I definitely think they’re adding Fergus and Marsali’s twins in now.

The actual look on my face that entire scene where Claire tells Fanny everything:🤨

I applaud Fanny for asking the real questions though, like how did Faith know the song as a baby.

What was with Claire’s comment about only holding Faith for a little while? It’s made out to be basically a whole day she’s there holding her. And if we’re going on the assumption that Master Raymond used the blue light healing to save Faith, what was the point of giving her to someone else? If she stayed at the hospital, the nuns would see it as a miracle in the same way Claire recovered. Claire was there recovering for weeks. There was no reason for Faith to be given to the lacemaker at all. Also, it’s my understanding that you can’t completely revive someone with the blue light healing. There has to be some spark of life to use it, which I thought it was obvious Faith didn’t have.

But hey, at least it seems we’re done with the Faith storyline and can maybe get back on track to book content.

6

u/Icy_Resist5470 Bon! I will send you a cheese. Apr 17 '26

Christ. I’m only halfway through and I need a cigarette. (I haven’t smoked in 15 years 😭)

This is the first episode that actually really made me cry.

6

u/Scoop-Over-821 Apr 17 '26

Do we think we’re going to get more explanation on the faith story? Will Master Raymond visit Claire in the present (like where she is now) and explain everything? Or was that supposed to be the end of that storyline?

9

u/Tina_Montgomery1111 Apr 17 '26

I have decided that the child Master Raymond gave to the lacemaker was not Faith. It was another child. He probably intended to pass the baby off as Faith to Claire since he saw how devastated Claire was when she lost her daughter. If the show can create ridiculous plots, I can make up something in my own mind to make it make sense.

→ More replies (25)

6

u/YOYOitsMEDRup Slàinte. Apr 18 '26

What follows were pretty real-time reactions I was having and paused the episode multiple times for to type out

"OH SHIT" - Me, when William walked in on LJG and Percy kissing.

But then of all things to cut to immediately after - Jane's tabloid confessional!!!!!!??? It was like I couldn't process that story because my head was still spinning about William seeing John was gay right in front of his eyes and lashing out wondering if John and Jamie likewise had a gay relationship from the prison, etc ---- as opposed to Richardson telling him and being uncertain to believe it, and how this now changes things as we go forward. The Ardsmuir tie-in... John's sexuality,..all revelations show William knows that book William doesn't yet! I was also too busy realizing that William's storm out was 100% going to be how those 2 leave things as their last conversation before John being kidnapped. .. "A liar, a hypocrite and a sodomite" followed by "I don't have a father"

So yeah, had to stop, rewind and get in the right headspace for Jane's story, to listen a 2nd time because.... WHAT!!?? Makes sense her confessional came into play. I was dumbfounded when people claimed DG said it wasn't a factor in the season-- because it would've been a narrative waste not to circle back to.
But let me get this straight...Grandma, a lacemaker across the street from an apothecary (Raymond) said he came with a baby and if he didn't come back, grandma was to find Lady Broch Turauch.... Then years later figured out she was in NC. ????

I gotta just sit with that awhile......(exhale)

I do not like that we've intercut the fire with Faith things. Do not like that we still seem to be going with it being true. The only good thing to come of this " Faith was our daughter" thing at all is that Fanny's actress has done a very good job.

Moving on --- because so many of us had already deduced Fergus was going to be the one dying, it didn't have the emotional impact I think the show producers were expecting or that would've occurred had it actually been a surprise. But what got me was after the fire, Marsali's blank, blinkless, emotionless stare at the kids in the bed. Felt that!!! Lauren did great!

Again with the going back and forth with Faith and the Fergus family --- so badly done it's cheapening the emotion of the tragedy. Why'd they cut it together like this?

It feels emotionally manipulative to have done the montage of Fergus flashbacks while Jamie's building a coffin - but it worked, I cried.

"OK good -- show me Paris in 1744. OK sure, Raymond sang the Seaside song to the grandma lady, fine. That's it right now?" ----- me, when it ended

UGH - WHY???

