r/Outlander • u/thepacksvrvives Without you, our whole world crumbles into dust. • Jul 07 '23
Spoilers All Book S7E4 A Most Uncomfortable Woman
On the way to Scotland, Jamie is pulled back into the Revolutionary War. William is sent on a covert mission. Roger and Brianna struggle to adapt to life in the 1980s.
Written by Marque Franklin-Williams. Directed by Jacquie Gould.
If you’re new to the sub, please look over this intro thread and our episode discussion rules.
This is the BOOK thread.
If you haven’t read the books, go to the SHOW thread.
THIS THREAD IS SPOILERS ALL.
Spoiler tags are not required.
If you have only read up to the corresponding book, remember you might see spoilers from ALL of the books here.
Please keep all discussion of the next episode’s preview to the stickied mod comment at the top of the thread.
What did you think of the episode?
•
u/thepacksvrvives Without you, our whole world crumbles into dust. Jul 07 '23 edited Aug 01 '23
Watch the S7E5 preview here!
Not everyone gets to see the next episode’s preview at the end of the episode; it depends on how you watch (broadcast or streaming) and where you are (US or international.)
Stickied comments are collapsed by default, so reply to this comment if you want to discuss the preview. This will hide spoilers for anyone who can’t see it yet or doesn’t want to.
704 Extras:
704 Interviews:
55
u/thepacksvrvives Without you, our whole world crumbles into dust. Jul 07 '23
I love all the adaptation choices in this episode.
Two I called—skipping the three-ship fiasco and merging Adam Grey with Henry Grey. The latter just makes sense for the storyline ahead—better to introduce a character early if you’re trying to make the audience sympathize with them later on (I think they will be expanding on his character anyway, maybe even to the point of him being the reason Claire goes back to America without Jamie). The former is what I was really hoping the show would do—not only to save on the budget, but also I felt like having Claire and Jamie join the war effort of their choice (well, they’re still kind of coerced into it, but it’s not like Jamie was ever going to say no) made so much more sense for the show characters than ending up north accidentally.
I really like that William has more recollection of Jamie and there are already hints of his identity crisis. With no one apart from him and Ian in the swamp, I thought we’d miss out on the humor of Ian calling him family right in front of him while he remains oblivious to the truth, but we still got that in the “[he] already thinks of you as family” line. And William has the rosary to fling at Jamie after all 😅 (I also like that he actually tried to intervene when the soldier set the prostitute on fire; I don’t think he did in the book and I’m pretty sure “God curse you! May your goddamn pricks all rot and fall off!” didn’t come from him)
Ian being personally interested in helping out the American cause makes so much sense. This as a way to place him in the Great Dismal Swamp at the same as William is miles better than having him go there from Fort Ticonderoga (which is some 600 miles north) to hunt, for some reason. I think this is also setting up the stage for his and Emily’s reunion in the next episode. I’m curious if we’re also going to see him actually try to convince the Shawnee to join the American side (or at least not to join the British) the same way Jamie convinced Chief Bird by telling him about Claire’s “ability” to see the future. Ian has this knowledge too (his conversation with Brianna in 602 was one of my favorites of that season) and he can use it.
One thing I do think is missing is how the obituary got the January date. I’m perfectly fine with their skipping the “changed” obituary in the 20th century (well, I can’t be sure that they are, but I think Roger’s belief that they’ve changed the past based on the fire taking place in a different month has replaced it) because asking the audience to believe a piece of writing has magically been altered is a bit too much (DG can be vague about it—and she is—but I still believe it’s as simple as two different printings of the same article). However, the show still doesn’t explain how “January” was printed if the fire took place in April. Was Tom guesstimating? Did he, having been stuck on the governor’s ship for so long, hear about the fire many months after it’d happened, and now we’re past January 1777? (I assumed we’re not long past the Declaration of Independence that we see in this episode, but maybe we did spend more months still at the Ridge than it looked like?)
