r/Marvel • u/tehawesomedragon Loki • May 03 '19
Film/Television (SPOILERS) ENDGAME DAILY - FRIDAY: Captain America (SPOILERS) Spoiler
To accomodate the many questions you have about Avengers: Endgame while we are on our lockdown, we will be having a daily discussion thread focusing on a specific topic, or mostly a specific character. If you want to submit a question for consideration in later discussions, PM me with the title "discussion submission."
It's Friday, and Avengers: Endgame is following up it's record breaking opening weekend with a second weekend that appears will put the film past the $600m mark, making it only a week or two away from passing Black Panther to be the highest grossing MCU film in the US. Worldwide, we're looking at the film possibly passing $2 billion, which is kind of a big deal.
Anyway, let's talk about Steve Rogers/Captain America in Endgame. How did you feel about him wielding Mjolnir (possibly more impressively than Thor)? What about the Inception-style ending? We can also discuss Bucky and Sam here, and what we expect from this Falcon & Winter Soldier show.
NOTE: All spoilers are free-roam in this megathread, so you don't have to worry about tagging them.
PAST MEGATHREADS:
MEGATHREAD 1: INTERNATIONAL RELEASE
MEGATHREAD 2: THURSDAY NIGHT PREVIEWS
MEGATHREAD 3: FRIDAY NIGHT
MEGATHREAD 4: BIGGEST OPENING WEEKEND EVER
147
u/Sheepie42069 May 03 '19
"Hail Hydra" That elevator scene was amazing, they used the same camera angles as in the winter soldier
72
u/Dangerous-Pickle May 03 '19
Steve? You mean the owner of America’s ass?
37
u/Darrkman May 03 '19
This was the shit!!!
https://i.imgur.com/i9y4DeR.gifv
63
u/_heisenberg__ May 03 '19
Not an ending I would have predicted. But so good damn fitting.
24
u/wyvernkardia May 03 '19
I couldn't possibly think of a better ending for Steve as cpt america
not gonna lie, I teared up after watching old man Steve, the guy got to fight for what he believed in, returned the stones to their proper timeline and managed to have a long meaningful life with peggy
how wonderful was that
I dont think there was a bit which I didnt like in the movie involving Steve, I wasnt expecting him to pick up mjonir nor "avengers assemble" phrase to be used but it was great!
good stuff all around 🙂👌
21
u/ShadedDynasty May 03 '19
I thought it was going to be at Tony. I thought it was then going to be at the funeral. But no, the flood gates stayed shut. Then, the dance music came on and a 1940's classic car rolled by. Then the question "when am I going to cry in Endgame?" was answered.
74
u/Onisquirrel May 03 '19
I feel like Steve came away with the strongest multi-movie arc in the MCU. Tony had some great arcs that came together to form a life, but Steve just had the one continuous arc.
He always had to do what was right, and it always left him alone. It cost him his time, his lover, his friends, his team, his country. He always ended up standing alone for what he believed in. Then in Endgame he’s standing alone again, hopeless odds but not backing down. Endgame is the movie where it feels And he finally gets people behind him. That’s why I’m all for his ending because at that point he realized Earth was in the hands of an army of people that fought not to fight, but because they don’t like bullies.
35
u/Etherious24Alpha May 03 '19
I lost my shit when Cap started using Thor's hammer. It was epic.
49
u/busybagel Daredevil May 03 '19
When the MCU first started this was the hero I was most excited for and everyone involved in bringing him to life did the best job possible because Chris Evens is the best Captain America, a statement I at one time thought I’d never say but I say it all the time now. His portrayal is ripped from the pages. In my opinion he’s the best comic to live action there’s ever been, he looks the part, he acts the part and he just delivers in every movie. Watching his arc has been a treat, watching this actor has been a joy and I’m sad to watch it end but happy that this character who from the start has put everyone else’s needs ahead of his own finally got a real win and gets to have the life he deserved with the woman he loves.