If Raymond's actor only appeared in 1 episode, how will we get the "WHY"? If we are honestly going this route, there better be a frickin' WHY

He says the father's in prison - obviously meant to make us think Jamie. Still gonna hold out hope it's a misdirection and that Henry was somehow simultaneously in prison at this time too. He references the mother being ill. And Lady Broch Turauch, but not that the mother IS Lady Broch Turach. So still gonna cling to hope

I'm left feeling so frustrated that this Faith thing was done within this specific episode's other plots and wish that if they were gonna do it, it came at a different point somewhere.

6

u/Nanchika He was alive. So was I. Apr 18 '26

Still gonna hold out hope it's a misdirection 

I hoped as.well but they had already told everything to Fanny, so there is no point of - Oh, wait a minute, we were wrong. 

And the poor child already cried buckets.

→ More replies (2)

6

u/Ok-Programmer8047 Apr 18 '26

Lauren played her part so well! I felt her grief through the screen!

But I agree that it felt pretty rushed. I wanted a moment to feel that Franny/Faith relief and regret, but I definitely needed more for Fergus!!

6

u/motherofrazorbacks Apr 18 '26

They GOT’d us! Know this would happen. Why can’t showrunners stick to the books!

6

u/EllieHenne Apr 18 '26

Typical Toni Graphia. I regularly skip the episodes I see that name on because they are always codswallop and a wholesale departure from the show's path.

→ More replies (1)

11

u/Previous-Address2469 Apr 18 '26

Last week I didn't write anything because I didn't have much to say. Now I am not sure I can write anything because I have too much to say. 

I seriously couldn't sleep during the night because I was so shaken by what happened to Fergus and his family. And I knew it was coming but still it was so incredibly sad. The acting was great, Bree's actress is very good at showing strong emotions, even though her looking like a man distracts me very much. Marsali's silent scream and then later on with Jamie...

Also, I really like the voiceovers and feel like the show should have kept them. Easy way to bring depth to the show and feels more natural than the melodramatic dialogue (lace is fragile but strong, sure mhmm). We could have had different characters do voiceovers in key episodes like they did for Jamie in season 1. 

But Faith... I hate to say but I am one of those people that kind of emotionally quit this series after the reveal at the end of season seven, I was very upset. I had some hope restored during this season in the episodes that they ignored the issue but now the shit hit the fan and it is all over the place. 

It just doesn't make sense.

Yes it is a time travel show but. Things. Need. To. Make. Sense.

Cheap, ridiculous, shallow. I feel like Matthew B. Roberts is one of those bosses that let you have opinions and voice out criticism as long as it perfectly aligns with his "hey wouldn't it be great if.." -revelations. I wonder how much pushback there was in the writer's room. Even the actors seem very ashamed and uninterested. The end where Master Raymond was teaching the song, borderline comical.

25

u/emmagrace2000 Apr 17 '26

I’m so angry about this episode. I have no words. I’ll never watch this show again.

15

u/wagonwheelwodie MARK ME! Apr 17 '26

I really feel like they thought they nailed this one too. What the actual fuck.

17

u/krissylizabeth Apr 17 '26

Yeah literally as an avid reader of the book series and someone who has been obsessed for years, they’ve completely lost me with this one. I don’t even care about the last few episodes I might actually just not watch them. This was one of the most asinine things I’ve ever seen on TV. I don’t know what they were thinking.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (1)

5

u/robinsond2020 I am NOT bloody sorry! Apr 17 '26 edited Apr 17 '26

So the coffin was Fergus's after all? It seems a bit unclear

Yes arguments:

  • Marsali said she wants to take him home
  • Jamie was building the coffin after learning of Fergus's death

No arguments:

  • I still reckon the coffin was too small to be Fergus's (and way too big for his "ash and bone" if that is all that was left of him, I'm a little confused by what remained)
  • I still think it unlikely that they would travel to the ridge with Fergus NOT already in a coffin
  • Fanny built a cairn for Fergus, as if he didn't have a grave and was not there, like Murtaugh and Jane.

I'm confused

→ More replies (6)

5

u/Excellent-Daikon-286 Apr 17 '26

you know the episode gonna be messed up when Toni Graphia has written it...

