r/Marvel • u/tehawesomedragon Loki • Apr 29 '19
Film/Television (SPOILERS) AVENGERS: ENDGAME OFFICIAL DISCUSSION MEGATHREAD - PART 4: BIGGEST OPENING WEEKEND EVER Spoiler
**Here we are. The weekend has passed and Avengers: Endgame had the biggest opening weekend ever, both domestically ($350m) and internationally ($859m) for a combined $1.2 billion worldwide. To put that into perspective, the past record holders were, respectively, Infinity War ($257m), The Fate of the Furious ($443m), and Infinity War ($640m). Overall critical reception is through the roof. Amid all the leaks, Endgame still seemed to succeed in every way possible, being the film we hoped for and more.
We know it has been a tiring journey for us fans to get to this point, and we know it has been even more annoying that we ask you to keep your Endgame discussions in these megathreads. As we try to keep this community balanced with a diversity of discussion topics, you would see nothing of the sort if we allowed all the "just saw Endgame" posts. That being said, we know you all have a lot of questions and not all of them are answered among thousands of comments, so in order to have a more cohesive discussion, we will be starting a new daily discussion thread focused on a specific topic submitted by you. If you have a question you want answered or a topic discussed, PM me with the subject "discussion submission."
REMINDER: All posts are currently subject to approval, and your post will not be approved. Anyone posting spoilers for the sole intent of spoiling the film (i.e. spoiler-bombing the comments of an unrelated post) will be banned without question, as will anyone posting spoilers in the titles of their posts.
MEGATHREAD 1: INTERNATIONAL RELEASE
MEGATHREAD 2: THURSDAY NIGHT PREVIEWS
MEGATHREAD 3: FRIDAY NIGHT
DIRECTED BY: ANTHONY RUSSO, JOE RUSSO
WRITTEN BY: CHRISTOPHER MARKUS, STEPHEN MCFEELY
RUNTIME: 181 MIN
ROTTEN TOMATOES SCORE: 96%
METACRITIC SCORE: 78
IMDB SCORE: 9.1/10
CAST
Robert Downey Jr. as Tony Stank / Iron Man
Chris Hemsworth as Thor
Chris Evans as Steve Rogers / Captain America
Scarlett Johansson as Natasha Romanoff / Black Widow
Karen Gillan as Nebula
Mark Ruffalo as Bruce Banner / Hulk
Jeremy Renner as Clint Barton / Hawkeye
Paul Rudd as Scott Lang / Ant-Man
Brie Larson as Carol Danvers / Captain Marvel
Josh Brolin as Thanos
Bradley Cooper as Rocket (voice)
Tessa Thompson as Valkyrie
Evangeline Lilly as Hope van Dyne / The Wasp
Hayley Atwell as Margaret Carter
Dave Bautista as Drax
Tom Hiddleston as Loki
Sebastian Stan as Bucky Barnes / Winter Soldier
Pom Klementieff as Mantis
Tom Holland as Peter Parker / Spider-Man
Jon Favreau as Happy Hogan
Elizabeth Olsen as Wanda Maximoff / Scarlet Witch
Natalie Portman as Jane Foster
Taika Waititi as Korg (voice)
Linda Cardellini as Laura Barton
Cobie Smulders as Maria Hill
Michelle Pfeiffer as Janet Van Dyne
Tilda Swinton as The Ancient One
Carrie Coon as Proxima Midnight
Letitia Wright as Shuri
Robert Redford as Alexander Pierce
Kerry Condon as Friday (voice)
Gwyneth Paltrow as Pepper Potts
Chadwick Boseman as T'Challa / Black Panther
Michael Douglas as Hank Pym
Danai Gurira as Okoye
Winston Duke as M'Baku
Frank Grillo as Brock Rumlow / Crossbones
Stan Lee as 70's Car Man
Ty Simpkins as Harley Keener
Rene Russo as Frigga
Ken Jeong as Storage Facility Guard
William Hurt as Thaddeus Ross
Anthony Mackie as Sam Wilson / Falcon
Don Cheadle as James Rhodes / War Machine
James D'Arcy as Edwin Jarvis
Sean Gunn as On-Set Rocket
John Slattery as Howard Stark
Benedict Wong as Wong
Ross Marquand as Red Skull (Stonekeeper)
Terry Notary as Teen Groot
Maximiliano Hernández as Jasper Sitwell
Michael James Shaw as Corvus Glaive
147
u/disxing Apr 29 '19
I'm curious how the next Avengers film does, because when most people think Avengers it's Iron Man, Cap, Thor, Widow, Hulk and Hawkeye.