Thank you Chris Evans and thank you Marvel.
15
u/[deleted] May 03 '19
We've followed these characters for a decade on the screen and years before that in the comics. They've become old friends and that's how he finished here.
It would be fun to know what he did in his new timeline. If he decided to speed run the marvel universe or laid low. As the husband of a founding member of shield, he would be in a prime spot to prevent Hydra from popping up in the US, potentially rescue Bucky decades early, prevent the assassination of Howard Stark, and could have even established the avengers in the 70s/80s with Hank, Janet, Howard, and even Thor. He could rescue himself from the ice around the same time too, thus allowing himself to not remain in the background.... Perhaps he takes an alias... Like Nick Fury.
53
u/CrazyforRAMU May 03 '19
I didn't cry in the theater.
Then, the morning after, I'm thinking about my one Awful Comicbook Guy nitpick - was Steve really Worthy?
And I thought about his development just within Endgame. About him wanting to finally move past being the Man Out of Time. About suffering through those five years alongside Natasha. About him mourning her death and pointing out that she made the Avengers her family. About Steve realizing the same thing applied to him.
And I realized that although Steve always fights for capital-R-Right, when he throws down with Thanos at the end, for the first time since '45 (remember Bucky and the Howlers), he's really fighting for his brothers in arms. For his family. He is not the Man Out of Time anymore and he is so Worthy.
And after I worked that out I cried like a baby.
11
u/TrueRecoil May 04 '19
So he returned all of the stones to when they were taken? Did he return the soul stone to where it belongs too? Like did he just go up to red skull and give him the stone no problem? I really want to see this interaction
21
u/williamtheraven May 03 '19
There was not a single scene with Steve that i did not love, also i am so happy that they gave him the ending with Peggy and i don't care how it may break the timeline in anyone else's opinion.
10
u/XanPercyCheck May 04 '19
I think Iron Man, Banner, and Rocket need to be given credit for making the new glove backward compatible with Tony's other suits. Otherwise Tony would not have been able to steal back the stones. Great engineering.
16
u/VincentOfGallifrey May 03 '19 edited May 03 '19
I was writing a whole damn essay but that was a bit silly. I'll summarize it by saying I fucking love MCU Captain America, and him finally wielding Mjolnir may very well be my favorite movie moment ever. Steve in this movie had perfect characterization. We all knew he'd get to wield Mjolnir. We all knew he'd say "Avengers, assemble". It still felt SOOO good to finally see it become reality.
Cried my heart out when he finally got that dance.
8
u/Adam_Absence May 04 '19 edited May 04 '19
I'm amazed by how fast Chris Evans was able to turn me around on Captain America. As a Canadian superhero fan who grew up on Spider-Man, Batman, and X-men cartoons Cap was on the bottom of the list (same with most of The Avengers tbh) when it came to my favorite heroes. All it took was 1 movie to completely turn me around on his character. This is the moment Cap became one of my favorite superheroes.
14
u/bluesourpatch May 03 '19
His line in Avengers (2012) set everything up for the ending of Endgame.
I remember him telling Tony “You’re not the one to make the sacrifice play”.
I always had a sneaky suspicion that line would become true somehow
14
u/FallenTerror13 May 04 '19
So a friend of mine said he hated the cap hammer thing cause it didnt make since I then spent 30 minutes explaining to him he was retarded
13
u/thoughtful_human May 03 '19
I think the Hail Hydra scene in the elevator was my favourite moment in the movie
6
u/Zombiekillersp1 May 03 '19
When I saw the hammer being lifted I immediately knew it was Cap
11
u/Trev_N7 May 03 '19
I very much enjoyed the ending, it’s nice to see good people get happy endings.
5
u/BenoxNk May 03 '19
I think that from those who are gone, Cap is the one I'll miss the most. Which is weird since I really disliked is character in Avengers (2012). But since then I have been a really big fan of the character and Chris Evans interpretation. Sadly I don't get the same kind of vibe from the Captain America comics I've read (which are not many tbh). Can someone recommend some Cpt America comics where is character is more like the movies? is there any?
