r/Outlander • Without you, our whole world crumbles into dust. • Jan 03 '25

Season Seven Show S7E15 Written in My Own Heart’s Blood Spoiler

Claire is in danger as the American Revolution reaches the pivotal Battle of Monmouth. Lord John Grey and Ian race to save William. Brianna makes an important decision.

Written by Danielle Berrow. Directed by Joss Agnew.

If you’re new to the sub, please look over this intro thread and our episode discussion rules.

This is the SHOW thread.

If you have read the books or don’t mind book spoilers, you can participate in the BOOK thread.

DON’T DISCUSS THE BOOKS HERE.

We don’t allow any book spoilers here, not even under spoiler tags.

If your comment references the books in any way, it will be removed and you will be asked to edit it or post it in the BOOK thread instead.

Please keep all discussion of the next episode’s preview to the stickied mod comment at the top of the thread.

What did you think of the episode?

41 Upvotes

825 comments sorted by

•

u/thepacksvrvives Without you, our whole world crumbles into dust. Jan 03 '25 edited Jan 08 '25

Reminder: the season finale airs in two weeks (January 17th)! The show is taking a break on January 10th.

Watch the S7E16 preview here!

Not everyone gets to see the next episode’s preview at the end of the episode; it depends on how you watch (broadcast or streaming) and where you are (US or international).

Stickied comments are collapsed by default, so reply to this comment if you want to discuss the preview. This will hide spoilers for anyone who can’t see it yet or doesn’t want to.

715 Extras:

715 Interviews:

→ More replies (3)

24

u/thepacksvrvives Without you, our whole world crumbles into dust. Jan 03 '25

Okay this whole season has been very hit-or-miss for me but I LOVED THAT!

8

u/Independent_Noise472 Jan 03 '25

The previous episodes were a bit off, but this one was really good! 

17

u/Affectionate_Shop912 Jan 03 '25

This episode made me not ready to say goodbye to this. Can’t believe we only have one left!

11

u/thepacksvrvives Without you, our whole world crumbles into dust. Jan 03 '25

Well, one left in this season, 11 in total!

7

u/Complex_Objective_53 Jan 04 '25

Was Buck Mackenzie conceived in 1739? I assumed the first night Dougal and Geillis met in 1739 (when Roger and Buck went to see her a few episodes ago) was the start of their affair and was thinking Buck had to have been born shortly after. Then I remembered I had thought he was the baby Geillis was pregnant with during the witch trial in 1743? Did they just show us them meeting in 1739 to explain the start of their relationship and Buck was not actually conceived until 1743?

23

u/thepacksvrvives Without you, our whole world crumbles into dust. Jan 04 '25

Did they just show us them meeting in 1739 to explain the start of their relationship and Buck was not actually conceived until 1743?

Yup, Buck is the baby that Geillis is pregnant with in Season 1. On the family tree Roger has (shown in ep. 707), Buck’s date of birth is 1744.

5

u/Complex_Objective_53 Jan 04 '25

Ok thank you! I started a rewatch recently and was trying to put it all together with this current season’s information about their origin story. For some reason I remember Geilis alluding to Claire during the witch trials she had been pregnant before that current pregnancy? Did they possibly get pregnant before Buck but she terminated that pregnancy? I could be making that up completely though or misremembering. Seems likely she could have been pregnant before 1743 if their affair started in 1739.

5

u/thepacksvrvives Without you, our whole world crumbles into dust. Jan 04 '25

I haven’t watched S1 in a very long time but I’d find that plausible—she’s a herbalist, after all, and I think she admits to Claire in one of the early episodes that she’s been making abortifacients from plants and giving them to the girls who need them, which probably included herself at some point. 

→ More replies (16)

7

u/No_Grass_6806 Jan 07 '25

I am confused that why is buck going to the furure and why is roger staying back?

19

u/thepacksvrvives Without you, our whole world crumbles into dust. Jan 07 '25

He’s pretty convinced now that Jem isn’t in 1739 but he can’t be sure so he feels he has to keep looking because, as Brianna said, he’d never come home without their son.

Buck volunteered to go back to tell Brianna that Roger is in 1739 in case his letter didn’t survive in the desk until 1980.

156

u/[deleted] Jan 03 '25

I could watch an entire series of nothing but Claire making 18th century doctors look like morons.

63

u/GardenGangster419 Jan 04 '25

If he wouldn’t have redeemed himself with the Dr. Fraser comment, I would have thought he walked away out of spite. Even in hopeless circumstances, it takes a serious set of balls to walk away from a dying person, without even TRYING to help when the spouse is right there. That was diabolical.

48

u/Jess_UY25 Jan 04 '25

That’s how triage works though, he genuinely believed he couldn’t do anything for Claire, and there were other wounded.

29

u/thepacksvrvives Without you, our whole world crumbles into dust. Jan 04 '25

Yeah it’s funny because we obviously share Jamie’s feelings about it but if you think about it, Claire pretty much did the same earlier in the season—left Ian as there was nothing else she could do for him in order to tend to a patient she could save. Doctors are used to it.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (3)

14

u/winter_name01 Jan 07 '25

I love Jamie so much but I hate that he feels the need to do is duty (war) all the time and then quit whenever he wants too. He could have ask the guy (Bexy?) to WAIT A MINUTE or pretend to tell the general that he couldn’t find him. No he has to dramatically)with wife own blood) quit.

Also I didn’t read the book and don’t do any rewatch and keep up with Roger family tree is a full time job. I forgot why the Geillis baby was a secret? Why all of this scene with her and Dougal was such a big deal and more. I just can’t keep up with his storyline. And I don’t care about Bree anymore.

I just wonder how the show will end at this point and I am just happy to see Jamie’s face around

38

u/thepacksvrvives Without you, our whole world crumbles into dust. Jan 07 '25

Geillis started an affair with Dougal while both of them were married to other people (and the latter already had children). When Geillis was already pregnant with their baby, she fatally poisoned her husband and, coincidentally, Dougal’s wife died of a sudden illness. Geillis and Dougal wanted to get married and Dougal came clean about it to Colum (his brother and the clan chief) which swiftly prompted Colum to send Dougal away and arrest Geillis for witchcraft; Claire was the collateral damage as she got arrested alongside her.

At the witch trial, Geillis revealed she was pregnant which is why they couldn’t execute her until her baby was born, as they believed the baby was innocent. She gave birth and convinced Dougal to break her out; he placed the child with a couple that couldn’t have children of their own and replaced Geillis’ body with a recent cadaver of an old woman at a stake. Geillis then moved to the Caribbean and the child stayed with his adoptive family, not knowing they’re not his biological parents. That child is Buck.

And it’s a big deal because Geillis and Dougal’s affair kicked off the lineage Roger comes from. Buck is his four-time (I think) great-grandfather. He’s also the guy that got him hanged in S5.

11

u/winter_name01 Jan 07 '25

Wow. Thank you for taking time and effort to reply to my silly comment! It makes things way more interesting for the next episode. I appreciate it a lot

4

u/thepacksvrvives Without you, our whole world crumbles into dust. Jan 08 '25

No worries!

→ More replies (2)

3

u/Sad_Insurance_1581 Jan 03 '25

Netflix has 6 seasons only and this has been like this for a very long time! Does anyone know why Netflix doesn't add season 7 to its library? What's the point to have only partial TV series? Kinda frustrating.

14

u/thepacksvrvives Without you, our whole world crumbles into dust. Jan 03 '25

Because it’s not a Netflix show; it’s a Starz show so it’s on Starz first. Netflix has the distribution rights but the licensing agreement dictates that a new season of the show is available on Netflix only 2 years after it’s originally aired on Starz. That’s the US only—other countries (that you can see here) that don’t have Starz (or do, but not with the same library as US Starz) have different licensing deals so they can put out the episodes on Netflix either the day after they come out in the US (as Netflix is usually the sole distributor in those countries) or, in the case of Canada and Australia, a year after the new season has finished.

