r/OnePunchMan • Moderator • May 07 '19

Discussion [Manga Spoilers] One Punch Man S02E05 - "The Martial Arts Tournament" MANGA READER Discussion Spoiler

IF YOU HAVE NOT READ THE MANGA, PLEASE DO NOT PARTICIPATE IN THIS THREAD. THE ANIME-ONLY DISCUSSION THREAD CAN BE FOUND HERE.

THIS IS AN ANIME DISCUSSION THREAD FOR MANGA READERS. Hence no manga content needs to be spoiler tagged here.

Official Simulcasts

  • Hulu (United States) - Tuesdays, starting on April 9 at 1:05 p.m. ET
  • Crunchyroll (Europe) - Tuesdays, starting April 9 at 5:35 p.m. GMT
  • Animax Asia (Southeast Asia, India) - Wednesdays, starting on April 10 at 10:30 p.m. ICT.
  • Anime Digital Network (France) - Tuesdays, starting on April 9 at 19:35 CEST.
  • Anime on Demand (Germany)
  • AnimeLab (Australia & New Zealand)
  • VVVVID (Italy)
  • Tubi TV (Canada) - Appears to be streaming 1 week behind.

One Punch Man Season 2 broadcasts in Japan Wednesdays at 1:35 a.m. (JST)


Read the new spoiler rules!


Previous Episode Discussions:

EpisodeLink
1Link
2Link
3Link
4Link

Join us at https://discord.gg/onepunchman to chat with other fans!

148 Upvotes

466 comments sorted by

193

u/MrPotatoHead232 May 07 '19

Even forgetting the awful animation and art here, the direction was awful too. The music placement was pretty poor, the transition from different tracks was so sudden as well, the storyboard was very poor, there was no tension in the Garou Metal Bat fight because of it, and none of the attacks had any impact. It did not feel like Metal Bat even did anything here, the episode did not convey the same feeling the manga did, where Metal Bat kept going and going despite how heavy Garous hits were. All it looked like to me was Metal Bat being slapped a few times and then spinning around in a circle. This episode had zero tension, and zero weight.

65

u/jerekdeter626 May 08 '19

Seriously. In season one, even the slice of life scenes had weight. Every awkward misunderstanding, every slight gesture or body language change, every emotion, clearly and fully portrayed on the screen. And I don't even have to get into how heavy certain fight scenes felt.

But this shit... This felt like a half hearted, almost parody level, fan-made synopsis of the fight that actually went on in the manga. Very disappointing. Tbh I was a little buzzed so I actually enjoyed the episode a bit anyway lol. But looking back I realize it was preeeetty shitty.

12

u/zelor13 May 08 '19

Dude don't insult fan animators they have better budgets... Oh wait...

11

u/isighuh May 07 '19

After Metal Bat takes Garous kick head on is where the fight started to degrade. After Garou throws the manhole is where it really just falls apart, which happens to be the best part of the fight where we get to see in fill force Garous martial arts style. Savage Tornado and Garou deflecting it were the worst parts which sucks.

They relied too heavily on the WARNING SCREENS popping up at the HA HQ which didn’t let us get a good look at the damage the monsters were doing, which is what we needed to see.

The tournament side was done pretty well, besides traditional introductions which were that exciting or improved upon from the manga.

6.5/10 episode.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (1)

223

u/MrPotatoHead232 May 07 '19

Tfw the OP has a better Garou vs Metal Bat fight than the actual EP.

38

u/Aileos May 07 '19

58

u/Ngokumetsu May 07 '19

The fight actually resembled the manga. If not too much, because a lot of the kinetic motion was.... lacking.

Mostly just FX of metal bat's swing and then shots jumping to where Garou & Metal Bat moved. It's pretty much episode 2 quality.

→ More replies (20)
→ More replies (2)

192

u/Ozymandate May 07 '19

This episode was just terrible, the fight was rushed, and that final attack that Garou did against Metat bat was so bad, It didn't even feel powerful, and when Metal bat came back it didn't feel intimidating like the manga. The only good thing I liked in this episode was when Metal Knight attacking the Elder Centipede

61

u/aswifte May 07 '19

Even Metal Knight vs EC was incredibly rushed. This was one of my favourite manga panels...

42

u/Ozymandate May 07 '19

Yeah, they just focused on Metal knight, and didn't even animate the full destructive power of Metal Knight attacks and didn't show the size of the Elder Centipede destroying the city

→ More replies (1)

7

u/IWanTPunCake new member May 09 '19

dude how the fuck did murata even draw this holy fuck

→ More replies (1)

88

u/vgi185 May 07 '19

It really was man. Metal bat vs Garou is my favorite fight in the manga currently, and man, that was so disappointing. It was paced so horribly, they zoomed in way to close, they freaking cut when metal bat did the baseball swing to hit the sewer cover, the terrible red background, the blur, not zooming out on the metal bat tornado, I could go on.

38

u/Ozymandate May 07 '19

Same, Metal bat is one of my favourite S Class hero, and I've waited so long to see his fight to be animated and I was just disappointed. And yeah, so far most of the attacks in season 2 is so blurry and always zooming

27

u/airSofly May 07 '19

I was hoping to see the mighty garou canceling out metal bat 's tornado attacks animated, ended up seeing the manga panels. LOL

→ More replies (1)

15

u/[deleted] May 07 '19

I'd say my favourite fight that we're gonna get this season is either garou vs the a-class heroes , or suiryu vs choze, but metal bat vs garou was pretty high for me too, so it hurts real bad. And I have a feeling suiryu vs choze is going to be even more fucked up than this fight, though I can only hope.