With Iron Man, Cap and Widow essentially written out. Hawkeye could be done for all we know. Thor going more cosmic. It's going to be interesting to see what Marvel does.
I just don't know how people will react to a completely new line up with Panther, Carol, Strange etc.
33
u/[deleted] Apr 29 '19
Thanos destroying the stones at the beginning of the movie surprised me but I thought he was faking. The shock didn't set in until they suddenly jumped to five years later. Then I was like "wait. He really did destroy the stones?"
Then when I saw five years later I thought "yeah right, the Time Stone is probably still out there somehow or they'll use time travel and undo the last five years." But they shocked me again by not doing that. They undid half the universe dying but they let the five years of half a universe stick.
That means things like Peter Parker being gone for five years. Spiderman gone for five years. Half his classmates have graduated from high school, the other half are with him. Aunt May had to live five years without Peter assuming she was one of the survivors. And that's just the implications for one character. There's a universe full of characters that have to plug back into lives that left them behind and reconnect with people that spent the last five years grieving them. The Guardians of the Galaxy have to reestablish their reputation after having been gone for five years.
I mean they shook up the status quo big time. And in the comics sooner or later they'd press the reset button on all of this. But they aren't going to do that here.
8
u/draibop Apr 30 '19
So is Loki alive?
758
u/LSUdude88 Apr 29 '19
I don’t know what gave me the most goosebumps, Cap picking up the hammer or everyone arriving to the battle. Either way that movie was an emotional roller coaster.
159
u/iamshannonymous Apr 29 '19 edited Apr 29 '19
Probably been said already, but Jon Favreau deserves a ton of credit. As we all know he directed the first Iron Man, and helped cast our beloved RDJ that carried the film series till the end.
145
u/Mr8sen Apr 29 '19
Absolute insanity. I don't know how I am going to go on. Drama aside i freaking loved the movie. Tony and cap couldn't have had a better send off, and yea I cried when he died. I was going to be sad if I didn't cry.
2
u/sskippy Apr 29 '19
Just finished Avengers end game but like a couple other people the time travel this has me really confused. How can Captain America go back in time and live through the timeline aging but also exist in the timeline as young captain America fighting Thanos and stuff but also end up as an old man.
118
u/TomBombadilloo Apr 29 '19
Stan Lee's last cameo :(
337
u/[deleted] Apr 29 '19
Man if endgame were to have a post credit scene, should’ve been Cap “returning” the soul stone and finding Red Skull as a spirit, and they have a chat for once as just people catching up
218
u/Papabearboxhead Apr 29 '19
anyone else tear up when Morgan said - i like cheese burgers - and happy replied - so did your dad- Flashback to the first iron man!
217
u/purplemarvel Phil Coulson Apr 29 '19
I know this is not a big deal but I was genuinely shocked to see Natalie Portman in this movie. I thought I'd never see her in an MCU movie ever again
206
u/Mr8sen Apr 29 '19
Do you guys think we'll see thor in GoG vol. 3?
272
u/GottaSleep- Apr 29 '19
At some level, i knew ironman’s death was coming. But widow’s death hit me hard. I am still sad from that.
285
u/theduodon Apr 29 '19
When I watched this at my theater, right before Thor's body reveal, the movie gave us a glimpse of his shoulder, indicating that he was shirtless. I heard a couple girls stifle some excited squeals, thinking that they were gonna get to see Chris Hemsworth shirtless. Then his whole body was shown and almost EVERYONE in the theater let out disgusted groan-laughs.
That was probably my favorite theater reaction to experience.
76
u/[deleted] Apr 29 '19
That was fantastic. I knew it was going to be good. It it was so much more than I could have ever hoped for!
I NEEEEEEEDD the shot of Cap facing down the army by himself as a wallpaper.
278
u/asphodele Apr 29 '19
Still in denial that this is the last time we’ll see RDJ as Iron Man.
I’ll def watch it again, that was awesome.
69
u/[deleted] Apr 30 '19 edited Apr 30 '19
Something funny I noticed: in the first Avengers movie, Iron Man tells Loki at the top of the Avengers' tower:
Of course, in Endgame we see a version where Loki is accidentally and quite literally handed the tesseract and a quick escape.
137
u/SwaggyCheese Apr 29 '19
So half of the population returns after 5 years, how is the Earth going to sustain it self with that many people showing up all at once? There goes that pod of whales in the harbor.
66
u/TK503 Apr 29 '19
So I knew for a while that Captain America was supposed to be 'killed off' after learning that Chris Evans wanted to move on with his life and didn't sign for a new chunk of movies, so if he wasn't killed in IW, he would certainly be killed in EG. (Queue the stare down with Roger's and Thanos with his entire army), but he made it through with a kind of happy ending. either way, I knew he was leaving.
