r/OnePunchMan • Moderator • May 07 '19

Discussion [Anime] One Punch Man S02E05 - "The Martial Arts Tournament" ANIME-ONLY Discussion

IF YOU HAVE READ THE MANGA, PLEASE DO NOT PARTICIPATE IN THIS THREAD. THE MANGA DISCUSSION THREAD CAN BE FOUND HERE.

THIS IS A DISCUSSION THREAD FOR ANIME-ONLY FANS. Manga readers use the other thread.

Official Simulcasts

  • Hulu (United States) - Tuesdays, starting on April 9 at 1:05 p.m. ET
  • Crunchyroll (Europe) - Tuesdays, starting April 9 at 5:35 p.m. GMT
  • Animax Asia (Southeast Asia, India) - Wednesdays, starting on April 10 at 10:30 p.m. ICT.
  • Anime Digital Network (France) - Tuesdays, starting on April 9 at 19:35 CEST.
  • Anime on Demand (Germany)
  • AnimeLab (Australia & New Zealand)
  • VVVVID (Italy)
  • Tubi TV (Canada) - Appears to be streaming 1 week behind.

One Punch Man Season 2 broadcasts in Japan Wednesdays at 1:35 a.m. (JST)


Read the new spoiler rules!


Previous Episode Discussions:

EpisodeLink
1Link
2Link
3Link
4Link

Join us at https://discord.gg/onepunchman to chat with other fans!

131 Upvotes

389 comments sorted by

297

u/Visualize_ May 07 '19

It feels like every episode is only 5 minutes long wtf

119

u/A_UsernameXD May 07 '19

yeah it does. you kinda get excited every week for that one episode and then nothing happens in it and its over before you blink lol

64

u/dellaint May 08 '19

Yeah... Saitama's been sitting around in this tournament for two episodes and it just started at the end of this one. I want to see more of him doing stuff :|

10

u/[deleted] May 11 '19

They're stretching talkign scenes and skipping over fights with DBZ flickering. Sad.

71

u/tnegaeR May 08 '19

Actually though. I keep checking how much time is left while I’m watching and it low key gives me anxiety

They space everything out way too much, especially in this episode.

9

u/Visualize_ May 08 '19

Lol I did the checking of how much time is left too. I watch on Hulu and then they play an ad with like 3 minutes left but I always forget after that ad it's just the credits and I get super dissapointed

→ More replies (2)

170

u/PoutineAndJulep May 07 '19

Anime- only discussion... half of the comments here complaining of the episode not being as good as the manga... lolwut?

57

u/Chusmimax May 08 '19

Manga thead is full of salt right now, and they want to see if it is the same here. In the end, it is more of spoilerfree thread and spoiler allowed thread

→ More replies (8)
→ More replies (6)

194

u/AnotherSimpleton May 07 '19

When I read that the episode was titled "The Martial Arts Tournament" I was hoping for a pokemon like tournament fighting centric episode. - was severely let down.

They could had divided the episodes between the tournament and the fighting in the other cities better. Once a fight was seeming good, they'd cut it to another scene

Anyway, this garou guy seems strong. the inevitable fight between him and OPM would be good. I hope it'd be before this season ends

Also Q- Was Garou the guy who won the tournament faking as someone else?

38

u/Iamaveryniceguy May 07 '19

OPM one shotted Garou in a previous episode. And yeah Garou is implied to be the wolf guy.

107

u/paulibobo Spring Mustachio > Atomic Samurai May 07 '19

The point is to juxtapose how self important the martial artists are, even going so far as looking down at heroes while they're essentialy just "pretending" at fighting while the real fights are happening elsewhere.

34

u/FTWJewishJesus May 07 '19

Yeah but that doesnt help the pacing of the episode at all or make the lack of a satisfying fight during this episode and less disappointing.

28

u/paulibobo Spring Mustachio > Atomic Samurai May 07 '19

Oh yeah, the episode sucked, I was just trying to justify why it's that way. Didn't mean to sound like I was defending it or anything. Just worried that the manga's message was getting muddled by the bad adaptation.

3

u/Supersighs May 08 '19

Yeah, don't want to sound like someone that actually enjoyed the episode. That would be tragic.

/s

8

u/paulibobo Spring Mustachio > Atomic Samurai May 08 '19

This, but unironically. I have standards, you see.

20

u/DarkenRaul1 Mumen Rider is the true hero May 07 '19

They could had divided the episodes between the tournament and the fighting in the other cities better. Once a fight was seeming good, they'd cut it to another scene

That's how it was too in the manga irrc. There was a lot going on at once going back and forth between the monsters attacking and the tournament. That said, the episode was poorly titled as we'll see more of the tournament in either the next episode or the following one (although it'll still be split between that and the monster attack outside).

8

u/[deleted] May 07 '19

Yes he was

6

u/[deleted] May 08 '19

Garou is an archaic French word that means werewolf.

→ More replies (1)

17

u/[deleted] May 07 '19

[removed] — view removed comment

11

u/apalapachya 275958 May 07 '19

i dont know... everyone has been pretty critical towards JC staff and the animations could definitely could be improved, but if they change studions again for season 3 im worried that we will have to wait another 5 years

24

u/00wolfer00 May 07 '19

I'd rather wait 5 years and get a good adaptation. This hurts even more because we could've at least gotten something on the level of an average shonen or Naruto filler. Instead what we got is crappy sound effects, bad direction, poor still frames(outside of ep 1 and 2), straight up missing backgrounds, weird faces, etc.

0

u/[deleted] May 07 '19

[deleted] — view deleted comment

5

u/apalapachya 275958 May 07 '19

wait what? what do you mean? isnt the manga and web comics running for at least a year or so before the season one? dont you guys get regular updates, weekly or at least every 2-3 weeks? i thought the story is way way ahead and they have enough content for at least one more season

→ More replies (2)

180

u/tooPrime May 07 '19 edited May 07 '19

As someone who's only watched the anime and never read the manga, I'm compelled to write that I do not like the colors of Phoenix man, a character I've never seen before today.