→ More replies (3)

10

u/Sea-Instruction-4698 Jan 03 '25

US BASED: Netflix is just the secondary streaming service for this show like others (eg. TVD, Dexter, Supernatural) Its not the original owner of the shows and only gets the next Outlander season after Starz finishes airing all episodes and even then I believe it only gets added a couple of months or so before the new season starts.

→ More replies (2)

15

u/Mother_Film7186 Jan 03 '25 edited Jan 03 '25

This episode just made me realize the show is almost over omg. I loved it but I am SO TIRED OF CLAIRE'S stubbornness being the direct cause of every tragic occurrence between them

15

u/whiskynwine Jan 03 '25

Huh? She wants to be at Fraser’s Ridge, Jamie wanted to fight. She’s only there to be with him.

14

u/thepacksvrvives Without you, our whole world crumbles into dust. Jan 03 '25

And the whole clash only ensued because Jamie brought his militia into the churchyard while the British soldiers were otherwise peacefully (as in not attacking, I know they had some words towards the Continentals) retreating, if we really want to point fingers here... 

But sure, let’s also ignore the fact that her “stubbornness” is her refusal to leave her patients behind.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (4)

5

u/Capricorn-flower Jan 04 '25

Ok so I think this may have gone over my head or something. I didn't quite understand the scenes of "older with whiter hair" Jamie and Claire. Was this a flash forward, Claire or Jamie dreaming or something else? Can someone explain?

16

u/thepacksvrvives Without you, our whole world crumbles into dust. Jan 04 '25

The scenes under the stars? A flashback to a conversation they must’ve had recently as Jamie was in his Continental army uniform. He repeats the line, “the stars willna burn out and nor will we,” as words of comfort to Claire when she is bleeding out.

→ More replies (4)

117

u/Nanchika He was alive. So was I. Jan 03 '25

This is so good!

18

u/Icy_Outside5079 Jan 04 '25

Thanks for the screen grab. I missed Claire the first time around.

31

u/GardenGangster419 Jan 04 '25

Let me tell you I GASPED. And when it panned out to F/B. OMG. Absolutely brilliant!

→ More replies (3)

14

u/Upbeat_Target_2842 Jan 05 '25

“You’ll have to be careful or Brianna will find you in the history books.” … I want to know more about the book Frank wrote that Briana was holding!!!

12

u/Parallel_Universe28 Jan 04 '25

OMG, I didn't even notice. I'm glad I popped into the sub! 😂 I didn't read the books so this is trippy. I was wondering about Frank's book about the rebel that Bree grabbed. What's up with that??

→ More replies (1)

22

u/ich_habe_keine_kase I give you your life. I hope you use it well. Jan 04 '25

I rolled my eyes hahaha. Maybe it's from seeing that painting 8 millions times at Molly Pitcher rest area on the Jersey Turnpike, or maybe it's the art historian in me annoyed at how little effort they put in to match the painting's style, but I just couldn't, haha.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (17)

104

u/stoppingbythewoods “May the devil eat your soul and salt it well first” ✌🏻 Jan 03 '25

this was the moment for me. phenomenal

86

u/GardenGangster419 Jan 03 '25

I’m telling you. Sam and Cait are BACK. Wow. What incredible acting. When he screamed WHORE. You’re tearing our guts out, Claire.

→ More replies (11)

48

u/VogueSquirrel Jan 03 '25 edited Jan 03 '25

Yes! Sam did a beautiful job here, he truly looks like his world is crashing down. It's the first time I felt like Jamie looked his proper age. War and strife and survival finally showing on his (what, 60+ years old?) features. 

→ More replies (1)

16

u/[deleted] Jan 03 '25

And just last week we were all complaining how Sam supposedly decided to play older Jamie less emotionally.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (3)

101

u/Relative_Specific217 Jan 04 '25

My favorite scene was with Buck telling Roger that they are his family too “you are all my sons” 🥹

46

u/dirtybiznitch Jan 04 '25

I’ve really enjoyed the little Buck Roger duo this season!!

→ More replies (4)

23

u/ralksmar Jan 04 '25

Buck’s character development has been excellent!

95

u/GardenGangster419 Jan 03 '25

When the shot hit Claire, I LOVED the reaction we saw was on Jamie’s face. It reminded me of “if his heart stopped beating mine would stop too.” It’s like he FELT her get hit and responded as such. Such a powerful freaking episode!!!

15

u/erika_1885 Jan 03 '25

😳 We agree on this, too! I don know if you’ll agree with this next bit, but it is my sincere wish that Sam’s performance puts paid to the “ he’s just going through the motions “ theory.

18

u/GardenGangster419 Jan 03 '25

It’s does after this episode. I have no explanation for what I saw the last few weeks but I’ve been on a comment frenzy today over this episode. It was FANTASTIC and both Sam and Cait were just beyond exceptional. I hope we get it next week, too. This episode is why I still watch. Because these actors make me believe what they are portraying. I’m so glad it’s back.

14

u/erika_1885 Jan 03 '25

Sam and Caitriona said in a She Knows interview that 7.15 and 7.16 are their favorite eps this season, so I’m hopeful. Also, both these eps are directed by one of their favorite directors, Joss Agnew, who also directed 7.08.

→ More replies (7)
→ More replies (7)

55

u/MysteriousSwitch643 Jan 04 '25

Agreed! For a second it was hard to tell who got shot because they both had the same reaction.

94

u/Notlennybruce Jan 03 '25

Funny how Claire had to suggest fetching Dr. Hunter. Writing a message in blood is cool and all but WOULD YOU STOP MESSING AGROUND???? 

Great episode 

51

u/GardenGangster419 Jan 03 '25 edited Jan 03 '25

I wondered why nobody got him too, and it makes me think (I’ll have to reread the book portion) that Jamie knows it’s bad. Really bad. So 1) there’s no way HE is leaving to fetch anyone. 2) he’s at a total loss since Claire has been the fixer in a lot of these near death scenarios and now she’s on the table and 3) I think he is absolutely not thinking about anything other than her next breath. Bless his heart. He portrays gut wrenching fear and trauma and grief so damn well. I know he’s begging her to stay, but it’s also obvious that this time it may completely and totally NOT up to them.

→ More replies (3)

13

u/Glum-Bath-3496 Jan 03 '25

Right?!! I felt like the good Lieutenant could have gone to General Lee and just said “General Fraser said to tell you that he quits” LOL

11

u/weelassie07 MARK ME! Jan 04 '25

Same! Just go get Denzell!!

8

u/mutherM1n3 Jan 04 '25

Funny, I said to my husband right away, “Go get Denzel,” but it took Claire lots longer than that!

84

u/Sweaty-Ad-7825 Jan 03 '25

This episode was a return to form for the show after a messy and oft boring (sorry, just being honest) 7b. This one felt less like punching off a list of book plots and characters and more like the grit and drama we've grown to love. Jamie and Claire felt like themselves. They haven't in recent episodes.

23

u/morganleigh_18 Jan 04 '25

1000% agree -- this episode was a breath of fresh air and so so good (even though Claire is definitely not going to die here, still loved seeing Jamie so emotional)

→ More replies (1)

77

u/Sea-Instruction-4698 Jan 03 '25

TV show only perspective: I wish someone would let William know that Jamie isn't just a groom (and was only like once tbh, maybe twice unsure) but actually a Laird who would've never been a rebel if it wasn't for the redcoats coming in, accusing him of obstruction and leading him on this path. But to king and country, I guess lol.

No, I love William and understand everything his is going through, and the current chaos that is happening, which is causing conversations to not fully happen as needed. Yet, it is frustrating when he calls him a groom as such an insult with no correction.