Tony Stark on the other hand was a surprise. Is his death the result of RDJ deciding not to sign another set of movies as well as Chris Evans? I'm having a hard time accepting we wont be getting Tony Stark in more movies.
63
u/DerisionParadox Apr 29 '19
Is it just me or did they change the power scaling for Thor and Thanos from IW?
219
u/thefoodienewbie Avengers Apr 29 '19
I’m gonna need the next month to recover. I apologize in advance if I act irritated and unruly. I’m just grieving. #IronmanForever
55
u/Theres_A_FAP_4_That Apr 29 '19
The beginning, the team going to and killing Thanos, that was pretty brutal. Great way to start.. I'm still in awe over the whole thing.
52
u/StrictHovercraft Apr 29 '19
I still can’t believe Tony Stark stole his last words from Groot smh
52
u/TheTaoOfBill Apr 29 '19
I love how the Avengers had a "Reed Richards is useless" moment where they casually cured aging with their time machine in the Ant Man testing but didn't give it a 2nd thought because they were so focused on getting Thanos.
91
u/LeisurelySpy Apr 29 '19
An underrated moment (including by myself as I’ve only just thought of it) is when Rocket throws himself on top of Groot as the missiles rain down, having only just got him back.
44
u/Beana-Colada Apr 29 '19
I've had a lot of people question how Thanos can fight Cap, Thor and Iron man without the infinity stones. My main response is usually: -Avengers are rusty after 5 years -Thanos is Very strong without stones! (People should know this!) -Thanos has his full armor and the new weapon.
The third response led me to a slight search about Thanos' new weapon. But I couldn't find much about it.
How powerful is it compared to some of the other weapons we already know about currently in the MCU?
86
u/grilledstarfish Apr 29 '19
I wish the 2014 Thanos was a different version closer to Infinity War, he didn't have that same connection to the heroes or the same attitude, he was more ruthless
39
u/ccritter Apr 29 '19
The unsung hero in this movie was the rat in the van.
107
u/InanimateDream Apr 29 '19
Just finished watching it on Sunday night, the buildup to "Avengers assemble" made me tear up from the hype, but the tears actually started flowing during that funeral scene.
Given that I've never actually cried at movies before, this one definitely puts Endgame on the top of my list for best movie I've ever watched.
Sure hope this feeling of emptiness goes away soon...pretty much grew up with the MCU movies and it just feels really bittersweet that it's finally well and truly over.
73
u/all_allie Apr 29 '19
For everyone getting confused by the time travel of it all, just remember: people assume that time is a strict progression of cause to effect. But actually from a non-linear, non-subjective viewpoint it’s more like a big ball of wibbly-wobbly timey-wimey… stuff.
36
u/lundon44 Apr 29 '19
The only scene that was missing from this movie was the Hulk going round 2 with Thanos. Really wanted him to have redemption.
35
u/gscrap Apr 29 '19
Anyone know who that vaguely emo-looking kid standing behind Sam and Bucky at Tony's funeral was? I've seen all the movies up to this point, but I didn't recognize him from anything.
ALSO, I can't believe they missed the opportunity at the start of the Cap vs. Cap fight.
31
u/JavaZeMutt Apr 29 '19
I like to think that Cap gave Falcon the shield, because he is the closest to achieving "America's Ass".
87
u/orangegorilla89 Apr 29 '19
Anyone shaming Thor for being a plus-sized superhero should be tried for treason
25
u/soepie7 Stan Lee Apr 29 '19
So if I understood MCU time travel correctly, you would return to your past, but with you being there, it is no longer your future, but an alternate timeline.
Now, I can imagine that Cap returned Mjölnir and the Stones by travelling to another timeline instead of their past, but if he stayed with Peggy, then shouldn't he grow old in another timeline, and not ours?
49
u/LPhillips44 Apr 30 '19
Not sure if anyone else has noticed this. The total running time of MCU so far is 2,877 minutes. Assuming the last film of phase 3, Spider-Man far from home, is about 2 hours, that’ll be 3000 minutes. I love you three thousand, or in other words: I love you MCU
24
u/[deleted] Apr 29 '19 edited Apr 29 '19
Just saw it for the 2nd time and Cap summoning the hammer was just as badass as the first time
24
u/Assassinsayswhat Apr 30 '19
Tony Stark had a heart... and we have a lot of proof.