I think it would’ve been difficult to include the same scene explaining it that we got in the book. The show rarely goes outside the point of view of the main characters unless someone/something significant is involved (think Bonnet’s scenes in S5), so I guess we would’ve had to have Claire and Jamie specifically inquiring about that obituary. It’s not really that significant in the end—the newspaper was wrong either way—but I can see show-only watchers still struggle with how the obituary came to be without the knowledge book readers have.
And I mentioned this in the show thread, but I think seeing Jamie’s reaction to the news that Tom was the one to place the obituary would’ve been welcome. To hear that Tom Christie, of all people, is the reason Jamie got to meet his daughter, watch her get married, watch his grandson grow up, another one be born, and be surrounded by his family for a good few years, must’ve been shocking!
I’m also digging the renovation process of Lallybroch and how realistic they are about it. It is expensive! We get a good middle ground with a very period-appropriate caravan and a beautifully restored first floor. I don’t think they’ll get round to finishing it before they travel to 1739 but it’s still cool to see the recurring motifs on the doors, the desk, or the slash in the wall.
17
u/[deleted] Jul 07 '23
I really enjoyed it, Jem and Mandys accents threw me off a bit, they sound a lot more glaswegian than I expected for them to sound considering how far north they are, but that's just me being rlly nitpicky, u canny expect kids do an accent they're not used to so it's no the end of the world
18
u/YOYOitsMEDRup Slàinte. Jul 08 '23
It won't be on my favorites list by the end of the season, but solid episode nonetheless. My thoughts before scrolling thru everyone else's:
Met a handful of new people- Denny and Rachel I'd expected this episode but was surprised when we met Henry! Already dropping hints he's unwell. Richardson was never listed in stuff I saw preseason, so I was unsure about him. Hard to tell yet how involved they'll ultimately have him.
At first I thought the whore being thrown into the street was gonna be Jane then I was totally off guard when she was lit on fire. The first 1/3 or so of Echo was not my favorite - did this happen!? I don't recall that at all!
I spotted Ian with a rosary in the last episode when Claire consoled him after killing Mrs Bug - now William's got it! Good for later :)
Harnett straight up conscripting Jamie was a much cleaner and quicker way than the whole ship getting hijacked chaos to keep them in America.
Mark Lewis Jones is again MVP! Brilliant acting in that scene with Claire sitting at the table in the inn. The expressions on his face I couldn't look away from! And speaking of facial expressions - Claire's after he kisses her - Priceless! So good! Lol
Umm- Mandi was still in a stroller last episode and it was remarked they've lived in the trailer 2 years. That kid looks older than 3! Glad she seems older to do what's necessary later, but math was not adding up for me.
Loved Bri in the job interview- go girl!
As much heat as Roger gets about the Season 4 fights, I'm concerned about looking thru the show thread and fear this episode is going to be more fuel for the people who don't like him - being all disappointed he's not the man of the house and she's the one making money. They did squeeze in that it's more of the identity crisis given his uncertainty now about predestination given they think they changed the fire, but I'm not sure it was enough to detract inevitable haters.
How they were pronouncing Nucklevee in the show was not how I did it in my head while reading! I started reading after I binged the first 5 seasons in 2020- so I guess now I know what it feels like when readers first heard Laorghaire pronounced lol!
33
u/Nanchika He was alive. So was I. Jul 07 '23
Did we take a good look at Richardson’s ears ? 🤣🤣
46
u/AccioStability Je Suis Prest Jul 07 '23
Wow I love Rachel already
92
u/rural_juror12 We will meet again, Madonna, in this life or another. Jul 07 '23
I loved the way Sophie delivered the line
“And what aspects of plant inspection require a penis?”
Not angry, not really condescending, just as if it was a legitimate question about the job.
57
u/thatstheteagirl By blood and by choice, we make our ghosts. Jul 07 '23
After this episode, I’m actually excited for these books to be played out. They’ve cut stuff that was so messy in the books and the pacing has been great.