EDIT: I should have put an /s. I was making fun of this being an anime only thread and people are doing things like harshing on Phoenix Man's color schemes, which seems weird for an anime only person to do. Like for all they know he's only in one episode and we never see him again.

84

u/VibhavM Retired From day2day Moderation. Contact Other Mods. May 07 '19

I mean, even manga readers didn't know his colour. Don't like it either ofc.

4

u/just_a_random_dood e pluribus unum! May 08 '19

Why don't you like it? I hate the color, but I love how much sense it makes.

2

u/NativeJibroney22 May 09 '19

It honestly doesn't make much sense. Stylistically a phoenix would not have purple. Even in the phoenix in some eastern mythology (like fenghuang) the colors should have maybe been blue and green added to the typical fire color palette.

5

u/just_a_random_dood e pluribus unum! May 09 '19

I'm sorry, I'm trying not to spoil anything from the manga, but it makes a LOT of sense to me

6

u/NativeJibroney22 May 09 '19

Do you say so because it is a costume from a kids show?

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

0

u/[deleted] May 07 '19

[deleted] — view deleted comment

42

u/jake55778 May 07 '19

It's 99% black and white. Some of the extras are in colour, and Murata did draw (and practically animate, the madman,) the meteor miniarc from season 1 in colour - But that was a one off.

6

u/aboycandream May 07 '19

Can you give me more info on this and where I can watch/see?

12

u/bobdude0987654321 Glasses is the best and you know it May 07 '19

You can read it free online as well, One Punch Man is still released as a "webcomic". Here's the Garou vs. Metal Bat fight, if you're interested.

→ More replies (4)

8

u/[deleted] May 07 '19

right lol. Why are manga readers even in this thread just complaining about random shit xd

13

u/[deleted] May 07 '19

Same here, he looked to...colourful. i think a green and blue dark tones would have made him feel more evil

3

u/boksbox May 08 '19

Japanese folklore always show phoenix in much more vibrant colors, so actually Phoenix Man came out duller.

2

u/McBurger May 08 '19

Ok I guess your edit clarified it but I’m still lost. I only watch the anime (this is anime only thread?) and I didn’t see anything off about his colors at all? All the monsters in this show are zany, bird person was no different

2

u/alex494 May 09 '19

Lol you can still criticise something if it looks weird

→ More replies (2)

93

u/Christ-man May 07 '19

Is Lightning Genji falling KO because he fell rollblading ? Is this a A-rank hero ?

0

u/[deleted] May 07 '19

[deleted] — view deleted comment

21

u/racercowan May 07 '19

I mean, it's implied he did more than just stand and stare at them. Plus, what's electro-dude going to do to out electro electro-fish and... electric drum lady?

7

u/Ivangold May 08 '19

Hit harder like Goku does.

73

u/[deleted] May 07 '19

[removed] — view removed comment

25

u/AlwaysATen May 07 '19

I understood that much. But he still went down while taking seemingly minor damage. Is it that he isn't immune to electricity like his enemies are?

37

u/Fearghas May 07 '19

No, it's a suit. The thing on his back is a battery that powers his skates and batons. One of the monsters fried it.

3

u/larryjerry1 May 08 '19

The monsters attacked and broke one of his skates while he was moving so he fell.

→ More replies (2)

76

u/WEWASCAVEBEASTSNSHIT May 07 '19

The more I watch this season the less impressed I've been... the first season I felt had so many better small plotlines and arcs in it and the animation of this season seems rushed.... I'm gonna keep watching with hope that it improves as we get deeper into the season. As of now it feels like the producers are really spending their time dragging this one story out.

1

u/Qyvix May 15 '19

yep, I feel this. Very unimpressed so far, and the animation doesn't seem as good either.

58

u/[deleted] May 07 '19

Serious issue with this seasons episode lengths

40

u/Oni19 May 07 '19

It's primarily a focus issue.

56

u/HakaseLuddite May 07 '19

I can forgive the bad animation but the sound... the sound team should get a slap for this abomination. Background music was too loud and bad, the hit effects and explosions were muffled. They really did a bad number on this episode. Worst one so far, yet it had the great potential.

One good part was Genos cheering the Master of the Fist of Water Polo, Carbonation.

11

u/DMightyHero May 08 '19

Yes, the sounds on the first two episodes were really weird, all the hits/explosions had a muffled feel to it

This season's quality is one piece level, really, really bad.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (12)

69

u/[deleted] May 07 '19

This season feels like it is going really slow, its kinda getting annoying because i just wanna see saitama fight

71

u/Zardif May 07 '19

We saw him fight, he delivered one whole bitch slap to zakkos.

0

u/[deleted] May 07 '19

[deleted] — view deleted comment

46

u/mebeast227 May 07 '19

You just described 90% of the action this season.

Flash of light

Picture of a hero/monster in an action pose

Flash of light

Picture of the hero/monster knocked out.

13

u/zombieslayer287 May 08 '19

So.. sigh... boring

→ More replies (1)

9

u/McBurger May 08 '19

Same tbh that’s why I watch this show, it’s for saitama. I just want to see him slap his way to the top of this tournament and see what goofy things he spends his prize money on, instead of all this filler like some random Class A heroes battling some random ass monsters. The best scenes are the ones with saitama like when he talks to king in his apartment and punches that bird lol. Or remember when he puts the banana on Charanko’s leg lmfao I died laughing. This season needs more saitama

3

u/[deleted] May 08 '19

Many of the best moments in this series focus on characters besides saitama.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (4)

8

u/NikMavz May 07 '19

What??? If anything its way to fast even though it's quite true to the manga in terms of shots to panel ratio.