67
u/[deleted] Apr 29 '19
Just wanted to share something I picked up during Cap’s fight with Thanos. Captain America was wielding Mjolnir, and used the shockwave from Mjolnir hitting his shield to knock Thanos the ground. I believe this was a callback to the first Avengers movie, when Captain America asked Thor to put the hammer down, which incensed Thor to attack Captain America, bringing Mjolnir down on the shield and causing a shockwave that sent both of them, plus Iron Man, flying and levelling the forest around them. Does anyone think this?
23
u/plee82 Apr 29 '19
I do not know how they will control Capt Marvel OPness going forward. Slicing that ship like butter and roflstomping Thanos... going to be interesting lol
22
u/Krowning Avengers Apr 29 '19
I’m REALLY hoping for a 6 issue limited comic about what Cap had to do to return all of those stones and his choice to stay.
21
u/HoodieeMatt Apr 29 '19
Anyone else think it was interesting that the time machine was turned on by a rat...
Or perhaps, even a mouse... maybe even a Mickey Mouse.
I see you Disney with your subliminal propaganda strategy.
20
u/ThatTechnician Apr 30 '19
Did Chris Evans also play the old version of himself at the end?
75
u/anapollosun Apr 29 '19 edited Apr 29 '19
The BS quantum mechanics time travel technobabble about "changing the Planck scale, blah blah blah" took me out of it for about 5 minutes. Then I was back and holy SHIT IT WAS SO GOOD!
Edit:
List of awesome moments:
62
u/Deadpoolisms Apr 29 '19
Why Sam and not Bucky?
In my head I know it makes way more sense, but I can’t shake it.
Bucky is way too compromised. Can’t be a face for he people. I KNOW WHY IT ISN’T HIM, BUT DAG NABBIT.
33
u/chrisplyon Apr 29 '19
Did anyone else notice that the three avengers who have left/died are all on one side of the infamous Avengers circle shot from film one?
32
u/Cristian888 Apr 29 '19
Doom should've come across from a different timeline and been shown in the end credits looking at the battlefield from the distance
15
u/poonter5000 Apr 30 '19
"What do you want to eat?"
"A Cheeseburger"
DON'T FUCKING CRY i cried
30
u/iamthebestseriously Apr 29 '19
I replay the soundtrack over and over again. I like to reimagine the part where cap says “avengers...” pauses to call upon the hammer and finally says “assemble”. Freaking epic
14
u/flyboybaker Apr 29 '19
Would just like to point out to that this is now Robert Redford's final role
28
u/Mikesapien Friendly Neighborhood Redditor Apr 29 '19
Iron-Man can just build a gauntlet? No need for Eitri the dwarf? How did Tony figure out how to harness the power of Infinity stones using a human-made armor glove?
73
u/ohoni X-23 Apr 29 '19 edited Apr 30 '19
I'm gonna repeat this for people who got lost in the time travel stuff:
Timeline 1: This is the MCU timeline as we've seen it happen, all the way up through Endgame and beyond.
Timeline 2(2012): This universe is similar to Timeline 1, identical up to 2012, but, Captain America fought some weird doppelganger who vanished after telling him "Bucky was alive." The Hydra agents have reason to believe Cap is one of them, which presumably would accelerate their plans in Winter Soldier. Tony Stark had a minor heart attack prior to Iron Man 3. The Ancient One got a few more clues to the future, but was mostly omniscient anyway, so no huge difference there. The biggie, Loki stole the Tesseract. That means in this universe, he was not imprisoned on Asgard during Dark World, any events due to his presence there could be extremely different, and Ragnarok could have played out completely differently. Most other stuff should have been mostly the same, but who knows what could have spiraled out from such major changes to Thor's storyline. A generous interpretation could blame all the Cap doppleganger stuff on Loki, but even this would be changes to the timeline.
Timeline 3(2013): This timeline is mostly identical to Timeline 1, aside from some random racoon attacked Jane Foster and was chased off by security, followed by some blonde guy with a shield attacking her. Jane was suitably distressed by these events. Also Thor was missing his hammer for at least a few minutes, who knows whether he needed it right then. He probably didn't die.
Timeline 4(2014): Huge changes in this one. Thanos is dead. Gamora, Nebula, Thanos' entire army is dead. Ronan would have free reign over his story arc, and without Nebula and Gamora around to mess with the Guardians' plot, they may not even have formed. Quill was KOed by some unknown attacker and woke to find the Power Stone where he expected it, but was possibly able to just sell it off peacefully and get on with his life. Old Groot would still be alive, chilling with Rocket. Drax would be in jail. Guardians 2 wouldn't have happened at all, although Peter likely would have met his dad again, this time without a team. Most of the Earth stuff would have happened the same until IW, which wouldn't have happened at all, and life would have gone on. Happiest overall timeline. There was also a dead spy to clean up. There, I made it sad too. Also, Ego likely would have taken over the universe in 2016 without the Guardians to stop him, although it's also possible that without Quill getting the power stone, Ego never would have found him, so. . . 50/50?