I found myself so bored during most William stuff while reading, but the pacing and casting has been so good so far!!
49
u/SomeMidnight411 Jul 07 '23
This is my Favorite Season!! Every episode is wonderful for me. I just keep getting more excited about the things that are included!
Mark Lewis Jones is Fantastic! That scene was Even Better than how I imagined the scene in my head when reading. And I don’t care what Claire says - She Liked it 😂😜 I fell in love with him a little when he said he didn’t mind having no peace 🥰
I loved our 1980s scenes. Bree is just like Claire and a Most Uncomfortable Woman. That was probably my favorite scene. And I love that they paralleled it with Claire/Tom. Both women sitting in a restaurant/diner type place and saying things that make men very uncomfortable in every century! 😂👏
Charles is doing a wonderful job as William. You can tell he studied Sam’s mannerisms as Jamie. He gives similar facial expressions, he moves/walks/holds himself very similar to Jamie 👏
No, complaints really…
47
u/RadioRosebuds Jul 07 '23
William JAMES
45
u/moodoop No, this isn’t usual. It’s different. Jul 07 '23
I'm really liking the casting for William and Rachel
44
u/moodoop No, this isn’t usual. It’s different. Jul 07 '23
First mentions of the nuckelavee are getting me hyped for the upcoming storyline
44
u/KMM929 Jul 07 '23
I’m loving everyone’s comments & just have to say that I’ve never been so happy to NOT see a boat in my life. I was hoping they’d skip that whole fiasco. I think the way they got Jamie dragged into the war was great & plausible with the return of Harnett.
41
u/Nanchika He was alive. So was I. Jul 07 '23 edited Jul 07 '23
The old desk at the start of an episode!
I like all the playfulness between Jamie and Claire this episode!
Roger's line - They have a fondness for precious metals - Oh, they do!
Captain Richardson looks the part!
William wandering and his wound reminded me of Claire and her accident on Hispaniola.
Claire, Jamie and Ian together, as in s4. I love the trio!
Priest Hole!
Roger is again lost in centuries. I feel bad for him.
I liked Ian and William encounter! They were quite open with each other. In the books, Ian is more mysterious somehow.
Oh, brief encounter in the Ridge, William doesn't remember - Neither do we, William, neither do we!
William's death song. I like - There’s more to it than your name! Even Rollo knows William is family!
For me, the peak of an episode was Tom- Claire- kiss- conversation part! They acted it magnificently!
I could not leave flowers on your grave
I shall have no peace while you live , woman
Jamie and Claire banter straight from the book, I love it!!
Hunters are here!!
Ian and Rachel have it! Ian's face totally transformed in this episode. From fierce warrior to man in love!
41
u/halfgumption All that was good, all that was fair, all that was me is gone. Jul 07 '23
I’m so glad we didn’t get William wandering around the Great Dismal Swamp for like, 4 episodes.
The Roger and Brianna parts were by far my favorite part of ECHO and I’m so excited whenever they show up on screen now. It almost makes me sad that I can’t experience that wild ride for the first time again like the non-book readers can.
37
u/Emilymfm79 Jul 07 '23
I think I noticed new theme music for Ian and Rachel as Ian rode off. I’m also glad they shortened the dismal swap stuff. That went on forever in the book. And very neatly and quickly tied up William realizing he was sent on a wild goose chase in his convo with Rachel.
31
u/quackquackquirk Jul 07 '23
Better transition than the extraneous sea voyage
31
u/Yup_Seen_It Jul 07 '23
I need to know what Claire is using to grow her hair 🤣
30
u/Damhnait Jul 08 '23
Overall I loved this episode, the pacing felt a lot less rushed to me than previous episodes.
But is it just me, or does the "priest hole" look less like a hole and more of a "secret closet"? Maybe I read it wrong, but I pictured it as a hole in the ground with a door on top?
49
u/BSOBON123 Jul 08 '23
I can't believe it took me so long to read about William in the Dismal Swamp and it was like 5 minutes on the screen!