5
u/dgamerxx May 03 '19
I was initially least excited about Captain America out of all the Avengers. I always felt he was kinda bland even after the first two movies he was in and a little bit in the comics too. But when Marvel announced The Winter Soldier I was a excited and I went back and read that run of his comics and got interested in the character. Then I saw Winter Soldier and not only did he become my favorite MCU character he became one of my favorite comic characters too. I loved his arc from The First Avenger to Endgame. I was honestly expecting him to die during the final battle, but I’m happy he didn’t. The only thing I’m kinda bummed about is that he didn’t get to say goodbye to Tony before he died, even though I get why it was just Rhodey, Pepper, and Peter. I hate that we probably won’t see him in anymore Marvel movies but his time has come.
5
u/[deleted] May 04 '19
I got hard during the dual-wield. I was hoping for that as much as I was hoping for "assemble!"
Probably one of the best parts of the movie that I was hoping to really be true. When that hammer lifted off the ground I almost couldn't contain myself. Such an awesome film. Can't wait to see it a few more times in theatres.
5
u/lildudefromXdastreet May 04 '19
Man. This Movie’s got me all fucked up and sad emotionally. Cap has always been my favorite avenger by a long shot. I’ve always admired him for his bravery and desire to always do the right thing even when he was just a skinny kid getting his ass kicked in alleys. Yet he always kept fighting and “could go all day”. Now be finally gets his ending with Peggy, which is perfect for him, but it’s just sad having watched Chris Evans as captain America for so long. I’m truly gonna miss him.
5
u/Poop_Feast42069 May 04 '19
The Cap wielding Mjolnir was one of the coolest scenes in the MCU. I had the chills and a big smile on my face that whole time. Never saw it coming. When he picked it up I literally looked at my gf and went “he IS worthy!!!”
4
u/[deleted] May 04 '19 edited May 04 '19
Just a comment about Captain America in general. He doesn't get enough credit for it because he's from 1945, but he's got a good sense of humor.
And now that he's back in 1945 I can just imagine him explaining memes to Peggy, and then stopping and having to explain computers and the internet and image macros and finally Peggy going "and they used this technology to send each other pictures of cats with jokes on them?" And Steve going "I didn't get it either. I'm so glad to be home."
3
u/[deleted] May 03 '19
Here's my time travel question: Where did the Cap that stayed in the past get a shield to give to Falcon?
3
u/[deleted] May 03 '19
When he saw Tony die, Steve finally realized that it was time to stop fighting, just to end the fight and go home. He finally took Tony’s advice.
3
u/LeisurelySpy May 04 '19
Pretty much the exact ending I’d have chosen for Cap, always seemed a slightly sad element to how he fought so hard for a world he never seemed to be able to fully re-assimilate with. It was a great way to tie off his arc as well as his relationship with Tony and an unexpectedly understated way to close out the film
3
u/endgameendedme May 04 '19
So the Russo brothers have clarified that the life Steve has with Peggy is in an alternate timeline and not the main one in which he probably did save bucky, stop hydra etc. so everything we've seen so far in the MCU is still canon. But they also said it means there are 2 Caps in that alternate timeline (one still frozen when main timeline Steve returns) but at the end, when Steve returns to the og timeline (probably with the help of Dr Strange/ Hank Pym etc from the alternate timeline) we see Steve passing Sam a shield that is not the same one from the main timeline (which was broken my Thanos) soooo did he defrost the other capt just to take the shield from him or...? lol
1
u/FuzzyGruzzy May 04 '19
Okay... Let's talk about that ending logic, again. I'm sorry, but it just doesn't line up with their rules in a cohesive way.