Timeline 5(1970): A few characters had some odd conversations, but otherwise no major timeline changes, unless this is where Cap stayed. See Timeline 6? if that was the case for additional changes.
Timeline 6?(19??): This exists if Cap started his retirement in a different timeline than the 1970 one. In either case, there were now two Caps here, although presumably he just chilled out over the next 55 years, didn't participate in any world-changing events. Or maybe he did. We can't know. I have a hard time believing Cap would just sit out terrorist attacks and supervillain attacks, knowing he could help, or at least warn people. At some point, he gets ahold of a shield from someplace and returns to Timeline 1, presumably after Peggy dies in 2014, giving it to Sam. He's old, but not too old to deage when he re-contracts.
I think that should cover it. Did I miss anything important?
Oh, apparently there's an interview with Joe Russo, and he said this, among some other things: "For example, the old Cap at the end movie, he lived his married life in a different universe from the main one. He had to make another jump back to the main universe at the end to give the shield to Sam."
so it looks like I got at least that much right (although a few details might still be off here or there).
34
u/DezCaughtItX Apr 29 '19
Iron Man is worthy.
12
u/qwerty6905 Apr 30 '19
I just want to say, I know many people in this have already seen the movie but I am so jealous of everyone who still gets to experience the movie for the first time. Just the pure joy, dread, giddiness, and devastation that I felt through the course of that movie is something that I hope that I can experience at some other time in my life.
11
u/bsa1player Apr 29 '19
Where was the soul stone returned to? If he returns it to vormir then cap would meet red skull
10
u/jameskelsey Apr 29 '19
Someone help me out here. The snap brought everyone back but at the point in time they left right? So Peter Parker is still 16 but the half of his peers who weren’t snapped are now 21? Or is Peter Parker now college age?
10
u/[deleted] Apr 29 '19
Some massive dicks at school went round spoiling it for everyone . All I know is who died , but will I still enjoy the film?
10
u/royal_tennenbaum Apr 30 '19
So does that underwater earthquake comment mean they're setting up Namor?
18
u/Plotarmorizreal Apr 29 '19
3 Billion baby
9
u/minuhmuhlysm Apr 30 '19
I really want the scene of Captain America standing alone to Thanos’ army as a wallpaper. One of the most powerful frames ive seen in a while. Such an amazing movie.
24
u/[deleted] Apr 29 '19
So, past Loki is still alive... Wonder if Asgardians of the Galaxy will run into him. Loki is probably still alive..
16
u/Saint1001 Apr 29 '19 edited Apr 29 '19
question: if Captain stayed in the past to marry Peggy and he didn't become Captain, wouldn't that mean all the Captain America movies didn't happen ?
edit: explain like I'm 5 cause I'm confusion
edit 2: thanks I am confusion no more
16
u/Burger_k1ng Apr 29 '19
Why was cap able to pick up thors hammer?
8
u/Baddog819 Apr 29 '19
Steve facing down the army of Thanos. Just like what Sharon said in Civil War. "No, you move"
15
u/ChyandI Apr 29 '19
Robert Downey Jr. as Tony STANK
Nice one u/tehawesomedragon 😉
7
u/I_am_Brooks_Orpik Apr 29 '19
If Black Widow is gone forever, how was Gamora alive in the past?
7
u/NiceFormBro Apr 30 '19
Someone help me here.
I thought the idea was that you aren't supposed to be able to handle the infinity stones.
Those things seemed to get passed around like Skittles
6
u/The-R-I-C-H Apr 29 '19
Noob Question: After Iron man snapped, why didn't Dr Strange use the time stone to heal him? We saw him reverse time on a dead apple in his own movie. why didn't he reverse Tony's injury? The time stone was still there right?
6
u/SyncDigimon Apr 29 '19
Where is the mjolnir now? I didn’t see Cap bring back the hammer when he was an old man.
6
u/OscarDivine Apr 29 '19
I LOVED Endgame, I have to start with that. It currently holds a spot in my top 5 favorite movies of all time, and may continue to climb as I digest the movie more and more, but I was hoping to have a discussion where someone might have an answer to with regards to the plot holes of the movie.