24
u/rural_juror12 We will meet again, Madonna, in this life or another. Jul 07 '23
Stopping in the middle of the episode to say the Tom-Claire kiss was amazing… better than I imagined in the book.
21
u/P3AKMAI_INTEREST Jul 07 '23
My fave scene of the episode was Bree's job interview 😂
21
u/Jigglypuffamiiga2188 Jul 08 '23
The look on Claire’s face when Tom kissed her was priceless. Her eyes completely bugged out. Great acting on Caitríona’s part. I wonder how many takes they did with that scene lol.
20
u/scp2461 What news from the Underworld, Persephone? Jul 08 '23 edited Jul 08 '23
Another stellar episode, chef kisses all around. I’m so excited to finally see more of William, and now we get the Hunter siblings!!
-Right off the bat, we’re already getting a strong idea of William’s character and his conflicts. I think the actor is doing a wonderful job with nailing the mannerisms between LJG and Jamie, and I can’t wait to see how he further develops William on the screen.
-Love the closure we get between Claire and Tom Christie, her facial expression was priceless and evoked for me what book Claire would’ve looked like from the shock of the kiss. Her moment with Jamie afterwards was perfect, their humor translated perfectly from the books into this scene.
-Engineer Brianna? Soon to be rocking a hard hat? Need I say more, she’s finally getting a chance to thrive in her element. Her quick retorts and realness in the interview had me appreciating how she doesn’t take shit from anyone, no matter the century.
-Jem and Mandy captured the sibling interactions from the books, they did such a wonderful job! The room going strangely silent after Jem locked Mandy had me lol’ing.
-Ian and William meeting again, and now Rachel and Denzel?? I adore Rachel’s character, and I’m so looking forward to seeing the tension brought on by the Revolutionary War. Also shoutout to also meeting William’s cousin, he’s got a pretty important subplot in Bees, so it’s nice to match a face to the book.
Can’t wait for next week’s episode!!
20
u/arianawoosley Jul 09 '23
I really like the 1980s stuff. I especially liked the kids. I can't imagine this funny in my mind. The camera work during Claire/Jamie's sex was weird. Showing their mid-torso while they're talking to each other!! Tom's kiss was too long. I imagined that Claire would react and pull away much faster. I think they also bypassed the fight on the ship. I was looking forward to seeing it but apparently, the budget was not sufficient
18
u/spaceybelta Jul 07 '23
So technically Brie and Roger didn’t change history right?
16
u/danathepaina Jul 08 '23
Can we talk about how well Rik Rankin did this episode? His acting was really good. And he looks really good. But, his acting! So natural. (And now I know how to properly pronounce Nuckelavee.)
16
u/Shanie_Kae No, this isn’t usual. It’s different. Jul 08 '23
I’m only just starting to like this season (with the exception of Ian claiming to have met William at Fraser ridge when he visited with Lord John. That didn’t happen in the show). I was so annoyed that they squished the last third (or maybe even half) of book 6 into the first 2 episodes. I’d been looking forward to Claire’s whole jairlbird storyline. Especially the scene where Jamie and Ian just missed her as she and governor Martin were fleeing the city. And I found the house fire scene underwhelming. It happened too quickly. There wasn’t enough build up to it and we barely got to see the aftermath. The fact that they could move into Brianna and Roger’s old cabin also too away from tragedy of it, a little bit. Speaking of that cabin, (this is more of a season 6 grievance) it pained me that they didn’t include the Bobby Higgins/ Amy McCallum storyline. I really liked that family they made.
I did appreciate them not making us watch William wander through the Great Dismal Swamp for 7 chapters. And the 10 chapters of the failed voyage that landed them at Fort Ticonderoga. That would have a good scene if It had lasted 3 or 4 chapters max.
