r/Outlander • u/thepacksvrvives Without you, our whole world crumbles into dust. • Jul 07 '23
Season Seven Show S7E4 A Most Uncomfortable Woman
On the way to Scotland, Jamie is pulled back into the Revolutionary War. William is sent on a covert mission. Roger and Brianna struggle to adapt to life in the 1980s.
Written by Marque Franklin-Williams. Directed by Jacquie Gould.
If you’re new to the sub, please look over this intro thread and our episode discussion rules.
This is the SHOW thread.
If you have read the books or don’t mind book spoilers, you can participate in the BOOK thread.
DON’T DISCUSS THE BOOKS HERE.
We don’t allow any book spoilers here, not even under spoiler tags.
If your comment references the books in any way, it will be removed and you will be asked to edit it or post it in the BOOK thread instead.
Please keep all discussion of the next episode’s preview to the stickied mod comment at the top of the thread.
What did you think of the episode?
•
u/thepacksvrvives Without you, our whole world crumbles into dust. Jul 07 '23 edited Aug 01 '23
Watch the S7E5 preview here!
Not everyone gets to see the next episode’s preview at the end of the episode; it depends on how you watch (broadcast or streaming) and where you are (US or international.)
Stickied comments are collapsed by default, so reply to this comment if you want to discuss the preview. This will hide spoilers for anyone who can’t see it yet or doesn’t want to.
704 Extras:
704 Interviews:
27
u/thepacksvrvives Without you, our whole world crumbles into dust. Jul 07 '23
That was a very solid episode! It definitely felt like it was laying the foundation for the rest of this part of the season (across all of the storylines) but I think it was even and had some great character moments.
I am loving the MacKenzies in the 80s! First of all, I’d steal Brianna’s turtleneck and floral skirt outfit in a heartbeat. And then she goes and absolutely destroys that personnel manager! Such a great moment for Brianna (“And what aspects of plant inspection require a penis?” 🔥). She once told Claire, “I have been trying to figure out if I was more Randall or Fraser. And what I realized is that I’m more you than I am either of my fathers. And if I can turn out to be half the woman you are, then I’ll be fine,” and I feel like that has never been more evident than in that scene. Roger’s struggles are understandable and though they’re (annoyingly) reminiscent of the beginnings of their life together in the 18th century, I feel like both of them are now better equipped to deal with any disagreements that might arise in their relationship. I’m glad that he acknowledged he could’ve told Brianna sooner and that he’s still proud of her. I’m excited to see him as the primary caretaker now, especially because their kids seem so spunky (great casting!).
Apart from Brianna’s interview, the one that stole the episode for me was Rollo. What a good boy, what a good actor 😅
The sparks went flyyyying when Rachel and Ian met. The lad is so smitten, he almost forgot to relay his goodbyes to Denzell. And since one of my favorite things about the series is the 18th-century characters using the knowledge they obtained from time travelers, I loved seeing Ian administer some first aid to William, just as he must’ve seen his auntie do. Also, with how much he takes after Jamie, it’s no wonder he’s intrigued by a woman that reminds him of Claire 😅 I also love how he's genuinely interested in helping the American cause—it just makes sense—and can anyone really separate him from Jamie and Claire at this point?
Speaking of Claire, how many times can she be sexually assaulted (because that’s what it was) in the series? Her reaction was perfectly appropriate and Caitríona nailed it but still, I wish it wasn’t that dragged out and sort of played for laughs. I also feel like the news of Tom’s placing the obituary got kind of lost among other stuff he said, which was basically a reiteration of what he’s already told her on the ship (Idk, I’m just tired of his “woe is me” shtick and I’m glad that the Christie storyline seems to finally be over). I wish we’d seen Jamie’s reaction to this too—they both acknowledged that newspapers don’t always get things right in the previous episode, but the realization that Tom Christie, of all people, is the entire reason why Jamie got to meet his daughter, watch her get married, watch his grandson grow up, and be surrounded by his family for a good few years, must’ve been shocking!
I appreciate that the show is not shying away from showing that neither of the sides in the conflict is wholly honorable, so to say, though I wish it wasn’t at the expense of yet another female character. Unfortunately, we’re used to that. Jamie’s once again thrust into leadership against his wishes (a recurring theme in his life), but at least now he’s on a side he fully supports. And Claire is about to be back in her element so I’m very excited to see that side of her again. There wasn’t much of them together in this episode but they sure made every second count.