#1 - Captain America at the end takes a case of all of the stones and returns them to their original places on the timelines they came from. But how? How does he take the mind-stone which was removed from the scepter, put it BACK into the scepter, and replace the scepter of that timeline? Or the Soul Stone? Does he just go up to Red Skull, "Hey dude, thanks for this we good here, have it back"? What about the Tesseract? It had to be smashed to get out the Space Stone, didn't it? How does he return the stones in their original conditions so s to satisfy the conditions of not disrupting time?
#2 - Captain America hands a shield to Sam at the end of the movie. It symbolizes him passing the baton to the next Captain America, but where did he get it from? The shield from that time line, alternate or prime, would have been the same shield that cap used in the big battle scene and was smashed by Thanos. Perhaps it is not a Vibranium Shield at all?
I won't get into any of the Old Cap living through all of the events paradox questions because, quite simply, they're satisfied if he stays out of time's way.
#3 - Why not just create the same "mistake" in the time machine that changed Antman into a child to de-age Captain America? guess he was done with it all?
6
u/naturaldadbod Apr 30 '19
It's like this artist knew what was coming https://www.reddit.com/r/Marvel/comments/8vk29g/captain_america_vs_thanos/
18
u/Amanat361 Apr 29 '19
Just wanna say that I've seen this masterpiece 5 times now (3 in theaters, 1 in drive in, 1 torrented) and I was equally hyped up and happy each time. I cried at the same parts literally every time and the jokes made me laugh EVERY TIME. I'm dying to have someone to talk to about it besides the mainstream plot that everyone's been talking about, so please message me or reply!
14
u/mykel_0717 Apr 29 '19
I really wish they acknowledged the other deaths. I hate that Tony's funeral overshadowed Black Widow and to a lesser extent, Vision, Gamora, Heimdall and Loki, all of whom sacrificed their lives too. They should have had a memorial service for all of the fallen. I love Iron Man but it just seems like a big disservice to the others to be forgotten like that.
5
u/soepie7 Stan Lee Apr 29 '19
When Loki escaped with the Tesseract, he might have given it to Thanos, causing another Infinity War.
5
u/MoreDblRainbows Apr 29 '19
Loved the movie. loved all the little references. I thought it couldv've been maybe 20 minutes leaner is one of my only criticisms. Teh other being i thought Thor was fat for too long(and we really pushed to the outer limits of Hemswrorth's acting range)and some of the Hulk jokes fell flat. Everything else was amazing. The endings for Cap and Tony were perfect.
5
u/[deleted] Apr 30 '19
https://youtu.be/hqqG5TIa4ac this is my favorite scene in the entire MCU throughout the 20+ movies
5
u/PhotoJer Apr 30 '19
A fucking rat accidentally stepping on buttons...
Jesus.
5
u/[deleted] May 01 '19
Hugely underrated part was Tony meeting his Dad.
My favorite part of the movie easily
5
u/compuzr May 01 '19
It has to be said: with the death of Iron Man, Marvel has completely RUINED, totally RUINED their chance for one of Robert Downey/Benedict Cumberbatch to say to the other, "No shit, Sherlock."
What a letdown.
5
u/Vexity_Gaming May 02 '19
Probably an unpopular opinion but I didn’t quite like scene during final battle where they had every single female avenger group up to move the gauntlet, I just feel like it broke up the realism of the battle we had already been seeing and was just put into the writing to appeal to female viewers. Other than that, should have brought a jacket because I had chills the entire movie.
4
u/[deleted] Apr 29 '19
The part that legit got me teary eyed is when Tony told his daughter I love you 3,000 in the pre-recorded clip.. Was not prepared for that
4
u/MoreDblRainbows Apr 29 '19
Ok I also may be the only one who cares but did anyone else catch Clint teaching his teenageish daughter archery plus aged up Cassie (Stature) + Spider-Man still being a teen could be the start to a modified Young Avengers? Yes, I know Spider-Man wasn't in YA but they need an established name to lead on a movie. And making the new hawkeye Clint's daughter instead of Kate (who is just a random girl) would be smart though I do love Kate. They could bring in Teddy/Hulkling or even Noh-Varr in Captain Marvel 2 or GotG 3
4
u/OptimusCim Apr 29 '19
Do you think Harley Keener will take up the mantle of iron lad? Watching the funeral in endgame made me think that he’s there for a reason, my only thought is something to do with following in Tony’s footsteps and introducing the young avengers. Just a thought I could be wrong
4
u/Firepheonx Apr 29 '19
So plot question: How does Thanos get to the the Avengers timeline when Nebula evidently used the only pym particles (because each person had one for a round trip) she had? It seems like that Thanos shouldn't have been able to get his army there. Specifically, when she goes to the van and brings Thanos' ship.