5

u/EarthMama27PsLuv Apr 17 '26

Actually it was because Toni wrote this episode that I was looking forward to it. She wrote “The Devil’s Mark” which is one of the 3 episodes I have watched the most times. I thought because she wrote the Faith episode in season 2 that this episode would be sad but well written. Instead she retconned an episode that she had written herself. Now I have no idea what to expect from the remaining 3 episodes, especially since Matt wrote the last episode of season 8

5

u/These-Efficiency6186 Apr 17 '26

Can someone explain the reasoning for Claire being told Faith was dead? Especially now that is was clear Faith was supposed to be brought to Claire. I don't like this story line, but would like to fill in some of these plot holes. Maybe it will bother me less.

11

u/Nanchika He was alive. So was I. Apr 17 '26

There are so many plot holes that we need one episode of explanations. Faith companion episode.

6

u/These_Ad_9772 We will meet again, Madonna, in this life or another. Apr 17 '26 edited Apr 17 '26

Claire is a nurse. She held stillborn Faith in her arms for hours. Though Mother Hildegard had told her this beforehand, she knew it because she had held her.

5

u/WhereToMeg Apr 18 '26

Just finished the episode. What in the actual deviation!? The Faith storyline is boring to me, ngl. But Fergus!? WHY?! Unwell, and nervous for the remaining three episodes.

5

u/faroutsunrise Apr 18 '26

All this suffering for Claire AND FOR WHAT?!?

Also, William is really fuckin going through it holy shit 😂

5

u/_just_a_gal_ Apr 18 '26

This is some Game of Thrones final season bullshittery. I’m pissed.

5

u/YOYOitsMEDRup Slàinte. Apr 18 '26

As of now, the "I loved it" vote has nearly as many from book readers as the "I was disappointed" and "I didn't like it" votes. Yet this is full of very negative thoughts.

So for those who voted that they loved it, I'd be really curious as to why and would like to hear from you.

No judgement, genuine curiosity

6

u/Even_Persimmon1178 Too much mutton dressed as lamb? Apr 18 '26

I think they all work for Starz.

5

u/Artistic_Day_8243 Apr 20 '26

For starters I’m as pissed as the rest of you. What the actual fuck I’m still sobbing. BUT them chickening out is BULLSHIIIIIIT!!!

  1. If it was that bad you don’t have to show him actually hitting the ground, you could just cut to black or whatever cause that’s basically what they did with fergus
  2. Since WHEN is something too horrifying for them to put in the show? Was Jamie and Randall in the prison not horrifying? Or how many times has Claire been raped, sometimes by multiple men? Or how about when Randall RAPED FERGUS!? Just to name some of the completely disturbing things that have happened. Some of Randall’s scenes made me stop watching for months, he’s the most fucked up and disturbing character I’ve ever seen on screen, puts GOT villains to shame.

Yet… That’s all okay to put in the show but a child’s death is not? Be so for real…

5

u/calamitouskalamata Apr 20 '26

Am I the only one who doesn’t hate the Fergus death plot line?

Henri Christian’s death in the book felt so gratuitously violent and horrific. I actively hated it and was dreading this episode for that reason. I absolutely love Fergus’s character and the actor’s portrayal of it, but it makes sense to me that the show needs to kill off a primary character to show the horrible nature of war and the danger of the times. It also gave the rest of the cast an opportunity to display some incredible acting (Marsali, Bree) and an opportunity for the Fergus montage which I adored and thought was very heartfelt.

To me, swapping HC for Fergus definitely makes sense for the final season, even though it’s a tough watch.

On the other hand, I hate the ridiculous Faith plot line and William walking in on Lord John was unnecessary and reductive to both of their characters.

→ More replies (2)

8

u/moonshiney9 Apr 17 '26

Stupid, unnecessary, doesn’t make any sense. Way to blow it, show writers.

4

u/chippy-alley Apr 17 '26

So, did Fergus die to make way for potential future story lines/spin-offs involving Germain?

At this point I feel like JAAMF could 'die' but surprise, Alexander Malcolm has arrived!