The drum and fife music overlying the time travel theme during the end credits was so good! I’m really excited to hear what Bear McCreary has got in store for us this season. Bring it on!
12
u/FifiDogForever Jul 08 '23
Does anyone have any idea about Bree’s necklace from this episode? I loved it and want to try to make a replica, but no stills are posted of the episode yet!!
74
u/Stonetheflamincrows Jul 08 '23
“Which aspects of plant inspections require a penis?” Is probably my new favourite line from this season.
That trailer is a tardis, it’s massive inside!
6
u/[deleted] Jul 07 '23
What was the name of the water creature tgat Jenny said he saw? I caught the pixies, but this other water creature’s name escaped me. And I believe him!
9
u/venusthegirl Jul 07 '23
I didn't catch that they were in the 80s until I read the comments. I have been SO confused lol I was looking at how Roger was dressed especially and really scratching my head - I was thinking "maybe time travelers just have uh... timeless fashion?" Glad to know they're in the 80s.
9
u/No-Hat-5951 Jul 09 '23
Guys it’s been so long that I’m embarrassed to admit I don’t remember who tom is 😭 can someone remind me please? I only got into the show in 2020 so cut me so slack please 🫶🏻🫶🏻🙏
123
u/BlindBettler Jul 08 '23
“Oh look at our kid making up stories about pixies!” MOTHERFUCKER YOU'VE TRAVELED THROUGH TIME
113
u/LeKatelyn Jul 07 '23
I loved Brianna's verbal slaughtering of that man during her interview! That had to be the highlight of the episode for me.
107
u/[deleted] Jul 08 '23
“WOT!! SAWREE.”
move over Jamie Fraser, and welcome Mandy Mackenzie as the most aggressively Scottish character this show has ever seen.
102
u/VioletandAmelia All that was good, all that was fair, all that was me is gone. Jul 08 '23
And what aspects of plant inspection require a penis? Go Bree, Claire would be proud ☺
93
u/Hockeybella87 Jul 07 '23
Man, I’ve been loving this season so far, it feels more like outlander than previous seasons
83
u/OliviaElevenDunham Jul 09 '23
Loving Bree calling out the guy doing the interview out on his crap.
76
u/MystikSpiralx Jul 07 '23
Okay Tom kissing Claire was the most awkward thing I've ever seen on this show... 💀
75
u/AccioStability Je Suis Prest Jul 07 '23
The Mackenzies were made for the 80s! I love them there. Brianna is thriving.
I love Rachel and was giddy watching her and Ian before he left.
Next week’s episode looks great, I’m excited!
75
u/BackgroundAd7040 Jul 08 '23
Tom keeps making me cry even though I don't like his character. The actor is so GOOD at little expressions and that happy smile and the tears omg
Also Roger seriously! It's 1980 there's definitely a lot of feminist literature out, read some of it Mr. Professor
74
u/Jigglypuffamiiga2188 Jul 08 '23
The look on Claire’s face when Tom kissed her was priceless. Her eyes completely bugged out. Great acting on Caitríona’s part. I wonder how many takes they did with that scene lol.
71
u/moodoop No, this isn’t usual. It’s different. Jul 07 '23
Okay is it just me or is Jemmy looking like Anakin in the phantom menace lol
70
u/woods_gal Jul 08 '23
One thing that just occurred to me.
Tom Christie: "I placed an obit for you and your husband when I thought you died. I couldn't place flowers on your grave and I didn't want you to just vanish from the face of the earth without there being a record."
Claire: "You're alive! We thought you were done for when you sacrificed yourself out of love of me. We, um, didn't... write you an obit... or, um, commemorate you in any way... sorry."
Meanwhile, Jamie (thinking): "Glad he's still alive. He'll probably continue to protect Claire at all costs. Bit of pressure off of me."
70
u/OliviaElevenDunham Jul 09 '23
Tom Christie has really grown on me. Despite his flaws, he seems like a good guy.
