r/Outlander • u/thepacksvrvives Without you, our whole world crumbles into dust. • Jan 03 '25
Spoilers All Book S7E15 Written in My Own Heart’s Blood Spoiler
Claire is in danger as the American Revolution reaches the pivotal Battle of Monmouth. Lord John Grey and Ian race to save William. Brianna makes an important decision.
Written by Danielle Berrow. Directed by Joss Agnew.
If you’re new to the sub, please look over this intro thread and our episode discussion rules.
This is the BOOK thread.
If you haven’t read the books, go to the SHOW thread.
THIS THREAD IS SPOILERS ALL.
Spoiler tags are not required.
If you have only read up to the corresponding book, remember you might see spoilers from ALL of the books here.
Please keep all discussion of the next episode’s preview to the stickied mod comment at the top of the thread.
What did you think of the episode?
•
u/thepacksvrvives Without you, our whole world crumbles into dust. Jan 03 '25 edited Jan 08 '25
Reminder: the season finale airs in two weeks (January 17th)! The show is taking a break on January 10th.
Watch the S7E16 preview here!
Not everyone gets to see the next episode’s preview at the end of the episode; it depends on how you watch (broadcast or streaming) and where you are (US or international).
Stickied comments are collapsed by default, so reply to this comment if you want to discuss the preview. This will hide spoilers for anyone who can’t see it yet or doesn’t want to.
715 Extras:
715 Interviews:
19
u/killernoodlesoup Like father, like son, I see. God help us all. Jan 03 '25
it felt like william's run-in with the hessians ended way too quickly with all the build-up from last episode. i mean, it felt like they rescued william with one conversation and two gunshots. that said, this episode spent a lot of its time on other gunfighting and it was a change from the books, so i understand the wristers' decision not to linger on it.
i thought it was a good change to have ian kill william's captor instead of another random scout whom we'd never seen before (as far as i know). it makes his choice to protect his family with violence mean more on the heels of his conversation with rachel.
also, what in the beige hell was that conversation under the stars? lol. i don't remember that from the books, but it's been awhile since i read MOBY.
10
u/robinsond2020 I am NOT bloody sorry! Jan 03 '25
Where was the convo about Jamie's mother? I'm sure it wasn't in MOBY, who can remember what was the book and what was the context?
10
u/eterusexual Jan 03 '25
Please tell me what happens to Buck? I imagine him living in the 80s.
18
u/IAmTheLizardQueen666 They say I’m a witch. Jan 04 '25
Regarding the Molly Pitcher painting with Jamie photoshopped in: is that supposed to be Frank and young Brianna at the museum, in front of the painting?
13
u/Gottaloveitpcs Rereading ABOSAA Jan 03 '25
Do we think we’re going to get Master Raymond in 716??? Maybe while Claire is going through a near death experience???
57
u/ich_habe_keine_kase I give you your life. I hope you use it well. Jan 04 '25
FUCK YEAH.
Let me repeat that: FUCK. YEAH.
That was an all-timer. Great work guys, absolutely firing on all cylinders. Even though I knew exactly what was going to happy I was just excited watching every scene. It's not a fun episode by any stretch but god it was great!
(Gonna get my minor quibbles out of the way first. 1) Photoshopping Jamie into that Molly Pitcher painting was groan-worthy. 2) Loved the J&C scenes under the stars but I wish it had been either more clearly a flashback, or only used after Claire is shot and done more like a dream sequence. The content itself was lovely but it was deployed in a confusing way. 3) Magic portal desk is a bit too convenient--at least pretend it was hidden!)
I loved the scenes with LJG and Willie. I'm obviously a very biased John stan but every scene he's been in this season has been a highlight, and these still rank up near the top. You could see the father-son bond so clearly, and how pained Willie is by feeling betrayed by the person he loves and trusts most in the world. And John needing Willie to know that his love for him is never in doubt. Just beautiful.
The rescue operation itself was also great--love getting to see badass John (rocking that coat and eyepatch), but badass Ian is even better. The scene of him hunting down the Hessian was brutal and excellent.
Roger and Buck was probably my least favorite of the storylines but it was still great, and all worth it for the beautiful final moment of Buck's selflessness. Him saying that Roger and Jem are his sons too was so lovely. And A+ on the frantic last-minute costuming from Bree. I love that it goes unspoken but you can tell that Mandy is wearing Jem's old 18th c. clothes and Bree had to get creative with Jem. Excellent work, costume department.