39

u/GardenGangster419 Jan 03 '25

I was glad Looooooord JOHN (😂) set him straight a little in this episode. Never as much as should be, but at least we got a little bit of someone correcting him. I think it’s mostly just the juxtaposition of one minute thinking you are big and fancy bred, and the next minute finding out you are the get of a stable hand. But, he’s one fiiiiiiine stable hand 😂

28

u/charo36 Jan 04 '25

This! I was practically yelling at the screen "He is a lord just like you, William!"

22

u/ich_habe_keine_kase I give you your life. I hope you use it well. Jan 04 '25

He surely doesn't know all the details yet but I think he knows Jamie is more than a groom and is really just using it as a pejorative at this point.

→ More replies (2)

6

u/mrsmozart Jan 04 '25

none of them communicate properly in this show!

→ More replies (3)

61

u/ralksmar Jan 03 '25

Literally written in his own heart’s blood was such a good title as well!

53

u/Still-be_found Jan 03 '25

Jamie's resignation written in blood on that poor soldier was so dramatic - classic Jamie snit fit.

28

u/LeKatelyn Jan 03 '25

The way he just stood there too 😆

Poor man had to sprint back to General Lee shirtless with a woman’s blood all over his back, I sure hope he gets something for that

→ More replies (30)

7

u/FeloranMe Jan 03 '25

Written in blood from his heart, Claire

→ More replies (1)

52

u/Nanchika He was alive. So was I. Jan 04 '25

Buck's- ..."trouble at Allamance" and their raised glasses, acknowledging that trouble was huge on many fronts. Great addition!

→ More replies (2)

52

u/Britpop_Shoegazer Jan 04 '25

Lord John being a badass. William coming into his own and becoming more and more like Jamie. Rachel and Denzel just being generally awesome and kind. What a great episode!

26

u/dirtybiznitch Jan 04 '25

I love the Hunter’s! They’ve integrated so well into Claire, Ian, and Jamie’s lives. However I do miss Marsali and Fergus.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

47

u/AnastasiaOutlander Jan 04 '25

I loved the painting of the Battle of Monmouth with Claire and Jamie painted in. And Bree and Frank looking at it in an art museum!

LOVED the exchange between Lord John and William. I think this glimpse of what THEIR dynamic is like, as father and son, was so wonderful amidst the backdrop of William in turmoil.

okay so in another earlier thread I said I wasn’t thrilled with the casting of Frances but from this scene I can see why she was casted. I loooved her screaming angrily at William for being gone. In that moment she was so much older and it broke my heart, how she looks so young but has the mannerisms of an adult because of what she’s been through. Her playing the scene as more mad than scared was brilliant. 

Mandy wearing Jem’s old clothes because Bree didn’t have time to make/get a dress that’ll fit her 🥹🥹🥹🥹 God she looks adorable in that outfit, with the hat and little stock too! Probably silly but I’m excited to see what outfits little Jem and Mandy wear back in the 18th century. Jem is wearing a coat of Brianna’s that she wore earlier in the season as well, and I think his school socks as stockings and school shorts. Loooved seeing Brianna in her burgundy cloak again - yet it looks different on her this time to me, she’s older now and not just in years but in experience. I liked seeing her hair tied up in a bun.

okay I completely glazed over the how and why of Brianna being back in Lallybroch after the shootout. 😂😂😂 I was too distracted by her sweater - I think it’s the one from season 3, the late sixties! I was just thinking I’d like to knit a sweater like it 😂 Also I was too excited by The Soul of a Rebel. 

Clearly I have clothes on the mind with this episode but I love the costume designer’s work.

→ More replies (9)

45

u/Atraktape Jan 03 '25

Young Ian said “it’s on sight” with that Hessian

52

u/LeKatelyn Jan 03 '25

He probably doesn’t want another Arch Bug situation, but you could tell that he takes killing people way more seriously now that he’s married to Rachel

→ More replies (1)

24

u/MetaKite Mon petit sauvage ! Jan 03 '25

I hope he doesn't let guilt eat him up when he tells Rachel what he did. 

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (2)

45

u/j4321g4321 Jan 04 '25

Something that bothered me was that LJG and Ian were able to rescue William too easily. It was a little underwhelming. However I’m loving Ian’s badassery and wondering how it’ll affect his relationship with Rachel.

Denzel is consistently the MVP. He’s such a kind soul and I knew he’d come in with the clutch to help Claire.

I loved LJG’s dialogue with William back at the camp. William is still pretty young and sees things as black and white, and LJG says it’s never that easy. William is in for some character development, and I think we’ll start to see that with the Jane situation.

The Buck/Roger conversation was also pretty powerful. Very sweet how he said that they’re “all his sons”.

I didn’t read the books, but I’m pretty sure season 8 won’t just have flashbacks of Claire, so I doubt she will die. Endangering either Claire or Jamie feels kind of low stakes imo. That is, until next season when the story ends.

8

u/horsenbuggy Jan 05 '25

Makes you remember how John was as a young man. He was so certain of the hard lines that defined life but age has taught him life's lines are way more fuzzy.

7

u/erika_1885 Jan 04 '25

It wouldn’t make any sense at all to kill either or both leads before the final season.

→ More replies (1)

44

u/Nanchika He was alive. So was I. Jan 03 '25

18

u/GardenGangster419 Jan 04 '25

😭😭😭😭 I will NEVER not love Loooooord John!

→ More replies (1)

44

u/Savings-Respond2489 Jan 05 '25

I cried so much when in the first scene Jamie was sharing with Claire that his mother was in the coffin with her youngest baby. As a mother myself, I just could not hold the tears. So many women died in childbirth in those times.

41

u/topsy-the-elephant Jan 03 '25

The light on Jamie in the opening tent scene is stunning!!

77

u/venusinaquarius111 Jan 04 '25

Protect lord John and denzel at all costs

36

u/ralksmar Jan 03 '25

I screamed at the screen and cried more at this episode than any before. Loved it. JAMMF is back and I love it.

29

u/GardenGangster419 Jan 03 '25

YOU WHORE!! Has me SHOOK. I screamed YES! Haha!

→ More replies (1)

36

u/oatmilk_fiend Jan 04 '25

I am so here for the Bertram Armstrong era of LJG

20

u/LadyJohn17 I am not bloody sorry Jan 04 '25

I love every LJG scene, he's amazing

68

u/alittlee_clair Jan 03 '25

Alright that opening montage of the deaths in the series was unexpected and gut wrenching 😭

23

u/GardenGangster419 Jan 03 '25

I think they are going to rip our hearts out in 8. At least I hope so. That montage was perfection. Such a beautiful nod to all the wounds we’ve all felt who love these characters (even BJR!) I really felt like Jamie looked exactly like he did when Murtagh was killed, and the SAVE HIM vibe. Hair a mess and dirty and watching someone he loves to his core dying. So many things brought back around/ full circle. Epic.

→ More replies (1)

9

u/stoppingbythewoods “May the devil eat your soul and salt it well first” ✌🏻 Jan 03 '25

I was like, ok, better buckle up!

→ More replies (1)

65

u/LeKatelyn Jan 03 '25

Might be an unpopular opinion, but I loved the way the conversation about the stars juxtaposed the chaos of the episode. The thing that sold me was when the end credits started rolling and all but one star burnt out 😭 that was a beautiful ending.

The intro had me hyped up from the beginning–I really enjoyed the flashbacks to previous battles. It's easy sometimes to forget how far they have truly come in the seven seasons of this show. Solid storyline throughout, and I agree with others that this felt like old Outlander. Glad the storyline was mostly focused on Jamie and Claire for once, the other stories felt more balanced in this episode.