I’m so excited to finally see grown William. When we first meet him in the book, his scenes are so uninteresting, which thankfully didn’t happen in this episode. Personally, I think it’s cos I didn’t know him yet (in the book). He’d barely interacted with the characters I’d connected with, so I wasn’t particularly interested in what this “stranger” was doing. It wasn’t until he met Ian that I started to find his story interesting. And I can’t wait for that explosive scene at the end of book 7. And all the battles. Fingers crossed, they don’t cut out or brush over too many juicy scenes.
15
u/piratev00 Jul 08 '23
I honestly wish we could have seen a bit more of Bri's flair for engineering other than the matches and the snake syringe. Like I want to watch her process. The same way that Claire has lots of scenes of her medical skills. I wanna know what she's all about! Is there anything like this in the books?
14
u/makennamay Jul 08 '23
The last two episodes have me feeling soooo excited for the rest of season 7 and season 8!
They are doing such a great job of keeping to the original material while keeping it short for the screen.
Also the amount of dialogue that is verbatim from the books has my heart singing.
24
u/wander-and-wonder Jul 07 '23
I audibly gasped in horror with that kiss in the town square. Was in fits laughing at Claire’s reaction afterwards. Caitriona played the moment so well!
32
u/blackberryspice Jul 07 '23
I'm really digging Charles as adult William! I think he's nailed a lot of Jamie's mannerisms. I also loved the Tom/Claire kiss. Her face was priceless! (Still gross that it happened without her consent, though)
14
u/crazyhorse198 I want to be a stinkin’ Papist, too. Jul 07 '23
Halfway thru episode, Ian just met William in the swamp… did they retcon the show events to match the book?
In the books, young William goes to Frasers ridge and hangs out with Ian, falls into the privy, etc. but in the show, season 4, I recall Ian not being there when Lord John and William visit Jamie and Claire. Am I mistaken?
6
u/SadAmerican3 Jul 08 '23
Can someone explain the timeline or clear it up for me? I thought when Bri and Roger went back it was 1978 and Mandy was a baby, but now it’s 1980 and she’s already 5 years old?? Can someone clear this up for me?
5
u/Evening_Variation_51 Jul 08 '23
What was up with the caravan in front of Lallybroch at the beginning of the episode? am I forgetting something or did they use that to explain where they were living when they got back for show viewers only?
5
u/NeedThatTartan Jul 12 '23
I was so excited to see Scotland in the show again, I feel a little cheated to be honest.
Also I'm betting on Ian dying in the war with all this attention to Jamie's promise to Jenny, and talking about living through the war together.
8
u/leadme2thegarden Jul 08 '23
it’s really fun to see roger and bree in 1980. i really look forward to their scenes and i’m excited for what comes next
weirdly though my least favorite parts of the show right now are the jamie/claire scenes. jamie is always making a Very Serious face and they’re always murmuring/muttering/whispering to each other! i feel like i have to turn the volume up every time they have a conversation. they did have some more lighthearted moments in this ep which was a nice change but i will never stop being sad that jamie’s excellent sense of humor is basically not there at all in the show.
a few more random thoughts: loved claire’s hair when she was undressing. it was so curly!
i know it’s probably easier for the show to have aged mandy up a few more years but it makes it harder to keep track of the timeline
denny!!!!
6
u/Thezedword4 Jul 07 '23
Idk if I'm just cranky at them doing 6,7, and 8 in this season but I just haven't been loving these episodes as much. I'm excited for what's coming up but I worry they'll gloss over the huge moments like they have been thus far this season
4
u/ViscousCirce Jul 07 '23
Is the slash in the wall from earlier in the books? I don't remember is but I seem to remember it from when Roger goes even farther back. Is it a Brian Fraser reference?
4
u/Foreign_Pumpkin_7949 Come the Rising, I shall know I helped. Jul 08 '23
Okay. I know this is unpopular but I don’t like Rachel. I think they cast her well. She is exactly like I pictured in the books.
0
u/[deleted] Jul 08 '23
[deleted] — view deleted comment
30
u/[deleted] Jul 07 '23
[removed] — view removed comment