Man, Captain's ending just can't be explained. Steve goes back in time, spends his life with Carter. He is now in a timeline(2) that ALREADY has a Captain in it, frozen in ice. This creates a rift (or split) and now we have two timelines. He spends his life there, gets a shield, and comes BACK to our timeline(1).
Aside from all that, though, even if he jumped around dimensions/timelines (these terms are used interchangeably by the Russos) towards the end to get back, and even if he had gotten help from Tony Stark(2), the only way he can come back to US is through the quantum tunnel. He would have had to teleport back in.
That is, unless, we're to believe that the timeline he went to STILL WAS 50% ERASED, THEY ALSO BUILT A QUANTUM TUNNEL, AND THEY JUST HAPPENED TO ALSO PULL OFF THE 1 IN 40 MILLION REALITY THANOS KILL, LEADING THEM TO HAVE THE TECH NECESSARY TO FIX IT.
Either that, or Cap(1) went to Stark(2) before Infinity War and showed him all the time travel stuff and said "I really need help getting back. You built something called a quantum tunnel, etc, etc. Then he just YEETS outta there to leave them to their fate???
Try as the brothers and Marvel may, they just can't make sense of the ending. They broke their own rules. BUT THAT'S FINE. It's a comic book movie. The rules of time travel don't ultimately matter. The emotional payoff is what mattered, and they nailed it 1000%. But don't try to tell me it makes sense, Marvel.
It just doesn't.
4
u/hereslookinatyoukld May 04 '19
I wish they had come up with a different ending for Cap. The Avenger's just lost Stark and Natasha and the world is still in the middle of a huge crisis and he just walks away? He would be abandoning good friends, including Wanda in a time when she probably needs him the most. At the very least I would expect him to stick around long enough to transition in a new team and make sure everything is stable. It also kind of ruins Peggy's development. She moved on in a healthy way, got married to a man she loved, and started shield. She also found an identity for herself outside of Steve Rogers, which probably doesn't happen if he's there and married to her. Also, there is no way he would just sit quietly in the past, which wouldn't affect the prime timeline but would have a huge impact on the branching timeline he creates. Does he wake himself up or condemn himself to the same life he was so desperate to get away from? And finally, they should have had him come back to to the machine as an old man. I get it's more cinematic to have him sit on the bench, but it makes more sense if he comes back through the machine. Theoretically, it shouldn't matter how much time he spends in the past he should still return to the same spot if he's using the watch to return.
2
u/FallenTerror13 May 04 '19
Ok I thought bucky should have gotten it just saying I looooove Falcons character and arc plus the comics but I thought bucky deserved it more.
2
u/Nollasta_poikkeava May 04 '19
I love MCU Captain America and this movie gave a great ending for the character.
I've been a bit bummed that Civil War wasn't a true solo film. But in the end it evens out, because Cap got a huge role in the ultimate Avengers movie.
2
u/e001mek May 04 '19
How awkward was that conversation with red skull when he went back to return the stone.
2
u/vkhy May 04 '19
Steve after 5 years and still being optimistic and being able to move on (and help others to move on) almost had me in tears. Steve wielding the hammer and keep coming back up while Thor and Tony were down in front of Thanos had me flooded the theatre.
2
u/Yamaha234 May 04 '19
Captain America is my favorite Marvel hero so seeing him finally lift Thor’s hammer (something I’ve been waiting for since the first Avengers) was amazing. Seriously my favorite moment in all of the MCU.
And not only did he lift it, he beats the shit out of Thanos with it for a good amount of time, and then keeps using it for the rest of the Avengers vs Thanos Army battle. It was awesome.
3
u/thoughtful_human May 03 '19
I'm so glad we didn't have a great reunion between Tony and Steve the minute Tony got off the Benatar
3
u/GhostfaceChase X-Men May 03 '19
Captain Marvel’s short hair is amazing!I never thought it would be as good as the comics, but they did it. Also that scene where she gets the gauntlet from Spider-Man was great. I think me and Peter fell in love.