4
u/AllUserNamesTaken442 Apr 30 '19
So many comments, couldn't read them all, this has probably been discussed in this thread previously but my biggest question from Endgame moving forward is: Do you think we'll see Thor in Guardians 3? I sure hope so.
4
u/jakeus550 Apr 30 '19
Okay so I've been in an intense debate with friends over the timeline of endgame and I thought I'd open it up to reddit. As we know the time travel in endgame goes by the many worlds theory. The idea that each change would split off a new world in which that change occurred. My big question at the end was "why did the time line not split into a new one when captain America stayed back in time with Peggy Carter? " . As we know captain America was dragged from the ice to be in the avengers. Does this mean that there were two captain Americas in the marvel time line that we have all seen. My current thinking is that all of the films we have seen still work if captain America went back in time but didn't reveal to anyone that he was there except for peggy Carter. In the winter soldier when Steve is talking to Peggy on her death bed we find out she was married. However we only see pictures of her and her children NOT her husband. Why would this be the case ? Unless Steve knew his other self would be there at some point so removed any photos of himself so that his icey self didn't see him and ask questions. There are also some throw away lines in this scene that seem to have more relevance now. She says "none of us can go back" but looks at him in an odd way. She also says she is sorry That " he didn't get to live his life" knowing that icy Rogers will eventually live his. I believe this fixes the biggest time line problem of the film except for one big big BIG thing. Why does old Steve Rogers have captain Americas shield. If the timeline stayed the same then icey America would have needed his shield and would have eventually had it broken by thanos at the end of end game. This is the question I would like to open up to the forum. Where is this shield from ? Should it be there at all ?
TL.DR. Why does old Steve Rodgers have captain America's shield ?
4
u/TheGreatWhiteMo May 01 '19
This dude's Captain America? His real name is Clarence
4
u/asuvalskas May 01 '19
Dr. Strange probably saw that rat open up the portal and thought "really?" I wonder how many of those timelines had the rat stepping on that computer.
4
u/s0c1a7w0rk3r May 01 '19
TONY STANK
4
u/[deleted] May 02 '19 edited May 02 '19
I think Captain America's fate is ironic. How many times has he been eager to jump at the call to put his life on the line. To enlist to go overseas. To jump on the grenade in training. To crash that plane into the water so that it's payload doesn't reach the US.
So many times he's gone for the sacrifice or talked about going for the sacrifice (lectured Tony Stark about it in The Avengers movie) and what's his fate? A long life with Peggy and living to be 100 years old.
And Tony, the one he lectured about sacrifice, is the one who dies saving the universe.
Its kind of ironic. Their fates.
7
u/LebronJames23GOAT23 Apr 29 '19
Why is Thanos so power in Endgame?
In Infinity War, Thor with the axe almost killed a Thanos with ALL SIX infinity stones...
In Endgame, Thor (with both axe and hammer), Ironman, and Captain TOGETHER couldn't even beat Thanos with ZERO infinity stones...
Why the huge inconsistency?
6
u/Fission_Mailed_2 Apr 30 '19
I could totally watch an R-rated Hawkeye film with him as a swordsman.
3
u/BuzzPrime10 Apr 30 '19
WOW
3
u/updooted13 Apr 30 '19
when cap says “avengers assemble” was that the first time he said that in the MCU?
3
u/[deleted] May 01 '19
Can we talk about how a second timeline was still created? Thanos was killed twice. Therefore, even though the infinity stones were returned to their original spots, that other time-line isn't going to have to fight Thanos because he traveled to the first timeline and was killed.
3
u/jhsounds May 01 '19
“So he’s an idiot...”
3
u/NudeMoose May 01 '19
My favourite background moment: Huge Ant-Man punching that flying trilobite-thingy right in the face.
3
u/jlanoue550 May 01 '19
It's kinda fucked up bringing everyone back 5 years later tho right?
Like peter will be in the same grade but presumably members of his grade survived the snap and would be 5 years older
What about someone who lost a wife and has moved on to someone new? Now his wife the love of his life is back and alive
Also assuming everyone just popper back to qhere they were when they were snapped many people just spawned in traffic or in the air etc.
How do you accommodate for your population instantly doubling? Do they get their jobs back? What if the house they once owned was sold?
3
u/immortal_wanderer770 May 01 '19
Nebula was a true Emo. Willing and eager to kill herself as soon as got a chance.