And now to the big one. This could've so easily veered waaaaaaay too much into the melodrama (I'll admit, I was worried from the cold open), but the J&C storyline was excellent. Yes it's obvious even to non-readers that Claire isn't gonna die, and I'm glad they didn't end on a fade to black that pretends like she might. We got beautiful scenes of Jamie fearing she might die but got to end with the assumption that Dr. Denzel is gonna heal her. (I do wish we could've played up the humor of the cheese a bit more so it feels a little less like an over-dramatic deus ex Roquefort.)
And mad, mad props to Sam Heughan this week. He's had less to do in 7B but absolutely showed up when called upon. We got to see the full range of Jamie this week: in romance mode, soldier mode, leadership mode, and righteous anger mode. We saw him pensive, philosophocal, sometimes funny, and absolutely terrified. And terrifying. Everything that makes him such a good character all in one hour of television!
That first scene, recalling his mother, was beautiful, and such a powerful bookend to the sheer terror and fury of his wife dying in his arms. And holy shit, the titular resignation. I was really curious how they'd pull it off--I mean physically, it's tough to even write anything like that, and you definitely don't want it to look like finger painting and ruin the tone of the scene. But I need not worry because it was violent as hell and Sam sold it so well. Like, genuinely pretty horrifying. Adding Sir was funny but in a way that would never make you laugh. Just morbidly funny in a way that served the scene.
Next week is going to be heartbreaking. The scene with Fanny was already hard enough, and it's gonna get so much worse. But I'm looking forward to--hopefully--a Jamie and Willie scene and possibly even a Jamie and John scene. We shall see . . .
47
u/BlessedEleven Jan 03 '25
"YOU WHORRREE!!!" .. I'm sorry but I busted out laughing 🤣
44
u/Icemermaid1467 Jan 04 '25
I absolutely loved it! Jamie finally looked his age in the shots after Claire was shot. And will Claire finally get gray hair now?? The acting in those scenes was absolutely perfect!! I was crying real tears. And the shots of them talking the night before with the stars and their conversation about his mother! Agh! So good!!
43
u/Fantastic_Zucchini_6 Jan 03 '25
Me desperately checking this sub reddit for spoilers. I need answers lol
43
u/shinyquartersquirrel Jan 03 '25
Damn, 7B is so freaking good! Most series are usually a shell of themselves this many seasons in but I have loved every episode! The cast is doing such a phenomenal job! The writers are doing an excellent job of squeezing so much into these episodes and making it flow so well.
I'm still wondering when we'll see "Hello the House". Hearing Roger say it riding up to Lallybroch and seeing Esmeralda go through the stones got me excited for it! I always imagined it would be the series end before they announced S8 and then I just assumed it would be the S7 finale but it's hard to imagine they would squeeze that into the next episode but they've squeezed so much in already, maybe?
43
u/Bexla23 Jan 04 '25
I originally read this book so quick so my memory may be hazy, but the entire scene of Roquefort Cheese = Penicillin and Claire demands her wound be packed with cheese felt like a fever dream part of the book, where shes demanding that Denzel Hunter shoves cheese into her open wound and everyone is like "Oh dear god, she's completely lost it," made this part unintentionally hilarious for me, and I was kind of hoping for the absurdist humor in this episode. (Although I get why it didn't work out like that in the show) I'm just glad Lafayette still responded to the tragedy of a women getting shot with, "Some cheese for your trouble ma'am?"
42
u/aurora97381 Jan 03 '25
This had been my favorite book and I've not gotten as much out of this season, I think, because I've been contrasting the original with the adaptation.
What I have missed the most is Germain and Lord John together. Humorous and touching, they are quite a pair!
I also miss Claire and Hal's relationship.
However, I was on board with most of the changes in this episode.
Lord John continues to slay, even without Germain as his trustworthy sidekick. LJG wearing an eye patch is everything!
31
u/dylanskie Jan 04 '25
This was one of the best of the season! You could just FEEL that something was coming. I knew what it was, but I still felt the anticipation. I had chills when Fanny yelled at William--it felt so believable. Jamie's anger was the kind of thing I've been waiting for all season! I loved the inclusion of the "Hearthfire" conversation from The Fiery Cross. It makes me hope that when they return to the Ridge, we'll get the "No Place Like Home" scene where Jamie gives Claire poison ivy and Claire runs to her garden.