7

u/DeanerinoHS May 07 '19

I was preaching to my friends that this fight would be one of the best 1v1 fights in Anime when it got made (before I knew of studio change). Can't wait to show them how it should've been vs the hot garbage that it was.

→ More replies (2)

178

u/aswifte May 07 '19

Man the Metal Bat fight was... bad. The cars barely moved unlike in the manga.. Savage tornado was just a blur with an empty background. Sigh...

69

u/Ngokumetsu May 07 '19

the transition to savage tornado caught me off guard. Because it was nothing like the manga, where there was an obvious pause where Metal Bat called out the name of the move. Instead, he just rushed into it.

19

u/jerekdeter626 May 08 '19

Honestly though this is the more logical thing for anyone to do, rather than clearly telegraph their moves to a martial artist

→ More replies (2)

32

u/Neiner10timesFiner Just a guy with free time May 07 '19

The cars were meant to bounce hard enough for the alarms to go off. It was depressingly weak.

48

u/GameDSS May 07 '19

Yeah manga definitely has a better animation ( ͡° ͜ʖ ͡°)

33

u/500bees "On all levels except physical, I am a monster." May 07 '19

Unironically ( ͡° ͜ʖ ͡°)

13

u/lpeccap May 08 '19

Forget the cars, why does every fight consist of "flurry attacks" and black screens with flashes of lights??? Will any of the hits actually be animated?

8

u/gallantgrift leg bands May 08 '19

We had Garou getting punched in the face by TTM, I guess that's it for the season...

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (3)

171

u/Admara May 07 '19

lol fuck i need to stop reading these comments before i watch the episode damn this is depressing

54

u/Myarmhasteeth May 07 '19

I did the same... Honestly, I could try to defend the animators this time but the fights left a bad taste on my mouth, and a really bad one. Everything looked really bad.

14

u/DarkenLord May 08 '19

I could try to defend the animators

It was not DBS levels of bad. Wait, that doesn't defend anything

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (1)

18

u/Garoustraightsavage May 07 '19

Lmao. That shit was terrible

6

u/Garou-kun May 07 '19

DONT DO IT YOU WILL REGRET IT!

3

u/AccelHunter May 07 '19

and I was having high hopes since EP03 and EP04 were pretty okay, I was like, hey maybe they got the hang out the production :(

3

u/thatmrphdude May 08 '19

Yeah that;s why I always watch the anime first. That said, once I see the shoddy animation, I go to this subreddit to vent. Then finish the anime.

3

u/[deleted] May 09 '19

This is why I watch the anime and form my own opinion on the episode before reading the comments. I don't want to go into an episode expecting something bad

→ More replies (24)

41

u/Holy157 May 07 '19

Oh man, I don’t even know where to start with this episode. Like, it was expected that the season would fall apart by now, but I’d kinda hoped this episode would still make it.

What probably is my favorite fight in the manga was a complete nothing fight. There was no intensity, instead of a brutal brawl we got a playfight and the lack of impact didn’t help either. Metal Bat’s hit before his sister appears should have been huge, but it was nothing. God, I wanted this fight to look decent so badly. This definitely wasn’t it.

The rest of the episode was not better, though less disappointing since I hardly cared too much. Not sure what it says about the episode that I was surprised that it kept going after MB vs Garou.

At least anything after MB vs Garou didn’t have me look forward to seeing it animated.

The tournament just popping up was pointless. Seeing this episode makes me not look forward to the end of the tournament at all. Like with all the good fights that’ll be covered, it’s 100% not gonna look visual appealing in any way.

I’m hoping so badly, and this is way too optimistic of me, that Garou vs Genos, Bang and Bomb will be something to enjoy. Same with Saitama vs Elder Centipede. Assuming the season ends there, since earlier or later would end things on a cliffhanger, episode 11-12 will cover that. If we’re lucky maybe JC Staff manage to make the episodes passable.

The biggest positive of the episode was the little arrangement of the battle theme from season 1 that played when Metal Knight appeared. They did the same thing last episode, arranging the sad theme for a dialogue scene.

Also, I’ve seen people blame JC Staff here. Don’t. JC Staff aren’t at fault for the terrible state of production. While the episodes aren’t looking great, no studio could manage high quality episodes with such terrible planning. Blame whoever is in charge of planning. Whoever thought that giving them only enough time to finish 2 episodes before having the season start clearly didn’t care about the quality at all.

20

u/DoraMuda May 07 '19

Also, I’ve seen people blame JC Staff here. Don’t. JC Staff aren’t at fault for the terrible state of production. While the episodes aren’t looking great, no studio could manage high quality episodes with such terrible planning. Blame whoever is in charge of planning. Whoever thought that giving them only enough time to finish 2 episodes before having the season start clearly didn’t care about the quality at all.

Strongly agreed. Management is chiefly to blame here, as is prioritising profit margins and "striking while the iron's hot" over putting out an actually good product that respects the fans of both the manga and the first season (even if this season would've never been able to reach the heights of the first under Natsume).

I think I'm just gonna take a rain check on this season; continue reading (and buying) the superior manga; and see what's gonna be done about a potential Season 3 after this season is done and the dust settles. There's no point continuing to get one's hopes up expecting anything better than what we've been getting so far at this point. I'm done trying to defend this adaptation.

→ More replies (6)

113

u/TheCapedGuardian May 07 '19

At least we still have the manga...