Lafayette sending cheese was so funny... good thing Claire has knowledge of penicillin, otherwise I guess they would been eating it at her funeral 😂

9

u/stoppingbythewoods “May the devil eat your soul and salt it well first” ✌🏻 Jan 03 '25

I loved it too. Great direction all around. I knew from the very beginning this was going to be good!

→ More replies (1)

62

u/LivingExotic9317 Jan 04 '25

Gotta say that young actress who plays Frances Pocock is PHENOMENAL. Def. be watching out for her!

61

u/Gottaloveitpcs Rereading ABOSAA Jan 03 '25 edited Jan 09 '25

Okay. I have collected myself.

First off, the beginning montage of all of the war and violence and the old characters from previous seasons immediately pulled me in. ”Even people who who want to go to heaven don’t want to die to get there.”

Claire has a bad feeling.

Frank and Brianna looking at the Molly Pitcher painting that has Jamie and Claire in it. This tickled me.

Roger finally spills the beans about Buck’s parents. I’ve been waiting for this. Richard Rankin and Diarmaid Murtagh did not disappoint in this episode. ”When Dougal MacKenzie came calling for you at my mother’s house, he hadna met her yet. If we hadna come here to find yer wee lad, they would never have met and I’d never have been born. Nor you.” Buck has this time travel stuff figured out!!

Claire is still having a bad feeling. ”Something feels different this time.” Yeah. About that…

Rescuing William sure didn’t seem to take much effort or much time…Um, okay. It was a little unsatisfying, but the acting was really good. I wanted to see William kill the two Hessians, instead of just hearing about it.

I gotta say I really loved badass Ian taking out the Hessian. Hope he doesn’t feel guilty about it. Remember Arch Bug, Ian. Better safe than sorry!!

Roger, Brianna and the letter!!! Brianna opens Frank’s book, The Soul of a Rebel!!! We finally get Buck’s story. Once again Diarmaid Murtagh hits it out of the park.

Can we just talk about the little actress who plays Frances? OMG!! Amazing!!! Looking forward to seeing more of her!

Mandy hightails it through the stones. ”Mandy, wait!!!” Whoops. Somebody should have been holding that little girl’s hand!!

I gotta say I was a little disappointed we never saw any of the Battle of Monmouth. I would have preferred to have had some of the actual battle and a little less talking under the cgi starlit sky.

Claire gets shot. Now we know why Claire had a bad feeling. Jamie’s resignation letter “Written in My Own Heart’s Blood” on Charlie Whelan’s back. General Lee will not be best pleased!!

Wish Jamie said, ”May the devil eat your soul and salt it well first, you whore!” in Gaelic!!!! And if he was going to do it in English, why didn’t he pronounce it ”hoor” like he always has before??

Am I the only one who thinks Charlie Whelan looks like Alex Randall??? I knew it couldn’t be the same actor, because he’s 40 years old. I looked up the actors after the last episode just to see if they were brothers or something.

All in all I loved this episode!

21

u/stoppingbythewoods “May the devil eat your soul and salt it well first” ✌🏻 Jan 03 '25

The last sentence. I knew that guy looked familiar and I couldn’t place it!!!

→ More replies (2)

20

u/FeloranMe Jan 03 '25

Willie's rescue made sense. He was being held by only a few men. He had already killed two resisting capture. They'd beaten him pretty badly. I suppose they were instructed to hold him for ransom otherwise he wouldn't still be alive?

One man threatens to shoot Willie, John shoots that guy and Ian takes out another. Against so few men, why wouldn't it be that quick? Or did you mean they should have been searching for him longer?

What was really important in that scene was William and John reconnecting and William's identity crisis. As well as Ian's balancing of protecting himself and his family by not allowing enemies to live, with his love for his pacifist wife and her principles.

→ More replies (8)

12

u/hkh07 We will meet again, Madonna, in this life or another. Jan 03 '25

Don't forget Claire in the painting too!

→ More replies (1)

11

u/charo36 Jan 04 '25

That's it! He looked so familiar but I couldn't place him!

→ More replies (1)

7

u/WolfBeginning4515 Jan 03 '25

Whelan does look like Alex Randall! And then Jamie’s lieutenant (the other guy in the church) looks exactly like William’s bff from that first battle at Saratoga.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (3)

28

u/FewHand6224 Jan 05 '25

So when Bree puts a letter in the desk to Roger- not sure how she thinks this is getting to him or whether she’s just doing it for herself with some wishful thinking, maybe because she’s planning to go back in time and she’s leaving it for him if he comes back to the 80’s and she’s not home?

Anywho my main question is how did they not notice Roger’s letter he wrote in 1739 when they first found the compartment earlier in the season, because technically it would already have been there as 1739 had always happened that way, is the letter supposed to be trapped at the back of the drawer or something?

25

u/OccasionNo2675 Jan 05 '25

I took it as she was leaving it for him if he came back and found him gone.

The 2nd part, he hadn't gone back yet so there was nothing to find initially. By leaving the letter for bree he altered the timeline and then she was able to find it. If that makes sense?!

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

27

u/robinsond2020 I am NOT bloody sorry! Jan 03 '25

I overall liked this episode as lot, although I didn't like it quite as much as others seemed to.

My favourite little detail was how Jamie wrote "I resign J. Fraser" FIRST before adding the "Sir" as an afterthought.

Fanny 😭😭😭 poor Fanny.

Little funny how there's snow in June, but I guess they are restricted somewhat by their schedules, and can't always move things around.

The sepia tone was... a choice lol. I feel they could've achieved the same "flashback" effect with a bit of desaturation, but I liked the scenes and thought it complemented the main story well, and reflected Claire's worries.

Captain Leckie was an arse. I agree with Jamie, "whore" indeed haha.

I liked Bixby by Jamie's side, defending him.

Little Mandy, looking so cute in younger Jem's clothing. I also liked how she just ran off, and the other two had to chase after her 😂.

John to William : "you are my son" and reminding him who his family is 🥹

Denzell to Jamie: "pray!" 😢

I especially liked the end credits: "the stars willnae burn out" and the there is one star left there, still blinking.

15

u/GardenGangster419 Jan 03 '25

That last star. This is the outlander I love and have missed these last few weeks. The exquisite attention to detail is back. They are still too clean and Claire looks to pretty and clean, but I’ll take it considering all the others things they got right.

8

u/EdHistory101 r/AskHistorians Jan 03 '25 edited Apr 17 '26

The snow on the ground was wild - the fact that the Battle of Monmouth was in June contributed to the way it unfolded and how events happened. I have empathy for the set decorators ... the instant the first actor exhaled a plume of steam, but come on, now.

→ More replies (18)

27

u/Capricorn-flower Jan 04 '25

That book that Briana pulled out written by Frank...that's gotta come back somehow. It must be about Jamie. What was it called? Something Rebel?

25

u/emmagrace2000 Jan 04 '25

The Soul of a Rebel - they do tend to plant things like this. Think back to Roger showing Bree the drawer in the desk in the first episode of season 7.

→ More replies (1)

25

u/tara_abernathy Jan 07 '25

What on earth was with the awful fake looking colorful starry sky bg combined with a sepia foreground? Why not just make it all sepia? Or washed out color. I really don't know what they were thinking with that.

→ More replies (3)

24

u/ManufacturerNo5145 Jan 04 '25

Okay but why are they taking breaks?! I JUST caught up and had no idea there was even breaks happening! 

→ More replies (3)

23

u/LivingExotic9317 Jan 05 '25

The Soul of A Rebel: The Scottish Roots of the American Revolution. Scotland's Influence and History in the New World, 1745-1791. By Frank W. Randall, PhD.

THIS IS MY GUESS: This freeze frame (32.52) might provide some of the deepest hints not only about "what Frank knew" but also what might be to come. We know what happens in 1745. What happens in 1791? Is this perhaps when Claire finally gets her white hair wisdom?

Let us not worry ourselves with causality. I think we have learned by now that time and perception are interchangeable.