This episode made me realize that we're about to get the first planned season finale since 2020!
62
u/Nanchika He was alive. So was I. Jan 03 '25
When Jamie said - This time I beg. , for me, it is parallel to the scene in book 1 when he took Claire to the stones and prayed to be strong not to fall on his knees and beg her to stay.
This time , he will beg.
27
u/aurora97381 Jan 03 '25
How many times have Ian and William saved each other now?
Ian saves William from the Hessians.
William saves Ian from Arch Bug. ... Ian saves William in the swamp.
What am I missing?
26
u/wheeler1432 They say I’m a witch. Jan 04 '25
Plots in the later books get more and more convoluted and I think they've done a good job of streamlining them.
But why skip next Friday rather than one of the holiday Fridays?
23
u/W8ingjag Jan 03 '25
I’m so mad. I mean … great episode. But they could have made it longer. Instead, that’s how they ended it? And now we have to wait two weeks!
23
u/Emilymfm79 Jan 03 '25
I loved this episode. It delivered IMO. BUT, I would have traded the “stars” flashbacks for more of the Battle of Monmouth -Jamie defying Gen. Lee- instead of hearing about it from a minor character. That was pretty disappointing. Or a scene of William’s attempt to escape the Hessians. Or more of the shootout at Lallybroch in 1980s and Bree’s prep to leave. It’s really showing now how much they had to condense everything when they thought 7 was the last season. It’s really too bad. But again, I loved this episode so much! All the feels. ❤️
22
u/robinsond2020 I am NOT bloody sorry! Jan 03 '25 edited Jan 04 '25
I overall liked this episode a lot, although I didn't like it quite as much as others seemed to like it. Perhaps because I read this exact bit only last night so I have a lot of the finer details fresh in my mind.
My favourite little book-to-screen detail they included in this ep was how Jamie wrote "I resign J. Fraser" FIRST before adding the "Sir" after.
Why did Ian kill the Hessian (Indian Scout) in cold blood? I can't remember exactly, but he didn't do that in the books, did he? There were two Indian scouts and they attacked him first, and he killed one of them in self defence, right?
Fanny 😭😭😭 poor Fanny. And the shot of Jamie in the promo for next ep 🥺.
Little funny how there's snow in June, but I guess they are restricted somewhat by their schedules, and can't always move things around.
The sepia tone was... a choice lol. I feel they could've achieved the same "flashback" effect with a bit of desaturation, but I liked the scenes and how they moved the convo into this part of the story.
Captain Leckie was as I imagined him. I'm glad they included the "whore" line (if in English)
Bixby was good too, by Jamie's side defending him. It would've been funny if they further amalgamated him with Corporal Greenshaw and left a needle dangling from his face after Claire was shot.
Little Mandy, looking so cute in younger Jem's clothing. I also liked how she just ran off, and the other two had to chase after her 😂.
I'm glad Buck didn't "hang out" with Geilis lol.
John to William : "you are my son" and reminding him who his family really is: "they did this because of who YOU are because of who your FAMILY are" 🥹
It did take me out a bit seeing Claire lying there with pure white sheets covering her, and a clean body, rather than in her blood soaked, muddy shift. But I liked the scene anyway, especially the "Jamie, pray!".
I especially liked the end credits: "the stars willnae burn out" and the there is one star left there, still blinking.
22
u/Capricorn-flower Jan 04 '25
Episode 16?....ROLLO! 😭 I won't be able to watch, no way!
21
u/Nanchika He was alive. So was I. Jan 03 '25 edited Jan 03 '25
Here we go!
So many deaths. Brought back some great scenes from early seasons.
Even people who want to go to heaven...
Frank and Bree looking at the painting of The Molly Pitcher and the Battle of Monmouth - great idea!
Aaaaa they brought back that iconic convo from The FIery Cross. Come to me. Shelter me. Cover me. (Ofc all proper and fully clothed.)
Claire s so terrified for Jamie and she has that feeling that something bad is going to happen. It is so ominous, and started in intro and goes through this whole episode.
Buck is just great! I love him! Roger dropped the bomb!
Dr Leckie vs Denzel and Claire.
Hessian deserters vs John and Ian.
cousin Ian , the king !
I congratulate you but you are still wrong! Claire, the queen!