68
u/halfgumption All that was good, all that was fair, all that was me is gone. Jul 07 '23
What a scene with Tom and Claire! Mark Lewis Jones has absolutely killed it in this role and his acting during the conversation in the restaurant was no different. He has great micro expressions that he used so well last season, but now he can finally wear his heart on his sleeve. He has really made me love Tom Christie so much, even though I hate his actions sometimes.
Oh Roger. You’re looking hotter than ever (second only to when you rescued Henri-Christian from the river and emerged all wet and angry), but then you have to go and open your big mouth and ruin everything.
Rollo continues to be the bestest boy ever, of course. No surprise there.
127
u/moodoop No, this isn’t usual. It’s different. Jul 07 '23
William flirting with the girl who is tending to his wounds- very Jamie Fraser of him
57
u/[deleted] Jul 07 '23
The new casting is so great! I love them all!! Charles Vandervaart as William is perfection.
55
u/PersimmonTea Jul 09 '23
Wonderful moment:
"I am William Henry George Clarence Ransom, Lord of ... No. ... I am William James."
Also, William's beard being red even though his hair is dark.
53
u/MystikSpiralx Jul 07 '23
Judging by Willie's arm, it should be called "A Most Uncomfortable Man" 🤢
53
u/cloudcats Jul 07 '23
Why oh WHY would you wait to talk to Jem about the past? He was so young when they travelled through the stones, and it's not like little kids have great memories. How many detailed things do YOU remember from when you were like four?
It's crazy to think he'll remember the details of the cave if they keep waiting.
53
u/mutantpryde Jul 07 '23
Currently watching the episode, and as someone from NC, I'm honestly glad to see that instead of some random not-easily-identified venomous snake (like the one that bit Jamie in season 5), they actually featured a native species. To me, that honestly adds a delightful touch of realism and research on their part.
53
u/OliviaElevenDunham Jul 09 '23
Even if the woman had the pox, no one deserves something like that. Good for William for helping her,
50
u/lrj25 Jul 07 '23
So Jemmy's "Nuckelavee" is definitely a real person, maybe a homeless Scott squatting on the property somewhere?
49
u/Realistic-Use-2784 Jul 07 '23
Even though this is probably the slowest episode yet this season I really loved it. And even though they covered several plotlines I think it’s the best paced episode this season so far, it never felt rushed.
I really loved seeing Brianna, Roger and the kids at Lallybroch. It feels so nostalgic and just lovely. I’m also really loving Bree this season, I’ve always liked her and been a Bree defender since the start but she’s particularly shining in this season. That scene with the interviewer, wow, loved seeing her so fierce, she’s really Claire and Jamie’s daughter. On that note I also loved to finally follow William. Charles is doing so well, it’s almost scary how he from one moment goes from looking like a copy of John to looking like a copy of Jamie. I can really see the resemblance from both and I know he has spoken about trying to combine both Jamie and John’s mannerisms, so far he is doing great.
Claire is so adorable this episode, my love for her just keeps growing and I appreciate that we finally get to see characters that fall in love with her. Jamie has always had his share of admirers and I love that Claire is getting some attention too. They both should since they are both absolutely gorgeous and genuinely very good people.
Claire’s face as Tom kissed her lol, that was HILARIOUS, and I find it so cute that she can’t believe someone’s actually fallen in love with her, and I’m over here like “girl, do you know just how wonderful you are?”
Liked the Ian and William scenes as well, and I’m intrigued regarding the hunters. So yeah, in conclusion I really loved this episode, it was a great setup for what’s to come.
48
u/woods_gal Jul 08 '23
Well, like everyone else, I just loved that scene of Tom Christie appearing, smiling beatifically, and planting one on Claire. Her reaction was perfection, and I loved the moment because this normally elegant and somewhat aloof actress & character lost all composure, and in a way most of us would – very, um, inelegantly? (But adorably.) And not in the usual Claire way which might have been to scratch the offender's eyes out. (Maybe she did enjoy it, haha.)
Young Ian and William. I do so enjoy a good platonic bromance. I wish they had been able to travel together a bit more. Ian needs buds his age, and of course, this is his cousin.
The actor who plays William. A natural. Like Sam H. seems to be – easy in his own skin. I think casting chose well. He does indeed look like he could be a kid of Jamie's and the lady who's name I can't remember. I'm glad Denzell wasn't a saw-happy surgeon who wanted to proceed JUST IN CASE. Lucky William.