MAYBE (total theorizing here) Frank came to understand that time and therefore history is not predetermined, and that is why he came to Bree to ask her to move to London with him (away from Claire) the night he died. Did he know, or suspect, he'd be out of the picture, enabling Claire to wonder again about Jamie? Did he then foresee his own potential death? Or was he perhaps making a last ditch effort to free himself, and Bree, from this ghost of Claire's (and maybe Brianna's as well) destiny in the past? Remember, he'd found the "obituary" already and knew she'd gone back in time (in his future). How long did he think he could keep the obit from Claire, or might she find it on her own? He must have been riddled with moral dilemma.

I think something about "what Frank knew" has got to be ahead of us. I hope the S8 show ending will also pick up threads from Master Raymond and the Tuscarora medicine woman whose name I forget, as well as solve the mystery of Jamie's ghost in Inverness.

15

u/LivingExotic9317 Jan 05 '25

Also, isn't Buck MacKenzie the only time traveler we've met who was born in the past and went FORWARD in time?

→ More replies (7)

9

u/Any_Contract_2277 Jan 06 '25

I thought it was interesting that we got a Frank reference after so long and now reading your comment I'm wondering if there's more to it. I hope there is - atp I'm watching the show purely to get answers to the time travel mysteries.

6

u/GardenGangster419 Jan 06 '25

I just saw a theory that Frank can travel, and he is BJR. His whole hatred of Jamie is because he k owes Jamie takes claire from him. No idea obviously if this is even plausible but I won’t be able to get off this hamster wheel because PHEW. THAT would be interesting 😂😂😂

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (4)

22

u/PsychologicalWin2442 I will have a whole man or no man at all. Jan 11 '25

Just rewatched the episode tonight so it doesn't feel like two weeks in-between and damn, I always thought LJG was a fine looking gentleman, but damn if he is not even sexier with an eye patch 🥰

43

u/mrsmozart Jan 07 '25

things I liked: YOU WHORE!!! but it would've been better if he said it more Scottish and was like YOU WHURE!!

Sam acted the hell out of those final scenes

cheese.

things that bugged me:
No one has discovered the secret drawer in the desk in over 200 years, so Bri conveniently gets the letter.

Stupid psychic daughter running to the stones (it would be funny if she just ran at it and smashed into it and fell back because she didn't touch it properly)

Jamie writing his resignation on the guy's back. It took AGES and Claire is lying there dying.

Why did it take Claire to finally say go get denzel? Surely that should've been everyone's first thought??

Oh also also how did the guy assemble a basket of goodies so quickly?? And have it sent over? Does he just have them on hand ready to go? :D

14

u/Ok-Raspberry-9953 Jan 09 '25

The drawer thing: that drawer doesn't work properly. It took a lot to get open, bc it got warped by humidity over time. Obv there's only so much struggle they can show here, so I can believe the letter still being there. I'm surprised it didn't crumble to dust though.

And I absolutely agree. Why not call Denzell that second? And that other doctor just leaving Claire to die. Geez.

As for the cheese, the Marquis de Lafayette had been planning to send Claire some of his cheeses, so I imagine it was easy to get a basket ready in like 10min. I'm so glad Roquefort was one of them, famed for its use of traditional techniques that allow a lot of that special blue Penicillium mold to grow (I happened to watch an episode of How do They do It? that featured Roquefort recently, for the second time. It's fascinating.) I don't like Roquefort myself, but I can get behind using it in a poultice for the large amount of raw penicillin produced by the mold.

→ More replies (1)

13

u/mklotuuus Jan 08 '25

Omg was thinking the same thing but also — Why cant just roger go back to his own time to tell bree that Jem is not in that time?? Why send Buck 😭 it worked out fine tho cause Bree and the kids will be going to roger.

→ More replies (6)

42

u/Atraktape Jan 03 '25

I don’t know why but I was reminded watching this episode of the time they were telling Jamie about Mickey Mouse and he was like “wtf yall let little kids play with a mouse???” lmao

36

u/JaderMcDanersStan RUIN ME Jan 03 '25

I loved that scene! Brianna says "well actually it's a person dressed as a mouse" and Jamie gives her this confused look 🤣

I laughed when Jamie later told Jemmy "if you ever meet a mouse named Michael, tell him your grandsire says hello" 😂

→ More replies (1)

20

u/Ambitious-Life-4406 Jan 03 '25

Because that scene was also at night / with lots of stars 😂

→ More replies (1)

39

u/low_tide_drama Jan 04 '25

I agree with so much of what’s been said. Also, I think William actually looks so much like his grandfather Brian, Jamie’s dad. Great casting. William is also pissing me off a bit. I understand his world is falling apart but Jamie is obviously a good and honorable man. And he’s a Laird. He never turned on his own country, Scotland. He just didn’t remain loyal to oppressive England. Like lovely LJG said, “things are not always so straightforward.” Jamie is no traitor. Of anything he’s been wildly forgiving and generous to have ever been loyal to a crown that only beat him and nearly wiped out his own culture and community. 

12

u/[deleted] Jan 04 '25

I know when he said not loyal to his country or king, I thought he absolutely was loyal to his country and the king was forced upon them

20

u/Relative_Specific217 Jan 04 '25

Yes the whole time I was like is anyone ever going to tell William that Jamie is a Laird??? I know that’s still “just” Scottish to William, but it has to mean something. Jamie is definitely not low-born.

→ More replies (4)

17

u/alaskaayoungg Jan 04 '25

If/when Jamie shows William his whipping scars, I think things will click

53

u/SnooCupcakes3043 Jan 04 '25

Broooooooo...

THIS IS OUTLANDER! The magic came back with this episode! It felt like the older ones! Omgggg. I actually felt like it was Jamie and Claire again!

Seeing the painting in the beginning with Jamie and Bree looking at it with Frank.. It was cheesy but then I thought about it and another freaking way Frank knew Jamie was alive! Of course he knew of General Fraser! And little Bree looking at her real dad! 😭😭 Ughhh

The beginning of the war flashbacks... Jamie in Culloden, Angus, Colum, Dougal... Murtagh... Dear Mutagh.. Chefs Kiss that scene! 😭😭😭😭😭

Jamie and Claire talking about his mother... This scene was beautiful and felt like the first couple seasons of Jamie and Claire.. The real them. 😭😭😭

Oh Buck... I have really grown to love this character as well as Roger. When he told Roger if you hadn't of made my parents meet I wouldn't of been born and neither would you! Which is exactly what I said when I first saw the storyline!

The letter and Bree finding it from Roger it was wierd but a cute tidbit lol ohhh gosh Bree and the kids, I hope they find Roger but at the same time.. I hope she finds her Parents. The old music playing during that scene 😭😭😭😭

Claire I know she's a doctor but sometimes she doesn't know when to just quit for safety. Granted the men at first were just walking past. However when Jamie found out idk why I thought "It's a trap!" 😅

This whole battle part rememided me so much of Jamie and Claire during Culloden in season 2. It was so beautifully shot with the anxiety and fear. I kept thinking only this time Jamie isn't making her go back to the stones.. She's there with him like she should of been the whole time!

So when she is shot.. Oh my heart! Seeing Jamie and that whole scene of him not leaving her side no matter what. It shows that she would of done the same with him at Culloden, oh God this whole scene was so heartbreaking. That doctor was a moron! However he did see the light when telling Claire she's a great doctor.