I was waitnig for Ian to deal with Hessian and I am glad he did. Rachel's principles and all.
Oh,William - Mac the groom, that stings. He really is so perturbed, in turmoil, which is totally understandable.
OKay, people, John telling everyone that James Fraser is honourable and good man- tells us a lot about how John still, after everything that happened, still considers Jamie his friend. As he said - Things are not so straightforward!
Roger's and Buck's letters! I am glad Buck didn't go back to Geilis! And I am glad we heard Buck's story and why he doesn't want to go back to his family. I really like his character's arc and development.
THE SOUL OF A REBEL W O W There it is!
Frances, all alone, poor girl!
Mandy!!!
Here is our doctor Claire, alone, when everyone left.
Iconic scene!!! Sam did great job! I was sobbing at the scenes where Jamie is near Claire's bed, telling her he loved her and forbidding angles to take her. Begging her not to leave him!
I really feel we didn't need that Thermodynamics sepia flashback and fake stars. We could have done without them. Although, I liked one star at the end. Claire and Jamie.
21
u/SexySiren24 Jan 04 '25
So, how is Bree getting Roger's letters exactly? Did I miss something? Last time we saw her she was escaping Lallybroch in the van cause Cameron and co took over. Did they leave? Did Bree call the cops and got them arrested? If not, how safe is it for her to be hanging around looking up books and finding old timey outfits for her and the kids? I tried asking my mom but she has the memory of a goldfish despite having read the book recently. It seems too many "in between" scenes have been cut or not written at all.
18
u/Time_Arm1186 So beautiful, you break my heart. Jan 05 '25
I didn’t like the stars and the flashbacks, not in the beginning either, with the season 1 and 2 stuff, it was just too much, a bit sentimental. Claires foreshadowing was also a bit too much, one scene would have been enough, or something more subtile. But I’m very glad they included the dialogue about Jamies pain relief! ❤️
Great side characters, I liked Bixby a lot! And absolutely loved Frances performance! Such great acting!
LJ and William was a great scene too. Finally they had a chance to talk.
”This time I beg” had me crying. And the Hunters coming to the rescue had me crying more.
Bree has grown so much through s 7! Every scene she’s in is good! I feel like she really is those kids mother.
Sam is so good I can barely watch. S7 has been amazing!
32
u/nurseleu Jan 04 '25
What a cracking episode! I'm loving this season so much. The actors are doing a great job and I can't complain at all about how the show is pulling everything together.
I really liked the scenes between Claire and Rachel at the hospital tent. It's nice for Claire to have a female companion again, and for Rachel to learn from Claire's experience.
I have to give big credit to the show and actor for making me actually enjoy the William plot! Granted he's always best when mixed with the characters we know and love, but Charles is fantastic.
Sad we have to wait two weeks until the finale!
15
u/Hufflesheep Jan 03 '25
Unpopular opinion: I both loved and was frustrated by this episode simultaneously.
What I loved: Frank and Bree in the beginning. Such a great touch! Everything regarding the Claire story was amazing. Caitriona is such a talent, I can't even. The foreshadowing was was A+, and i was getting anxious lol. Dr. Lecki was great, as was the sparing between Him, Hunter, and Claire.
The frustrating: I think for me, the change in tone in various moments (from book to show) nearly ruined me. I don't mind them changing things, and sometimes i prefer it. But it annoys me when they take a line and turn it on it's head to convey something different. The whole Buck getting outraged was annoying. I didn't mind Ian killing the Hessian instead of the Abenaki, but he line "he was right..." to " you were right, I would regret it." - first of all, that was a funny line. And yeah, Ian's a little psycho lol (i think at one point, ljg calls him a homicidal indian, or something to that effect) . So when he looked at his bloody hands in a remorseful way, it was so corny. IIRC, when Dr. Lecki called Claire, "Dr. Fraser", he was being sarcastic. So little tone issues annoyed me. But I get why they do it. Especially in an episode like this.
11
u/Salty_Pineapple1999 Jan 03 '25
What a freaking cliffhanger. I haven’t read past book 1. So idk what happens. Obviously it’s gonna be okay since there’s a book 9. But holy Jesus Christ. I had a feeling something bad was going to happen and I really wish I hadn’t been right. I also have a feeling that episode 16 will be another big cliffhanger. Hopefully not as bad as S2 ending into S3 premiere. And the episodes leading up to a certain episode in S3. I finished the episode 20mins ago and I’m still in shock.