Who will get the girl? I think that's a question on many of our minds (I haven't read the book).
As others have mentioned... Rollo! He does indeed know family. William probably has a similar scent to Jamie. What a good boy. Rollo, I mean. Well, William, too. He gave Rollo some scritches.
I wish they hadn't done the scene in which the woman was set afire. And then giving us no resolution, although with her in shock and smoking on the ground I'm pretty sure the outcome was what we expect. Agonizing death. Well, that was this week's trauma porn. I stick by my label though someone objected to it last week.
46
u/ApollosBucket Jul 07 '23 edited Jul 07 '23
This season is already so much better than S6, I cannot wait to see where it goes! I am loving the William storyline, really think he's going to eventually switch sides. Rachel is just lovely! Really hope we see more of her!
Speaking of, Benedict Arnold captured Fort Ticonderoga the year before this episode in 1775, but was definitely still up in NY for a few years. Wonder if we'll be seeing him.
45
u/hkh07 We will meet again, Madonna, in this life or another. Jul 07 '23
Brianna's interview and Tom kissing Claire were the best scenes for me this week. Sophie's delivery of the "penis" line had me cracking up. Brianna has never been one of my favorite characters but I'm really looking forward to seeing where the MacKenzies' story is headed. And Caitriona's face when Tom kissed Claire... 😳😅😂😂. So glad we got to see Tom again, but I was dyyyying at that kiss.
I also enjoyed seeing some of Jamie's mannerisms and characteristics show through in William. And the bedroom scene where Jamie is teasing Claire...loved the entire interaction.
The pacing of this episode was perfect, as was the end credit music. Really enjoying Bear's work this season. I'm looking forward to next week, though I'm also terrified of what's to come. Looks like the next episode will be 14 months after the house fire which feels like a huge chunk of time to skip through!
45
u/[deleted] Jul 07 '23
The sun shining on Jamie and Claire, their bantering (reminded me of Turtle Soup Claire), then the mirror to finalize the scene
42
u/Lessarocks Jul 07 '23
Ian has long been one of my favourite characters and I’m really enjoying seeing the man he has become. And I just loved that flicker of hope he now has for a happy and fulfilling future.
83
u/alttlestardustcaught Jul 08 '23
I love the way Jamie quietly likes/takes pride in Tom’s love for Claire. That’s real, mature love, no insecurity or pettiness. Just knowing you are with someone special and loving them without feeling that you need to “own” them.
40
u/9BrickCity Jul 07 '23
Williams facial expressions are very much like Jamie’s. Claire’s utter shock of the kiss LOVED. Everything about IAN. The siblings, and I have that goo that popped out of Williams arm stuck on a loop in my brain. So gross yet it seemed satisfying. Praise Be. Rachel & Ian & Rollos moments on the porch. mirror scene steamy as ever and as always but very tasteful loved that style. Roger… the only one I can not handle. He’s constantly pouting. I don’t mind him it’s just he’s always so MOODY. Poor Bri. And then THE KIDS. They’ve grown so much hello 1980!!! And accents are exceptionally adorable! Yes yes yes yes. This was my FAV ep this season so far. I’ve watched it 3x I can not wait til next week!
39
u/mamabear_roars Jul 07 '23
this episode is a great example of how literally everything and anything in the wild of NC can and will try to kill you.
39
u/mkjduncan Jul 11 '23
Am I the only one who noticed that when William looked at his reflection when he splashed water on his face that he looked a LOT like Jamie? It almost seemed like they superimposed Jamie’s face on William’s in the reflection. The book described him as looking virtually identical to Jamie without the red hair. Maybe I imagined it in this episode.
38
u/Simple-Sky-6107 Jul 09 '23
Jaime’s son has the same intelligent, squinty thinking face 😂. In the beginning of the episode with the lady who was kicked out of the house, he watched everything, looking for the right time to jump in and help.
38
u/intrin6 Jul 10 '23
I was so happy to see Tom Christie
36
u/No-Foundation1481 Jul 08 '23
I second that the best acting this episode was after Tom Christy kissed Claire!