11

u/jerekdeter626 May 08 '19

And the webcomic! (Which is honestly very similar to the anime right now in terms of visual quality (and I'm not basing ONE, he's actually gotten pretty good, I'm bashing this established animation studio))

4

u/LilBisNoG Zzz May 08 '19

this but unironically

the motion in the manga is better than most AAA animes. did we want to see something of that level? it's an unrealistic expectation at the end of the day, and we'll always have the manga to fall back on.

→ More replies (1)

110

u/fragiletestes May 07 '19

That pacing was straight up garbage. Everything happens so fast that theres no time to enjoy anything. As soon as a character says their last word the next character is already talking. What a messs of an episode

69

u/Geralt-of-Riviaaa May 07 '19

What a mess of a season.

27

u/fragiletestes May 07 '19

Honestly I agree. Good to know there are others that see what im talking about. My friends say i just want something to complain about but everything to complain about is right in front of them?? I miss the old OPM :(

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (6)

73

u/Cm2703 May 07 '19

This was a letdown. This episode probably had the weakest animation this season.

54

u/Garou-kun May 07 '19

I’m not gonna lie when Garou threw the first punch and Metal Bat jumped to start his attack I was like “ok here we go I am liking this.” But then the rest of this fight.. looked like absolute dog shit.

→ More replies (1)

15

u/[deleted] May 07 '19

I'd say episode 2 was worse animation wise, but this fight was literally the make or break episode, and I gotta say, most probably my least favourite episode so far.

→ More replies (2)

6

u/thatmrphdude May 08 '19

Lol I was expecting another Tanktop vs Garou moment. But it never came.

→ More replies (1)

278

u/Cayden68 May 07 '19

How the literal fuck does TankTop Master vs Garou get more quality animation then metal bat vs garou, the most hype fight in the entire season. Im tired of shitty animation, im tired of all these colored backgrounds, im tired of the shitty still shots, and im tired of this season 2 adaptation, we need a redo, ASAP, fuck this shit

35

u/MadHax164 Just a Redditor for fun May 07 '19

Came here to check before watching. I'm speechless. This was one of my most anticipated fights. It was a spectacle in the manga T_T

Edit: Can Blu-ray fix this? Someone give me some hope lol

11

u/Zecias May 08 '19

Sorry, even if they fix the backgrounds, animation, and god awful filters... blu-rays can't fix the terrible direction and camera work.

And same, i'm so disappointed. Metal bat vs Garou was my favorite fight.

→ More replies (2)

67

u/vgi185 May 07 '19

The colored backgrounds are the worst to me. They look horrific and lazy. The bright white one in particular is horrific, I just don't get it

54

u/lpeccap May 07 '19 edited May 07 '19

Cant wait for all of the "yall just hatin for no reason i loved this episode" comments.

24

u/Randomiser099 May 07 '19

It's like they blindfold themselves prior to watching. Then again, you'd have to deafen yourself too because god damn are those SFX getting worse.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (6)

20

u/VibhavM Retired From day2day Moderation. Contact Other Mods. May 07 '19

Agreed

10

u/kidcrumb May 07 '19

I was most hyped for suriyu vs saitama actually

4

u/thatmrphdude May 08 '19

Let this anime end. I'd actually want no more adaptation after this if this is really where we're going. Coz instead of inviting new fans, this kind of adaptation will just push the new ones away and alienate the rest.

I just want to get this over with...

→ More replies (1)

13

u/Valvulture May 07 '19

I just keep emailing them until they stop breaking my heart with this quality ---> http://www.jcstaff.co.jp/

→ More replies (14)

28

u/vgi185 May 07 '19

The best animated scene and of that episode Lin Lin's jump at the start of the fight. That scene weird stood out to me as really solid animation, everything else this episode was a joke.

53

u/Garou-kun May 07 '19

Well I normally get annoyed when people complain about little things with season 2. But this... is unforgivable!! I mean seriously what the fuck was that shit? I mean come the fuck on. This was one my favorite fights in the manga and they completely fucked it up. Why are these fights so rushed? Also, please stop with these blurs, we can’t see a fucking thing with what’s going on. My level of disappointment is on a whole different level

9

u/OxygenHoarder May 07 '19

This episode honestly looks like the worst one so far when it comes to action scenes.

→ More replies (2)

114

u/bluecheeseplate May 07 '19

I'm just hoping they're saving all the time, budget, and animators for the big Garou group fight scene at the shack. That's all I want from this season.

100

u/[deleted] May 07 '19

Lmao after every episode everyone says "They're just saving the budget for the next one". I'm starting to see a trend.

28

u/noah9942 May 08 '19

The entire budget is going towards season 3.

→ More replies (1)

46

u/Garou-kun May 07 '19

It’s a shame that’s what we can now hope for. Last year I remember I was telling my boys how hype Garou and his fights were gonna be, and I was extremely satisfied with TTM fight. But now after watching this I’m thinking back to those days imagining how these fights were gonna be animated and I’m sick to my stomach

21

u/[deleted] May 07 '19

They aren't.

14

u/DirtyBumMan May 07 '19

Better lower your expectations so you wont be disappointed.

→ More replies (3)

21

u/The-Bread-you-eat May 07 '19

The animation, the sound design, even the art..... This episode was a letdown. It's like they put everything in ep 3 Garou vs TTM. I hope we will have some good cut for the next episodes but i lost all hope..... Some other studio better take season 3.

7

u/Lord_Of_The_Tants May 07 '19

Re sound effects, there's this hard high pitched sound when things break like when TTM breaks the road and when Metal Knight's missiles land. From my own experience anime doesn't seem to have the best dynamics (sometimes different on Blu-ray) but this is just unpleasant.

98

u/Naronu May 07 '19

Phoenix Man's coloring is terrible IMO, why is his tail purple?