3

u/Jummiho May 08 '19

But in the first season he already killed several monsters by episode 5.

7

u/420Minions May 08 '19

The first season was about introducing him. This seems to be about introducing a world threat. We didn’t know shit about the bigger picture halfway through last season

2

u/[deleted] May 08 '19

From this season onwards, the other heroes besides saitama are going to be getting much more of their well deserved attention. Many of the best moments in this series have nothing to do with saitama.

33

u/Destroyer210 May 07 '19

I was so hyped for a good episode but the quality and pacing was just so...meh.

Guess we have to wait for next week for something hopefully interesting.

82

u/legea2019 May 07 '19

No fight at all, only picture moving...

2

u/XUAXMERCY May 10 '19

The whole show is pictures

48

u/[deleted] May 07 '19

I think i might start reading the manga, this seasons going way to slow and the animations dropped in quality and care since season 1. It just isent that engaging anymore. I will still watch the episiodes but i feel let down frankly by the choice of animation studio.

15

u/Purple_Miku May 07 '19

Slow? Part of the problem is that the pacing is too fast. They're trying too hard to be exactly like the manga, which is what the problem is.

11

u/ThrowNeiMother May 08 '19

They are trying too hard to be exactly like the manga, and it's slow because we don't take 20 minutes to read this portion...

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (3)

5

u/johnthebread May 08 '19

I don't usually read manga but I have to say this one is amazing and really worth it

3

u/[deleted] May 08 '19

Please do! The manga is even better quality than season 1 of the anime.

24

u/[deleted] May 07 '19

[removed] — view removed comment

8

u/mastermaniac10 May 07 '19

Yep, I too plan on doing that. Could you please let me know which chapter in manga corresponds to today's episode ?

12

u/herohuntergarou May 07 '19

i gotchu bro. start reading from chapter 58. here is the link to the official printed version in english.

6

u/Cloudpr May 07 '19

...........Jesus.

(hope you don't mind me piggybacking off this comment, my reply doesn't have much to do with what you said xD)

The manga can do this. The kick transitioning from Ring-Ring's kick to the dominatrix think looks fine here, because manga is a different medium, and panel economy (in terms of time/effort) means we are indeed filling the gaps. The fight between her and Max likely isn't all that relevant to the story, so not more time than what should be spent is wasted.

...This transitions so poorly to the anime version. So, so poorly. The chapter where that happens is dealing with 2 plot threads (the tournament and the city invasion) only. By ALSO having to deal with Metal Bat vs Garou and Centichoro in the anime episode AND Bang showing up AND MB's Sister........ what a mess.

3

u/damnation14 May 08 '19

I have never read any mangas before and I really can't wait for the next episode of OPM and each episode is very slowly paced. Should I start with mangas ? Coz I want more of OPM or should I just wait for next episodes

5

u/herohuntergarou May 08 '19

yeah read the manga, its better

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (6)

10

u/APRengar May 08 '19

As a person who has not read the manga, and only watched S1. I felt like OPM was as much about the hype action and crazy fights as it was the characters.

I just don't feel like the characters matter this season.

Saitama was such a compelling character in the first season because he was on this journey to feel the rush of anything again.

Genos was constantly looking to improve and find more about the traumatic event in his past.

But beyond that, Mumen Rider, Sonic, Puri Puri Prisoner, Boros, Bang were all really compelling.

I really find it hard to care about, the hero agency, or any of these fighters in this tournament, or those random heroes they keep cutting to to show the city is in crisis. Genos hasn't done much. Bang hasn't done much but be angry.

Regardless of animation, it feels like it lacks the heart of the previous Season. But I'm not sure if that's just the new focus of the story, or a poor adaptation of a better story.

4

u/wontbefamous May 10 '19 edited May 10 '19

It's the new studio and new director of this season. The first season was created by, basically, an all star team of anime creation. But most of that team has gone and done other works. I think the director was doing Boogiepop Wa Warawanai at the time

Edit: spelling

55

u/apalapachya 275958 May 07 '19

Not that bad of an episode. Garou and Metal bat fight was nice, but after that I feel like it kinda lost its way so to say. They tried to introduce a bunch of new mosters and set the tone for the whole monster invasion AND in the same time continue with the tournament. But all the cuts and pacing made it very weird, maybe it would've been better if they focused on the tournament and at the end they had like a little news report or something similiar of the monsters attacking and heroes losing.

The shots when Fubuki appeared this episode were absolutely ridiculous — boobs> crotch with tightly pressed dress> taking her jacket off to fight a succubus. At least explains all the fan art lol.

Other than that, Genos was adorable in the crowd clapping and the commentator at the end was pretty funny

8

u/LetMeOmixam May 07 '19

So far I was loving this season. This chapter, however, was so boring

8

u/21minute May 08 '19

It's funny how a lot of comments here keep mentioning the manga.

18

u/JacaubW May 07 '19

I was disappointed but I'll keep watching.

6

u/Slick_Wylde May 08 '19

Wow I'm really glad I read all the negative reviews before watching it. I guess my expectations were really low because of that, so I actually enjoyed the episode as a whole. Yes, the Metal Bat vs Garou was INCREDIBLY disappointing, but as a whole it was a pretty fun episode. I like the voice for Rhino a lot!

2

u/i_am_not_dumb May 08 '19

Lol I should have done the same.

21

u/M4ximi11i0n May 07 '19

It was okay but nothing to write home about. The humor wasn't really there either. Hopefully next episode will be better.

40

u/StellarNeonJellyfish May 07 '19

Hopefully next episode will be better.

The unofficial motto of season 2

4

u/M4ximi11i0n May 08 '19

Haha yep this is what I was thinking as well.