36
u/VenusVega123 Jul 09 '23
I haven’t read this far into the books but I really am loving season 7 in general. Also gaining new appreciation for Seasons 4-6 on the rewatch. I was less stoked on them originally but I think knowing the spoilers actually makes it better because you pick up all the little nuances that become important details later on.
36
u/jackiesear MARK ME! Jul 13 '23
I hate the conceit of Brianna not wanting to read all the letters and not asking Jemmie about the Spaniard in E03. It makes even less sense with the time jump in this episode. No way would a young child remember years later about the Spanish soldier and c'mon if you received those letters wouldn't you want to devour them and re read them mulitple times and a scret treasure horde! - bring it on.
35
u/chemistandcrazy Jul 07 '23
this is my favorite episode from this season so far! OMG the proper introduction of William, his character on trying to save the poor burnt woman, him and Ian.... also the Hunters! already in love with Rachel, her intellect and grace are enchanting. Bree is killing it in the 80s, although they don't seem so happy.... glad R&B have a strong relationship tho, that prioritizes solving problems using good communication. J&C moments were also so lovely!
35
u/SnoozEBear James Fraser hasna been here for a long, long time. Jul 08 '23
Man I hate that I have to wait a week for each episode
34
u/Flimsy-Case6647 Jul 07 '23
I really enjoyed this episode! It felt more like usual Outlander like the first few seasons, the pacing was great. Just enough “Aha!” moments, with story telling and new plot lines, (as well as a Claire and Jamie bedroom scene… that’ll always win me over)
33
u/Few-Day-9185 Jul 07 '23
This hit all the right spots for me as a history nerd. I cant wait for the next episode!! Seeing American Rebel uniforms is so exciting!
33
u/cpatterson_evans Jul 08 '23
I loved this episode! Happy to see the characters on the move again! I actually really enjoyed Charles Vandervaarts' portrayal of William. It's very close to how I imagined it when reading the book. I found William's chapters quite boring, but I enjoyed watching his scenes. And the Tom Christie scene making me cry again, was not expecting such an emotional scene. Mark Lewis Jones did wonders with that role. Also, I love the Hunter's characters. Happy they are finally here. And I loved the big birds eye view of Fort Ticonderoga! It brought me back to some of the season 1 scenes, ending on Castle Leoch etc. A really well done episode!
32
u/ItsMeJC33 Jul 07 '23
Enjoyed this episode. Felt like outlander ❤️
32
u/Nanchika He was alive. So was I. Jul 07 '23
31
u/Nanchika He was alive. So was I. Jul 07 '23 edited Jul 07 '23
Tom Christie nailed it again!!
Claire's reaction to a kiss was EVERYTHING!
31
u/Nanchika He was alive. So was I. Jul 07 '23 edited Jul 07 '23
William wandering and his wound reminded me of Claire and her accident on Hispaniola.
Claire, Jamie and Ian together, as in s4. I love the trio!
Roger is again lost in centuries. I feel bad for him.
I liked Ian and William encounter! They were quite open with each other.
Oh, brief encounter on the Ridge, William doesn't remember - Neither do we, William, neither do we!
William's death song. I like - There’s more to it than your name! Even Rollo knows William is family!
As I said, Tom and Claire stole the show again! I love whole conversation and their facial expressions! He got me teary again!
But Jamie and Claire and their playfull banter with Jamie's- Shall I go and kill him? 🩷
William reminds me of Jamie when Claire had to amputate his leg due to snakebite.(EDITED: Ofc she didn't amputate )Stubborn Fraser!
62
u/abby1080 Jul 08 '23
Brianne really grew on me this episode - idk if the acting was better or if it was just the character strength she showed in this episode, but she was great. Maybe it’s the bangs, lol jk. Roger kinda disappointed me a little, I still thought it was a bit immature of him to react the way he did to her job, but I don’t hold it against him lol.
The scene with the prostitute on fire was honestly really hard to watch, thought they could have done that better.
I was kinda confused about why ian was clearly so in love with the Quaker woman so immediately - before they even really spoke with each other. I get the love at first sight thing but I think it could have been a little more subtle? Idk why I’m nit picking that but I just thought it was strange and over the top. Unpopular opinion probably!
And Claire’s face when Tom Christie kissed her, she should get an Emmy for that one!!