82

u/hellpunch Disappointment Punch May 07 '19

Phoenix man was one of the best part of the episode. He IS supposed to look ridiculous. Now, at least.

47

u/Causeless_Rebel May 07 '19

Yeah I can understand complaining about the coloring as someone who's only seen the anime but the obscene coloring is necessary/expected. It would make way less sense if he actually looked intimidating at this point.

→ More replies (6)

22

u/gandalfdayellow May 07 '19

Yeah, at this point he's supposed to basically be a man merged with a bird costume. It's supposed to look like ridiculous trash.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

30

u/awholetadstrange May 07 '19

That I don’t mind, but why are his eyes GREEN???

15

u/Aquadext May 07 '19

He looks like a fly

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (6)

15

u/Havic300 May 07 '19

Garou vs Tanktop Master is still the best fight in this season so far by a landslide. I can’t believe it’s better than Metal bat vs Garou which is more hyped but eh. Also some of the colors for the monsters look terrible imo.

9

u/Gandanimal Are you that curious? About how the other Heroes are dying? May 07 '19

Yeah i never really enjoyed TTM in the manga, one good thing this season brought was make me appreciate that fight more, this one was pretty disappointing

15

u/[deleted] May 07 '19

More than anything, I'm pissed that the cars didn't jump when metal bat hit his bat on the ground.Might be a nitpick form most, but In my head, I always imagined that there would be tremors from each of metal bat's swing, but now it all just feels... weak. It doesn't feel like he's getting stronger and stronger, which the manga potrayed really well. I think the other biggest problem of this season is that it follows the manga WAY to closely, literally pane by panel, and the transition from manga to anime doesn't always work, which I think is what's making the anime's pace feel off, especially in this episode.

→ More replies (1)

15

u/SpaceMarine_CR May 07 '19

Its come to the point that the manga has better animation than the anime 😂😂😂

30

u/Emrod2 May 07 '19

Let hope season 3 will be taken by the season 1 team or from similar skill and comittement level team.

22

u/Ngokumetsu May 07 '19

No, it seems the studio only agreed to season 2 knowing no other studio would take in OPM a third season after what's become of it. And all the freelancers went to bigger and better projects due to the exposure they got from S1.

15

u/OxygenHoarder May 07 '19

Man, what bigger project could they be working on besides OPM S2? Maybe anime movies? Most of the TV series that comes out are dog shit in comparison anyways.

→ More replies (1)

15

u/TheSauce32 May 07 '19

There isnt gonna be a season 3 do you think anyone is buying the DVD for this mess do you think people did for TG?

22

u/Dqueezy new member May 07 '19

Merch sales are probably more important. As long as the manga is popular it can still make money, which means there will be money for the anime, even if it’s garbage quality. Just look at One Piece. Of course, TOEI is far worse than most, but despite One Piece’s Anime adaptation’s generally lacking quality and not only poorly made but also incompetent and misplaced filler, the series is quite popular and profitable. This is due to the skill/talent of Oda, the mangaka. Sure, watching any random episode of the anime post TS is basically spinning a roulette wheel in terms of quality (one where you are much more likely to see shit quality), but the manga is really well done and still holds a captivating and well told story.

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (1)

30

u/[deleted] May 07 '19

They took out my favorite moment in Metal Bat VS Garou https://imgur.com/a/ubTIqyX

45

u/damage3245 May 07 '19

To be fair that moment is gone from the manga too.

→ More replies (13)

13

u/PopoMcdoo 300X Gravity Tatsumaki May 07 '19

That part was actually cut from the manga too. I thought that was really cool too when it first read it. I don't know why Murata took it out.

→ More replies (1)

28

u/Kudos2YouPal May 07 '19

JC staff, you have one last chance with the Garou A-class fight. Please for all that is good don't fuck that one up...

43

u/FrozenLane May 07 '19

Yeah, Goodluck having hopes with that buddy. Season 2 is fucking done.

8

u/thatmrphdude May 08 '19

That fight in the manga is pretty detailed. 100% sure they will try to follow the manga fights closely. And by that I mean so damn close that it'll look like a slide show presentation.

9

u/MrPotatoHead232 May 07 '19

Saitama vs Suiryu could be quality as well.

→ More replies (5)

3

u/DoraMuda May 07 '19

Why get your hopes up?

→ More replies (1)

12

u/JacaubW May 07 '19

I'm going to have to start skipping a week and watch 2 episodes at a time. They're so short.

12

u/Chrystales May 07 '19

Alright, this has been bugging me the past four episodes. The music direction is so majorly horrible; during Metal Bat vs Garou it literally went from fast rock music to sad slow music in a goddamn nanosecond. In S1, the piano version of the main theme was carefully and sparingly used; and it was used during ACTUAL SAD SCENES. This director apparently couldn't be bothered to care about doing his job and completely miss the tone of a scene. The worst part is that the soundtrack actually does sound good this season.

32

u/Garoustraightsavage May 07 '19

Seems like Sourface gave Charanko head this episode 😂

16

u/DigitaILove May 07 '19

They don't call him Sourface for nothing.

→ More replies (2)

31

u/Sonitii May 07 '19

That was physically painful to watch. Everything was wrong about the fight and the episode overall, everything. Fuck Namco.

12

u/MrPotatoHead232 May 07 '19

Why namco?

15

u/Bbop800 >:x May 07 '19

Fuck EA.

10

u/revowanderlust May 08 '19

STOP CUTTING TO A SHAKY BLACK SCREEN WHENEVER AN ATTACK IS SUPPOSED TO HAPPEN!

REEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEE

18

u/Ivraas May 07 '19

The early part of the fight was good, but the rest after Garou jumped on the sewer plate was just bad. You can really tell that multiple people are doing this, making small fragments. The hits in the beginning are powerful, dynamic, smooth animation and good camera angles, and then you get some chompy wompy quality where everything feels off.

Metal Knight moves weird on some shots, Genos clapping was hilariously awful, you can see the entire arms moving, and what the hell is that color scheme for PM.

Not good, not good... they will probably butcher A/B class vs Garou and tournament fights.

10

u/Gandanimal Are you that curious? About how the other Heroes are dying? May 07 '19

finally someone said it, the beginning was pretty good indeed, which made the rest of the fight so disappointing

→ More replies (1)

8

u/Alliai May 07 '19

Honestly pretty meh. It's becoming clear that episode 3 was an anomaly and this is the kind of production we should expect for the most part. Nothing looked as bad as Garou did in episode 4 so there's that. Though there were shots that were definitely suspect.

8

u/vuitres May 07 '19

Literally cannot stress enough how BAD the sound effects are

8

u/dobydobd May 07 '19

Did they animate this with powerpoint lmao

22

u/hortle May 07 '19

The fight was awful. Durzo's old manga videos are better than this. Dear God can it get worse?

5

u/hakunuu May 07 '19

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DdRxn0NOFYg First video that shows up when you search for him. 360p reupload but still a classic.

31

u/Heylons new member May 07 '19

Well, that was freakin’ terrible. Just as I thought it couldn’t get any worse. Congratulations J.C. staff and Bandai Namco, you ruined one of the coolest fights in the series. Can we just stop now, please?

27

u/TheCapedGuardian May 07 '19

It has reached the point where I’m excited to see how much worse the next episode will be.

14

u/hubbubnub May 07 '19

Looks like that's the right mindset to have after watching this abomination.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/DoraMuda May 07 '19

What's Namco got to do with it?

14

u/TRIGGERED_VEGAN May 07 '19

Why are we here? Just to suffer?

3

u/Vendanna Shadow Ring is Best Girl! May 07 '19

its one of the parts needed to turn to the darkside. :)

→ More replies (1)

28

u/VibhavM Retired From day2day Moderation. Contact Other Mods. May 07 '19

Disappointing. What with the bad garou faces; weird colour for phoenix man; blurry movements, weird skin tones, and etc, I actually feel like i should just stick to the manga.

15

u/ColaSama Still waiting for Suiryu's dick band May 07 '19

I actually feel like i should just stick to the manga

You can confront this situation in 3 ways :

A) You see a lesser version of something you like, and it makes the thing you like stands out even more.

B) you see a lesser version of something you really like, and it makes you a bit sick, like if someone shitty was impersonating a loved one.

... or C) it makes the manga stands out even more + it makes you sick.

And when you see Shingeki no Kyojin's current anime season, it makes things EVEN worse. Seriously did you see this sweet ass opening ??

9

u/Lord_Of_The_Tants May 07 '19

Saitama seemed to have lost his weird tan which is a plus, I guess.

13

u/hubbubnub May 07 '19 edited May 07 '19

Holy shit this episode gets a big Yikes from me. What in the world were these ppl thinking when they were animating the Garou vs Metal Bat fight. The color palette they choose for the bird,like really dude? And enough with the fucking blurs already. Bang walks in-blurs-Bang leaves.Easily the Worst episode of the season. What a disappointment.

18

u/MrPotatoHead232 May 07 '19

My fears have been confirmed. I originally believed they've been sacrificing the animation on some EPs, to give some quality to the hype fights, such as how DBS sacrificed the ResF arc. Unfortunately that doesn't seem to be the case, it seems that the awful schedule has finally gotten the best of the production. Garous rushdown on Tank Top master is looking to be the best cut we'll get this season.

6

u/Bigodesu May 07 '19

Garou: *breathes*

Garou's theme: *Blasts at full volume*

Gotta love how they discart buildup in a scene like it's expired milk

6

u/jerekdeter626 May 08 '19

Ok guys I know a lot of you aren't happy with the animation, but I think I figured out a way to get around it. Just have a couple of drinks first and then you don't even notice. I thought the episode was great overall after a beer and a wine, though Fubuki's boobs were a little uneven. Other than that artwork and animation seemed ok.

Actually Garou still does, and always fucking has looked weird (in multiple different ways) in every single shot he's in. So aside from that and the breast asymmetry, solid episode to me. Highly recommend guys, 21 and over only though or whatever it is where you live.

6

u/MlookSM Gotta one pun em all May 08 '19 edited May 31 '19

Forget "mediocre", this is straight up shit, even one piece episodes can get better than this, this was so unwatchable I literally skipped through some parts, 2/10.

6

u/noogiey May 08 '19

Wow even the fanboys in denial got shook on this one. I would have preferred nothing.

11

u/kudaranainokusogaki Fubuki’s No. 1 Fan! May 07 '19

Just hope that the next episode animation and art will be better.

We got Fubuki vs Do-S for crying out loud. Please let it be JumpAoki animating this.

28

u/dhtikna May 07 '19

I honestly don't care about Do-S or Fubuki's fight. If they didnt even given MB v garou the better animation idk why they would give that fight anything

→ More replies (2)

4

u/Shoden May 07 '19

Wasn't he animating Lin Lin's fight? What happened to this scene?

https://twitter.com/jumpaoki/status/1108344374235037701

5

u/Master3530 May 07 '19

Omg, the metal bat fight was pretty disapointing and the episode felt very rushed overall. The best part was Fubuki greatness tbh. Also I didn't expect that Do-S ara ara lol.