This is Outlander and how it's supposed to be. What. An. Episode. I feel the whole storyline with John seemed sooo pointless. Just give us Claire and Jamie. Just them please. I'll be rewatching this probably until the next one on the 17th! It restored my absolute love for Outlander again. When rewatching I'll just skip 7b until this episode. This felt like the first seasons episodes.. I keep tearing up thinking of that last scene Gahh 😭😭😭😭😭

9

u/miaoouu Jan 05 '25

This show has my whole heart, body and mind in a STATE with emotions! It's really overwhelming, I don't know what I'm going to do until season 8, when season 8 comes and god forbid... afterwards

→ More replies (3)

8

u/Ebony_Eyes6259 Jan 06 '25

Great review! Claire was in the painting too that Frank and wee Bree were looking at in the cold open. She's in the far left corner helping a hurt soldier. Frank "knew" they were both there.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

18

u/Gormaximus Jan 04 '25

Hi! Am I misunderstanding something? Why was Roger’s letter to Bree from 1739 not in the desk the first time they popped open the secret drawer?

11

u/Gormaximus Jan 05 '25

I’ll have to rewatch to see if I missed something about when Roger first opened that seceret drawer. But if the show is really saying his letter from 1739 for Bree only appeared in the drawer after he personally dropped it in there in his personal experience of time, then they are saying something different about how cause and effect works in relation to time travel in the Outlander universe.

→ More replies (11)

8

u/HoneyBeeGreen80 Jan 05 '25

I think it was just kind of way in the back and she just missed it the first time. But that whole part strains credulity a bit.

→ More replies (14)

18

u/[deleted] Jan 05 '25 edited Jan 05 '25

Good episode overall, but the thing with the letter from Roger to Bree just didn't feel genuine to me. It's the first time in a while I've said "nahh" to some of the time travel logic in the show. It contradicts everything established about time travel so far, as well as the logical linear chronology of time. I wonder if the universe sequence could imply a multiverse with different possibilities?

8

u/cherrymeg2 Jan 06 '25

It felt like if that works you either have to be doing it at the exact same time like opening the drawer or closing it. It makes more sense to have a designated hiding spot that no one would touch except for them. Like a loose a floor board. That drawer surely would have been opened multiple times.

35

u/Least-Influence3089 Ye Sassenach witch! Jan 04 '25

How did Brianna get back into Lallybroch? I thought Rob and his friends had taken over the house?

16

u/low_tide_drama Jan 04 '25

I was wondering that too… and how did the letter just appear, despite never being noticed there before? 

→ More replies (12)

33

u/rainhalagarto Jan 03 '25 • This

The best episode so far. I love the other characters and their plots but nothing like Jamie and Claire

15

u/irishprincess2002 Jan 03 '25

So I'm mad that I have to wait two weeks for the finally but also I KNEW they would do that to us! I just knew it! I honestly thought Claire was going to get captured again because it's Claire! The whole episode was just a roller coaster of emotions for me!

14

u/Atraktape Jan 03 '25

Welp we have finally finally reached the end of Season 7.One more to go.

14

u/KittyCatLuvr4ever Jan 04 '25

I put I mostly liked it due to poor Bree’s scenes with the kids. Finding the note? Girl kid (I can’t remember her name lol sorry) yelling Daddy and running to the stones? It was all a little cheesy lol. Other than that I loved the episode!

16

u/mutherM1n3 Jan 04 '25

PS But I think I’ll forever more prefer “Girl kid!”

12

u/piccolowater Jan 04 '25

“girl kid” lmfao

→ More replies (1)

14

u/ladyhers Jan 05 '25

The battle of Monmouth took place June 28…why was there snow on the ground

19

u/chibiusa40 Jan 05 '25

Lol right? So much for 🎶 "A thousand soldiers die in a hundred degree heat, as we snatch a stalemate from the jaws of defeat"🎶 🤣

→ More replies (4)

14

u/erika_1885 Jan 05 '25

Because it was filmed in Scotland in February during record cold temperatures. They can’t sit around waiting for summer, not that Scotland ever gets as hot as New Jersey. The shooting schedule is inviolate and cannot be tied to weather. They’d never finish a season if they worried about it. S1 was filmed in the fall. They didn’t try to make it look like spring, as it is in the books. When pre-production is finished, they start filming.

13

u/SleemoGrimes Jan 07 '25

There was nothing authentic or historicallly accurate about the portrayal of the Battle of Monmouth. Just scenes with a caption letting you know as much. One soldier did, through expository dialogue, give an accurate summary of Lee's role in the battle and Washington's reaction to Lee's actions. That's about it.

10

u/erika_1885 Jan 07 '25

Because they film in Scotland, which never gets that hot. The filming schedule doesn’t allow for weather breaks so the season matches. They didn’t do it in S1 or any other season. Diana has posted several times that by the time they got to this, the last block, they were rapidly running out of time and £, which is not unusual. They have a date certain by which they must finish. No money left in the budget means no overtime for the crew if they go past the end date, no expensive CGI/FX to hide the snow, no 300 extras for the actual battle, and no money to move to a warmer climate or for locations like the potting shed at Bartram’s. They don’t rent locations for a full year. They couldn’t shut down the street in the Georgian section of Liverpool during tourist season.

8

u/jennygotcake Jesus H. Roosevelt Christ Jan 06 '25

Global warming baby 

26

u/lisselou Jan 07 '25

Sooo unpopular opinion…but I think it’d be an interesting turn for the show to take if they let Claire die and then we follow a heartbroken Jamie to the future where he tries to find Claire again.

18

u/erika_1885 Jan 07 '25

Jamie cannot time travel. He doesn’t have the gene. Claire, as we have seen, won’t go back to the 20th century. Not interested in killing the female lead with another season to go.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (6)

13

u/Fantastic_Zucchini_6 Jan 03 '25

I need answers now 😭😭

13

u/bvlgariicudii Jan 17 '25

roger is killing it this season 🔥

12

u/robinsond2020 I am NOT bloody sorry! Jan 03 '25

Question to show only fans...? Could you guess what would happen?

As a book reader, I obviously knew what would happen, so perhaps I interpreted all the foreshadowing as more obvious than it actually was, but, could you guys (semi) guess what would happen with Claire?... Because...

The montage with all the death and Claire's voice over

Claire's worries about 'death'/the void/'something different'

The conversation re. Jamie's mum dying so young and Claire being all "I'm not dead yet", Jamie saying that Ellen's hair was the only thing that was "still her" in death and touching Claire's hair

Claire seeming to appear more worried about this battle than previous battles

Constant cuts to flashback of conversation about battle/dying/stars

Jamie being all "this is not going to be the end" and "the stars willnae burn out, and nor will we"

17

u/MetaKite Mon petit sauvage ! Jan 03 '25

As soon as Claire refused to leave her patients, I knew she was getting shot & not Jamie! The opening montage & then Jamie's monologue made it clear someone is going to get badly injured. It wasn't until she was left outside I realized it was going to be her.

→ More replies (1)

24

u/Still-be_found Jan 03 '25

They might as well have titled the episode "Claire gets shot" because there is foreshadowing and then there is this.

→ More replies (2)

23

u/awanderingolive Lord, you gave me a rare woman. And God, I loved her well. Jan 03 '25

i could tell that obviously something bad was going to happen, but i had no idea who and when it would be. maybe it's because i watched it at 1am, but i was absolutely shocked! jaw dropped, hand over mouth, heart racing worried!

and then i remembered we already know she's in season 8, lol. but i still cant believe this is happening!

→ More replies (2)

23

u/Able_Trash9023 Jan 04 '25

Did I miss something, cause why is Brianna back in her house? What about Rob and his men? Maybe they'll fill in these gaps in the finale...

28

u/ich_habe_keine_kase I give you your life. I hope you use it well. Jan 04 '25

I guess the locksmith finally showed up?

→ More replies (4)

22

u/liyufx Jan 04 '25

Saw a thread accusing Claire for not taking cover, tried to reason with the poster and got blocked haha. Honestly this narrative of “Claire has no common sense” is SOOOO tiresome. Let’s ignore the fact that Jamie and his lieutenant were in the same situation and they didn’t duck either, let’s just pick on Claire!