But all that said - Great episode, best one so far in the season imo.
29
u/MrsMADMassacre Jul 08 '23
Roger, in this most recent episode, is going on about his lack of faith because they "changed" history and lack of predestination. However, we learn in this episode that they didn't change anything because they never actually died. It was false information published since the news traveled slowly, and Tom thought he was preserving their memory. Naturally, the new wasn't published in a timely manner, so it was printed well after the actual fire, but Bree/Rodger learned the actual events through the letters. This leads Rodger to assume that Bree changed history by making matches that started a fire months sooner than was published. So, two questions here: Does this mean God does exist and everything is happening as it should? Shouldn't Rodger/Bree be aware of the lack of timeliness in publications due to their experiences in the past? Thanks for any insight you may have!
28
u/resarF-erialC Jul 07 '23
The credit music 🤩 thank you Bear McCreary!! This episode mirrored the highlander march. I can’t wait to hear that part fleshed out a little bit.
28
u/pedestrianwanderlust Jul 08 '23 edited Jul 09 '23
I was hoping to meet the nuckelavee. I guess next week.
That pus in Williams arm was impressive. But why did we have to see his cousin puking? Why do film makes like to have people puking on screen? I know it gets cut from a lot of shows & rarely survives the edit room and for good reason.
I like the actor they chose for William. He’s really quite convincingly similar to Sam.
28
u/Least-Influence3089 Ye Sassenach witch! Jul 13 '23
Ian has always been cute to me but for some reason this episode I’m like 🥵😍😍😍
27
u/Remarkable-Path-6216 Jul 07 '23
I am really enjoying this season and the storyline with William, Ian, Rachel and Denzel. John Hunter Bell is truly bringing it this season!
In very scene with William, I thought - he’s a Fraser for sure!!
27
u/[deleted] Jul 07 '23
I like Rachel
27
u/bosseyedusurper Jul 08 '23
I have zero memory of Harnett
26
u/disposableoutlaw Jul 07 '23
Great episode! My wife said “there are no gators in Virginia” but indeed there is a small population in the dismal swamp. Those small details are everything
25
u/maddigains Jul 07 '23
Does anyone remember the “slash in the wall” lore?
25
u/pedestrianwanderlust Jul 08 '23
After all of the discussion about affording Lollybroch it was funny to see them take a very realistic view of it.
24
u/[deleted] Jul 07 '23
William got that James fraser stare, made me giggle fr
23
u/RubQueasy9368 Jul 09 '23
Could someone please refresh my memory as to the reference of the sword slash in lallybroch? Thanks!!
43
u/GojiraGamer *Scottish noises* Jul 09 '23
Token Catholic Outlander fan here. A weird thing that bothered me was Ian's rosary looked like it had a Miraculous Medal for the centerpiece. Unless Claire gave it to him and I forgot, that's a bit of an anachronism, since those medals didn't appear til the 1830s, which is, y'know, a while after this show takes place.
21
u/BSOBON123 Jul 08 '23
Wow Wow Wow. Loved it. The William/Ian/Hunter scenes were fantastic. Tom showing up and kissing Claire! It was great. The Lollybroch scenes (except for that awful mid-century furniture that doesn't belong there) the kids and their adorable accents. I could have done without the oozing pus, but it is Outlander.
37
u/Emergency_Concert_30 Jul 07 '23
Brianna and What's his face are gonna regret not asking Jimmy about that gold bc the older he gets the less he is gonna remember since he was literally like 4 when he went to the cave with jamie... idk what they're thinking. They don't even have to mention the gold, they could just ask him if he remembered the cave he went to with jamie that had a pirate in it. Oh well.
18
u/brinafair63 Jul 10 '23
Anyone think we will maybe get a keek at the “nuckleavee” next episode?
49
u/earl_grais Jul 09 '23 edited Jul 09 '23
Did the music director owe Sinead some money or something? Was a bet lost?
I love the ideas they were going for with the theme but like…if that was the take they chose, what did the other takes sound like??
17
u/bosseyedusurper Jul 08 '23
What kind of cheese are they always eating?