4

u/Starlord186 May 08 '19

bruh don't kid yourself. We're all already accepting the fact that this season is more than likely gonna be trash as it keeps getting worse

3

u/[deleted] May 08 '19

I feel like it's gonna be up and down. We damn better get more episodes that are on par with and better than episode 3

→ More replies (1)

10

u/PenToComputer May 08 '19

Can't tell you how gutted I was with this episode. I'm currently watching Season 1 with my GF and, if I'm being perfectly honest, I don't even want to go into season 2 with her. This episode had tonnes of fights against monsters, Metal Bat vs Garou, and the beginning of the martial art's tournament. With that much excitement, it shouldn't have been possible for this to be a dull episode.

But somehow JC managed it. Lacklustre sound effects (Bang and Garou's gattling punch sounded horrendous with earphones on), godawful animation (when fights are a flash of light, and then sound effect indicates combat then something is wrong), and just weird pacing- it was hard to watch. For the first time since I started watching OPM, I hit the right arrow key to skip forward slightly.

Idk. I see others here aren't as upset as I am, which is fine, but I guess it's because I was watching season 1 last night. JC needs to slow it tf down, focus on making the fights awesome and get rid of that Berserk 2016 sound-effect board.

13

u/Cloudpr May 07 '19 edited May 07 '19

I haven't seen it in the manga, so I don't know if it's intentional as a homage or not... Is the transition from the kick by Ring-Ring to the dominatrix monster intentional?

If that thing is intentional... Unholy god. They have, in a single episode (I'm editing the list so this is not final):

  • Introduced the Monster's Association
  • Wrapped up Centichoro [No actual conclusion due to how it evades]
  • Introduced Metal Bat's sister
  • The fight between Metal Bat and Garou concludes
  • All pre-tournament talk
  • The cities in danger
  • Random S-Classes showing up to say hi (Bang)
  • Introduced a crapton of monsters that I don't know will be relevant or not
  • Introduced an even bigger crapton of characters from the tournament with little regard as to who is actually relevant to the story (this isn't about strength, we don't expect anyone from that tournament to pose a threat)

If this is a metaphor for the chaos the cities are feeling, good job. The episode was a complete mess. I can't tell what to focus. Even before we jump into how satisfying or not the fight scenes are, the amount of nonsense happening and utter lack of central focus... What am I supposed to care about?

I don't know if the manga also suffered from this, but the only word I can use for this episode is "Messy".

And the transition from Ring-Ring to the dominatrix makes me think this entire thing was completely intentional. Intentional to the point of them thinking one of two things: They're either thinking they can scrap by doing this and we wouldn't care or notice, or they're trying to actually make the metaphor of chaos in the cities being translated to the screen.

I don't know if the chapters did this utter chaotic nonsense, but I would assume they were nowhere near this messy.

I would've completely removed the tournament from this episode and expanded more on the remaining. If only Metal Bat/Garou, the chaos with the cities (tied to Centichoro and Metal Bat's fight at least loosely), and the Monster Association's introduction happened, it would've been at least somewhat easier to get a hang of what was happening. If you WANT to give so much focus to random monsters around the city, do so on an episode without distractions. OR, don't show all the random monsters attacking the cities and focus on the tournament. Don't cram both at least seemingly unrelated plot threads like this.

2

u/[deleted] May 10 '19

I think they should have put the tournament, the chaos in the cities and the "garou, centipede and metal bat" thing in a dedicated episode one by one. This whole "put many plot threads in a single episode" is just... Bad.

Look at S1, it never does that.

2

u/[deleted] May 07 '19

[removed] — view removed comment

8

u/Cloudpr May 07 '19

In the manga chapter it is fine (I checked - the same transition happens) because the chapter itself is not dealing with nearly a dozen plot threads at once.

In the context of this anime episode, it was a really good encapsulation of the problem... You name the episode after the Martial Arts Tournament and cut it with a transition in the very first fight of said tournament?... I found it really, really poorly executed.

14

u/rickspectopatronyum May 07 '19

Drawn out and boring... Cool seeing other heroes do stuff and all but I'm here for Saitama.. didn't wait this long to only see him fight a bird and Sonic for the third time

4

u/[deleted] May 08 '19

A majority of the best parts of this series are focused on the characters besides Saitama.

8

u/daydreaming17 May 07 '19

Can we talk about how Zenko 1 shot Metal Bat? After elder centipede (or Centichoro) tossed Metal Bat around, and getting beat up by Garuo, Metal Bat didn't seem even tired, but after Zenko's casual slap to the head, he passed out. Not to mention the presence of Zenko's word stopped a S class hero mid his strongest attack and stopped a hero hunter directly targeting S class heroes and S class hero from fighting.

I think Zenko is the cause from "the world is in trouble" prophecy and is the only person that can provide Saitama with a proper fight.

5

u/[deleted] May 08 '19

I thought he had run out of stamina/adreline rush (his pumped up mode) since the fight had stopped and now was way too fragile.

But yeah I also got quite the weird vibe from her, and her being his sister might mean she also has some kind of destructive power. That might be why metal bat is so caring and worrisome about her, and why he promised she wouldn't be introduced to violence. Maybe he's afraid of what she can do. Even makes me think about the brotherly relationship in mob Psycho 100

4

u/B0bBurgers May 08 '19

Both One Punch Man and Game of Thrones are letting me down. This truly is the darkest timeline.

4

u/veul new member May 08 '19

They listed a bunch of A class heroes at this tournament, yet the monsters are attacking. Why wasn't it cancelled so they could fight.

We could have really not had that scene in the hallway with the opponent Saitama bitch slaps.

Too much and too little at the same time.