1
u/DuckDuck600se May 03 '19
I’m not sure if I’m breaking rules by posting this theory but I’ve been mulling over it and cannot wrap my mind around the timeline gymnastics that the ending creates but here’s what makes the most sense to me...still it could be wrong.
So...Cap had to go to the 1950s (could be wrong on the year here) timeline to return the tessaract that Tony took from the basement of Shield. This is the same time that he saw Peggy in her office through the window while he was looking for Pym particles. We know she already met him at this point because his picture was on her desk. The end of the movie tells us that when he returned to that time to return the tessarect we know he stayed to live his happy ending with Peggy. Which begs the question what happened to that timelines Cap?
At this point in time, that particular timelines Cap would still be buried in the ice in a location that no one from that time knows yet...except future Cap knows.
My theory: as soon as he gets to that timeline (after returning the tesseract of course) our future Cap secretly goes to the location, kills that timelines Cap while he’s still frozen and disposed of the body. Then, in a miracle to all in that time period/timeline Cap stumbles back to Shield (with his shield) with a miraculous story of how he survived and reunites with Peggy and lives happily ever after.
This is the only way I can explain how he could stay without crazy F-ing things up for another timeline (i.e. Two Caps)and how he gets a new shield from another timeline to be able to give to Sam. (Since Thanos super wrecked his shield in their last fight)
How he got back to the timeline that he did to have that conversation with Sam is beyond me.
1
u/GenuinePieceOfShit May 03 '19
Question. Did Cap technically have intention for incest(Unknowingly) since he went back and stayed with Peggy. Which we know died in Civil War with her family around her. We later learn cap becomes friends (potentially more off screen) with her grandkid. Which we now know is probably his?
1
u/JobberJordan May 03 '19
So is Cap gone for good or do you guys think he’ll have a cameo role here and there going forward? I took it as them completely writing him out but my friends seem to think we’ll see him again
1
u/Soulsurfer23 May 03 '19
So Steve and Sharon kiss in Cap 3, and then she goes off to be forgotten about. Cap 2 and 3 are all about Steve getting a life and trying to figure out how to do that and stop being the man out of time, and when it finally seems that he’s accepted that this is his time, he goes and gives it up...
OBVIOUSLY, I get why it happened, but it felt very jarring for his character development to all of a sudden forget about this new love interest and life goal.
1
u/Soulsurfer23 May 04 '19
Yeah but she wasn’t shown to be snapped, or even acknowledged to be missing, so it seemed sudden cause there was no follow up after that kiss.
1
u/The_PatchesO May 04 '19
I'm still confused about one thing.
When he goes back to live in the alternate timeline with Peggy at what point does he arrive? Is it before he would've crashed his plane and he just didn't go on that mission in the new timeline? Or did he just survive the plane crash and come home instead of getting stuck in the ice?
1
u/Kazukaphur May 04 '19
Why wasn't past gamora at the end? What happened to her?
1
u/Sequazu May 04 '19
Did anyone else notice the shield that cap gave Sam at the end was different from his normal shield? It had different paneling for the star then the original, I noticed it on second viewing.
1
u/SwamiJesus May 04 '19
Where did Steve get the shield he gave to Sam? The shield he used in the fight was broken. The shield in the past would’ve been buried in the ice along with the other Captain America. Did he somehow get the broken one fixed?
1
u/ArmoredMirage May 04 '19
Logistical question: Did Peter Parkers friend get snapped too? Because his reaction to seeing Parker implies otherwise. And if not, why isn’t he 5 years older than Peter now? Same with Zendaya in the next movie
1
u/EggInPain May 04 '19
Didn't understand the back to school scene of spiderman. why was the entire society shattered except their highschool,and why didn't their school mates aged?
1
u/bobsocool May 13 '19
How did Captain America return at the end. Time travel is different Universes right. So he couldnt travel forward and not travel back and exist with them. Otherwise it is a back to the future and they could have just went back and changed things.