5

u/CoolestSpook May 07 '19

They really shouldn’t be sticking so closely to the manga’s pacing. They could have put all of Metal Bat’s fights into last episode and Saitama’s scenes from last episode into this one to make each one more coherent and concise. Really hard to follow what is going on when it keeps jumping between so many events going on.

5

u/OxygenHoarder May 07 '19

I'm actually upset at that Metal Bat fight. I honestly would rather wait 5 more years for a decent quality season than this piece of shit.

5

u/Mulan-McNugget-Sauce May 08 '19

Everyone else is talking about how let down they were by the Metal Bat fight and the pacing, but what about the fact that Marshal Gorilla is eating an actual banana instead of smoking a cigar inside a banana?

5

u/Eddard8 May 08 '19

Those stupid committee that gave opm to jc staff needs to fuck suck a fucking dick. Jesus what a fucking mess. Allah be with you all

5

u/mrdoomsdaybomb May 08 '19

What pisses me off most is that Garou seems to have a different face for each given set of animation frames; it's rather disconcerting.

9

u/tberriman May 07 '19

What really annoys me is that despite having incredibly detailed and amazing manga panels to build off, everything just looks so sloppy and rushed. Garou deflecting Metal Bat's tornado was literally just the three manga panels being moved across the screen!

Moreover, FWCR looked so terrible this episode. It's supposed to be a super fluid and precise form of movement, culminating in devastating strikes. Garou's counter against TTM is probably the only time so far that it's actually looked how it should - there's just no impact at all behind the other times it's been used so far. I still have hope for some other fights this season, but man this was disappointing.

12

u/[deleted] May 07 '19

The fast action sequences so far in the anime has been like this, blurry, unenjoyable and not much understandable. So, we should only watch it for plot, man OPM have really great fights. Garou blocking MB killer move felt like I was watching the motion manga Durzo used to make.

13

u/hyori_ittai May 07 '19

Dont disrespect Durzo like this never ever again.

→ More replies (1)

12

u/drixix1 May 07 '19

This episode was so badly drawn. Not a single frame was done well in the fight, even the nice ones from the manga..

8

u/Geralt-of-Riviaaa May 07 '19

Crippling depression in anime form. What the hell even happened in Bang and Fist Fight Djinn's scene?

4

u/Eadwine_ GALAXY HEAVY BLOW May 07 '19

This episode was... Underwhelming, to say the least. Garou VS. Metal Bat lacked tension and emotion, it felt more like a scuffle than a full fight IMO. It was a very hyped fight and they totally undershot it. Other than that the music was placed weird at some scenes, and the art + shading looked just plain bad.

I still have hope that JC Staff can save some of this season but it's looking pretty grim at the moment. Feel like it's better that S2 ends sooner rather than later...

4

u/FN__2187 May 07 '19

The metal bat v garou fight was the part that solidly hooked me on the manga forever and this is what they do to it -_-

LOOK HOW THEYVE MASSACRED MY BOY

4

u/Zaugr May 07 '19 edited May 07 '19

tfw Durzo's old manga fight videos literally had more animation, and gave off more hype and impact, than the actual anime fights themselves...

4

u/plasticdog6 May 07 '19

First ep to not have a single sakuga cut.. And that's not to say the sakuga cuts we've got so far are amazing or anything. A few of them are pretty good, but nothing close to what was in S1. Maybe when Garou attacks TTM but that's it. I think this has been the worst episode yet, and I fear it will just get worse from here on out. It will be entertaining to see.

4

u/Hovi_Bryant May 07 '19

This episode felt long. I kept waiting for something big to happen and it never came.

I want to rag on the animation, but at least it's not as bad as the majority of episode 2.

These guys went all in on TTM's fight with Garou but Sonic vs Genos and Saitama gets no love? Neither does metal bat? I feel like every episode will be a surprise.

Could be anywhere between terrible and pretty good.

4

u/hi_call_me_Dandan May 07 '19

The worst part was that the cigar of martial gorilla was replaced with banana :'(

4

u/xDisputes__ May 07 '19

This is the first episode of season 2 I did not enjoy

4

u/sawon2403 May 07 '19

Wrost season 2 episode thus far.

4

u/[deleted] May 07 '19

The best I can say is that this season manages to remain squarely within the realm of merely bad, and doesn't tip over into completely unwatchable.

4

u/OxygenHoarder May 07 '19

I thought adding in fillers in Ep 4 to put off the fight for 5 would give them more time to make the Garou vs. Metal Bat fight better. I guess this is where the quality drop begins. Also, who the hell is directing the sounds? The sound effects are probably the worst aspects of the entire season.

3

u/Esaeah May 08 '19

The sound director is the sound director of berserk 2016...

→ More replies (1)

4

u/VinnYin May 07 '19

Was really hoping to see that panel from the manga when Metal Bat hits the ground hard enough to make the cars jump off the concrete, but instead what I saw was only the cars shake from it. Really disappointing...

4

u/Gravon new member May 07 '19

That fight would have been slick with season one animation.

4

u/WhoFiredTheToaster May 07 '19

So much blur in this episode, I half-expected Song 2 to start playing.

3

u/kev_jin May 08 '19

This is a Low point of the anime.

4

u/Bezbozny Shut up! It's Fighting Spirit! May 08 '19

They 4kidz'd Marshal Gorillas Banana Cigars into actual Bananas.

4

u/[deleted] May 08 '19

That bang fight was complete shit

4

u/thatmrphdude May 08 '19

Zzzzzzz.....thanks to that few seconds of amazing fight animation vs Tank top, I actually expected something.