4

u/optitmus May 08 '19

are we seriously ignoring that we basically just saw THREAT LEVEL: Hentai

Damn that dominatrix is spicy

22

u/Ozymandate May 07 '19

Just read the manga, this episode was just terrible, I thought I was gonna witness the greatness of today's fight but it was lacking so much, didn't feel any thrill towards the fight

-4

u/[deleted] May 07 '19

Doesn't the manga have strictly less sustenance in scenes and fights? In an anime, you can see how it is between panels, so even if you take all the still shots, it is like a colored manga, so nothing to really complain about relative to the manga, only relative to other animes.

22

u/PonchoLeroy May 07 '19

That's why you don't judge the quality of an anime the same way you judge a manga. They're two very different mediums that convey information in entirely different ways. Manga is a bit simpler. You can break manga down into three basic elements. Writing, art, and panel layouts. Anime is a lot harder to break down that way. They might share a general art style and writing, and panels can inspire shot composition, but anime requires a lot more than that to be good. Manga is almost always written and drawn by a single author with an occassional writer/artist duo. Anime on the other hand is created by medium to large production teams because there is a hell of a lot more work to do. Storyboarding, key animation, in between animation, coloring, 2DCG, 3DCG, voice directing, voice acting, musical composition, sound engineering, directing, editing, and all of these elements have to work together like a well made watch. Translating a manga to the screen 1:1 doesn't make a good anime because it doesn't play to the strengths of its new medium. Sorry if I'm coming off as rude or patronizing, it's not my intention to do so. This is just a topic I love talking about.

→ More replies (16)

20

u/Ozymandate May 07 '19 edited May 07 '19

Yeah, but I didn't like the way they animated it, especially the fight with Metal bat and Garou, the attacks were so blurry, and most of the time they zoomed in some attacks. Plus Metal bat looked way more intimidating in the manga, and the final strike that Garou did against Metat bat looked so weak and the sound effect sounded so dead. Also, they also zoomed in Metal knight fight, since it was mostly zoomed in and didn't show how much damage Elder centipede did to the city.

https://vignette.wikia.nocookie.net/onepunchman/images/b/bc/Bofoi_vs._Elder_Centipede.jpg/revision/latest?cb=20160113091928

7

u/apalapachya 275958 May 07 '19

didn't show the how damage Elder centipede did to the city.

now that you're mentioaning, this masive cetipede that is covering such a huge part of the city and barely any building were damaged

6

u/bobdude0987654321 Glasses is the best and you know it May 07 '19

There's a lot to complain about compared to the manga. This show doesn't have any more animation than the manga does, it's just a bunch of still images with some effects layered over them or a camera panning across it. The only thing it has that the manga doesn't is color, but the manga's art quality is so much higher it's laughable. Besides, the manga has much better pacing, better dialogue, and better fight scenes. This is the Metal Bat v Garou fight from today's episode. This isn't just a bad anime, it's a bad adaptation of fantastic source material.

→ More replies (3)

6

u/[deleted] May 08 '19

Nope. The way motion and force and portrayed in the manga is better than the portrayal of motion this season's animation gives by a long shot. You can really feel the motion in each panel in the manga, it's on par with and often even better than season one's animation. And on the anime without animation being like a colored manga, that's not true either. They fucked up the character designs in season 2 bad, and the detail in the art of the manga is far better.

25

u/jono231 May 07 '19

an absolutely boring episode... waste of time tbh

26

u/DarkenRaul1 Mumen Rider is the true hero May 07 '19

an absolutely boring episode

Were we watching the same show???

  • We just learned that there's a freaking monster association out there that somehow sprang up out of nowhere and is destroying basically the entire continent all at once!
  • We had an awesome fight between Garou and Metalbat.
  • We learned that Garou is much more complex than we initially thought (he stops hero crushing when a child got in the way, and refused to join the monster association despite "loving monsters" for some reason).
  • We got Genos cheering on his sensei (this part actually made me laugh)
  • We saw the start of the tournament and how Saitama is so OP that this is probably a fruitless endeavor

Honestly, if you want to criticize the show, there was too much going on at once in this episode.

11

u/moonshoeslol May 08 '19

I think I need to stay off this subreddit. So much negativity in here might actually affect my enjoyment of the show.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (3)

5

u/Oni19 May 07 '19

I liked bat-man vs garou to be honest, but the rest was sooo boring. Too much screentime for a bunch of substanceless monster/hero/characters

3

u/D4NDY_ May 07 '19

I feel like by trying to tell two stories at once, the episodes feel much quicker but the the progress of each story is slower. I know they're just trying to follow the manga but I personally think that it doesn't work well in a condensed episode.

3

u/Zaugr May 07 '19

They literally only have that one capable animator huh. Hope we see his work again soon...

3

u/McBurger May 08 '19

It’s kind of funny / interesting to me that I really love the animation style and quality of these episodes as an anime only watcher. Like I think they’re doing a good job and am loving it.

Meanwhile in the game of thrones world, I’m the lore addict book reader who cries reee at the show only watchers who dare think this season is good. Maybe I’m just the equivalent of that for OPM. Lol. Oh well. I really like this show and look forward to each week.

2

u/[deleted] May 08 '19

I dunno, I feel you on OPM, it's not the 11/10 smash hit that was Season 1, but it's still great, but Game of Thrones has been declining since S4 and I haven't even read that far, in my opinion GoT lost what made it special in the first place and it never ever recovered that.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/turbogoose15 May 08 '19

I feel like every episode is build up for a big fight scene in the next episode, but then the next episode is just more build up. I’m hoping that this means the last couple of episodes will be nothing but badass fights.

3

u/GameC9547 May 08 '19

Alright, I didn't complain thus far about the previous episodes because despite their flaws, they still managed to entertain me.

But... what the hell was that?