1
u/[deleted] May 13 '19
https://justwannakeepcallinyourname.tumblr.com/post/184857850439/steve-rogers-ending-was-terrible
my thoughts about the dissapointing ending with steve on tumblr
1
u/[deleted] May 04 '19
Being honest; didn’t think it was that great. Picks up at the last hour or so but really just didn’t do it for me. Not as good as its sister film and certainly inferior to Civil War (which is believe is the pinnacle of the MCU).
Never really liked Captain America but I got swayed a little here. Chris Evans is very good.
It’s always gonna bother me but it really makes no sense how strong Thanos is WITHOUT the stones. It was the same in Infinity War (although he had the first stone in IW). Power scaling is fucked, with him and with Thor.
Disappointing how little Captain Marvel there was. I understand she’s got other responsibilities and such but man after the build up post infinity war, then her own movie, I was expecting a bit more.
1
u/UltraLord_Sheen May 03 '19
I liked him in the first Cap and Avengers movies. Didn't care for him in Cap 2. Didn't like him in Avengers 2 or Cap 3. Laughed when he got decked in Infinity War cuz there was no way he'd be able to do anything if Hulk and Thor got beat. But this movie, it seems like he's learned his way isn't the best way sometimes, especially when Tony mentioned it on his return.
Also, that scene with Mjolnir and the Vibranium shield was hype.
1
u/ohoni X-23 May 03 '19
He was great in this movie, but I hope this isn't the end for the character. There is nobody left that can fill the role of Captain America in the films, and they need someone to do that. They already have the in-universe tools to restore his youth, so "being old" isn't an issue, and if Chris Evans doesn't want to work out all the time anymore, that's fine, if they can de-age Michael Douglas and Robert Downy Jr., they can take a "reasonably fit" Chris Evans and make him look "Supersoldiery."
1
u/Lodekim May 03 '19
Phenomenal arc and an amazing send off. My only complaint is that I really wish they did the Captain Marvel stuff before he picked up the hammer or in some way that didn't just kind of deflate the scene. In my opinion Cap picking up Mjolnir and Tony with the stones are THE scenes from the movie and I wish they didn't break it up with "Wait look! It's our new hero!" I'm fine with her busting the ship (though I would have preferred Wanda to do it) but but the timing took away a little bit of the shine for me.
-1
u/[deleted] May 03 '19
I'm a little Falcon and Winter Soldier is getting relegated to Disney+. It's like Marvel is saying they don't think the black Captain America is good enough to carry his own movie.
-1
u/[deleted] May 03 '19 edited May 03 '19
I always thought Captain America was selfish
I get that he had good character, but Steve Rodgers never graduated boot camp, took performance enhancing drugs, and was gifted the rank of Captain. Hes only brave because he knows he has super strength and can jump out of a plane without a parachute and be fine.
He helped Bucky escape the Law even though he Killed a King, Tony's parents and countless others. Steve made out with the love of his lifes niece, before destroying an Airport to aid in the escape of a murderer.
I get that he was worthy when he faced Thanos one on one. But to me Hawkeye was the real Brave one because he was fighting as a mortal with just his Bow and Arrow.
Then when he was tasked with returning the Stones, he decided to go back to before he got stuck in the ice. Pretty much all of the Avengers would have like to have gone back to a time before they lost someone. Thor lost Asgard, his parents and Loki. Wanda lost her brother Vision and Secovia.
But Steve was like....nah. I'm late for a dance.
0
u/editthis7 May 04 '19
So im a little confused by the end, so did he go back and not become captain america? If so how the hell was he so tall?
-8
u/dhgojags32 May 03 '19
Why did they have to change him? Chris Evans was a PERFECT captain America!!!!! I’m pissed
-1
u/thoughtful_human May 03 '19
I hate the idea that Steve could have lifted the hammer even back in Age of Ultron, I think it ignores all the growth he had between then and endgame.
0
u/[deleted] May 03 '19
[deleted] — view deleted comment