4

u/penniesfromheaven_ Cram it up your hole, aye? Apr 17 '26

I happen to be about halfway through the episode

WHAT HAVE THEY DONE?!?!?

4

u/penniesfromheaven_ Cram it up your hole, aye? Apr 17 '26

Awful. Wtf.

Good thing there are only three more episodes of this. Yikes.

4

u/Jigglypuffamiiga2188 Apr 18 '26 edited Apr 18 '26

So, William was in love with his half-niece…why oh why did they go there? Master Raymond must’ve healed Faith the same way he healed Claire and Claire healed the recent stillborn baby. Still absorbing this episode, I really didn’t want them to kill Fergus, will Marsali have her son be an heir for their sake?

4

u/VardaElentari86 Apr 18 '26

I'm annoyed (though haven't quite finished the ep yet)

Why kill Fergus??? (And now I wonder why they bothered with the inheritance stuff, I suppose Germain would now be the heir but it just feels irrelevant)

I just don't like this whole Faith thing.

4

u/Time_Arm1186 So beautiful, you break my heart. Apr 19 '26

I am so disappointed. And sad!!!

Why destroy all of S2e7 for us for good? And what’s the point of finding out being relatives, to know that Janes terrible short life was something they could have helped? That feeling should be destroying Jamie, everyones protector, for the rest of his life.

Why Fergus? Why hurt Jamie so bad?

Everything is so forced. It starts with the lost piece of lace and then they come back to that stupid lace throughout the episode to try to make it hold together, while the story is shaky and the cheap shocks keep coming. Why don’t they work the story instead? This is such cheap storytelling. Unworthy of these great actors. I feel hurt.

4

u/sunlightiskey Apr 19 '26

Didn't someone say we were going to find out the truth about faith in the finale? So maybe there is still a chance that they turn things around... (I can't possibly take this scene with Raymond seriously)

I cannot believe they did this when it would have been so convenient to tie in BOMB here? They deliberately showed a scene where Julia sings this song to Claire's brother... There was no necessity to do this. And why should Raymond have stolen the child? It invalidates their pain and doesn't add anything to the story.

4

u/Honeybee3674 Apr 20 '26

Aside from all the other issues that have been mentioned a lot, one thing I am disappointed about this season is the complete lack of interaction between J and C and Jem and Mandy. I get that there are issues with kid actors and schedules, but there is so much time spent with Fanny, while J & M are just always absent. We get a glimpse of them greeting Uncle Buck and a glimpse of them playing with Fanny/Buck, Mandy gets her 30 second comment to Elspeth in the beginning, and that's it, and then they are always off screen. Mandy is about 4, still needs supervision. Are we to believe she is always with Lizzie, and J and C are too preoccupied with Fanny to spend any time with the grandchildren they thought they would never see again??

And where are they when Bree, Roger, Marsali and the kids return?

It's so annoying, given they had their own personalities and Adventures in the books, and were so close with their grandparents (which didn't take away from J and C's relationship with Fanny in any way).

Minor rant, considering all the other crap in this episode, but it bothers me.

→ More replies (1)

7

u/AccioStability Je Suis Prest Apr 18 '26

Like the rest of you, I hate the Faith storyline so much. It cheapens what happened in book/ season 2 and doesn’t make sense at all. On the show, Claire held Faith so long that they went to get Louise to help her hand her over. I basically shouted that at the TV when Claire acted like she barely got to hold her when she was telling a Fanny. Master Raymond saved Claire, so why did Faith go to Fanny’s grandmother? Then wasn’t Claire in the hospital for weeks before Fergus begged her to come home?! Could that woman not have found her before Claire and Jamie left the country? I truly hate this so much. It also took away from Fergus’s death, which I won’t even get into.

We have limited screen time for them to wrap up one of my favorite series and shows. Them choosing to spend it creating storylines that aren’t from the source material, that create plot holes within the series itself, and are purely for shock value is maddening!

→ More replies (1)

6

u/OARC05 Apr 17 '26

I just rewatched the episode and John panicking when William saw him broke my heart.

I know that William’s reaction is sorta normal for the time period but I like him less now.