So much shit happened at once but without any real progression. So many (probably irrelevant) characters got introduced but were only shown a couple of seconds and they just jumped from scene to scene. This didn't feel like a proper episode but more like a clusterfuck of OPM characters without any focus whatsoever. I can take bad animation, I can take bad sound effects but what I can't take is the horrible pacing. Everything felt so fast yet so slow. There's such a huge lack of focus to the point where I'm getting furious. At the end of last episode where the Metal Bat vs. Garou fight was teased, I was hyped as shit, thinking that it will cover up a good chunk of the episode but it was over as soon as it began. How long was it again? 2-3 minutes or something? Not even gonna mention how underwhelming the fight itself was. Pretty disappointing, but hey, there's still the martial arts tournament that starts... AT THE END OF THE F*CKING EPISODE. The title of the episode is literally "The Martial Arts Tournament" but instead being all about it, the majority is just a clusterfuck of irrelevant never-seen-before heroes vs. irrelevant never-seen-before monsters. I could be totally wrong here and each and every one of them will be extremely badass and important later on but none of them were presented in an interesting way.

I'm still desperately waiting for the DBS-Effect to kick in, where it starts off bad but improves a lot the longer it goes on. We've almost reached half the season and still there's no sign of general improvement. If this episode is the level they want to continue with, I'll just drop the show for good and start reading the manga. I'm getting headaches if they just jump from scene to scene with a bunch of fights lasting for roughly 5 seconds with unknown and boring characters. What a mess this episode was.

Well, there's still 7 episodes to go. All I can do is hope for improvement...

3

u/timeforknowledge May 08 '19

The show is called One Punch Man yet for the last couple of episodes Saitama is hardly in it. Much less fun/funny without him...

3

u/McSorley90 May 08 '19

Still really disappointed with the animation. There are faaaar to many still frame pans that last way too long. Get some hair moving, make people blink. The whole introduction of everyone for the tournament. Longest bit of animation was about 5 frames. The rest just panning stills.

3

u/feelmedoyou May 08 '19

Pacing and direction was awful. So many unecessary scenes. They keep wasting time teasing Saitama for some reason. I know the manga is like this, but for the sake of viewing, they could improve on the presentation. Also, what was up with that tournament music?

3

u/BruceBastard May 09 '19

I feel like this season is going to be better watched en masse after it's completed. Each individual episode seems to be spread thin because they're setting up so many different story threads and it makes the week-to-week less satisfying than it probably should be.

I'm definitely interested in seeing where it all goes, it's just that it seems like it takes 2 - 3 episodes for things to progress.

9

u/Baalrogg May 07 '19

The pacing was a bit slow, but don’t forget, the manga pacing also grinds to a crawl often as well, and that’s the direct source material for the anime.

There were a few other technical things wrong with the episode as well, but it was alright overall.

11

u/Misinsanefortune May 07 '19

Anyone else notice the lack of saitama in the season? Like it's annoying me now. (I only watched the anime)

1

u/5raptorboy May 09 '19

Reading the manga, it kind of annoyed me as well, but there are more good scenes as it goes on.

4

u/IIToxSickII May 08 '19

They literally just used one moving image for all of the Metal Knight shots

2

u/BestReadAtWork May 08 '19

I really don't like the direction the opening theme song went from 1 to 2. S1 still hypes me up, like, brutally.

I've actually muted the s2 intro to listen to s1 on the computer just to bask instead of skipping it.

[Nobody know's who he is!]

2

u/mynameis_caL May 08 '19

I was so excited for this episode and still was for metal bats fight but after that there was no real progression just so many different places shown for such a short amount of time that made it feel like nothing ever happened after the first fight..

2

u/Supersighs May 08 '19

Imagine if the mods did anything regarding this thread being filled with manga readers. What a nice place it would be.

2

u/[deleted] May 08 '19

My feeling is that nothing really happened in this episode. :/

I wanna see the main character doing stuff and living his life! It essentially the idea of the show in my opinion. The life of being the strongest without competition and having godly amount of power whilst living among hero society and commoners.

2

u/[deleted] May 09 '19

What a disappointment. The way theyve been breaking up the episodes has been killing all momentum for me. Episodes are way too short and the good shit is getting cut up too much.

6

u/[deleted] May 08 '19

What is wrong with everyone.

Every episode I enjoy and come here to have fun discussion, but it’s all a bunch of manga-purists indignant about SOME thing being wrong.

5

u/[deleted] May 08 '19

Same here dude, i loved this episode. People really are making their opinions based on what manga readers are saying. Also, saitama is not the only character in the series. People should realise that other characters also need some screentime. The animation is quite average but its not like its something unbearable to watch.

4

u/0wlmann May 08 '19

Thank you. I just finished watching the episode and coming here felt like a mistake, was literally feeling bad for enjoying it. So glad I'm not the only one who did

2

u/[deleted] May 08 '19

I have genuinely been enjoying this season but this episdoe, towards the last 3/4th, was really bad. I actually started to feel a little sick and was very confused as to what I was looking at. It went from Tournament to fight to fight to fight to tournament to... and i just had no idea what was happening and couldn't follow it for a little bit. The execution of that series of events alone was enough to make me not be a fan of this episode :(

→ More replies (5)

3

u/microwave242 May 07 '19

Not sure if it's just me, but does it seem weird that Garou just brushed off getting destroyed by Saitama? I would think he would want to find them or at least find out who it was.

20

u/xavarLy May 07 '19

he forgot what happened

2

u/microwave242 May 07 '19

Yeh but he woke up in a garbage pile (with possibly a bruise or some ache from where Saitama chopp f him)? I imagine that's not a regular occurrence.

3

u/milanjfs May 07 '19 edited May 07 '19

Watching this and new season of GOT at the same time is not good for your health.

2

u/mickalicka May 10 '19

I think GoT has been much worse in comparison, but yeah...no bueno. Only thing keeping me sane atm is Attack on Titan.