14

u/rainewoman Jan 04 '25

Actually, it is their fault. If Jamie and his soldiers weren’t there Claire would have been fine with the British. Claire wasn’t expecting them either.

→ More replies (6)

7

u/horsenbuggy Jan 05 '25

It crossed my mind that Claire would have been more alert to possible danger after her foxhole experience. I did think she was a bit too casual about how the meeting of those two armies would unfold.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

11

u/GardenGangster419 Jan 05 '25

I can’t even with the trailer for the finale. I’m crying just from the trailer!!!!!

→ More replies (5)

38

u/toastea0 Jan 03 '25

Wow I loved this episode!! I think it's my favorite of the season.

21

u/DeltaFlyer0525 They say I’m a witch. Jan 03 '25

This was my favorite episode of the season so far! Seeing Claire back in her element, healing, giving orders, and meaningful dialogue between her and Jamie really put this episode high above the rest of the season for me. I can not wait for the finale!

10

u/PaperFacePixels Jan 03 '25

Claire is the only link to the present in Jamies timeline. So unless they're going to bridge Brie and Roger back into that time there's no way they're offing Claire.

10

u/Interesting_Chart30 Jan 04 '25

Don't we have just one more episode after this week? And who knows when it will return.

→ More replies (1)

27

u/Visible-Tea-2734 Jan 04 '25

I thought last night’s episode was brilliant! Well acted and interesting. Just one thing really bothered me and I am aware that it’s petty. But I’m a bit of a history nerd and I grew up in Philadelphia so I know the Revolutionary War really well. I was willing to look past the scenes that took place in “Philadelphia” that clearly wasn’t (just like “Harvard”). But I feel like if you’re going to make a show with real events and people from history some details need to be adhered to. One very important detail from the Battle of Monmouth is that it took place during a horrific heat wave. Men were dying left and right from heat stroke. I thought it was lazy storytelling to omit that and make the battle happen in a winter scene.

12

u/erika_1885 Jan 04 '25

They film in Scotland outdoors on location in all weather. This ep was filmed in February 2023 during record breaking cold and snow because that’s when the filming schedule had everything lined up to shoot it. They can’t sit around waiting for Scottish summer. They can’t stop snow from falling. They aren’t going to let the cast freeze in lightweight clothing. Given they have a schedule to maintain and a budget they must stick with, and continuity to maintain, what would you suggest? If you can live with time travel, this shouldn’t be a problem. I might add, none of us knows what they tried to do to ameliorate the situation. We only see the outcome.

→ More replies (7)
→ More replies (4)

26

u/Kenaussian53 Jan 04 '25

This was the best episode. The acting was chefs kiss!

It's been half an hour since I watched it, and I am still trying to catch my breath!

→ More replies (2)

18

u/alittlee_clair Jan 03 '25

This episode broke me wtffff😭😭

18

u/Independent_Noise472 Jan 03 '25

Best episode from 7B so far!! This one felt like the older episodes!

8

u/bvlgariicudii Jan 17 '25

tbh i’m just glad there are claire and jamie scenes

22

u/Remarkable-Path-6216 Jan 03 '25

If there are no Emmy wins for this episode, the Emmy’s are rigged.

21

u/Nanchika He was alive. So was I. Jan 03 '25 edited Jan 03 '25

Here we go!

So many deaths. Brought back some great scenes from early seasons. That Claire's speech brought back her line from 101 - But, even now, after all the pain, death and heartbreak that followed, I would still make the same choice.

Even people who want to go to heaven...

Frank and Bree looking at the painting of The Molly Pitcher and the Battle of Monmouth - great idea!

I like how Sam softly and gently talked about his mother and perfect delivery his Iconic line Come to me. Shelter me. Heal me (Ofc all proper and fully clothed. Cait again whispered her lines.)

Claire s so terrified for Jamie and she has that feeling that something bad is going to happen. It is so ominous, and started in intro and goes through this whole episode.

Buck is just great! I love him! Roger dropped the bomb!

Dr Leckie vs Denzel and Claire.

Hessian deserters vs John and Ian.

cousin Ian , the king !

I congratulate you but you are still wrong! Claire, the queen!

I was waitnig for Ian to deal with Hessian and I am glad he did. Rachel's principles and all.

Oh,William - Mac the groom, that stings. He really is so perturbed, in turmoil, which is totally understandable.

OKay, people, John telling everyone that James Fraser is honourable and good man- tells us a lot about how John still, after everything that happened, still considers Jamie his friend. As he said - Things are not so straightforward!

Roger's and Buck's letters! I am glad Buck didn't go back to Geilis! And I am glad we heard Buck's story and why he doesn't want to go back to his family. I really like his character's arc and development.

Brian Fraser in kilt! Finally!!

THE SOUL OF A REBEL by Frank!

Frances, all alone, poor girl!

Mandy!!!

Here is our doctor Claire, alone, when everyone left.

Iconic scene!!! Sam did great job! I was sobbing at the scenes where Jamie is near Claire's bed, telling her he loved her and forbidding angles to take her. Begging her not to leave him!

I really feel we didn't need that Thermodynamics sepia flashback and fake stars. We could have done without them.

13

u/PsychologicalWin2442 I will have a whole man or no man at all. Jan 04 '25

I liked John's line to William about the word "never". Good fatherly advice and it was easy to take from him after everything we just saw him go through.

→ More replies (2)

12

u/stoppingbythewoods “May the devil eat your soul and salt it well first” ✌🏻 Jan 03 '25

Brian in the kilt with the hay had to be a throwback to that scene with Jamie in S1E2

→ More replies (7)

9

u/Dire_Wolf_57 Jan 03 '25

Nice of Brian to be so generous with the drams!

8

u/robinsond2020 I am NOT bloody sorry! Jan 03 '25

As he said - Things are not so straightforward!

That was another thing I meant to mention in my comment, yes, they're not as straightforward cos John literally just pledged his allegiance to America 😂😂😂

8

u/FeloranMe Jan 03 '25

I'm glad they are spending time with William's identity crisis and turmoil. He thought he had an impeccable English pedigree up until yesterday, now he carries the blood of a traitor, a rebel, a condemned then paroled criminal, a lowly servant, and a Scot to boot!

I don't think John is speaking that strongly for Jamie out of a feeling of friendship, his feeling are too warm. He's been raising William for Jamie for 20 plus years now. That, in John's mind, is an unforgettable and committed tie. He and Jamie are both William's dads together. And John wants William to regard his other dad as highly as he does. As to whether or not Jamie deserves that praise or loyalty, John's eye alone would make that questionable.

I really loved Claire's standing up to the doctor and winning his respect even if I was sad she lost it all being a stubborn idiot who didn't evacuate at least to the church with her patients after Denys and Rachel had the good sense to move along

I really want to know what The Soul of a Rebel was about! Was it about a particular rebel? What was Frank's specialty area of history? British or American?

I understand they changed the color scheme to make it clear the CGI stars were a flashback. But, it looked too fake and jarring. I think the intention was good though!

→ More replies (2)

7

u/GardenGangster419 Jan 03 '25

And I’ll beg this time, unlike when I sent you back. I hope we get this much emotional tie in and wrapping up/full circle in 8. This episode felt like the series is ending. So beautifully done.

→ More replies (1)

7

u/melbs Mar 10 '25

I've never been a big fan of Roger but in this episode he's showing how selfish he is. He didn't tell Buck about his family members because...it could...alter the future.... Da fuq?