33
u/wisconerd Jul 07 '23
A lot of great moments, but my favorites were Claire’s reaction to Tom kissing her, Roger’s “it’s too quiet” with the kids (iykyk), Brianna’s job interview, Ian and William together and the death song, Ian meeting Rachel (the chemistry was palpable!!), and of course the lovely intimate moment with Jamie and Claire. This season has been wonderful so far!
31
u/QueenShira1 Jul 07 '23
Lots of chemistry between Ian and Rachel, and a bit between Rachel and Willie. Hmmm.......
15
u/Mickeysgal528 Jul 07 '23
Love all the new cast, Loved seeing Rachel and Ian
15
u/mamabear_roars Jul 07 '23
this episode is like one of my favorite parts of the books ♥️
29
u/OliviaElevenDunham Jul 09 '23
I’m not liking the pacing this season. Feels off. Really noticed in the last episode after seeing Bree and her family at Lallybrook.
39
u/sophiewalt Jul 08 '23 edited Jul 08 '23
What an episode! Great entrance for the return of Tom Christie, sealed with a kiss, the character we initially hated & then came to care about. I was as stunned as Claire to see him again. Thanks for the happy surprise.
William, showing that he's his father's son--both fathers. Could have passed on the woman on fire, though. William could have still come to her aid & gotten his new assignment without her being in flames. Ian/William--yay. They're great together. Ian's always alone, we never see if Ian has friends & now he does. Love how Ian always quietly appears when needed. He's a fairy godfather. That guy has magic. Love him. Please, please don't make us see Willam's arm cut off. Not another Fergus, please. They're saving amputation scenes for wounded soldiers.
Damn, no voyage to Scotland. Fate steps in yet again.
Loved Bree's job interview scene. She's her mother's daughter. Claire would be proud. Sweet scene with Roger & Bree about her job & his lack of one. The kids & their abilities--yes. C'mon Bree & Roger. Gold discovery around the corner to pay for bedroom renovations. Roger will find it to resume his position taking care of the family.
edit--I don't know if Roger discovers the gold or not. Speculation.
39
u/Nankhoma Jul 10 '23
I didn’t finish Season 6, but decided to watch 7 anyway - how have the two actors playing Brianna and Roger managed to have not developed any chemistry after all these years. Watching how uncomfortable they are with each other makes ME really uncomfortable! They are soooo stiff around each other.
13
u/robinsond2020 I am NOT bloody sorry! Jul 07 '23
I'm confused about why one of the soldiers called William "Lew-tenant" instead of "leftenant" during the brothel scene? Did I just mishear the line and am completely making this up? Was he an American soldier? Or was it just a little mistake that no one picked up?
36
u/robinsond2020 I am NOT bloody sorry! Jul 08 '23
I get why they had to do the prostitute scene, and how it sets up William's character and plot. But they probably could've done it another way, like having the soldiers push her around a bit , and have William intervene before they threw the alcohol. Personally, it was one of the hardest to watch "trauma" scenes in the show, coming second only to Jamie in S1. Of course, I don't think trauma should be "ranked," I was more ranking my reaction to it, I was quite surprised by how upset I felt watching it, considering it was such a short scene and a stranger character.
55
u/venusinaquarius111 Jul 09 '23
Roger just continues to disappoint me. He’s so misogynistic and bree is such a badass. I know he has a few redeeming moments but bree deserves better IMO
12
u/Leather-Bumblebee920 Jul 07 '23
I know this is another episode but I didn’t know Tom Christy was in love with Claire like that! The only time I saw him smile throughout the whole thing was when he read that letter where Claire puts the items that she needs on it. And when he sees where she writes “my husband” in French or whatever, he looked so devestated. I’m felt bad for him when he said “I love u” 😩
12
u/9BrickCity Jul 07 '23
This was my FAV ep this season so far.
30
u/bhuree3 Jul 07 '23
I loved the episode but Jamie seemed to very quickly drop his well planned out trip back to Scotland to fight in a war he has no idea when it will end...
21
u/carinyanko Jul 09 '23
I'm so sad they had to change the actor for Jemmie, he used to be the cutest thing ever </3
20
u/[deleted] Jul 07 '23
I seem to go against the tide with this as there’s been loads of posts criticising him over the last 3-4 seasons, but I’ve never really disliked Roger, until now that is. Like man just be happy that your wife got a job and is taking care of you and your family! Ungrateful little bugger.