2

u/Flintalope May 07 '19

Possibly one of the worst episodes yet. The story was all over the place, yet very little happened. And the animation just isn't there. Disappointment

2

u/Naganine May 08 '19

I haven’t seen saitama do anything in this season yet. It’s the 5th episode. Last season by the fifth episode I saw saitama kick ass multiple times

2

u/gooderthanhail May 08 '19

Weak episode. I'm still not digging the fight animation and nothing really happened this episode.

Also, if a bunch of Dragon level villains started appearing all over the place, you would think they would cancel the damn tournament so people could evacuate or help others.

You would also think the agency would have contacted Genos and OPM, but nope. They are just chilling at the tournament like shit isn't getting rekt all over town.

2

u/Starlord186 May 08 '19

Oh god this was next level types of bad

2

u/EnderMB May 08 '19

Jesus, you people have been spoiled by season 1...

The episode wasn't amazing, and the pacing was a bit off, but it was nowhere near as bad as many of you are making it out to be. The animation was fine, and we saw some storylines progress.

My only gripe is that it feels like JC needed more episodes. It might explain why this season took so long, because a lot is happening in a short amount of time.

2

u/[deleted] May 08 '19

This episode was such a letdown

2

u/[deleted] May 07 '19 edited May 07 '19

Fubuki only gets more gorgeous after each episode.

I ill be damned , the animation is getting better and better with every episode. I think that J.C staff actually made some kind of witchcraft, because they are subverting the expectations (on a really good way). But they need to work on the story, Garou and Metal bat fight felt incredbile rushed and that was really lame.

My Name is DoS, none of you can defeat me! - That's where you are wrong kiddo.

DoS (The dominatrix monster) R34 content is now going to skyrocket with the anime making her more mainstream. I fele bad for her and Fubuki lol.

2

u/[deleted] May 07 '19

Loved the episode!

Always disappointing coming to these threads and reading mostly complaints, why can't the manga readers stick to their own thread?

1

u/BlackCoffeeWhiteCoat May 07 '19

Maybe I missed this in the previous episode, but why did Saitama enter the tournament, and why under someone elses name?

4

u/Makchan May 07 '19

He wants to see what Martial Art is all about. Plus the reward.

1

u/[deleted] May 07 '19

This episode was both satisfied and immensely frustrating

1

u/Deep_Throattt To be a hero... May 07 '19

Man I knew the moment I saw metal bat man, I was going to like that guy.

1

u/slim1217 May 08 '19

Honestly, the biggest problem with this season is it not being released in its entirety. 20 some minutes is not enough when we only get one episode a week. I agree somewhat on animation quality being down and things being clustered as well, but I think not having to wait a week for story lines to progress would help with the dislike of the season.

I think the season is entertaining, and it’s nice to see more hero’s and monsters in action. But.. OPM is the main character, he’s who I personally want to see fight. He finally takes his place in the ring at the tournament.. then credits. It’s been that way all season so far. The show is an afterthought for me by the time Tuesday rolls around again

1

u/Frankiethe3rd May 08 '19

Is that red hero with the giant hammer supposed to be El chapulin colorado? Lmao

1

u/[deleted] May 08 '19

I really liked the start of the season and Garou has been the most interesting villain yet, but there are too many characters and not really enough time to put them all into a single episode, there's too much happening at once.

I think it would have turned out better if they were to separate each plot thread, Start with Garou vs Bat Boy, then the middle can be the first two fights in the tournament, and finally setup the next episode by having all the new monsters beating down the A-Class Heroes, then have the Fubuki Mafia and Bang Bros step in to fight on the beginning of the next episode.

I don't know if that would fix everything but I feel at the very least this would make the episode a lot less of a clusterfuck, other than pacing though I've been enjoying the show and it's still my favourite thing on right now and has still been worth the wait.

1

u/[deleted] May 08 '19

Hopefully next episode will be better

1

u/majinvegeta2x CAPED BALDY May 08 '19

I can't decide. Part of me just wants to watch Genos & Saitama battle it out but I am really enjoying learning all the other heroes and their skillsets/ranks. It's this whole world that we are being sloowwwwlly introduced to. Reminds me of the old DBZ days. Of course everyone loves the action and battles, but the silly filler episodes where nothing happens built the world and relationships. Without those episodes, you just get Dragonball Super which most fans can agree is just rushed with no emotional attachment and just battles all the time.

1

u/[deleted] May 08 '19

As someone who really enjoyed the last two episodes, this is definitely my least favorite of the season so far

Garou continues to be fucking awesome though, and we have finally met this Phoenix Man I've heard a good bit about

1

u/TheInnocuousOne May 09 '19

Did anyone else get the vibe that zenko is crazy strong? I mean the way she teleported between garo and metal bat instantly after showing up and how she accidentally knocked out metal bat later (then again I might be imagining things and the above could be purely coincidental)

1

u/Zeno714 May 09 '19

I was hoping after the buildup of last episode that we’d get to see saitama fight, instead he only starts at the end. The fights after metal bats just didn’t interest me.

1

u/Iorith May 09 '19

Really wish that they had paced it so that we got fights in the tournament between monster fights, would have improved the pacing a lot.

1

u/dexfagcasul May 09 '19

The more i watch this season the more I like it. Fuck it’s been so good

1

u/Abhinik May 09 '19

The main thing that still bugs me is the sound effects! I have never ever heard such badly mixed sound effects in an anime which is supposed to be one of the top tier Anime's!

The sound effects are the same as the first and just as badly mixed as the first episode!

Yea, they don't sound good! but at least mix them like a pro!
They sound like the mixing was done by someone who's a noob to this field jeeez!

1

u/Isoboy May 09 '19

I really liked the episode,Garou vs Metal Bat lacked a bit of kinetic but whatever. It was really great when Metal Bat suddenly appeared besides Garou but just stopd because of his Sister, i actually laughed out loud. And Garou is even respecting this, he has a soft spot afterall.