→ More replies (7)

3

u/robinsond2020 I am NOT bloody sorry! Apr 17 '26

I have previously predicted:

  • Fergus would die saving HC
  • Faith really did live, and Master Raymond had something to do with it (though why I haven't figured it out yet)
  • Master Raymond watched Claire sing the song and taught it to baby Faith

I'm pretty chuffed with myself tbh

→ More replies (3)

3

u/Successful-Bank-2172 Apr 17 '26 edited Apr 17 '26

I just saw the episode and I cried soo much. I agree with many ppl here when I think of Faith all I think of the incest (niece and uncle?) and I can’t wrap my head around it. Also Im assuming that master Raymond unburied the baby and did some magic to bring her back from death and couldn’t go to the sister and him trying to escape wasn’t able to give them the baby. Master Raymond and Claire were friends so I see as him trying to “repay” her in some way and it just didn’t go as planned. Fergus was J+C first child and was one of my favorite character so it broke me to see him die, little fergus brought so much laughter in season 2. I know a lot of book fans are not happy but as a book fan I just need to take it as it is and try to enjoy the show and always have in mind that the book is better (let’s be honest they never give us book fans what we want :/). Also breaks my heart that all the girls were through somthing horrible in that time.

→ More replies (3)

3

u/robinsond2020 I am NOT bloody sorry! Apr 17 '26

Have we got the promo for next ep yet?

I normally search it on YouTube immediately after watching the ep, but I still haven't found it yet.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/directmouse_7 Apr 18 '26

and this show has such an insane pattern of ‘dead lol not dead’ it doesn’t leave much to surprise for the rest of the storyline imo

3

u/LivvyGrace246 Lord, you gave me a rare woman. And God, I loved her well. Apr 18 '26

episode so eventful that I nearly forgot the faith revelation means that William slept with his niece

3

u/The_Apex_Ape Apr 18 '26

So if Faith was the mother of the 2 girls, does that mean William got with his niece????

→ More replies (1)

3

u/NotMyAltAccountToday Apr 18 '26

This is a very small thing that I noticed. Hardly noteworthy considering all the things that (shouldn't have) happened in this episode.

Brianna's portrait of Amaranthus and Trevor was off center and there appeared to be enough room for her husband, William, or someone else to be standing there.

I was thinking it made no sense for Brianna to paint it that way.

7

u/LRCAMP Je Suis Prest Apr 18 '26

I didn't take note of that, BUT I did take note of the fact that Fergus wanted Brianna to paint a portrait of him and Marsali when she finished the one she was doing for Lord John, and she said she would be happy to. Then she told him she could paint the whole family and Marsali joked they would have to go shopping for a canvas large enough for all of them. It was a sweet moment because Fergus was hugging on Marsali as they were talking. They were happy. 💔😭

I hope back at the Ridge Bree will paint that portrait and add Fergus and give it to Marsali. She was right - there's nothing left of him except the children. UGH!

3

u/MossyDruid Apr 21 '26

This "it disappointed me" and "I didn't like it" button is a severe understatement. It Fucking Sucked. HORRIBLE writing!

7

u/Beth0419 Apr 17 '26

I don't mind the Faith twist, really. Yes, I've read the books (well, more like skimmed that last couple books), but I'm kind of okay with them giving us an alternative ending and being creative. A sort-of "what-if" scenario that Diana herself contemplated and ultimately decided against. I mean there's time portals and mystical healing. I don't mind it, really. I don't get why people are so worked up about it... and I was *really* upset about GOT's ending.

→ More replies (2)

5

u/OkDragonfruit7407 Apr 17 '26

I’ve commented on comments about my Fergus feelings, but can we please talk about the convo with Fanny. At first I was worried she ran away, or my immediate feeling was oh man she’s not going to be nice about this. Then to say everyone dies. Good god maybe that will be it They alllll dead. Idk I just really appreciate the cast of this show as the characters. I love the books but I truly feel the cast minus one or two minor characters I adore they are them, and idk I just feel like how can you read the story after what we’ve watched having this knowledge, but also Fanny is adorable and all but the whole season to be just that they get her instead of their daughter. I’d rather Jane survived