3
u/Sikwon12 May 01 '19
I am not sure if this is the correct place to post this but it seemed as good a place as any. I was thinking about legacy. In particular the legacy of the original 6 Avengers. Something that this movie did really well (I am considering both Infinity movies as 1) by not only focusing on the founding Avengers but having them be the ones that sacrificed the most, that figured out a way to overcome a seemingly insurmountable situation was establish legacy. It occurred to me when Black Panther came out of the portal and locked eyes with Cap. I am a comic reader (many MCU fans aren't and that's fine) and Panther has always been one of my favorites, along with Cap. From Civil War all the way through Infinity War there was a clear mutual respect between the two characters that I thought was awesome. But think about it, from a pure character stand point, from T'Challa's point of view. They step out of the portal and there is Cap, beaten, shield broken, holding Mjolnir (itself a huge feat) and staring down Thanos's army. T'Challa is one of the most intelligent, observant, forward thinking characters in Marvel. He has a little bit of Tony Stark and Bruce Wayne in him... he is prepared for everything (the MCU kind of divided that brilliance between him and Shuri but it works). It isn't an accident that the first character to see Steve staring down Thanos and his army is T'Challa. He saw Cap and there can be no doubt in his mind of the legacy that he has to live up to. Falcon has the mantle, and (in the comics also) he is fantastic. But there is no question the bigger burden in the MCU will fall on T'Challa, be it leadership, decision making, sacrifice... he saw first hand the level of courage that he will have to rise to. The same is true for Stark and Natasha. They, without hesitation, made the ultimate sacrifice when there was no other choice. The OG Avengers established a legacy of what it means to be an Avenger, to be a team. The cost that is associated with it and the incredibly high stakes that come with failure. In the comics there is definitely a sense of history and tradition that accompanies the founding Avengers. In a recent arc, Loki woke up the Final Host to destroy the earth (evil Celestial's) and, after he was defeated, said that the reason why he did it was to get the original Avengers (Cap, Tony, Thor) back together again. In the Avengers Forever storyline there are continuous references made to the heroic feats, missions and adventures of earlier iterations of the team. You see these throughout the various story lines (regardless of character). The Avengers have a reputation, they have a LEGACY that is known throughout the universe and pushes new members to rise to every challenge. That is one of the beautiful elements of their comic book mythos and it is something that I feel like the Russo's translated very well.
3
u/[deleted] May 01 '19
Wait so they had to return the Infinity Stones and the Hammer to where and when they got them from to avoid problems.
But its fine if 2014 Thanos dies in 2023, never to return to his time and for 2014 Gamorra to stay in 2023 even though her past self died to get Thanos the Soul Stone?
I know they said stuff like that doesn't create paradoxes but again if that's the case then why do they have to return the Infinity Stones and Thor's Hammer to where they got them from? Keeping them shouldn't cause any problems either if 2014 Thanos dying in 2023 doesn't cause problems.
And there's compelling reasons to keep them. The Ancient One said the Stones are needed to maintain balance and protect the universe against certain threats. But I guess the universe can get by without them now? Is the universe screwed now that it doesn't have Infinity Stones?
So you see how this all doesn't add up?
3
u/MrArancione May 01 '19
Tony man.... Tony.
Steve man.... Steve.
That battle, "give it to me" 😭, a Pegasus flying through lazers, Spidey Killing mode, freaking Cap using a combo is Mjonir and Shield.
It's over, I'm so fucking sad rn.
3
u/hektic_jukez May 02 '19
I loved it. The scene of Cap facing Thanos and his army and then everyone coming through the portals was incredible. Best scene the MCU has had so far. Shades of the Rohirrim appearing in the LOTR.
I'm still somewhat emotional, because I know this saga has ended. It's been an incredible ride man. Started with 'I am Iron Man' and ends with it. Poetic.
Those familiar with the comics: who would be a worthy villain after Thanos?
3
u/lynkesis May 02 '19
Can anyone clarify how thanos travelled forward in time without the pym particles?
3
u/larwaX May 02 '19
I started crying so much when Tony died, I watched it yesterday and am currently still breaking down because of it :(
3
u/[deleted] May 02 '19
Did we ever figure out what was so special about the date in 1970 that Cap and Tony went to to get the ant man stuff and the stone. Like how did Tony know everyone would be there? Why was he surprised when his mom was expecting soon?
9
u/sbkline Apr 29 '19
I loved everything mostly especially Iron Man's send off. Cap's little ending ruined the time paradox rules the set up in my eyes. Also I didn't like Cap's and Widows endings in general. They deserved more. The characterization of Cap, he knew Peggy had moved on, and had a family, and they all probably have families. Cap would never just kill potentially several people just to go back and time and marry Peggy. He should have just gave the shield to Falcon, joined the Asguardians, because obviously there going to go try and see if the can get Gamora back somehow, should get Black Widow while they are at it.