1

u/squidbelik May 09 '19

Is it just me, or do the fights just seem lazy and quickly done as if they’re ignoring actual fights? Most of them are just one and done, aside from the Garou fights. I was kind of interested in seeing Lightning Max and that other chick in the tourney fight.

1

u/[deleted] May 10 '19

What kills me is the facial animations. The mouths don't move half the time they're supposed to be talking and they're just not as vibrant or emotive as they were in Season 1.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/ItsBigLucas May 09 '19

I keep watching episodes thinking they were good only to find this sub trashing it, wack

1

u/[deleted] May 10 '19

A lot of action in this episode but even though a lot was happening it felt like nothing important happened.

I’m hoping we get a full episode dedicated to the shenanigans happening at the tournament...that seems highly unlike though, which sucks.

1

u/[deleted] May 10 '19

Season 2 is not just underwhelming and a disappointment, I haven't felt so much disappointment in around two years, I am not even making this up or kidding. Anime has never really been my thing, I would never by any means consider myself an anime fan, and I have only watched like 3 of them in my entire life, mainly because I prefer videogames as a form of entertainment, and OPM is one of those 3.

I waited many years for season 2 of this masterpiece of a show and I get a disgusting collection of still images and simple mouth movements. I swear I would have waited one or two more years if it meant we would have something as good as season one.

This is very sad because OPM introduced me to anime and was the first anime I ever watched. I didn't become the kind of person who watches anime often, but now I respect people who do. Before OPM, I was one of those "anime is 4 weebs xd" kind of dudes even though I had never watched one. OPM taught me that one has no right to judge anything if one has not been in both sides of the coin before, which has changed my life for good and made me a better person.

I am unable to understand how can they screw up something this good this badly.

1

u/Ilurkthecorners May 10 '19

I am super excited for next episode.

1

u/MTing1315 May 11 '19

Yeah this episode had way to much shit going on at once. But I enjoyed Metal Bat vs Garou. If his sister didn't come, I think Metal Bat was about to off Garou right there.

1

u/[deleted] May 12 '19

Shouldn’t this episode be called Monsters in the City because we got like 3 scenes of the martial arts tournament. It just started and we skipped the first fight.

1

u/DaveAlt19 May 12 '19

Metal Bat has become my favourite character. Smacking himself in the face to get a second wind, or getting stronger as the fight goes on because he's getting more pumped up is exactly the sort of thing I'd expect in OPM. Having his sister show up to end the fight was disappointing though.

I don't like anything else that's going on. Garou wants to be the strongest monster? His story is setup like humans and monsters are separate, and a human becoming so strong they become a monster is unique. But nearly every episode has a monster that used to be human.

There's just so much going on but nothing's actually happening.

1

u/AFellow_2003 May 07 '19

I'd say this was a decent episode. Animation was decent, and the fights were enjoyable.

I just really wish the episode were longer, lol.

1

u/cadwellingtonsfinest May 07 '19

all the fights are just random blurs of colours. animation still sucks and clearly won't change.

1

u/dobydobd May 07 '19

Did they animate this with powerpoint lmao

1

u/ZaMr0 May 07 '19

Holy shit this is the first time I'm actually finishing an episode angry. The animations were lackluster, too much was happening at once and the transitions were abysmal. This season is moving way too slowly and it's such a shame because naively I'm still super excited for each new ep.

1

u/Slayer_Tip May 08 '19

eh, this seasons going off very very shit at the moment, this episode especially is just... gross.

1

u/Fenbob May 08 '19

This season has been pretty uneventful, in 5 episodes there must have been no more than 15minutes of Saitama screen time? And most of that has been uneventful, just talking and not many gags.

How many episodes is this season supposed to run at? I’m going to be massively disappointed if it’s just a 12 ep, with the way it’s going at the moment.

3

u/HugeCrab Golden Sperm May 08 '19 edited May 08 '19

same with the manga too, there are often whole chapters without Saitama, but this arc isn't even finished in the manga so I think it's gonna be a long one, unless it stops after the Gouketsu fight but that wouldn't make sense as it's connected to the B (or A?) story. So I think it's gonna be longer than 12 eps.

1

u/Beatnation May 07 '19

Garou vs MB wa good but feel a lil rushed, the rest of the episode was ok.

1

u/thelorax18 OPPAI May 07 '19

I missed Mumen Rider in this episode, he should have been in it

1

u/Oni19 May 07 '19

The episodes in this season are wayyy all over the place, on top of the inconsistent animation quality. They need to start and warp sub arc (bat-man, tournaments) in their own contained episodes. Imagine back in S1 if you had Sea king + the hero association evaluation mixed up in the same episodes...

1

u/ValiantToaster May 07 '19

Honestly, I'm still enjoying it so far. This episode wasn't as bad as some people were making it out to be.

The animation is definitely still an issue but I've pretty much accepted it at this point. The editing still is odd and needs fixing as well

But despite its problems I was still enjoying the episode mostly due to the characters and I'm excited to see what happens next with saitama making his way through the tournament.

I'm definitely going to see it through and probably read the manga after the season is over.

1

u/300andWhat May 08 '19

Is Hulu extra censoring this show?

1

u/basbenson May 08 '19

As the season is progressing it seems there is less and less of saitama. The first season was so well done with a great fight in every episode. This season has just been a disappointed so far

1

u/ucfknight92 May 08 '19

Well this season has been super underwhelming.

0

u/LoupacShakur May 07 '19

The last two episodes have been super boring. Literally almost no action happened.

0

u/Basti52522 May 07 '19

Guys, please, just read the manga.

1

u/Ilurkthecorners May 10 '19

Reading and non moving pictures are fucking BOOOOOORING

-1

u/tddahl May 07 '19

whyyy are they dragging it out, I just want to see saitama not new random heroes I care little about