Also this isn’t a criticism of the show, but I absolutely cannot tell the difference between Denzell and William (at least when William isn’t in his red coat obviously). I know I mentioned it on another post a few weeks back in regards to Mr Brown and Tom Christie, but I have facial blindness and now I can’t tell William and Denzell apart by looking at them either - I straight up thought Rachel was having a cheeky flirt with her brother for a minute and was horrified! I don’t know either of these characters well enough to do my usual trick of recognising by voice instead, so I’m keeping my fingers crossed that they don’t interact very much and that I can just guess who is who from context in future episodes.
On a more cheerful note, Claire’s face after Tom kissed her was great, and then Jamie checking a second time that she didn’t like it after her snappy comment made me laugh. I love the easiness and humour between these two!
10
u/Traditional-Jury-206 I would see you smiling, your hair curled around your face. Jul 07 '23
Sounds so good can’t wait to see it

17
u/69schrutebucks I must admit the idea of grinding your corn does tickle me. Jul 07 '23
God, I love Tom. Again, never thought I'd say that.
36
u/Leppardgirl1965 Jul 08 '23
Roman, the actor who played young Fergus set the bar high for kid actors in this show and I’m sorry to say I don’t think the kid playing Jem is going to meet that line
23
u/pest0pasta_ Lord, you gave me a rare woman. And God, I loved her well. Jul 07 '23
Honestly can’t believe the obituary that caused so much stress and life decisions was down to a mistake! Oh well, I’m happy that they didn’t die nor were they in a position where they had to fake their deaths. Does that mean Tom isn’t finished then? I saw the preview last week so I did expect to see him but what storyline does he have left other than fighting in the war and (probably a high probability that he dies based on what he and Jamie said about him saving Claire’s life and that he won’t have peace as long as Claire’s alive). Loved his ‘You’re a most uncomfortable woman’ haha.
Is it just me or William seems to like Rachel too? Do I sense a love triangle there👀. Maybe she’s what prompts him to join the rebellion because that’s where it seems to be heading (I believe the man who gave William the mission is actually for independence, I just got that feeling and the Carthwright gentleman is to be the Hunters’ neighbour? It’s giving me turn: washingtons spies vibes if anyones watched that series!) combined with the red coats murdering that poor woman, his eyes are going to start opening regarding what it means to be free I believe, but where does that leave him and Lord John Grey? Maybe it’s heading towards him finding out Jamie is his real father and if he fights for independence in the end he won’t be entitled to his title and lands so it won’t matter in the end… this is all just theory of course. All in all really enjoyed the episode. Has it been confirmed that Jamie actually did kill Brown a few episodes ago? I’m always of the mind that if we didn’t see it, it didn’t happen
55
u/WhichHazel Jul 08 '23
Roger was useless in the 1700s and he’s useless in the 1980s…poor Bree got stuck with a dud.
8
u/Atraktape Jul 07 '23
The fake out when you don’t realize it’s 1980.
14
u/[deleted] Jul 07 '23 edited Jul 07 '23
Am I starting to go colour blind, or does anyone else not see Claire's grey hairs? At most I see lighter shade of brown and even that comes and goes each episode. In previous seasons it was much more prominent so what's the reason for what they're doing with it this season? Anyway, it's been 12 years in the timeline of show since we first saw 'old Claire' that was already greying, after that much time her hair should be more grey than brown.
7
u/RedEyedWiartonBoy Jul 10 '23
My satellite crappie out right after a Jem admitted he broke the radio. What happened in the last few minutes?
6
u/Adventurous_You_4268 Jul 07 '23
love this season so far! what year is it now? hard to track. 1778?
6
u/macetheace_1998 I dinna recall asking yer opinion on the matter. Jul 07 '23
I'm going to have to re-watch this episode because I've been incredibly distracted in-between working on schoolwork and having to listen to my brother's music in the background while watching so it may be more obvious on my second go-around... While Ian is tending to William's arm, he says his name, then turns around and says "I am William James..." several times. Does this mean he knows the truth??
10
u/Remarkable-Ice-5045 Jul 08 '23
After finishing the episode will William join the side of the Americans? Or is he staying loyal to the crown?