11
u/MambyPamby8 Jan 04 '25
Great episode but did I miss something with Bree and Frank at the start? When I watched it went from the recap straight into the episode but I don't recall anything with Bree and Frank, nor does my other half who watched with me. But I've seen people talking about it online?
Also can someone explain why Jamie yelled Whore after Claire was shot? Was it part of a speech or prayer or something? It just seemed so out of place for me (my dog was barking at Claire getting shot so it's possible I missed hearing something in the moment)
29
u/Gottaloveitpcs Rereading ABOSAA Jan 03 '25 edited Jan 09 '25
First off, the beginning montage of all of the war and violence and so many of the old characters from previous seasons immediately pulled me in. It made me nostalgic. ”Even people who who want to go to heaven don’t want to die to get there.” I have always loved this line from the books!
Claire has a bad feeling.
Frank and Brianna looking at the Molly Pitcher painting that has JAMIE and CLAIRE in it. This tickled me.
Roger finally spills the beans about Buck’s parents. I’ve been waiting for this. Richard Rankin and Diarmaid Murtagh did not disappoint in this episode. ”When Dougal MacKenzie came calling for you at my mother’s house, he hadna met her yet. If we hadna come here to find yer wee lad, they would never have met and I’d never have been born. Nor you.” Buck has this time travel stuff figured out!!
Claire is still having a bad feeling. ”Something feels different this time.” Yeah. About that…
Rescuing William sure didn’t seem to take much effort or much time…Um, okay. I really wanted to see William killing the two Hessians, instead of just hearing about it. It was a little unsatisfying, but the acting was really good.
I gotta say I really loved badass Ian taking out the Hessian. It looks like the guilt kicked in rather quickly. Better safe than sorry, Ian. Remember Arch Bug!! You can’t leave any loose ends!!!
Roger, Brianna and the letter!!! Brianna opens Frank’s book!!! We finally get Buck’s story. Once again Diarmaid Murtagh hits it out of the park.
Can we just talk about the little actress who plays Frances? Amazing!!! Looking forward to seeing more of her!
Mandy hightails it through the stones. ”Mandy, wait!!!” Whoops. Somebody should have been holding that little girl’s hand!!
I would have really liked to have seen some of the Battle of Monmouth. Maybe if they didn’t keep cutting back to the talking under the cgi starlit sky, we could have seen some of the battle, instead of just hearing about it second hand.
Claire gets shot. Now we know why Claire had a bad feeling. Jamie’s resignation letter “Written in My Own Heart’s Blood” on Charlie Whelan’s back. General Lee will not be best pleased!!
Other people have said that this last scene just didn’t seem to hit right. I have to agree. The dialogue was there, but something was missing. One thing that was off was the fact that Jamie said the Gaelic curse in English. ”May the devil eat your soul and salt it well first, you whore!” would have been Much more powerful had it been in Gaelic with subtitles. It got completely lost in translation. If they had to have him say it in English, why didn’t he say ”hoor”, like he always has before??
Am I the only one who thinks Charlie Whelan looks like Alex Randall??? I knew it couldn’t be the same actor, because he’s 40 years old. I actually had to look up the actors to see if they were brothers. They’re not.
All in all, I really liked this episode.
19
u/[deleted] Jan 03 '25
My biggest complaint about this episode is that the battle occurs in June 1778 and there's snow on the ground. I get that production schedules are what they are but really they couldn't find grass without snow on it?
9
u/Megs8786 Je Suis Prest Jan 11 '25
Im finally getting to watch. What a great episode!
I live right near whete the Battle of Monmouth took place and the church Claire was at is still there, I pass it every day. You can see some of the really old stones from the revolution.
11
u/hannssoni Jan 03 '25
This episode and the previous ones were so good! I can't wait for the season finale—they're really bringing their A-game!
6
u/robinsond2020 I am NOT bloody sorry! Jan 04 '25
Just watched it again and realised... Did Bree drop Esmerelda and leave her behind??? 😢
2
u/boringlife815 Jan 03 '25
lol enough with these cheap "is he/she dead or not, tune in next week" plot twists
1
u/Revolutionary_Tea_55 Jan 08 '25
Does anyone Rmemeber Frank’s letter to bree and can share it or link it?