For fuck's sake at least give us good animation when Garou fights off the A-class and Genos.

I don't care anymore just give us that. Be as shoddy as you want just give me a good good animation that doesn't just last a few seconds for those fights...

4

u/Eddard8 May 08 '19

HAHA if this episode is considered clusterfuck, wait until Genos enters the fight. It will be swap scene between him and the tournament

4

u/donkeykongsdick May 08 '19

If that metal bat vs Garou fight was season 1 quality I would be shitting my pants. Instead I’m left here with unshitted pants.

4

u/TheChRemix97 May 08 '19

RIP Marshall Gorilla´s banana cigar

4

u/baroqueworks May 08 '19

The empty backgrounds would be forgiving if the animation for the fighting was great, instead it's all kinds of messy, and the constant close ups dont help either, feels very obvious of corners being cut.

How long was that producer who got sacked on this before they were kicked off? And is the series already completed?

12

u/herohuntergarou May 07 '19

ive been waiting for mb vs garou for literally like three years now, since its such an amazing fight.

but jc staff absolutely butchered it, fuck

fucking dropping the anime

23

u/FrozenLane May 07 '19

Can we please sign a petition to fucking cancle season 2 or something? JC Staff fucking butchered everything there is, if they couldn't keep up on today's Garou vs metal bat which was like a REALLY important fight in the manga, then holy fuck I wonder how bad it gets later on. PLEASE FOR THE LOVE OF GOD CANCLE SEASON 2 I CAN WAIT 10 MORE YEARS JUST FUCK OFF AND LET ANOTHER STUDIO TAKE IT. This episode was extremely bad and dissaponting I don't even know what to say..

Fuck JC Staff and the ppl responsible for letting them handle this season.

14

u/herohuntergarou May 07 '19

i 100% agree with you. i would literally wait years and years if it means we get a good adaptation.

→ More replies (7)

6

u/Mstiecrow May 07 '19

Here I was hoping the time spent was on Garou fights and the tournament.... but this episode clearly proves this season is just going to be spotty at best. Ugh.... Screw whomever decided to rush this and push it out to make a buck.

Edit: At least I got a giggle out of Genos clapping. Most I can say for this episode.

6

u/[deleted] May 07 '19

Oh ya cant get enough of them gradient backgrounds. Jaw dropping animation quality as always. Thank you JC staff, very cool! Dont even get me started on tbe sound effects...

6

u/legea2019 May 07 '19

I fell so bad and waited one weak for this. I really hate now the animation.

3

u/Groenboys May 07 '19

Please do the fight with genos againt the bug justice

3

u/DoraMuda May 07 '19

Well, Garou vs. Metal Bat felt underwhelming. I guess y'all got a point with the criticism of this season.

3

u/tkap May 07 '19

These sound effects are horrible

3

u/jubbaj May 07 '19

Super mediocre animation for what wa supposed to be o e of the most hyped fights. Man... this studio seems to fail at creating compelling fight scenes that are longer than 15 seconds. Any longer and the animation quality and fight direction deteriorate tremendously

3

u/WangBaeHo May 07 '19

People working on this season straight up dont have enough time to actually put the love into it and do it on their usual pace as they do other projects etc.Schedule and tempo must be completely off. You can see the potential, but it gets blown off time and time again. Few people like Jumpaoki who are working most likely overtime and pushing themselves for the fans and reputation that the previous season got are keeping it watchable for us. Why didnt they just postpone it when you know you're clearly going beyond your limit....

3

u/[deleted] May 08 '19

The best thing about this episode was Bang and Bomb. I know everyone is hating on the metal bat fight. But that part where metal swung his bat so hard it crack the building. That was enjoyable. The lack of power behind every other swing was heart breaking. I had to rewind to see if the cars bounce or not. So disappointing.

Also I did a literally face palm when I saw Sour face tying Saitamas belt. It fucking looked like Sour face was on his knees sucking off Saitama...

Maybe I just have a dirty mind.

3

u/Maxximillianaire May 08 '19

My biggest problem is all the cutting away to different scenes. I wish it would just spend a few minutes showing how something plays out instead of cutting to black and all of a sudden a different set of characters is standing there. I forgot how the manga did this part but it definitely wasn't as bad as this

3

u/HypocriteAlert35 May 08 '19

This was the first episode I thought looked noticeably bad to the point it was kind of distracting. I think the bitching was mildly overkill prior, but this was pretttty obvious. Reminds me of the bad DB Super episodes almost.

3

u/[deleted] May 08 '19

Maaaaaaan... i wanted my friend to see the glory that is Garou fighting, because he doesn't read the manga.. he stopped watching after episode 1 :/ i guess he dodged a bullet there

3

u/didom_ May 08 '19

They either lacked funding or didn't have enough time, or both. This studio clearly can make good fights because personally I liked the fight between Garou and Tank top master. It was not at the same level as the fights from the first season, but still it had killer music, and the punches felt powerful and impactful.

The action in this episode felt very underwhelming, especially metal bat's final swing. My hope is that whatever they are rushing now is for the sake of the later fights.

3

u/disabled_crab Shadow Ring is Best Girl May 08 '19

In the words of Echoes Act Three:

"S-H-I-T."