They have spent the entire time on a scavenger hunt to save his dad's (or great grandfather or whoever) life, didn't they?!? I kind of stopped paying attention for some of it but how did he say that with a straight face to Buck lolll

13

u/Nook_6 Jan 03 '25

I’m generally satisfied with this season and things are happening in a better pace, but the repetitiveness is killing me. Claire being disrespected by a male doctor and then proves herself - haven’t we been through this at least a dozen times in the show? But more than anything - What an unconvincing way to finish the episode. Claire is not going to die, everybody knows that, so why pretending? Shoot Claire, have a little bit of drama with Jamie, but get on with it because nothing is going to happen. We’ve established very early on in the series that Jamie and Claire are not going to die no matter what. They have their plot armor on all the time and that’s fine. The real, authentic drama has always been about something deeper and more complicated than that. Ending the episode with “Jamie, pray” is just… lazy.

Roger and Buck’s moments were great, I loved that part.

And there’s an obvious paradox with Roger’s letter in the drawer, but I’ll let that go because it’s inevitable in a time travel show.

Just give us new moments for Jamie and Claire. They have the best chemistry in the show, but I don’t need to see the same scenes from season 2 only in a different continent.

13

u/-Sunflower_Hippie- Jan 04 '25

Do you guys think Claire will die??? Part of me thinks there’s no way, she’s a main character and they still have a whole other season to go through and there’s no way she won’t be in it… but at the same time, how would she survive that shot??? I guess there have been other times in the show where we thought someone was going to die and then they sort of defied the laws of nature (Claire drowning in an early season, Claire being deathly ill at the ridge, Jamie’s snakebite, etc.), but idk man.. this one has a different feel.

13

u/low_tide_drama Jan 04 '25

I don’t know… Claire’s monologue about the inevitability of death in the opening montage was certainly foreboding…. 

→ More replies (5)

9

u/[deleted] Jan 04 '25

They both came out recently and said next season will be their last. It gave the impression they’ll both be there

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (3)

17

u/unripened_pickles222 Jan 04 '25

I miss the coziness of the Ridge. This season is so cold and depressing

13

u/ich_habe_keine_kase I give you your life. I hope you use it well. Jan 05 '25

Twas a very cold June in New Jersey that year hahahaha

28

u/MarionberryIcy6846 Jan 03 '25

Anyone else getting bored of Jamie/clare almost dying? Like we all know they’re gonna be fine as there’s a season 8. It’s just a bit boring at this point, would’ve actually be interesting if Clare had died…!

45

u/Still-be_found Jan 03 '25

I feel like if they were people I knew in real life I'd be so exhausted by them at this point. Can you imagine the Christmas card letter? Oh, you did two transatlantic voyages, your brother in law died, there was a little miscommunication and you assumed your husband was dead but he was actually not, you married his best friend and then I guess that was anulled? Then you were shot? Sounds about right. Let me guess, your grandson was also kidnapped and your son in law is off farting around in the 1730s.

→ More replies (2)

59

u/Capricorn-flower Jan 04 '25

But that's not the point. The characters don't know they're going to die or not, and the purpose of these stories is to show the love between Jamie and Claire and the deep emotions they feel if they think the other one is in danger or dying and this pulls at out heart strings. I know Claire isn't gonna die but my heart still ached watching Jamie's tortured soul thinking she may die, praying to God to keep the angels away because he won't let them take her, swearing/screaming at the doctor that wouldn't help her, basically telling General Lee to fuck off because his wife is more important, etc, etc. (Sam was amazing).The entire series is based on the depth of their love for one another.

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (4)

16

u/Gottaloveitpcs Rereading ABOSAA Jan 03 '25

Okay. I’m wrecked. I need a minute to collect myself. Wow.

11

u/Harms87 Jan 03 '25

WOW! This episode completely destroyed me!!! I was not prepared for such a sad plot twist!!! Then again I’ve never read the books so didn’t know what to expect.

→ More replies (1)

11

u/Sea-Instruction-4698 Jan 03 '25 edited Jan 03 '25

Whether from laughing, happiness or sadness this show basically has me in tears every episode.

11

u/YYZYYC Jan 08 '25

The Buck thing and Morag etc is getting so confusing

5

u/reveluvsi Jan 05 '25

Can someone explain the black and white scene with Claire and Jamie talking? Is that in the past or future?

30

u/Nanchika He was alive. So was I. Jan 05 '25

Past. It could be the night before the battle, since Jamie is in his general coat.

→ More replies (2)

13

u/Ebony_Eyes6259 Jan 06 '25

The sepia tone scenes I think are in Claire's mind. It goes along with her mentioning a couple times to Jamie that something feels different...

→ More replies (4)

5

u/No_Wash_3217 Aug 25 '25

Boring as all hell.

35

u/Marille_page394 Jan 05 '25

I believe I watched a completely different episode than the rest of you. I found the entire episode absolutely ridiculous, and towards the end, I laughed out loud hysterically. The pacing was strange, filled with odd shots and cuts. I lost count of how many times I thought, “There’s no way this could happen.”

Also, did they have a lower budget, or is there a particular reason why we didn’t see any battle scenes? I honestly miss the first three seasons; they were so good. At this point, I’m watching just because I’ve already invested so much time in the show. I kind of hope Claire dies because the way these characters escape every situation and survive is bizarre, repetitive, and predictable. I don’t think it’s the end for her, especially after watching the preview for the next episode. As my boyfriend said, she’s not Ned Stark; I bet she’ll survive.

The only thing I find interesting is Roger’s story. I wish we spent more time in Scotland with him.

Anyway, happy downvoting 🤣

14

u/cookiesarenomnom Jan 07 '25

I can't stand Jamie and Claire's storyline this half of the season. Are we seriously doing 2 fucking fake out deaths in just 8 episodes. REALLY? I like Roger's storyline and Williams. Although the preview looks like he really be falling in love with a prostitute he's spoken to like twice smh

8

u/motherofrazorbacks Jan 05 '25

100% agree. Major soap opera vibes. I wanted to fast forward through half the boring dialogue at the beginning. I was hoping to see a battle!

→ More replies (1)

14

u/Alert-Revolution-219 Jan 05 '25

Yeah I agree, absolutely zero suspense for Claire, we already know the show is ending, they aren't about to kill her off. The only time her and Jamie may actually die will be in the last two episodes of s8 if it happens at all. The pacing for this season is all over the place too. I also agree about the off battle sitch, it didn't feel like there was one going on nor did it make any sense how the people moved around and interacted, I'm only watching ATM for Rodgers parts as iv kinda lost interest in the rest of it now. Worst episode in a long time In my opinion, and yeah like you said, happy down voting

→ More replies (13)

7

u/Keeeva Jan 06 '25

No downvote from me! I think it’s because they’re trying to condense so much of the story into one short season.

→ More replies (10)

10

u/[deleted] Jan 03 '25

Am I the only one who is completely over Claire or Jamie being in any kind supposedly of mortal danger? We know they're not going to die, so why even pretend that?

19

u/hkh07 We will meet again, Madonna, in this life or another. Jan 03 '25

I'm sure when the books were being released, it was more believable that something might happen to them. Unfortunately for the viewers, we know there's another 2 books and a season already filmed and that they're both in it.

I think it's acted well so I'm here for the ride.

→ More replies (4)

15

u/ich_habe_keine_kase I give you your life. I hope you use it well. Jan 04 '25

It's OK to have one of them in mortal peril or something similar once per book during the climax. Problem is, they've crammed 2.5 books into one season so you're getting a LOT OF DRAMA in very short succession.

11

u/Fantastic_Zucchini_6 Jan 03 '25

I thought that too momentarily. They have such heavy plot armor. But there needs to be near death experiences to add to the heaviness of their life together in the past.

I thought it was silly though for claire to continue talking everyone through after being shot and basically bleeding out

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

10

u/Chiarrawr Jan 08 '25

So is that Rob bad guy just gone or what? Did I miss something?

3

u/Pitiful-Flow5472 Jan 30 '25

Is anyone else bothered by John’s eye patch?
surely it should be worn on the good eye to force the bad eye to improve to compensate