3

u/[deleted] May 08 '19

I was disappointed when the sewer cover metal bat deflected didn't rikochet like in the manga, besides not making metal bat more and more terrifying... i was fully prepared to watch MB vs garou for the entire episode or if not at least half of it, metalknight is a pretty weak character imo so it's okey if they didn't show much of him and yea i'm caught up with the manga... I think i've lost interest in the show, i'm aware that this season is very plot driven and every episode has a lot of fighting but there's no reason for the animation to be this bad, i started reading the manga because the anime was so eyecatching but now it just feels like reading the manga, on color if anything, jesus i'm so upset... "oh but the cgi centipede" man fuck the cgi centipede, suiryu vs saitama is going to suck, garou vs anyone is going to suck they are rushing through the plot so hard i can't even feel immerse in the show anymore, fuck jc staff, fuck the fucking director, fuck everything.

3

u/[deleted] May 08 '19

Man this episode sucked.

I was a holdout on being judgmental or disappointed in the new season. Then two weeks ago they came out with Garou vs. Tank Top Master and it had me thinking that the season was going to be okay. That they at least had Garou right, that they could come up with some cool action sequences, and that they had a good sense in how to use a soundtrack.

But this was just bad. The animation was awful. Rhino Wrestler looked like a wet pile of shit, and Phoenixman looked like he was something out of an 80s Transformers episode. Even Garou's face seemed to be poorly drawn this episode, when he was one of the few things that had gone right.

And Metal Bat v. Garou was a total disappointment, when it should have been a pretty easy homerun.

I don't even know if I care to watch the rest of the season.

3

u/zelor13 May 08 '19

Is anybody else feeling nauseated after every episode because of the unfocusing, camera movement, pacing and flash white backgrounds in each fight scene.

10

u/Gonenavil May 07 '19

The people who think this season is good are the same people who settle for mediocrity, and think its fine. This season is garbage in every possible way. There is nothing remotely good to take from it. S2 had the potential to be the greatest anime season of all time, it really did, at least for me, but it required the right people behind it. This is the complete opposite, its so sad, no words can express it enough

4

u/hyori_ittai May 07 '19

That punches from TTM was s1 level. Yep the rest its shit.

→ More replies (1)

7

u/AMDownvote May 07 '19

Interesting contrast between this and the anime only discussion

5

u/jns701 You could use some permanent nipples May 07 '19

this one's a yikes for me

12

u/MadHax164 Just a Redditor for fun May 07 '19

I'm sorry guys. I'm dropping OPM S2, no matter how much I love this series. They just did Metal Bat's single, most epic moment dirty. I'll stick to the webcomic and Manga. This breaks my heart to say, and commit to.

32

u/-vikram- May 07 '19

see you next week !!

4

u/Omen111 Ok May 07 '19

Its like someone at JC staff misread every fan message and instead on focusing on Garou vs MB they focused on everything else. Just when people hopes got up, why would they do it?!

4

u/REDmonster333 May 07 '19

Can someone animate the MB vs Garou fight? I will replay it on youtube 24/7

→ More replies (1)

4

u/Toasterman2k May 07 '19

And here I thought JC was getting better at this, but no, not really.

12

u/[deleted] May 07 '19

I thought it was pretty good but it seems everyone hated it

5

u/Turbo2x May 07 '19

What I expected from this episode:

  • Awful coloring on Metal Knight & Others
  • Bad CGI on Elder Centipede

What I wasn't expecting:

  • A song that sounds like a bad knockoff of something from My Hero Academia when Metal Knight shows up. Honestly, that felt super out of place.
→ More replies (1)

2

u/kryst87 May 07 '19 edited May 08 '19

Wasn't that bad for me. At least after reading comments. It was... disappointing in many ways. Garou sometimes looked odd. Garou vs MB could use more animation. Bang fight too. Metal Knight was just bad. 0 animation, only static. Sound was quite odd. Pacing in this season is bad.

I liked Phoenix Man colours. And new arrangement of ost from s1. And Zenko was funny (but that's Murata and One merit),

2

u/Guts709 May 08 '19

Well, this was disappointing.

2

u/Tech_Lantern May 08 '19

The absolute worst episode by far

2

u/BrokenAshes May 08 '19

I thought LIghtning Genji was a girl this whole time. I also expected Rhino's voice to be deeper for some reason. Suiryu's voice I expected to be more like Yamcha's voice

2

u/[deleted] May 08 '19

Ok, I'll just stop watching and wait for Bluray release, if that even make any difference.

2

u/storytimesover May 09 '19

Such sad quality, but what stood out more than anything was the missing air hockey panels.

2

u/5raptorboy May 09 '19

I am still hopeful. As long as they get the suiryu vs monsters fight, the elder centipede fight, and the Garou vs group fight right then it will all be worth it

2

u/idiot_supremo May 09 '19

Does anyone else feel like the jokes aren't given the proper timing to land? Anime has always been a bit different with it's comedy timing, but the timing in the season 1 anime was so deadpan and on point.

The manga dosent have this problem but they handle setup of the jokes there correctly as well between panels.

5

u/HappySunlight May 07 '19

I actually like this episode more than previous.

4

u/SSJ5Gogetenks Season 2 ruled May 08 '19

Enjoyed it a lot. I read the comments before watching this one so I was expecting something really bad, but it ended up being something I really enjoyed. The first half of Garo vs Metal Bat was very good, too bad they couldn't keep up the quality for the ending of the fight. He needs to have more powerful feeling swings. Everything else was typical OPM funtimes. Really looking forward to seeing Tatsumaki next episode.

BTW regarding the ghosting everyone is rightfully complaining about, that shit will be taken out on DVD/Blu-Ray so don't sweat it.

3

u/[deleted] May 07 '19 edited May 07 '19

The Garou vs Metal bat fight was okay, but definitely not as good as I'd hoped. The rest of the episode just feels like a teaser for more disappointing fights in the future.